Bacerra v. Aldridge Connors, LLP

Filing 11

ORDER Denying Defendant's Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 12/11/2013. (vds)

UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRJ CO U RT FOR TH E
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI OF FLORI A
CT
D
M i m iD i s on
a
vii
Cas N um be 13e
r: 23763- I - O REN O
C V M
GLO RI BA CERR A,
A

Pl ntf,
ai if

A LD RJ GE CON N O RS,LLP,
D

De e n .
f nda t
/

ORDER DENYI DEFENDANT' M OTI TO DI I PLAI FF'
NG
S
ON
SM SS
NTI S
C O M PLA I
NT
TH I CA U SE c m e be or t Cour upon Def nda , l i Connor ,
S
a
f e he
t
e nt A dr dge
s LLP' M oton t
S
i o

Dimis Pli ifs Compli a Su ri M e a
s s antf
ant nd ppo tng morndum of La ( E.No.5 ,fld on
w D.
) ie
Nove be 11.201 THE COURT ha co i r d t m oton a t peri ntpori nsoft
m r
3.
s nsde e he
i nd he tne
to
he
r cor a beng ot nvief l advie i t pr m ie ,i i
e d, nd i
he s uly
s d n he e s s t s
A DJUD G ED t tt m oton i DEN I .
ha he
i s
ED
1.

BA C K G R O U ND

Thsi a a to i whc Pli ifalg sDe e d n vo ae Se to 1 9 ()1 )o te
i s n ci n n ih ant le e fn a t iltd ci n 6 2 e( 0 f h
f
F i De t le to P a tc sAc,1 U.. j 1 9 - 6 2 CTDCPA'
ar b Colcin r cie t 5 SC. j 6 2 1 9 p
).
Thecompli al ge t tDe e nts htt cole tade fom Pli ifarsng outof
a nt le s ha f nda oug o l c
bt r
antf ii
a pr i s y not s ur d by a m or ga on Pl i i f s pr m a y r s denc A c di t t
om s or
e ec e
t ge
a ntf ' i r e i e. cor ng o he

c
ompl i ,De e ntwashied by W elsFa go Ba t c lcton t a l ed de a s r d a
ant f nda
r
l r
nk o ole
he leg
bt nd e ve
s
ummons a compl nt on Pl i if i f t a e t e . Pli if a s c e t t t
nd
ai
antf n urher nc her of
a ntf lo ont nds ha he

frco u ec mpli s u h ap tnil eiin yj d me t Ale e l atc e t tec mp an
o e ls r o ant o g t oe t d fce c u g n . lg dy ta h d o h o lit
a

wa aNoi Re r unde t Fai Deb Cole tonPrci sAc (t Noie'.
s tce quied
r he r t lci a tce t ihe tc ')
t
Pl i if a l ge t N otc cont ne f l e,de e i a m i l a ng r pr e a i i
a ntf le s he
ie
ai d a s
c ptve, nd s e di e es nt tons n

co to wih t c lci ofa d i vi ai ofs cton 1 e)1 oft FDCPA.
nnecin t he ole ton
ebt n olton
e i 692( ( 0) he
Spe fc l Pl ntf algest tt Notc ( )misaedt a ia elgalsa r wihrgad
ciialy, ai if le ha he ie 1 stt he pplc bl e tndad t e r
t t pr umpton ofvai t ofade bya ngawrtngr quie nta ( fley saest
o he es i
ldiy
bt ddi
ii e rme nd 2) asl tt he
a ountoft debti sa e i t f e os e c pl nt
m
he
s t t d n he or cl ur om ai .
D e e nt sm oved t di m i st com pl nt a gui t t hePl i if sc pl i s ul
f nda ha
o s s he
ai , r ng ha t
a ntf om a nt ho d

b ds se a amatrof a b c u e()t ePli tf ha n tb e t eo j c o d b -olcin
e imis d s te 1w e a s 1 h anif s o e n h b e t f e tc le to
aci t frpur esoft FDCPA a Defnda wasno a tngasade c lco ,2)heFDCPA
tviy o pos
he
nd e nt
t ci
bt ole tr ( t
notc atc dt t morga f ecos eco ai wasnota i tal
ie ta he o he t ge or l ur mpl nt
n nii communiai a ( t
c ton, nd 3) he
N otce w a no de p i t t l s s s i t cons e .
i
s t ce tve o he ea t ophitca ed
um r
I1.

STAN DA R D

(fo s vi a m oto t di m i s pl i if m us do m or t
i
- ur ve
i n o s s , a ntf s
t
e han m e el s a e l ga
r y tt e l

c usons'i ta pl i if m us k l es es c fcf t lba i f rt ec usonso a
oncl i ,'nse d antfs ts eg om pe ii acua ss o hos oncl i rf ce
al

dimisloft i cams'Jac v Bel h Teec
s sa her li .' kwn . lsout l omm.372F. 1 1 ( 1hCi.
,
3d 250, 263 1 t r 2004)
.
W he r lng o amoton t dimis ac tmus vi w t c
n ui n
i o s s , our
t e he ompl i i t lg mos f vor bl t
ant n he i ht t a a e o
t pl ntf a a ce t pl i ifsw e lpl ade f c sast ue.SeeSt Jos ph' H os , nc v Hos
he ai i f nd c pt he a ntf
l- e d a t r
. e s p. l . . p.

Cop.o , 9 F.d 9 , 5 ( 1h Ci.1 8 ) i tn t h we e , o sn ta pl t lg l
r fAm. 7 5 2 48 9 3 1 t r 9 6 .Ths e e, o v r d e o p y o e a
c ncu in . e h rj v l b l5 6U. 6 2 6 8( 0 9 . o e v rtwl ielg l o cuso
o lso s Se As c ot .q a , 5 S. 6 , 7 2 0 ) M ro e ,d h l e a c n l ins
g
c n pr de t fam e or of a c pl i ,t y m us be s
a ovi he r w k
om a nt he
t uppor ed by f c ua a l ga i . 1 a
t
a t l le tons ' d. t
'

67 Thos 'fa t l l tonsmus bee
9.
e ' jcua alegai
l
t nought r s arg t rle a t s ul i lve
o aie ihto eif bove he pec atve e l
on t as umptont ta1 oft co pl ntsa lga i a etue. l At.Cor v Twombl 550
he s
i ha 1 he m ai ' le tons r r ' l l p. .
'Be
y,
-

2-

U..5 4,5 5 ( 0 7 . I s r,t e c mp an mu tno meey alg a mic n u t b tmu t
S 4 4 2 0 ) n ho t h o lit s t r l le e
s o d c, u s
de ons r t t tt pl a i e il d t r le . See I ,556 U . a 663.
m t a e ha he e der s ntte o e i f
qbal
S. t
1
11.

D ISC U SSIO N

Til 1 U. C.j169 e)1 pr bis'gl us ofa flerpr e ai o de e i
te 5 S.
2( ( 0) ohi t tthe e ny as e es ntton r c ptve
m e nst c l c ora t m ptt c l c an de ort obt n i o ton conc r ng a c um e . 15
a o ole t te
o ole t y bt o ai nf nna i
e ni
ons r '
'

U.. jl 9 ()1 ) Tosaeacam u d rt prviin apanif s alg ( )gh wa t e
SC. 6 2 e (0 . tt li n e he o so , litf mu t l e 1 l e s h
e
o j c o c l ci na t t a iigfo c n u rd b, 2 d fn a t sad b c le t r sd fn d
b e t f ol to ci y rsn r m o s me e t( ) e e d n i e t o lco a e ie
e
vi
by t FDCPA,a ()dee t hase ag i a a oromisonpr bie byt FDCPA.
he
nd 3 fndans
ng ed n n ct
si ohi td he
John t vAl igeConnor,LL#, 1 61 7- V, 3W L60860 *2( D. a. 20,
sone . drd
s
No. 3- 75 C1 201
49, S. Fl Nov.
201 )
3.
Thi co pl nta motont dimisa ene ry i tca t t ei Johnsonev. drd
s m ai nd
i o s s r a l den i l o hos n
t
Al ige
Conno s LLP,c r ty pe ng be or J
r,
uren l ndi
f e udge Cohn i t s Diti t J
n hi src . udge Cohn de ed t
ni he

deenda ' moi t dimis( c defnda ha
f nts ton o s s whih e nt ppenst bet smeast Dee nti t s
o he a
he fnda n hi
c s ) Se Jo t ,201 W L 608
a e . e hnsone 3
6049. Thi Cour a e wih t ras ngpr
s
t gres t he e oni opounde b
d y
J
udge Co
hn.

De e ntar ue t tPl ntf c nno sa eaFDCPA c am bec us am o t gef r c os e
f nda g s ha ai if a t tt
li
a e
rga o e l ur
a tondoe not
ci
s cons iut de colec i How e r asJ
tt e bt l ton.
ve , udgeCohnpoi e out t El ve h Cicui
nt d , he e nt r t

ha r c ntyhe dt tacommunia i r a e t de coledi doe notbe
s e e l l ha
c ton elt d o bt l on s
comeum e aedt debt
lt o
smpl be us i a s r a e t t e or e e ofa s c iy i e es. SeeJohn t
i y ca e t lo elt s o he nf c m nt
e urt nt r t
s one,201 W L
3

6086049a *2- (ii Re s v Eli,Pai e ,Rate r et Adams LLP,678F.3d 1 l 1 8
t *3 ctng e e . ls ntr tr e t
,
21 , 21

( 1hCi. 2).Acc di y, ai if ss fcintyalge t t e nt e edi de
1 t r201 ) or ngl Pl ntfha ufi e l le d ha Defnda was ngag n bt
c l c i a tviy.
ole ton c i t
-

3-

D e e ntf rhera guest tPl i i fc nnots a e a c a m be us t N otc wasnota
f nda u t r
ha a nt f a
tt li
ca e he i e
n
i ta com m uni a i f
nii l
c ton orpur e oft FD CPA .How e r a wast c s i
pos s he
ve , s
he a e nloh t ne Pl i if
ns o , a ntf

alg savolto o 1 U. C. 1 9 ()l ) n t1 U.. j 1 9 g ()wh c d aswi i t l
l e i ain f 5 S. j 6 2 e( 0 , o 5 SC. 6 2()a , ih e l t nia
e
h i

c mmu iain . S eJ h so e 2 3 W L 6 8 0 9 a #
o n c to s e o n tn , 01
0 6 4 t 3.Addto al,J g Co nrjce
iin ly ud e h ee td
Def n ' agume t tt e mpto pr vi dbyj 1 g)d)woul e e t camsunde
enda ts r nt ha he xe in o de
692( (
d xtnd o li
r
j1 e a wel I a *3- Thi Cou t gres Theefr Dee tsagume t tt Notc
692() s l. d t *4. s r a e . r oe, fndan ' r
ntha he ie
i e m ptf is
s xe
a l.

Fi ly, e ntrgue ha t
na l Def nda
st t heNotc i notde e i t hel t ophitc t dc ume .
ie s
c ptve ot eas s sia e ons r

Ho ve ,hi Co ta e wihJ Cohnt tPl ntf salgai t t( )t Notcefley
we r t s ur gres t udge
ha ai if le tons ha 1 he i asl
camst amountoft deb wassaedi t f ecos ec anta ( t Notcei ore ty
li he
he t
tt n he or l ur ompli nd 2) he i nc rcl
i ist tt r i awrtng r r ntu rj 1 g ()3)c lci y etbls potnta
mple ha hee s ii equieme nde 692()a( ole tvel sa ih e il
vi ai ns of t FDCPA whi h c d be de e i t t las s si a e cons e .Se
ol to
he
c oul
c ptve o he e t ophitc t d
um r e
Johnsone 201 W L 60860 a *
t , 3
49 t 4.
A c or ngl D e e nt s M oton t D i m i si DEN I .
c di y, f nda '
i o s s s
ED
D ON E AN D ORD ERED i Cha be s a M i m i Fl i t s
n
m r t a , orda, hi

da ofD e e be ,201
y
cm r
3.

FED
CO . O REN O
UNI
TE TATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
*

.,
.

.
.'

Copi pr de t
es ovi d o:
Cou e ofRec d
ns l
or

4-

-