Bettner v. Macy's Florida Stores, LLC. et al

Filing 13

ORDER REMANDING Case to State Court. This action is closed. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 2/28/2014. (rtn)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i Di son
ami vii
Cas Num ber: 14e
20382- V- ORENO
CI M
CYNTHI BETTNER,
A

Pl ntf,
ai if

M ACY' FLORI STORES?LLC d/ aM ACY' ,and
S
DA
b/
S
SUNHAM HOM E FASHI , LLC,and KAM HI
ONS
NG
ENTERPRI
SES,I .,
NC
Def nda s
e nt .
O RDER REM ANDI CASE TO STATE CO URT
NG

THI CAUSE c me b f et Cou tup Pli ifsM o in t Re d ( .E.No.7) fld on
S
a e or he r on antf
to o man D
, ie
Februarv 10.201
4.

THE CO URT has c i ed t m oton and t peri
onsder he
i
he tnent pori of t r d, and bei
tons
he ecor
ng
ot wie f l advied i t pr ies i i
her s uly
s n he em s , t s
ADJUDGED t tt m oton i GRANTED and t case REM AN DED t sa e c tf f l e
ha he
i s
he
o tt our or aiur
ofDef
endant Sunham Hom eFas ons LLC and Kam Hi Ent r ies
s
hi ,
ng e prs , l c.opr pe l c ns ntoor oi
n t o ry o e t j n
ir
n emovali accor
n
dance w ih 28 U .S. j 1 b .
t
C. 446( )
LEGAL STANDARD AND ANALYSIS

Thebu d n o e t ls ng fdeal u iditon f l ont p ry whoi a tmptngt i oket
r e f sabihi e r j rs c i als he a t
s te i o nv he

j rs ci ofh fd rl o tMide vMa a Cop.45 F3d1 22, 3 ( 1hCi. 6)Klmpn r
uiditon te e ea c ur. e ma . ytg r , 0
3 l 30 1 t r200 , e e
.
.

v No twe tr M utal ('l s Cos1 6F. pp. l 33, 1 37( D. a. 01 (1 prs toni f v
. rh se n u L/ n . . 9 Su 2d 2 2 S. Fl 20 ) t e ump i n a or
c
A
o r ma i ne e s r be a ei af d r l o t e c st eme isof()p ndigmo i i ar move c s
f e nd s c s ay c us f e e a c ur r a he h rt a e n ton n e
d ae

wh r s betmatru idito ma belc n ide i sasaec t isrght e teCo ttto
ee uj c tej rs cin y a kig t prve tt ouroft i und r h nsiuin
t r ol contover es i is ow n coursa' Re alsau e a e c tu d nar y,a d wh n te
o es ve
r si n t
t l. mov ttt s r onsr e rowl n
e h

plitf a d f nd ntcl h o t is ofj iditon u e t n i a er s ve i f v o r ma
an if nd e e a as n he sue urs ci , nc raites r e ol d n a or f e nd

.

Bur v.Wi
ns
ndsorl .Co. 31F.3d 1 92,1 ( 1hCi.1 94)
ns
,
0 095 1 t r 9 .

Pu s a t 28U. C.j 1 47() a d f c i t r mo l oc du ei gr und f rr ma d The
ru nt o
S. 4 c , ny e e t n he e va pr e r s o s o e n
.

' a mi rq rme t' n tst ti c ssi ol n muli ed fnd nt,ldee da t mutoi t
' ni t e uie n'ma dae ha n ae nv vig tpl ee a sa1 fn ns sj n he
un
y
rmo al e iinoro h r s ma f s c e tf rr mo l t nt ry( 0)da sofs r c ofapla n
e v p tto
t e wie nie t ons n o e va wihi hit 3 y e vie
e dig
t b p o rwi nt eme nigofj l c .Ea hr mo n p ry mus tkes a fr tvea tont
o e r pe t h a n
hi
447() c e vig a t
t a ome fimai c i o

i o t Couto isc e ta /rj n ri ama rt ti ()tmeya ( bidi E. , tui
nfnn he r f t onsn ndo oide n nne ha s l i l nd 2) n ng. g.Mi
s
Li sLt v Cs l e moda I c,56 F. pp. 1 ,1 l( D. a. 08)
ne d. . x ntr l n . 4 su zd 357 36 S. Fl 20 .
To dae,Def
t
endant Sunham Hom eFashi ,LLC and Kam Hi Ent pries l havef l t
s
ons
ng er s , nc.
aied o

t tm el and bi ng ac i m anies i t rcons t r m oval The onl evi
ake i y
ndi
ton
f tng hei
ent o e
.
y dence ofcons ar
ent e

De e an M a y' a s rinsi isRe alS ausRe r ( E. l fld Fe r r l ,201 )a is
f nd t c s s e to n t mov tt po t D. No. 0, ie b uay 8 4 nd t

Re p e i Opp ii t Plitf Moton t Re nd ( E.No.1 fld Fe r a y 2 201 ) t t
s ons n oston o an ifs i o ma D.
2, i
e b u r 0, 4 , ha
Def ndant Sunham and Kam H i ' s 'M acy' t t cons t r oval The Courtfndst e
e
s
ng '
advied'
s hat hey
ent o em
.
i hes
s aem ent do notr l bi ng m aniesatonsby Def
tt
s
etect ndi
fti
endant Sunham orKam Hi oft rc entor
s
ng hei ons

j nd r TheCourf te fndst th s e rsi ofc nsnt j nde aeu i l wheet ywee
oi e.
turh r i ha te e xpesons o e oroi r r ntmey r he r
m ade mor t n 30 daysaferSunham orKam H i wer pur t y s ve on J r 6 a Januar 7,
e ha
t
ng e poredl er d
anua y nd
y
201 r pectvel Eachoft sfndi al w arantr and whe eDef
4, es i y.
hi i ngs one r em
r
endant havenotmett rbur
s
hei den

t ivo fdea j idito Acor ngl ii
o n ke e rlurs cin. c di y,t s
ORDERED AN D ADJUDGED t t s cas be,and t s
hat hi e
he ame i,her REM ANDED t t
s eby
o he

Cicui Cour f t El
r t
t or he event Judi alCicui i and f Dade Count Fl i The Cl k oft Cour i
h
ci r t n
or
y, orda.
er
he
ts
her diect t t aI necess y sepsand pr
eby r ed o ake l
ar t
ocedur t efectt e
es o f he xpedii r and oft a
tous em
he bovesyl acton.
t ed i

DONE AND ORDERED i Cha be sa M i ,Fl i t s
n m r t ami orda, hi

ayofFe uar 201
br y, 4.

FED l A.M
CO
O
UN TED ST
S DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
Copi pr de t
es ovi d o:
Couns ofRecor
el
d
Cl k oft Cour,Elve hJudi alCicui
er
he
t e nt
ci r t

/

,