Boom v. Rosebandits, LLC. et al
Filing
27
ORDER denying 18 Motion to Dismiss; denying 18 Motion Judicial Notice. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 11/5/2013. (err)
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SO UTHERN D I
STRI OF FLO RI
CT
DA
M i m iDi s on
a
vi i
C as N um be 1 215 C1 M O R EN O
e
r: 3- 06- V-
ERI BOOM a BELLY & KI
KA
nd
CKS 1 LLC,
,
Pl ntf ,
ai if
V S.
RO SEBAN D I LLC , al,
TS,
ef .
D e e nt
f nda .
O R DER D ENY I D EFEND A NT S'M O T I N T O D I I
NG
O
SM SS
1.I roducton
nt
i
Thi i a c e f br a of c r c and i rnge entof bot c
s s as or e ch
ont a t
nf i m
h opyr ghta t a m a k.
i
nd r de r
Pl i ifErk Boom wa t f
antf i a
s he oundi m e rofDef ntRos bandis LLC, f e ore e
ng mbe
enda
e
t,
a emal- i ntd
biyc ecub.
c l l Boom alo ownsPli ifBely & Ki 1 LLC,w hi h doe bus ne s unde is own
s
antf
l
cks ,
c
s i s
rt
na e a unde t na e ' m Cyc i ' D e e nt Hea he M a a Duf y D a s a e
m nd
r he m '
Boo
lng. f nda s
'
t r nn nd
f
ni h r
me be soft Ros ba t a l de si t or ni a i
m r
he e ndis nd ea r n he ga z ton.
De e n sha f l d aM oton t D i m i st Com pl i . Conc r l w iht M otont
f nda t ve ie
i o s s he
a nt
urenty t he
i o
Dimi s De e nt as tld aRe tt tt Cour t J c a N o i o doc e sat c
s s , f nda s lo le
ques ha he
t ake udii l tce f um nt ta hed
t t M o i t D i m i s Fo r as e a ned m or f l be ow , t C o tD EN I t M oton
o he ton o s s . r e ons xpl i
e uly l
he ur
ES he
i
t Dimisa t Req s f J cal ie. De e n ha at c a srng ofe a l, y one
o s s nd he ue t or udi i Notc
f nda t s ta hed ti
m is onl
ofwhih wasmentone i t Co pl i .l e Def nda sdi no eve a t h t De e nt
c
i d n he m ant nde d, e nt d t n tac he f nda
M ann' r ponse em ai.l lght of t e a t
s es
l n i
hes t avhm ent , t Cour vi w s Def nda s M o i as a
s he
t e
e nt ' ton
motonf s
i or ummayj
r udgme , a amotont dimis W hiet Cour c nconsde docume s
ntnot s
i o s s. l he
ta
ir
nt
outi t pla ngswhent doe
sde he e di
he umen sa er f re t i t Compli ande nta t Pli ifs
t r e e r d o n he
ant
e r l he antf
cli , f nda shavegonet f ri hedoc e st yha a tche t t i m oton. Them oton
am De e nt
oo a nt
um nt he ve ta d o her i
i
t d s s i c n re t amo inf rs mmayj d me tDee d n ss lfl a Ans r oltr
o imis s o vetd o to o u r u g n . fn a t halie n we n ae
t n N o m ber 22s201
ha
ve
3.
I .Fac ualand Pr edur Bac ound
I
t
oc
al kgr
Ac di t t Com pl nt Pli ifBoom frtc ei d oft i f t Ros ba t
cor ng o he
ai , antf
is onc ve
he dea or he e ndis
i Augus 2009,a bega wor ng a ound t ttm eon gr ng t cub. She a s ca e up w ih
n
t
nd
n
ki r
ha i
owi he l
lo m
t
t namea d l d al whi f aur das l t l e as hol ngar ei ist e h,
he
nd eveope ogo, ch e t e kul wih ong yel hes di
os n t e t
wih t wor ' e ndis' rte i ac s ve f bel . On Se e r15, 0, n Pl i if
t he d ' ba t 'w it n n ur i ont ow
Ros
pt mbe
201 whe antf
Bo w asr
om
oughl 8 m on hspr
y
t
egna , he s nta e a lt ot Ros ndism e be s i l ng
nt s e n m i o her eba t m r , ncudi
Defnda sM n a Da s I t te a l s i onnedt m t t due t t i pe ng bit of
e nt nn nd nih. n ha m i, he nf
he ha ,
o he m ndi
rh
h r hl s ewo l h v ls t t d v t t t e o ss eddfr h cu wh c s es i icu e
e c i h u d a e e s i o e oe o h j b h i o t e lb, ih h ad n ld d
d,
me
we ie ma eme ,a cou i s orhi a t e tbls e tofal ga e iy. Acc di
bst nag nt c ntng, pons s p, nd he sa ihm n
e l ntt
or ng
tt c
o he ompl i , f nda M a r pondedt t e alon Se e r17, 201 s a i t tot x
ant De e nt nn es
o he m i
pt mbe
0, t tng ha he
me be swoul tyt pi u t sa k. h e l a e e i il r e e d i t Compli .
m r
d r o ck p he l c Bot mais r xplcty ef r nce n he
ant
Fr f l 201 t oughm uc of201 Boom s
om a l 0 hr
h
2,
uppore heRos ba t, t h a l s a tve
tdt
e ndis houg t e s c i
l ve t n be or he pr na y.On Fe ua y 22, 2011 Ros ba t ,LLC fl f a tad r
e l ha f e r eg ne
br r
e ndis
ied or r ema k
r sr ton t twa s t nta l sm ia t t l Boom ha deve ope . The U . Pa e a
egita i ha s ubsa ily i l r o he ogo
d
l d
S. t nt nd
Tr mar Ofi is d Ros ba t ,LLC a tade k on Se e
ade k fce s ue
e ndis
r mar
pt mber 1 , 2011 Boom Cyclng
3
.
i
s
pons e t Ros ba t ea h s as n, nd e e e i t aone- a s
or d he e ndis c e o a nt r d n o
ye r pons s p conta ton M a 1
or hi
rc
y ,
201 Boom satd t ts ' lowe 'hecl t c i usnghe m a kandname. A spa toft t
2.
t e ha he a l d't ub o ontnue i
r r
r ha
s o s p,
pons r hi Boom Cyclng a l dt cl t us fve Boom Cyclngbiycl durng t s as
i lowe he ub o e i
i c es i he e on
a pur ha et m f ar duc prcea t c l i n oft s s . On M a 22, 2,heUnie
nd c s he or e ed i t he onc uso
he ea on
y 201 t
td
Stt sCopyrght fc is dar gita i t Boom f he orgi m a k. I J nua y 2013,
ae
i Ofie s ue e sr ton o
or r i nal r n a r
Boom
c rs
ore ponde vi e lwih De e nt t ne it a s or hi co r c f 201 . O n Januar
d a mai t f nda s o gota e pons s p nta t or 3
y
l 201 Boom r eveda e lfom De e
0, 3,
ec i
n mai r
f ndantM am t tld he t bele t tt ywe ec os
l ha e r o i ve ha he r l e
t r wi t i de .
o ene ng her al Howe r on J nua y 1 , 201 D ef ntM a ca l d Boom ' hus nd t
ve , a r 5
3, enda
nn le
s ba o
i or t m t tt Ros ndiswoul go wih a dif e biycl s orf 201 . Pl n if
nf m he ha he
eba t
d
t
fer nt c e pons or 3 ai tf s
a l get tDe enda salow e t ne bi l s
le ha f
nt l d he w cyc e pons t begi adve ts ng iss
or o
n
r i i t pons s p prort
or hi i o
t conc us on of Boom ' e us ve s
he
l i
s xcl i pons s p. Be or t e of t s
or hi
f e he nd
he pons s p pe i , t
or hi r od he
Ros bandisce s d rdi on t fame t tBoom Cyclng ha pr de undert s orhi
e
t a e i ng
he r s ha
i
d ovi d
he pons s p
agr ent.
eem
OnAprl 201 Pl ntfsbr
i29, 3, ai if ought herf - tc pl nt e ngr m e esf br ac
t i ourcoun om ai s eki e di or e h
ofc r c a i tRos ba t , LLC, i e tc
ont a t ga ns
e ndis
d r c opyr gh i rnge e a ns a1 de enda s and t o
i t nf i m nt gai t 1 f
nt ,
w
c s of ta
ount
r dema k i rnge e , ba e upon t l
r nfi m nt s d
he ogo a na e, r pe tvel a i t a l
nd m
es c i y, ga ns l
def nda s Pli tfsa tche t c i tr gitai a t s or hi c r t ase bis
e nt. a n if ta d he opyrgh e sr ton nd he pons s p ontacs xhi t
t t Compli .On J l 201 De e nt fl t rM oton t Dim ist Compl nta
o he
ant
une 0, 3, f nda s ied hei
i o s s he
ai nd
Re u s f r u iil tc . fn a t' oi nf r u iil o ies e t a t eCo r tk j dca
q e to l dca No ie Dee d n sM to o J dca n tc e ks h th u ta e u iil
no ieofsxpa sofe a l i udi Pli ifBoom' Se embe l , 201 e a l ot e a l
tc
i ge
m is ncl ng antf
s pt
r 5
0 m i and her m is
pur t y com i f om t ts m e cha n. Not bl t e a l Def nda s ha a t he do no
poredl
ng r ha a
i
a y, he m is e nt ve tac d
t
i ude D e e ntM a s Sept m be 1 , 201 r y e a l The Def nt alo a k t Cour t
ncl
f nda
nn'
e r 7
0 epl m i.
enda s s s he
to
tkej cilnotc ofRosba t,LLC' atcl ofor ni ton,ta ma k rgitai , and
a udi a ie
e ndis
S ri es
ga zai rde r e srton
s r c m a k r s r ton.
e vi e r egit a i
111 A nal s
.
ysi
TheCour ha t dic e i t a e ore ude t doc e sou sde oft pl di .
t s he s r ton o cc pt xcl he um nt t i
he ea ngs
-
3-
Pr pe t M gmt & I . ' ,I .M Le s,752 F.2d699,604( 1bci.1 .Whe
o ry
. nv s nc
wi
1 t r 985)
n
,
on a 1 b)6)
2( (
motont dimisf f l et sat acli , ' t r outi t pl di a epr s nt t a not
i o s s or aiur o t e am ' e s sde he ea ngs r e e ed o nd
mat
e cu e b tec u ttemo inmu t ete tda o ef rs mmayj gme t n e Rul 5 'Fed.
x ld d y h o r,h to s b rae s n o u r ud n u d r e 6 9
.
R.Ci P.1 d) Da v Ta or 400 F. 1 , 1 76 ( 1h Ci.2005 .The 11h Cic tha
v. 2( ; y . yl ,
3d 272 275- 1 t r
)
t rui s
r ognie an e e i whe e ' c tma c i radocumen a t he t
ec z d
xc pton
r ' our y onsde
a
t tac d o
am oton t dim is
i o s s
wi o t o v rigtemoi nit o efr u r j d me tfh atc e d c me ts( ) e ta
t u c n e t h to no n o s mmay u g n it e ta h d o u n i 1 c nr l
h
n
t t pli ifscai a ( undiputd 'l atl 6;Horsly v Fel ,304 F.d 1125
o he antf l ms nd 2) s e 'd 27
e
dt
3
.
l1 ( lh
34 1 t
Ci. ) Thet m ' s ed'me 'hathea hentct oft doc nti notc l d.'
r 2002 . er ' put ' ans ' t ut iiy he ume s halenge '
undi
t
.
,
I The 1lh Cicui ha nota
d.
t r t s
nnounc able - lte r ef dee mi ng whe he a doc e ti
ed a k et r ul or tr ni
t r
um n s
' e r 't t pl ntf c e;i t d c t ha f us d on af ctbas d a ys s
' ntal'o he ai ifs as nsea ours ve oc e
c
a - e nal i
.
2100 Condo.As n, I c @
s' n .
See Weis v.
s
So n' Cu v ,2 2 W L 8 51 22 a *l( D .Fl .O ct 17, 201
la s r e 01
7 1 t S
a
.
2)
.
( kamp,J..Somefcor c t ha f us d on i ude whehe t cli de nd on t
Rys
)
a t s ours ve oc e
ncl
t r he ams pe
he
doc
ument, t rt c
s whehe he ompli a lgest contnt oft doc
ant le he
e s he u
m e s orwhehert doc e s
nt ,
t he um nt
a eanec s a y par ofpl ntf e f ta ma ng hi c am .'l
r
e sr
t
ai ifs for t ki
s l i ' d.
l t c e a ba , Pl ntfsrf r dt t e isi t c
n he as t r ai if eere o wo mal n he ompli : 1 Plitf Boom'
ant ( ) anif
s
Se e r 1 201 ema lt m e
pt mbe 5, 0
i o mber ofRos ba t
s
e ndis
,
a ( Defnda M a srs ee i
nd 2) e nt nn' epons mal
.
l r pons ,D e e nt a t he a s resofe a l . l e esi y, a sr pons emai t Boo
n es
e f nda s tac d e i
m is nt r tngl M nn' es
e
lo
m
i not m ongt e l . Furhe , antf se a l sno , src l s ki atac a iso emai
s a
he mais t r Pli if m i i t tity pea ng, t hed s t wn
l
.
Ra h ,i i f l quot a t botom of a e ala Ve oni a M e n,a Ros ba t m e r
t er t s uly
ed t he t
n m i n r c
ni
e ndis mbe
unr a e t t sadi , s i r pons t Pl i i fBoom ' Se e be 1
el t d o hi
on ent n es
e o a ntf
s pt m r 5
,
201 e ai. c en
0 m l The ont t
oft e l r ngefom eon e ua l be gnt s r y r l va t t c s a ba . e m pl
he mais a
r
t xt ly ni o qua el e e nt o he a e t r For xa e
,
one e oft s c r , t ea e aha ulofemaisat m ptngt a r ngea outn t
nd he pe t um her r
ndf
l te i o ra
n ig o
at
cel at
ebr e
t gr sSe embe rhdays Ont ot ere t r a ee a l fom Def nda M am t J nni
he oup' pt
rbit
.
he h nd,he e r m is r
e nt l o e f
er
4-
-
J g am e roft gr a a a t ne , a e sngt cossa l lr r nt ofs tng
or e, mbe he oup nd n tor y ddr s i he t nd ega equieme s eti
teRo e a isu a a5 ()3 n n r ft Pl ntf Boom wasnoteven copi d on t s lter
h s b ndt p s 01c( ) o p oi ai if
e
he e at
.
e l
mais.
l i difcul t a gue t tt s e al a e ' en r l't Pli if 'cli s I a a st t
t s fi t o r
ha he e m is r ' ta ' o antfs am . t ppe r ha
c
De e nt a e at
f nda s r temptng t pe s det cour t tt e lte e l ar ' ntal'o Pl i ifs
i o r ua he
t ha hes at r mais e ' r 't antf
ce
cli sbe us Pli ifr f r t he own e lsdicli e t s
am
ca e antf e e s o r
mai' s am r hat o
meoneele woul ne d t t
s
d e o ake
ove t t s ofesa ihi Ros ba t a alga e iy, a Def ntM a t t i ta i
r he a k
t bls ng
e ndis s e l ntt nd enda
nn ook he niitve
a di t .De e
nd d hat f ndant a e notpe m it t daiy c i doc
s r
r ted o s ha n ument i o t pla ngs i t s
s nt he e di n hi
-
f s on.
a hi Undoubt y, Pl ntf Boom ' ema li c r t hercai .
edl ai if
s i s ental o
lm
Ne rhels ,t docume s
ve t e s he
nt
i t ee i c an ta teDee d n sa kt i Co r t j d cal n tc aeno Pl ntf cl ms
n h mal h i h t h fn a t s hs u to u iil o ie r t ai ifs ai
y
.
dono de ndont doc e s t c
t pc
he um nt ;he ompl i doe not l gefom t c e ofa lore mos
ant s ale r he ont nt l, ven
t
,
oft e l;a f rfo beng ne s a yt t c am s s eoft e a l ar note n r e nt
he mais nd a r m i
ce s r o he l i
om
he m is e
ve elva
,
.
l ed, antf wasnote n i pos e son ofs
nde Pli if
ve n s s i
omeoft m os r e nte aisi t c i
he
l el va m l n he ha n
Thus
,
.
t Cour fndst tt ' res nde e t ke t t ri br de t n t c a m s a l ge
he
t i ha he ' r po nc a n oge he s oa r ha he l i le d
co
' See
'
.
Weisv 2100Condo. As ', n .@ Sla % Cu v , 0l WL 8 51 2 a * .
s .
sn l c
o n re 2 2
7 l2 t 2
Alhought Cour hasdic e i t exeudet doc e sa l o y a t pl adi
t
he
t
s r ton o l he um nt nd ook nl t he e ngs
whe r lngont m otont dim is t bel ra oa h i t a ce t doc m e sa c
n ui
he i o s s , he te ppr c s o c pt he u nt nd onver t
the
moi nt ds s it amo in f rs mmay j d me t Si y put t se docum ent cannotbe
to o imis no
to o u l u g n mpl s he
s
.
unr a Re inc on t doc e spenne t st m o i t dim i
e d. la e
he um nt
a e he ton o s s
s and t doc e sa e t
,
he um nt r he
s c m a e i lf t tr t c pt s of D e e nt ' na r tve of t c s Furher i i vi t ly
our e t r a or he i s ha er
f nda s r a i
he a e. t , t s r ua l
i o sbef rteCo r t spaaeM a nse isa d tea j dc tvef c t t fve da lt
mp sil o h u to e rt n ' mal n h d u iai a t ha, i ys aer
,
M a or ni d Ros ba t a a LLC f om D e e
nn ga ze
e ndis s n
r
f ndantsc nt nton t Pl ntf Boom w a ' '
' o e i hat ai if
s'
a'
f di me be of Ros ndis a no 'he'f
oun ng m r
eba t nd t ' ' oundi
t
ng
-
5-
m em be a Pl ntf ale s i t
r s ai if l ge n he
Compli .Re ol ng t is ofwhehe Pl ntf Boom f
ant s vi he s ue
t r ai if
ounded Ros ba t on herown ora
e ndis
s
agr p m a pot ntaly s veasacrtc f c t t out om eoft sc e. Thus doc nt t tt
ou
y e i l er
ii al a t o he c
hi as
, ume s ha end
t s
o uppor Def nt' i oft f c ua diput s d no be c i e i am oton t dimi s
t enda s sde he a t l s e houl t onsder d n
i o s s
f f iur t saeacli . I s t t e alc i pr s nt pa tbu nota l oft pit e
or a l e o t t
am n hor, he m i han e e s r t
l, he c ur
,
,
a t
nd he
itrsso j siea eb te s r e b watn u tlh pit r i c mpltd Se O fc Ma I c v
nee t f u t r etr e v d y iig n ite cu e s o ee e fîe x n . .
c
.
Co nyPlï Prn, n .8 2F. p z 2 , 7 ( M e.2011.
u t i/ itl c, 0 su p.d 71 2 8 D
'c
)
.
Re r ngt a to ldoc nt at c t t motont dim is
ga di he ddii na
ume s ta hed o he i o s s
c u tma u iil
o rs yj d cal
y
n iematr ofpublcrcor wihoutconve tnga 1 b)6)motont dimisi oamoi f
otc tes
i e d t
ri
2( (
i o s s nt
ton or
,
s mmayj d me t n e Rue5 Hamo v Bo r ir r s c Cop., 404Fed. ppx.376, 377
u r u g n u d r l 6. l s . ma de Ae opa e r
A
( 1bci. 0) Se Br v AvadoBrands,lnc., 1 F. 1 l 1 (11hCi.1 . hiet
1 t r201 ; e yant
87 3d 27 , 278 t r 999) W l he
.
Co r ma u iil n tc matr of bi rc r , i m ay notdraw i er ncesfom t m att
u t yj dcal oie t s pu l e o d t
y
e
c
nf e
r he
he
moton t dimissage Stat dlol ng, LC v Fog Ca Ret l nv sor LL C,51 Fed.
i o s s t . r f i di L
or
.
p ail e t s
6
Appx
,
.
874a #1( 1hCi. i 1 201 . ot rdocume satc dt Def nt' otont Dim is
t 1 t rAprl 6, 3)The he
nt ta he o enda s M i o s s
t Compli a e( )Ros ndis ArilsofOr niai fldbyHeahe MannonSe ember
he
ant r 1 eba t' tce
ga z ton ie
t r
pt
1 201 ( Ros andisJ 28,2011 ta r tlng, a d ( )Ro e a dt s r ie mak
9, 0, 2) eb t une
rdemak ii n 3 s b n is e vc r
r s r ton.
egit a i
M n fl t Ari e ofI or a i ame ef da afe Boo
nn ied he tcls nc por ton
r our ys tr
m s nthe e a lsa i
e
r m i t tng
t ts wass alngba k he wor f Ros ndis
ha he
c i
c r k or eba t .
Fo t ee u totk j d ca noieo t efl g
r h o r t a e u iil tc f h ii
n
whiedr wi no i e e est tt flng da es pporsDef nda s t or e t tPl ntf Bo
l a ng nf r nc ha he ii
t u
t
e nt ' he i s ha ai if om
wa not'he'f
s
' ' ounde butj t' 'me
t
r
us ' ' mberoft gr fom t begi ng woul rquie a
a
he oup r he nni
de r
s pe i ofdi belefnot m a l a s a e w ih l lpr e ngs.Fort e r
us ns on
s i
nor ly s oci t d t ega oc edi
hes easons
,
t Cour
he
t
de i st tkej calnotc a t stme
clne o a udii ie t hi i
.
Thus t Cour tnds t tt be tc s ofa i i t c
, he
ti
ha he s our e cton s o onve tt m oton t di m i s i o
r he
i o s s nt
6-
-
amo inf rs mmayj d me tpemit epa t st e g gei d so r a dc mplt t erc r ,
to o u r u g n , r th ri o n a n ic vey n o ee h e o d
e
a dalw tep rist a n ter to frs mma yj d me t t h c n lso o ds o ey
n lo h a t o me d h imoins o u r u g n a t e o cu in f ic v r
e
.
As a r ul,t Cour doesnotr ac t me is of Def nda ' a gum e st tt ta mar
es t he
t
e h he rt
e nts r
nt ha he r de k
,
c i , nd br c ofconta tcai ss d be dimis d a t stm e
opyrght a
ea h
r c l m houl
s s e t hi i .
I .Conc us on
V
l i
THI CAUSE c mebef et Cour uponDee
S
a
or he
t
fndant Motont Dimis( .E.No.1 ) fldon
' i o s s D
s
8 ,ie
June 1 201
0. 3.
THE COURT ha co i r dt moton, r pons a t pe tne pori oft r c d,
s nsde e he i es e, nd he ri nt tons he e or
a bei o he wief l a s d i t pr s , i i
nd ng t r s uly dvie n he emies t s
A DJUD G ED t tt m oton i D EN I . The Def nda s Reques f J ci Notc i
ha he
i s
ED
e nt '
t or udi al ie s
lke s DENI
i wie
ED. Def ndant s l fl a Ans r no lt r t n No m be 22. 2013. The
e
s ha l ie n
we
a e ha
ve r
Dee d n sma r-ietermo inf rs mmayj d me t ttec n l so o d so e y
fn a t y efl h i to o u r u g n a h o cu in f ic v r
.
DONE AND ORDERED i Cha be sa M i mi Fl i ,t s
n
m r t a , orda hi
da ofNove r 2013.
y
mbe ,
z v.
'
. '
.
FED E CO A .M O EN O
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
Co e pr vi d t
pi s o de o:
Couns lofRe r
e
co d
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?