Jackson et al v. U.S. Bank, N.A. et al
Filing
46
ORDER denying 25 Motion to Dismiss; denying 20 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim; denying 20 Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction; denying 22 Motion for Hearing. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 8/20/2014. (bnt) Modified signature date on 8/22/2014 (asl).
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI CO U RT FO R TH E
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i m iDi s on
a
vi i
C as N um be 1 21
e
r: 4- 252- l - O R EN O
C VM
PHI P J
LI ACKSON a STEPHEN LARGESS,
nd
o be f of t m s l s a ot r sm ia l
n hal
he e ve nd he s i l ry
st t
iua ed,
Pl n @j
ait '
,
U . BAN K , N . . A SSUR AN T, I C . a
S.
A,
N
nd
A M ER I A N SECU R I Y I SU RA N CE
C
T
N
COM PAN Y,
Dee d ns
f n a t.
O R DER D ENY IN G DE FEND A NT S'M O TIO N S TO D ISM ISS
Thi matrc me b f r t e Co r u n j itr ve o Dee d n U. Ba , A.
s te o s eo e h u t po o n e iw f fn a t S. nk N. '
S
M oto t Dimis ( E.No.20) fl on June 23.201 a Dee ntAme ia Se urt
in o s s D.
, ied
4, nd fnda
rc n c iy
l urnc Compa sM oi t Dimis( E.25) fld on June23.2014.Fort f e ng
ns a e
ny' ton o s s D.
, ie
he orgoi
r s ,t Co tD EN I bo h D e e nt 'M otons t D i m i s Pl ntf s pl d f c ua c t nt
ea ons he ur
ES t
f nda s
i o s s . ai if ea a t l on e
t t a l s t Cour t dr w t r s
ha low he
t o a he ea onabl i e e
e nf r nce t t D e e nt m a be la e f t
ha
f nda s y
i bl or he
m ico uctaleg s t ca e s l no be di m i s d a t ss ag i t ltga i
s nd
l ed, o he s ha l t
s s e t hi t e n he ii ton.
Fac ualBa kg ound
t
c r
Dee ntAmeia Se urt l urnc Co ny(W SI 'pr desmoniorngs r i s
fnda
rc n c iy ns a e mpa $ C') ovi
t i e vce
a i s s i ur e polc e c rng bor ow e s'pr r i whe bonow e s f i t pr de pr
nd s ue ns anc
i i s ove i
r r ope tes
n
r a l o ovi
oof
ofa c pt bl i ur nc a r uie by t i m orga .
c e a e ns a e s eq r d
he r
t ges Thes m oniorng s r i s a polc esa e
e
t i e v ce nd i i r
pr de pur ua t c r t w ih m orga l nde sa s r c r , nc udi D e e ntU . Ba
ovi d s nt o ontac s t
t ge e r nd e vi e s i l ng f nda
S. nk,
N. CI S. nk') Pli if tl t sca sa tonCompl ntag ns Dee nt wihr pe tt
A. U. Ba '. antfs ied hi ls ci
ai ai t fnda s t es c o
aha r lnderplce i urnce($ ')pr r i Aprl201 I rc ye r,s h c ant
zad e - a d ns a k ' ogam n i 4.n e ent a s uc ompli s
LPI
ha be
ve comecomm on a i t sDiti t Se r ls h c eshavecomebe or t sve y Cour.
plce n hi src . ve a uc as
f e hi r
t
Se Fl lv W els Far Bank N A.N o.1 6072l fo z v.HSBC Bank US N o. 1 211 ,
e adel . l
go
,
,
3; pe
A,
3- 04.
Sac oc o v JP M or Chas Bank N A. N o.1 211 Pl ntf s s ven ca e ofa t o a e al
c ci .
gan
e
,
,
3- 07. ai if ' e
us s c i n r l
g oundedi f m iiral ga i
r
n a la le tons t tU. Ba r cevedt c
ha S. nk e i t kbac 'i c
ki
ks'n onne ton wih LPla
ci
t
nd
di notdicos t s
d
s l e he ame, ndt tt LPlcove a wase s i a r toa tve. f ndan sbot
a ha he
r ge
xce sve nd e r c i De e
t h
fl motonst dim isPl ntfs Compli i J 201 a bec us t em otonsi
ied
i o s s ai if '
ant n une 4, nd a e hes
i nvoke
d
s m ia a hor te a a gum e s t Cour r vi w st m t t r
i l r ut ii s nd r
nt , he
t e e he oge he .
I.
I
St nda d ofRevi w
a r
e
UnderRul 1 b)6) aco ai mus bedimis whe i f l Sosat acam upon
e 2( ( , mpl nt t
s sed n t ais ç t e li
t
whihr i ca beg a e 'CAJcompli mus algee
c elef n r ntd. I
'I
ant t le noughfct t saeacam t r i t t
a s o tt li o elefha
i pl us bl on isf ce a t tr s a
s a i e t a nd ha i es bove t s ul tve l vel' Tr yl v. 'hi Til Co. LLC,
he pec a i e .' a or # s p te ,
491F. x 988,990( 1h Ci.201 .1 cam ha fca plusbiiywhe t pl ntf plads
App'
1 t r 2) $ li s a il a i lt
A
n he ai if e
f c ua c e t ta l st cou t o dr t r a ona e i e e t tt de e
a t l ont nt ha low he r t aw he e s bl nf r nce ha he f ndanti la e f
s i bl or
temic n u talg d. As c o tv l b l 5 6 U. 6 2 6 ( 0 9 . sçe u rsmo eta
h s o d c le e ' h rj . q a , 5 S. 6 , 78 2 0 ) Thi û q ie r h n
'
r
l bel a c l i ,and a f m ul i r iato of t e e e s of a c us ofac i ' Be lA t.
a s nd onc us ons
or a c ec t i n
he l m nt
a e
ton.' l l
Cor v Twombl 55 U. 5 555(
p..
y, 0 S. 44, 2007)Sl lusbiiy'de ndst et nas rposi lt
.spja i lt ' ma l
mor ha hee sbiiy
t ta de e
ha
f ndanthasa e unl w f l ' l al 556 U . a 678.
ct d a uly. qb ,
'
S. t
11
1.
Le Anal i
cal
vss
M orga l r a s vier ha be n ltga i f c plce i ur ncec am sbr
t ge ende s nd er c s ve e ii tng or e- a d ns a
li
ought
i cl s a ton l s t na i
n as c i aw uis tonwi f m or t n t e ye s and ha f ie t pr ur di m i s
de or e ha hr e ar ,
ve a l d o oc e s s al
i tev s mao iyo ted z nso c s st yh v d fn e Se , ..Ca d nv 1 Ba k FS
n h a t j rt f h o e f a e he a e e e d d. e eg , r e .NG n B,
No. 1 c 80 9:3-v- 659KLR ( nyi motont dimisbra ofc r tbrac ofi idc nan,
de ng i o s s e ch ontac, e h mple ove t
u j s e rc me t b e c o fd cay duy a d triu itree c cams noig t a the
n u t n ib n , r a h f iu ir t, n o t s ne frn e li , t h t s
o
n
t
mao i ,f tal( PIc s sta h v p e e e tec re t a e h v al we t ep an if' l
j rt ino l, F a e h t a e rc d d h u rn c s l a e lo d h litfs FP
y
camst pr e );s ealoHamit v SunTr s M org.l .No.1 c 60749-l 201 U.
li o oce d' e s
lon .
u t t , nc,
3-vJC, 4 S.
DitLEXI 41 ( D. aM a . 201 ;Wilamsv Wels goBank NA.No.11cv- 233s.
S 668 S. Fl. r25, 4) li . lFar
,
- 21
CMA, 1W L4368 0( D. a Se .1 2011. r Dee
201
98 S. Fl. pt 9, )Hee, fndant ditnguiht rMotonst
s si s hei i o
Dimiswih a hea r inc on t r ce a l e de sons Upon c r f r vi w,howev ,
s s t
vy ela e
wo e nt ppelat cii .
a e ul e e
er
t s t de sonsa editnguihabl and Def nda sdo notm e t bur n ofde o ta i
he e wo cii
r si s e,
e nt
et he de
m nsr tng
t tPl i if f lt s a e a c ai upon w hi r i c n be g ant i a Cou oft rCo pl nt
ha a ntf s ai o t t l m
ch elef a
r ed n ny
nt hei m ai .
A.
Re e De i i byt Se nt a El nt CicuisDo NotCompelDim is
c nt c sons he ve h nd eve h r t
s s al
ofPli if Kikbac Cl ms.
antfs' c
k ai
De e nt a gue t tr e o ni by t Seve h a El ve h Cic t i Cohen v
f nda s r
ha ec nt pi ons he
nt nd e nt r uis n
.
Ame iansec i n r eCo.735F. 601( hCi. 3)a Fe v WelFar Bank NA.
rc
urt su anc ,
yl
3d
7t r201 , nd az . ls go
,
745F. 1 ( 1hCi. 4) s dc
3d 098 1 t r 201 , houl ompeldimis lofPl ntfs kikba kcli . Cour
s sa
ai if' c c ams The
t
de e nes how e r t tt a l ga i i bot c s a e m a e i l di tnc f o t e he e.
t nni ,
ve , ha he le tons n h a es r
t raly s i t r m hos r The
co ti Cohe a ove dim is ofaborowe ' c am st ts hadbe n c ge f rki kba ks
ur n
n ppr d s s al
r r s l i ha he
e har d o c c
bec us t pa m e ss des rbed i he c pl i we e pa m e sf wor s a l ge ha b n
a e he y nt he c i n r om a nt r y nt or k he le d d ee
-
3-
peror d bya afii t oft lnde - s de c i d e r comm isons a s
f me
n flae he e r he s rbe a ned
s i , nd oughtt r ove
o ec r
by lbelngt m tkikbac .' F. a 607. c pl nti Feazi ved f ce pl e tood
a i he s c
ks'735 3d t
The om ai n
nvol or - ac d l
i ur e a wa sm ia l c us y;t ale tonslcke uli a ef c st s
ns anc nd s i lry oncl or he l gai a d tm t a t o uppor ahol ng
t
di
t tt pl i ifhad,n f c , enc r edf abrbe. F. a 11 Her , c r t Pl i if
ha he antf
i a t be ha g or i 745 3d t 01. e by ontas, antfs
aleg t tki kba ks w e e pa d t U . Ba t tw e e e ie y unea ne and D e e nt ASI
l e ha c c
r i o S. nk ha r ntr l
r d,
f nda
C
m ild borowe sby r pr s ntngt t m t tt a ou swer pa e sf wor t tha be
se
r r
e e e i o he ha he m nt
e ym nt or k ha d en
p ro me . eCo rj ist ohe dsrc c u t i hodngt a alg to lk Plitfs ae
ef r d Th u t on wo t r itit o rs n li h t le ains ie anif' r
m a eraly di tnc f om t e i Cohe a Fe z s as t r
t i l si t r
hos n
n nd a o
o ende t e opi ons i ppos t .Se
r hos
ni
na
ie e
H am it 201 U . D i t LEXI 41
lon, 4 S. s .
S 668, t * 30;Els t v.U S.Bank N A. 201 U . Di t
a 26l wor h
,
, 2 S. s .
LEXI 38 , * ( D.Ca. a . , 4)1
S 691 at 63 N. lM r 21 201 .
Pli if Ha St t Cli sBa e on Exc s Cove a
antf s ve aed am
sd
es
r ge.
U . Ba l r le on Fc -w hi h i ves f c pl ce food i ur e o a g t t
S. rk e i s
lz
c nvol
or e- a d l
ns anc -t r ue ha
Pl i if he ec nno s a ec ai sba e on e s c
a ntf s r a t t t l m
sd
xce s over ge.
a Exce stood c ve a cl i s ho e r
s l
o r ge a m , w ve ,
a e ditnc fom Pli if 'haz r i ur ecl ms Pl ntfsal gi e es c a f ce i
r si t r
a ntf s
a d ns anc ai . ai if le ng xc s over ge or d n
t tood i ur nc c e ba et i cli on cove a plce i e es oft tr quie by t
he l
ns a e ont xt s he r a ms
r ge a d n xc s ha e r d he
Nai Fl I urnce Ac ($ A' a a pr son i borowes morga a e me s
tonal ood ns a
ti
NFl ' nd
)
ovii n r r' t ge gre nt
s ii ly gove ni t ood i ur nc w hi ge r ly r r t bor ow e t t ns e a l
pec fca l
r ng l
ns a e, ch ne a l equies he
r r o d ur l
i
l heCour ma consde pl di fom ot ra tonsonaRul 1 b)6)motont
'
r
t y
i r ea ngs r
he ci
e 2( (
i o
ds s wih u c n e t t emoint o ef rs
imis t o t o v ri h to o n o ummayj d me tS e eg,Cttc v Wama t
ng
r u g n . e , .. l / . l r
?.
ç
St es No.2:3-v-26, 3U. DitLEXI 1
or ,
1 c 5 201 S. s.
S 35502,a *2n. ( D.Al Se .23,201
t
1 N. a. pt
3)
(iAj ea hort e sswhihrcogni st tmatr ofpublcr or i l ngc t
sg mpl ut iy xit c e
ze ha te s
i ec d,ncudi our
r or i r l t d orunde l ng c esw hi h ha a die tr a i t t m a t r a i s m a be
ec ds n e a e
r yi as
c ve r c el ton o he te s t s ue, y
l dt whe r i ona1 b)6)motont dimis' ( ttonsomitd)
ooke o n ulng
2( (
i o s s.' ciai
)
te .
i r v me t o t P o e t .. g i s ls b to d t tee tn r q ie b t eSe rtr g f
mp o e n s n he r p ry . a an t o s y l o s o h x e t e urd y h ceay o
t De rmentofHousnga Ur nDe opment. Fe ,745F. a 11 2.nt s c es t
he pa t
i nd ba vel
q' az
'
3d t 0 l he e as ,he
que ton pr s nt d i whet r f de alr r m e s e t bls a m i m um o m axi um am ountof
si
ee e s
he e r equie nt s a i h
ni
r
m
food i ur et tt borowe i r quiedt m a n ai a c r pondi y, t rt lnde
l
ns anc ha he r r s e r o i t n nd, ores
ngl whe he he e r
b ea he t morg a ee ntorvi ae ot re r conta ual i st bonowe sbyr rng
r c d he tage gr me
ol td he xta r ct dute o
r
equii
t m t m ant i tood i u a e i exc s oft mnou r quied by f de a l w.The que ton
he o i an l
ns r nc n es
he
nt e r
e rl a
si
be or t Cour he e i dif r nt Pli if a lget tDe e nt c ge t m f t t pesof
f e he
t r s fe e . a ntfs le ha f nda s har d he or wo y
t xc s ' ha r cove ag .r r ctv c a f pe i whe e no cl ms we e made a
d e s' za d
e
r e' etoa i e over ge or rods
r
ai
r
nd
d ia i c er ge f pe i when vol a y c r ge ort morga sStnda d M org e
uplc tve ov a or rods
untr ove a
he
t ge' a r
tag
Clus ort Le r sLos Pa bl Endor e e , c ge al c rt lnderf am i m um
a e he nde '
s ya e
s m nt whi h ner ly ove he e
or ni
oft n da afe a lps i vol ar c er ge,we e i e f c .l t s i t nc ,bonowe s a e
e ys tr a e n unt y ov a
r n fe t n he e nsa es
r r
c r d f u c s r c r ge eiherbe us t ew a no r s t cove orc r ge w a a r dy
ha ge or nne es a y ove a , t
ca e her s i k o
r ove a
s lea
i pl e. ealegai nsr rpli if ' l m sditnc fom t ebr
n ac Thes l to ende a ntf s cai
si t r hos ought
bypl ntfsbrngi
ai if i ng
cli sbas on f ce tood c r ge.
am
ed or d l
ove a
TheNai lBankA c Doe N o Pr e Pl ntfs St eLa Cl ms.
tona
t s t e mpt ai if ' at w ai
Dee n saloatmptt aguet tt Nai lBn Ac,1 U. C. let e C$ ',
fnda t s te o r ha he tona nk t 2 S. j s q. NBA'
)
pr e s sa e lw cai s pr s nt he e A c s r r vi w of t r e ntc elw,howe r
e mpt tt a l m
e e ed r . ur o y e e
he elva as a
ve ,
d mo srtsta c u tr u ieyrj c t eag me th th Nain l n Ac p e mp s tt 1w
e n tae h t o rs o tn l ee th r u n t a t e to a Ba k t re t sae a
c ai si f c - a ed i ur nc ca es Se ,eg. Le
l m n or e pl c ns a e s . e . , ghor v.We l Far Bank N A. 950 F.
n
ls go
,
,
Supp.
2d 1
093,11 1 ( D.Cal 201 ;Kun l
07-4 N.
. 3)
zemann,201 U. Dit LEXI 18 34,a *1 1
2 S. s.
S 61 t 2- 6;
W ilam s 20ll U . D i t LEX I 11 36,a *1 35.U . Ba r i est ar m e hopi f a
li ,
S. s .
S 91
t 9S. nk a s he gu nt
ng or
dif r ntr s tbutt si not c s off
fe e e ul, hi s a a e i
whoe t l t be t t ywi . iAm it 'Dr n W or
ver els he s sor ns' k sad' e m
'
#
ks
SKG ( 997) TheNBA andr ae r ultonssmpl donotl e
1 .
eltd eg ai i y
s emptt e ietel ofba ng.
pr
he ntr i d nki '
'
Demig v Fis Fr ln,No.C09- 8,201 W L 21
n . rt anki
541
0
94830,a *3( . W as Apr 23,201 )
t W D. h. .
0.
Though t NBA doe çs edg nai lba fom undul bur ns a duplc tve sat
he
s shil l tona nks r
y de ome nd
iai t e
rgulton,ed al c ree ba r i s j c t saelwsofg r a i toni t rdal
e ai f erly ha trd nks eman ub e to tt a
eneal pplcai n hei iy
busne st t e e s h lw sdono c lc wiht ltero t ge r pum os oft NBA.
i s o he xt nt uc a
t onfit t he e t r he ne al
e he
'
'
Ge h r v Ba ko q ,NA. No 2:9 CV- 1 9 2 0 W L 5 0 9 , t* ( D. l Fe l ,
b a d . n fzm. , . 0 - 03 5 , 01
8 9 5 a 4 E. Ca. b. 1
201 (iai a i enalquot i omitd) The eor,Sglaesma rgult t aci te of
0) ctton nd ntr
atons te . r f e tstt y e ae he tviis
na i lba s l a t ydonot eve orsg fc l i e f ewih t e r s oft ba s
tona nks o ong s he
pr nt i niianty nt rer t he xe cie he nk'
a hort 'Mwantmbev FD Bank N A.669F.Supp.2d5 549( D. 2009.
ut iy.
'
e
.
, ,
45, E. Pa. )
The s ope ofNBA pr e i i f r na r rt n U. Ba s gess The d e a
c
e mpton s a rowe ha
S. nk ug t .
t es nd
f
c g 'atis e he ea enotbn ng f esa al- t yar i ur ncepr m i sa a i sr i
har es' s u r r
nki e t l he e ns a
e um nd dm nitatve
fesc c atd a c gedby i urnc compani f t i pr sand sr c .1 C. R.j
e alul e nd har
ns a e
es or her oduct
e vies 2 F.
7. b)2)i,7. b)2)i) Se i 7. oft NBA doe notpr e Pli if cams
4002( ( () 4002( ( (i. cton 4002 he
s
e mpt antfs' li
be us i a e s ss r i ec r si
ca e t ddr s e e v c ha ge mpos d b na i ba , i ur nc pr m i si pos d
e y tonal nks not ns a e e um m e
by i ur nce c
ns a
ompa es The s c i woul notpr emptPli if 'cl m se i i di a y,
ni .
e ton
d
e
a ntfs ai ven f t d ppl
m o eove , ca ePl ntfsdonot hale U. Ba sa hort t esabls t pr mi , y
r r be us ai if
c l nge S. nk' ut iy o t ih he e ums onl
isalg dma p lto o t p e u . e 1 C. R. 74 0 ( )2 ; e ,as Guir e , 01
t le e niuain f he rmi ms S e 2 F. j .0 2 b ( ) s e lo t r z 2 0
e
WL1
233885,a * (i ngnopremptonwheet prci c l ddi notquetonba s
t 2 fndi
e i
r he a tce halenge d
si nk'
rg t c gepa tc a ovedr tfe .
iht o har riulr r af e )
-
6-
D.
TheFie lat DocrneDoe NotBa Pli if 'Cli .
l d-k e ti
s
r antf s a ms
Bot De e n s' otons c t ndt tt fl r t docrneba sPli tfs cli sbec us
h f nda t M i
on e ha he ied-ae ti
r a n if ' am
a e
t r tsus dt cac aet pr um sc r dt U .S. nkwe ea ove b M is i ndRhode
he ae e o lul t he emi
ha ge o
Ba
r ppr d y s our a
lln r g ltr . u t i t i a doh rd srcsh v rj ce t sag me t h we e, e l i
sa d e u ao s Co rs n h s n te itit a e ee td hi r u n, o v r d ci ng
n
t a y t doc rne t l nder ,s r i e s or i ur r i t f ce pl ed i ur nc c e . See
o ppl he t i o e
s e v c r , ns e s n he or - ac ns a e ont xt
K u e mann,201 U . D i t LEX I 18 34, a *8- 0;
nz l
2 S. s .
S 61
t 1 Abel,678 F.Supp. a 1 78;ac or
s
2d t 277c d
Ho v r 2 4 U. Dit LEXI 4 7 3, t* 4 2 (iigt u tn ilb d o c s lw'rj cig
o e , 01 S. s.
S 0 4 a 2 - 5 ctn s bsa ta o y f a e a ' ee tn
s
a iai offl rt docrneonmoton t dimisi f c plce i urnc c e )(iai
pplc ton ied-ae ti
i o s s n ore- a d ns a e as s cttons
omitdl Canno v Wel Far Bank N. ,91 F.Supp.2d 1 1 38 ( D.Ca.201 ;
te ;
n . ls go
, A. 7
025, 036- N. l 3)
Galov PlH Morg.Cor ,91 F.Supp. 537,543- ( N. 201 .
l . l
t
p. 6
2d
49 D. J. 2)
TheCour ' de e m i ton he ei c i t nt iht s o he dec s o . TheCo t
ts t r na i
r s ons s e w t he e t r i i ns
ur fndst t
ha
t tld-a e docti i una ia e a a de e e i t s ltgai n be us De e nt a e no
he ie r t
rne s val bl s
f ns n hi ii to ca e f nda s r t
i s rr s b e t terlv n r g ao yrgme'Ho v r 201 U. Dit LEXI 4 4 , t* 0.
n u e s u j d o h ee a t e ultr e i . o e , 4 S. s.
'
S 07 3 a 3
U. Ba ki n ts b e t a miitaieo esg t ysaei u a c c mmiso ' sars l,t
S. n s o u j d o d n srtv v rih b tt ns r n e o sins a e utis
,
a hort t r ul t a a ove i ur r 'r t sdoesnott h Pl i i f 'cl i st tU .S.Bank,a
ut iy o eg a e nd ppr
ns e s a e
ouc a ntf s a m ha
l nde a s r c ,i l
e r nd e vi er nc uded i pe m i s bl cos s i t a ount i cha ge bor ow e s f f r e
m r s i e t n he m
s t r d r r or o c -
plc d i u a e.Se i ;s e alo Le or 950 F.Supp. 2d a 1 1 1 (
a e ns r nc
e d. e s gh n,
t 1 5- 6 dodrnei pplc bl
i na ia e
be us pl ntf ha notc lng l ul s ofr t , but nk' de son t c
ca e ai if d
hale ed awf ne s a e
ba s cii o hoos i ur t pa
e ns er o y
akikba k) Abes,678F.Supp. a 1 (ame .
c c ; l
2d t 277 s )
The doc rne i a s i pplc bl he e be us Pl i if a e not r t pa r . See e. ,
t i s l o na i a e r ca e a ntf s r
a e ye s
, g.
Roh ti 2 3 W L 5 7 4 , t* 8 9(ee t a p ia lt o d crn b c u er tsh db e
tsen 01
43 6 8 a - rj ci p lc bi y f o tie e a s ae a e n
ng
i
a oved f r pay e by m orga l r whih wa t r t pa r a notby borowes.
ppr
o
m nt
t ge ende , c
s he ae ye , nd
r r)
Pl i if a lge t tU. Ba pur ha e am a t polc fo ot rDef nda s t tt f c antfs le ha S. nk c s d
ser iy r m he
e nt ha he or e
,
pl c d polcisa e c
ae
i e r omm e c a i u anc polcis a U . Bal pai t i ur epr um st
r i l ns r e i e , nd S. rk d he ns anc emi
o
ot r De e nt. U. Ba , t r or , not Pl ntf s i t ale d r t pa er ba r d fom
he
f nda s S. nk he ef e
ai i f , s he l ge a e y
re r
c le ng t ot De e nt 'r es Thefl d-a edoc rnedoesnota y. Se Squar D Co.
hal ngi he her f nda s at .
ie r t
ti
ppl e
e
v Niga aFr nirT rf r, n .47 U. 4 9 4 2n2 ( 98 )
. a r o t a l .I c, 6 S. 0 , 2 .9 1 6 .
e
fBu
Pl i if Cli Ar NotBa r d by t Vol a yPa e Doc rne.
antfs' a ms e
re
he untr ym nt ti
U. Bark a s a gue t tPli if 'cli a e ba r d by t vol ar pay e docrne
S. t l o r s ha a ntfs a ms r re
he unt y m nt ti
be us Pl ntfspad a ount f f c - a edc a wih f lknowl
ca e ai if i m
s or or e pl c over ge t ul
edgeoft a ount t y
he m
s he
woul bec r d,ha t amount mi c
d ha ge t t he
s ght overc misonst U .S. nk, nd oft tmepe i ds
om s i o
Ba a
he i
ro
f whih c r gewoul bepr de . Butt s f c sa e notm a e i l o Pl ntf s' l i s Fort
or c ove a
d
ovi d
he e a t r
t r a t ai if c a m .
he
doc rnet a y, . Bankwoul ha t s t tPl ntfsha f lknowl
ti o ppl U S.
d ve o how ha ai if d ul
edgeoft aleg y
he l edl
undicos kikba a ot wr ulconduc al ge . M or over t vol ar paym ent
s l ed c cks nd her ongf
t le d
e
, he unt y
docrnei ana tr tvede e et tor na iy ma no ber i e onamoton t dim is See,e. ,
ti s fi ma i
f ns ha di rl y t a s d
i o s s.
g.
Els t 908 F.Supp.2d a 1 ( ci ng t dimisFPIcli be us vol ay pa nt
lworh,
t 083 de lni o s s
am ca e untr yme
defns wasnota e fo fceofc ant; l 91 F.Supp. a 553n 11(W thi sa
e e
pparntr m a
ompli ) Galo, 6
2d t
ç t s tge
.
o tep o e dn ,ti n tce rfo t efc o t eg Co liti P an ifh df l k o e g
f h r c e igs i s o la r m h a e f h l mp an f litf a ul n wld e
of t r e nt f ct whe he m a pa nt unde t f c pl c i ur nc polc .)I i
he elva a s
n
de yme s
r he or e- a ed ns a e iy t s
i pr ntt c i ri he e.
m ude o ons de t r
Pl ntfsHa Sufi i l Plad RI Cli s
ai if ve fcenty e
CO am .
Dee nt ague f dimis ofPli if'Seci 1 2()Ra kee rI l nce a
fnda s r or s sal
antfs ton 96 c c te nfue d nd
Co r p Or a iains (k CO' camscami ha d s ls rs r vie oPlitfsaeS o
ru t g nz t Ad $
o
R1 ' li , li ngt t ico u e p o d dt an if r t t
)
n
c itnt'wih m aland wie fa r l ng ag n on Cohe and Fe , a he f c pl c
onsse ' t
i
r r ud, eyi
ai
n
az not r or e- a ed
i ur nc o ni n a es i RI cli s Wenb gerv M elon M orgageCo. 1 W L 5991 2
ns a e pi o ddr sng CO am , i er
.
l
t
, 998
9
( D. Se .1 1 ,a ont M ccara Fegus nAc (t FA' ,15U. C.j 1 2( ) But
E. Pa. pt 0, 998) nd he
rn- r o t ;
M '
)
S. 01 b).
Cohe a Fe zdono a yher , c us t a lga i pr s nt i t eca e we em ae ily
n nd a
t ppl e be a e he le tons e e ed n hos s s r tra l
ditnc fom t e pld he e s e Sec i A.M o eove , W ei r r hasbee di tng s i t
si t r hos e r , e
ton
r r
nbe ge
n s i ui hed n he
f r - a d i ur nc c t xt See e. ., Rotsen, 3W L 5437648, t* (l Wenbe ge ,he
o ce pl ce ns a e on e . , g
h ti 201
a 13 1n i r r t
$
co tco l
ur ncuded t tnone oft a t i t ale s he e... ul be r as
ha
he c s n he l ged c m
co d
e onabl cac a e t
y lult d o
de i a t wa ni lte sa notc hads cii ly sa edt t hef ce pl e i ur nc wa
ceve, s he r ng el r nd i es
pe fca l tt ha t or - ac d ns a e s
am or e
e xpensvepr tt twoul notpr t c t pl n if 'i e e t ..l t c r ntc e,o
i
oduc ha
d
o e t he aitfs nt r ss . n he ure as n
teoh rh n Pl it d n t le etath f a d ln s h mewJ&itn e omirpr s n te
h te a d, an p o o a lg h t e r u ue t c e
, ne d dt s e e e th
n tr o
au e fLP1o tikt e it lpsn o t er a me t. t rt ealg dsh meh r i mo e
r rc h m n o a ig n h i p y n s Rahe,h l e c e ee s r
e
sm pl t tC oss' nd t em bureme s'lsed i t l te a lgii ael owed we ema e i ly
i e: ha t t 'a d i
c
r
s nt' it n he et r s e tm t y
r t ral
ove sae '(mphassadde )
rttd. e
'
i
dl.
Pli tfs s t inty a lge a RI c us of a on.Pli if pl d t t U .S. Bank
a n if ufk e l le
CO a e
di
a ntf s ea ha
unde t k t pr vi contnuo haz r c a on borowe s'pr ri i t e tofalps ,
roo o o de
i us a d over ge
r r ope tes n he ven
a e
pur ha e am as e i f om ot rD e e nt and pa dt pr m i sdie tyt t m ,us dASI
c sd
t rpolcy r
he f nda s
i he e um r c l o he
e
C
t pr de l n ta ki s r c sa be o c t a t tot De e nt pa d at
o ovi oa r c ng e vie t l w os, nd ha her f nda s i s
comm iso 't
s i n' o
U. Ba t t awholyunea ne kikbac The f t ra lget Def ndan smaiednotc s
S. nk ha was
l
r d c
k. y urhe le hat e
t
l
ie
t bor o e s w ih U . Ba s pe s i a on is l te hea , r pr s ntng t tt a ount
o r w r , t S. nk' nni s on nd
t e t r d e e e i ha he m
s
c r t m r l c e t i t of i ur e,' a om itng t m enton t tt s m e a o m t
ha ged he efe t d he f
cos
ns anc ' nd
ti o
i ha he a
m t s
c r une r ki kba ks a ot r c r s The e alega i ns s a e a c a m f vi a i of
ove ed
a ned c c nd he ha ge . s l t o t t
l i or ol ton
-
9-
s cin 1 6 ()S e eg.Ca n n, 01 U.. s.
e to 9 2 c . e , . , n o 2 4 S DitLEXI 1 1 3, t 7 1 (p ligRI cam
S 1 6 a * - 1 u hodn CO li
bec us ' efnda s non- s l ur oft kikba ksma bet bassf hes he t defa '
a e O e nt' dicos e he c c
y he i ort c me o rud'
)
.
ASI a g t tt M c ra Fe g onAc (t FA' basPli if 'RI cams The
C r ues ha he ca rn- r us
t$
M ' r antfs CO li .
)
wr ng ulco uc a lged,
o f nd t le
howe r doesnotconsiut t ûbusnes ofi u a e,'a t RI
ve ,
tt e he û i s ns r nc ' nd he CO
saut doe no S n lda e i
t t e s t t vai t ,mpai, xs re 't a i a eM is ur orlhodeI l i u a e
i
r o upe s de'he pplc bl s o i l
sand ns r nc
lw.Tha Ac d e l sa i ton o a f r lsa ut i f e ofsa e l w e t d . . . f t
a
t t s cude pplcai f ede a t t e n ac
pr
tt a nac e
or he
pupos ofrgultngt busne sofi urnc ,'ft fde a me s edoesnotlpecfc lyr ag)
e e ai he i s ns a e'i he e r l aur
Cs iial elte
t t busnes ofi ur nc ,' ndwo dCnvaldae,i i, s r e 't sae' lw . Hu
o he i s ns a e'a
ul û i t mpa r or upe s de'he tt s a ' mana
i
'
I c v Fo s h 5 5U. 29 ( 9 9 (uoi 1 U.. j1 2 b )He e Plitfs no c alng
n . . ryt, 2 S. 9 1 9 ) q tng 5 SC. 01 ( ). r , anif do t h l e
e
ASI Sû i i dee mi to 'ort r t st ti s t f rt f ce pl e c r t ti s lst
C' s cng tr nai ns' he a e ha t es o he or - ac d ove age ha t e l o
pr
U . Ba Pl i if i t d c le ASI Spa tc pa i i a a l ed l r r s he e w he e
S. nk. a ntf s nsea ha l nge
C' ri i ton n n leg a ge c m
r by
bo r e s a e c r d by t i l nde ,U . Ba ASI S r e i t t s hem e i notaleg t
r ow r r ha ge
he r e r S. nk. C' ol n ha c
s
l ed o
i vet i i sofi urnc 'ASI i c r dwihpa ngbrbe ( c cks t U. Ba
nvol he s nes ns a e. C s hage t yi i s kikba ) o S. nk
bus
'
t mai a nise l i r a i hi wiht lnde , f i t lnde bel c ta i sr tve
o nti t xcusve eltons p t he e r oferng he e r ow- os dm nitai
s r c ( c pr ry beong t t sr c r,a a c e ofsndi mil di notee t
evies whih ope l l o he evie) nd c usd e ng sea ng i s o
borowe spur tngt beU . Ba Pl i if 'cai sdo noti vet d i s ofi ur nce''
r r pori o
S. nk. antfs l m
nvol he t ne s ns a ,
bus
bu i t a t lndersl n s r i i o i a i ,s t M FA ha no a i a i on Pl n if '
t nse d, he e ' oa e v cng blg tons o he
s
pplc ton
aitf s
RI c am she e. Cannon,201 U. Dit LEXI 111 , a +1 24;M oor v.Fi lt Fi
CO l i
r See
4 S. s.
S
63 t 8e
de i n.
y
Se v .88 F.Supp. 8,292- @ , 11 1 )( CO woul noti i,nvai t ors re
r s, 4
28
93 D.1. 995 RI
d mpari ldae upes de
llnoi i urncelw unde M FA i f cepl e c ext; okahomaM org.Cop.v Ca t
li s ns a a
r
n or - ac d ont ) Banc l
t r . pial
Til Co. 1 4F. 1 1 ( 0hCi.l .
te , 9 3d 089, 099 1 t r 999)
Pli if Ha Sufk inty Ale TI Cli .
antfs ve f e l lged LA a ms
U. Ba aruest tPl ntfs Tr hi Le ngAc (ç LA' cli oughtbedimis d
S. nk g ha ai if' ut n ndi t û
TI ' ams
)
s se
.
The f m e a pur e ofTI , 1 U. C. 1 1 e s ,st pr deboroweswi cla
unda nt l pos
LA 5 S. jj 60 , t eq. i o ovi
r r t er
h
a a cu at di cos e ofl n t r s Be h v Ocwe Fe Banks
nd c r e s l ur s oa e m . ac .
n d
523U. 41 41 ( 998) 1
S. 0, 2 1 ; 2
C. R. 2 .7 c . ihrs c t rsd n il rg g s TI ai sdt ass et cons er ar
F. j 261 ( )W t epe to e ie ta mo ta e , LA m to ur hat um s e
ofer d a r c ver sde i morgagel nson t
f e nd e ei e i ntal t
oa
enns. . . t ta eunde sa bl a no u ai
ha r
rt nda e nd t nf r
,
de ptve ora i .' l U. C. 1
ce i , bus ve ' 5 S. j 639b()2) Addii l i e ur t tç c e trma not
a( . tonaly, t ns es ha ' r dio y
a
c nget tr soft ext i n ofcr di i s h c nge m a t dic os e i c ae unl s
ha
he e m
he enso
e t f uc ha s ke he s l ur s na cur t
es
,
ne dicl ur sa epr de .'l j1 a( ( .
w s os e r ovi d 'd 639()2)A)
Pli if s fc e l sat a c us ofa i i t i Compli a t t i TI cli s
a ntfs ufii nty t e a e
cton n her
ant s o her LA am .
Pli if a lge t tU .S.Ba c nged t t r s ofPl ntfs l ns t c eai ne l n
antfs le ha
nk ha
he e m
ai if ' oa , hus r tng w oa
oblga i b addi f c plce i ur ncet Pl i if outtndi l n balnce . The a l ge
i tons y
ng or e- a d ns a
o antfs' sa ng oa
a s
le d
k c b c swo l h v b e s b e t oTI Sdicos r rq ie ns K i kbacksar notpr ry
ik a k ud a e e n u j c t LA' s l u e e u rme t c
e
ope l
.
c a sfe a i emi s f i ur nce'unde t excuson cie by U .
l s ii d s û
pr um or ns a '
r he l i
td
S.Ba ,1 C. R.j
nk 2 F. j
2 6.( )8 , 2 4 d ( ) U. Ba kwo l h veb e r q ie t ds l s t ea u t n n t r o
2 4 b ( )2 6.( )2 . S. n u d a e n e urd o ico e h mo n a d au e f
t ç omm isons' spa toft ç i nc c r '
he '
c
s i 'a r he i na e ha ge'unde 1 C.F. j226.8d)bec us unea e
f
r 2
R.
1(
a e nzd
commisonsa enot t i dbyPl ntfs m orga . Se Cannon, 3 W L 1 2450, a *1 -1
si r
au horze
ai if ' t ges e
201
3
t 6 7
( di t tTI cam bas onki c t or i f c plce i ur nc ltgai wa vibl)
hol ng ha LA li ed ckba k he y n ore- a d ns a e ii ton s a e
.
Not y, . Ba a guest t ai if ' LA cai sa eba r dbyTI Sone-years at e
abl U S. nk r
ha Pl ntfs TI l m r re
LA'
t ut
oflm ia i . ow e r o t ep e dn s Plitfs TI camsaes b e tt e ui bet l n .
i t tons H
ve , n h la ig , anif' LA li r u j c o q t l ol g
a
i
Thedocrneofe t bl t lng û a s' TI c am whe eapl ntf hast n pr ve e fom
ti
quia e oli t ve 'a LA l i
s
r
ai if
t
bee e nt d r
g i ngs t duet i quiabl cr t e .' lsv G en.M ot sAcce anceCor ., 160F.
brngi uil o ne t e icumsanc s'Eli
or
pt
p
3d
.
7 3, 0 -08( lh Ci.1 9 ) Dimis lo aTI cam a t pe d n sa ei a p o rit onl
0 76
1 t r 9 8 . s sa f LA li t he la ig tg s p r p ae y
tft a s tonsoft co pl nt r d wih t r r d lbe alt woul notper tt pl i if
i he s eri
i
he m ai , ea t he equie i r iy
d
mi he antf
,
t pr t t hesat ewa t ld.'yt t v De Witr& Co.,
o ove ha t t ut s ole ' l/? . an te
a
61 F. 677,682( hCi.1 .
4 2d
9t r 980)
He e,Pl i if cai t tt had no mea bywhi h t dic rU .S. nk' pr c iesbec us
r antfs l m ha hey
ns
c o s ove
Ba s a tc
a e
U. Ba ne rdicl e isf c plc i ur e s he e t bonowe s a hi t f c t t
S. nk ve s os d t or e- a ed ns anc c m o
r , nd d he a t ha
i lt d pr m i s r s t d fom U .S. Bank' ki kba s he e The Cour t r uphol
nfa e e um e ule r
s c ck c m .
t he eby
ds
Pl ntfs TI cli she e, mid ulh tt l arme il tt t, LA mus b c nsr e lb rly
ai if ' LA am
r n f ta Ca s e da saue TI
l
t e o tu d ieal
i f voroft c um e .' Br
n a
he ons r ' agg v BilH e d Chev ol , I . 374 F. 1
. l ar
r et nc,
3d 060,1 ( 1h Ci.
065 1 t r
20 4 .
0)
H.
Pl ntfsHaveSufii nty Ale d Tori I e f r nceCl m s
ai if
fc e l l ge
tous ntr e e
ai .
Fi ly, C a g st Pli if ha f ie t s fc e ypl d ist tousi e f rence
na l ASI r ue hat antfs ve al d o ufi i nc ea t ori ntre
cai s r l ngonisfld-aedocti de e e. Thi ar
l m , eyi
t ie r t
rne f ns
s gume f isf t s m er as a isfldnt al or he n e ons s t ie
r e docrne de e e.Se Se ton D . I a ton,t docrne doesno a y t e iislkeU .S.
at
ti
f ns e c i
n ddii he ti
t ppl o ntte i
Ba whih donotfl i ur ncer t . Se Abel, F.
nk, c
ie ns a
aes e
s 678 Supp. a 1 . Bec us Pl ntfsha
2d t 277
a e ai if ve
pl d t t U. Ba br a d t r morga a e nt and t t t As ur nt De e nt
e ha S. nk e che hei
t ge gr eme s
ha he s a
f nda s
itn in l a d u j siiby c u e s c b e c e , Pli if havesuffcinty st ed cl m sf
ne to al n n u tfa l a s d u h ra h s antf s
y
i e l at ai or
t ri i e f r nc t s vi a m oto t dim is Se ,e g. H am it 201 U . Di t LEX I
o tous nt re e e o ur ve
in o s s . e . ,
lon,
4 S. s .
S
41
667,a *17- W ilams 2011 W L 4368980,a *1 .
t
24; li ,
t 2
Th Co r as rj csAS C' p iie ed f n ea t stme becausePli if havealeged
e u t lo ee t I S rv lg ee s thi i ,
antfs
l
ta te Dee a t weeno j tfe i teritree c , as t y act wih i oper means
h t h fnd n s r t usiid n h i n efr n e he ed t mpr
.
Pl i if a lget tDe enda sma pult d t ma ke f f c - pl c d i ur ea knowi y
antfs le ha f nt ni a e he r t or or e a e ns anc nd
ngl
-
1
2-
i e e e a s he t pas kikbac t U .S Ba k a d oh r s u j siiby itae te
mplm nt d c me o s c
ks o
. n n te wie n u tfa l nl t h
a o sc r dt borower . e We t r M as . Bl tn Cor v. e r . Pr p.drCas I .Co.
m unt ha ge o r
s Se
sen
s as i g
p. M t o o
. ns ,
783A. 398, -02( I2001 ( ai ifma ovec t prviegebys ngû t mai
2d
401 R.. ) pl ntf y rome he i l
howi acual lce'
o tep r o tealg dwr n d e '. C i p r te t r-r u t ed fns a altrsa ei
n h a t f h l e o g o r' ASI s e mitd o eag e h ee e t ae tg n
e
)
t sltgai
hi ii ton.
Concl i
uson
Uli t l t Cour dee nest tf ea h Countoft i Compl nt Pl ntfsplad
tma ey, he
t tnni ha or c
her
ai , ai if e
f c ua c en t talowst Co t odr w t r as bl i er ncet tDe e
a t l ont t ha l
he ur t a he e ona e nf e
ha f ndant a ela ef r
s r ibl o
t mic
he s onduc alege M or over e n t
t l d. e , ve hough bot De e nt aleget tt sc us s d be
h f nda s l ha hi a e houl
dim is dbe us Pli ifLa ge s swiea co- orgag , Elz b t Lea d h sn t e nj n d
s s e ca e a ntf r s ' f nd m t or ia eh ln , a o b e oie
a ds ei a idip n a l p ry t eCo r fn sta s en e n tb j ie a apat. an if
n h s n n s e s be a t,h u t id h t h e d o e on d s ry Plitfs
ha de c i t the i e essa he hus nd' a e a i d, and t rl ga c am sa eonea
ve s rbed ha r nt r t nd r ba s r lgne
hei e l l i r
nd
t s me t rpay e oblgai wih r pe tt t m o t ge a t f r - a ed i u a e
he a - hei m nt i tons t es c o he rga nd he o ce pl c ns r nc
po so aej ita ds v r la dafn l u g n o Pli tf Lag s ' camsi t i c s wil
rviin r on n e ea, n i a j d me t n anif r e ss li n h s a e l
ha apr cl i efec on any f t ec am sb M s Le and.I i ac or ngl
ve e usve f t
' ur l i y . l
u
t s c di y
ADJ
UDGED t tDe e nt 'M otonst Dimi sar bot DENI .
ha f nda s
i o s s e h
ED
>
DO NDOR E E ica est a ,lrati oAuut 04
NEA D R D n hmbraMi Foi s JQy f gs21.
mi d h
,
FED
O A .M O N O
U N ED STA TES D I
STRI J DG E
CT U
Copi pr d t
es ovi ed o:
Couns ofRe or
el
c d
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?