Pinecrest Consortium, Inc. v. Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC

Filing 19

ORDER granting 7 Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 4/25/2013. (cbe)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i Di son
ami vii
Ca eNum be 13s
r: 20803- V- O RENO
CI M
PI ECREST CO N SO RTI M ,m C .
N
U
,

Pl i if
antf,
VS.

M ERCED ESBEN Z U SA ,LLC,
Def nda .
e nt
O R DER G M NTI G D EFEN DA N T' M O TI N FO R
N
S
O
JUD G M EN T O N TH E PLEAD I G S
N

THI CAUSE c me be or t Cour upon t de e
S
a
f e he
t
he f ndants M o i n f rJ
'
to o udgmenton t
he

Pla ngs ( E.No.7 ,fl onM ar 27.201
e di D.
) ied
ch
3.
THE COURT ha c i r t m oto r pons a t pe tne pori oft r o d,
s onsde ed he i n, es e nd he ri nt tons he ec r
a bei o he wief ly a s d i t pr m ie ,i i
nd ng t r s ' l dvie n he e s s t s
u
ADJUDGED t tt moton i GRANTED i vi w oft pl i ifsl k ofsa ng.
ha he i s
n e
he antf ac
tndi The
pl ntf pur t t brngt sa ton, c dea swih a lge delysi ob a ni r plc ntpa t
ai if pors o i hi c i whih l t le d a n t i ng e a eme
rs

f las dM e c desBe a omobie , sa ' gre dpa 'unde Fl i ' Dec ptvea
or e e
r e - nz ut
ls a n ' i ve o ' r ordas e i ndunf i
ag
ar

Tr d Prcie ('
a e a tc s '
FDUTP ' Th panif t rl r u n sae t t i t eft e-n lw o t e
A'. e litf a o a a g me t ttd ha he s h ah ri-a f h
)
l s oft M e c desBe a om obie f whih r plce
es ee he r e - nz ut
l or c e a mentpars we e s
t r ought Cou e f r
. ns l o
pl ntf f rhe sa e t tt com o ai t ti t pum oredpli ifi t sc ewa f me f
ai if u t r t t d ha he
r ton ha s he
t antf n hi as s or d or
t pur eofbrngi l s t . pl ntf com o a i doesnota l get ti hase ro ne o
he pos
i ng aw uis The ai i f
r ton
le ha t
ve w d r

l s daM e ce s Be .
ea e
r de - nz Nowhe ei t c
r n he ompl i doe t pl ntf a lget iha eve te ed
ant s he ai if le hatt s ra tmpt
t obt i r plc ntM e c desBez pa t .
o an e a eme
r e - lz rs

Byist ms FDu-pA wa e tdt ' o e tt c umi publca l ii a ebusne s
t er ,
f
s nace o ' t c he ons ng
pr
i nd eg tm t i s
en e rs sfom t ewhoe gei unf i m ehodsofc
t m ie r hos
nga n ar t
ompe ii oruncons i bl dec ptve
tton,
cona e, e i ,

o unfi a t orprctce i t conduc ofa tadeorc
r ar cs
a i s n he
t ny r
ommec 'j 501. Fl Stt The
re.
'
202, a. a.

d fn a tm'u st a j d me to t e pla ig i a p o rae be a e te panifi n ta
e e d n g e h t u g n n h e dn s s p r p it c us h litf s o
' ons r'i t ta a ton a i s a a s h,doe no ha sa ng t pm s a c am f
' ume ' n he r ns c i t s ue, nd s uc
c
s t ve t ndi o
ue l i or
vi ai n ofFDUTPA. n r s
ol to
l e pons , hepl i ifa g st tFDUTPA alowsa pe s n t brng a
et
antf r ue ha
l
ny r o o i
c am f vi a i oft saut whi h no l nge r uie t ta pl i ifbe a ' o lm e . The
l i or olton he t t e, c
o r eq r s ha
antf
' nsl r'
c
'
pl n ifa g st t hesaut ' r l r quie a alegai nt tt a i ve pa t i i aposto
aitf r ue ha t t t e ' ey e r s n l to ha he ggre d ry s n
me
ii n

t c mpan (i) t a h o s o iwa a g iv db t alg dvilto )a dt a t v oain
o o lit sc (h t e r he r t s g re e y he l e oain n h the i lto s
e
h so c re , sn w o c ri go i l eyt o c ri teft r . D. No.1 a !3
a c u rd i o c u rn r s i l o c u n h uu e' E.
k
'
5t .
W hie i i t e t t t sa ut s orgi l s
l t s nz ha he tt e' i na cope has be n br ned by s e nt
e oade
ubs que
mnend e sa t tt t r ' ons r' sbee r pl e byot rt r si varousplce ,'he
m nt nd ha he e m c ume 'ha
n e ac d
he e m n i
a s '
t
lgiltvehit yi caest tt ec nge we ei ende onl oc a iyt tbo hpe s ha me
e sa i sor ndi t ha hes ha s r nt d yt l rf ha t r ons r d
i c umptona busne se ii sha m e bycompe io ' a i ompettvea t ,
n ons
i nd i s ntte r d
tt rs ntc
ii c s mayma n an a
iti n
a to i t y we e ha me by a ac i vi ai ofFDUTPA . I r M ilr,418 B. 406,411
ci n f he
r r d
n t n ol ton
' n e le
'
R.

( nkrN. Fl 2009)s Fl H. Comm.
Ba . D. a.
; ee a. R.
Councif Compeii Comme c HB 685( )
l or
ttve
r e,
2001
St fAnayss( a.1 2001 Apr 1 2001 (xpli ngt tt 2001c ngest FDUTPA'
af l i M r 6, ; . 8, ) e ani ha he
ha
o
S
pr sonsf aprvae rghtofa ton we eonl i ende t clrf t tt r m e esa ia et
ovii or i t i
ci
r
y nt d o a iy ha he e di val bl o

i vi l aeas a ia et busnese hamedbyavi ainofFDUTPA)Alhoug FDUTPA
ndi duas r lo valbl o i s s r
olto
. t h
ma e e t pr e tbusnes e ii by s h vi a i pr c i s 'tha no a i to t e ii s
y xtnd o ot c
i s nttes uc oltve a tce ,' s pplcai n o ntte
i
c pl i ng of t tous c
om a ni
or i
onduct w hi h i not t r s t of a c lm e ta ac i n. H & H
c s
he e ul
ons l r r ns to '
'

Re t ant,LLC,2001W L 1
saur s
850888,a *9( D. a. )(
t S. Fl 2001 emphassadde .
i
d)
-

2-

A ' ons r'i one who hase age i t pur has ofg
' ume ' s
c
ng d n he c e
oodsors r i e .Se N G. .
e vc s e
L

T a e Aso itsv Cee rt Cr ie,I . 7 4 So2 6 2 6 4 ( a 3 DCA 2 0 ) Nat n l
r v l s cae . lb i us s nc, 6 .d 7 , 7 F1. d
y
0 0; i a
o
Alo ls Pr g a / pe C f,Fl .I c v Pal S igsHop.
c hoim o r mscoo r Ry a, n . . m prn
s Emplye Be e Pln, 2
o e nht a 8 5
F.
supp. 302- ( D. a.993)Bas ont algai i t Complitt plitf c nnot
299, 03 S. F1 1 . ed he le tons n he
an,he anif n
bes i t bea' ons
ad o
' umer' c ei hasnotenga di an ta a ton i vi et rM e c des
c
'be aus t
ge n y r ns c i nvol ng ihe r e Benz a omobie orr ac m e pa t.Ac or ngl be aus t pl i if c or ton i nota
ut
ls epl e nt rs c di y, c e he antf om a i s
' ns
' umer' sde i dbyFDUTPA,tdoe not vesa ngt brngac am a ns t def n
co
'a fne
i s ha t ndi o i
l i gai t he enda t
f r vi ai n oft saut The Cour fnds i a opra e t gr nt t de e nt M oton f
o ol to
he t t e.
t i t ppr it o a he f nda '
s
i or
J
udgmen on t Pl a ngs Ist r f e
t he e di . t he e or

ADJUDGED t tt defnda ' Moton f J
ha he e nts i or udgme ont Pl di ( E.No.7 i
nt he ea ngs D.
)s
GM NTED andt ca ei CLOSED. t i f rhe
he s s
Is s u t r

ADJUDGED t tt pli ifsMotont Re
ha he antf
i o mand( E. 11 i DENI asmoo.
D. No. ) s
ED
t
/N

DO A OR R DiC a est a ,lrati XdyoApi21.
NE ND DE E n hmbraMi Foi ,h a f r,03
mi d
l
.
X

FED ERI A . O REN O
CO M
UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI J GE
CT UD

Copi pr de t
es ovi d o:
Couns lofRe d
e
cor

-

3-