Circeo-Loudon et al v. Green Tree Servicing, LLC et al
Filing
29
ORDER granting 18 American Reliable Insurance Company's Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 8/22/2014. (rtn)
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI COU RT FO R TH E
CT
SOU TH ERN DI
STRI OF FLORI A
CT
D
M i m iD i s on
a
vi i
Cas N um be 14e
r: 21384- I - O R EN O
C V M
R EN A TA CI
RCEOLOU D ON a LO UI J.
nd
S
CI
RCEO ,on be foft m s l a a lo he s
hal he e ves nd l t r
sm ia l st t d,
i l r y iua e
Plit f,
an fj
V S.
GREEN TREE SERV I N G , LLC, GREEN
CI
TREE I SU R A N C E A G EN CY , I C .
N
N ,
A SSU RAN T, N C.K dAM ERI N RELI BLE
I ,
CA
A
I SU RAN CE COM PAN Y ,
N
Dee d ns
fn a t
O R DER G R AN TI G D EFEN DA N T' M O TI N T O DI I
N
S
O
SM SS
Thi trcome be or heCour uponar vi w of f nd Amerc nRei bl I u a
smate
s f et
t
e e De e ant
ia la e ns r nce
Compa (ç C' ' M oi t Dimis( E.No-18) fl on June 23.2014,Dee nts
ny û
AR1 ' s ton o s s D.
)
, ied
fnda '
r la e on r c nta lt c eshe e i die ty on poi .Fort f e ng r as ,t Cour
ei nc
e e ppela e as
r s rcl
nt
he or goi e ons he
t
GR AN TS Def nt sM oto t D i m i s
enda '
in o s s.
1
.
Fac ualBa kg ound
t
c r
Pli if ha s Ameia Relabl I urnceCompa (û C', ongwiht ohe
antfs ve ued
rc n i e ns a
ny :
ARI ' al
)
t wo t r
de e nt ,aleg ng t t ARI pa tcpaed i a na i de f c - a ed i ur nce s he
f nda s l i ha
C rii t n
tonwi or e pl e ns a
c me,
i e ng t ç a pul t 't l nde - a e i ur nc m a ket nd d r ii aly i l t pr m i s '
nt ndi o ' ni a e ' he e r pl c d ns a e r a t tfci l nfa e e um 'by
m
a
a e ngwihGre TreSe vii LLC (s e n Tre' a Gr n Tr I ur ceAge y,l .
grei t e n e r cng,
û e e ' nd ee ee ns an
Gr
)
nc nc
(t e nTrel urnc 't pa c ksdiguie a c
û e e ns a e' o ykikbac s s d s ommisonsa ot ralge yû
Gr
)
s i nd he le dl û rtd
unmeie
cha ge . Le r pl e i ur e i i u a e whi h,pur ua t t t r s oft m orgag a
r s ' nde - ac d ns anc s ns r nc
'
c
s nt o he e m
he
t e,
lnde orl n s r ce pur has st pr decon i
e r oa e vi r c e o ovi
tnuousc a on pr ry s l ng asc lt r l
over ge
ope t ewi
ola e a
whe t bor rfist mant ncovea Thelnde orl ns r ce (nt sca e Gre Tre)
n he rowe al o i ai
rge. e r oa evi r i hi s , e n e
o anst co rgefom t i urr( r, CI a t natmpt t r ove t c toft LPl
bti he vea r he ns e hee ARI , nd he te s o ec r he os he
fom t bor ow e / ope t owne .
r he r rpr r y
r
A RI f l d a M o i t D im i st Com pl nti ise ie y i J 201 w hi h t Cour
C ie
ton o s s he
ai n t ntr t n une 4, c he
t
r viwsher
e e
e.
l.
I
Le lSt nda d
ga a r
Unde Rul 1 b)6) ac antmus bedimisd whe i f l io saeacam upon
r e 2( ( , ompli
t
s se
n t ais t tt li
t
whihr ifc begrntd.'$Ajc antmus algeenoughf t t sat acam t r le t t
c ele an
a e '1( ompli
t le
acs o t e li o eif ha
i pl usbl on isf c a t rs sabovet s c ai l l'Tr yl v P 'hi Til Co.LLC,
s a i e t a e nd hat ie
he pe ul tve eve . a or . s p te ,
'
491F. x988,990( 1hCi.201 .t cam ha f i pl i lt whe t pli ifpl ds
App'
1 t r 2) $ li s acal ausbiiy n he antf ea
A
f cual e t al t cour t dr w t r s bl i er ncet tt def nti labl f r
a t contnt hat lows he
t o a he ea ona e nf e
ha he enda s i e 0
t miconduc a lged.' hc ot v I ,556 U. 662,678 (
he s
t le 'As r. t . qbal
S.
2009) Thi (e rsmor t n
. s i quie
r
e ha
lbel a c l i ,a a f m ul cr ct ton Oft ee e sofa ca eofa ton. Bel At.
a s nd onc usons nd or ai e ia i
he lm nt
us
ci ' l l
'
Cop. . wo l, 5 U. 5 4 5 5( 0 7 .il a sblt'd ma d û r t a as e r o sblt
r v T mby 5 0 S. 4 , 5 2 0 )C Nlu i i y' e n s s e h n h e p s iii
g
i
mo
y
t ta de enda hasac e unl w f l ' I ,556 U . at678.
ha
f
nt
t d a uly. qbal
'
S.
11
1.
Le lA nal i
za
vs s
A.
The Cli sAg ns ARI a eBa r b Dicl ur sPl i if Re i
am
ai t C r red y s os e antf s ceved
Pli if do notdiput t tt i m o t geoblga e t m t mai ai c i
antfs
s e ha her rga
i t d he o nt n ontnuousha a d
zr
a o he i u a on t i pr pe t f t pur e of pr e tng t l nde ' i e es i t
nd t r ns r nce
he r o ry or he pos
ot c i he e r s nt r t n he
pr ry.l i f t r uncont t d t tPl i if unde sood t t i t y f ie t ma nti t
ope t t s urhe
ese ha antfs
rt
ha f he al d o i an he
i ur nc t i lnde c ddo a pa f whae ri f
ns a e,he r e r oul
nd y or tve t oundt bea opraet pr e t t i e e t
o ppr i t o ot c is nt r s,
i udi pu cha i i ur nc and c gi Pli if f t lnderplce i ur nc Fi l
ncl ng r sng ns a e
har ng a ntfs or he e - a d ns a e. naly,
Pli tfsdo notdiput t tt y wer no ii dt tt LPlwoul bes t ntal mor e nsve
a n if
s e ha he
e tfe ha he
d ubsa i ly
e xpe i
t t i ur ncet y c dobt i on t rown, nd t tc
han he ns a
he oul
an hei
a ha ompens tonwoul ber cevedbyt
ai
d e i
he
l r ort i af ii t f t pl e entofLPI
ende s he r fla es or he ac m
.
l ar c ntSe nt Cic tde ii t c t eviweda al os i ntc s toff c sa
n ee
ve h r ui c son, he our r e
n m t de ial e
a t nd
f
ound i crtc lt t
t iia ha
( t sg an if 'r s o iiiyt mananh z r i u a c o tep o e t a a1i s
i wa plitfsl e p nsb l o iti a ad ns rn e n h r p ry t 1tme ;
l
t
i (he jfie t dos (herlnde jha t rghtt s c et i urnc ..a pa st
f t y ald o o, t i e r d he i o e ur he ns a e . nd s he
c to t (he .( antfs'lndejf l dicos t tlnde- ac d i urnc maybe
os n o t mj Pli if e r uly sl ed ha e rpl e ns a e
sgnii ntymor e
i fca l e xpensvet n ( ai if' ownpolc a ma i l af orot r
i ha pl ntfsj
iy nd y ncude ee he
c pe aton t t ba z and isi ur nce a nc af ii t .I s t m ai ai ng pr r y
om ns i o he lk
t ns a - ge y fla e n hor, nt ni
ope t
is rn ewa ( litfsqc nrcu l bi ai na d gh y fie t f lili; e a s te
n u a c s panif' o ta ta o lg to n t e ) ald o u fl t b c u e h
c n e u n e o ta f i r weece ryds ls dt (h mjn n o (h il li fr eif
o s q e c s fh tal e r la l ico e o te , o e f ter cams o rle
u
c s e d.
an ucc e
Cohe rAme ianSec i ns anceCo.7 F. 601 60 (t Ci. 3)TheElvent Cic t
n . rc
urt ur
yl
, 35 3d , 4 7h r 201 .
e h r ui
r e e a ve y s m ia c s s ty t r fer a
evi w d
r i l r a e hor l he ea t , doptng t r as ni i Cohe i isa l s s Fea
i he e o ng n
n n t na y i . z
v WelsFar Bank N A.745F. 1 ( 1h Ci.201 .
. l go
,
3d 098 1 t r 4)
H e e, a ntf s' le tonsvi t ly m ir rt s i Cohe a s m ia l t e i Fe A s
r Pl i if a l ga i
r ua l r o ho e n
n, nd i l r y, hos n az.
Pl ntfs do he e,t pl i ifi Cohe al ge t tt c r s f t LP1we e i lae a
ai if
r he antf n
n le d ha he ha ge or he
r nt t d nd
ov r ie be us t pr m i alege y i l d s t nta , s l e ki c whih pad
e prc d ca e he e um l dl nc ude ubsa il undicos d ckba ks c i
f t pl e en a s vi i oft i ur nc See i at604. nd lke t Pl ntf s he e,t
or he ac m t nd er c ng
he ns a e.
d
A
i he ai i f r he
pl ntf i Cohe alege s woul no ha pa d t LP1pr m i ha s kno a utt
ai if n
n l d he
d t ve i he
e um d he wn bo he
d c cks'f l at mpt t ditnguih Cohe Pl ntfsm ic tuet tc ea c endt t
' kba . J.n te s o si s
ki
'
n, ai if s onsr ha as nd ont ha
t pl ntf t r c
he ai i f he e once d t t t s c l d ckba ks'w e e l w f S om pe a i 'f t
de ha he o- aled s
ki c ' r a ul t
c
ns ton' or he
pl e e a s r i i oft i ur nc Thi ditnc i i unc ncng. e t Cour f us
ac m nt nd e v cng he ns a e. s si ton s onvi i Her , he
t oc es
ont me toft algai ,dee mi ngt tkthes tnc oft ta aci wascla l a
he a he le tons tr ni ha l l ubsa e he rns ton
l
e ry nd
f l ds os d (opli if;nomae ilfc wasomitd. 735F. a 609.Aswa t lnd i
uly icl e t antfj
tra a t
te '
'
3d t
s he e er n
Cohen, r Gr en Tr ewasc it ntycla t ti di nota ton Pl i if 'be forr e e t
he e, e
e
onsse l e r ha t d
c
antf s hal epr s n
t ri e e t . ai if 'morgag us sne ry i ntca t nnsa t m orgage i Cohe t m a
hei nt r s s Pl ntfs
t e e a l de i l e
s he
t
n
n o ke
cl a t t hei ur ncer qui e en w a f t l nde ' pr ec i .û l i ur nc polc esr quie
e r ha t ns a
e r m t s or he e r s ot ton' A l ns a e i i e r d
1
b Le d ra rn was o s c p lce s alb s be tt L n e ' rg tt ds p r v s c
y n e nd e e l f u h o iis h l e u jc o e d rs i h o ia p o e u h
polces s li l asa r morga clus a s l nameLe ra m o t ge a o a a
ii , hal nc ude t nda d
t ge a e, nd ha l
nde s rga e nd/ r s n
addii nall s pa e.Lende s l ha t rghtt hol t polc e and r ne lc riiat .
to
os ye
r hal ve he i o d he ii s
e wa e tfc es'
'
Co r D. l - ( 5 wi Co e , 3 F.da 6 4, 1 -2. litfs mo ta eas smi ry
mpa e E. 8 l ! ) t h n 7 5 3 t 0 6 1 1 P an if ' rg g lo i l l
h
a
saes dl si ur nc s lbemai ai i t a
tt :t- ns a e hal
-hi
nt ned n he mount (ncl ngded tbl l l)a f t
s i udi
uci e eves nd or he
pe i t tLe rr quies W ha Le rr quiespur ua t t pr ce ng s nt nc c n c ng
rods ha nde e r .
t nde e r
s nt o he e di e e es a ha e
d rn tetnno t Lo n'Co r D. 1 - ( 5 wihCo e 7 5F.da 6 4 61 . an if'
u ig h e fhe a . mpa e E. 8 1 ! ) t h n, 3 3 t 0 , 1 Plitfs
'
morga s cii lyadvie t tt LPIpolciswoul pr ec t l nde and mi htnotpr e t
t ge pe fcal
s d ha he
ie
d ot t he e r
g
ot c
pli if çl uc covea shalc e Lende , mi ormi notpr e Borowe '
antf:ssl h rge l ov r
r but ght ght
otct r n'Compar
e
D. 1 - ( 5 wihCo e , 3 F.da 6 5(mp a i a d d .
E. 8 1 ! ) t h n 7 5 3 t 0 e h ss d e )
Pl ntfs morga gi sGr e Tr br ddicr tont a t pr t ctisown i e e t a
ai if ' t ge ve e n ee oa s ei o ct o o e t
ntr s, nd
lke t pl i ifi Cohe Pl ntfshe e we e r peae y a s d t tLP1c d be muc mor
i he antf n
n, ai if r r e tdl dvi e ha
oul
h
e
e nsve t n i ur ncet y c d obt n f rt m s l .Cohe 735 F. at611 Unde t e
xpe i ha ns a
he oul
ai o he eves
n,
3d
.
r hes
u ip tdfcs Gre Tr ewa n t u j c t dvd dly lis S eas Fe z 7 F.da 1 1
nds u e a t, e n e s o s be to iie o ate . e lo a , 45 3 t 1 1
(i ngt tPli if'i c k'algai fit pr dean vibl bassf t rcai ,a
fndi ha antfs û kbac ' le tons al o ovi y a e i or hei l ms nd
ki
a fnni dimis lofalexta ta t cai s sa i t e a e wih t Seve h Cic tt t
fi ng s s a
l r con r c ual l m , ttng $
W gr e t he
nt r ui ha
di y c lng a c
smpl ali
omm ison a ki kba k does t ma i one. The defni cha a t rsi ofa
si
c c
n' ke t
i ng r c e itc
kik a k i dvd d ly lis Bu (h ln ejwa n ta tn o b hafo yh b ro r o
c b c s iie o ate . t t e e d r s o cig n e l f te o r we) r
r pr e i he i e ess Thel n a e m e ma i c e rt tt i ur ncer quieme i f
e es ntng r nt r t .
oa gr e nt kes t l a ha he ns a
e r nt s or
t l de spr e i ' (tlc i orgi )( i Cohen 735F. a 611)M akTwanke nl
he en r' otcton.) iais n i nal quotng
'
,
3d t ). r
i ey
obs r t tû fyou l d alofourlwse t e , t r wo d beno e 'Buton t s toff c s
e ved ha k
l
ai l
a nd o nd he e ul
nd.
'
he e
at
pr e e t t Cour,t r i l la hort die l onpoi . Pl ntfsf i t ditnguih t i
es nt d o he
t he e s ega ut iy r cty
nt ai if al o si s her
al tonsfom t e f
legai r hos ound unperuasvei bot Cohe a Fe . Se Cohe 735 F. a 61l
s i n h
n nd az e
n,
3d t ;
Fea ,745 F. a 1111 1
z
3d t
- 2.
B.
Pli if 'RI Cl i sFa lt St t aCa eofAc i
antfs CO am
i o ae
us
ton
A1 r l va dicos e we epr vi d
l e e nt s l ur s r o de
Pl i if donotd s et the ec i w rte no i et the we eoblgae t m ant i
antfs
iput ha t yr eved it n tc ha t y r i t d o i an
i ur nceon t rpr pery a t t i t y f ie t dos t lnderwoul obt i c r ewhih
ns a
hei o t nd ha ,f he al d o
o, he e
d an ove ag
c
m i tc t ubsa i lym or a pr del sc r get n a ia et Pl i if ' he s ve . N or
gh os s t nta l
e nd ovi es ove a ha va lbl o antfs t m el s
do Pli if dipu et t dic os e i onne t t ta fla esofGr n Tr e ma r c vea
antfs s t hat he s l ur s nf
d hem ha fiit
ee e
y e ei
fna i lbe i wih t LP1plce nt .None hees , Pli if a gue t tt r r c t e i
i nc a neft t he
a me s
t l s a ntf s r
ha hei a ke e rng
al tonsa e s t intbe us t y cli t tt dicos esf ied t a s t t tale d
legai
r ufk e
ca e he am ha he s l ur al o dvie hem ha lge
Skikba ks'we e t
sc c ' r d
bundld i o t i pr mi ' Thi Cour detr nes s h al gai t be
e nt he r e ums.
' s
t e mi
uc le tons o
s ns l s .Dr wn t a l ca concuson,Pli if 't or ofda a a ount t a c am t ti
e e e s a o ogi l
l i
antfs he y
m ges m
s o l i ha f
t y kne t c r sw e e ki kba ks t y woul have br a d a contac ualdut t pa . Los ng
he
w he ha ge r c c , he
d
e che
r t
yo y
i
a o r uniy t br ac a co r c ca m ot c tt e a c
n ppo t t o e h
nt a t l
ons iut
ogni a e f a ha m . U li at y,t
z bl r ud r
tm el he
dicl u espr de t Pl i if ba t rRI cli .
s os r ovi d o antfs r hei CO a ms
2.
Pl ntfs alegai do no esabls RI c us ton
ai if ' l tons
t t ih CO a a i
M orove, CO pr maec ustonrquie aç r telton'bewe nt ij ya s td
e rRI
oxi t a ai e rs d ec r ai ' t e he nur sere
di
a d teij ro c n u talg d. igev Ph e x Bo d & I d mn t Co,5 3U. 6 9 65
n h n u ius o d c le e Brd . o ni n
n e i . 5 S. 3 , 4
y
( 0 8 .nt s a e p an if fit e panh w o wh Dee a t' u p re mal n wiefa s
2 0 )l hi c s , litfs alo x li o r y fnd n s p r o td ia d r rud
p o ma ey c us d i ur e t be plce when t s m e i ur nce woul ha bee plc
r xi t l a e ns anc o
a d
he a
ns a
d ve n a ed
rg r ls o t ealg dfa . ed rc d a s 'o t ealg dij r h r i teLP1 a e n ,
e ade s f h lt e rud Th it t k u e' f h le e nu y e e s h
c
plc me t
nott s
he uppos y i c a e l te s s nti t m ai. Si epli tf sdonotC r c t Cour t a
edl nac ur t e t r e n he l nc a n if
t e t he
di
to ny
aleg tonsof ei nc wha s ve ,'hei RI cli sf i. S e nr Wel itI c Ou -fNe o k
l ai
r la e toe r't r CO am al e I e l n,n . to - - r
po
UCR RatsLii ,903F.Su 2d880,91 l ( D.Ca. 2)
e tg.
pp.
5- 6 C.
l201 .
Pl i if do no a qua e y a l ge ope a i or m a
a ntf s
t de t l le
r ton
nage e of a RI
m nt
CO
e e pr s
nt r i e
A s a fna dea h kne l f t r RI c a m s Pl i if m a no alega i n t t A RI
i l t
l or hei CO l i , a ntf s ke
l to ha
C
pa tci t d i t C r to orm a ge e 'ofa a lged RI e e prs . Se Re e v Er t
ri pa e n he t a i n
ope
na m nt' ny le
CO nt r i e e v s . ns
t Youn 507U. 1 1 ( 993) ARI i algedt ha pr de lnde- ac di urnc t
o
g,
S. 70, 83 1 . C s le o ve ovi d e rpl e ns a e o
Gr n Tr e,ie. t ha pe f med a s r ce i t cour e ofARI Snor busne sa tviis.
ee e . , o ve ror
e vi n he
s
C'
mal i s c i te
Pli if a g t t he ha s f e l a lge pa tcpa i i t o r tonofaRI e eprs
antfs r ue ha t y ve ufkinty le d ri i ton n he pe a i
CO ntr ie
bec us t y al et tDe e nt ha 'o rt ppedt bounda i oft l tm a ebusne sof
a e he leg ha f nda s ve tve se
he
res he egii t
i s
i s r n e' ypa i ge mmiso sa ds n n n tc st tlo tre )temitk ni r sin'n
n u a c 'b y n o s in n e dig oie ha C se ld h sa e mp e so 'i
f
Pl n if t tt a
aitf s ha he mount c r d f lnde - a ed i ur ncewe e l ii ae. Thes al tons
s ha ge or e rplc ns a
r egtm t
e legai
f i t m e tt r r m ent f m ai a w i ef aud be a e t di c os eswer a ct a e a f i
a l o e he equie
s or l nd r r
c us he s l ur
e c l t nd a l
r
t a t ly s
o c ua l uppor an cl m off a See Cohe 735 F. d a 604.
t y ai
r ud.
ns
3 t
Pli tfsFalt Stt a Cli f Tori l e f r e
a n if i o a e
am or tous nt re enc
W ihoutc edi t tabr c ofconta i nec s a yf rt rt tousi e f r ncecai
t
onc ng ha
ea h
r ct s e s r o hei ori nt re e
lm
,
Pl ntfsar t t he haveade t l pl dt tGr e Tr ebr ac d t rm orga a e nt
ai if gue ha t y
qua ey e ha e n e e he hei
t ge gr eme s
a d t a Dee a tARI itn in ly a d u j siibl c us d s c b e c e The alegatons
n h t fnd n
C n e to al n n u tfa y a e u h ra h s
l i
.
r ga di t tousi e f e e a eba e e iel on Pl ntfs m orga , t ni on t al gai n
e r ng ori ntrer nc r s d ntr y
ai if ' t ge ur ng he le to
t a ARI ha a alg dt d a tg o b sn s a dc n rcu l eains i l t teGre Tre
h t C s n le e i v n a e us u ie s n o ta t a rlto hpg wi h e n e
a
h
D e e nt pur ua t t m orga conta t ,' i l ng t û i nott be cha ge exor t
f nda s s nt o he
t ge
r c s ' nc udi he t ght
r
o
r d
biant
pr m i m s
e u
f f r d- ac i ur nc .' Co an ! 1 2.Un e Flrd lw, h we e ,
or o ce pl e ns a e ' mpli t
2
d r o ia a o v r
i e f r nc wihabusne sr a i hi a wih ac r tf ( sngl cl m bec us t prma
ntre e e t
i s eltons p nd t ontac onn $ i e ai
a
a e he i
f ci s i f i entonal nt r e enc w ih c r c ua r a i hi a i ento l nt r e e e
a e how ng or nt i i e f r e t ont a t l el tons ps nd nt i na i e f r nc
wih busne sr l to hi a e,i s t nc , t s m e. I r Pe l an, 201 W L 3 8 *1
t
i s e ai ns ps r n ubsa e he a ' n e ar m
'
0
431 25,
( . Fl Aug. 201 .M orove ,t Elve hCic thashedt t1 cl m f abra h of
M D. a.
27, 0) e r he e nt r ui
l ha $ ai or e c
a
i id c na ofgood f ih a f i de i c nnotbe m ant i d underFl i lw i t
mple ove nt
at nd a r alng a
i ane
orda a n he
a e ofabr c ofa e es t r ofac r c .'Ce uronAi Car ,I .v Unie Par e
bs nce
ea h n xpr s e m
onta t ' nt i
r go nc
td
cl
.
Se v Co.420F. 11 11 2( 1h Ci. ) se aloBr ggmannv NCOA Sel tl . 2009
r. ,
3d 46, 5 1 t r2005 ; e s ue
.
ec, nc,
W L l 3651,* ( D.Fl J 30,2009)(a . or ngl a e plusbl aleg tonsofa
87
6 S. a. une
s me)Acc di y, bs nt a i e l ai
br ac ofPli if m org ,t t tousi e fr nc cai agans ARI f is
e h
antfs' tage he ori ntre e e l m
i t C a l.
D.
Pl ntfs Uni tEmi hm e Cli I Gove ne ByAn Expr s Conta
ai if ' us
c nt am s
r d
es
r ct
To saeava l Flrd cam f ru j s e c me t ap an ifn e st p e d: 1 h
tt ib e o ia li o n u t mi h n , litf e d o la () e
c e rd abe f on dee nt ( dee ntkne oft be f ()dee nta ce edt
onfre
neh
fnda ; 2) fnda
w he neh; 3 fnda c pt he
be ttc erd; nd( iwasi q tbl unde t cic tnce f t dee ntt rti t
nei onfre a 4)t ne uia e r he rumsa s or he fnda o ean he
be ttw ihoutpa ng f i. Ve v T- obi USA, nc,564F. 1
ne i t
yi or t ga . M l
e
I '
3d 256,1 4 ( 1h Ci. )
27 1 t r 2009
-
7-
(ii Ro l s I c .Buln 9 S .2 8 0 8 6 ( a Dit Ct Ap 20 6) An u j s
ctng li , n .v t d, 51 o d 6 , 7 Fl. s. . p. 0 ).
n
a
nut
e ihme cai 'als ont s ng ofa e es co rc ' Valdsa,I .v.PD VSA Servs.,
nrc nt l m k ill he howi
f
n xpr s nta t ' i
nc
.
I . 42 F. pp' 862, 873( 1h Ci. 1. c us of cto i qua ico rc e sswheet
nc , 4 A x
1 t r 201 ) No a e a in n s- nta t xit r he
pari 'r a i hi i gove ne by a ex e s c r t l
tes el tons p s
r d
n pr s ontac . d
Hee Plitfs u j t mi lne tcam i b s do ARI Src ito alg db n f si
r, an if ' nus e cu n li s a e n C' e ep f l e e ei n
e
t
t f m off ndsf f c pl c i ur nc pr mi r l td t f c -plce i ur ncepolces
he or
u
or or e- a ed ns a e e ums e ae o or e a d ns a
ii .
Plitfs u j t n ihme t li fis eeb c u eii b s do awrte is rn ec nr c The
anif ' nus e rc n cam al h r e a s ts a e n i n n u a c o ta t
t
.
e itn e o wrte c n rcsta g v m te s b e tmatro te dipue d faste u j s
x se c f itn o ta t h t o e h u j c te f h s t ee t h n u t
e c e c am asama trofl . D imond ' 'De . Cor v M e c ieBank 989 So. 697
mi hm nt l i
te
aw a
'' v
S
p. . r antl
2d
,
( a Dit CtApp.
Fl. s. .
2008)
.
Th u j s e rc me t li as f isb c u epan if d n talg a yfcss o n
e nu t n ih n cam lo al e a s litfs o o le e n a t h wig
adie tpa e oft pr m i , orpr i c ponent s h asc m i sons by Pl ntfst
r c ym nt he e um
em um om
s uc
om s i ,
ai if o
ARI Flrd lw h sa(d rc pa me t r q ie n 'f ru j te c me tcams w hih
C. o ia a a l ie t y n ' e urme t'o nus mi h n li , c
i
r quie t tapl ntf ha ma aS r c pa e 't a de e nt
e r s ha
ai if s de f e t ym nt' o
di
f nda ,
o ewh c wo l b u j s
n ih ud e n u t
f t de enda t r t n. Kunz l
or he f nt o eai
emann v We l Far Bank NL ,201 W L 1
. ls go
,
A.
3
39913,*5 6
-
( D. a J n.1 201 (ii Vigii v.Ryl Gr ., 680F. 1 (11hCi. 2).
S. Fl. a 0, 3) ctng r lo
and p
3d 329 t r 201 ) The
Compl i al ge t tGr n Tr e ob ai d a pai f t LP1pr m i and t c m i s ons
ant le s ha ee e t ne nd d or he
e um
hat om s i ,
,
r i u a e pr mi
ens r nc e ums a ot rbe ft we epad by ARI t Gr e Tr orisa fla e.
nd he ne is r i
C o e n ee t fiit Thus
,
Plitfs u j s e c n cam fisSe Ku z l n , 201 W L 1 3, t*6( di t tt
an if ' nu t mi hme t li al. e n ema n 3
3991 a hol ng ha he
u j s e c me tcam i LPlc s f i b c u eS o s in
n u t mi h n li n
a e al e a s t mmiso
s
c
...
g s n tp i t gevc r b
wa l o ad o s r ie j y
teplitfl, u ise dt ei u a ec mpa yp y i'
h an it) b t n ta h ns rnc o n a s t'
)
.
Plitfsc ne dt t h yaee tte t pla teru j t n ih n cam i te
anif o tn ha t e r nild o e d h i nus e rc me t li n h
aler tve. we , ter l t a p nnisatr aiepe dn o u j s e rc me t li a p is
t na i Ho ver h ue h t e t len tv la ig f n u t n ih n cams p le
wher t r i unc rant r r ngwheherac r te ss Ast cour i Zar elav. Pa lcL(
e he e s e ti y ega di
t
ontac xit . he
tn r l
cf J
l e
'
I s r n eCo. xpan d,h ug Ru e8p r t atr aiepla ig S nu j s e rc me t li
n ua c
e lie to h l emis len tv e dn ,t n u t n ih n cam
a
c n onl bepl d i t a t r tvei one o m or pari c e tt e s e e ofa expr s c r c
a
y
ea n he le na i f
r e tes ont s he xi t nc
n
e s onta t
g v r igt es b e to ted s ue'a ti i n t h c s h r . p risd n tds t t e
o enn h u j c f h ip t, nd h s s o t e a e e e The a t o o ipue h
'
e
e se eofa e e scon r c gove ni t i i ur epolc a ee nt s t e t bl r me
xit nc
n xpr s
ta t
r ng her ns anc
iy gr me , o he quia e e dy
o u j s e c me ti n ta alb e 7 5F. u p. d 1 8 1 2 ( D. a 2 0 .
f nu t mi h n s o v ia l. 5 S p 2 21 , 2 7 S. Fl. 01 )
I .
V
Concl i
us on
For t r s ns s a e he e n,t Cour G RAN TS D e e nt s M o i and di m i s a l
he ea o t t d r i he
t
f nda '
ton
s s es 1
cai sa s redagans Def ntARI
l m s et
i t enda
C.
*
DO N E AN D O RD ERED i Cha ber a M i m i Fl i t
n
m s t a , orda, h'
.
y ofA ugus , 4.
t 201
FEDE O A.M
O
UN I
TED ST
SDI
STRI J G E
CT UD
Copi pr ded t
es ovi
o:
Couns lofRe d
e
cor
-
9-
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?