Gandhi et al v. Carnival Corporation
Filing
15
Order Granting Defendant's Motion to Strike and Motion to Dismiss Counts II, III, and IV of Complaint. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 3/14/2014. (bnt)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M im iDi son
a
vi i
Ca eNum ber 13s
: 24509- V- ORENO
Cl M
PM CHIGANDHIand ABI
SHEK GANDHI as
,
Pa e a Naur l Gua di ns of AM W A
r nt nd
t a
r a
GANDHI a m i ,a PRACHIGANDHIa
,
nor nd
nd
ABHI
SHEK GANDHI l vi l
, ndi dualy,
Pl i if ,
a ntf s
VS.
CA RN I A L CO R PO RA TION , d/ a
V
b/
CARN I
VAL CRUI LI
SE NES,m C.
,
De e nt
f nda .
/
O R DER G R AN TI G DEFEND AN T ' M O TI N T O STR I E and M O TI N TO
N
S
O
K
O
D I I C O U N TS l .1 1 and I ofPLA I TI S C O M PLA I T
SM SS
I 1.
V
N FF'
N
THI CAUSE c m e be o e t Coul upon De e nts M o i n t Sti Alegai i
S
a
f r he
'
t
f nda '
to o rke l tons n
Count l of Pl i if ' Compli a M oton t Di mi s Count 1, 11 a I of Pl ntfs
antfs
ant nd
i o s s
s 1 1, nd V
ai if '
Compli ( E. 7 ,ie onJanuar 9. 4. sc e, c i acaebr hti a miat
ant D. No. ) fld
v 201 Thi as whih s s oug n d r ly,
c n e sp ro a ij re alg dys san db Plitfsd rngt ec u s o ac us o o eo
o c m es n lnu is le e l u ti e y an if u i h o re f r ie n n f
Ca i Cor ai sc u s ve s s De e
m val por ton' r i e s el. f ndant e kst srkepa t Count oft Compl nt nd
s e o ti r of
I he
ai a
dim i s t Com pl i ' Count l, II a I . Fo t f l ng r a ons t Cour gr nt
s s he
a nt s
s 1 I nd V
r he olowi e s , he
t a s
De e
f ndan ' M o i t Dim is Count 1,1la I M or ove , t Cour gr nt Def nda '
ts ton o s s
s I I nd V.
e r he
t a s
e nt s
M oto t Sti t r s is l t rr e e esi CountlofPli if 'Com pl nt alhough t
i n o rke he e p a oquiu ef r nc n
antfs
ai , t
he
Cour r e ve isdec sononwhehe ar si s l t i t ci wil a opraelt ri t s
t es r s t ii
t r e p a oquiur nsnlton l be ppr i t a e n hi
Cas
e.
Fa ualBa kc ound
ct
c r
Pli if Pr c a Abhihe Ga
antfs a hi nd
s k ndhia lge t tt rda e ,Pl ntf Ar na Ga hi
le ha hei ught r ai if ai
nd ,
wa ij rdwh nh ram c u h i a ee ao d o o av se o eae b Dee d n Can v l
s n u e e e r a g t n n lv t r o r n e s l p r td y fn a t r i a
Co or i du i avoy a s a. or ngt t Compl i , ai wassa ngi ane e t r
m aton rng
age t e Acc di o he
ant Ar na
t ndi n l va o
whenhe l ta m wasdr wn i o t s ei o whih o sde oft eeva o doo swa si i
r ef r
a nt he pac nt
c ne i
he l t r r s ld ng.
The elvat door a lge y ate e t c os and ope wih he a m e r ppe untla he
e or
s le dl tmpt d o l e
n t r r nta d i not r
p s nge us d a c r1 g t as i ti r l s ng t ar .
as e r e
hai e o s s n e ea i he m
Pl ntfsPr hiGa hi ndAbhihekGa
ai if ac
nd a
s
ndhi e t tAr i s t nedadee l c r ton
plad ha ana usai
p a eai
t he lf ebow,a s ve i ofoneofhert
o r et l
e rng
endons a a facur l a ton,Pli tf Abhihe
, nd r t e. n ddii
a n if
s k
Ga
ndhicai s t ha wines e Ara nas or a i e iet a aleg t t he ha s f r d
l m o ve t s d ii ' de l n ntr y nd l es ha
s ufe e
e oi
m tonaldi t e s as a r s t l t i Com pl i ,Pl i i f pl a t f l w i Count ag ns
sr s
e ul. n he r
a nt a ntf s e d he olo ng
s ai t
Dee d n Canv l p oain:l ane lg nc cam f r a g so t emio c idAria (1
fn a t r ia Co rto () gie e li o d ma e f h n r hl an , 1)
'
aca m f rda a purua t t ne i nti lc i ofe o i ldites ofAbhihe Ga hi
li o m ges s nt o he glge nfiton m tona sr s
s k nd ;
(1)adama scam f me c e
11
ge li or dial xpens i ure b Prc Ga a Abhihe Gan ;a
es nc rd y a hi ndhi nd
s k dhi nd
(V) a g scam r ltn t t ls o fl l o s ri m o Prc i nd i n Ab ih kGa d i
l ad ma e li eaig o he o s f ii c n o t f a h Ga h a d h s e n h .
a
u
Def nda Ca ni lCom or tonsr s
e nt r va
a i e ponde b flngisM oton t Sti Ale tonsofPli if
d y ii t
i o rke l ga i
a ntfs'
Compli a t Dimi sCou s1,1, nd I ofPl i if Compli , c t Cou t ddr s e
ant nd o s s
nt 1 11 a V
antfs'
antwhi h he r a e s s
nOW .
11
1.
Leaa St nda d
l a r
Th Co r h sj rs ito i t sa to p ru n t 28U. C.j 1 3 ( 0 6 . a to
e u t a u idc in n hi cin u s a t o
S.
3 3 2 0 ) An ci n
iv l igp ro a ij re s san da o r as pwhl a s ai ac s i a miat .d j1 3 ( )
n o vn es n lnu is u ti e b a d hi ie t e s a e n d rly 1 . 3 3 1 .
,
s aloCar v Cr s Li s I .v Shut 499U. 585, (1 )Ar haws iv. ot, 0
ee s
nial uie ne , nc . e,
S. 590 991. c k Hani i35
,
U. 5 2, 3 -3 ( 9 6 .t s l-ete ta g n rl tmelw a pl st a to sa iigfo
S. 3 5 2 3 1 5 )l i wels tld h t e ea mmii a p i o cin rsn r m
e
alg dtrsi o te a o r as i sii i n via l wae s'Kef , 6 F.da 1 21 s e
l e o t ' mmitd b ad hp al n a g b e tr. ee 8 7 2 t 3 ; e
e
c
ng
'
alo Be d v Nonvgi Carbbe Li s 900 F. 71( h Ci.1 ;Po drTal ,l .v
s ar .
e an i an ne ,
2d 6t r 990) pe
bot nc .
Hawn, 4 U. 4 6( 9 3 . c r igy t p ee t cini c nr le b g n rl rtmelw.
3 6 S. 0 1 5 )Ac o dn l,he r s n a to s o to ld y e ea maii a
S eEx c tv J t ito , n . . t o e ea d 40 U. 2 9 2 3( 9 2 ; r mo t n . .
e e uie e Ava in I c v Ci fclv l n , 9 S. 4 , 5 1 7 ) Fo e s I s Co
y
v Rih r s n, 7U. 6 8, 7 ( 9 2 .nt ea s n eo aweld fn db d o ma i me1w
. c a d o 45 S. 6 6 4 1 8 ) l h b e c f l- eie o y f rt a
i
r a i t a pa tc a cai ,g r lma ii e1 w i s eme e by eihersa e1w org ner l
eltng o
ri ul r l m ene a rtm a s uppl nt d
t tt a
e a
c
omm on 1w prnci es For
a i pl . emos I .Co. 457 U . a 674.
t ns
,
S. t
Unde Fe rlRul ofCi lPr dur 8()2) apladi mus c ai ats ta pl n
r dea e
vi oce e a( , e ng t ont n shor nd ai
sae e oft cai s
t tm nt he l m howi t tt pl de i e ild t r le . Dim is lf f iur t sae
ng ha he ea r s ntte o ei f' s s a or a l e o t t
'
acai i wara t twhe i a ar t tt pl n ifhasltl orno c nceofs e s ie,whe
l m s r n ed s n t ppe s ha he aitf
ite
ha
ucc s , ..
n
t c
he ompli on is f c make cla l bas l s a lga i orr le on l alt ore t ta e
ant
t ae
s e ry ees le tons
ei s
eg he i s ha r
ids u a l rte s'Wr l ov Ma t Ctt l le # k 4 F d Ap x5 5 5 6( 1h r2 0 )
n ip tbyme i s . u nn . ri p nys r . 3 3 e . p' 3 , 3 1 tCi. 0 9 4
l '
n l
/
s eas As c o v I b l 1 9S. . 9 7, 9 -5 ( 0 9 ( c mplitmu tc n an s fi in
e lo h rft . q a , 2 Ct 1 3 1 49 0 2 0 ) A o an s o ti u fce t
f c ua m a tr ac e e a tue,t d tt acli t r le t ti pl i e on isf ce'n or rt
a t l te , c pt d s r o s ae am o e if ha s ausbl
s
t a 'i de o
s r ie a mo in t d s s ..Fo p r s so a mo i n t d s s ,te Co r mus v e te
u vv
to o imis) r u po e f
to o imis h u t t iw h
al gai oft Com pli i t lg m os f vor bl t Pl ntf,c i rt a lga i oft
le tons he
a nt n he i ht t a a e o ai if onsde he le tons he
Co pli a tu a a e a 1 ea o bl i e e est r r m . Sc erv Rhode , 6U.
m a nt s r e, nd cc pt l r s na e nf r nc he efo See heu .
s 41 S.
232,236( 97 .
1 4)
-
3-
Leg lAna ys s
a
l i
M oto t Sti Pli if 'Re e e e t t DocrneofRe I a Loquiu
i n o rke antfs f r nc s o he ti
s ns
tm
Pl ntfs cam f ne i ncei Count1pladst a iato oft docrneofr sf
ai if' li or glge n
e he pplc in he ti
e pm
l t r I t sM oton,De e
oquiu . n hi
i
f ndan m ovest srke t as e ton ofr s is l t r wihi t
t
o ti he s ri
e p a oquiu t n he
Cou ,a g ng t ti i nota c us ofa to De e nt i co r c .t-he Su e e Cou thas
nt r ui ha t s
a e
c i n. f nda s r e t sl
pr m
r
de l a1w o r s,J l tri ad r t t tpemist tiroff tt drw i e e e o
veoped a f e > w oquiu n mialy ha r t he re ac o a nfrnc s f
ne l e c fo u e p an dcr u tn e .fxleo a kn b a kn v Fa r llie,nc, 0
gi n e rm n x lie ic msa c s' / / fL r is yL r is . r elv sI .8 6
g
'
n
F. 51 51 ( h Ci.986)( tngJohns v.Unie St e 333 U. 46,68,68 S. .391 92
2d 0, 2 4t r1
cii
on
td ats,
S.
Ct ,
L. 468( 9 ) Puta he wa i a rly, e is l t i r e nti deemi ngwhih
Ed. 1 48 . not r y,n dmiat r sp a oquiur s elva n tr ni
c
c s so u x lie cru tn e s o l g t t ej r I a 51 Toiv k ted crn o r s
a e f ne pan d ic msa c s h ud o o h uy.d t 2. n o e h o tie f e
i al t ,t pli ife tbls $û1 t eve i ofatpewhihor naiydoesnotha
ps oquiur he antf sa ihes 1( ) he nt s
y
c di rl
ppen
i t ea s n eo s me n 'n gie c ;()t ei snz n ai c usngt eij r wa , th t
n h b e c f o o es e l n e 2 h n t me tlt a i h nu y s a te i
g
y
me
oft a i t wihi t e l i conr oft defnda ;(ndq( t a ci ntwa no duet
he ccden, t n he xcusve tol he e nt a 3) he c de s t o
a yv l naya t no c nrb to o tep r o t epli if' I a 51 ( oigOle v Sats
n o u tr ci r o tiu in n h a t f h antf ' d t 3 qu t
o
'
n sn . t e
Li ,378F. 21 220( h Ci.1 .
ne
2d 7, 9t r 967)
Re IJ l tri t notaspaaec eofa ton;at r ii a e de ir docrne
s J oquiu s hus
e rt aus
ci r he ,t s n vi ntay ti
t tpe m ist ti roff tt i e neglgenc fom cic sa ile denc Pu s tt Fe r
ha r t he re
ac o nf r
i er
r um t nta vi e. r uan o de al
Rueo CiiPr c d r 1 4 t i Co r ma srk fo Pli tf pla igiv c to o r si a
l f vl o e u e 2 9,hs u t y tie r m anifs e dn n o ain f e ps
l q iu a i tra ma tr Fe . Ci . 1 9. epup eo amo int srk i loce n
o utr s mmaeil t . d R. v P. 24 Th r os f to o tie s i la
e
t
u t pl di ,sr mlne ltga i a a d unnec s a y f r i o i matra ma tr .'
p he ea ngs tea i ii ton, nd voi
e s r o ays nt m
e i l te s'
M cnene v Mo rLumb drHa dwar ,I ,244 F.Supp.2d 393,402 ( D.Pa.2002) For
l r y . ye
er
r e nc.
E.
.
e mpl i fobe i rv.Ceebrt Cr s s J e Alona dim is d t pl ntf scli f
xn e, n
gege
l i
y uie , udg t ga s s e he ai if am or
-
4-
S lge eBasd on Re I a Lo tf'ex ani t t docti ofr sf w I t wa
d i nc
Neg
e
s ps quiu , pli ng hat he rne e rJ oquiur s
i ppr itl i
na opraey nvoked a ac us ofaci 2011W L 3703329,* ( D.Fl.Aug.23,2011.
s a e
ton.
7 S. a
)
Si lry,Pli if heepl dr slJ l trwihi Count1 wheei t youghtt lmi t i
mial antfs r ea e / J oquiu t n
, r n he
o i t her
a l ga i ns i t Cou t t c e of a i of ne i nc A c di y,t Cour GR AN TS
le to n hat nt o he aus
cton
glge e. cor ngl he
t
De e nt 'M o i t Sti Pl ntfs Ref e est t DocrneofRe I a Loquiu i Count
f nda s ton o rke ai if ' er nc o he
ti
s ps
tr n
1 Howe r t Cou tr e v isde son ast whe he a r s i a I t r i tuci wilbe
.
ve , he
r es r es t cii
o
t r e ps oquiu nsr ton l
a oprat l t r i t sca e
ppr i e a e n hi s .
B.
CountI :N eg i ntI lc i ofEm otonalD it e s
I
lge nfi ton
i
sr s
Count1 ofPl i ifsCompl ntr quessda
1
antf
ai e t mage f De e ntsN e i entl lci of
s or f nda ' glg nfiton
Emotona Dites . r a et e pr domi nt e t whih a s s cl m sofneg i nti lc i of
i l sr s The e r hr e e
na t ss c s e s ai
lge ntiton
e i ldites a delmirco r f e i lda ge ( )t physca i c ts,( t
motona sr s nd i t e vey or motona ma s: 1 he i lmpa t et 2) he
z ofda rts, nd( t r ai b tndert tSe Cons . lCor v Gots l5l U.
one nge eta 3)he eltve ysa
es. e
olRai p. . thal, 2 S.
532, 49( 994)Thephy i li ctetrquiest tapli ifseki dama f
546. 1 .
sca mpa ts e r ha antf e ng
ges oremotona
i l
ij r s h v c n e o a e u l s sane ap y ia i a tn matr o sih ) r nu yd e
n uymu t a e o tmp rn o sy u ti d h sc lmp c ( o te h w lg to ij r u
t t def nt c
o he enda ' onduc . d.a 547. s c t s,t zoneofda rt t lm isr ove y f
s
t1 t
The e ond e t he
nge es, i t ec r or
e to a ij r t p an if wh s san ap y ia i a ta ars l o ad fn n ' n g ie t
moi n l n u y o litfs o u ti h sc l mp c s e ut f ee da ts e lg n
c
onduc o who a epl edi i e at rs ofphysc lhar byt tco
tr
r ac n mm di e ik
ia m
ha nduc . d a 5 5 The
t l t 47- 48.
t r lm ii t t t r l tve b t dert t e ua e a pl ntf r a i hi t a a i nt
hid i tng es, he e ai ysan
es, val t s
ai ifs eltons p o n ccde
vi tm ,hi pr m iy t an ac i nts e a w he he t pl ntf e re e s ck d t a
ci
s oxi t o
c de c ne, nd
t r he ai if xpe i nc d ho ue o
s ns y a c e por neo obs r a e oft ac de . d
e or nd ont m a us e v nc
he ci nt l
-
5-
TheElve t Cic thase i tya edt s condoft s t ss t z ofda rt s,
e n h r ui
xplcil dopt he e
he e e t ,he one
nge e t
aspa toff rlmaii lw. Cha r v Car valCor aton,693F.3 133 ( 1h Ci.
r edea rtme a See paro . ni
por i
d 3 1t r
201 (ttng,tfde a maii 1w ha a e .t tone ofda r ts ) The Cic ts
2) sai se r l rtme a d doptd..he z
nge' e f'.
rui'
a
dopto oft z ofda rt ti eo i t ntw ih isw i s ea a ce a e by c t s ti i
i n he one
nge es s ns s e
t t de pr d c pt nc
our s i tng n
a r ly a t i
dmiat nd he mpora e of f t rng unior iy i a r ly l w.See gene aly Smih v
tnc
ose i
f m t n dmiat a
r l
t
.
Car v Cor ,58 F. zd 13 1 ( D.Fl 2008) Tas nar v.Ke lrs Wat Tour,
nial p. 4 supp. 43, 353 S. a.
) si i y le' er s
f
L. , 0F. zd 1 8,1 ( D. a 2007) Purua tt azoneofda ra l i,e t i
C.48 supp. 31 320 S. Fl.
. s n o
nge nayss ours n
t eElv nhCic i l t e o eyfre to a ij r t tos plitfswh û u ti ap ysc l
h e e t r ut i rc v r o moi n ln u y o h e anif o ' san h ia
mi
s
i c a ar s t ade e
mpa t s e ulof f ndan ' ne i en c
ts glg t onduc , whoa epl c i i medit rs ofphysca
t or
r a ed n m
a e ik
i l
ha m byt tc
r
ha onduc .' t 584 F.
t'Smih,
supp. a 1
zd t 354.Ac or ngl t pr vai i t spr e ng,
c di y, o e l n hi oc edi
Pl ntf she em us c ai m or t n m e ew ine sofat a a i eve t s ûc entypl d ne i en
ai i f r
tlm
e ha
r t s
r um tc nt o uf i l ea glg t
i lc i ofe i ldites . e Cha r a 1
nfiton motona sr s Se
par o t 338.
Eve vi w i t ale tons of t Com pl i t i t lg m os f a e t Pl i if ,
n e ng he l ga i
he
a n n he i ht
t avor bl o a ntf s
Pl i if he eha notplad s tce f c st s ts yt zoneofdange t s . Pl ntf Abhihe
antfs r ve
e ufi int a t o a if he
r e t ai i f
s k
Ga hial ge o yt thewines e t alege i i nto t c i es p a t tasar ul o
nd le s nl ha
t s d he l d nc de n he nzs hi nd ha
es t f
hi die o e v tonsand hi a t m pt t he p hi da ht r hes f r e o i na dit es . H ehas
s r d bs r a i
s te s o l s ug e , uf e ed m t o l s r s
nota l ed t the e t rs t i d a phys c li pa ta a r ul ofCa i l sa l ged ne i nc or
leg ha
ihe us a ne
i a m c s es t
m va ' le
glge e
t the wasa t l pl c i i e ae rs ofphysca ha m by Ca i lsal ge ne i e .
ha
c ualy a ed n mm di t ik
i l r
m va ' le d glg nce
Thi Cour t r by dimi s Count1 oft Pli ifsCompl i .
s
t he e
s s es
1 he antf
ant
The Cour not t tPl i if a
t es ha antfs cknowldge t tt weghtofa t iy i t El ve h
e
ha he i
u hort n he e nt
Cic tdoesno r cog z a c a m f ne i en i lc i ofe o i
r ui
t e ni e l i or glg t nfi ton m tonaldit es . Aga ns t stdeof
sr s
i t hi i
a hort Pl i if haveur dt sCour t adopthet r oft t eeprma yt ssouti da
ut iy, antfs
ge hi
to
t hid he hr i r e t lne bove,
-
6-
t r ltvebysa rt s ,orus he e. antfs a gume sa eunpe s svea s t Cour he e
he e ai
t ndv e tf e r Pl i if ' r
nt r
r ua i nd o he
t r
r esco it l wiht sCic tspr c nt Thez ofda rt s ha be n c e ry e t bls
ul nssenty t hi r ui' e ede .
one
nge e t s e l a l sa ihed
f ru ei f d rlmaii c s s s ei a 1 3 - 8 a dwh l oh r u id cinsma f lw te
o s n e ea rtme a e , e d t 3 7 3 , n ie t e j rs ito
y ol h
o
r ltvebysa rt s f rneglge i lc i ofe oto ldite scli s a pton oft t s he e
ea i
t nde e t o
i nt ntiton m i na sr s am , do i
he e t r
i no c pai ewiht goal ofma ii el w.' hena yi m a ii lw , c t mus a r
s t om tbl t he
s
rtm a l
W
ppl ng rtme a ours t dhe e
t t prnc plsofha mony a unio miy. Sut v Car v Cor ,
o he i i e
r
nd f r t ' er .
'
nial p.2007W L 46621 *3( D.
44, S.
Fl M a 1 2007) s aloDoev. lbrt Cr s ,I .3 F. 8 , ( t Ci.
a. y 4,
;ee s
Cee i uies nc, 94 3d 91 902 11h r2004)(t
y
she
t
p r o eb hndt ee ecs o ti Co r' a miat j rs ito i t p o ie f rteu fnn
u p s e i h x r ie f h s u ts d r l u id ci n s o r vd o h nio
y
a iai ofge r lma ii 1 '.Cic tc t a r st c r us t zoneofda rt t
pplc ton
ne a rtme aw') rui ours cos he ounty e he
nge es
i a ia i ofge r lm a ii lw,a i i nott sCour' plcet a tm ptt at rm a ii
n pplc ton
ne a rtme a nd t s
hi
ts a o te
o le rtme
lw a dds p isu io mi S e eg.Ba k rv He c lsO fho e I .71 F.d20 , 2 ( t
a n inlt t n fr t e , . , r e . r u e fj r , nc, 3 3 8 2 4 5h
y.
Ci. 3)(t rmaii l abysa rc nnotrc meeyf winesi ham t a he
r201 d
unde rtme aw, tnde a
e over rl or t sng r o not r
w he e t b t nde s f r d no ha m ortu'a .' .
r he ys a r uf e e
r
let'
l
Co 11 M edialExpe es
unt 1:
c
ns
Count1Ioft Compli ta lge ve y smpl t tasaçdiec a pr m a er s toft
I he
a n le s r i y ha
i r t nd oxi t e ul he
ne i nc oft Def nt . Pr c Ga
glge e he enda .. a hi ndhia Abihe Ga
nd
s k ndhii ure ce t n outofpoc t
nc r d rai
ke
expe esf t hos t i ton a m edi lc r a tea m entoft rc l , A r i G a ,a
ns or he pialza i nd
ca a e nd r t
hei hid a na ndhi nd
w il i l i trs e ns i t f ur .'Howe r Pli if ' ai i Count (s i ne '
l lke y nc t uch xpe es n he ut e '
ve , antfs cl m n
It
Neglge e'
)
s e t r ove Ge nss ofhos t i to gndlme c la nuri c r a te t ntof
e ks o ec r dxpe e
pialzain, a
dia nd sng a e nd rame
da ht rA r i '
ug e a na.
'
Pli if ca
antf s nnotr ove t s m e alege da a m uli e tm e
ec r he a
l d m ges
tpl i
s Pli if de a
. antfs m nd
r i b s m e ofAr i spas medial
em ur e nt
ana' t
c expe e aswelasf t emedi le ns i Coun 1 a
ns s
l u ur
ca xpe es n
t4s
ar ul, hi Cour GRANTS De e n ' M oton t DimisCountlId t isduplc t nalr
es t t s
t
f nda ts
i o s s
1 ue o t
ia e tze.
D,
CountI Los ofCons tum
V: s
ori
Co I ofPli if Co ai r que t damag f t l sofc ori oft
unt V
a ntfs' mpl nt e s s
es or he os
ons tum
h
em i
nor
daug e Ar naofPl ntfsPr c Ga
ht r ai
ai if a hi ndhia Abihek Ga hi Li Count1,
nd
s
nd . ke
1 CountI f ist
V al o
sae acai unde g ne a ma ii el w .
tt l m
r e r l rtm a
Ge r l a ii elw doesnot ut iel sofc ori cai s Se M ie v Ape a ne
ne a m rtm a
a horz os
ons tum l m . e ls . xM ri
Cop.4 8U. 1 ( 9 0 ; a v S ceyEx dto s I .39F. 1 (t Ci.1 ; c s
r , 9 S. 9 1 9 ) Ch n . o it pe iin , nc, 3d 398 9h r 994)Nihol
p Per e Helco e s I ., l F.d 1 9 1 2 3( t Ci.1 9 ) Fr n o v Ro Ca bbe
. tol um
i ptr , nc 7 3 1 , 2 -2 5h r 9 4 ; a g
yal ri an
.
Cr se , t ,891So. 2 1 0 ( a DitCtAp 2 05 . eSu rmeCo r hedi M i sv
ui s L d.
d 2 8 Fl. s. . p. 0 ) Th p e
ut l n l
e
.
Ape
x
M arne Cor t tda a f l sofs i t a e notr cove a eunderge r m a ii lw f
i
p.ha m ges or os
oc ey r
e
r bl
ne al rtme a or
t wr ulde t ofas a . 498U. a 37. l ngM ie , courshavec itntyhel t t
he ongf a h
e man
S. t Folowi
ls
t
onsse l d ha
ge a ma ii e lw does notpr de f l s of s ey orl s of c ori i c u s lne
ner l rtm a
ovi or os
ocit
os
ons tum n r ie i
p s e g rij r c s s S el r Ev r a sIl dBo tT u s LLC,484 F.Supp.2d 1259, 1
a s n e nu y a e . e n e eglde san a o r,
263
( . Fl 2007)Al reli NCL Cor ., 20 8U. DitLEXI 5 7 9( D. l . uy29 2008)
M D. a.
; be t lv.
p 0 S. s.
S 7 8 S. F a J l ,
Ci cam f l sofco o tum i notpemitdunde ge r maii l , and t ef em us
A li or os
ns ri s
r te
r neal rtme aw
her or
t
bedimis ' Mari zv DannOce Towig, I c, 0 U. Dit LEXI 20 4 ( . Fl.
s sed.l; tne .
an
n n .20 5 S. s.
S 9 6 M D. a
2 0 )I b r e v Cee rt Cr ie, nc, 0 6U S. s.
0 5 ;s e n r . lb i us s I .2 0
y
DitLEXI 9 9 4( D. a 20 6 (' h
S 4 3 S. Fl. 0 ) 'T1 e
g
.
Elve hCic tha r peaedl hel t m mii e1 w doesnotpenui C e over f l sofs ey
e nt r ui s e t y d hat tm a
t t c y or os
r
ocit
o c ns rim i p ro a ij r c s s' (iigLo l v BrownM ari Ser ., 995F. 1565,1565
r o o t n es n ln u y a e .) ctn li
u
'
e
ne v
2d
.
-
8-
( 1hCi.1 93).
1t r 9 )
Thewe le t bls dca el pr cudi t a s ri ofc ori ca msunde a ii
l- sa ihe s aw e l ng he s e ton ons tum li
rm rtme
1w lave ltl que ton f t Cour.Co I ofPl i ifsCom pl nti Dim is d.
a e s ite si or he
t unt V
antf
ai s s s e
E.
Concuson
l i
I s , t s Cour GR ANTS D e e
n um hi
t
f ndants M o i t Sti a l ga i r f r i t
'
ton o r ke le tons e e enc ng he
docrne ofr s i a l t r fom Countl a GRANTS De e nts M oto t Dim iswih
ti
e ps oquiu r
nd
f nda '
in o s s t
P eu ieCo n s1,I a dI o Plitf sCo litRe i alqutri n t s p rt c u eo
rj dc u t Ill n V f an if mpan . sps o iu s o a e aae a s f
a ton a opra ef c i r tonatt ssagei t c s M or ove ,hel r ga di Count1
c i ppr it or ons de ai
hi t n he a e. e r t aw e r ng
1
a t a i a i o t zoneofda rt tha bee c e ry es a i he f us i f der l mi i e
nd he pplc ton f he
nge es s n l a l t bls d or e n e a m tm
c es i t Elve h Cic t a has t 1 peri ntt Count 1 ' cli f l s of fla
as n he e nt r ui, s
he aw
tne o
V s am or os
iil
c ori Countlli a r pe ii pla f da es Ther f e onl CountIr m ans oft
ons tum.
1 s e ttve e or mag .
e or
y
e i
he
Pl ntf sCom pl i .
ai if
a nt
DONE AND ORDERED i Chambe sa M i m i Fl i t s
n
r t a , orda, hi
FE
Copi pr ded t
es ovi
o:
Couns lofRec d
e
or
-
9-
da ofM a c 201
y
r h, 4.
CO A .
M
NO
TED STATES D I
STRI J G E
CT UD
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?