Duncan v. Miami Gardens Police Department et al

Filing 6

ORDER DISMISSING CASE Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 6/26/2013. (cbe)

UNI
TED STATES D I
STRI COU RT FO R TH E
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i iDi s on
am
vi i
C as N um be 1 20743- I - O R EN O
e
r: 3C V M
SA M H N ON I BA N D ELE D U NCA N ,
Pl i if
a ntf ,
VS.

M I M IGA RD EN S POLI D EPT. ET AL .
A
CE
,
,

Def nt .
enda s
/
O R DER DI I N G CA SE AN D DEN Y I G ALL PEND I G M O TI N S A S M O O T
SM SSI
N
N
O

THI CAU SE c m e be or t Cour upon a s s e e
S
a
f e he
t
ua pont xami ton of t r cor
nai
he e d.

l herlfor
n ' mapau i ' fda t't Pli ifaleg t ts wa f c f l e ce fo
n
pers ' i vi,'he antf l es ha he s ore uly vitd r m
af
he r i nc by he pr o m a ge and s ve a me be s of t M i Ga de Polce
r esde e
r ope
na r
e rl m r
he ami r ns i
De rm e .D. No.1a 1 3- I a s pa at a tche doc e ,t pl ntf cl m st the
pa t nt E.
t , 4. n e r e, ta d um nt he ai if ai ha r
team e amount t ' bl t ci l i ht vi a i andilgal c i unde t col ofFl i
r t nt
ed o ' aant vi rg s olton
a
le eviton
r he or
orda

St ea Fe r La '1 a 4.Thepl ntf a s rst ts i ' i ng ac
at nd de al m ' d. t
ai if s e t ha he s ' ngi
br
ompl nta l ws t
ai nd a ui

f ru lwf le ito ll''r u ln e e to (i)h r sme t a d t ra o ars a d drc
o na u v ci n ,' ' a due t v cin sc aa s n , n h e t f re t n ie t
f
vi ainof( r M oors saus'I Thepli iff t rcli t ' i ac us ofa tonunde
olto heq
ih tt . d.
'
antf urhe ams o ' ng a e ci
br
r

tte4 s b e to 1 81 1 3 1 8 , n 1 8 o teU. C()'d. hes e 'et to (i) f 0
il 2 u s cin 9 , 98 - 9 5 a d 9 6 fh S. .' S e ks' suin sc o $1 0
l
r
m ilon dola s f Pai a Suf e i '1 a 1.
li
l r or n nd f rng. d. t
'

Un e 28U. C. 1 5 e( )B)i, c u t'h lds s tefn o mapa pe i a to ja
dr
S. j 91 ()2 ( () a o r ' al imis h if r
s
u rs cin t
a tm ei t co tdeer nest t... hea ton ... sfi ousormalci ' Ac r ngt t
ny i f he ur t mi ha
t ci
i rvol
i ous. co di o he
'
Unie Stt sSupr
td ae
eme Co t acompl i i fi ous' r i l c a a g bl ba i i l w or
ur,
ant s rvol ' e t a ks n r ua e ss n a
whe

i fc. Netk v Wi ims 49 U. 31 , 2 ( 9 9 ( ic sn dimis l u d rfr rscin
n a t' i e . la , 0 S. 9 3 5 1 8 ) d susig s sas n e ome e to
' z
l
1 5( ,whih c aned t sme l ua a c rnts ci 1 1 e( ( ().A cour ma
91 d) c onti he a ang ge s ure e ton 9 5()2)B)i)
t y

d s s camst e s cin 1 5e( )B)i wheetecamsr s o a id s ua l meils
imis li md r e to 91 ()2 ( () r h li e t n n n ip tby rte s
lgalt or ora ecomprs d off t c e i nst ta ec e ry bas l s 1 a 327.
e he y r
ie
acual ont nto ha r l a l
ees . d. t
I Nei e t Supr m eCour pr de s r lexn e offi ousormalci cli s
n t , he
zk
e
t ovi d eve a
mpls rvol
i ous am .
W he e t defnda i cl ry i
r he e nt s ea l mmune fom s t orwhe e t pl ntf a lge i rnge ntofa
r
ui,
r he ai if le s nfi me

lga i e e twhi obvi l doe note s,hent cli i f mde on a i s a ym e ils
e l nt r s
ch
ousy s
xit t he am s ot d
n ndiput bl rte s
lga t or 1 at327. Cl m sde alng f nt tc ordel i ls na i fti o t f ct ly
e l he y. d.
ai
t ii a asi
usona ce ros i nt he a ua l
ba ees caeg y.1 a 3 28.Fi ly, hi Cou tas not t tapr sepl ntf m us begi n
s l s t or d. t 27na l t s r lo es ha
o
ai if t
ve

g e trle yi pla igh rc mplit ie v Ke n r 4 4U. 51 ( 9 2 .
rae e wa n e dn e o an .Han s . r e , 0 S. 9 1 7 )

M i d u o t e eprn i e ,h Co r h se au tdt panif if r
n f l f h s icpls te u t a v l ae he li tf s n o mapa pe i fln ,
u rs iig
whos o ydice i ec e ofaci i f 'le le ci 'whi h doe notti rt sCour'
e nl s m bl aus
ton s or ' lga vi ton,
i
' c
s
rgge hi
t
s

s be tmatrj rs ito litf sc mpan i fio o u d r28 U. C.j 1 5 e( )B)i
u j c te u idcin.P an if o lit s rv lus n e
S.
91 ()2 ( ()
bec us i doe notc ai ' n a gua eba i i 1w o i f t' Netke 490 U. a 3 Afe
a et s
ont n ' r bl ss n a r n ac .
a
' iz ,
S. t 27. tr

r viwi t e ie c
e e ng he ntr ompl i ,t Cour c l st tt cai a ei s a y m e ils .
ant he
t onc ude ha he l ms r ndiput bl rte s
I addii ia
n
ton,t ppea st ai i sflngvi aest
r hepl nt/ ii olt heone- l m - - ount ul Fe R. V.
cai perc
r e. d. Ci P.

1 ( ) I An e s nv Ditit a do r se so nta Flrd Co nt Co lg , 7F.d
0 b . n d r o . src Bo r fT u te fce r l o ia mmu i le e 7 3
y
3 4 3 6 7( 1hCi. 9 6 ,h c u tc n en da o th r miiains c s sp o e dn o t e
6 , 6 - 1 t r 1 9 )te o r, o c r e b u t e n fc to of a e r c e ig n h
bassofts gun'pladi , e
i thot ' e ngs not d:
Expere t a s t t unl s ca es a e pl cl a l a pr ci e y,i s a e not
i nce e che ha , es s r ed e ry nd e s l s ues r

j ie , ic v r i n t o to ld tetil o r' d c e b c me u ma a e be
on d ds o e y s o c n r le ,h ra c u ts o k t e o s n n g a l,
t ltga s s f r a s e y l e c i e i t co t a lt t a i s e
he ii nt ufe , nd oci t os s onfdenc n he ur ' biiy o dm nit r
s

j tc .
usie

-

2-

S eas Ma l t v S mpls 25 F.d 1 8 ( 1t Ci. 0 ) Ce n kv Ed e o pt t u c ,
e lo g ua . a e , 6 3 2 2 1 h r2 01; s i . g wo dBa i Ch r h
s
8 F.d9 2, 0 ( 1hCi.1 9 ) f.. I c v Cr w, 9 F.d 6 9 68 ( 1h Ci. 9 5 .Thi
8 3 0 9 5 1 t r 9 6 ; S r, n . . o 4 3 7 , 4 1 t r 1 9 ) s
pr e i es ily pr valnti a tonswhe e myra f c ua a lga i a l ga t oresa e
obl m s peca l e e n c i
r
id a t l le tons nd e l he i r
ofen c olda e i o a sngl c
t ons i t d nt
i e ount ori o one s toftge r a lga i ' whih,i t n,i
, nt
e
s ne al le tons' c n ur s

i op o ae byr f r ewhol a ei o e r cot oft compl i .Her , hepl i ifhasct
nc r td e e enc
es l nt ve y mt he
ant
et
antf
ied
s ve alFl rda a Fe r sa ut s wihouti ntf ng whih of he cli gi rs t a
e r
o i nd de al t t e , t
de iyi
c
r a ms ve ie o ny
vi a i t r .Such f hot ' e di i
olton he eof
l gun'pla ng mperl f nda e alprncpl sofduepr s .
s
is u m nt i i e
oce s
TheElve hCic tha ex es e i r s df sr i wih diti tc t t t1tt c e
e nt r ui s pr s d nc ea e nztaton t src ours ha e he as

pr e ddes t s hs t pl di Se Byr v. z , F. 1 11 ( 1hCi. )
oc e pie uc hogun ea ngs. e ne Ne hat261 3d 075, 30 1 t r 2001.
The Byr c ts
ne our oughtt a d ha ng dititc t unde go t tm e c um i pr e s of
o voi vi
src ours
r he i - ons ng oc s
'e ra i t pla ngsa di c r ng whet rt pli ifha saed a cli ,orcli s f
' a r ngng he e di
r
nd s e ni
he he antf s t t
am
am , or

r i ,a whehe t de e
elef nd
t r he f ndantsafimatve de e e ar l ly s fcint'1 a 11
' tr i
f ns s e egal ufi e . d. t 29. The
'
Byr pa la s c
ne ne lo ouns l ' t pladi ,ft e a e har t c t i di isa lt
eed,' gun e ngs i ol r t d, m he our by mpe ng t biiy
Sho

t a miitrj sie Th tmeac u ts n sma a i l iain fn d b s o g n pe d n s
o d nse u tc . e i
o r pe d n gng i g to rme y h tu la i g
t
s d bede e t ot rc eswatng t be he r '1 at11
houl
vot d o he as
ii o
a d. d.
'
31.
Acc di y,i i
or ngl t s

ADJ
UDGED t a t i c s i DI M I ED wi u p eu c ,wih la e t rfl a
h t hs a e s S SS
t t rj die t e v o eie
ho
co pli tt tcomple wih pl di r esc ai d i t Fede a RulsofCi lPr dtr A1
m a n ha
is t ea ng ul ont ne n he
rl e
vi oce le. 1

pendi motonsa eDENI AS M OOT.Thi c s i CLOSED.
ng i
r
ED
s ae s

D N A DO D R DiCabraMi ,liati édy fue21.
O E N R E E n hm est a Fod, s aoJn,03
mi r h
'

'

,

FEDE

O

.

.

NO

UNI S
T/D TATES DI TRI J
S CT UDGE
3-

-

Copi pr ded t
es ovi o:
Couns lofRe r
e
co d
Sa a N o - nde e Dunca
r h niBa l
n
1
4905NW 22 Ct
nd
OpaLoc ,FL 33054
ka
305- 5
316- 978
PR0 SE

l