Castillo v. U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services et al
Filing
11
ORDER granting 6 Motion to Dismiss. This case is closed. Signed by Senior Judge William M. Hoeveler on 5/21/2014. (ar2) Modified on 5/21/2014 (ch1) to change to opinion per chambers.
UNI
TED STA TES D I
STRICT COU RT
SO U TH ERN DISTRICT O F FLORI
DA
CA SE NO .1320810- V- O ER LER
CI H
M ARIO REN E CA STI
LLO ,
Pl nt f,
ai if
V
.
CLOSE
CI D
VI
CA L
SE
LI DA SW ACI A ?U SCI M T ID ISTRI D I
N
N
S AM
CT RECTO R
ERIC H OLD ER ,ATTO RN EY G ENEN AI,OF TH E U N I g STATES
TED
JAN ET N APO LI
TAN O , SECRETM W O F TH E DEPARTM EN T OF ,
.
HOM EI ND SECURI (
A
W DHSI S.CI ZENSHI AND I M I TI
U. TI
P
M GM ON
SERW CES,
D ef
endant
s.
/
ORDER G M N TIN G M OTI TO D I I
ON
SM SS
TH I CAU SE com esbef e t Cour on t Def
S
or he
t
he
endant M ot on t
s' i o
Di m i s. The Courthas r ew ed t m ot on, r
s s
evi
he
i
esponse,and r y,and fnds
epl
i
t di i sali appro i e.
hat sm s s
pr at
Pl ntf c l
ai if halenges t dec si oft U ni ed St es Cii
he i on
he
t
at
tzens p and
hi
I mi r to Se vie (
m g a i n r c s USCI , s ued June 22 2012,w hi deni Pl ntf s
S) i s
ch
ed ai if
,
reques t obt n st us as a perm anentr dent Pl ntf ,a Guat al
t o ai at
esi
.
ai if
em an
natve cur enty z i ng i t Unied St es r s a s ngl bas s f hi
i
r l ' di n he
es
t
at , ai es i e
i or s
c pl ntagai U SCI bef t s Cour :t U SCI f l t f l 8
om ai
nst
S ore hi
t hat
S aied o olow
C. R.1 2( )1 () whih pr vi est t
F. 03. b ( 6)i, c o d ha :
i t dec s on wilbe advers t t applcantorpett oner and i
f he i i
l
e o he
i
ii
s
bas on der
ed
ogat y i orm at on c
or nf
i onsi ed by t Ser c and of
der
he
vi e
whi t applc or pett oner i unaw are, he/ he s lbe advi ed o
ch he
i ant
ii
s
s hal
s f
t s f tand ofered an oppor uniy t rebutt i or aton.
hi ac
f
t t o
he nf m i
Pl i ifc nc de t t sCour l ksj i d c i n t r v e t
a ntf o e s hat hi
t ac urs i to o e i w he
U SCI S deni ofPl ntf s r
S'
al
ai if equest as s h dec s on i c m it t t
,
uc
i i s om t ed o he
di r i oft U SCI , butc nt ndst t sCo tm ay ad ud c t
sc et on
he
S
o e
hat hi ur
j ia e
Pl ntf scl m ofproc
ai if ai
eduralerr a pr
or
oposii wi h whi t U ni ed
ton t
ch he
t
-
St es agr
at
ees.
BACKG RO U ND
A st s case i bef t Cour on a m oton t di i t Cour
hi
s ore he
t
i o sm ss he
t
,
ac pt al f ualalegat ons i t Com pl ntas t ue. The s m ar oft
ce s l act
l i
n he
ai
r
um
y he
f s bel ,releson t Com pl nt and excer sofPl nt f s own
act , ow
i
he
ai
pt
ai if
t tm ony,as r
es i
eport i t Dec si i ued by U SCIS dat June 22 2012,
ed n he
i on ss
ed
,
denyi Pl nt f s r
ng ai if eques f per anentr i
t or m
es denc . l
y
Pl nt f ent ed t U nied St esi Apr l1989, as a tem porary
ai if er he
t
at n
i
vi t and w asel gi e t rem ai untlOc ober 30, 1989. On M ay 15,1989,
sior,
i bl o
n
i t
Pl nt f fl a r
ai if ied equestf asyl alegi t he w asfeei pastorf
or
um l ng hat
l ng
uture
per ecut on ( ed upon hi i vem enti f er Guat al
s
i d
bas
s nvol
n orm
em an
governm ents polce f ce and penali t t i .' Co a nt I 2. Twe v
'
i or
ns i utons ' mpl i , J
le
year l er,Pl nt f w as i er e ed by U ni ed Stat i m i i ofi i s
s at
ai if
nt vi w
t
es m graton fc al
' s Co tpro y r i on t cont oft doc ent as i w as
Thi ur
perl eles
he
ent hat um
t
,
at ached t Pl ntf s c pl nt. Fe R.Ci P.1 c CA c py o awrt e
t
o ai if om ai
d.
v. 0()
o f
it n
i t entt i an exhi tt a pl ng i a par oft pl ng f a1
ns rum
hat s
bi o
eadi s
t he eadi or l
pur
poses.) Seealo,SolsRam iezv.U. De tofJus ie, 758 F. 1426,
'.
'
s
ir
S. p'
tc
2d
1 0 ( t Ci .1 )(e to t i i r to ag nc wasatac d t t
43 11 h r 985 r por f he mm g a i n e y
t he o he
c mpl ntand pr pe l c ns d r dby c ur i r i o Rul 1 ( )
o ai
o ry o i e e
o t n ulng n e 2*)6
moton)
i .
2
i M i i att As um O fi , on M ay 31,2001,and ans er ques i as
n am , he yl
fce
w ed
t ons
t hi pr ous em pl entby t Guat al governm entas a polc ofi er
o s evi
oym
he
em an
i e fc
( 97 1 )a adee tve(978 1 ) i l ng tm e w orki w i h a
1 4-978 nd ic i 1 - 984, nc udi i
ng t
m iiar i eli
lt y nt lgence uni i
t dent fed as G22w hi h i
ii
c nves i ed s
t gat uspec ed
t
g r il ,a alo a a prs wa de ( 985- 987 .
ue rlas nd s s ion r n 1 1 )
On M arc 5,2002,Pl ntf w as det i t be i i bl f as um ,
h
ai if
erm ned o
nel gi e or yl
and t dec si w as uphel upon r ew by t As um di s on oft
hat i on
d
evi
he yl
vi i
he
Ofi e ofI er i
fc
nt natonalAf ai s. Acc ng t a s m ar oft f t i t
f r
ordi o um
y
he ac s n he
U SCIS Deci i dat June 22, 2012,t r e i l
s on
ed
hat evi w nc uded a fndi t dn
i ng hat t
i
lghtofc
i
ount y condi i i or at on s fc t t G- and yourt i ony
r
tons nf m i pecii o he 2
estm
t you gat ed i orm aton on an arr t ci lan suspec ed ofbei
hat
her nf
i
es ed vii
t
ng
guer las t evi
il , he denc es abls t you assi ti t pers
e t i hes hat
s n he
ecuton ofot s
i
her
on t ac ountofpoltcalopi on.''
he c
ii
ni 3
z ' r ord r erst G2 and G - , i er
'he ec
I
ef
o
2 nt changeabl
y.
3 ree doesnoti l
r
rhe ord
nc ude a c
opy ofan agenc doc entf om 2002
y
um
r
advii Pl ntf t U SCI (hen known ast I m i aton and
sng ai if hat
St
he m r i
Nat alzaton Ser ce)had m adesuc fndi The r d doesr
ur i i
vi
h i ng.
ecor
evealt
hat
i 2002 Pl ntf w as notfed t he was i i bl f beneft avaiabl
n
ai if
ii hat
nelgi e or
is
l e
purs
uantt a s tem ent agreem entent ed i Am er can Bapt s Chur
o et l
er n
i
it
ches v.
Thor
nbur 760 F.Supp. 7 ( D.Cal 1 91 whih pr vi edpr t to
eh,
96 N.
.9 ) c o d
o ec ins
f s e c t z ofE1Sal
or om i i ens
vador or Guat al whom al o m et ot c i e a
em a
s
her r t ri
and s
oughtas um i t U ni ed Stat . Pl nt f w as det i t notbe
yl
n he
t
es ai if
erm ned o
e i itered't suchon t i s.q r i noc ed bl e de e t y0u
lgs ef r f r asbenefttthe e s r i e vi nc hat
bl o ' he e
hat '
l
r
egi
or
0n Apr l 10,2005,4Pl nt f w as i er ewed agai att M i i
i
ai if
nt vi
n
he am
As um Ofi e r atng t hi reques f as um , and ques i
yl
fc el i o s
t or yl
t oned regardi
ng
hi dut es as a w arden, atw hi h tm e he t t fed t duri hi t m e as
s i
c i
es ii hat
ng s i
war t i at were kil and t ve guar were ar t . O n
den wo nm es
led
wel
ds
res ed
Augus 16,2005, he was f
t
ound i i bl f as um s at and r er ed t an
nelgi e or yl
t us
ef r o
I i r to j gef rr m o pr c e ng .
mm g a i n ud o e val o e di s
On Sept ber 7,2005,Pl nt f w as notfed t hi r
em
ai if
ii hat s eques f
t or
as um ( s
yl pur uantt Fo m 15 )ha no be n g ant d and i t d was
o r - 89 d t e r e
ns ea
r f r e t a I mi r i n Judg f rad udiato i r m o lpr c e ngs a s
e e r d o n m g ato
e o j c i n n e va o e di ,
Pl ntf had notest i hed t he w as a r ugee. O n t sam e dat he
ai if
abls
hat
ef
hat
e,
al w as not fed t hi r
so
ii hat s equestf s
or uspensi ofde t i s alr e
on
por at on/ peci ul
canc l i ofr ovalhad notbeen grant and was r err t an
elat on
em
ed
ef ed o
I m i i Judge f dec si , as Pl nt f (
m grat on
or i on
ai if t
appear t be bar ed f om
ed o
r r
r le und rSe to 240 c( )o t I mi r i n and Na i na iy Ac
e i f e ci n A()5 f he m g ato
to lt t
( dNA'1( r o whoo d r i ie as it d, ro he wie pa tcpa e i
(I ' pe s ns
)
r e ed, nct d, s s e o t r s r ii t d n
t pers ut on ofot s on ac ountofrace, relgi nat onalt
he
ec i
her
c
i on, i
iy,
m em ber hi i a par i ul s i gr , o poiialo ninl'
s p n
t c ar oc al oup r ltc pi o .s
'
4
r Com pl nts est t i er e w as on Apr l10, 2005,but
rhe
ai tat hat he nt vi w
i
t U SCIS r d st es t Pl nt f w asi er ew ed on A ugus 10, 2005.
he
ecor at hat ai if
nt vi
t
5 appr m at y t sam e t m e, Pl nt f r ved a N otce t Appear
At
oxi el he
i
ai if ecei
i o
i I m i i Cour on M ay 18, 2006,t N ot c advi ed hi t r oval
n m grat on
t
. he
ie
s
m hat em
pr eedi had been i i ut as he had rem ai i t U ni ed St es
oc ngs
nstt ed,
ned n he
t
at
wi hout aut i i
t
hor zat on.
4
Duri t c se oft r ovalpr
ng he our
he em
oceedi , Pl nt f s wie6
ngs ai if
f
s
ubm i t a pett on, purs
t ed
ii
uantt f
o orm 1 130,s
eeki i m i aton beneft
ng m gr i
is
f herhus
or
band. O n Apr l16, 2009,t I m i i Judge t m i ed
i
he m grat on
er nat
Pl ntf s r o pr
ai if em val oceedi , no i t tPl i ifsr que tf ra j t e
ngs tng ha a ntf e s o d us m nt
ofst us waspendi bef e t agenc The 1 130 r
at
ng or he
y
equestwas appr
oved on
.
M ay 26,2009,and -consi t wi h t appr
s ent t hat
oval w hi h r
c equi Pl ntf t
red ai if o
,
appl f perm anentr denc wi hi t rt days on June 7,Pl nt f
y or
esi
y t n hi y
ai if
-
s
ubm i t For 1- , seeki per anentres denc i t U ni ed Stat .
t ed
m 485
ng m
i
y n he
t
es
On Sept ber 14 and N ovem ber 9, 2009,Pl nt f appeared f U SCI
em
ai if
or
S
i er ews att H i eah Fi d Ofi e. H e w as ques i
nt vi
he al
el fc
toned abouthi dutes
s i
as a det t ve and as a war
ec i
den i Guat al .
n
em a
On June 22,2012,Pl ntf s applc i f s at as a per anent
ai if
i aton or t us
m
r dentw as deni Acc di t t r
esi
ed.
or ng o he epor oft deci i , t U SCI
t hat
s on he
S
dec i t exer s is di c i t gr Pl nt f s r
lned o
ci e t s reton o 'ant ai if eques af erfndi g hi
t t i n s
t t m ony t be notc edi e. Specii l t U SCI not t t he
es i
o
r bl
fcaly, he
S
ed hat t
t
t tm ony you pr ded dur ng your i er ews c erni youri vem ent
es i
ovi
i
nt vi
onc ng
nvol
*0 h i r c / ie t and awar nes o t ac sc m mit d w i h the aid of
t ndie td r c )
e s f he t o t e
t
.. .
t po i e det i i G uat al i notf
he lc
ectves n
em a s
ound c bl asi i c rar t
redi e
t s ont y o
t ext i c
he ens ve ount y c
r ondi i i orm at on f
ton nf
i ound regardi t hum an
ng he
ri s vi at onsc m it .. ..' Co l ng t t ne tv f t r ( s
ght ol i
om t ed ' nc udi hat he ga i e ac o s hi
c
onduc i Guat al , and resdencei t Unied St esil l
tn
em a
i
n he t
at legaly)
T l ntf sw ie al o i a nat ve ofGuat al , butshe had r ei a
ai if
f s s
i
em a
ec ved
Cer ii at ofNat alzat on f
tfc e
ur i i rom t U SCIS on Sept ber 29, 2006.
he
em
5
o we g d t po ii e f t r ( sf l te , and l h ofr i e i t
ut i he he s tv ac o s hi amiy i s
engt
es denc n he
Unie St e ) t USCI ad s Pl i ift thewas notauthori ed t
t d at s, he
S vied a ntf ha
z o
rem ai i t U ni ed St es and shoul m ake a
n n he
t
at
d
rr
angem ent t depar as
so
t
s
oon asposs bl
i e.
On M ar h 7, 2013,Pl ntf fl t scas
c
ai if ied hi
e
,
as e tngj i diton unde
s r i urs c i
r
s ve als at e : e r lque to j i d c i n, 28 U. C. 13 , he
e r t ut s f de a
s i n urs ito
S. j 31 t
M andam usAct 2 U. C. 1 , heDeca a o y Judg e Ac
, 8
S. j 361 t
lr t r
m nt t
,
2
201, t Adm i s r i Pr c dur Ac ( PA' ( U
and he
nit atve o e es t W ' 5
)
.
28U . C.j
S.
S. j 7 e .
C. 01 t
s q.. Sp c fc l , Pl nt f c ai st D ef
e )7 e iialy ai if l m hat endant vi at a
s ol ed
r
egul or
at y
pr s on and,i doi s , c m i t a pr eduraler or nec i atng t s
ovi i
n ng o om t ed
oc
r
ess t i hi
Cour ' i er
ts nt vent on.
i
ANALYSIS
Pl nt f aleges t t U SCI reled on d - r ut t t m ony f
ai if l
hat he
S i
t ef ed es i
un
rom
Pl ntf s as um i er ews over 7 and 11 yearsol res t vel
ai if yl
nt vi
d pec i y
,
t
he
N ovem ber 9, 2009,1- i er ew and s
485 nt vi ,
econdar sour c
y
ce ondii ' and
tons'
t he ( as never pr ded t o
hat t
w
ovi
he ppor uni y t r
t t o ebut any o t derogat y
f he
or
i or at on pres ed agai thi
nf m i
ent
ns m
'
'
,
c rar t t pr s ons of8 C F. .
ont y o he ovi i
R
.
1 2() 1 () Thats cfcr ul in pr vi st tapetto i entil
03. b ( 6)i.
pe ii eg ato o de ha
ii ner s t ed
t be advi ed ofder
o
s
ogat y i orm at on w hi h f
or nf
i
c or
m s t basi ofan adver
he
s
se
7 Def
As
endant c ec l argue, t M andam usActand t
s orr ty
D
he
he
ec arat y Judgm entAc need notbe addr sed h
l or
t
es
t
h
ere -ast A PA pr des
he
ovi
e r evantf am ew or .
el
r
k
i m i i dec s on and ofer an
m grat on i i
f ed
o
ppor uniy t r
t t o ebutt i or aton,
he nf m i
butt ri t be advi ed and t o f
hat ght o
s
o f
er r
ebut ali bas on t pett oner
t s ed
he i i
bei unawar ofsuc i or at on.
ng
e
h nf m i
Pl nt f ac
ai if knowl
edgest when h
hat
e w asques i
t oned by t agenc , t
he
y he
i e v e rt d alud t s me (o r c ndii ns t ough hi lne of
nt r i we ' l e o o c unty) o to hr
di
si
ques i ng'butPl ntf c ai s t he w a
t oni '
ai if l m hat
s unaw are oft spec fc
he
ii
s atstcs ori orm aton t w as us t deny hi applcat on
t i i
nf
i hat
ed o
s
i i
.
He sayst
hat
he w as notpr ded an oppor uni y t r
ovi
t t o ebut t
d
gener sourc ' and R
al
es'
general
r
epor s f om out i publcsour es' us a
t r
s de
i
c ' ed
S
gai thi ,and com pl nst
ns m
ai hat
U SCI i r yi on t
S s el ng
hese gener sou
al
r and has notref enced any s ii
ces
er
pec fc
i t es ofPl ntf m i t i any
ns anc
ai if s reat ng
one under hi super s on.
s
vi i
The Cour hasrevi
t
ewed t r d p
he ecor
r ent by Pl nt f, and fnds
es ed
ai if
i
t Pl nt f hi s fhad t ii as t
hat ai if m el
estfed
o hi aw arenessofatl t s e of
s
eas om
t e generalc
hes
ondii i G uat al . Forexam pl
tons n
em a
e, dur ng hi efor s t
i
s f t o
o a n a yl (n 2001 Pl ntf t tfe t tt e G uat al arm y w as
bt i s um i
) ai if es ii d ha h
em an
doi t ds l ng f guerr las'i 1983
ng d
rai ooki or
il ' n
-
84 and t t G 2 woul have
hat he
d
d onf ont i wi h t guer il .' H e al o adm i t t he t
d r at ons t he
c
r las '
s
t ed hat d t
saw hem
m i t eatt pr soner , lke ki ki t
sr
he i
s i
c ng hem and pus ng t
hi hem do
w n on t w ay
he
t t bat oom .' W hen t i er ew er asked Pl
o he hr
'
g
he nt vi
ai if S d you hear
ntf : t
Di
8 ai ifadm i s t t si orm at on i t
pl nt f
t hat hi nf
i si
wi y avaiabl t t
del
l e o he
publc'butc pl nst he w as notm ad
i'
om ai hat
t
hi
e aw are t t U SCI w as us ng
hat he
S
i
spublci orm at on agai thi
i nf
i
ns m
.
g hen he w ast d by a s r or t r ai
W
ol
upe i o em
h
n s l ,Pl ntf c ai s t
ient ai if l m o
ave rai ed hi com pl nt agai , butt U SCI concl
s
s
ai s
n
he
S
uded t Pl ntf
hat ai if
7
an hi e s gbo G2J lke t m as gr
yt ng l e a ut , i he
s 'aves and hor
ror
s enac ed by G 2?'
t
'
Pl nt f res
ai if ponded:( di notk
t d
l
no anyt ngg)Ia a cv lan Tha i a l()
w
hi , m i ii
ts 1 I
.
ever hear ' H e al o t t fed t ï
d.
'
s es ii hat d
ot s m ay have har ed peopl but w e
her
m
e
di not'-an apparentc ess
d
'
onc i
on by Pl nt f t he w as aw ar
ai if hat
e
o t G 2'
f he s
m i onduc even i he s fcaly di
sc
t,
f
pecii l
s ai ed any di ec r e i s h acts.
cl m
r t ol n uc
M or
eove , i Sq em ber 2005
r n pt
,
Pl nt f w as advi by t U SCI
ai if
sed
he
S
i a
n
,
Not c Regardi Ref ralo Appl
ie
ng er
f
i
c i f Sus
aton or
pens on ofDe t i or
i
por at on
Spec alRul Canc l i ofRe
i
e
elat on
m ovalt he m ay be bar ed f om
hat
r r
i mi ato r le unde Se to 2 A()5 oft I
m c in eif
r c i n 40 c ( ) he NA
.
ThatN otce
i
s ii l r erenc t I provi on bar i d onsw ho or ed
pec fcaly ef
ed he NA
si
r ng d
pers
der
,
i t as i ed, or ot wi e par i i ed i t pers
ncied, s st
her s
t cpat n he
ecut on ofot s on
i
her
ac
countofrace,relgi , natonalt m em bers p i a par i ul
i on
i i y,
hi n
tc
ar soc al
i
gr
oup,orpoltcalopi on.' Af er r ei ng t s notce
ii
ni ' t ec vi hi
i , Pl nt f w as
ai if
i er ewed on t o addii
nt vi
w
tonalocc
aso (n 20 ) whi h s g t t theha
i ns i 09 , c ug es s ha
d
an o
ppor uniy att e subsequenti er e
t t
hos
nt vi w
s t di prove t he had
o s
hat
par i pat i t pe ecut on ofo hers. o
tci ed n he rs
i
t
l
Taki i o c i aton Pl nt f
ng nt ons der i
ai if
sow n t t m o t U SCI f
es i ny, he
S ound
t s nc Pl ntf w as a t em ber oft polc f e ass gned t w o
hat i e ai if
'
m
he i e orc
i
o
r al
k ong
wi h G2 m ii ar i eli
t
lt y nt lgenc ,
e
i i i o bl t t( )wo d be unawa e of
t s mpr ba e ha he ul
r
c i
ontnued t per or hi dut es '
o f m s i ' m
and
ade no f t r
ur her eport oft
s he
m i r m entoft
st eat
hose c ur and
apt ed
arr ed.
est '
'
' ai ifwas i er ew ed a t aloff
G nt f
pl
nt vi
ot
(wiei t c nt ofhi as um applcaton and tsiy i mi r ton o fcal
t c n he o ext
o tme b m g a i fii s
ur i w
s yl
i i
f per ane
or m
ce duri hi pett on
ng s ii
ntr i nc .
esde y)
8
t abusest oc r
he
hat cur ed
at t hands oft G - 2. Fur her
he
he
'
'
t
,
t agenc
he
y
de er i t d ordi
t m ned hat t
acc
ngt ( s t s i o t ( lg he ed i orm ati
o hi) e tm ny hat he at r nf
on
on and ar est c vii sus
r ed i lans pe
c ed ofbei guer las
t
ng
ril
,
( was i ol d i
he ) nv ve n
t pers uton ofot s
he
ec i
her
on acc
ountoft rpolt calopi on.
hei
ii
ni
' The U SCI
'
S
f
ound Pl ntf s t t m on
ai if es i
y t he had notcom m i t a
hat
t ed
c s ofper
t
secuton t
i o
be l ki i c edi lt and,bas on hi adm it
ac ng n r biiy
ed
s
t ed
em pl ym entas a polc
o
ie
det i worki w i h G 2
ectve
ng t
s
om ot o
i
, and hi subsequentpr
n t t posii of
o he
t on
w arden ofGuat al sl gest
em a' ar
pr s t U SCI c l
i on, he
S onc uded t
h
atPl nt f
ai if
had par i i ed i act w hi
t cpat n s
c r nd r d hi i lbbl f pe
h e e e m ne i e or r
m anent
r denc i t U ni ed St e
esi
e n he
t
at
s.
W hie Pl nt f woul pref
l ai if
d
ert have been advi oft s
o
sed he
pecii
fc
count y r
r epor s f om ac
t r
adem i and
cs
ot r s
he ourc as t t c
es
o he ondii
t
ons i
n
Guat al att t m e h
em a
he i
e w asw or ng w ih t polc f c
ki
t he i e or e
and a m ii ar
lt y
i eli
nt lgenc uni and al o
e t
s
as a w arden,i i notcl t t s C
ts
ear o hi
our t s
t hat uch
gener r
al epor s were us as t
t
ed d
der
ogat y i or aton'agai Pl nt f
or nf m i '
nst ai if
suc
h
t any f l e t provi hi
hat
aiur o
de
m w i h advanc not c w as a vi at on of8
t
e ie
ol i
C. R.103.2( )1 )i.The i o m ato g ea
F.
b ( 6 ()
nf r i n l ned f
r such re t appear
om
por s
s
m er y t have pr ded c extf t U SCI S eval i
el o
ovi
ont
or he
S'
uat
on ofPl ntf s o n
ai if w
t t m ony and t agenc sf
es i
he
y' i
ndi t hi t i ony w
ng hat s estm
as notc edi e.l For
r bl l
e
xam pl t U SCI f
e, he
S ound t lt
hat d
i
w oul be unreas
d
onabl t bel
e o i
eve t you
hat
woul nothave or ed, i i ed or o he se been i
d
der
nc t
t rwi
n
vol and aw ar oft
ved
e he
llhi Cour does notrevi
la s
r
t
e
he
s'
er nat on he
c edi lt ofa pet t oners t st m w t U scl s det m i i oft
r biiy
ii
' e i ony
.
hum an r ght vi at
i s ol i
onsocc ri agai tt sus
ur ng
ns he pect
ed guer il and
r las
i at c i i t
nm es ons der ng h
e posii and dutesyou h
t ons
i
e d.. ( )yo wine s d
l . and u t s e
.
t abus t w er d
he
es hat e
one att handsoft G - 2 and m ade onl t ee
he
he
y hr
at em pt t r
t
s o epor t
t hem .''
Even i t r por s
f he e t
,
or a por i t eof c t t e t t of
t on her , ons iut he ype
( ogat y i orm at o
t
der
or nf
i
n'r er ed i t r
' ef enc n he eg
ul i , the Cour does notfnd
at on
t
i
t Pl nt f w asuna
hat ai if
w are ofs i or at on p
uch nf m i
ri t hi i er ew s b
or o s nt vi
U SCI
S
y
The Cour fnds t s
ti
hat
uch generalt ogat
t
der
or
y i or aton'oft
nf m i ' he
c
ount y condii i i orm at
r
t ons s nf
i
on ofw hi h Pl nt f was
c ai if
wel aw are -asa
l
res tofhi ofi alr e as
ul
s fci ol
a polc det i and w ard
i e ectve
en and al o as
s
evi
denc i hi i er
ed n s nt vi
e s and r pons t t que
w
es
es o he
stonspos by t
i
ed
he
i m i at on ofi s.
m r i
fcer
.
Al hough Pl nt f c ai
t
ai if l
m s t he w as deni adva
hat
ed
nce notc t
i e hat
U SCI was r yi on
S
el ng
s l c e c unt y r po t ( nd t
ee td o r e r s a h
e s ii dat i suc
pec fc a n h
r po t )t pr de gener i or at
e r s o ovi
al nf m i
on aboutt c
he ondii i G uat al at
t ons n
em a
t t m e ofPl nt f sem
he i
ai if
pl ym entas a det i
o
ectve
and a warden, t Cour
he
t
does notfnd t suc
i hat h
l ofnotce c t t ed a vi aton oft
ack
i ons iut
ol i
h
e applcabl
i e
r
egul i
at ons Atm os
t t t ext t t gen
, o he
ent hat he
er r
al eport even c be
s
an
c i ed as G ogat y i
ons der
der or nf
or at on'agai tPl nt f
m i '
ns ai if
, any err
or c m it
om t ed
by t
heagene i notp
y n
rovi ng Pl nt f w i h t
di
ai if t ho
.
se country reports w as
har l s, i lghtofPl ntf so
m es n i
ai if
wn t t m ony and em pl ym e
es i
o
ntrec
ord.
I c l i , t Cour fndst Pl
n onc us on he
ti
hat ai
ntf s alegatons are
if l i
i ufi i t s
ns fc ent o uppor hi
t
sc ai ofpr eduralerr
l m
oc
o
r by Def
endant , and
s
1
0
t ef e di m i
her or s ssalpur
suantt F
o
ed.R.Ci . P.1 ( )i a o i e
v
2*)6 s ppr prat
.
ln
lghtoft abo , i i
i
he ve t s
ORDERED A ND ADJU DG ED t
h
att m ot on t di m i i GRANTED
he
i o s ss s
wih pr j ie.Thi c ei co e
t e ud c
s as s l s d
.
D ONE AN D O RD ERED i Cha
n
mb r i Mimi hs / a o Ma
e s n a t iR d y f y
-
2014.
W I AM M . OEVELER
LLI
SEN I U N I
OR
TED STATES DI
STRI JUD GE
CT
c est c
opi o: ouns ofrec
el
ord
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?