Blue v. Garda CL Southeast, Inc.
Filing
24
ORDER Granting Partial Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 7/11/2014. (bnt)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STM CT OF FLORI
DA
M i Di son
ami vi i
C as N um ber 1 21
e
: 4- 898- V - O R EN O
Cl M
RI RDO BU LE,
CA
Pli if
a ntf,
VS.
GARDA CL SOUTHEAST, l C.
N ,
De e nt
f nda .
ORDER GRANTI DEFENDANT' M O TI N FOR PARTI DI ISSAL O F
NG
S
O
AL SM
PLAI FF' CO M PLAI
NTI S
NT
THI CAUSE c m ebef et Cour u ar viw ofDe e ntsPa ta M oto f r
S
a
or he
t pon e e
f nda ' ri l i n o
Dimis ( E.7 ,fl onJune5. 4,i whihDee ntse t dimisCount 1 I,11
s sal D. ) ied
201 n c fnda e ks o s s
s , 1 1,
a t coleci a ton compone sofCount I a V , ofPli ifRiar Bul sCompli .
nd he l tve c i
nt
s V nd
a ntf c do e'
ant
THE COURT ha c i r t m oto , r po e,a t pe tne po tonsoft r c d a
s onsde ed he i n es ns nd he ri nt ri
he e or , nd
he e GRANTS Def ntsPa ta M oton f Dimis l Pl i if s c a m s f rbr c of
r by
enda ' ril i or s s a . a ntf ' l i o ea h
c nrc, n u te rc me t a dq a t m me uts o l b d s s e b c u ete ae
o ta tu j s n ih n , n u n u r i h u d e imis d e a s h y r
pre e byt FarLa StndadsAc (TLSA'ort $ t';he aesae1w cli
e mptd he i bor a r t S
' he t ' t y r tt a ams
Ac )
pr e e byt FLSA ,nvo d onl a as c ofr me e f a lged FLSA vi ai . The
e mpt d he
i ke
y s our e e di s or le
ol tons
c lc i a ton c
ole tve ci omponent ofCoursI a V oft Compli , mor r a e voi ofa
s
t V nd
he
ant
eove , r
d ny
a lga i de c i ng t cls Pl ntf pur rst r pr enta ar t r by dim is aswe l
le tons s rbi he a s ai if po t o e es nd e he e
s s ed
l.
1
.
Fac ualBac ound
t
kgr
Pl i ifRi r Bul he e s s D e e ntG a da CL Sout a t l ,ass tng vari
a ntf ca do e r ue
f nda
r
he s , nc. eri
ous
sae lw cai a s e ng unpad wag pur ua t t Fai LaborSt ndar Ac , 29 U . C.
t t a l ms nd e ki
i
es s nt o he r
a ds t
S.
j e s q.W ihouti ntfi adaernge, ai ifalgest thewoke f Defnda
201 t e t
de iyng t a Pl ntf le ha
r d or e nt
G a da asa non- xem pte pl e, a t tdurng hi empl ym e pe i , he wo ked wihoutt
r
e
m oye nd ha
i
s
o nt rod
r
t
he
pr rove tmer t f a lhour wor i e s of40perwee . Bas d on t e alega i ns
ope
ri a e or 1
s ked n xce s
k
e
hes l to
,
Pli ifa r t tGadahas ()bra he a ti idag e menf'( rti da i uia e
antf ve s ha r
: 1 e c d n ûmple r e
; 2) eane n neq tbl
b n ftfo Pli t f ( )b e u j sl e c e a d( )vo ae teFLS Dee d n Gad ,
e ei r m ani ; 3 e n n u ty mi h d; n 4 iltd h
f
A. fn a t r a
pu s ntRul 1 b)6) mo dt dimisCouns1I,a IlofPli ifsComplit whih
rua
e 2( ( , ve o s s
t ,I nd 1
antf
an, c
c prs s a e l w cl i s a w e last c l ctve a ton com pone s ofCount I and V ,
om i e t t a a m , s l he ole i c i
nt
sV
w hi h pr entf de alFLSA cl i s
c es e r
am .
I.
I
LegalSt
andar
d
Rul 1 b)6)oft Fe r Rul ofCi lPr dur pr de t tacompli ma be
e 2( (
he deal es
vi oce e ovi s ha
ant y
dimisdf fiur t saeacli uponwhihr ifma begrntd. d. Ci P.1 b)6)
s se or al e o tt am
c ele y
a e Fe R. v. 2( ( .
To s tvi a m oton t di m i s a c pl i m us c a n s t c en f c ualm a t r a c t d a
tr ve
i o s s , om a nt t ont i ufi i t a t
te , c ep e s
tu ,osaeacam f rrle ta i pa sbeo isfc . h rj v l b l 1 9S. .1 3 ,1 4
re t tt li o eif h t s lu i l n t a e As c ot . q a , 2 Ct 9 7 9 9
(
2009) A cli ha fca plusbiiywhe t pl ntf pla f t lc e t tal t
. am s a il a i lt
n he ai if e ds acua ontnt ha lows he
c t o d a t r as bl i e e et tt def nda i la e f rt m ic
our t r w he e ona e nf r nc ha he e nt s i bl o he s ondud aleg d. #.
l e f
W hieacompl ntat ke bya1 b)6)motont dimisdoesnotne ddetie fcua
l
ai tac d
2( (
i o s s
e ald a t l
a lgai ns pl i if ha an o i ton t pr det gr
le to , antfs ve
blga i o ovi he oundsoft re ilm e t r le wih
hei ntte nt o e if t
m or t n m e e l bel and c us ons a a f m ul i r cia i oft el m e sofa c us of
e ha
r a s
oncl i , nd or a c e t ton he e nt
a e
a tonwilnotdo. eBelAtantcCor v Twombl 550U. 5 570(
ci l
Se l l i p. .
y,
S. 44,
2007) W he a
. n
c pl ntf l s r oft s sanda d bec us i r le on f
om ai als ho t hi t r
a e t ei s
onnul c r c t tons a uns
ai e ia i
nd uppore
td
c l i ,aCour s ldim ist defcen c am sf rt i f iur t pr vi an a qua e
oncusons
t hal s s he i i t l i o he r al e o o de
de t
bassf t posi lt ofga i rle . eFe R. v. 1 b)6 .
i or he sbiiy rntng eif Se d. Ci P. 2( ()
111.
LegalA nal i
ys s
A.
Pl ntf' Cl msForBr ac OfAgre me ,Quant M e ui,and Unj t
ai ifs ai
e h
e nt
um r t
us
Enri entFai t St e C l m sU pon w hi R elef M ay be G ranted
chm
l o at ai
ch
i
1.
Pl ntf Cl msf Bre h OfAgr me ,Quant M e ui,And
ai irs ai or ac
ee nt
um r t
Unj tEnrc ntAr Duplcai OfPl ntf' FLSA Cl msAnd
us
ihme
e
i tve
ai ifs
ai
Preem pt By t FLSA.
ed
he
Thega
rvame ofPli ifsCompl nti asf l :( )Pl ntf alge ywor dove
n
antf
ai s olows 1 ai if le dl
ke
r
40hour pe we k;a ( Dee n ale ydi notpa Pli ifa t ove tmer t f al
s r e nd 2) fnda t lgedl d
y antf t he ri ae or l
hour wor d i exc sof40 pe we k.Pl i ifduplc t shi al ga i ac os a s isof
s ke n es
r e
antf
i a e s le ton r s ere
Count, we r puruan t bo h sa ea f r llw.l Count 1 l,a 11 s e ngr le
s ho ve , s t o t t t nd ede a a n
s , 1 nd 1, e ki ei f
unde e t bl t r e ofr c y,he a l ge t tDef nda di notç ope l pa Pl i iff r
r quia e heo i s e over
le s ha
e nt d
û
pr r y y a ntf o
a lhour w or d. The i Co I oft Com pl i ,Pl i t f a l ge t tD e e
l
s ke '
' n, n unt V
he
a nt a n i f le s ha f ndan G a da
t r
f ie t c pl w ih t FLSA S n t tPl i ifpe f m e s r c s a w or d i e s oft
a l d o om y t he
t ha a ntf r or d e vi e nd
i
ke n xce s he
ma mum hour pr de byt FLSA butnopr sonwa ma by( da t prperypa
xi
s ovi d he
ovii
s de Gar j o o l y
hi att rt oftmea onehaff alhour woke i exc soff t hour ( pe
m he ae i nd
l or 1 s r d n es ory s 40) r
w o kw e k aspr de i t FLSA .
r e
ovi d n he
'
'
Expr s i t cli a i tDef nda i t msofbr a ofi i d a e nt
e sng he a ms ga ns
e nt n er
e ch mple gr eme ,
q a tm me u to u j te rc me t al t r n e te esae1w camsmaeilyd sic
u nu r i r nus n ih n f is o e d r h s tt a li
,
tral itn t
f om t FLSA c ai br hti Countl ,a i ke a n i CountV ,ofPl i t f s
r he
l m oug n
V nd nvo d gai n
a n if
Com pl i .Bot t FLSA c ai s a t c ai sofC o s 1 1 a I lpr s ntt s m e m a e i l
a nt
h he
l m nd he l m
unt , 1 nd I e e he a
t ra
a l ga i :t dif r nce i t w a Pl i ifc a s fe t s cl i s The FLSA ,
le tons he f e e
s he y a ntf l s ii d he e a m .
howe ,
ver
pr cl ss h a e f tt e nm iscl msa pr dur s
e ude uc n for o nd- t ai nd oce e .
Se ton 21 oft FLSA i t excusve r medyf enf cngrght c eae unde t
ci
6 he
s he l i e
or or i i s r td
r he
Ac. eTombr lov USX Cor ,763F.Supp.5 5 ( D.Al 1 ) lA.amatroflw,
tSe
el .
p.
41, 45 N. a. 991.i s te a
g1pli ifc l cr
a antf amot icumve t e l i rme prs rbe byConges bya s ri
nt he xcusve e dy e ci d
r s s e tng
e u v ln saelw camsi a dto t (1FLSA cam. 1
q i ae t tt a li n d iin o a
li ' d.Co rsds s d p iaiesae
'
u t imis u lc tv tt
1 co mon l w cli whe et y r y o pr oft s m ef ct.Asone c tsae ia
aw m
a a ms
r he el n oof he a a s
our tt d,'
pl ntf ma notpla unde at or ofunus enrc ntt a dt saut yfame kof
ai if y
ed
r he y
j t ihme o voi he tt or r wor
teF A. fnd n s mo int ds s Plitfs u j t mi h n cam a ir ltst a y
h LS Dee a t' to o imis an if ' nus e c me t li s t eae o n
cl i off iur t pa m i m um w a s orove tm e undert FLSA i G RAN TED . Bout r v
am
a l e o y ni
ge
ri
he
s
'
'
hne .
Clv andCon t.I . 2011W L 297 68, t* ( Md. ul 21,2011;s ealoHel v.
e el
sr nc,
68 a 7 D. J y
) e s
m
Al rwood Gr ,I .696F.Supp. 1 1 ( D.Ca.2009)(heFLSA S e s
de
s p. nc,
2d 057, 076 N. l
t
f empt
pr
c mmo lw camsta s e rme isfrrg t p oe tdb teFLS (u ha mii m wa e
o n a li h t e k e de o ih s r tce y h
A s c s nmu
g
a d o e t pa )'.nBoel v CO1T lc m,L C, o e a e t cour dim is d t
n v ri
me y ' I tl .
)
o
ee o L fr x mpl, he t s s e he
pli tf ssae lw c am sf qu um me ui, u j s e rc me t a db e c o c n rc a
a n if t t a l i or ant
r t nu t n ih n , n ra h f o ta t s
pr mpt byt FLSA be us t yweei e cae ong ee ntsalgedfiur t
ee ed he
ca e he r l di td dlfnda ' le al e o
pr
c
ompe aeherf hour wor d i e es of40 hour ;ar quie e i
ns t
or
s ke n xc s
s e r m nt mpos d by t FLSA
e
he
gn l( h F A prvie tee cu ierme yf rvoain o i ma d ts'2010 W L
a d t e LS o d s h x lsv e d o ilto f t n ae '
l
s
.
3724202,a *4( . Te Se .21 201 .Uli tl apli r di ofPli ifssaelw
t W D. x. pt , 0) tmaey, an ea ng
antf' tt a
c a m sr ve t y ar a l wihoutadoubt de nde on afndi oft s
l i e al he e l, t
, pe nt
i ng he amevi a i oft
oltons he
F A. e Co l a ! 1 1 25 3 4 - 5. eeo e t i Co r fn sipr d n t f l w
LS S e mp . t ! 3, 9, , 4, 4 4 Th rf r ,hs u ti d t u e t o ol
o
Bou hne , elo,andt ot rc esa os t c r t pr bi pli if fom a di
t r Bot l
he he as cr s he ounty hat ohi t antfs r
voi ng
t pr edu e a s t ntver l oft FLSA t oug arf pladi .
he oc r s nd ubsa i ues he
hr h tul e ng
TheCour not st tPli tf a guest the i pe m it d t pur uehi cai sunde t
t e ha a n if r
ha
s r te o s
s lm
r he
FLSA aswelason at or ofbr ac ofa e m e ba e on t hol ng i Wvp y v
l
he y
e h gr e nt s d he di n r .
Ci o
tf
y
T l ga. F. 1 ( 1hCi.994) Thi agume i unperua i TheElvent Cicui
alade 24 3d 337 1 t r1 . s r nt s
s sve
e h r t
.
ha ex i ty lmie Wv r ' hol ng,e ai ng t tt de son i a er onl a es e t
s plcil i td e .p s di xpl ni ha he cii n dv y y ddr s s he
quesin ofwhe he asa el w c r tcli i pr e pt wher t c r c i quesi i a
to
t r tt a ontac am s e m ed
e he onta t n
ton s n
e es e c r tt te i typr de t te oye wilbepai ove tm ei ac or nce
xpr s d ontac ha xplcil ovi s ha mpl es l
d ri n c da
wiht FLSA . e eg.
t he
Se . Johns v W e l nt I . 106- 2430on . lpoi , nc , : CVODE,2009 W L 87533 a
25 t
* ( D. .M a.30,2009) Hee Pl ntf sCompl nti de dofa alegai t ts h
22 N. Ga r
. r, ai if
ai s voi ny l ton ha uc
d gr e e 'wase e s d o t ta t nnsofs h ag ee e whe e e iil pr ded. I i
t e m nt'
a
xpr s e r ha ny e
uc r m nt r xplcty ovi
ts
w holy di tgui ha e.
l si s bl
2.
TheFLSA Pr de An Ade
pvi s
quat Re e For Pl ntf Cl m sof
e m dy
ai irs ai
Br ac ofI id Agr eme ,Quant M e ui,and Unj t
e h mple
e nt
um r t
us
Enri ent
chm .
Cl msf br a h ofi id ag ee nt q a tm me ut a du j s e rc me taeal
ai or e c
mple r me , u n u
r i, n n u t n ih n r l
s
ynony ous t y a ea lcai si e t desg t pr dear
m : he r 1 l m n quiy i ned o ovi
emed whe e onepa t wa
y
r
ry s
u j sl e c e S ePo ey v Ec e dCop.4 3F. u p. d 1 7 1 3 1 ( D. a 2 0 )
nu t mi h d. e s l . k r r , 3 S p 2 28 , 31 - 4 S. Fl. 0 6 .
y
Bec us t y a e alba e i equia et or onl , r c r underPl i t f scl i s f br e
a e he r l s d n
t bl he y y e ove y
a n if a m or ea h
ofi ple a e m e , ant me ui, a du j te rc n i o l a ia l wh r te ei n
m i d gr e nt qu um r t n nus n ihme t s ny valbe e e h r s o
a ua e r m e a l w . isubihi nt1Cor . v Car nalTe ieSals l . 1 F. 1
deq t e dy t a M t s 1 ' p . di
xtl e , nc, 4 3d 507,
1 8- 9( 1hCi.1 . ursha a ese t c ptofSa quaer med a lw'i a
51 1 1 t r 994) Co t ve ddr s d he once
tde t e y t a 'n
va it ofco e sa ha hel t tt a ia lt ofm one a y da a svi a at r tve
rey
nt xt nd ve d ha he va lbiiy
t r m ge a n le nai
cli de
am monsr t t ta uaer medisa lw e s. Se M ar i z v W e r us r M org.
taes ha deq t e
e t a xit e
tne . ye hae e
t
Co.9 9F. u p. 5 1( D. l . 9 6 ( imisngu j s e c me t li b c u e
, 5 S p 1 1 S. F a 1 9 ) d s si n u t mi h n cam e a s
tg li if f it alget tana quaerme a lw doe notexif'.
splantfs al o le ha de t e dy t a
s
s)
l t i tnta ton,heFLSA pr desa a quaer m e t oug whi h Pl n ifm a
n he nsa c i t
ovi
n de t e dy hr h
c aitf y
pur uea c am sheha f runpad ove tm edurng hi empl e wih Ga da. Not bl i hi
s ny l i
so
i
ri
i
s
oym nt t r
a y, n s
Re p n e Plitf a tal i lct c n e e t t i cam f ru j s e rc me t co n 11
s o s , anif cu l mpiil o c d s ha h s li o n u t n ih n t u t 1)
y
y
ma bedim is f t sr as Bec us ala qua er m e notonl e ss butha be n
y
s s ed or hi e on. a e t de t e dy
y xit ,
s e
s c fc lypld asabassf rt sa ton i Pli ifsCompli , t Cour once a i
pe ii a l e
i o hi c i n antf
ant he
t
ga n
dee mi t tPli tf sc am sf br c ofi ple a ee nt q a t m me u ta du j t
tr nes ha a n if l i or ea h m i d gr me , u n u
r i, n nus
e ihme s ul bedim is d.
nrc nt ho d
s se
3.
Pl ntf Faist Es abls t he i E nt ted To R e i U nde St e
ai if l o t i h hat s i l
lef
r at
Law
To s vi a m oton t di m i s a c pl i m us s tf r h f c ua c e f om w hi h t
ur ve
i o s s , om a nt t e o t a t l ont nt r
c he
Co tm a dr w a r as na e i e e t tt de e nti la e f t m i co uc alege .
ur y a
e o bl nf r nce ha he f nda s i bl or he s nd t l d
Ashcr .f v I ,55 U. 662, (
o t . qbal 6 S. 678 2009) çl e dbaer ct sof heee nt ofac us of
.s- a r e ial t lme s
-hr
a e
a on,s
di uppore by m er c us y s a e e s do nots fc '1 ,s ealo BelAtantc
td
e oncl or t t m nt ,
ufi e. d. e s l l i
' .
Cor v Twombl 550U. 5 555(
p. .
y,
S. 44, 2007)(CAIpli ifsoblgai t pr det Sr unds
tg antf
i ton o ovi he g o '
ofhi Sntte e t r le r quie m or l be sa concusons a a f m ul c r cia i of
s e ilm nt o e if e r s e a l nd
l i , nd or ai e t ton
t ee e sofaca e ofa ton wilnotdo.'. r t sae1w camsrie i Pli ifs
he lm nt
us
ci
l
' Hee,he tt a li as d n antf'
)
Compli a lunior l afim t tDef ntsa tonsvi a e t hel of.t Stt of
ant 1 f m y fl ha
'
enda ' c i
olt d t aws ..he a e
t
Fl i 'Pl i if howe r f ist s cii aly c t t r er nc lw
orda. antf,
'
ve , a l o pe fc l ie he ef e ed a
,
r l ,orr gul ton eiher
ue
e ai t
i hi Com pli ori hi Re po et t sM oton. The o y die r e e i Pl ntf'
n s
a nt n s s ns o hi
i
nl r ct ef r nce n ai ifs
pladi t a pe tne l w i t t FLSA . The ef e i addii t beng duplc tve a
e ngs o ny ri nt a s o he
r or , n
ton o i
ia i nd
pr mpt by t FLSA,dimi s lofCount II, a IlofPli ifsCompli i wa r nt by
ee ed he
s sa
s 1 nd 1
antf
ant s ra ed
Pli ifsf l et gi Def ntGa daf i a pr pe notc oft cl i s br
antf aiur o ve enda
r ar nd o r i e he a m
oughta ns i
gai t t
.
B.
Pl i ifsFLSA Cole tveAc i Ale i
a ntf '
lc i
ton l gatons
I Count I a V ofhi Compl nt Pl ntf a lgesvi a i oft FLSA a i t
n
s V nd
s
ai , ai if le
oltons he
ga ns
De e ntGa daon be fofhi s fa ot r i i lry st t 'Thi Cour fndst tt
f nda
r
hal
m el nd he s l mia l iuaed'. s
s
t i ha he
c l c i a ton c pone sofCount I a V s d bedim is d b
ole tve c i om
nt
s V nd houl
s se
e us Pl ntf'
ca e ai ifs
Compl i f l t plad o de i a atrbut oft a lge sm ia l st t e oye s a
ant ais o e r fne ny ti es he le d i l ry iuaed mpl e , nd
,
t r f e, hea lga i f i t sa ea cai f r i a a c lc i a ton.
he e or t le tons a l o tt l m or elef s ole tve c i
TheFLSA per t ac lc i ac i t bem ant i d a ns a e pl rby a one
mis ole tve ton o
i ane gai t ny m oye
ny
o m or e oye sf a on be foft m s vesa o he empl yee sm ia l s t t Se
r e mpl e or nd
hal he el nd t r
o s i l ry iua ed. e
M or n v.Fami DolarSt e , I 551F. 1 ,
ga
l
y
l or s nc,
3d 233
1 5 ( 1h Ci. 0 8 (ii 29U.. j
2 8 1 t r 2 0 ) ct
ng
SC.
21 (). ly e mus b S i lryst ae 'rg r igter o r q ie n sfrt ec s t
6 b) Empo e s t e t mi l iu td'e a dn h ij b e urme t o h a e o
s a
pr e a ac lc i aci n. Se i W he pl i if brng a FLSA a ton f a o be l of
oc ed s ole tve to
ed
n antfs i n
c i or nd n ha f
t m s l and ot rsm iary st t d e pl es t c
he eves
he i l l iua e m oye , he ompli ts d i c ewho t e o he
a n houl ndiat
hos t r
e oye sa e a alegef c st twoul enttet m t r i . See i H e e,how e r
mpl e r , nd l a t ha
d il he o elef
d r
ve ,
Pli ifsCompli c ansnodesrptonoft j dutesoft aleg smial st t
antf'
ant onti
ci i
he ob i
he l ed i lry iuaed
e pl e a ha no a l ga i c e ni t pay pr s ons oft e pr
m oye s nd s
le tons onc r ng he
ovi i
hos opos em pl
ed
oyees
.
TheCompl i conti no f t bassby whi h t as es whehe Pli
ant a ns acual i
c o s s
t r a
ntf a t o he
if nd he t r
e pl e a esmia l st t . Acc di y,t sCour fndst tPl i ipsc lc i ac i
m oye s r i lry iuaed
or ngl hi
t i ha antf ole tve ton
a lgai nss d bedim is d. D i z v Gar CL Sout s , l ,Cas N o.1 1 cv- 1 U 1
le to houl
s se
a . da
hea t nc. e
: 2: 2 746- 7
( D.Fl 201 ,se aloJ',' , .Cr xv Ge ntch I .201 U. Dit LEXI 8
S. a. 2). e s c , St oi . ne e , nc, 2 S. s.
go
S 6742, 7
6-
( . Fl. 01 )
M D. a 2 2 .
I .
V
Conc us o
l in
Fort f e ng r as ,t sCour DI I
he or goi e ons hi
t SM SSES Count 1 1 a IlofPl ntf s
s , 1 nd I
ai if
Co an wi p eu ie Th s camsaed pl ai a dp e mp e b teF A, ih
mplit t rj dc . e e li r u i tve n r e td y h LS wh c
h
c
pr desa a qua er m e a lw f rt Pl ntf.M o eove , t eCount ofPl ntf s
ovi n de t e dy t a o he ai if r r hes
s
ai if
Compl i f i t s tbl putDe e nton notc a t t l wsi al ge y vi a e .
ant al o uia y
f nda
i e s o he a t le dl olt d
l a ton,Pli ifsCompl i f ist a qua ey s tf t a cai f rr i a a
n ddii
antf
ant al o de t l e orh l m o elef s
c l vea on unde t FLSA. c ldi a on c
oledi di
r he
The ole ve di ompone sofCount I a V a e
nt
s V nd r
ac or ngl DI I
c di y SM SSED. ti her by
l s e
ADJ
UDGED t tCount 1 1 a 1IofPli if sCompli ta e DI I
ha
s , 1 nd 1
antf
a n r SM SSED wih
t
p eu ie a dtec le tv a to c mp n n so Co n sI a V a eDI M I ED a wel
rj dc , n h olci e cin o o e t f u t V nd r S SS s l.
.
D ON E AN D O RDERED i Cha be s a M i m i Fl i , t s
n
m r t a , orda hi
'
,
da ofJ y,201
y
ul
4.
,'
,-
jw, .
s y .
.
z
e
sl
o
'
. . ..
.ox
<(,' ' - .
..e- ' . .
:.-( - .
- ( ) .
FEDERI
CO . O
M
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI J D GE
CT U
Co espr de .
pi ovi d'
Couns lofR e or
e
c d
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?