Malekmarzban v. Levine et al

Filing 17

ORDER granting 13 Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction. The case is dismissed without prejudice. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 4/17/2014. (rtn)

*

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i iDi s on
am
vi i
Cas N um ber 1 20 3- V- O R EN O
e
: 4- 31 CI M

FARZAD M ALEKM ARZBAN a FARZARD
M
M A LEK ,

Pl n if
aitf ,
VS.

RI
CHARD LEVI a J
NE nd OSE CALDERI ,
N
Def nda s
e nt .

O R DER G R AN TI G M O T I N TO DI I
N
O
SM SS

THI CAUSE c mebeor t Cour uponDefnda s M oi t Dimis( .E.No.1 .
S
a
f e he
t
e nt' ton o s s D
3)
THE COURT ha c i e t motona t peri tpo to oft r c d, a beng
s onsder d he i nd he tnen ri ns he e or nd i
o he i e f l a s d i t pr i es i i
t nv s uly dvi e n he em s , t s

ADJ
UDGED ta temoi ni GRANTED a dtec s DI M I ED wih u p eu iefr
h th to s
n h a e S SS
t o t rj dc o

lc o s be tmatrj rs ito p ru n t Fe R.Ci.P.1 ( ( ) Pl i if has f ied t
a k f u j c te u id cin u s a t o d.
v
2b)1 antf
al o
.

d
emonsr t t tt a ounti c r r y i t sm at re e ds$75,000.
tae ha he m
n ontove s n hi te xc e
00.
A N ALY SI
S

Tie2 ,e to 1 3 o teUntdS ae Co ep o ie t ttth dsrc c u t s al a e
t 8 s ci n 3 2 fh ie tts d r vd sha i l e itit o rs h lh v
l
g
o iia j rs ito o al ii a to swheet ematrnc nr v rye c e st es m o v leo
rgn lu idcin f lcv l cin
r h te i o to es x e d h u r au f
$75, e l i ofi e es a c t , a i bewe n gltz ofdifrntStt gl' U. C.
000, xcusve nt r t nd oss nd s t e ciiens
fee aes.'28 S.

j1 3 () l. n r l ,ostsyt ea u ti-o to e s rq ie n f r i ri u id ci n
3 2 a( ) Ge eal t aif h mo n-n c nr v ry e ur me t o dvest rs ito ,
y
yj
apl nifmus etbls t tagoodfihesi tdvaueofhi orhe cai s a i tadeenda
aitf t sa ih ha
at tmae l
s
r l mt) gans f nt
e e t saut iyr uie a o . f. , de at d M u . n . Co.v M c i
xce ds he t t orl eq r d m unt g. Fe r e
tI s
. K nnon M ot s LLC,
or ,

3 9F.d8 5 8 ( 1hCi. 0 3 .Toj tf d s s a,l l mus a p a t alg l e tit t a
2 3 0 , 07 1 t r 2 0 ) usiy imis lçit t p e r o e a c rany h t
g
tecam i ral f rls ta tej rs ito a a u t.'d (i n S . l r uyI d m. .
h li s e l o e s h n h u idcin l mo n g '1 .ct g tPau Me c r n e Co
y
l
i
v Re CabCo.303U. 28 289( 938 .
. d
,
S. 3,
1 )

Ho ve,ts l- sa ls e t a ç r j rs ito i b s do acam f rn eemiae
we r ii wele tbih d h tl e u id ci n s a e n li o id tr n t
whe
d ma e ,he. le a c rany ts gv swa a dt ep rys e i t ivo efd r lu id cin
a g s t . lg l etit ' et ie y, n h a t e kng o n k e e a j rs ito
.
be r t bur n o pr ngbyapr ponde a eoft e de et tt c am o whih i i basng
a s he de f ovi
e
r nc
he vi nc ha he l i n c t s i

j rs i o me t t j rs ito a mi mu 'Fe e ae Mu.l s,3 9 F.d a 8 7. e as
u iddin es he u idcin l ni m. d r td t n . 2 3 t 0 , e lo
'
s
Br e v Kel Se vie ,I ,224Fe Appx.893,894- ( 1hCi 2007 ( i Fe r e
adly . l r c s nc.
y
d.
95 1 t r. ) quotng deatd

Mu .n .od s s f rlc o j rs din ; a e d nAme iaI s Co v Mimi v rCl , n .
tIs t imis o a k fu idi o l Clr n o
rc n . . . a Rie ub I c,
41 F. zd 1 1 ( D.Fl.2006)(nme .
7 supp. 309, 315 S. a
s )
Pl i ifc e t tt dama a s re i t sel m a eS i ui t d a t r f e
antf onc des ha he
ges s e td n hi ai r t q da e nd he e or
unl

u c ran. ( E. 5a 1.Theeo e Plitf c rist eb r e t p o ei yap e o d r n eo
n e ti ' D. 1 t ) rf r , an if are h u d n o r v û
'
b rp n e a c f
e de e't thi cai m e tt $75, 00 a
vi nc 'ha s l ms e he
000. mounti c r ve s r r m e Jlg. Feder ed
-n- onto ry equie nt
,
at
.

M utI .329F. a 8 Pl i ifha f ie t dos he e.l hi Com pl ntPl i ifsa fnnai
.ns,
3d t 07. antf s a ld o o r n s
ai , antf fi tve

e i n eidc tstef lo n : a a$1 ,0 .0i v sme topu c a e8 wo kso a t( E. ,
vde c n iae h o lwig () 00 00 n et n t rh s 4 r f r.D. 1
Ex.A) a ( a$1 400. tx c e tf donai .( E.1 Ex.B)
; nd b) 2, 00 a r di or tons D. ,
.Thetx ce ti mo y
a rdi s ne

ara yrc ie , n t eeo ec n o b c n iee a p l o tej rs ito l mo n c luus
le d e ev d a d h r fr a n t e o sd rd s a' f h u idcina a u t ac l
t
oh rta a Dee d n sc re t a s r,os e ult a t wh ttevau o t es be ta t o l
t e h n, s fn a t or cl se tt p c ae s o a h le f h u jc r c ud
y

Rahe ta s tig f rh a dto a e d n eu o Dee a t'j rs ito a c alng ,
t r h n etn o t d iin l vie c p n fnd n s u idci n l h l e
e
Pl ntfsi t a r y ont ra lge çgood f ih be ift tt vaue oft pa t s p pr pe t
ai if nse d el
hei le d l
at le ha he l
he rnerhi o ry

i o e $ 50 05g E. 6a 2 .A ç o dfihb le 'sis f in wh nfc dwihDee d n s
s v r 7 ,0 . D. 1 t ) l o at eif i n u t e t e a e t fn a t'
'
g
k
-

2-

*

*

o j cin , ihaef u d do Plitf s wne ie c s t o t i hsCo an, andt Cour
be to s whc r o n e n anif o vd n e e f rh n i mpli t he
t
i t e or lf t s c ae a t how t a
s her f e e t o pe ult s o
he mounti c r ve s coul bem e . SeeBr e 224
-n- onto ry
d
t
adly,

Fed.
Appx. t89 95(f mi dimislofc antnoi t emplye ss c ai t the
a 4- afr ng s sa ompli , tng he
o e' pe ulton ha r
cli se ee d $75, di nots ts ybur n ofpr ng be
am xc de
000 d
a if de
ovi
yondapr ponder nc oft evi nce
e
a e he de

ta camse c e e s c a a u t o p mo e o s be t te j rs ito ) Fe e atdMu
h t li x e d d u h n mo n f r u s s f u j c matr u idcin ; d r e t
.

I s,3 9F.da 8 8( fimig ds sa o c mplitwh r p ly fi dt r b t u idcin l
n . 2 3 t 0 a fr n imis l f o an e e a' al o e u j rs it a
t e
o
a gumen s a c d no pr by a pr ponder nc oft e de e t tcai wasi e es of
r
t nd oul t ove
e
a e he vi nc ha l m
n xc s

j rs ito a a u t; a e d n 41 F. u p. da 1 6(idngpanif aife u idito a
u idcin l mo nl Clr n o , 7 S p 2 t 31 fn i li tf s tsidj rs ci n l
a
mountwher t c ai andatc nt t t compl ntl xpr sl s edl'ha dee nt
e he ompl nt ta hme s o he
ai i e sy howg 't t fnda
e
c dfc la lt i e s of$75, 00)
oul a e ibiiy n xce s
000. .
Pl i ifha f l t c ry hi bur n t s tsy t a ounti contove s r quie e .
antf s aied o a r s de o ai f he m
-n- r r y e r m nt

Ac o dn l,h Co rg a t De e d n s Mo int Dimisf r a ko s j c matr u idcin
c r igy te u t rn s fn a t' to o s s o lc f ube t te j rs ito
p ru ntt F d R.Ci.P.1 () 1, n P an ifsCo liti ds se wih u p eu ie
u sa o e .
v
2 b ( ) a d litf
mp an s imisd t o t rj dc

.

D ON E AN D O RD ERED i Cham be s a M i m i Fl i t s
n
r t a , orda, hi

FEDE
UN I
TE
Copispr de t
e ovi d o:
Couns ofRecor
el
d

-

3-

a ofAprl 201 .
y
i, 4

. OlE O
k
TA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U