Williams v. Discount Auto Parts, LLC

Filing 10

ORDER denying 7 Plaintiff's Motion to Remand. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 10/1/2014. (whl)

UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COU RT FO R THE
CT
SO UTHERN D I
STRI O F FLOR I A
CT
D
Cas N um ber 1: 22344- I - O REN O
e
: 14C V M
ALI W I A M S,
CE LLI
Pl ntf ,
ai i f

D I OUN T AU TO PARTS,LLC,
SC
D e e nt
f nda .
O R DER DEN Y I G PLA I TI S M O TI N TO R EM AN D
N
N FF'
O
TH I CA U SE c e be or t Cour u
S
am
f e he
t pon Pl ntf M oton t R e a M a t r Ba k t
ai i fs
i o m nd te c o

t Stt Co t( E.No.7) fld on Jul 23.2014. Pli ifcli t tt Cour doesno
he ae ur D.
, ie
v
antf ams ha he
t
t

h v dv ri j rs ito t a j d c t t smatrb c u e Dee a th sn te tbls e t a
a e iest u idcin o du iae hi te e a s fnd n a o sa ih d h t
y
t amounti conr rye eds$75, Se 28U. C.j 1 a)
he
n toves xce
000. e
S.
332( .
THE COU RT ha c i r t m oton a t peri t por i of t r c d, a
s ons de ed he
i nd he tnen
tons
he e or nd
be ng o he i e f l a s d i t pr m i e , ti
i t m s uly dvi e n he e s s i s
A DJUD G ED t tt m oto i DEN I .
ha he
in s
ED
Pl ntf t s i o c r s t di pos ton of her M oton. W he Pl i if a wer d
ai i fs e tm ny ontol he s ii
i
n a ntf ns e

Dee ntsFis Reque tfrAdmison (
fnda ' rt
s o
si RFA) s sae t the t a da
, he ttd ha r otl mage ae notls
sr
es

t n ore t $75,
ha
qual o 000. ( e D. 12,13. Pl ntf i i t bes poston t qua iy t
Se E. - - ) ai if s n he t ii o ntf he

a u ti c nr v ry t ts e b ig t t c s a d f rj rs ito a p r o e- De e d n
mo n n o to es ha h rn s o he a e n - o u id ci n l u p s s fn a t
a e w ih heras e s e . A c ptng Pl i i ps a l ga i as tue, t e Cour hasno r a on t
gr es t
s s m nt
t
es o
ce i
a ntf le tons r 1 h
doub t a c ac ofhe ans e .
t he c ur y
r w r

1 an ifs e src v r f rt e eea dg ivo p ro ln u is,p ysc la dme tl i
Plitf e k e o ey o t v r n re us e s na ij re l) h ia n n a pan
s
a ds feig g ifh miito l s o wa e ,os o c p ct f rtee j y n o l e ls o
n u frn , re , u l in,o s f g s l s f a a iy o h n o me t f i ,o s f
a
f

Des t he a we , Pli if bele
pie r ns r antf
ives he pr -e ova s tlm e ofer of ls t n
r e r m l e te nt f
e s ha

$75, i t bes e de e of t a
000 s he t vi nc
he mount i c r ve s Howeve , s tlm e ofer a e
n onto r y.
r e te nt f s r
c pos d t r tec t r s and c t as oc a e wih co es e ltgato r t rt n c c a e
om e o e l t he iks
os s s i t d t nt t d ii i n, a he ha al ul t d
ba e on t de e n ' t ale
sd
he f nda t s ot xpos e a t i l See Ve mande v Hyu
ur t r a .
r
. ndaiM ot A me i ,l .
or
r ca nc ,

352F.Supp. 1 203( Conn.
2d 95,
D.
2004) J ta t Cour woul notlmi Pli ifspos-ral
. us s he
t
d
i t antf' tti
a d ba e on herpr - rals tl m e of e ,t Cour w ilnottea Pl i ifs of e as a c ii
war s d
e t i e te nt f r he
t l
r t a ntf
fr
e lng

f t ra a
or he e l mounti c r r y.
n ontove s
Pl ntf s M o i pl e Def nda i a dif c t poston. Pl i if ha not a t he a
ai i f
ton ac s
e nt n
f i ul
ii
a ntf s
tac d
dola f g e t he c ai ,a Pl i if now wa s t us t l k of a de i tve a ou i
l r i ur o r l m nd a ntf
nt o e he ac
tnii m nt n

c toves t he adva age. Rahe t n prj ce Defnda f Pl ntf s c rdit y
onr ry o r
nt
t r ha eudi
e nt or ai if onta cor

pla i s t eCo r wi r ti j rs ito s ln a Plitf d e n tsiuaet a a u ti
e dng , h u t l ean u idcin o o g s an if o s o tp lt o n mo n n
l
c toves beow j1 smoneayt es d.
onr ry l
332'
tr hr hol

D ON E AN D O RD ERED i Cha be sa M i m i Fl i t s
n
m r t a , orda, hi

FED E

4 -

day ofO c obe , 4.
t r 201

.M O REN O

1 ,71S ATESDIT CTJ
1E7 T
,
'
.
1
S RI UDGE
Copi pr de t
es ovi d o:
Couns lofRe d
e
cor

a lt t e r mone now a i t f e,e ns ofme c lc r a te t nt a )t
biiy o an
y
nd n he mur xpe e
dia ae nd r ame , ndg he
a a tonofapr ousye si condii ' ( E.12a 5 )
ggrvai
evi l xitng
ton. D. - t -6.
'
-

2-