Silber v. US Attorney Miami, FL

Filing 4

Order Dismissing Case and Denying All Pending Motions as Moot. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 4/29/2013. (tkn)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SO U TH ERN DI U CT OF FLORI
STI
DA
M i iD i s on
am
vi i
C a e N um ber 13- 37- V - O R EN O
s
: 214 Cl M

LEE SI
LBER,
Pl ntf,
ai if
VS.

U . ATTORN EY M I M I FL,
S.
A ,
D e e nt
f nda .
/
O RD ER D I I N G CA SE A N D D EN YI G A LL PEN DI G M O TI N S A S M O O T
SM SSI
N
N
O

THI CAUSE c
S
amebe or t Cour uponas s eexa i ton oft r c d.Fo t
f e he
t
ua pont
m na i
he e or
r he
r a o s tf t bel t sc s i DI I
e s ns e orh ow, hi a e s SM SSED.Addii l a 1pe ngm oto a e DENI
tonaly, 1 ndi
i ns r
ED
A S M OO T.

Pl n ifhasnotpai t a o i t flng f i flng hi c
aitf
d he ppr prae ii ee n ii
s ompl nt Ac or ng y,t
ai . c di l he

Co r wilc n tu Pli tf sc mpan a a i f r pa pe i c mpan . I hsc mp an ,
u t l o sr e anif o lit s n n o ma u rs o lit n i o lit
Pl i i f l est tD e e nt . Ator y M i m i FL e age i a tviy c tt i obs r ton
a ntf aleg ha f nda u s. t ne
a , ng d n c i t ons iutng t uc i

o j sie
f u tc .

Un e 28U. C. 1 5e ( )B)i, c u tthal imisteLn o mapau rsa to a
dr
S. j 91 ( )2 ( ()a o r t ld s s h i f r
s
pe i cin) t
an tm e i t c tde e m i t t... he a ton ...i fi ousorm ai i . Alhoug t
y i f he our t r nes ha
t ci
s rvol
lcous' t h he
'

saut us st t m ç ione , çj 1 5 a i t non- ioneri gen ltga s a wela
tt e e he er i s r' $ 91 pples o
pr
'
prs
ndi t ii nt s l s
pr s r .'Dav sv Si u I .Cor / s e net N o.1 1 c 041 TW T- J 2013 U . Di t
i one s'
i . gni s nv
p.An w r ,
: 2- v- 43A B,
S. s .

LEXI 49047,a * n. ( b.26,201 ( tngM a i zv.KrsiKlanes I .364 F. 1305,
S
t 2 2 Fe
3) cii
rtne
it e r, nc,
3d
1 n. ( 1hCi.
306 1 1 t r 2004) Rie av Ali 1 F. 71 722( 1hCi.1 ; ichelv Far as ,
; v r . ln, 44 3d 9, 1 t r 998)M t l . c s

1 2F.d 1 8 ,1 1n. ( 1h Ci.1 9 :.
1 3 4 3 49 1 1 t r 9 7
Ac or ng t t Unied St t Supr m eCour,aco pl nti fi ousS r i lc a
c di o he t
aes
e
t
m ai s rvol t e t a ks n
whe

ag a l b ssi lw o i fc. Netk v Wi ims 49 U. 31 ,3 ( 9 9 ( ic sn
r u be a i n a r n a t' i e . l a , 0 S. 9 25 1 8 ) d susig
' z
l
dimis l unde f mers ton 1 5( ,whi c ai d t s lngua a cure sci
s sas r or eci 91 d) ch ont ne he ame a ge s rnt e ton

1 5 e( )B)i) A c u t yds s camst e scin 1 5 e( )B)i wh r t camsrs
91 ()2 ( (). o rma imis li md r e to 91 ()2 ( () e e he li e t
on a i s a y me ils l lt r ora e c
n ndiput bl rte s ega heo y
r omprs off t c entonst ta e cla l
ied acual ont i ha r e ry
ba e es . 1 a 327.
s l s d. t

I Ne tke t Supr m eCour pr ded s ve a e
n iz , he
e
t ovi
e r l xnmpl soffi ousorm ai i c am s
e
rvol
lcous l i .
W he et def nti cea l i unefom s t orwhe e t pli ifal gesi rnge
r he enda s l ry mm
r ui,
r he a ntf le
nfi mentofa
lgalnt r t chobvi l doesno exit t n t c am i f
e i e es whi
ousy
t s ,he he l i s oundedon a i s a yme il s
n ndiputbl rtes
lgalt or f a 327. Cl m sde alng f nt tc orde usona s e rosfti o t f cualy
e he y. #. t
ai
t ii a asi
l i l c na i i nt he a t l
ba e es ca eg y.1 a 327- Fi l t sCour a s not st tapr s pl i ifm us be gi n
s l s t or d. t
28. naly, hi
t l o e ha
o e a ntf
t
ve

g e t le yi pla nghe c ant ne v Ke ne 404U. 51 ( 972)
r aer e wa n e di r ompli .Hai s . r r,
S. 9 1 .

M i flo t e ep icpe ,t Co r p o e d t e auaePlitf si f r pa pe i
nd u f h s rn ils he u t r c e s o v l t an if n o ma u rs
c pl i . l t sc e, he c pl i c ai no hi m or t n c s y,i
om a nt n hi as t om a nt ont ns t ng
e ha ur or ncohe e a l ga i
r nt le tons

t t heU. Ato ne sf iur t co i re de eofapr es i l e te ' deaht e t agans
ha t
S. tr y' a l e o nsde vi nc
of sona wr sl rs t hr a s i t

P an ifc n t ue o tu to o j sie P an ifsc mp an i fio o su d r2 U. C.j
litf o si td bsr ci n f u tc . litf o lit s rv l u n e 8 S.
t
1 5 e( )B)i b c u ei d e n t o ti C na g beb ssi 1w o i f c. Netk , 9 U.
91 ()2 ( () e a s t o s o c nan t r ua l a i n a r n a t' i e 4 0 S.
a
' z
a 327.Afe r vi wi t e ie c
t
tr e e ng he ntr ompl i ,t Cour c udest tt cai sa ei s a y
ant he
t oncl
ha he l m r ndiput bl
m e il s Furhe m or t c pl nt doe not a
rtes .
t r e, he om ai
s
dequa el s a e a c a m unde t hei e d
t y tt
li
r he ght ne

pe dn rq ie nso Fe ea Ru eof v l o e u e1 b ( ) S eAs rh v I b l5 6U.
la ig e urme t f d r l l CiiPr c d r 2()6 . e hc o . q a, 5 S.
66 ( 09) Ac or ngl i i
2 20 . c di y,t s
ADJUDGED t tt s ca e i DI I
ha hi s s SM SSED,a al pendi m otons a e DENI AS
nd 1
ng
i
r
ED
M OOT.Thi ca ei CLOSED.
s s s

DONE AND ORDERED i Cha be sa M i , orda t
n
m r t ami Fl i , hi

da ofAprl 201
y
i, 3.
?

v,
>
#
.. '

F
RI A . OR EN O
CO M
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI J DG E
CT U

Copi pr ded t
es ovi o:
Couns lofRe d
e
cor
Le Sibe
e l r
900 N W 6 Ave
nue
A pt 1
. 48
Fl i Ciy,FL 3303
orda t
4

( 6)42778
9361
Pr Se
o

U. Ator y' Ofi e
S. t ne s fc
99 N . 4t Ste
E. h r et
M im i FL 331
a ,
32

( 05)9619001
3
-