Blue v. Garda CL Southeast, Inc.
Filing
25
ORDER granting 10 Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 7/14/2014. (bnt)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M im iDi son
a
vii
Cas Num be 1 21 Cl M O RENO
e
r: 4- 898- VRI
CARD O BULE,
Pl ntf,
ai if
GARDA CL SOUTHEAST,l ,
NC.
D e e nt
f nda .
/
ORDER GR ANTI DEFENDANT' M OTI FO R JUDGM ENT ON TH E
NG
S
ON
PLEADI
NGS AS TO CO UNTS I AND V
V
THI CAU SE ca ebe or t Cou tupon r viw ofDe e ntsM o i f rJ
S
m
f e he r
e e
f nda ' ton o udgme
nt
o t Pla ngs( E.10 ,fldonJune6.
n he e di D. ) ie
2014,i whih Deenda s kst dimisCount
n c f nt ee o s s
s
I a V ofPli tf Ri a do Bul ' Co pli t whih as e tc am spur uan t t FarLa r
V nd
a n if c r
es m an , c sr li
s t o he i bo
Stnda dsAc, U. C.
a r
t29 S. j201e s q..Pli ifheec e st tDee ti amot c rir
te
antf r onc de ha fndan s
or a re
t y
ans ai
s
i
ogeher t
s j tt t j iditon oft Secrear of Tr portton.Thi concesson,t t wih
ubec o he urs ci
he
Pli ifsa s ri t thea De e
antf s e ton ha
nd f ndan e
t ngag i i e saecomm e c durnghi e pl
ed n ntr t t
re i
s m oyme
nt
t r ,r nde s Pl ntf' FLSA alegai ns una lng. The Se r tr of Tr ns ra i has
e m e r ai ifs
l to
vaii
c ea y
a po tton
una g
mbi uousyesa ihedt te pl e s hasPl i ifa er s i ef , nd a f c t s f t
l t bls ha m oye s uc
antf r e ponsbl or a fe t he a e y
of mot ve ces He e, ve ac e i t f c salege i t Com pli a tuea c t i
, or hi l . nc e n c ptng he a t l d n he
a nt s r nd onsnzng
t m i t lghtmos f vor bl t Pli if t sCour de e m i st tPl i ifi note il dt t
he n he i
t a a e o a ntf,hi
t t r ne ha antf s
ntte o he
r le hcs ksi Coun sI a V bec us a am at rofl w, wasa a1 tmese mptfom t
e if ee n
t V nd
a e, s
te
a he
t li
xe
r he
o tm er quie e soft Fa rLa St nda dsAct vit of hemot c nie e mpton. s
veri e r m nt he i bor a r
by rue t
or a r xe i Thi
Cour a cor ngl GRANTS Def nda ' M otonf J
t c di y
e nts i or udgm e on t Pl a ngsa DI I
nt he e di
nd SM SSES
t sc e.
hi as
Fact Background
ual
Pli tf Ri a do Bul he es De e
a n if c r
e r ues f ndan Ga daCL Sou hea t l , s e tngva i sae
t r
t s, nc.a s ri
rous t t
lw cli andseki unpadwag purua t t FarLa Stnda dsAc,29U. C.j e
a ams
e ng
i
es s nt o he i bor a r
t
S. 201 t
se W iho i ntf ngada er ng Pl i ifa lgesi hi Co pl ntha hewor df De e nt
q. t ut de iyi
t a e, antf le n s m ai t t
ke or f nda
Ga daasano e mpte pl esa t tdurng hi e pl
r
n- xe
m oye nd ha i
s m oyme pe i hewor wihoutt
nt rod,
ked t
he
pr pe ove tmer t f a1ho swor d i e e sof40pe we Thi Cour pr vi l dim is d
o r ri a e or 1 ur
ke n xc s
r ek. s
t e ousy s s e
t sae 1w cai sofPli ifsCompli , c co prs d Count 1 I,a 11 a dimis d
he t t a l m
a ntf'
ant whih m ie
s , l nd 1, nd s s e
t c l ci a ton compone so Coun sI and V. e e t Cour dimis st r m ande of
he ole tve c i
nt f
t V
H r , he
t s s e he e i r
t Compl n ,hati ,
he
ait t s Count I a V,a t e dimi s st a ton.
s V nd
nd her by s s e he c i
1
.
Le St
gal andar
d
Rul 1 c oft Fe r lRul ofCi lPr dur pr de t t a a tmeafe t
e 2() he de a es
vi oce e ovi s ha, t ny i
tr he
pla i g ha eco e , olnga i d e n td lytila ypat ma mo f r u g n o te
e d n s v ls d s o s t o s o ea ra , n ry y ve o j d me t n h
pl di . ealoBr e Facor I .v.Unie St e 957F.
ea ngs Se s adly t , nc
td ats,
Supp.1 1 ( . Fl.
259, 260 M D. a
1 ) l udg ntont pl di unde Rul 1 c i a opraewhe t ear nomae ilfcs
997.k me
l
he ea ngs r e 2() s ppr it n her e
tra a t
i d s ue a j d me tma b rn ee b c nsdeigt es bsa c o t pla ig a d a y
n ip t, nd u g n y e e d r d y o i rn h u tn e f he e dn s n n
j iil n tc df cs'Ho se v Rie a 2 2F.d6 5 7 0( 1h Ci. 0 2 .
udcal oie a t. r ly . v r , 9 3 9 , 0 1 t r 2 0 )
y
'
A Rul 1 c moi li s j tt t s me sa r asamoton t dimisunde Rul
e 2() ton ks ubec o he a tndad
i o s s
r e
1 b)6 'Doev Mys e l , F. 41 418( t Ci. ) s ealoThunde
2( ().
'
. pac , nc.528 3d 3,
5h r 2008 . e s
,
rWave l .v
, nc .
Car valCor , F.
ni
p.954 Supp.1 1 ( D. a.
562, 564 S. Fl 1997)TheCour d tac e t fct alge
.
tt
mus c pt he a s le d
i t c pli a tue a c tue t m i t lghtm os f vor bl t t nonm o ng pary.
n he om a nt s r nd onsr he n he i
t a a e o he
vi
t'
'
Ca n nv Ci o s Pam Be c , 5 F.d 1 9 1 01( 1hCi. 0 ) Ho ve,h Co r i
n o . t fWe t l a h 2 0 3 2 9, 3 1 t r 2 01 . we rt e u t s
y
no '
t'
boundt ac e astuealgal
o c pt r
e concuson c he a af c ual l ton. Be l l i Cor
l i ouc d s a t alegai ' l Atantc p.
'
v Twombl 1 S. .1 1 4- ( ) Fore mpl,hee,Pli ifsaleg tont thei a
.
y, 27 Ct 955, 96 65 2007 . xa e r antf l ai ha s
no e mp!e oye i pr pe l e ude fom t Cour' a yssbec e is a
n- xe
mpl e s o ry xcl d r he
ts nal i aus t mount t a
so n
uns
uppored l galc us on and,t ,i note il t t as um pton oft t A r vi w oft
t e
oncl i
hus s
ntted o he s
i
nzh. e e
he
r mani ale tonscarfest dimis lunde Rul 1 c i pr rbe us Cti ce rt tt
e i ng lgai l ii hat s sa
r e 2() s ope ca e t s la ha he
i
pl i ifw o d notbe e il t r i unde a s toff c st tc d be pr d c i t ntw ih
a ntf ul
ntted o elef
r ny e
a t ha oul
ove ons s e
t
t ale tons ' H or ly,292 F. a 700.
he l ga i .
' se
3d t
Pl ntf c endst tD e e
ai i f ont
ha f ndan pr e sm a t sout i oft pl adi i isM oton a
t es nt ter s de he e ngs n t
i nd
t eM oin s o l te eo eb src e o te tda amo in frs mma yj d me t TheCo r
h to h u d h r f r e tik n r r ae s to o u r u g n .
ut
det nni s howeve ,t tt D e e nt sM oton pr ry r i onl on t a l ga i s tf t
e ne ,
r ha he f nda '
i
ope l eles y
he le tons e orh
i Plitf s Co an a d Dee d n ' An we .A mo in frj d me to t epla ig i
n anif mplit n fn a ts s r
to o u g n n h e dn s s
a o i t i an a ton t di m i saco pl nt n i i or a e pl adaf i tvede e es s nc
ppr pr a e n c i o s s
m ai whe t nc por t s e
fnna i
f ns , i e
anaf im a i def ns i e ema t t c pl i . eBr
fr tve e e s xt l l o he om a nt Se ownmar l , LC v Com e ypar ne s,
kFims L
.
d
t r
68 F. 687(t Ci. 2)
2 3d
7h r 201 .
I1.
LegalA nal s
ysi
Pl i ifi e m ptfom t FLSA ' ove tm er r m e spur ua t t M ot rcar i rA c
a ntf s xe
r he
S r i equie nt
s nt o he
o
re t
e mpton. M ot CarirAc Exe i t t FaiLaborStnda dsAc a iswhee: 1 t
xe i The or re t mpton o he r
a r t pple
r ( )he
e pl e C e e pl d by c r i r w hos t a pora i of pa s
m oye s û m oye
ar
a re s
e r ns tton
s enge s or pr ry by m ot
r
ope t
or
v hil i s be tt te Se rtr sj rs it n u d rt e Mo o Care Acgl'a d ( )t
e ce s u j c o h ceay' u idci n e h
o
t r rir tn' n 2 he
e pl s S
m oyee i ge i a tvii ofa c r c e die ty a f c i t s f t of ope a i ofm o or
enga n c i tes
ha a t r r c l f e tng he a e y
r ton
t
ve cl i t ta por a i on t publc hi a of pas e r or pr t i i e s a e or
hi es n he r ns t ton
he
i ghw ys
s nge s
opery n nt r t t
f rinc mmec wi i t eme nigo t eM oo Care Ac. Mc ny ev Fl o imiI c,
o eg o r e t n h a n f h tr rir t' l tr . x fM a , n .
h
'
No. 20030- V,2008W L 45
08CI
41017, t* ( D. a. t 8,
a 4 S. Fl Oc. 2008)( tngBae v.Wel Far
quoi
z
ls go
Ar e r c Cor , F. l 1 - ( 1hCi.1 ). amatroflw,he Dee nt
mor dse vie p.938 2d 80, 8182 1 t r 991)As te a t n, fnda
Gad ( ihi s be tt t j rs ito o t eS c eayo Tr n p rain i e e tfo te
r a wh c s u j c o he u idcin f h e rtr f a s o tto ) s x mp r m h
overi e pr sons oft FLSA i r a i t Pli tf be aus whie De enda a Pl ntf
tm
ovii
he
n elton o a n if c e
l f nt nd ai if
e ge i i e saec me c unde t Ac , antf e gedi a i te afe tng t s f t of
nga d n ntr t t om r e
r he t Pl i if nga
n ctviis f c i he a ey
m o o ve c e . c nt e,
t r hil s M l yr 2008 W L 4541 ,a *
017 t 4.
A.
Pl ntf and D e e
ai if
f ndantEngage I I er t e C om m e c
d n nt s at
re
Pl i ife es l co e t the a Def nda we e e age i i e sae c
antf xpr sy nc des ha
nd
e nt r ng d n ntr t t omm e c
r e.
Par gr ph 30 ofPli if sCompli sa e :
a a
antf'
ant tt s
Ata1tmespe tne t t sCompli , enda ope ae a a o ga za i whi h s l
1i
ri nt o hi
ant Def nt r td s n r ni ton c els
a o m a ke siss r i sa org
nd/ r r t t e vee nd/ oodst c t
o usomer fom t oughout heUnie Stt sa
s r hr
t
t d a e nd
a s pr de iss r i s f r go s d a ta pored fom ac os sa e lnesofo he
lo ovi s t e vce o ods ol nd r ns t r
r s tt i
t r
sae a t De e ntobt nsa s i t f
tt s, nd he f nda
ai nd olcis undsfom non- ordas c , c ep sf
r
Fl i our es a c t unds
f o non- orda s c s us t e ni t a m i s o goi ove s a e lne t do is
rm
Fl i our e , es el pho c r ns s i ns ng
r tt i s o
t
busne s ta m isf
i s , r ns t undsouti t Stt ofFl i ,and ot m ie r gulry e
sde he a e
orda
he s e a l ngag i
es n
i e s a e c m e ce pa tc a l w ih r pe t ise pl es
nt r t t om r , r i ul ry t es ct o t m oye .
SeePli ifsCompli at!30. ai ifsCompl ntfrhe alge t thi çwor f ( r q
antf'
ant
Pl ntf'
ai u t r le s ha s s k or Gada
lkewie afcsi e sae c
i s fe t ntrtt ommec '1 a ! 32.Thee aleg i esa ih t tPli ifand
re.' d. t
s l atons tbls ha antf
Def nda w e e bot e ge i i t r t t c m e ce, uli lng t tr tpr oft M ot Ca re
e nt r
h nga d n n e s a e om r f fli he i s ong he
or r i r
Act mptont t Fai La rStnda dsAc . eAiav. s NatonalVendi 201 U . Dit
Exe i o he r bo a r
t Se r Be t i
ng, 2 S. s .
LEXI 1 534, 24( D. a. tbe 1 201 (i ngnoditnci bewee t dei tonof
S 48 * S. Fl Oco r 6, 2) fndi
si ton t n he tnii
i e saec
ntrtt ommeceunde t M CA ort FLSA)
r
r he
he
.
l addii t Pli ifsj ci a s i Elve h Cic tprce ntesa ihest t
n ton o antf' udi al dmison, e nt rui e de tbls ha
Pli ifsa i te f De e
antf ctvii s or f ndan ,t ti,r ns tngc r y, n, hec , ot rvaua e
t ha s ta pori urenc coi c ks and he l bl s
be we nba ,heFe r Re e'eBa ,ba
t e nks t
de al s l
v nk nkpr s i c nt r , he c s ngf ciii a ot r
oce sng e e s c ck a hi a ltes nd he
l to ,i veta pora i ofpr ry i i e sa ecommer easdetne byt M CA . Baez
ocai ns nvol r ns tton
ope t n nt r tt
c
i d
he
Wel Far Ar e Se vie Cor ., 9 8F. 1 0 1 l8 ( 1h Ci.1 91. k Plitf,h
ls go mor d r c
p 3 2d 8 , 8 - 2 1 t r 9 ) Lie an if te
e o esi Bae s l d a drve - r a mes e r - r andwor d onl wihi Fl i ,
mpl ye n z ewe s i rgua ds nd
s nge sgua ds
ke
y t n orda
ta pori c ksa c r nc s m eofwhih wa uli t l boundf ro - -t t de tnai ns
r ns tng hec nd ure y, o
c
s tma ey
o utofsa e si to .
1 .Th Ba zCo r g a td s mmayj d me tf rd fn a tW el Fag ,ûn i s c c n u t
d e e u t r n e u r u g n o ee d n ls r o dng u h o d c
c tt t i ert t c
onsiu es nt sae omm e c unde t M CA,a t Elven h Cicui afimed. See i a 181.
re
r he
nd he e t r t fr
d. t
B.
D e endanti a M ot Car e Cover by t M ot C ar i r A c
f
s
or
ri r
ed
he
or
re
t
I i a s unc e t t t De e nt Ga da i a r se e c r c ca r wih t
t s lo
ont sed ha
f nda
r s egit r d onta t nie t he
De rm e ofTr ns tton a he e or m a i
pa t nt
a porai ndt r f e y nvoket M ot Ca rerAd Exe i ot Fai
he
or ri
mptont he r
La St r A c .Se , e g. Bae ,938 F. a 18 ($ heper tis by t gntrtt
bor anda ds t e . , z
2d t 2 i(
T)
mi sued he l esae
CommeceCommison)i caest turs ci ha ar dybee e rie ' . l Defnda
r
s i ndi t ha j iditon s lea
n xecs d.) Alof e nt
'
Ga da' drve / es e r f lunde t Sec e a y ofTr ns tton' J iditon be us t r
r s i rm s nge s al
r he r t r
a porai s urs c i
ca e hei
e oy e dute i vol t s f t ofm o orvehi eswe ghi o r10,000 po
mpl m nt i s n ve he a ey
t
cl
i ng ve
unds SA FETEA .
LU Tec ca Cor e t o A c of2008,Pub. L. 1 244,
hni l r c i ns t
1 0- j306()a ( ; t t 29U. C.j207.
a nd c)Noe o
S.
C.
Pl ntf A c i tesA f e t Saf t O fM ot V e c e
ai irs tvi i
f ct he e y
or hi l s
De e nts drve s a m e s nge s a e e ge i a tvii t t die ty a f c t
f nda ' i r nd s e r r nga d n c i tes ha r c l fe t he
o r tona s f t of a mor d ve ces The Se ea y of Tr ns tton ha de e ne t t
pe a i l a ey
r e
hi l .
cr tr
a pora i
s t nni d ha
e oye who( )d i mot ve ce ;( rdeonamoedtu ksi ca cte ot rt nt to
mpl es
1 rve or hils 2) i
r r r c n pa iis he ha ha f
drve, nd( l da unl dve cl ,r r ponsbl f , ndaf thes eyofmoorve ces
i ra 3) oa nd oa hi es ae es i e or a fec t aft , t hil .
29 C. R.jj782. b)1,782. Cl i r' ,78 4 Cs i r Hepes',78 5 (sz r') The
F.
2( ( )
3 Drves' 2. Drve s l r' 2. û oades'.
)
)
t
r gul tonspr s rbed unde t M ot Ca re Ac t addr s s ey oper ton undoubt y a y
e ai
e ci
r he
or rir t o
e s af t
ai
edl ppl
t t postonhel byPl ntf.Se Bae 938F. 18 (xe i a i t drve- r a
o he ii
d
ai if e z,
2d 0 e mpton pples o i rguads nd
me sng rg a d ) Brn s 2 0 U. Dit LEXI 2 2 , 1 (i anif wh wo k da Drv r
se e -u r s; ik' 0 9 S. s.
,
S 7 6 * 0 t itfs o r e s ie s
pl
gndM e sng r)flwi nter g lto ' deiiino d ie swhoafc t es ft o o e ain
a
se e s al t h e u ain s fnto f rv r
hi
fe th aey f p r to
a aet rf eco rdbyt FLSA' motrc nie e
nd r heeor vee he
S o a r xempton.)Pli ifha no s te t t
i ' . antf s t ubmild ha
'
t r i a i s o f c i t sr ga d' he e i uli a el no que t o t t he s cond pr r quie
he e s n s ue f a t n hi e r , r s tm t y
t
s i n ha t e
ong e r d
t i
o nvoke t M ot r Ca rerA c Exe pton t t Fa rLa r St nda dsA c i f t led.
he
o ri
t m i o he i bo a r
t s uli l
11
1.
C onc us on
l i
Pl i if sCom pl nt Re pons , nd M oton t Sti c edehea D e enda G a daw e e
a ntf
ai , s
ea
i o r ke onc
nd f
nt r
r
e g g d i itrtt c mmec a dta Dee d n i amoo c rirs b e t otej rs ito o
n a e n ne sae o r e n h t fn a t s tr a re u j c t h u idcin f
t Se ea y ofTr ns tton.Pli ifdoe not norca he,a lget tt r i af c ua diput
he cr tr
a pora i
antf
s ,
n
le ha he e s a t l s e
wi r s e t ohi j b d te whi e o e wi Dee d n , ci iiswhc dr cl afc t e
t e p c t s o uis l mply d t fn a t a tvte ih ie ty fe t h
h
e
h
s f t of m ot r ve c e .The e or a a m a t r of l w ,Pl ntf i e m pt f om t ove tm e
a ey
o hi l s
r f e, s
te
a
ai i f s xe
r
he r i
r quie e soft FLSA by vit oft m ot c r i re m pton.
e r m nt
he
rue he
or a r e xe i
Fort f e ngr s ns t sCour he e GRAN TS De e ntsM oton f udgme on
he or goi ea o ,hi
t r by
f nda '
i orl
nt
t Pl di r ga di Count I a V ofPl ntf sCo pl ntand DI I
he ea ngs e r ng
s V nd
ai if
m ai
SM SSES t sc s The
hi a e.
Cl r ofCour f t Sou he n D i ti tofFl i s l c os t sc e
ek
t or he t r sr c
or da ha l l e hi as .
D ON E A N D O RD ERED i Cha ber a M i m i Fl i ,t s
n
m s t a , or da hi
FEDE
O A.M
da ofJ ,201
y u
4.
NO
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J DG E
CT U
Copi spr de
e ovi d:
Couns lofRec d
e
or
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?