Capella Photonics, Inc. v. Cisco Systems, Inc.
Filing
77
ORDER GRANTING 19 DEFENDANTS' MOTIONS TO TRANSFER. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 7/23/2014. (lbc)
U N IT ED ST A T E S D IST R IC T C O U R T
SO U T H E R N D ISTR IC T O F FL O R ID A
CAPELLA PHOTONI l C.
CS,N ,
Pl n i f
ai t f ,
CaeNo 14s
20529- V- TZ J
CI SEI
CI
SCO SYSTEM S,l C .
N ,
D e enda .
f
nt
.
V.
Cas N o.1 20530- V - TZ
e
4C1 SE1
CI A CO RPOM TI N ,
EN
O
Def nt
enda .
V.
C a e No.1 20531 C1 - TZ
s
4- V SE1
FU J TSU N ETW O RK
I
CO M M UN I TI S,I C.
CA ON N ,
Def nda .
e nt
9.
Ca e N o.l 60350- V - TZ
s
4C1 SE1
TELLABS OPEM TI S,N C. a
ON l , nd
CORI (
ANT USA)I ,
NC.
Dee
f ndant .
s
/
O RD ER G R AN TI G DEFEN DA NTS'M O TION S TO TR AN SFER
N
THI M ATTER i bef r t Cour on t motonst ta f rve t t Norhe n
S
s o e he
t he i o r ns e nue o he t r
Diti tofCa iom i fl byt fveDe enda si t above syl d a i ns Cic Syse s
src
lf a ied he i
f nt n he
- t e cto : s o t m ,
l .Cin Co r to , u is Newo kCo n c to s l c, la sOpeain , n .a d
nc, e a mo ai n F jtu t r mmu iain , n .Telb
rto s l c, n
Co in (
ra t USA)I c (olcieyd fn ns). DE- 9( 4 2 5 9 ; 43(4- 0 3 ) DEn . c le tv l t e da t' ( 1 1 - 0 2 ) DE- 1 2 5 0 ;
De
25(4- 31;DE- ( 41 205 ) 63 1 60350).Be us Dee nt haves ts dt i budent s
11 ca e fnda s
aiie her r o how
t tt f c ua c r s a e s r y f vorta f t t N or he n D i t i tofCa ior a
ha he a t l icum t nc s t ongl a
r ns er o he
t r sr c
lf ni
purua t 28U. C.j 1 a ,heCour wilgan Dee nt'moi t ta fr
s nt o
S.
404() t
t l r t fnda s tons o rnse .
1
Be us t em otonsf
ca e hes
i ocuson es e i l t s m ef c uala l galis s t Cour
s ntaly he a a t nd e s ue , he
t
w ila es t m t t r notng a r e tdi tnc i a t a i e.
l ddr s he oge he , i ny el van s i tons s hey r s
1.
Proceduraland Fact Background
ual
A .The Pat s atIssue and ProceduralH i ory
ent
st
The Co pl ntaleg t tPl i ifi t owne oft pa e si s t Unie Stt s
m ai l es ha antf s he
r he t nt-n-ui: t d a e
Pae No.1 42, (he11 pae ' a Unie SttsPae No.1 42, (he1:
tnt V 368 t .368 tnt' nd td ae tnt V 678 t 1678
)
P tn '. Th ' 6 p tn wa iv n e b Ta Ch n J fryP. i e a dJ s p E. v s
ae tlz e 3 8 ae t s n e td y i e , efe W l , n o e h Da i
'
d
andwasis d on M a 1 2011.
s ue
y 7,
The : pa e wasi nt by J fr P.W idea J e
678 t nt
nve ed
e fey
l nd os ph
E.Da sa wasis d on Septm be 6,2011 M r W ide a M r Da scu r ntyr sdei
vi nd
s ue
e r
. . l nd . vi r e l e i n
norhe' Calf ni,whieMr Chen' l ai i urknown.( ' Tr 1 20-21,J y 1
t l ior a l .
n
s oc ton s l
Hrg . 40:
ul 0,
201 )Thepr e tngatomeysf t t pae s Bar Young,Davi Aleri a J hu
4.
os cui t
or he wo tnt, ry
d b t, nd os a
Ie r aeas l t i norhel Caiomi ( ungDe . . J L g 43- 43- 1
s nbeg, r lo ocaed n t ' lf a. Che
n
clExs H, , DE- 9, 1 ,
43- 3( 41 1 20530)) Thepae si s thavebot be n a sgne t Pl ntf Ca laPhot c,
1.
tnt-n-ui
h e si d o ai if pel
onis
I c (Ca e1' , os p icp l fiei i n rh r Caioni.
n . 1 p 1a' wh e rn ia o fc s n o ten lf r a
ç
)
Bot pae s i s tr a et fbe - i co munia i s t m s whi h ta m i daa
h t nt -n- ui elt o i roptc m
c ton yse , c r ns t t
o rop i lfbe si t f m oflghtsgnal.M uli e sg s e h usng a dif r t
ve tca i r n he or
i i s
tpl i nal, ac i
fe en
wavee h oflg ,c n ta a o a sngl optc lfbe sm ula usy.Spe ii a l t
lngt
i ht a r vel l ng i e i a i r i t neo l
c fc ly, he
pae si s ta ef rconfgurbl optc la dr muli e r (k
tnt-n-ui r or e i a e ia dd- op tplxes $
ROADM's, c ae
') whih r
d v c sta c n sp rt a ddr c e c wa ee gho lg tit s p r t c a es A mao
e ie h t a e a ae n ie t a h v ln t f ih no e a ae h nn l. j r
co
mpone o t pae si s ti awa e h s l tves th (t SS'3 whi us sa
nt f he tnt-n-ui s velngt eeci wic $
W ' , ch e n
)
a r ofmir ror t r elghtsgnal bewe optc lfbe s. c di t t i
ray
c omir s o out i i s t en i a i r Ac or ng o her
s m a i ,di tnc i f tlesoft pa e s i s ti l de t m i r ir s abiiy t pi t
um res s i tve ea t
r
he t nt - n- ui nc u he c om r or ' lt o vo
aong t a sand t ROADM ' c pa iy f powe co r .
l
wo xe
he
S a c t or
r ntol
2
Thes pae sa ear is ofN o.67879F750 a No. 625,46,r pe tvey.
e t nt r es ue
nd
6, 3 es ci l
The W SS i al o known asa t a e h- e r tng r e ' or a d a e t c os s s
s vel ngt s pa a i out r'
w
t vel ng h r s
w
conne ts ich.
c wt '
'
On Fe u y 7,201 Pli iffld s par t s t agans De enda sCico Syse s
br ar
4, a ntf ie e a e uis i t f nt s
tm ,
I (f ic ' CinaCor aton(i e ',Fuis Net kCommuni tons I (t '
nc.s s o' e
)
por i tcina' jtu wor
)
cai ,nc. 6
FNC'
)
a Telbs l (t elbs'f i rnge ntofbot pae si s t4Pl ntf alge t t
nd la , nc.d la ' or nfi me
T
)
h tnt-n-ui. ai if le s ha
Dee nt infi da c i jt die tyi rnge...byma ng,usng,s li ofei
fnda s d rnge nd ontnuel o rcl nfi
i
ki
i elng, frng
t s l and ori pori optc ROADM pr t t ti or at awa l ngt s e i
o el / m tng ial
oduc s ha nc por e
ve e h elctve
s th'( e ,eg.Se o dAm. mp . DE- 2 (4- 5 0 1a 5!2 )
wi . S e . , c n
c '
Co l ( 8 1 20 3 ) t 3.
On Aprl4, 4,Cic movedt ta frt t N orhe n DititofCa ior a
i 201
so
o r nse o he t r src
lf ni
p ru n t s cin 1 0 ( )5OnAp i 2 , 01 , pel a n e i c mpan a ans Telb
u s a to e t 4 4 a .
o
r1 9 2 4 Ca la me d d t o lit g i t la s
s
t a Defnda sTelbsOpeai ,nc (t la Ops',Col
o dd e nt la
rtons l . û lbs ') umbusNewoksUSA,nc.
Te
t r
l ,
dco in (
ra t usA)Ic (' ra tl6onM a 1 201 , p l a n e isc mplita an t
n . t in- .
co '
y , 4 ca el me d d t o an g is
a
Cinat add Def nda Telf ca S.
e o
e nt e oni , A.
OnJ l 1 , 01 ,h Co r h l aj itsh d l a dpamigc n ee e Fol wi
uy 0 2 4 te u t ed on c e ui n lr n o frnc . lo ng
ng
t conf r nce Tela , nc.a Telf c S. we edim is d,Tel onia l t m ai na
he
e e , lbs l nd e onia, A. r s s e
ef c n e to l
W h ls l Se vc sUS l c wa j i e , n Cou usNewo ksUSA, n . n Teeo ia
oe ae r ie A, n . s o n d a d lmb
t r
I c a d lfn c
l tnzt n l h ls l Se c sUSA,nc wees v rd. ( e DE- 4( 4 20 29 ; 8 , 5
ne ai a W o e ae ni e
o
l . r e ee 7 S e 7 1 - 5 ) DE- 0 8
( 41 20530) DE- (1 205 ) DE- (4; 63 4- 31; 71 1 60350).
1
4
Be us t s pae sa c am sofi rngeme a eati s i e ch c e, he
ca e he ame tnt nd l i
nfi
nt r
s ue n a as t y
weea1 s ine t t u d rine i o d rt p o t j dca efce ya dr d c c ss
r l a sg d o he n e sg d n r e o r moe u iil fiinc n e u e o t.
W iht pa tes c e ,heca e ha snc bee c oldae f prti pur e .('e
t he ri ' ons ntt s s ve i e n ons i td or eral poss ke
s
DE- ( 4- 29) DE- ( 476 1 205 ; 86 1 20530) DE- ( 4; 65 1 20531;DE- (4) 75 1 60350).
1
FN C a Ci na m o d t t a f ron A prl 1 a A pr l25,201 r s ctvel
nd e
ve o r ns e
i 5 nd
i
4, e pe i y.
Cora a Tel bsOpsm o dt ta f ron J 20, 4.
int nd la
ve o r ns e
une 201
Col b Ne wor USA,l and Telf caI e na i W hol a eSe vce USA,
um us t ks
nc.
e oni nt r tonal
es l r i s
I we e s r d bec us t y a e Fl i ba e c t e sofCor a and Ci a of e no
nc. r eve e
a e he r orda- s d us om r
i nt
ena nd f r
m e ni f c rbu i t t pa e diput Ca l sca e a i tt a esa d pe ng
a ng ul onti ton o he t nt s e. pela' s s ga ns hem r t ye ndi
t r ol i oft a
he es uton he bove-t e a tons
syl d c i .
B.The Partes
i
1 Pl i ifCa l
. ant pel
f
a
Ca l i a D e aw a e c or i w ih a pr nc pa pl c ofbus ne s i Sa J e
pela s
l r op aton t
i i l ae
i s n n os ,
Calf ni Ca la des gne de ope pr
ior a. pe l
i d, vel d, oduc d, nd s d s ic ng de c f optc l
e a ol w t hi
vi es or i a
ta m ison newor ,i l ng t W SS,untli s d ism a a t i ope a i t ye r
r ns s i
t ks nc udi he
i t ol t nuf c urng r tons wo a s
a a c as doi busnes .Thus Ca l i c r nty a nonpr c i ng e iy. pe l has
go nd e ed ng i s
, pela s ure l
a tci ntt Ca la
no ofi so o r tonsi Fl i a iss ni m a ge e a l d couns i t smater
fce r pe a i n orda, nd t e or na m nt nd ea
el n hi
t
a lr i i t N orhe D i ti tofCalf ni .
l esde n he
t m src
ior a
2 Dee a Cic Ca eNo 1 - 0 2
. f nd nt s o, s . 4 2 5 9
Ci co i a Ca ior a c or ton w ih is prnci lpl ce ofbus nes i San J e,
s s
lf ni om a i
t t i pa a
i sn
os
Calf ni Fory-i pe c ntofisU. e oye wor i ise g ofi si t Norhe n
ior a. t fve r e
t S. mpl es k n t i ht fce n he t r
Ditit fCaio na ( a eDe lg 1 - ( 4 2 5 9 )! 7 9)Cic h st o fc si
src o l r i. Ha s c. DE- 9 4 1 - 0 2 ) ! , . s o a wo fie n
f
Fl i ,bu net rofieha anyi ve twiht ac us dpr ucs.1 ! 11 3.The
orda t ihe fc s nvol men t he c e od t (d. ! -1 )
mao iyo t eCic e o e sivov di d v lpn a d makei gt ea c e p o u t
j rt f h s o mply e n le n e eo ig n r tn h c us d r d cs
wo ki Cic ' S nJ s o fc s (o ns nDe l ( 1 - ( 4 2 29 ) !5 1 ,1 .
r n s o s a o e fie . J h o c. DE- 9 1 1 - 05 ) ! , 2 4)
Cic pur s st W SS de c i or a e i o isa c ed pr t fom t e
s o cha e he
vies nc por t d nt t c us
oduc s r hr e
s p les J Unih s Co p rto (tDSU' F ns rCo r to (t n s r) a d Oca o
u pir: DS p a e r o ain $
J
' i ia mo ai n $ ia ', n lr
)
Fi '
I . t 1r ' (d ! 8 0)Be a s Cic d e no ma fcu et W S d vie ,t s
nc (d ao'.1 ! -1 . c u e s o o s t nu a tr he S e c s iha
Oc )
lm ied kno l
i t
w edge oft de i a de l pm e oft s ic The w ines esa doc e s
he s gn nd ve o nt he w t h.
t s nd um nt
fom t W SS s ppler a e i po t ntt Ci c sdef ns s ofnon-nf i m e a i i t
r he
u i s r m r a o s o'
e e
i r nge nt nd nvaldiy.
De ndantCina,Ca eNo.1 20530
fe
e
s
4Ci na i a Del w a e c por ton w ih isprnc palpl c ofbus ne s i Hanove ,
e s
a r or a i
t t i i
ae
i s n
r
M a ylnd.W hie Cina doe ha t ree e oyee i Dor l Fl i no oft m ha a
r a
l e
s ve hit n mpl s n
a , orda, ne he
ve ny
-
4-
iv le n wihted sg o d v lp n o tea c s dp o u t.Roh n ti De l (
n ov me t t h e in r e eo me t f h c u e r d cs ( t e sen c. DE4 - 4( 420 3 ) ! 1 . M o e v r Cin ' lr e t s.b s dr sa c a d v l p n
3 2 1 - 5 0 ) 1) r o e, e as a g s U. - a e e e rh nd e eo me t
fclt i l ae i Sa J e Calf a (d.!8.
a iiy s oc td n n os , iomi. 1
)
Li Cico,Cina pur has t W SS de ce i
ke s
e
c es he
vi s ncom or t i o isa us d pr t
aed nt t cc e oduc s
fo J U, i ia, n Ocao.I !4. Be a s Cinad e n t n f cu eteW SS
r m DS F ns r a d lr (d ) c u e e o s o ma u a tr h
de ce ,i, oo,ha lm ied knowl dgeoft desg a dev opm e oft s t h.
vi s t t
si t
e
he i n nd el
nt he wic
Ac or ng y,wine s sa docu e sfom t W SS s ir a e i ra t Ci na'
c di l
t s e nd
m nt r he
upple s r mpo tnt o e s
def ns ofnon-nfi m e and i i t
e es
i r nge nt
nvaldiy.
4 Dee a tFNC, s No 1 - 0 31
. f nd n
Ca e . 4 2 5
FN C i aCalf ni c por ton wih isprncpalpl c ofbusne si Riha ds n,
s
ior a or a i
t t i i
ae
i s n c r o
Te . FN C hasno ofi esi Fl rdabutdoe l s onec cl8f om a out i pa t i
xas
n s de ry n
fc n o i
s ea e
ubi e r
J c onvil,Fl i ( ouDec.( 27( 4a ks le orda. Gal
l DE- 1 20531)! 1 5.FNC ha aplc of
) ! 3-1 )
s ae
busne si Sunnyv e,Calf r a whih e oysr ughl 86 peo e i l ng e ne r
i s n
al
io ni, c mpl o y
pl, ncudi ngi e s
iv v di ted sg d v lp n , n tsi go tea c e pr d cs (d. 9.
n ole n h e in, e eo me ta d e tn f h c us d o u t.1 ! )
Li Cic a Ci na,FNC pur has t W SS de c i or a e i o isac us d
ke s o nd e
c es he
vies nc por t d nt t c e
p o u t fo J
r d cs r m DSU, n s r a dOca o (d ! 5 )Be a s FNC do sno ma u a t r te
Fiia , n lr .1 . ! -7. c u e
e t n fcu e h
W SS de c s i,t ha lmie knowldgeoft desgn,de opm e , f ton oft
vie , t oo, s i t d
e
he i
vel
nt and unc i
he
s t Thewine s a doc
wich.
t s es nd ument fo t W SS s ir a ei
s r m he
upple s r mpora t FNC' d e e
tnt o
S efns s
ofnon-nfi m e and i i t
i rnge nt
nvaldiy.
J De ndant Tel 0psandCorant Ca eNo.1 60350
. fe
s labs
i , s
4Te lbsOpsi a Delwa e c por ton wih isprnci pl eofbusne si Na vle
la
s
a r or a i
t t i pal ac
i s n per il,
Ilnoi.TelbsOpshasac port ofiei Sa aClr Caio ni ( angDec.g 63li s la
or ae fc n nt aa, lfr a. W
l DE- 3
8
The e o who oc e t tc ce,howeve ,i no i ve i t desg
mpl yee
cupis ha ubi l
r s t nvol d n he i n,
d l e t m an a t e, a l i oft a us d pr
eve opm n , uf c ur or na ys s he cc e oduc .
t
( 4 6 3 0 1! 9 0)W h l Telb Op p e i u l la e t o fc si Flrd ,t sno
1 - 0 5 ) ! -1 . ie la s s rv o sy e s d wo fie n oi a iha t
dones snce2011 (d. 1 )
oi
.1 ! 5.
Cora i aDe a r co po ai wih isprnc pa plc ofbusnes i Brdge tr
int s
l wa e r r ton t t i i l a e
i s n i wae ,
Ne J s Cora ha noofiesi Fl i o Caior abutdoesbusnes i b h.Be on
w erey. int s
fc n orda r lf ni
i s n ot ( ns
De l ( 6 - ( 4 6 3 0 1! 9 1 .
c .DE- 3 4 1 - 0 5 ) ! , 1)
Si ia t t ot rDe enda s TelabsOpsa Cora do notm a a ur t W SS
m lr o he he f nt, l
nd
int
nuf ct e he
de c t tar i r aed i ot i ac us de c s Tela Opspur has st W SS
vies ha e nco por t nt her c ed vi e . lbs
c e he
de ce i us si t a us d pr t fom Fi s r Ocar a Oplnk Cor a i
vi s t e n he cc e oduc s r
nia , l o, nd i
por ton
(k i1 '.( a De .!6. Si lry,Cora pucha e t W SS de ce t tae
ç rk' W ng cl ) mial
Op1 )
int r s s he
vi s ha r
i r ae i oisac e pr ct fom J
ncopor td nt t cusd odu s r DSU a Fi s r ( ns De . 6. Be aus
nd nia .Be on cl! ) c e
TelabsOpsand Cora do notm a a ur t W SS devies t y ha lm ie knowldge of
l
int
nuf ct e he
c ,he ve i t d
e
t de i a de opm e oft s th.Thewine s sfo t W SS m anu acur r a e
he sgn nd vel
nt he wic
t s e r m he
f t es r
i
mpora t Tel bsOpsa Cora ' de e esofnon-nfi eme a i ldiy.
tnt o la
nd i nts f ns
i rng nt nd nva i t
6 WSS Su i sJDSV Fi s ,Ocar and Oplnk
.
ppler
niar l o,
i
J SU des g ,de l ,a s i s m a oft W SS de ce t ta e i or a e
D
i ns ve ops nd upple
ny he
vi s ha r nc por t d
i o t a cus pr t . ( t r De l ( 6 - ( 4 6 3 0 )!5) Alhoug isW SS
nt he c ed oduc s Reo t c. DE- 3 5 1 - 0 5 ) .9 t h t
de ce a emanuf c u e out i t Unied St es J
vi s r
a t r d sde he t at , DSU i hea
s dqua tr i t M ipia ,
re ed n he l t s
Caio na (d !2,1 . IsCo nc to a d Co r il tc lP o u t (I
lf r i.1 .
1) t mmu iains n mme ca Opia r d cs t
CCOP'
'
)
Busnes Seg e i r s nsbl f t de i n, ve o nt manuf c ur ,m a ke i a s l
i s m nt s e po i e or he s g de l pme ,
a t e r tng, nd ae
ofW SSde c s (d. 7.W hiet mao iyoft i ta desgna de l ntwas
vie . 1 ! ) l he j rt he niil i nd veopme
9
Al Def nt s r t s m eW SS s i s wiht exc pton ofCora who a s
1 enda s ha e he a
uppler , t he e i
int
lo
us O plnk. n s
es i I uppor oft i m o i t t a f r D e enda st l d dec ar tonsby c r a n
t he r tons o r ns e , f
nt s e
l ai
e ti
e oye soft es ir t taee s talyt s mei ea hca e.Compar ,eg. Ret t
mpl e hes upples ha r seni l he a n c s (
e . , or
Dec. t ( 1 5( 4lwih DE- 9- 1 20529). Acc di y,t Cour wilr e t t de a ai fldi
1) or ngl he
t l efr o he clrtons ie n
Ca e No.1 60350.
s
4-
6-
pe f m e i Ota ,Ca
ror d n twa nada J
, DSU' CCOP Busnes Se nti now ba e i t Norhe n
S
i s gme s
s d n he t r
DititofCaior a.1 !7,1 )J
src
lf ni (d.
0. DSU ha na t eee oyee whoovereeW SSde i
s med hr mpl s
s
sgn
a de l
nd veopmen,a1ofwhom r i i t Norhen DititofCaiomi ( ei ;M umm
t 1
esde n he t r src
lf a.Se t
f
De l (7 6 - (4 6 35 ( Ki De l(7 6 - ( 4 6 3 0 1)
c.1E- 36 1 - 0 01; m c. 1E- 3 7 1 - 0 5 ).
Fi s r O c ar a O plnk a s de i de l a s y s e oft W SS devi es
ni a , l o, nd
i l o s gn, ve op, nd uppl om
he
c
t ta e i op or t d i o t ac us d pr
ha r nc
a e nt he c e oduct .Fi s ri hea
s ni a s dquare ed i Sunnyva e
tr n
l,
Caior a;Oclr i Sa J e,Caior a; Oplnk i Fr mont Caiomi ( a De .
lf ni
ao n n os lf ni and i n e , lf a. W ng cl
( E- 3 3( 4 6 3 0)! 6 .Th rc r c n anslmie e ie er g r i t ed sg
1 6 - 1 - 0 5 ) ! -7) e e o d o ti i td vd nc e adng h e in,
7
de o e ,a m a a t i a tvii oft s W SS s i r .
vel pm nt nd nuf c ur ng c i tes he e
upple s
I . Le St r
I
gal anda dfor# 1404() Tr fe s
a ans r
S 'rt ec n ne c o p risa win se ,nt eitr s of u tc , dsrc c u t
t o h o ve in e f a t nd te s s i h n ee t j sie a itit o r
F
e
ma ta f a c vi a ton t a ot rdititordi son wher i mi htha be n br
y r nser ny i l c i o ny he src
vii
et g
ve e ought
ort a dititordi sont whihalpa te ha c e e '28U. C.j1 a .The
o ny src
vii o c l ris ve ons ntd.
'
S.
404()
pur e oft a f runde t s s c i i t avoi unne s ar i
pos
r ns e
r hi e ton s o
d
ce s y nconve e e t t ltga s
ni nc o he ii nt ,
wine s s and t publc,a t c e ve tm e, r a m one Def nda sm ovi f
t se,
he
i nd o ons r i ene gy, nd
y. e nt
ng or
ta f rbe rt bur n ofpr ng t tt pl i i f sc c off um çi c e r y o w e ghe
r ns e a he de
ovi ha he a ntf' hoi e or çs l a l ut i d
byot rc i r tons'Ho lv Tanne ,650F. 61 61 (t Ci.1 1.
he onsde ai . wel .
'
r
2d 0, 6 5h r 98 )
Ac t
our cons de s t o quesi t de e ne whe herta f r i ve i a opra e.
i r w
tons o t nni
t r ns e r ng nue s ppr i t
Fi s ,i t ta f e f um o i w hi t a ton m i htha be n br
r t s he r ns er e or
ne n
ch he c i
g
ve e ought Se ond,upon
? c
baa ngt prvaea publcf t s i tanse j tfe Mas v SmihKlne Bee ham
lnci he i t nd i acor,s r f r usiid? on . t i
c
ClnialLabs, 1 F.Supp. 1
ic
. 46
2d 355,1 ( D.Fl 201l . fcor c i r i
359 S. a. ) The a t s onsdeed n
a l ng t s c ques i i ude:
na yzi he e ond
ton ncl
( )t ec n ne eo t wi se ; 2 t elc to o r lva td c me t a d
1 h o ve inc f he t s s ( ) h o ain f ee n o u ns n
ne
t rltvee eofac es t s c sofpr ;( t c ninc oft pa tes
he eai as
c s o oure
oof 3) he onve e e he ri ;
( t l usofo rtvefcs ( t a lbiiy ofpr es t compelt
4) he oc
peai a t; 5) he vaia lt
oc s o
he
at nc ofunwilngwine s '( t rltveme nsoft pari ;() a
tenda e
li t ses 6) he eai
,
a
he tes 7
fr m' f la iy wih t gove ng lw;( t wegh a cor d a
o u s amiirt t he mi a 8) he i t c de
pli ifsc c off um;a ( ti e fce ya t i eessof usie
antf' hoie or
nd 9) ral fiinc nd he ntr t j tc ,
ba edon t t aiyoft cr ums a e
s
he ot lt
he ic t nc s.
WiLAN US l .v Appl I .No.1 24318, 3W L 13
A, nc . e nc,
2201
43535,a * ( D.Fl Apr 2,
t 2 S. a. .
201 )( i M anue v Conv gy Cor ,430 F. 11 11 n. ( 1h Ci.2005).
3 quotng
l.
er s p.
3d 32, 35 1 1 t r
)
A.W he he t C l m sM i H a Bee Br
t r he ai
ght ve
n oughti t N or he n D i t i tofC alf a
n he
t r
src
iorni
Ther i no di put t tt sac i c d ha bee br
es
s e ha hi ton oul ve n oughti t N or he n D i ti tof
n he
t r src
Calf ni M or ve ,a lD e e nt ha c e ed t s tt r
ior a. eo r 1 f nda s ve ons nt o ui he e.
B. he he T r f t t Nor he n D i t i ofC alf ni i M ore C onveni ntt A l
W t r ans er o he
t r
s r ct
ior a s
e o I
Partesand W i nes
i
t ses
1 Co e e eo Wi s e
. nv ninc f t s s
ne
The c
onve e e oft w ine s i pr bl t sngl m os i por a f t r i a
ni nc
he t s es s oba y he i e
t m t nt ac o n
t a f a l i . di ti tcour s d a s s t r e
r ns er na ys s A sr c
t houl s e s he el vanc a m a e i lt oft i or a i
e nd t r a iy he nf m ton
ea h w ines m ay pr de buta de e
c t s
ovi ,
f ndantne nots ciy exa ty w ha t tm ony e h
ed
pe f
cl
t es i
ac
w ine sm i htof e orot r s i ntf Ske w ine s . I r G e nt ch I . 566 F.
t s g
fr
he wi e de iy t y t s es ' n e ne e , nc ,
'
3d
1 ,1 44( Ci. )
338 343- Fed. r 2009 .
Dee
f ndan sha nam e po e i lw ine s s w ih know l
t ve
d t nta t s e t
edge oft W SS de c s oft
he
vi e
he
a c e pr
c us d oduc sa ha pr de e a tonsoft r l ntt tm ony.
t nd ve ovi d xpl na i
he e eva es i
The na e J SU
m d D
e pl sr pons bl f t de i de opm ent a t tng oft W SS de ce r s de i
m oyee es
i e or he s gn, vel
, nd esi
he
vi s e i n
t N o t r D it i tofCalf i a do t i nt s a i talpr e utng a t neysoft
he r he n s rc
iom a, s he nve or nd nii os c i tor
he
pa e s i s t The ot rW SS s i sa e a s hea
t nt - n- ui.
he
uppler r l o dqua t r w ihi t N orhe n Di t i tof
r e ed t n he
t r sr c
Calf ni a s a e lkel t ha w ines e w ih r e ti o m a i t r A c di y,
ior a nd o r i y o ve t s s t el van nf r ton he e. cor ngl
-
8-
De e d n sa s r t mao iyo poe ta wi e sswi r lva t n wld eo t W S
fn a t s ethe j rt f tn il t se t ee n k o e g f he S
n
h
de ce a el aed i t Norhe n Diti tofCalf ni
vi s r oc t n he
t r src
ior a.
I conta t none oft pa te ha i ntfe any w ines esi Fl r da w ih r l nt
n
rs,
he ri s ve de ii d
t s n oi
t e eva
i onua i Be us m any pot ntalwines e a
nf
ton. ca e
e i
t s s ppea t be l t i t N orhe D i ti tof
ro
oca ed n he
t m sr c
Ca i o i bu none i Fl i , hi f c ors r y f vor t a f r
lf m a t
n orda t s a t t ongl a s r ns e .
Ea eo c s t So r e o o f
s fAc es o u c s fpr o
I pa e i rnge e ca e ,t bul oft r l va e denc us l comesfom t
n t nt nfi m nt s s he k he e e nt vi e ualy
r he
a c e i rnge .I r Ge nt c 566F. a 1
c us d nfi r n e ne e h,
3d t 345. r t r e tdoctne a y e de e
He e, he elvan
u nt r vi nc
i s a t r d i dif r ntl a i whe e D e e nt a e he dqua t r d,butnone i l ca ed i
s c te e n f e e oc tons
r f nda s r a
re e
so t n
t Sou he n Diti ofFl i On t ot ha m a De e nt ha ofi si t
he t r srct
orda. he her nd, ny f nda s ve fce n he
Norhe n Diti ofCalf ni,a t W SS s ir ar he
t r srct
ior a nd he
upple s e adqua tr d t r
re e he e.
H owe r a Ca l s
ve , s pela ugges s docu e pr
t,
m nt oduc i i lke y t be c
ton s i l o
onduc e
td
el c r ni aly,a t r i no i ca i t tt sca e w ilr qui ephys c e de t tw oul
e t o c l nd he e s ndi ton ha hi s l e r
i al vi nce ha
d
be cu be s e t ta por . e W iLAN USA,201 W L 1
m r om o r ns t Se
3
343535,a *3.A ss h, he a e s
t
uc t cc s -
t evi nc f c ori ne r l
o- de e a t s uta .
TheConv ni o heParis
e ence ft
te
W he e a ta f r s m pl s fst i onve e e f om one pa y t a he ,a pl i if s
r r ns e i y hi t he nc
ni nc r
rt o not r
a ntf
c ceoff um s d r
hoi
or houl emai undit be Ca l sc c off nz i t Sout
n
sur d. pela' hoie o m n he
hem Ditit
src
ofFl i i c t st ti i c
orda ndia e ha t s onve e f i.Howe r ta f rt t Norhe n Dititof
ni nt or t
ve , r ns e o he
t r src
Ca ior a w ilnoti onve e e Ca la, is c por t he dqua t r a couns la e l at d
lf ni l
nc
ni nc
pe l as t or a e a
r e s nd
e r oc e
t e.
her
De e nt , t ot r ha a la
f nda s on he he nd, 1 ppea t be i ve enc d by t Sout r Di t i t
ro
ncon ni e
he
he n s rc
ofFl i be us none ha of i e wihi t s a e r a i t t ac ed pr
orda ca e
ve f c s t n he t t el tng o he cus
oduc s. I
t n
c r s , hie D e e
ont a t w l f ndant m a nota lbe hea
s y
l
dqua t r d i Ca ior a,m a ha ofi es
r e e n lf ni
ny ve t c
-
9-
l a e i t Norhe n Diti tofCaior a a alha cons nt t ve t r
oc t d n he t r src
lf ni , nd l ve
e ed o nue he e.
Ac r ngl t c
co di y, he onve e - -he- ri s f c orw e ghs i f vorofta f r
ni nce of t pa te a t
i n a
r ns e .
4 Lo u o
. c s fope aieFa t
r tv c
The c nt rofgr viy f a pa e i rnge entca e i ge a l w he e t ac us d
e e
a t or t nt nf i m
s s ner ly
r he c e
p o u twa d sg da dd v lp d M oo oaMo lt I c v Mir s? Cop.8 4F. u p.
r d c s e ine n e eo e . tr l bi y n . . c o o r , 0 S p
i
2d 1 1 ( D. a.2011 . pela' pla ngsandi rnge ntc e i e
271, 276 S. Fl
) Ca l s e di
nfi me ontntons mphaie
sz
t W SS,a c po n oft ROA D M , a ng i cl art tt de i and de l e of
he
om ne t he
m ki t e ha he s gn
ve opm nt
W SS de c sa t rus i t a us d ROADM Swilbec nta o r tve f c si t sc e.
vi e nd hei e n he cc e
l
e r l pe a i a t n hi as
(e ,eg.Se o dAm. mp .DE- 2( 4 2 3 ) a 5!2 ; ei I fi g me t
S e . , cn
Co l ( 8 1 - 05 0) t 3 Prlm.n rn e n
Co tnins( 2 ( 4 2 2 ) a 2)W h l t eW SSd v c sween tf lyd sg e a d
n e to DE- 5 1 - 05 9 1 t . ie h
e ie r o u l e in d n
deve ope i t N orhe n D it i tofCa ior a, he J SU hea
l d n he
t r s rc
lf ni t D
dqum e s CCO P bus ne s
r,
i s
s gment a engi e scure l r s nsbl f t desg a de l e oft de c a e
e
, nd
ne r
r nty e po i e or he in nd veopm nt he vies r
l a e t r I c r t net rt de i nort de opm e oft W SS de c t
oc t d he e. n ontas, ihe he sgn
he vel
nt he
vi es ook
pl c i Fl r da.
ae n oi
Ca l a gue t tDef nda s s y ROA D M S f optca net o ksdepl
pela r s ha
e nt uppl
or i l w r
oyed i
n
Fl i How e r D e e nt of e t ac us d pr ct f s l na i i w hi doe not
orda.
ve , f nda s f r he c e odu s or a e tonw de, ch s
g ve rs t a s t ntali e e ti a s c fc venue. I r A c rAm e i a Cor ,626 F.
i i e o ubs a i nt r s n ny pe ii
See n e e
rc
p.
3d
1 2,1 6( Ci. 0 .
25 25 Fed. r 201 )
A c or ngl t l us ofope a i f c i i t N orhe n Di t i tofCa ior a, t
c di y, he oc
r tve a t s n he
t r sr c
lf ni no
Fl i Thi f orf s tans er
or da. s act avor r f .
TheAv l lt o oc s t Co lt Ate
aiabii fpr e s o mpe he tndanceo Unwilng Wine s s
y
f
li
t se
Cour sge r l t a f rca e when i pora w ines e c d be s
t ne aly r ns e s s
m t nt t s s oul
ubpoe d i t
nae n he
t a f r e f u b noti t o i na f um .W iLAN USA,201 W L 1
r ns e e or m ut
n he r gi l or
3
343535,a *4.M any
t
oft potnta wines e a et r pa t wines e i Caiom i whos a t nc t
he e il t s s r hid ry t s s n lf a,
e tenda e he
-
1 0
N orhe n Di t i tof Ca i om i ca c pe w ih isRul 45 s
t r s rc
lf a n om l t t
e
ubpoe power The Sout r
na
.
he n
Di t i tofFl i how e r c m otenf r e co pul or pr s overt e pot ntalw ines e
sr c
orda,
ve , ar
o c m s y oce s
hes
e i
t ss
be a enoner sdei Fl i Alhough Ca l a guest tde ii oft s wines es
c us
e i n orda. t
pela r
ha postons he e t s
c d beus d a ti ,vi otpe de ii a epoors tt e f lvewines es es c a l
oul
e t ral de a d postons r
ubsiut s or i
t s , pe i ly
i c mplxp tn c s swh r tej r r ma ha ef lo u q e to atrr drc
n o e ae t a e e e h u o s y v o lw-p u sins fe e ie t
e m i ton.Acc di y, hi f c orweghsi f
xa nai
or ngl t s a t
i n avorofta f .
r nser
6 TheReatv M e o hePa te
.
l ie ans ft ris
Ca la spr nc pa a g e i t ti i a s a lc pa t nee t pr e tis
pe l ' i i l r um nt s ha t s m l om ny hat ds o ot c t
pa e si a f um t ti f t rt n t N orher D it i tofCalf ni .H o eve ,Ca l i
t nt n or ha s as e ha he
t n s rc
ior a w r pela s
onl s albe a ei de dedt s l isas e s a t dif r ncei tme f pr e utng pa e
y m l c us t ci o el t s t, nd he fe e
n i or os c i
t nt
c s sbe w e n t t o di t i t i a m os sx m ont ,w hi h ca ha dl be cons de e
a e t e he w
sr c s s t
ti
hs
c n r y
i rd
p o e a i A cc di y, hi f c ori a m os ne r l
r bl m tc. or ngl t s a t s t
t ut a .
7 , Forum ' F am ii t wih t Gover ng Law
. 4
s
lariy t he
ni
Bot di t i t ar f m ii rw ih f de alpa e l w .Thi f t i ne r .
h s rc s e a la t e r
t nt a
s ac or s utal
8 Pl i f Choc o r m
. antfs ie fFo u
Ge r ly, hepl ntf c ceoff m i g ve consde a ede e e e.
ne al t ai ifs hoi
onl s i n
i r bl f r nc Robi o v
ns n .
Gir r o d BilP. , 4F.d2 3 2 0( lh Ci.1 9 )( litf' c o c o f r m s o l
a ma c r l C.7 3 5 , 6 1 t r 9 6 p an ifs h ie f o u h u d
,
no bedit bedunls ii cla l out ihe byot c i r tons.Ho ve ,onl
t sur
e s t s e ry weg d
her onsde ai ) we r y
mi ma defrncei rquie whee()apl ntf ha c e afnz t ti notishome
ni l ee s e r d r a ai if s hos n o m ha s t
fr m o ( t ope ai fcsundel ngt ca eofa tondi notoc urwihi t f u
o u r b) he r tve a t
ryi he us
ci d
c t n he orm
t pl ntf ha c en.Ce l ar i on Te hs t Te l c m . L. v Alt lCor ,508 F.Supp.
he ai i f s hos
lul v si
c . t le om , P. . le
p.
2d 11 1 9( D.Fl.2007) WiLAN USA,201 W L 1
86, 88 S. a
; 3
343535,a #5.
t
Ca la i a D e a a e cor a i wih ispr nc pa pl c ofbus nes i Sa J e
pe l s
lw r
por ton t t i i l a e
i s n n os ,
Caio i.Iss ni m a ge e a l d c
lf m a t e or na m nt nd ea ouns a 1r i i t N orhe n Dititof
el 1 esde n he t r src
Caio i wih no of e orope a i l t i Fl i .Aspr ousy dicus ed, hel
lf m a t
ûc s
r tons ocaed n orda
evi l s s t ocus
ofoper tvef c i i t N o t r Diti tofCalf r a. a et Sout r Dititof
ai a t s n he rhe n src
io ni Bec us he
he n src
Fl i i net rCa l shom ef u no t l usofope atve f c ,Ca l sc cei
orda s ihe pela'
or m r he oc
r i a t pela' hoi s
e il d t m i m a de e e ,a t sf c orw e ghsonl w ea y a i tt a f r
ntte o ni l f r nce nd hi a t
i
y
kl ga ns r ns e .
# T il m ce ya t I e e t o sie
. ra E inc nd he ntr ss flu tc
The Cour mus as tkei o c i r ton t publc-ntr s c i a i of
t t lo a nt onsde a i he
i i e e t onsder tons
s se citg iya df in s , u ha j dca efce ya dt ef r m sae sc l cint
y tmi n e rt n ar e s s c s u iil fiinc n h o u tt' ome to o
t diput Se M ot ol M obii 80 F.
he s e. e or a
lt 4 Supp.2d a 1
y,
t 278.
The N orher D i ti ofCa ior a' l a i e es i g ea e t n t Sout z D i ti
t n s rct
lf ni s oc l nt r t s r t r ha he
he . s rct
n
o Flrd si ee tb c u etemao i o t epa t sa dt idp risha eete
f o ia' ntr s e a s h j rt f h ri n hr a te v i r
y
e
h
h a q a tr o mao o fc slc tdwihnt eNo te nDitito Caio aa da1 o uc
e d u res r j r fie o ae t i h rh r src f lf mi n 1c nd t
busnes t r .I c r s ,asdi c s d a ve none oft pa tesha s gnii a c a t
i s he e n ont a t
s us e bo ,
he r i
ve i tc nt ont c s
wih t Sout r DititofFl rdaa alwines e r sde outi ofFl i
t he
he n src
o i nd l t s s e i
sde
orda.
Asfr u iil fiin y te ec s sha eb e cms ld tdf rp era c s
o j dca e fce c ,h s a e v e n c o iae o r til a e
ma ge e b a et y i vet s mepa e sa s tntaly sm ia is sof
na m nt ec us he nvol he a
t nt nd ubsa i l i l r s ue
i rnge e ,a t y s d r i c olda e i et rf u .W hie Ca lam a be
nfi m nt nd he houl ema n ons i t d n ihe or m
l pe l y
c r c i as e tngt tt Sout r DititofFl i sdoc ti mi maly ls co se
ore t n s ri ha he
he n src
orda'
ke s ni l e s nge td,
t s c i r i i out ghe by t s di ti ' l k ofc
hi ons de aton s wei d
hi s rcts ac
onne ton t t di pu e. e I r
c i o he s t Se n e
Gene ec ,I .566F. a 1 47(i t tilma beac i rtoni t ta franayss
nt h nc,
3d t 3 tme o ra y
onsdeai n he rnse l i,
buts dnotout ghs vealot rlva f t spoi i t ot rwa . co di y,
houl
wei e r her ee nt acor ntng he he y) Ac r ngl on
b ln e t itrsso -usief co fvo sta se .
aa c ,he n eet- fj tc a tr a r rn fr
-
12 -
1
11. Concl on
usi
W he a 1oft r l va f c or ar c i r d,t Cour fndst tDe e nt have
n 1 he e e nt a t s e onsde e he
t i ha f nda s
m e t rbur n ofs i t tt a f roft s f ca e t t N or he n D i t i tof
t hei de
how ng ha r ns e
he e our s s o he
t r s rc
Ca iom i i a opr a e,pm i ul ry gi n t lm ie de er nc owed Ca l ' choi ofa
lf a s ppr i t
c a l ve he i t d f e e
pela s
ce
ve w hi h i neihe isr i nc no t l
nue c s t r t esde e r he ocus ofope a i f c .Acc di y,i i
r tve a t
or ngl t s
ORD ERED t t
ha
l Ca la Phot c ,l v.Ci c Sys ,l ,Cas N o.1 20529:
n pe l
oni s nc.
so
. nc. e
4-
Cico' M otont Tr nserVenue( 191i GRANTED.
s s i o a f
DE- s
I Ca la Pho oni s I v.Ci Cor ,e a . Ca eN o.1 20530:
n pe l
t c , nc.
ena p. t 1, s
4-
Cin ' M oint Trnse Ve ue( 4 1i GRANTED.
e as to o a fr n DE- 3 s
I Ca laPh t nc ,n . . u is Newo k Co ' s Ca eNo 1 20 31
n pel oo is lc v F jtu t r mmc n , s . 4- 5 :
a. FNC' M otont Tr f Ve g 25 i GRANTED.
S i o anser nue DE- 1 s
4)
I Ca laPhoonis l v.Tela ,nc.e a1,Cas No.1 60350:
n pel t c ,nc.
lbs l , t . e
4-
a Telb Op a dCo in ' M oin t Trnse Ve u ( 6 ji
. l s s n ra ts t o a f r n e DE- 3 s
a
o
GRAN TED .
TheClr s lTRANSFER t f a
e k hal
he our bove syld aci t t Unie Stt s
- t e tons o he t d ae
D i ti tCour f t N orhe n D it i tofCalf i The notc oft a f r
sr c
t or he
t r s rc
iom a.
i e r ns e
s l not t tt ca e ha bee cons i t d f pr r a pur e
ha l e ha he s s ve n
olda e or eti l pos s.
- a f uy 2 4.
DONE a dORDEM D i M imiFl i ,t s / 5X dyo J l, 01
n
n a , orda hi
-
*
.
z
PA TRI A A . TZ
CI
SEI
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J DG E
CT U
c
c:
Al Couns ofRec d
l
el
or
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?