Cone v. Regalado et al
Filing
16
ORDER Granting 11 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 4/7/2014. (jw)
UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI T CO U RT
C
SO UTH ERN DISTRICT O F FLO RI A
D
M I IDI I O N
AM
V SI
CA SE N O .13- vc 24674JLK
Làw x CONE,asPe sonalRe es atv
r
pr ent i e
t /eEsat O ' WEAT
n : t e /CI
/l
XX
HERS
POON
J? o b hafo urN CONE;
?# n e l fll
N
Wz #r WEA THERSPO ON;
4
f;' WEA THERSPO ON .and
.
&
,
LJNFSFII WEATHERSPOON ass vi s
F
ur vor ,
,
Pl i if
a ntf ,
M AN UEL OROSA ,M AURI SODRE,
CE
a d THE CI OF M I I
n
TY
AM ,
Dee
f ndant
s.
/
O RD ER G R ANTI M O TI N TO DISM I
NG
O
SS
TH I CAU SE com esbef et Coul upon D e e
S
or he
'
t
f ndantCiy ofM i isM oton t
t
am '
i o
s uly
Dimist Ame d Compl i ( E.11,fld J n r 3 ,201 The Courti f l
s s he
nde
ant D. ) ie a ua y 0
4.
bref d on t m ater l
i e
he t .
L BA CK GR O U ND
i t
ng r
fce
Thi i a Fl i a 1w a 42 U. C.j 1 3 acton sem m i f om an ofi rs s ord a nd
S.
98
i ved s i i t Ove t
nvol
hootng n he
r own a ea ofM i m i Fl i on Ja r 1 2011. Pl i if
r
a , orda
nua y ,
a ntf
i t e ft e o Ly W e t r po n (s e De e nt',who wa a lge l kild b a
s h ah r f nn ahe s o çh
t
c de '
)
s le d y le y n
1 an iffld aRe p s onFe uay 9 201 ( E.1 t whihDe e da tRe le o Fe uay 1
Plitf ie
s on e
br r , 4 D. 3) o c f n n pid n br r 9,
201 ( E.1
4 D. 4)
ofi r on Ja y 1 2011. Pl ntf brngst s ac i as t pe s
fce
nuar ,
ai if i
hi ton
he r onalr es nt tve f
epr e a i or
t De
he cedent s e t e and on beha fofvarous s vi s D. 6 ! 8. D ef
' s at
l
i
ur vor . E. (
endant a e t
s r he
Ciy ofM i m i Chi M a
t
a , ef nuelOr a oft Ciy ofM i iPolc Depa t e , and Of i er
os
he t
am
ie
r m nt
fc
M a i Sodr of t Ciy of M i i Polc D e t e . Pl ntf fl t c e on
ur ce
e
he t
am
i e parm nt
ai if ied he as
De e r 30, 201 ( E. 1 a fld t o rtve Ame d Co an (t
c mbe
3 D. ) nd ie he peai
nde
mplit she
t
Compl it' o J nu r 2, 4 ( E. . The i t n M o in fl d b t Ci ofM i mi
an ' n a a y 201 D. 6)
)
nsa t to ie y he t
y
a
se t di m i st Com pl i .2 The Ciy ofM i m ii s i is ca t ast Ciy of
eks o s s he
ant
t
a s ued n t paciy he t
M imiPolc De rme t( E.6 a ! 11 nd wilhe e n fe b r f re t a ûhe
a
i e pa t n D.
t
)a
l r i a tr e e e r d o s t
t
C 1y.'
- '
t
l .LEG AL STAND AR D
l
l de di a m oton t dim is t Cour mus a
n ci ng
i o s s , he
t t cceptacom pl nts alega i a
ai ' l tons s
tue a consr t m i t lghtm os f vor bl t t Pl i if See M T. 7 v.D ek b
r nd
tue he n he i
t a a e o he a ntf .
P
al
Cny,Sc Dit,44 F.d 11 3 1 6 ( 1h Ci.2 6) d n a l i t s tc e y of
. h. s. 6 3 5 ,1 5 1 t r 00 ,û nayzng he ufs inc
l
te c an , ghe Cou t lmig) gt) c nsd r to t t welpla d f cua
h ompli t t
r) i ts is o i e ai n o he l- e de a t l
alg to ,d ume t c nrlt o rfrnc d i t c ant a matr j iily
le ains oc ns e ta o r e ee e n he ompli , nd tes udcal
n tc d. La Gr sa v Fis Unon S c, n , 8F. 8 ,8 ( 1h Ci. 00 .
o ie '
'
a t . r t i e .I c.35 3d 40 45 1 t r 2 4)
A com pl i m us cont n s ta pl n s a em e soft gr
a nt
t
ai hor nd ai t t nt
he oundsf t c ts
or he our '
jrs c in,oft ca e o a to a o t e r le s ug . d.R. v. 8 a . Und r
u idito
he us f ci n, nd f h ei f o ht Fe
Ci P. ( )
e
?Ofi Sodr has notr ponded and t e i no pr ofse ce on t docket Pl ntf has 1 days
fcer
e
es
her s
oof
rvi
he
.
ai if
20
fo t d t oft Complitt s r e Ofie Sod e Se Fe R.Ci P.4( . ChifOr a fl d a
r m he ae he
an o e v fc r r . e d.
v. m)
e os ie n
Ans and Af imatve Def ns
wer
fr i
e es.
2
t hei ened pl adi sandar s t f t by t Supr e Cour i Bel At.Cor v
he ght
e ng t
ds e orh
he
em
tn
l l
p.
T mbe 55 U. 5 4( 7)a As rh vI b ,5 6U. 66 ( 01 ,heemus be
wo ly, 0 S. 4 200 nd hc o q al 5 S. 2 2 0) t r
t
' no h f c st sa e a c am t r le t a i plusbl o (he f c ' oft e c ant
i ug a t o t t l i o eif h t s a i e n t ) a e' h ompl i .
e
Twom bly, 550 U . at 570. A pl ntf m us pl s sci f s t s
e
S.
ai if
t ead uf ent act o how r i and
elef
'm or t l s a concl i .a f m ul c r t i oft el ent of a c e of
l e han abel nd
usons. , or ai eciaton
he em s
aus
ac i wilnotdo. 1
ton l
' d.
'
1 1 ANA LYSIS
1.
A.î 1983 Cl m s
ai
if1 83 Cl i a Fou t e h Ame me Vi l tons
. 9
a m nd re nt
nd nt o a i
Def ndant r s conce n t pa agr ph t o of t Com pl nt s a es t acton
e
aies
r hat r a w
he
ai t t he i
t nd
e h
s
a l s vi atons of t U . Cons iuton' Fourh a Fourtent Am endm ent . The
lege ol i
he S.
tt i s
gai t aw nf ce nt fce s or xce i
Supr e Cour ha hel t a1 cl m s a ns l e or m e ofi r f e ssve
em
t s d hat 1 ai
f c s d be a yzed unde t Fourh A m endm ent sr onabl s s a d a not
or e houl
nal
r he
t
' eas
enes t ndar nd
t Foure h A m endm ent s due pr s sandar Gr
he
t ent
'
oces t
d. aham v.Connor,490 U . 386,
S.
3 ( 98 ) Ac o di gl t t e t n t tt e Compli s e r le f e e svef c
95 1 9 . c r n y, o he x e t ha h
ant e ks e if or xc s i or e
i vi aton oft Four ee h Am e
n ol i
he
t nt
ndm e ,t Cour fndsno s r i fi pe m i sbl
nt he
ti
uch ele s r s i e.
i.Count1:Exce si Force
i
s ve
Count1alegest D ef
l
hat endant Sodr and t Ciy vi at t D ece nts Fourh
s
e
he t ol ed he
de '
t
Ame dme rg t b fe fo e es i f r e D. 6 a ! 46. Th o y a lgai ns
n nt iht o e r e r m xc sve o c . E. t
e nl le to
agai tt Ciy ar t tt Ciy ha û bas sf s zur 'oft D ece
ns he t e ha he t d ç
no i or ei e' he
dentand c ea ed a
r t
3
s ci lzed uni ofwhi h D ef
pe a i
t
c
endantSodr was a m em be on t ni i ques i 1 a
e
r
he ght n
ton. d. t
! 48 5
l , 2.
!
l i wele t b ihe t a t r i no r s nde s pe ir la lt u r j 1 3.
t s l sa ls d h t hee s epo at u ro ibiiy nde 98
N n l v De 'o So .Se v.o Cï o w Y r 43 U. 6 ,6 1( 9 ) Ci o
hnel . p t f c r s f / fNe o k, 6 S. 58 9 1 78 ; t f
y
y
Can o ,Ohi v Ha rs 48 U. 378 385( 98 ; e h v Clyt n Cn@. Ga. 33 F.d
t n o , r i, 9 S. ,
1 9) Gr c . a o
, , 5 3
1 2 1 29 ( 1h Ci.2 3) munii l y c n o y be s d und rj 1 3 whe i i
3 6, 3 1 t r 00 .A
cpai a nl
t
ue
e 98
n ts
t e c to o apoiy o c tm t tdntit t ij y. M o l,43 U. a 6
he xe uin f lc r uso ha i lcs he nur ' nel 6 S. t 94.
i
'
Thus Countldoes notpr e a pr r s tagai tt Ciy. Def nda Sodr s alege
,
es nt ope ui
ns he t
e nt
e' l d
lc ofr a o bl ba i f rhi us off r e c nn tbec le d a a ns t e Ciy a a j
a k e s na e ss o s e o c a o
ha lnge g i t h t s
1 8 vilto Thee oe a a i theCiy Cou 1i dimis dwihprj c .
9 3 oain. rf r, s gans t t, nt s s se t eudie
iiCount1:Dei r t I e e e
i.
1 lbe ae ndt r nc
Count 1 aleges t Ciy was delbe at y i f e ent i ha ng polci i f ce
1 l
he t
i r el ndif r
n vi
i es n or
t a vi lt d t Fo t Ame
h t oa e he urh
ndme .D. 6 a ! 73,De e nto i na l mo e t
nt E. t
fnda rgi ly v d o
di m i t Com pl nt f l ck of f ual s
s ss he
ai or a
act
uppor. I hi Res
t n s
pons Pl ntf atac
e, ai if t hes
De a t n ofJ tc fndng sai g t a t De rme b le s Cha (h Ciy o
p rme t usie i i s t tn h t he pa t nt ei ve , ç t t e t f
t
M im iPolc De rm e le a si apa tr o p a tc ofe e sveus o f r ewih
a
i e pa t nt ng ge n ten r r ci e xc s i e f o c t
r s e tt fr a m d s ha ge . D. 3 1a ! 1 l lg oft t i isRe y De e da
e p c o ie r ic r s' E.1 - t ( . n iht ha, n t pl , f n nt
'
w ihdr w t spori ofisM oton.
t e hi
ton t
i
A w e ls
l- uppored R e pons doesnotm a a w el- ed Com pl nt The Compl nt
t
s
e
ke
lpl
ai .
ai
doesnotcont n s fci f ct s
ai ufi ent a ual uppor f is alegatons The Depa t e ofJ tce
t or t l i .
r m nt us i
fndi atac t Pl ntf Res
i ngs t hed o ai ifs pons a e neihercont i i norr e enced t i t
e r
t
a ned n
ef r
o n he
4
Co ant Ac o di l Co t1 i dimis d wiho tprj c t r - e d t cam
mpli . c r ngy, un 1 s s s e t u eudie o epla he li
w ih s fci ntf t s
t ufi e ac ual uppor .
t
B.Fl i St e Law Cl m s
or da at
ai
i Fl i Wr gf De h Ac
. orda on ul at t
Pl ntf brngst ee sat 1 w cl m s agai tt Ciy:CountII ale W r ul
ai i f i
hr t e a ai
ns he t
I l ges ongf
Dea h, Count I brngs a cl m of ba t r a Count V s
t
V i
ai
te y, nd
eeks dam ages f diec
or r t
neglge e.3 D ef
i nc
endantar
gues Pl ntf' ba t r a neglge cl m s m er i o t
ai its te y nd
i nce ai
ge nt he
wr ngf d ah c am u r Fl i a' W r ngf De t Ac ,Fl S a .j . 6 768.
o ul e t l i nde ord s o ul ah t a. tt 768 1 - 26
( 01 . Pli tf a gu s e c o t c n s a e pe misbl b c us t y a e pld a
2 4) a n if r e a h f he ou t r r s i e e a e he r e s
aler i
t natves.
Flrda s s vi a saut ,Fl.Stt j 4 0 1 ( 01 ,p e e v s t rg t brng
o i ' ur v l t t e a a . 6.2 2 4) r s r e he i ht o i
p ro lij y a to wh c t de e e t ma ha b ou tprort hi d ah onl
e s na nur c i ns ih he c d n y ve r gh i o s e t y
wh n tepes na ij r wa nott c us ofd ah.St ln v R. Re ol To ac o
e h ro l nu y s
he a e e t arig . J yn ds b c
C 7,8 F.Su 2d 1 1 ,1 1 ( . Fl .201 )( iig sf tn v Unie Se .Se v .
R . 45
pp. 2 5 2 9 M D. a
1 ctn arl . td c r st
'
I c,3l So. 7 ,7 n.1 ( a 1 75 ) Und r t Fl rda W r ng u De t Ac,
n . 4 2d 65 70
8 Fl. 9 ).
e he o i
o f l ah t
( napes na ij r t t de e e rs t i d ah, a to frt pe s na ij r
û
Whe
ro ln u y o he c d nt euls n e t no cin o he ro l nu y
s l s vi ,a d a y s h a ton pe di a t tme ofde t s l a t . Fl,S a .j
hal ur ve n n uc ci
n ng t he i
ah hal bae' a t t
'
7 20 ( 01 . The Fl i a Su e Co tha u l t W r ngf De t Ac a
68. 2 4)
ord pr me ur s phed he o ul ah t s
c nsiuto l h di S s pa ae saut r a to f r pe s lij re r s tng i
o tt i na , ol ng ' e r t t t o y ci n o rona n u i s e uli n
no
3countI i i orecty l l CountVli t Com pl nt D . 6 a 1
V s nc r l abeled
n he
ai . E. t 4.
5
dea h ca s vi t de
t n ur ve he cede ' de ie.'M artn,314 So. a 770. A lhough Pl ntf
nt s m s '
i
2d t
t
ai if
sat she ûac
te
t knowl s'M artnt hol ng,he doesnotditngui h t cas
edge '
i s di
s i s he e.
The Com pl nt aleges t t t bater a t neglge
ai
l
ha he t y nd he
i nce eac r uled i
h es t n
De e ntsde t D. 6 a ! 92,1 2.Ac or ng y,t batr a ne i e ec ams
c de ' a h. E. t !
0
c di l he te y nd glg nc l i
a e wr
r
ongf dea h actons pr m ied on dif entt i of t t la lt Thus unde
ul t
i
e s
fer heores
or i biiy.
,
r
Fl i lw ,t c ai s f ba t y a neglgence ca
orda a he l m or ter nd
i
nnotsand as i pende ca es of
t
nde
nt us
a to a Cou sI a dV mu tbeds se wihprj ie
cin nd nt V n
s
imis d t eudc .
i. at eo Li t i
iSt ut f miatons
A lhough notr s by any pary,t Cour has i ii a pot ntalpr e w ih
t
aied
t he
t
dentfed
e i obl m t
t sat e of lm iatons. l Fl i a wr
he t ut
i t i
n or da,
ongf dea h a i aga ns a sat agency or
ul t cton
i t te
s b viin mus be b o htwihi t - a s ofwhe t a ton a c ue Fl S a .j
u di so
t
r ug
t n wo ye r
n he ci c r d. a. t t
7 . ( 4 ( 4 ;j 9 114 ( ( 01 . A mu cpaiy i asae a e y o s di so
6828 1 ) 201 ) 5. ( )d) 2 4)
nii lt s t t g nc r ub vii n
f r pu po e o t s saut .Fl .S a .j 7 28 2) ( 4 . De e ntpa s d a y o
o r s s f hi t t e a t t 68. 4 201 )
c de
s e wa n
J nu r 1 2 1 D. 6 a ! 2 26.Thi c s wa fld o De e e 3 2 3,amos
a a y , 01 . E. t ! 2,
s a e s ie n c mb r 0, 01 l t
t ee yea safe t deat D . 1.
hr
r tr he
h. E.
Pr ort brngi a t tacton agai t a s a e agency or s vi on,a pa t m us
i o i ng or i
ns t t
ubdi si
ry
t
com pl w ih ce t n pr s t r quiem ent
y
t
rai
e- ui e r
s.
l a w r ul dea h ac i
n
ongf
t
ton, t e
hes
r r m e s i ude pr se i a cl m t Fl i Deparm e of Fi
equie nt ncl
e ntng
ai o orda
t nt
nanci Se ces
al rvi
wihi t ye r a trt cam a c ue .Fl .Stt j 68. ( )a ( ( 4 . The sau e
t n wo a s fe he li c r s a a . 7 28 6 ( )2) 201 )
tt t
oflm iatons i t l durng t tm e i t
i ti
s oled i he i t akes t D e t entt r h a deci i Fl
he parm
o eac
son. a.
6
Stt j 7 . ( 4 ( 4) I no de so i ra h d i awr ngf de t c s wihi
a. 68286)d) 201 . f
ciin s e c e n
o ul ah a e t n
ni y da ,t deci on i dee e a fna de a oft c ai . 1
net ys he
si s m d i l ni l he l m d.
Pl ntf aleges t t he com pled w ih t condii pr ede t br ngi t s
ai if l
ha
i
t he
tons ec nt o i ng hi
a to a ct sù bi B. D. 6 a ! 7.No s h e hi ti at c d. Th Co an
ci n nd ie s
Exhi t ' E. t
'
uc x bi s ta he
e mpli t
pr e s no f t t a l ge t wr ul dea h c ai has bee tm el f l as i
es nt
ac s hat le he ongf
t lm
n i y ied;
s
c r nty pl t s cas w as t ed one ye beyond t t our e l ed, hi
e
ll
ar
he w year sat e of lm iatons
t ut
i t i .
Ac or ngy,Co tIImus be dimis d wiho tp eudie t p o ry pl a t tt e
c di l un l
t
s s e t u r j c o r pe l e d ha h
sa ut of lm ia i doe notbar t s a i and t s
tt e
i t tons s
hi cton
o how com planc w ih Fl . S a .j
i e t a tt
768.
28.
l .C H I O RO SA
V
EF
D e endant Chi Or a fl a Ans e a A fim a i Def ns
f
ef os ied n
w r nd fr tve
e es. A s hi fr t
s is
afir a i def ns Def ndant Or a sa es ( l ntf f l t s a e a c e of ac i
m tve e e,
e
os t t , T ai i f ais o t t
aus
ton
u n whih r le c n b gr n e a ans t sDe e n . D. 1 a ! 1
po
c e if a e a t d g i t hi f nda t' E. 2 t 03.
'
Thi i not a pr
s s
oper af m atve def e. An af m atve def e i a de e e
sr i
ens
ûr i
ens s
f ns
whih i dmistee s ntalacsofac mplita d st up oh rf csi j tsc to o
c i t h se i f t
a
o an n es te a t n usi ain r
a i a e. Wilv Rih d on Me r l,I c ,6 F.S pp.5 5 ( D.Ga 1 6
vo d nc ' l . c ar s - r e l n . 47
'
u
44, 47 S.
. 98 )
(mpha i i orgna ) $ de e ewh c poi sou ad f c i t pl i it prma f ce
e
ss n i i l. $ fns ih nt t e e t n he antf' i a i
A
s
cas i nota afim a i def ns ' I r Rawson Food Se v. I ,846 F. 1343, 1
es
n fr tve e e.' n e
r , nc.
2d
349
( 1h Ci.1 ) De e a tOr ad dno fl aM otont Dimis
1 t r 988 . f nd n os i t ie
i o s s
How e , t Com pl nt does i f t f l t sat a ca e of a i agai t
ver he
ai
, n ac , ai o t e
us
cton
ns
Dee a tOr a t u h i s e i hi i di dua c pa iy und r42 U. C. 1 3,
f nd n os .Alho gh e s u d n s n vi l a ct
e
S. j 98
no of t Count alege a ac i t ken by Or a. The onl a l tons conce ni
ne
he
s l
ny ton a
os
y lega i
r ng
hin ar t the was t c efof polce a t tm e of Decedents deat i a k r on' as
l e ha
he hi
i t he i
'
h, s k s '
pe
d i d i j 1 83 a d i s d i hi i di du c pa i D. 6 a ! 1 Th si frfom
ef
ne n 9 , n s ue n s n vi al a ct E. t 3. i s a r
y.
s fci ntt s a e a caus ofacton a ns Def nda Or
ufi e o t t
e
i gai t e nt osa. A ccor ngl t Am e d
di y, he
nde
Compl nta ns D ef
ai gai t endantOr a m us be dim i s Pl ntf w ilbe gr nt l ve t
os
t
s s ed. ai i f l
a ed ea o
fl a ne pl di cont ni s sci alega i agai tD ef nda Or a.
ie
w ea ng
ai ng uf ent l tons
ns
e nt os
V .C O NCLU SI N
O
A c di y,upon a ca ef r vi w of t r d and t Cour be ng ot wi e
cor ngl
r ul e e
he ecor
he
t i
her s
f l advied,i i O RD ER ED ,A DJU DG ED ,and D ECREED as f l s:
uly
s ts
olow
De e da tCiy ofM imisM o i t Dimist eAme e Co ant( E.1 )
fn n t
a ' ton o s s h
nd d mpli D. 1 ,
be,and t s e i ,he eby G R ANTED ;
he am s r
2. A sagai tD e endantCiy ofM i i CountlofPl ntf sAm ended Com pl nt
ns f
t
am ,
ai if
ai
( E. i he e DI I
D. 6) s r by SM SSED wih pr j c ;
t e udi e
Co 1 o Pl i ips Ame d Co ant ( E.6) i he e DI I
unt 1 f antf
nde mpli D.
s r by SM SSED
wihoutpr j c '
t
e udie
,
4. Co t I I of Pli ifs Ame d Compli ( E.6 i he e DI I
un I
antf
nde
ant D. ) s r by SM SSED
wihou pr j c '
t t e udie
,
5. Count I of Pl ntf Ame e Compl i ( E. 6 i he e DI I
V
ai ifs
nd d
ant D. ) s r by SM SSED
wih pr j c ;
t e udi e
Co V ofPlitf Ame de Co a n ( E.6 i he e DI I
unt
an ifs
n d mpli t D. ) s r by SM SSED w ih
t
Pr j c ,
e udie
'
8
As a ai tDe e ntOr s Pli ifsAm e d Compl i ( E.6 i he e y
g ns f nda
o a antf
nde
ant D. ) s r b
DI I
SM SSED wih tprj c ;a
tou eudie nd
8. Pli tf ha t n y ( ) da fo t e d t o t s Or e t fl a Se on
a n if s we t 20 ys r m h a e f hi d r o se
c d
Am ended Compl nti ac dancew ih t sOr .
ai n cor
t hi der
DO NE and O RD ER ED i Cha ber a t J esLawr nce K i Fede alJ tce
n
m s t he am
e
ng
r us i
Buidi and U nied St t Courhous M i i Fl i t s7t day ofA pr l 201
l ng
t
a es
t e, am , orda hi h
i, 4.
N.
J
ES LA W REN CE K I G
N
I
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT U
SOU THERN DI
STRI OF FL R1 A
CT
cc:
A l Couns ofRecor
l
el
d
9
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?