Generali - U.S. Branch v. Las Plazas Investments, LLC et al
Filing
22
ORDER Granting Defendant Jeffrey Ransdell's Motion to Dismiss the Complaint. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 9/13/2013. (vds)
'
t
)
:
t
'
j
t
'
)
j
'
)
,
,
q
1
sdi iI i so
anx lvii
i
(
1
UNI
TED STATESDI CT OURT FOR THE
STRI
SOUTHERN DI CT O FLORI
STRI
DA
Case Num ber: 13- 21113- V- O R EN O
C M
GENERALI - U S. BRAN CH d/ a THE
b/
I
.
GEN ERA L I SURAN CE CO M PAN Y OF
N
TRI
ESTE & V EN I
CE, as subr
ogees of
COECLERI
CIAM ERI SM A LESTATE,N C.
CA
l ,
Pl ntf ,
ai if
VS.
JEFFREY RAN SDELL,
Def
endant
.
/
O R DER G R ANTING DEFENDAN T FFR EY R ANSDELL '
S
M O TI N TO DISM ISS TH E CO M PLA I T
O
N
THI CAU SE cam ebef et Courtupon Def ntJef r Ransdel' M oton t D im i t
S
or he
end
f ey
ls
i o s ss he
Co aitf La kofSube tMat J iditona f Faiur t J na l s nsbl Pat a
mpl n or c
j c ter urs ci nd or l e o oi n ndipe a e ry nd
:
l c po aedM e a
n or r t
mor ndum ofLa ( E. 1 ) fld onJul 26, 3.Def n ntRa dela gue
w D. No. 2 , ie
y 201
e da
ns l r s
;
t tteCour s ddimist c ef lcko s j t atrj iditona ter i no c lt
ha h
t houl s s he as or a f ubec te urs ci s h e s t ompee
!
i
!
i
die st , postngt tCoe ei i ara pa t i itrs a a idipe a epat t t ij ne
v r iy ii ha
clrcis e l ry n nee nd n n s nsbl ry ha, f oi d,
,
)
desr di siy.THE COU RT hasconsder t m oton and t pertnentportonsoft r d,
toys ver t
i ed he i
he i
i
he ecor and
.
@
r
r
è
-
-
t
bei ot
ng herwie f l advied i t pr ies, i i
s uly
s n he em s t s
)
,
)
(
(
ADJUDGED t tt moton i GRANTED .
ha he i s
1
.
#
BACKGROUND
#
)
'
.
Thec ant lge t t f da JfryRan eI(6 ns l', ctze of orda la e
ompli ale s ha Deen nt efe
s lû de1' a ii n Fl i ,e s d
Ra
)
#
t
acn o nu u i i MimiFoia( e$ a Pa su i'ta wa o e b L sPaa
o d miim nt n a , lr t $ s lz nf) ht s wn d y a l s
d h L
z
(
)
(
.
j
!
j
è
q
'
'
(
.
)
(
'
*
)
E
.
q
)
'
%
1
.
'
'
I
7
,
ë
,
'
j
j
I
;
.
:
.
'
1
'
1
'
j
1
1
.
l t ent , LLC,a Fl da col aton. The LasPl
nvesm s
ori
por i j
azas uni i l ed atSuie 5401 900 Bicayne
t s ocat
t
s
,
f
j
Boulva d, i m i Fl i Coe e i i m e i a Rea Es a e l . ( coe e i ' , Fl i r ai
e r M a , orda. cl rc A rc s l t , nc d clrci)a ordaco porton,
d
'
:
è
)
)
r
j
'
)
q
(
k
i te o rofa c
s h wne
ondomi um u ti t s buidng a Suie 5201 (he ( ece i u f)
ni ni n he ame l
t t
t d lrci ni
co
.
Coecl i i ur is uni t ough a polcy of i ur
erci ns ed t t hr
i
ns ance s ued by G ener i U .S.Br
s
alanch d/ a t
b/ he
Ge rll uan eCompa ofTret & Venie(i ne l',aNe Yor c ai
nea nsr c
ny
ise
c s r i)
Ge
'
w k omorton.
O norab Apr l 201 t c
out i 7, 2, he ompl i ale st tRa d lltac ndl wihi t La Pl z
a nt l ge h
ns el i a e t n he s a as
uni a pl c d i i i a w o n c bi tbe or g ng t be Th b ni c ndl ale dl i t d
t nd a e t nsde
ode a ne f e oi o d. e ur ng a e l ge y gnie
t ew oo n c bi e , hust i ge i a fr s pr s o s i l rhe d I t d w ihi t La Pl z uni.
h
de a n t t rg rng ie up es i n prn e a oca e t n he s a as t
Thi r uled i t r eas ofa l ge am ountofwat i t Coecl i uni,causi dam age t t
s es t n he el e
ar
er nt he
erci t
ng
o he
Coe lrciu t Gene aipai isi u e Co lrc,a n si e es $1 28 1 f t da g
ce i ni.
r l d t ns r d, ece ii mo t n xc s 04, 4.9 or he ma e.
Bas upon t s paym ent Gener ialeges i i subr t t Coecl i t r
ed
hi
,
al l
ts
oga e o
erci o ecovert m oney f om
he
r
'
Ra d la LasPl za .
ns el nd
a s
The com pl nts
ai oundsi w ocount breach oft ecl aton and neglgence.Gener ialeges
nt
s:
he
ar i
i
al l
i
q
ta teCo rh s ie st u idito b c u eGe eaio teo eh n , n Ra s el n L s a a ,
h th ut a dv ri rs cin e a s n rl h n a d a d n d la d a Plz s
yj
,
)
t
on t ot hand,ar cii ofdif entsat
he her
e tzens
f er t es.
I.
I
i
DI
SCUSSI
ON
(
!
Dek d n Ra s el a mo e t ds s tec m litb lc o s be t te j rs ito ,
fn a t n d lh s v d o imis h o an fr a k f u jc matr u idcin
I
!
k
(
ar ng t e i notcom pl edi siy becaus t s og r,Coecl i ,i a r pary i i er tand
gui her s
et ver t
e he ubr
erci s eal t n nt es
l
j
(
t
'
è
.
7
)
'
a i s nsbl pat t tij ne detoysdi st R ns lagu t tGen alh i opel
n ndipe a e ry ha,f oi d, sr veriy. del r es ha er i as mpr ry
)
7
i ed t cii
gnor he tzenshi of Coecl i ,whi m us be i uded i t anal s becaus Gener i as
p
erci
ch
t nc
n he
ysi
e
al,
1
t
.
s b o e , a n talg ta ip i tee tr ls alg d s fee b Co ce ii I se d Ra s el
u rg e c n o le e h t t ad h nie o s l e l u frd y e lrc. n ta , n d l
e
:
(
t
)
ï
.
E
a g s Coe lrc pad a$1 000 de tbl un t epo iyt a c tt e a un ompe a e I s
r ue , ce ii i
0,
duc i e der h
c h t onsiuts n c
ns t d os
'
)
(
q
la Pl l t ent , LLC wasorgi l aD e ndanti t sac i H ow ever Pl ntf
tas azas nvesm s
i naly
n hi ton.
, ai if
di nottm el s 'e LasPl l t ent and t sCour accor ngl di ised t cas agai i.
d
i y el
v
azas nvesm s
hi
t
di y sm s he e
nst t
'
C
2
-
!
j
.
;
.
ù
(
.
-
1
(
l
i
)
'
4
.
5
j
)
'
y
(
f rwhi Co l rcic d pot nta l s ek r c r , r nde i Coe erc a r l ry i it r s a d
o
ch ec e i oul e i ly e e ove y e rng cl ii ea pa t n n e e t n
i
an i s nsabl pary.
ndipe
e t
i
Ge r l a ist a Coe e i ii a r a pary i i e es . H o e er Gen r i gue t tb n
ne a i dm t h t clr c s e l t n n r t w v , e al ar s ha ei g
a r pary i i tr tdoesnot perse,m ake a pary i s ns e. See Uniedst esv. na Cas t
eal t n nt es
s
t ndi p abl
t at Aet
.t
Su . Co. 338 U. 36 (949 ; AGSC Ma i I . Co v S cr Undegr nd, I .,
r
,
S. 6 1 )
rne n
. pe tum
r ou
nc
8:2 - 4-T-30
l-cv 47
TGW ,201 W L 2087 ( . Fl zol tol n t tt i urd i n a
2
441 M D. a. zlh dig ha he ns e s ot n
idip abl pa t t afder c ta to br htbyap ri l s br atd i ur r es aly when
n s ens e ry o e al our c in oug
taly u og e ns e , peci l
j id r u dd p ietec u t f u j c matr uidcin .Ge eai set t a ih sterg to
on e wo l e rv h o r o s be t t j rs it ) n r la srs h t t a h ih t
e
p o e i t s a ton i is o na e w iho na i t i ur d.
r c ed n hi c i n t wn m
t ut m ng he ns e
The Co ta r swih Ra de lsa gum e tt a t c pl ntm us b di m i s d f f l r t
ur g ee t ns l' r
n h t h om ai
t e s s e or aiu e o
j i Co ceii a n c say a d ids e sbe p ry wh s p e e c d sry dv ri . Be a s
on e lrc, e e sr n n ip n a l a t
e r sn e eto s iest
y cu e
Coe l rci i a r alpa t i i t r s who has a a l
ce i s e
ry n n e e t
n lege unc pe a e I s f w hi h i c d
om ns t d os or c t oul
pur t dl s e r c r a i tRa de l i woul be i uia ef Ra de l o de e t o pos i e
pore y e k e ove y ga ns ns l, t
d ne t bl or ns l t f nd w
s bl
s t co eni tes mec us o a to a rs i o itn j me s I T av lr l mni
uis nc r ng h a a e f cin nd ik nc n se t udg nt. n r ee s nde t
y
Company v.W e i
stnghouse El rc Cor ., 42 F. 77 ( h Ci.1 0) t Fit Cic ta fr a
ect i
p
9 2d 5t r 97 ,he fh rui fimed
dimis lofapata s og e' c an frfiuet j nt s r or whowasdeemi dt b
s sa
ril ubr e s omplit o alr o o he ubog ,
tr ne o e
a i s ns bl pa t und rRul 1 wh epr e ede to e di r iy. Se aloAxi n . . . l
n ndipe a e ry e
e 9 os es nc s r d ve st
e s
sl s Co v Hal,
287F. D.l1 ( Me. 2)Gn nga i urdt b ane es r a i s nsbl pat un rRul
R. 0 D. 201 ( di n ns e o e
say nd ndipe a e ry de e
1 bt a t t i ur d ha a unc
9 c us he ns e d n ompt a e l s ofa 5,000 de tbl a dim isng t s t
ns t d os
duci e nd s s i he ui
I
be a ej n rwoul d toydi riy .
c us oide
d esr vest)
TheD it c ofM ai t oughl anal
srit
ne hor
y
yzed t si u i 2012 i Axi Ins. Co.The Cour not
hi ss n
n s
t ed
t dc/ whi i cied by G ener if t pr
hata na, ch s t
al or he oposii t an i ur w ihadeductbl i anecess y
ton ha
ns ed t
i es
ar
bu n idipe a epat ha b ns re dbyt 1 rvii t Rul 1 b) Now, el b
t otn s nsbl ry, s ee upesde he 99 e sons o e 9( .
Rul 9()
-
3-
t
.
:
l
1
y
I
'
)
1
1
'
i
(
'
.
(
,
.
.
i
r qur s a pr g tc c s by- s a s s me ofwhehi t de tbl- payi g i ur d' abs nce
e ie
a ma i a e- ca e s e s nt
t : he duc i e
r
n ns e s e
i
.
t
'
(
:
'
r quie dimis l Ree ntf c o s icl e whehe t de tbl- yi i ur d ort e si
e r s s s a . lva a t r n ud
t r h4 duc i epa ng ns e
he xitng
t
)
p riswo l b peu ie b aj d me tntea s n e fh is r d wh te ta peu c c ud
at
e ud e rj dc d y u g n i h b e c te n ue , eh r h t rj die o l
.
b I s e i a ywa wheheraj gme twiho t is e woul bea quae and whet t
e esen d n n y, t
ud n t uthe urd
d de t,
her he
i s r rpl i tfswoul h ve a a qu t r m e i t a t n we edim i s d. I a 11 l5.Th: court
n u e a n if
d a n de a e e dy f he c i
r s s e d. t 4i d :dim i s d a a ton c nt ni a al os i e i a f c ua ba kgr nd t t on a pr s n . The
n-xf s s e n c i o ai ng n m t d ntc l t l c ou o he e t e e t
c ur poi e outt tt a l t i ur t pr e d i f d r co twoul efe tve y pr l t
o t nt d
ha o low he ns er o oc e n e al ur
d f c i l ec ude he
i u e f o i pl di t o he r alp t i i e es, a Rul 1 a c t mplt s 1 a 1 7.
ns r d r m m ea ng he t r e ary n nt r t s e 7( ) on e a e . d t 1
E
)
W hehe Coe lrc ch est purueis$1 000d d tbl i s t nga twhihonec n
t r ce ii oos o s t 0,
uc i e s omehi bou c
a
onl s c a e. Ne rhel s Coe e i ' u om pe a e I sarsng f o t s m e c us ofa ton
y pe ul t
ve t es , cl rcis nc
ns t d os ii r m he a
a e ci
#
!
)
ast i tnt s t r nd si ar al aryi it r s a a i s ns bl pa t . Addii naly, c us
he nsa dipu e e er t e p t n n e e t nd n ndipe a e ry
to l be a e
@
)
t lws ti i isifnc dimisn iwoul no c us nypat prj c The pari wilhave
he a ui s n t na y, s sig t d t a e
ry eudie
tes l
i
.
:
)
.
t i da i c t i Wilbesaec t Accor ngl
her y n our-but t l t t our.
di y,
)
.
The Def
endant sm oton t di i i G RAN TED t case i DI I
'
i o sm ss s
he
s SM SSED , a a lpe di
nd l n ng
m otonsa e DEN I A S M O OT.
i r
ED
-
DONE AN D ORDERED i Cha b sa M i m i F orda t s
n
m er t a ,
i , hi
da ofSe e b r 201
y
pt m e , 3.
)
.
)
7
)
J
FED l
k1 A .M OREN
> 1 ED STATES DI
STRI J GE
CT UD
Copi spr vi d t
e o de o:
L
(
y
'
'
t
CounselofRecor
d
j
)
;
y
ï
t
t
'
j
è
;
-
4!
l
t
'
.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?