Duarte Hernandez v. Art deco Supermarket at Normandy Isle, LLC et al

Filing 23

ORDER granting 20 Motion Deem Defendant Served. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 7/23/2013. (err)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI OF FLO RI A
CT
D
M i m iDi s on
a
vi i
Cas Num ber 1 20705- V- O RENO
e
: 3CI M
MI
CHE DUARTE HERNANDEZ,
Pl i if
antf,
VS.

A RT D ECO SU PERM A RK ET e al
/ .,
D e e nt .
f nda s

O RDER GRANTI PLAI FF' M OTI TO DEEM DEFENDANT PETER J.
NG
NTI S
ON
N EA RY SERV ED

THI CAUSE c
S
ame be or t Cour upon Pl i ifsM o i t Dee Def ntPe e J.
f e he
t
antf
ton o
m
enda
tr

Ne r Ser d( E. 20) fldonJune27.201
ay ve D. No. , ie
3.
THE COURT hasc i r t m o i r s e, a t pe tne por i oft r or .
onsde ed he ton, e pons nd he r i nt tons he ec d
a be ng ot
nd i
hem i e f l a s i t pr m i es i i
s uly dvi ed n he e s , t s
A DJUD G ED t tt m oton i GM N TED .
ha he
i s
1.Background

Thi i ac us of tonunde t Fai La St nda dsAc , 29U. C. 201e. e Pl ntf
s s a e aci
r he r bor a r
t
S. j
ts q. ai if

i s eki ale yunpa dove tmef hour hewor dasabut he f Def nda s Pli iffl
s e ng lgedl
i
ri or
s
ke
c r or e nt . antf ied
hi Compl i onFe uar 27. 3a i t hr eDefnda s Ar De o Supe r ta Nonna y
s
ant
br v 201 gans t e
e nt : t c
nna ke t
nd

Il,LLC,Ar De o Supemake ( 435 W a hi onAvenue2007)LLC, and Pet rJ.N ear The
se
t c
r r t1
s ngt
e
y.
t c or eDe enda swe es r donM ar h 7. 3,andt e cut s monswe er t ne
wo om at f nt r e ve
c 201
he xe ed um
r eur d
on Aprl3.201 l i undiput t tDe e ntNe r hasnotbe n s ve . 1 dayshaspas e
i
3. t s
s ed ha f nda
ay
e er d 20
sd
snc t tlng oft Com pli .
i e he ii
he
a nt

On M ar 26.2013,Def nt ,i udi Def nda Nea y, fl a M oton t Dim is
ch
enda s ncl ng
e nt r ied
i o s s

u d rF d. Ci . Ru e1 ( )1 a d( ) De e d n Ne r d dn to j c t s r iea dddn t
n e e R. v P. l 2 b ( ) n 6 . fn a t ay i o b e t o e vc n i o

r iea yd fn e r ltdt p ro a j rs cin i u tce ts r ie o is fi in yo s r ie
as n e e s s eae o e s n lu idito ,ns fi in e vc , r n u fce c f e vc
.

On June 27.201 Pl ntf fld a M oton t dee Def ndantPet J Ne r s r ed.i i not
3, ai if ie
i o m
e
er . a y e v t s
dipu e t tt swa t fnal yoft 1 da wihwhih Pli ifmus s r De e
s t d ha hi s he i da
he 20- ys t
c antf
t e ve f ndan unde
t
r

Fe R. v. 4( . e ntNe r fldhi Res eonJul 15.201
d. Ci P. m) Defnda
ay ie s pons
y
3.
I .LegalA nal i
I
ys s

Unde t Fede a Rul ofCi lPr e e, t Co r mu tdimiswih u p eu ieo
r he
r l es
vi oc dur he u t s s s t o t rj dc r

o de t ts viebec
r r ha er c
omplt d wihi as cii d tmea a ton a i taDef ntwho ha not
e e t n pe fe i ny c i ga ns
enda
s
be s r e wihi 1 daysa t a c
en e v d t n 20
fer ompl i i fld. Fe R, v. 4( . paryma a sr t
ant s ie
d. Ci P. m) A t y se the

d fnsso lc o p ro a j rs it n,n uf in p o e s o is fce tsr ieof r c s b
ee e f a k f es n l u idci is fce t r c s , r n ufiin e vc p o e s y
o
moton ori a r s i pladi . F d R. v. 1 ( )2 -5 . p rywav sd fn e u d r
i
n e ponsve e ng e . Ci P. 2 b ( )( ) A at i e e e s s n e

Fe a Rul 1 b)2)( i i omist fom aRul 1 moton.Fed.R Ci P.R.1 g)2)
derl e 2( ( -5) f t t hem r
e 2 i
v.
2( ( ,
.

1 h)1.
2( ( )
The11h Cic thasitmrtdRul 1 h) 1 t mea ' pat i dee dt havewaved
t rui
ne ee
e 2( () o n ' ry s me o
a
i

a yo j cint p ro a j rs ito o sr ieo p o e si t ep ryma e ap e a s rmoin
n be to o e s n lu id cin r e vc f r c s f h a t k s r -n we t
o
u d rRu e1 a dfist i ld s c o j cin i t a mo in. Pa d z v Culman M ed.Ct.,
n e l 2 n al o ncu e u h be to s n h t to ' r a i
'
l
r
.

896F. 1 3,1 7( 1hCi.1 . ri mus r iet afimatvedefns sbasdonpe s
3d 31 31 1 t r 990) Pa tes t as he fr i
e e e
ronal

j rs ito a dis fiin s r ieo pr e si terfrtRue 1 mo in ohe i ta pla n ,
u idcin n n u fce t e vc f oc s n h i is l 2 to , t r ni l e dig
i
orge r appe r nce. eI r Wordwi We S ., 328F.d 1 1 1 ( 1h Ci.
ne al
aa
Se n e
l de b ys
3 29 , 299 1 t r2003 . e
) Onc

apat h swav da o j cint pes n lu id ci no is fiin s r ieof r c s, 'hecourt
ry a ie n be to o ro aj rs ito r n u fce t e vc p o e s '
t
ma n , ihe upont def ntsm otonorisowni tatve, dim ist s tf lckofpe s l
y ot et r
he enda ' i
t
nii i
s s he ui or a
r ona
-

2-

j rs ci no is fiin s r ieo p o e s'I ;Hemipheri Bipharma, I .v.Johannesbur
u idito r n u fce t e vc f r c s ' d.
s
x o
nc
g
.

Cons . nv .553F.3d1
oll s,
351,1 ( 1hCi.
360 1 t r2008) Coursi t sditi havedee Dee nt
. t n hi srct
med fnda s
valdl s r e whe et yhavewaved s vie ofpr e s
i y evd
r he
i
er c
oc s .

Se Ho ma v EMIRe o t,l c, 01
e f n.
s rs n .2 0

W L 9034908,a *8 ( D.Fl J y 21, 2 0 ( 1 J) (e ti d fn a t a re t wav
t S. a. ul
01 ) God, . c ran ee d n s g e d o ie

j rs ito a d fn e )
u idcin l ee s s .
l t ei t ntc s i i notdiput t tPl i iff iedt s r De e nt r wihi 1
n h nsa a e t s
s ed ha antf al o e ve f nda Nea y t n 20

da asrquie byRul 4( .
ys e rd
e m)Howe ral Def nt ,i l ngDef ndantNeay, fl aM oton
ve , l enda s ncudi
e
r ied
i
t Dimispurua t Ruls1 b)1 a ( D. 7.Def ntNear di nota ars i l
o s s s nt o e 2( ( ) nd 6) E.
enda
y d
ppe pecaly
.

.

Bec us De e ntNea y fld a Rul 1 M oton, a be us De e ntNe y di notr iehi
a e f nda
r ie
e 2
i nd ca e f nda
ar d
as s

afr t ed fn e b sdo lc o p ro a j rs i o o i ufiin s r ieofproces a t t
fimai e e s s a e n a k f e s n lu id di n r ns fce t e vc
v
s t ha
tme, f nda Nea yha wai d t m .
i De e nt r s ve he
De e ntNe r a guest thehasno wa ve hi rghtt c ale t Cour' pe s l
f nda
ay r
ha
t i d s i o h l nge he
t r ona
s

j rs it no e hi b tl t eMo int Dimisb c u e'h ag me t r ied i t M oton
u id ci v r m y ii h to o s s e a s ' e r u n s as n he i
o
ng
t
t Dimison be foft i vi lDef nda Ne r we e de i tvear
o s s
hal he ndi dua
e nt a y r rva i
gume sr ied by t
nt a s
he
Cor r t De e nt .'M e i Oppostont Pl i ifsM otont De m De e
po ae f nda s ' mo.n
ii o antf
i o e
f ndan Nea ySe v d
t r re

a 4 (ul l 201 .W hiei i tu t t i cerai cicum stnces, an i vi lcannotbe hel
t J y 5, 3)
l t s r e ha, n t n r
a
ndi dua
d
pe s l la e f c por t a i t e por toni notf nd labl, hi ' rvai agum e '
ronaly ibl or or a e ds f he or ai s
ou i e t s ' i tve r
de
nt'

d e n t p l t is e r g r igp ro a j rs ito C F. v US Fi .41 F d. p 9 0
o s o a py o su s e a dn e s n lu idcin / TC. . A n, 5 e Ap x. 7
.

,

975atn. ( 1hCi, 1 .ndee , Def ntNear hasciedno caseorst ut
3 1 t r201 ) l d enda
y
t
at e

,

a t sCour ha
nd hi
t s

f und none,t t s
o
ha uppor t pr pos to t t a a
t he o ii n ha n p
pe r nc m a i Cour by a i vi l
a a e de n
t
n ndi dua

d fn a t o s o wav o j ci n t p ro aj rs ito b c u ela ii of andt t Courts
ee d n d e n t ie be to s o es n lu idcin e a s ib ly , hus he
t
'

j rs ito o e teidv d a aed rv tv o t ep tnilla ii a dt eC
u idcin v r h n ii u l r ei ai e f h o e ta iblt n h
y
o r'j rs ito
u t u idcin
s

ove t c por t co- f nda s Thi a gume ha no me i a no s
r he or a e De e nt . s r
nt s
rt nd
uppor i l w .Thus t s
tn a
, hi

Co r fnd t tDee d n Ne r h swav d a y o j ci nt is fiin s r ie o p o e so
u t i s ha fn a t ay a ie n be to o n u fce t e vc f r c s r
peronal' iditon.
s J s ci
ur
1 1 Concuson
1.
l i
Fort r a onssatd above, a ntf sM otont De m Def ndan PeerJ Nea y Se ve
he e s
te
Pli if
i o e
e
t t . r r d,
orAle a i y,f a Enlr m e ofTi t Se v i he e GRANTED.Thi Cour dee s
tm tvel or n a ge nt
me o r e s r by
s
t m
DefndantPee J. a y s r ed.
e
tr Ne r e v
DONE AND ORDERED i Cha
n
mber a M im i Fl i ,t
s t a , orda hi

da ofJ y,201
y ul
3.

''A

R
.e

..

.

FED E C
. REN O
11 1
.
N
STATES D I
STRI J DG E
CT U

Co e pr de t
pis ovi d o:
Couns ofRe or
el
c d