Bank of America, N.A. v. Grec Homes IX, LLC et al

Filing 182

Clawback ORDER. Signed by Magistrate Judge John J. O'Sullivan on 4/10/2014. (tro)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
SOUTHERN DI I OF FLO RI
STR CT
DA

( a Di son)
Mimi vii
CA SE N O .I3ZI7I8- V- LTONA GA/ '
CI A
O SULLI
VAN
BAN K OF A M ERI ,N .A .
CA
,

Pl n ifcou e - e e nt
ai tf/ nt r D f nda ,
GREC H OM ES I ,LLC ;etal,
X
.
Def
endant /
s count - ai f s.
er pl ntif

CLA W BA CK O RDER

Purua t Fe r RulsofEvie e502( and( ,a t si ai oftepate
s nt o deal e
d nc
d)
e) nd he tpulton h ris

ta tef l n Clwb c Or (t de' s lb enerd i t a e- p inedc s ona
h t h olowig a a k der i r' hal e t e n he bov ca to
or )
ae
t m po a y ba i onl u i s c tm e a t Cour c n s hed e a m ut aly c ve en he r n
e r r s s y, ntl u h i s he
t a c ul
u l on ni t a i g

dae,t c ie 1 t ne d f s h a Or ra / 2)t tr t rofa t fciiae
t o onsd r ) he e or uc n de ndor he ems hee nd o a ltt
Pl i if s a lt t tm e y c pl w ih pr c i t t i due t D e e n s b Frda Apr l
a ntf ' bii o i l om y t odu ton ha s
y
o f nda t y i y
i
t.
r hal
pt
ve
11h The enty s lnot be deem ed an acce ance or w ai rby a pa' ofobe to t t
ny ly
t
j cins o he
enty oft Or or any of is t m s. The Or r i b ng e t r d on a t m po a y b i onl t
r
he der
t er
de s ei n e e
e r r as s y o

pr e tc rai prvieg d orot r ie pr t c e doc e s a d el c r c l sor d i or a i n
ot c e t n i l e
he w s o e t d um nt n e toni aly t e nf m to

(oleci l i ume ' orf c
c l tvey, i
doc nt' ' umens' a ns cli ofwa v un i t e Cou tc n c i r
do
t' gai t ams
)
i er tl h
r a onsde
t sm a t i t e e en t y a epr e durn t e c s o t sItg ton, whet pur uantt
hi ter n h v t he r oduc d i g h our e f hi ii a i
her s
o
an or ,a pary' dicovery r
der
ts s
eques , or i or a pr duc i La ge vol e ofdoc e t a e
t
nf m l o ton. r
um s
um n s r

bei pr e i t s c e a , t com pl w ih di
ng oduc d n hi as nd o
y t scover deadlnes t pari w ih t
y
i , he tes s o
com pl e dicover as expedii y as pos bl , w hie pr vi and not w ai ng any
et s
y
tousl
si e
l eser ng
vi

e d ta y pr t c i or cl i s of p i l g s o c i n i lt a i abl t t i or a i
vi en i r o e tons
am
rvie e r onfde ta iy pplc e o he nf m ton

t a m a be c t n d i t pr
ht y
on ai e n he oduced docum ent A ccor ngl , i i O RD ER ED A ND
s.
di y t s
ADJUD GED asf l :
olows
Th pr duc i n of a d um e t a c t i prvie d or o h r i e pr e t d
e o to
ny oc nt h t on a ns i l ge
t e w s ot c e
i o ma i s l n be de m e a w a ve or i im tn ofa cl m ofprvieg orevi i y
nf r ton ha l ot
e d
i r mpa r t ny ai
il e
dentar

potcinf tedoc me orf t s j c matroft do me , i l ng,butnotlm ied
r e to or h u nt or he ube t te he cu nt ncudi
i t
t an cl m s ba e on t at ne - i n prvieg ort w or pr duc do t i , orany cl m s
o, y ai
sd
he tor y cle t i l e he
k o t c rne
ai

ofc s ntaiy purua t te Con i ntaiy Or rc ee i t s c e ( No 9
ontde ilt s nt o h
fde ilt de ntrd n hi as ECF
9)
(ole i l d oece l or ton'.An pr ci ofdoc t s lbewihou prj di
c lctvey,s t td nf mai ' y odu ton
pr
)
umens hal
t t eu ce
.

t t pr
o he oduci part s rghtt cl m t t docum ent cont n Pr ect l or i , and t
ng
y' i o ai hat he
s
ai ot ed nf maton
he

pr i pary s l not b h d t h ve w a ve is rgh s by s h pr c i . The pr
oduc ng t ha l
e el o a
i d t i t
uc odu ton
oduci
ng
pa t s l notbe r r t pr t a t e pr
ry ha l
equied o ove h t h oduc i wa i ad ren , t t i t r onabl
ton s n ve t t ha t ook eas
e
s eps t pr
t o event dicl e oft Pr ect l or a i , t a i t r s bl se t r c iy
s osur
he ot ed nf m ton h t t ook ea ona e t ps o e tf

t e r ,or t t i ac e pr m pty t r c iy t dicl s e M or
he r or
ha t t d o l o e tf he s o ur .
eover t m er pr
, he
e oducton of
i
d um e s c t i ng Pr ec e I or a i wihoutf t rus oft t Pr t c e l or a i n i
oc nt on a ni
ot t d nf m ton t
urhe e ha o e t d nf m to n
t si ony,a t i , or on a m oton o he t an a m oto t c p a c e plt d by t s
e tm
t ral
ny
i t rh
i n o om cl s ont m a e
hi

Ore , h lno b de d dne tona'purua tt Fe r Rul ofEvi nc 50 a( )
d r s al t e eme d tni l' s n o deal e
i
de e 2()l
.

l t e r c vi g pa t r vi w s a d um e t t o is f c a a s t c t n
f h e ei n
ry e e
ny oc nt ha n t a e ppe r o on ai

Pr e td I or ton,t r evi pat s l()rfanfom ra ngtedoc me a mor
otce nf mai he ec i ng ry hal: a eri r e di h
u nt ny e
cls l ta i ne es r t a c rai ta ima c ai Pr ece l or ton;( i dit y
o ey h n s c say o s et n h t t y ont n ot td nf mai b) mme ael
notf t pr
iy he oduci pary i wrii t t i has di
ng
t n
tng ha t
scover a docum ent t t m ay cont n
ed
ha
ai

Pr t ce I or ton ien iyi t doc n b Baesnumbe ;a ()te tt do
o e td nf ma i d tf ng he ume t y t
r nd c r a he cume ta a
n s
Re ale Docu nt( fne b ow)a r t n i i a c da e wih t s Or e , wihi tn (0)
c ld
me de i d el nd eur t n c or nc t hi d r t n e 1
busness days of dicover . N ot ihsandi t f egoi , t r vi par y i under no
i
s
y
w t t ng he or ng he ecei ng t s

oblga i t r e t pr ci pa t sdoc e t t i e iy a Pr e t d l or aton.
i ton o eviw he odu ng ry'
um n s o d ntf ny ot c e nf m i

A pr uci pat ma se t rt n ofa doc nt(d ald Do ume '
od ng ry y e k he eur
ny ume i lc c nt'
Rec
)
pr c d i t s a ton t att e p t l t r c a m s s ul h ve be n w ihh d
odu e n hi c i h h ary a e l i ho d a
e t el

on t gr ndst a
he ou
ht

i c ai Pr e t d I or ton b pr vi ng wrte no i e oror lnotc i d i r d on t
t ont ns ot c e nf ma i y o di
i n tc ,
t
a
i e f elve e
he

rc r a a d p sto (No ie o Re al) wi i tn ( 0 b sn s d y o dic v r Upon
eo d t e o iin i tc f c l', t n e 1 ) u ies a s f s o ey
i
' h
.

r vi a Notce of Recal, t r c vi pa t m us pr
ecei ng
i
l he e ei ng ry
t ompty r t n t e Re a l d Do um e
l eur h
c le
c nt

a d a y ha d a e e toni c e , al w ih any not , a ta t , or c pia i ns o t
n n
r nd l c r c opi s ong t
es bs r c s
om l to f he
cont oft Recaled Docum ent wi n t n ( 0)b i s d ys ofi r c p oft No ie o
ent he
l
,
t e 1 usnes a
hi
t e eit he tc f
s

Re al.El c r c co e of a Re le Doc e s l b r m o d f om t r cei ng pary'
c l e toni pi s
ca l d
um nt ha l e e ve r he e vi
t s
el r c s t
ectoni ysems,r ovabl m edi , a a r vi w d a s s a t r c vi p t s l s
em
e
a nd ny e e at ba e nd he e ei ng ary ha l o
ceriy i w rtng t t pr
tf n ii o he oduci pary. The r vi pary s l be r ponsbl f t ki
ng t
ecei ng t hal
es i e or a ng

r a on bl s c t r t i e al c e of a Re ale Doc e t i udi t
e s a e t ps o e rev l opi s
c ld
um n , ncl ng hose disem i ed t
s nat o
o he s a s lc tf i w rtng t t e pr ci pa t t t al co es ha b en r t ned.
t r , nd hal eriy n ii o h odu ng ry ha l pi
vc e e ur
W h l t e r t r o a Re a l d D o m en i pe n t r c vi g pa t s l not r ew,
ie h e u n f
c le
cu t s ndi g he e ei n
ry hal
evi
dicl e or o h w i e us t doc e t o t Pr e t l or a i . Con e por ne w ih
s os ,
t er s e he um n r he ot c ed nf m ton
t m a ous t
s vi a N otce of Recal, t p oduc ng p t s l s ve a upda e prvieg l f t
er ng
i
l he r
i ary ha l er n
t d i l e og or he
Recaled Docum entpur uantt t LocalRul oft sCourt
l
s
o he
es hi
.
4.

N ot ng i t sO r shal pr
hi n hi der l eventa r vi pafy fom appl ng t t Cour t
ecei ng ' r
t
yi o he
to

c le a pr ci p t s c ai w ih r s c t a Re a ld Doc e a i such i t
ha l nge odu ng ary' l m t e pe t o ny c le
um nt nd n
nsance
t pr
he oduci pary s lm ake any chalenged docum ent avaiabl f
ng t hal
l
s
l e
ori camera r ew by t
n
evi
he
Cour .l t eventofa chalenge, t pr
t n he
l
he oduci pary s lhave t bur of es ablshi t
ng t hal
he den
t i ng he

prvieged na ur oft Pr ect l or aton.
i l
t e he ot ed nf m i

5.

The r ei n pa t m a notus or dicl e t Pr e t I or a i con ai ed
cc vi g ry y
e
s os he ot c ed nf m ton t n

i a Re a ld D o
n
c le
cumen a t t
t nd o h
ee en t tt ePr t ce l or ton c
xt t ha h o e td nf ma i
ont n d i aRe ale
aie n
c ld
Doc
umen ha a r a be n us d i
t s le dy e e
n orde c i d i ot erd ume sge
s rbe n h oc nt n
e ae orman ane by
r td
it i d
t e r ce vi pa t t r c vi
h e i ng ry hc e ei ng
pa t ma no us t os o h doc nt et
ry y t e h e t er ume s ih
er,unl and untl
ess
i
ach lng i ma t t pr ducn
ale e s de o he o i
g p r y' c ai a t Cou tr s ve t e ch l ng i t e
a t s l m nd he
r e ol s h ale e n h
r c vi pa t sf vor afe t e ex r ton ofa r he
e ei ng ry' a , t r h pia i
ny e a i g a a pe pe i
rn nd p al rods
.

The r vi pary' r ur of
ecei ng t s et n

a Re ale D o m en a pr vi d i t s Or r
c l d cu t s o de n hi de

s l no a ta a wai roft r c vi pary' ri t m ove f t
ha l t c s
ve
he e ei ng t s ght o
or h
e pr c i oft Re a l d
odu ton he c le
D ocum enton t gr
he oundst t e docum enti noti
hat h
s
n

fc s be toava ecam o p i lg o
a t u j c t ibl li f rvi e r
e

e de i r p ot ton, However t r c i n pary i
vi nta y r ec i
t spr bie a esopp f om a g
, he e e vi g
ohi t d nd t ed r
r ui t t
ng ha
t e pr uc i o t do um e
h od ton f he c
n s i t s c s a t as a y a ve of
t n hi a e c s
vi r
a a i a e prvie or
n pplc bl i lge
e de i r pr t c i n, t tt dic os r oft Pr ec
vi nta y o e to ha he s l u e he ot t
e l or a i w a noti d re ,t
d nf m ton s
na ve tnt hat
t e pr uc ng pa t di no t
h od i
ry d t ak
e r onabl s eps t pr
eas
e t
o event t di os r of t Pr t c e
he scl u e
he o e t d
l or a i , ort a t pr i pa t f ld t t
nf m ton
h t he oducng ry aie o ak
e r a on bl s e t r c iy t e r a s
e s a e t ps o e tf he r or s et
f t i Fe er l Rul of Ci l P
orh n d a
e
vi
r d e 26()5)B) Th pr cig pat ne m ake no
oce ur
b( ( . e odu n ry ed
s ow i wih r pe tt m e s est k
h ng t es c o a ur a
e t pr ve tt ia re pr cton oft d
n o e n he n dve tnt odu i
he
ocum ent
s
i qu s i i or rt b e ild t t ei r ur
n e ton n de o e ntte o h r et n.
Thi Or rs al be no be u e t r uie a pr ci pary t di c os orpr
s de h l
t s d o eq r
odu ng t o s l e
o e
duc
Pr t c ed l or a i w ihou t opporuniy t revi such
o e t nf m ton t t he
t t o
ew
i or a i pr o t pr duc i .
nf m ton i r o o ton
DO NE AND O RD ERED i M i m i Fl i t i ? a t
n a , orda s P y 201
4.
,

JO H N ' LIVAN
SU
UNI
TE STATES M AG I
STM TE JUD GE
CC#

couns ofr d
el ecor

4