Corbacho Daudinot v. Puig Valdes et al

Filing 42

ORDER SETTING SCHEDULE, REQUIRING MEDIATION, REFERRING CERTAIN MATTERS TO MAGISTRATE JUDGE,AND ESTABLISHING PRE-TRIAL PROCEDURES. Pretrial Conference set for 10/15/2015 11:00 AM in Miami Division before Judge Kathleen M. Williams., Jury Trial set for 11/16/2015 in Miami Division before Judge Kathleen M. Williams., Calendar Call set for 11/10/2015 11:00 AM in Miami Division before Judge Kathleen M. Williams., Amended Pleadings due by 10/31/2014., Discovery due by 6/19/2015., Expert Discovery due by 6/19/2015., Joinder of Parties due by 10/31/2014., Mediation Deadline 7/17/2015., In Limine Motions due by 9/30/2015., Dispositive Motions due by 7/31/2015., Pretrial Stipulation due by 9/30/2015.), ORDER REFERRING CASE to Magistrate Judge Andrea M. Simonton for Pretrial Non-Dispositive Matters, ORDER REFERRING CASE to Mediation. Mediation Deadline 7/17/2015., Notice of Court Practice. Signed by Judge Kathleen M. Williams on 6/30/2014. (lbc)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
SO UTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
CASE NO .1322589- I A M S
W LLI

M I UEL ANG EL CO RBACHO DAUDI
G
NOT,

Pl ntf
ai it
VS.

YASI PUI VALDES al a YASI PUI and
EL
G
èl
EL
G
MARI VALDES GONM LEZ.
TM
Def
endant
.
/

ORDER SETTI SCHEDULE.REQ UI NG M EDI O N.REFERRI CERTAI
NG
RI
ATI
NG
N
M ATTERS TO MAG I
STRATE JUDG E,AND ESTABLI NG PRE- A L
SHI
TRI
PRO CEDURES

Thi M ATTER i setf ti durng t Coud' t week ti cal
s
s
or ral i he
s woral endarbegi ng
nni
on Novem ber 16,2015. Cal
endarcal wi be hel on Novem ber 10, 2015,at 11:
l l
l
d
00
a. . 400 Norh M i i
m ,
t am Ave. M i i Fl i Coudr
, am , orda,
oom 11- Perr
3.
equestoft Pari ,
he
tes
a pr ralconf ence wilt e pl on Oct
eti
er
l ak ace
ober 15, 2015,at 11: a. . 400 Norh
00 m ,
t

M i iAv ,Mi i Fl i Courr
am
e. am , orda,
toom 11- The Padi shal adher t t f l ng
3
es
l
e o he ol
owi
.

schedul
e:
Schedul
e.
Jul 25,201
y
4

The Padi shal f ni I s wih nam es and
es
l ur sh i
st
t

addr
esses off tw inesses. The Padi ar undera
ac t
es e
contnui
i ng

obl i
i on
gat

t
o

suppl ent di
em
scover
y

r pon es wi n t ( 0) day o r eit or o h
es s
t en 1
hi
s f ec p
t er
notce ofnew orr sed i or aton.
i
evi
nf m i

Oc ober31,201
t
4

The Padi shal fl m otons t am end pl ngs or
es
li
e
i
o
eadi

j n Padi
oi
es.

Aprl15,201
i
5

The Pl nt f shal di ose expers, exped w iness
ai i
f
l scl
t
t
sum m ares and r
i
epors,as r r by Feder Rul
t
equied
al e

o Ci l oc e 2 2)
f viPr edur 64 .

Aprl 2015
i30,

The Def
endantshal dicl expeds, exped winess
l s ose
t
sum mares and r t as r r by Feder Rul
i
epors,
equied
al e

ofCi l oc e 2 2)
viPr edur 6( .

May 15,2015

The Padi shal exchange r t exped winess
es
l
ebutal
t
sum m ares and r
i
epods,as r r by Feder Rul
equied
al e

ofCiiPr c e 2 2)
vl o edur 64 .

June 19,2015

The Padi shal com pl e aI di
es
l
et I scover i udi
y, ncl ng
exped di
scover
y.

Jul 17,2015
y

The Padi shal com pl e m edi i and fl a
es
l
et
aton
i
e
m edi i r
aton epor w ih t Coud.
t t he

Jul 31,2015
y

The Padi shal fl aI di
es
l i I sposii pr ti m otons
e
tve e-ral
i
and m em or
anda ofl .
aw
2

Sep emb 3 201
t er 0, 5

The Padi s al fl a j n pr -rals i l i as
es h l i
e oit e ti tpuat
on,
r r b L al e 1 1 e andfnal o s j y
equi y oc Rul 6. ( )
ed
i pr po ed ur
is r c i s. J n pr os j y i tu t s or
n tu t
on oit op ed ur nsr c i
on
c cusons o Iw (orn jur ti s s lou l 1
on l i f a f on y r ) hal tne: )
al
i
t I
he egal el ent of Pl ntf cl m s, i udi
em s
ai i
fs ai
ncl ng

damag 'an 2)t Igalel t o t de en es
es d he e
,
emen s f he f s
t ar r sed.
hat e ai

Sept ber30,2015
em

The Padi shal fl winess and exhi t I s and aI
es
li t
e
bi i
st
I
m otons i l i ' The w iness I shal i ude onl
i n i ne.
m
t
i
st
l ncl
y
t
hose w inesses t Pari act l i end t cal
t
he
tes
ualy nt
o
l

at t i and shal i ude a bref s
ral
l ncl
i ynopsi of t r
s
hei
t i ony. The exhi tI s shal i iy each winess
estm
bi i
st
ldentf
t
t wi i r
hat l ntoduce each exhi t
l
bi.

I
I
.

Me a i W i n t dy ( day oft dat oft s Or ,t e Padi
diton. t hi 30) s
hi
he e
hi der h
es
shal:sel a m edi or cerii under LocalRul 16.2( ) s h e a t
l ect
at
t ed
f
e
b ' c edul i
,
me,
dat and pl f medi i , a j n l fl a pr pos d or ers he ig
e,
ace or
aton' nd oit i
y e
o e d c dul
n
m edi i as show n on t Sam pl For O r Schedul M edi i f
aton
he
e
m der
i
ng
aton ound
i t For s l ed on t Coud' websie I t Padi cannotagr on a
n he
m ocat
he
s
t f he
es
ee
.

1I appl e. t Padi shalfl any m otons t excl exper t i ony based on
f
i
cabl he
es
li
e
i
o
ude
t estm
Feder Rul ofEvi
al e
dence 702 and Dauber 7 M er e/ Dow Phar aceut s, I ,509
t.
r /
m
i
cal nc.

U. 5 ( 9 ) t dy ( 0)da prort t cal
S. 79 1 93 , hi 3
ys i o he endarcal.
l
3

m edi or t shalnotf t Cl k i wrtng i medi el , and t Cl k shal
at , hey
l iy he er n ii m
at y
he er
l
desi e a cerii m edi or on a blnd r aton basi . Counsel f aI
gnat
t ed
f
at
i ot i
s
or I
Padi shalf ii i t
es
l am l ze hemsel wih, and adher t al pr si ofLocal
ar
ves t
e o, l ovi ons
Rul 16.
e 2.

11
1.

Ref r , Pur
eral
suant t 28 U. C.j 63 and t s Ditit Ma sr e J ge
o
S
6
hi s r ' gitat ud
cs
.

LocalRul al non- sposii pr ti m otons and di
es, l
di
tve e-ral i
scover di es ar
y sput
e
r ered t Magi r e Judge Andr M . Si ont
ef r o
stat
ea
m on. Such m otons shal
i
l
i ude,but ar not I i t , m otons t appearpr hac vi m otons t
ncl
e
i t o
m ed
i
o
o
ce,
i
o

pr
oceed i f m a paupers,di
n or
i scover r at motons, m otons f ator s
r el ed
i
i
or t ney'
f
ees and cost and m otons f sanctons
s,
i
or
i

.

However t s O r does not
, hi der

r erany m oton t r
ef
i hat equest a contnuance oran ext on oft pr ti
s
i
ensi
he e ral
-

m otons deadl ort ti dat The Padi shal com pl w ih t separ e
i
i
ne
he ral e
es
l
y t he
at
.

pr e e on di o er di t an obec i as s t ou i Atac men
oc dur s
sc v y spues d j t
ons
e tn t h t

I
V.

Motons. Sti com pl
i
rct
i
ance wih t LocalRul i expect wih r d t
t he
es s
ed t egar o
m oton pr i
i
actce. See Local Rul 7 1. For exam pl when flng none
e,
i
i
.

di
sposii m otons,t m ovi Pady shal subm i a pr
tve
i
he
ng
l
t
oposed or i W or
der n
d

f matvi emai t Ch er a W ii @ f d. s ouds.
or
a
l o amb s t lams l u c
l
s
gov Local Rul
e
.

7. ( ( . Coun el f t e mo n p
1a)2)
s or h
vig ady m u t alo c f , or m ake a
s s oner
r
easonabl efor t conf ,bef e fl cerai m otons, as r r by Local
e f to
er or ing t n
i
i
equied

Rue 7. ( )3)
l 1a( .
4

AI m otons and atachm ent t m otons ar r r t be fl i a t
l i
t
s o
i
e equied o
i n ext
ed

s r abl f ma pu s tt CM/ Admiitat e Pr edu e 3G( .
ea ch e or t r uan o
ECF
nsr i oc r
v
5)
Stit com pl
rc
i
ance w ih t Local Rul i al expect wih r d t
t he
es s so
ed t egar o

mot s f su
i or mmar j dgmen . Se Loc Rue 5 1. Forex e,t e
on
yu
t
e al l 6.
ampl h
m ovi Pary m us cont por
ng
t
t
em aneousl fl a s at entofundi ed mat i
yi
e t em
sput
eral

f t delneatng by number each m at i f , suppoded w ih specii
ac s, i i
eral act
t
fc

ci i t t r or ( ck En r Ex bi Pag Nu
ltons o he ec d Do et ty, hi t
, e mbers ) Th
ll. e
opposi Pady m ustfl cont por
ng
i
e
em aneousl wih is opposii a r
y t t
ton esponse t
o
t st em entofm at i f t , whi shalr
he at
eral ac s
ch
l espond by corespondi num ber
r
ng

t each oft m ovi Pary' st em entofm at i f t . Lo lRue 56. a)
o
he
ng
t s at
eral ac s
ca l 1( .
The opposi Pary shal s at , based on ci i t t r d, whet
ng
t
l t e
t ons o he ecor
at
her
each f ti di ed orundi ed I t f i di ed,t opposi Pady
ac s sput
sput
f he act s sput he
ng
.

shal s at why t di e i a m at i one. S I m at i f s setf
lt e
he sput s
eral
' I eral act
A
odh i t
n he

m ovants st em ent ...w i be deem ed adm it unl contoveded by t
' at
l
l
ted ess
r
he
opposi pady' st em ent pr ded t t Cour fnds t t m ovants
ng
s at
, ovi
hat he
ti
hat he
'
st ement i suppoded by evi
at
s
dence i t r d.' Loc Rul 56. ( .
n he ecor '
al e 1b)

These pr
ocedur shal al appl t t movi Pary when r
es
l so
y o he
ng
t
espondi t
ng o
any addii
tonalf s setf
act
odh i t opposi Pady' st em ent of m at i
n he
ng
s at
eral
f t
ac s.
The Pari m ay stpul e t ext
tes
i at o
end t tm e t answer i erogat i ,
he i
o
nt r ores

pr
oduce docum ent and ans
s
wer r
equest f adm i on The Padi shal
s or
ssi
es
l
.

notfl wih t Coud notces orm otons m emoral ng any such stpul i
i t he
e
i
i
ii
zi
i aton
unl t stpul i i erer wih t tm e setf com pl i di
ess he i aton nt f es t he i
or
etng scover , f
y or

hearng a m oton,orf ti . Such stpul i m ay be made onl wih t
i
i
or ral
i atons
y t he
Cour' appr . See Fed. R. Ci P.29. I addii t t docum ent
ts
oval
v.
n
ton o he
s

en
umer t i L al Rul 2 1 b) t e Paris sh l n t fl n ies o
aed n oc
e 6.( , h
te
al o i ot
e
c
f
deposii w ih t Cour.
ton t he
t
Any Pary seeki t m ake a flng undersealshal com pl wih LocalRul
t
ng o
i
i
l
y t
e

5. Th Pari c tov r t e r r
4. e t anno eri h equi
es
de
emen soft a Rul t o aj n
t h t e hr ugh oit
pr ectve or .
ot i
der

Any pary seeki t change any oft above deadl m ustfl a Moton
t
ng o
he
i
nes
i
e
i
t Contnue or Moton f Ext on ofTi e. Notces of unavaiabiiy w il
o
i
i or ensi
m
i
l lt
l
notbe const ued as m otons t contnue orot
r
i
o
i
he- i oper e t change
se
at o
t Cour ' schedul i any w ay.
he
ts
e n

V.

J w l tuci s. The Pari s lsu tt i pr s j r is r c i s
u nsr ton
t hal bmi her opo ed u y n tu t
es
on
j n l t oug t e n no ag ee on ea an e y i tu t
oity, h h h y eed t r
ch d ver ns r c i l t e
on. f h
Padi do notagr on a pr
es
ee
opos i tuc i , t i r i shal be set
ed ns r ton hat nstucton
l

f t i bol t ace. I r i
orh n
d ypef
nstuctons pr
opos onl by a pl ntf shal be
ed
y
ai if
l
underi , i r i
lned' nstuctons pr
oposed onl by a def
y
endant shal be ial zed
l
t i
ci

.

Ever i r i m ustbe suppored by a ciaton of aut i . The Padi
y nstucton
t
t i
hort
y
es

shal use t El
l
he event Cicui Pater Jur I r i f Ci lCases as a
h r t t n y nstucton or vi
gui i udi t diec i
de, ncl ng he r tons t counsel The Padi shal subm i t r
o
.
es
l
t hei

pr
oposed i r i
nstuctons i W or f mat vi em ai t Cham ber at
n
d or
a
l o
s

W ii
lams@fs us ou g
l
ld. c ds.ov.

VI
.

Setl ent l t case setl i whol or i pad, counselm ust i or t
tem . f he
tes n
e
n
nf m he

Cou wi n t ( day b c l g Ch b s a ( 05) 5 - 540 an
d t wo 2) s y aln
hi
i
am er t 3
23 5
d
t ea fl aj n s i at o dimis .
her qer ing oit t
i
pul i f s s al
on
DO NE AND ORDERED i Cham ber , atM i i Fl i t s
n
s
am , orda, hi

day ofJune,

201
4.
.,

.''
.

.
.w

KA MLE N V . I AM S
W LLI
UNI
TED TATES DI
STRI JUDG E
CT

cc:

The Honor e Andr M .Si ont
abl
ea
m on
CounselofRecor
d

ATTACHM ENT GA'
'
DI
SCOVERY PROCEDURES FOR
MAGI
STRATE JUDGE ANDREA M .SI ONTO N
M

The di
scover pr
y ocedur bel appl t t s case.
es ow
y o hi
A. Pr hear no Com m uni i
ei
caton. l a di
f
scover di
y sput arses, Counsel m ust
e i

ac ualy speak t one anot (n per orvi t ephone)and engage i r
t l
o
her i
son
a el
n easonabl
e

com pr i i a genui ef or t r ve t r di
om se n
ne f t o esol hei scover di es bef e seeki Cour
y sput
or
ng
t

itreni . TheCoud e pe t aIPa e t a tc
nev ton
x cs I dis o c oudeou ya qr e i al i te
sl nd ofsson l n h
y
r uton of t r di
esol i
hei scover di es i an atem ptt r ve t dl
y sput n
t
o esol he scover i
y ssue pror
i

t set a h arn Th Cour ma i os sa ton ,moneay orot - ie i te
o ti
ng e ij. e
t y mp e nci s
tr
he s , f h
Cour det m i dl
t er nes scover i bei I pr
y s ng m opery sought or i not bei pr ded i good
l
s
ng ovi
n
f th.
ai

B.He rn Pr e e l,at co ern p e ar u bl t r ole t i
aiq oc durs. f fer nfrij, adis e na e o es v her

di
scover di es w ihoutCoud i er
y sput
t
nt venton,M agl r e Judge Andr M . Si ont w il
i
st at
ea
m
on l

sett mat f a hearng.Di
he ter or
i
scover di esar gener l setf hearng ( mi es
y sput e
al
y
or
i 10 nut
persi on W ednesdays and Frdays beG een 10: a. and 12: p. . Counselshal
de)
i
30 m.
00 m
l
appeari per att hearng.
n son he
i

The m ovi par y m ust seek r i by cont i M agi r e Judge Si ont s
ng
t
elef
actng
st at
m
on'

Chamber ( 523s 305- 5930) and pl ng t mater on t next avaiabl di
aci he
t
he
l e scover
y

c lnd . The mo ntmus c t tc mb s no lt t n t e ()bu n s da
ae ar
va
t onac ha er
aer ha hre 3 sie s ys

bef e t di
or he scover cal
y endar a
, Aerconf rng w ih opposi counsel
er i
t
ng
and confr i hI
im ng s
or heravaiabiiy.
l lt

f

Ont es meda t emat i ql e ontedic er c ln ,hemov ntsh l
h a
y h ters ac d h s ov y ae dart
a al

iea Notce ofHearngwhi shal brefy speci t subst
l
i
i
ch
l ll
î he
ance oft di
he scover mater
y t
t be hear ( exampl l Pari di e t appr i etmefamef Pl ntTs
o
d. For
e,'
The tes sput he
oprat i r
or ai i
l er ogat y Nos. 1, 5, 6- ' or '
nt r
or
9,
'
'
The Padi di e t num ber of deposii
es sput he
tons

per ted.) The Notce shal i ude a cedii i t t pari have compled wih
mit '
'
i
l ncl
fcaton hat he tes
i
t
t pr flng conf ence r
he e- ii
er
equied by S .D.Fl L. 7. a)3) A Notce ofHearng mustbe
r
a. R. 1( ( .
i
i

fl wihi f t (4)days oft dat of t occurence of t gr
i
ed t n oureen 1
he e
he
r
he ounds f t
or he
di e.
sput

The m ovant shal pr de Magi r e Judge Si ont a copy of aI sour
l ovi
stat
m
on
I
ce
m at i s r evant t t di
eral el
o he scover di e,vi hand- i y ort ough a scanned PDF
y sput a
delver
hr

d umen t a i e i d t t CM/ mal x ( mont @ f u ouA aov ,wh n
oc
t h t s mal o he ECF i
e
bo si on l sc
sd.
g ) e

t Notce ofHearng i fl ( exampl i t di e concer i erogat i , t
he i
i s ied. For
e, f he sput
ns nt r ores he

i er ogat i at i
nt r
ores ssue and t r
he esponse t et shal be pr ded t M agi r e Judge
her o
l
ovi
o
st at

Si ont s Cham ber )
m on'
s.

C.NoWrtenMoton Nowrte di o r moton i l igmoi st
i
t
i s.
i n sc vey i s,ncudn ton o
t

com peland m otons f pr ec i or ,shal be fl unl r
i
or ot tve der
l led
ess equest by M agi r e
ed
st at
Judge Si ont
m
on. I i t i entoft s pr
t s he nt
hi ocedur t m i m i t necessiy ofm otons.
e o ni ze he
t
i
8

The Par i shal notf Cham ber as soon as pr cabl i t r ve som e, oral,of
tes
l iy
s
acti e f hey esol
l
the i
ssues i di e.
n sput

QI
SCOVERY OBJECTI
ONS

l oreroe i t rs v dico er dipue t ep e aeh e noiid
n d t mcenl e ole s v y s ts,h adis r erby tfe
y

t t f l i r es appl t di
hat he olow ng ul
y o scover ob ectons bef e t s Cour .
y j i
or hi
t
1. Vaque. verv Br
O l oad,and Undul Bur
v
densom e

The pari shal notm ake nonspecii , boi pl eobectons.Suchobj i
tes
l
fc
d
l at j i
er
ectons
o notcompl wih LocalRul 26. g)3)A) whi pr des,' her anobecton i
y t
e 1( ( ( , ch ovi '
W e
j i s

ma t an itrog t yorsubjadt er fort a jdocu ntrque tu erF erl
de o y ne r aor
- h eo o n
me e s nd '' ed a
Rul ofCi lPr
e
vl ocedur 34,t ob ecton shal st ew lh specii t aI gr
e
he l i
l at t
fciy l ounds.

Obecinsta saeta adico er rju s i ' agu ,o erybr d, un y
j to h t tt h t s v y e e ts ' e v l oa or dul
v
bur
densom e' ar st
' e, andi al
ng one,m eanl ess,
ngl
Co
a wi b f ndmerte sb t s
nd l e ou
l
ils y hi

ur.A paryobj tng ont
t
t ec i
hese gr
oundsmustexpl nt specii and padl arway
ai he
fc
cul

i whi a r
n
ch equesti vague,overy br , or undul bur
s
l oad
y
densom e. See Fed.R . Ci P.
3
v.

3( ( ;Jose v.Hari Cor ,677 F. 985,992( Ci.1982)(' hemer st ement
b)4)
phs
rs p.
2d
3d r
'm
e at

by a pary t t i er ogat y w as d l br , bur
t hat he nt r
or
overy oad
densom e!oppr ve and
essi
ir evant i notadequat t voi asuccessf obj i t anI erogat y. O n t
rel
's
e o ce
ul ecton o nt r or
he

c tar,h q dyrssi di o er ' ts w s cfc l h . . c
i r y te a e itng sc v y mus ho pe iial ow . ea h
on
y

nt r
er ogat y l notr evantor how each queston i overy br , bur
or s
el
i s
l oad
densom e or

op e sie.'cotonomi l.Iaq t b iv st tterqu ti v gu t tp t
prs v ' Ii i
'
hed) f ary el e ha h e es s a e,ha ary
e

shalatemptt obt n cl ii i prort obj i ont sgr
l t
o ai arfcaton l o ectng hi ound.
2. Obi i Based Upon Scope
ectons

It e i anobecton based uponan undul br scope, such as tm e fam e or
f her s
j i
y oad
i r

teo ap cl ai , s ov ys l bepr i dast t os matr wihi t s oje
g jr hi oc ton dic er houd
h
ovde o h e tes t n he c
atI notdi ed. Fore
s
sput
xam pl i di
e, f scover i soughtnatonw i f a t
ys
i
de or en
an ters ondig p ryobe t ont gr dst atonl a fi yearperod Imarptl
d h e p n at jcs he oun h
y t erod,
e
y vei l ied o
-

actvii i t St t ofFl i i appr i t , t r
i tes n he a e
orda s
opra e he espondi par y shal pr de
ng
t
l ovi
r
esponsi di
ve scover f lng w ihi t fvey ali
t n he i yearperod as t t St e ofFl i .
i
o he at
orda
3. lr evantand NotReasonabl Cal at t Lead t Adm i bl
r el
v cul ed o
o
ssi e
Evi
dence

Anobj i t adi
ecton hat scover r
y equesti ir e and notr
s relvant
easonabl cal at
y cul ed

t I t adm i bl e dence m usti ude a specii expl i descrbi w hy t
o ead o
ssi e vi
ncl
fc
anat on
i ng
he
r
equestI s r evance and w hy t i or aton soughtw ilnot r
ack el
he nf m i
l
easonabl I t
y ead o
adm i bl evi
ssi e dence. The padi ar r i
es e em nded t t Feder Rul alow f br
hat he
al es l or oad

ds ov q t tdo sn n dt bea s i ea ti .Se F d. Ci.P. 6 b()
ic e ha e ot ee o dmisbl t ral e e R. v 2 ( )1;

Oppenhel erFund,I ,v.Sander , 437 U. 340,
m
nc.
s
S.
351- (
52 1978) seeal S. Fl L.
;
so D. a. R.

26.( ( ( .
1g)3)A)

4. For ul c Obi i Folowed bv an Answer
m ai
ectons l

The padi shalnotr t a f m ul cobectonf l
es
l ecie or ai j i olowed byananswert t
o he
r
equest l hasbecomecommon pr tcef a Paryt obectont basi ofanyoft
.t
aci or
t o j
he
s
he

above r
easons,and t st e t '
hen at hat '
noG ihst
t andi t abovej' t Pary w ilr
ng he
' he
t l espond t
o

t di
he scover r
y equest subj t orwihoutwai ng suchobj i . Such an obecton
, ect o
t
vi
ecton
j i

a an we prs v sn t n a sev sonyt wa t t tmean rsoure ofb h
nd s r e ere o hig nd re l o se he i
d e c s ot

t Padi and t Cour . Fur her such pr l I
he
es
he
t
t ,
actce eaves t r
he equestng Pary unceA i
i
t
n
as t w het t queston has act l been f l answ er orw het onl a podi of
o
her he
i
ual
y
uly
ed
her y
on
t queston has been answ er See Ci lDi
he
i
ed.
vi scover St
y andar , 2004 A. A.Sec.Li.
ds
B.
t

18;seeal S. Fl L. 26. g)3)A)
so D. a. R. 1( ( ( .

6. Obi i Based upon Prvieqe
ectons
il
ng t ney- i
Gener i obectonsassedi at or clent prviege orwor pr
alzed j i
il
k oduct
w ih t I
t he ocalr es. LocalRul 26. g)3)B)r r t
ul
docrn as dono c mql
tie lo
to y
e 1( ( ( equies hat
obec i ba e up prvlgei nt t s cic natur oft prviege bei
j tons s d on ll de i he pe f
e
l
i
e
he i l
ng
assered,aswelas,i erala,t na ur andsubj m aterofthe com m uni i at
t
l nt i he t e
ect t
caton

i
ssue and t senderand r veroft com m uni i and t rr atonshi t each
he
ecei
he
caton
hei el i
p o

ot .Thepadi ar i r ed t r ew LocalRul 26.( ( ( car ulyand t
her
es e nstuct o evi
e 1g)3)B) ef l
o

rfanfo obeci ssu a ' j ton Thi i or toni qr e tdb
eri rm j ton ch s:' eci . s nf ma i s otce y
Ob

at ne clentand/ wor pr
tor y/ i
or k oductprviege. l agener obecton ofprviegei made
il ' f
'
al j l
il s
wihoutatachi a pr
t
t ng operprviegeI t obectonofprviegemay be deemed
i l og, he j i
il
w ai
ved.

11