Ferk v. Mitchell

Filing 36

ORDER Denying 26 Motion for Partial Summary Judgment. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 8/24/2015. (jw)

U NI
TED STATES DISTR I T CO URT
C
SO UTH ERN DI
STRICT O F FLO RI
DA
CASE N O .14- vc 2191 K I
6- NG
LAW RENCE FERK ,
Pl ntf ,
ai if

A . OE M I
J
TCHELL,J ,
R.
Def nda .
e nt
/

ORDER DENYI M O TI FO R PARTI SUM M ARY JUDG M ENT
NG
ON
AL
THI CAUSE com e be or t Cour upon Pl ntf s M oton f Pari Sum mar
S
s f e he
t
ai if
i or tal
y

J d me t( 2 ) l mus bed nid: ha weha eheea eg nuneis so mae ilfc .
u g n DE 6 . t t e e W t
v r r e i sue f tra a t
La ence Fe k,t pl i if l nt$1 000. t A .J M ichel,t de enda ,i J nua y
wr
r he antf, e
25, 00 o
oe t l he f nt n a r
201 I a lte t M ic lda ed M a c 25,201 Fe k' couns dem a
2. n e t r o t hel t
rh
3, r s
el
nded t the pay
ha

b c t la a u ( u i e e t.
a k he o n mo nt pl s ntr s)
On t smuc t pari a e buton notmuc ele. n hi m oton,Fe k r i on a
hi
h he tes gr e,
h s l s
i
r eles
pr is y not t s
om s or
e o how hi rghtofr pa e a t t r sofr pa e .Se D E 27,at
si
e ym nt nd he e m
e ym nt e

! 2 4. nhi rpl h ve , dicamsa y r la eo t pr mis r no e(o s mmay
! - l s e y, owe r he s li n einc n he o s o y t f r u r

j d me tp r s s , shemu t be a s M ic l pon so ti h so po ii nt thedin'
u g n u po e ) a
s, c u e thel it u n i p sto ha
d t
sgn t pr is y not a he diput t the i bound by ist r s.
i he om s or
e; nd
s es ha
s
t em
M ic l cl m st thi r pa entoft l am ounti c i
t he l ai ha s e ym
he oan
s ontngenton hi s lng a
s eli
pa celofr alpr ry i Te
r
e
ope t n xas whi h hehas tdone ye . r dia eest t e i any
c
n'
t Fe k s gr hat her s
s h contnge y. k f t ra guest s h acontnge w oul be ba r d by Fl i s
uc
i nc Fer urhe r
hat uc
i ncy
d
re
orda'
sa ut offa ,buthe ciesno a hort s
t t e r uds
t
ut iy uppori hi c e i t tt ale
tng s ont nton ha he lged

c i nc s e w ta f m st l n a e e i o a k r tf t s e ofl nds
ontnge y om ho r ns or he oa gr em nt nt s
contac or he al
a ,

tn me t o hee ia n s o (o t es llofa y u e ti itr s i o c nc r n t e '
e e n s r r dt me t, r f r h a e n nc ran n e e t n r o e nig h m.
'
1l. t t j7 5. . r sa g me tc nc r i Flrd ' lnd rsaut o fa dsas f is
Fa S a . 2 01 Fe k' r u n o e nng o i a s e e tt e f r u lo al:
$ ti cl a t t ssa ut doesnota y t afim a i def ns . Pavolniv.Wilams,915
k s e r hat hi t t e
l
ppl o fr tve e es'
'
i
li

S
J 2d2 , 5 ( a 5 hDCA 2 05 .
o. 51 2 4 F1. t
0 )
Eve i Fer i rght t tt l n a e e i notc i
n f k s i , ha he oa gr em nt s
ontngentupon M ichel' s li
t ls e lng
apa c ofr lpr ry i Te s t n whatar t t
r el ea ope t n xa , he
e he ennsoft l a e e ?l
he oan gr em nt f

rpa me ti no d cae b t tr oft p o s o y n t ( c Fek i f r e t
e y n s t ittd y he e ms he r mis r o e whih r s o c d o

d s li f rs
icam o umma yj d m e tp r s s , n i no c n ige t n M ic e lss ligr a
r u g n u po e ) a d s t o tn n o t h l' eln e l
p o e t i Te s( c Fek g n i l dip t s, e d e M ic e l a et p y t
r p ry n xa whih r e uney s u e ) wh n o s th l h v o a he
m one bac Ri now,beca e Fe k dema i?Unde wha t ms Fe k does ts y.
y k? ght
us r
nds t
r
t er î r
n' a

Th pa te 'l a a r e n tss b e t ot eb scrqur me t o c n r c 1w s c
e ris o n g e me t k u j c t h a i e ie n s f o ta t a u h
i
a of e ,a ce ance consde a i a s fci s ci ton ofes e i lt r s'St Joe
s f r c pt ,
i r ton nd ufi ent pe icai
s nta e m .' .

Cop. . cv r 8 5 S 2 3 5, 81( a 2 0 . ei s e ta t r 'ofac n r c a e
r v M l e , 7 o. d 7 3 F1. 0 4) Th s s n il e ms'
e
o ta t r
t r or aim a e i f t'i a a to t e or t c r c . eAnder on v.Li t
he ef e s t ral ac ' n n c i n o nf ce he onta t Se
s
bery

Lo b I c, 7U. 2 2, 48( 98 )( f c i S tra'i i t g af c t eo t o o
b y, n .47 S. 4 2 1 6 a a t s i e il'f td ht fe t h u c me f
ma
mi

t es tu d rt go e n n 1w' . r i n te tte t s
h ui n e he v r i g a ' Fe k s o n ild o umma yj d n o h scam
)
r u gme t n i li
agai tM ic lf br ch ofc r c beca e hi c a med rghtt enf e t c r ti
ns t hel or ea
ont a t
us s l i
i o or e he ontac s
pr ca e on es e i t r sove whih t pa te have age nediput
edi t d
s ntal e m
r c he ri s
nui
s e.

Fo t vey s mer a o s Fe k' mo in f rs
r he r a e s n , r s to o ummayj d m e to hi cam f r
r u g n n s li o

i n yln 'mus bed ne To a hiv s mm ayj d n o t a cam, ewo dh vet
' e et
mo
' t e id. c e e u r u gme t n h t l i h ul a o
l sa iht tmo yi d e. Ba o r v Ban u a 6 5So. d 1 8 ,11 8( a. t DCA
s tbls ha ne s u ' nn u a . no r , 5
e
'
2 1 7 8 F1 4h
1 ;Pal nShi ng Co.v. arCa t Fund,LLC, 1 21 1 C1 20l W L
995) adi ppi
St pial
No. 0- 6 2- V, 0

3 1 3 , t* ( D. a Au 2 2 0)(a ) Th pa t sge i l ds t t smae il
4 9 97 a 2 S. Fl. g. 7, 01 s me . e ri nuney ipu e hi tra
e

.

f t
ac .
The ef e,i i ORDERED ,
r or t s
ADJUDGED,and DECREED t tPl i if sM oton
ha antf
i

f Pari Summay J
or tal
r udgment( 26)be,a t s mei,her DENI
DE
nd he a s eby
ED.
DONE and O RDERED i Cha be s a t Ja e La ence Ki Fede alJ tc
n
m r t he m s wr
ng
r usi e
Buidi a Unie St esCourhous M i i Fl i t s24t da ofAugus,201
l ng nd
t d at
t e, am , orda, hi h y
t
5.

<

YM k
'
J

ES LA W RE CE K I G
N
I
TED STATES DI
STRI JUD G
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI A
CT

cc;

Al Couns ofRe d
1
el
cor