Checa Curi v. Pershing LLC

Filing 33

ORDER denying Motion to Compel. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 4/2/2014. (bnt)

UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI C OU RT FO R TH E
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRJ OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i m iD i s on
a
vi i

Cas Num be 1 22597- V- ORENO
e
r: 3CI M
J
OSE ANTONI CHECA CURI
O
,
Pl i if
a ntf ,
VS.

PERSHI LLC.
NG
,
D e e nt
f nda .

O R DER DEN Y I G PLA I TI S M O T I N TO C O M PE L TH E PRO DU C TI N O F
N
N FF'
O
O
DO CUM ENTS FROM DEFENDANT
THI CAU SE ca e be or t Cour upon Pl i t f sM o i t Com pelt Pr
S
m
f e he
t
a n if
ton o
he oduc i of
ton

Doc nt fom Dee ntPe s ngLLC ( E. 27) t e onM ar h 28. 4.
ume s r
fnda rhi
D. No. ,ild
c
201
THE COURT ha c i e t moton a t pe tne pori oft r cor a bei
s onsder d he i nd he ri nt tons he e d, nd ng
ot r s f l a s i t pr m ie ,i i
he wie uly dvied n he e s s t s
ADJUDGED t tf g ca es
ha or ood us hown,t moton i DENI f f l et c or t
he
i s
ED or aiur o onf m o

Lo a Rue 7.()3 a d7 1c( )
c l ls 1a () n .()2 .
Rul 7.()3)diecs:
e 1a( r t

( ) ehl g Cof r n e Re ie o u s lPro t fl ga ymoin i acv l a e
3 Pr - i n e e c s qur d fco n e. i r o ii n to n ii c s ,
n
n
e c pt mo infrij n t rle, o j d me t nt ep e dig ,o s mmayj d me t
x e a to o nu ci eif f ru g n o h la n s f r u r u g n,
ve
t dimisort per i mai e nc ofa cas a ton, o dimi sf f l et sa eacli
o s s
o m t ntna e
l s c i t s s or aiur o tt
am
upon whi h r i c be gr nt d,or t i unt rl di m i s an ac i c
c elef an
a e
o nvol a iy s s
ton, ouns l f t
e or he

mo n s al o e ( rlyo i m iig , rma era o beef r t c n e (r l o i
va t h l c nfr o al r n tn ) o k e s na l fo to o fr o al r n
y
m ii ,wih alpa te ornon- riswho ma beafe t by t rle s
tng) t l ris
pa te
y
f ced he eif oughti t
n he
m oton i ag f ih e f to r s vebya ee tt is st ber s i t moton..
i n ood a t for t e ol
gr men he s ue o aied n he i ..
A tt e oft m oton,
he nd he
i and above t s gnat e bl
he i ur ock,c
ouns lf t m o ng part
e or he vi
y

s lce tf et :( t c elf t movanthasc er e wih aI parisor
hal riy iher A) hat ouns or he
onf r d t l te
non- i sw ho m ay beaf e t by t r i s ughti t m ot on i a good f t e f
parte
f c ed
he elef o
n he
i n
aih f ort

t r s vet is sr s d i t moton and hasbe unabl t do s or( t
o e ol he s ue aie n he i
en
e o o; B) hat
couns lf t m o
e or he vant has m ade r onabl e f s t c erw ih aI par i s or noneas
e f ort o onf
t I te
partesw ho m ay be af ect by t relefsoughti t m oti w hi ef s s lbe
i
f ed
he i
n he
on, ch fort hal
i ntf e w ih s i i iy i t s at e ,buthas bee unabl t do s
de i i d t pec f c t n he t em nt
n
eo
o.

M orove , a Rul 7.( ( advie
e r Loc l e 1c)2) s s:

( )Le gt. e pro pe miso o t Co t n ih ramo i n a d is
2 n h Abs nt ir r si n f he ur , et e
to n t
i
ncor at d m e or
por e
m andum of l w nor t oppos ng m em or
a
he
i
andum ofI w s l
a hal

e e t y( page .
xc ed went 20) s
TheCour detr i t Pl ntf' c ns f ie t r pr e a t end oft M oton,
t e m nes hat ai ifs ou el a ld o e es nt t he
he
i
a
bovet sg ur bl k,t tcouns a tmptd t c e wih a lpari orm a r s bl
he i nat e oc ha
el te e o onf r t 1 tes
de ea ona e

e f t t do s M o eove ,
fors o
o. r r couns c e ry vi a e t pagelm ia i ass tf rh by t Lo l
el l a l olt s he
i t ton, e o t
he ca
Rul ,by s bm itng a2lpa moton a i om or t d m e andum ofl w.Ac or ngl t s
es
u ti
- ge i nd nc
ae
mor
a
c di y, hi
M oton i D ENI .
i s
ED

D N A DO D R DiCabraMi i ori thi 22/ ofApri,2014.
O E N R E E n hm e t a Fl da, s w y
s m
da
l
,

:.. 4
)ç
-+

sl'
J

.
'
.'

.

.
.

z'
ae
e'

;

'

X
.

Z
EDEM CO A.M ORENO
U N J D STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
.
.
.

Copi pr dedt
es ovi o:
COUNSEL OF RECORD

-

2-