Bowman v. G.F.C.H. Enterprises, Inc.
Filing
17
ORDER granting without prejudice 10 Motion to Dismiss. Plaintiff is granted leave to amend the complaint, consistent with this Order, by no later than 10/30/2014. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 10/17/2014. (rtn)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
M i m iD i son
a
vi i
Cas Num ber 1 22651- V- O RENO
e
: 4CI M
A DRI N E BO W M A N ,
EN
Pl ntf ,
ai i f
VS.
G. C. ENTERPRI
F. H.
SES, l C. a Fl i f
N ,
orda or
pr i cor a i n,
ott por t o
Def nda .
e nt
ORDER GR ANTI M OTI TO DI I W I OUT PREJUDI
NG
ON
SM SS TH
CE
Pl ntf Adrer Bowm a fl d a lws ta ns De e
ai if i me
n ie a ui gai t f ndantG. C. Ent r ies l .
F. H. e prs , nc,
o r ope a ora ls orofas
wne , r t nd e s
hoppi c e i M im iDa Count a lgi vi atonsoft
ng entr n a - de
y, le ng ol i
he
AmeianswihDia lte ActADA)42U. C. 1 81c u ça heFl i
rc
t s biiis (
, S. j 21 /ç ndt ordaAcc s i lt Code
c
e sbiiy
( AC) Pli t fs e sad ca ao yj d me t h tDee d n i i vo ain o t eADA a a
F . ani e k e lr tr u g n t a f n a t s n ilto f h
f
nd n
ij i die i Defnda t brngisfciiisi of lc inc wiht a opraeADA
nuncton rctng e nt o i t a lte nt ul ompla e t he ppr it
a FA C r ul tons
nd
eg a i .
For t r s pr de bel t Cour fndst tDef ndants M oton t Dim is i
he ea ons ovi d ow, he
ti
ha
e
'
i o s s s
g a td p ru n t Fe R.Ci.P.1 ( )1 d e t lc o sa ig u d rAril I1o t
rne u s a t o d.
v
2 b ( ) u o a k f tndn n e t e I f he
c
Co siuin Th sa to i ds se wih u prj dc .Plitf i g a tdla et a n t e
n ttto . i ci n s imis d to t eu ie an if s rn e e v o me d h
c mpan, conssentw ih t sO r r by no lt rt n
o lit it t hi de ,
a e ha
Sa .2014.
1.D i
scussi
on
Pl i if a r i ntofBr r Count i a a put e who m us us a whee cha ra ç
a ntf , es de
owa d
y, s n m e
t e
l i nd d
has
difculy o a i m e ha s st tr qui e tg g as ng, nc ng, t i tng oft w rs . On
f i t per tng c ni m ha e r i ht r pi pi hi or w s i
he i t'
'
Fe ua y28, 4,Pl i ifviie Def nda ' commer i pr ry, s lsrp ma ll a e i
br r
201 antf st d e nts
cal ope t a mal ti l oc t d n
M i miDa Count De e
a - de
y. f ndan owns ope aesa l s st c
t
, r t nd ea e he omm e cilpr t Durng t t
r a opery. i ha
vii, ai ifas viie M ilrsCa e e i owne byoneofDef nda ' t nant.Pl ntf a lge
stPl ntf lo st d le ' f t ra,
d
e nts e s ai if le s
s ee c u trdc ran ac ie trlb u d re a t es be t r p ris icu ig,ntra i, n
h n o nee e ti rh tcu a o n ais t h u j c p o e t ,n l dn i e la a
e
i ufi e num be ofdia e pa ki s ce a ac s ases i cc s i er e c
ns fcint
r
s bl d r ng pa s nd ce s il , na e sbl out s onne tngt
c i he
par ng s swih t e r nc oft pr ry, va i de i i i i t M il ' Ca e e i
ki pot t he nta e he ope t and rous fcences n he lers f t ra
r toom s She al gest t a ar ul oft s bounda i a De e
esr
.
le ha , s es t he e
res nd f ndan ' f iur t i eme
ts a l e o mpl nt
p o e p l isa dp o e u e r q rdu e t eADA,hewa ij r da dd s rmiae a an t
r p r oi e n r c d rs e uie nd r h
c
s
s nu e n ic i n td g is.
Panifu te alg ss t e ie t ,ndwo l r- ii'h s be t r p risb te i
litf frh r le e het sr s o a
d
ud evst te u jc p o e t , u rmans
'
e
una e t do s a l ast ba e sr
bl o
o s ong he ni r emai a t De e
n nd he f ndan doe no i e e t pr r
t s t mplm nt he ope
polces a pr edur s La ty,whie Pli ifdoes not e e a e t m ie ge bewe her
i i nd oc e . sl
l antf
num r t he la
t en
rsd n ea d t s b e tp o et,De e d n h salg d, n Plitf i h rrs n ed e n t
ei e c n he u j c r p ry f n a t a le e a d an if n e epo s o s o
r f t a dit nc ofr ug y 25t 30 mies
e u e, sa e o hl
o
l .
De enda m ove t dim ist compl i ,a gui t tPl i ifl c sandi t brng a
f nt
s o s s he
ant r ng ha antf a ks t ng o i
c eofa tonunde Til 11oft ADA, f ie t sat aca eofa ton unde t ADA, nd
aus
ci
r te 1 he
has a ld o t e us
ci
r he
a
h s aldt oi idip ns bepat s i t i c s tec mmeca tna t.Be a s teCo r fn s
a f i oj n n s e a l ri ,n hs a e h o r ile ns c u e h u tid
e
e
Pl ntf l c Ari el1sandi i wilnota es t s c and t r a gum e s.
ai if a ks tcl 1 t ng, t l
ddr s he e ond
hid r
nt
I.
I LegalSt
andar
d
l tn ig i a tz s l j rs ito a q e to whih mu tb a d e s d p irt a d
' a dp s h e hod u idcin l u si n c s e d rs e ro o n
S
i pe ntoft meisoft pa tes cams'U. Co t, t11 j2,c.; u v Deendes
nde nde
he rt he ri ' li . S. ns.Ar.1, l1 f jan . f r
'
o l l , 0 U. 5 5 5 0- ( 9 2 .Fu t r S tndn mus b d tr n d a o tetmea
fWidfe 5 4 S. 5 , 6 61 1 9 ) rhe,l a ig t e eemie s f h i t
s
whiht pl i ifsc
c he antf ompli ti fl 'Foc sont Fami v. nel Sunc tT ansiAut i
a n s ied.
' u
he
l Pi la
y
oas r t hort
ys
3 F. 1 1 ( 1hCi. )
44 3d 263, 275 1 t r 2003 .
Sa dn rq r s te f l wi t re ee n s ( )t e p an ifmu tha e s fee a
tn ig e uie h ol ng h e lme t: 1 h litf s v u fr d
o
' o c eea dp riu aie 'a dt cua o i n n'ij r n-a t f lg l p oe tditr s;
t n r t n a t lrz d' n s t l r mmie t'nu pi fc o a e al r tce ne et
c
c
a
y
()heemu t ac u a c n e to b t e t epan ifsij r a dt ed fn a tsc n u ta
2 t r s be a s l o n cin ewe n h litf n u y n h ee d n ' o d c; nd
()imu t elk l t a t ij r wil er d e sdb afvo a l d cso 1 W i r s e t ot
3 t s b iey h the nu y lb e r se y a rbe e iin.d. t e p c t he
h
trtee n , e a ePlitf i s i Dee d n f rij n t erle , emus as alg ç ra
is lme t b c us an if s ung fn a t o nu ci eif h
v
t lo le e $ e l
a
a d i dae -a o p s d t a me ey c ne tr lo h p t eia -t e to f t e ij r '
n mme it s p o e o
r l o j cu a r y o h tc l hra f uur nu y.
'
Wo d nv Bo r o g nt o iest S s o o, 4 F.d 1 6 ,1 8 ( 1hCi. 0 .I
o e . a d fRe e s funv ri y . fGe .2 7 3 2 2 2 4 1 t r 201 ) n
y
ADA c es t pl ntf m us a lgeûac r t a r a itcpl nofwhe hewoul vii't publc
as ,he ai if t le t onc ee nd e lsi a
n
d st'he
i
ac
c ommodai a i Housonv Mar dsu r k sI , F. 1 13 ( 1hCi. )
ton gan.
t . o pemar et,nc.733 3d 323, 40 1 t r2001;
s ealo Wooden, F. a 1 4(hepl ntf çmus s as fce lkelhoodt thewilbe
e s
247 3d t 28 t ai iff t how ufiint i i
ha
l
af ce b t ealg dyu lwf l o d t nt ef tr ' ; t o o An ee v L o s 4 U.
fe td y h l e l na u c n uc i h ' u e.l Ci fL s g ls . y n , 61 S.
e
u ' y
9 , 1 n. ( 9 3 (ç i terai o t etr a o rp ae ij r t a i rlv n t t esa ig
5 1 8 8 1 9 ) it s h e ly f h h t t f e e td nu y h t s ee a t o h tndn
l
t
iq iy n tteplitf ss be tv a p e e so s'
n ur , o h an if u jcie p rh n i n .
).
P an ifb asteb r e of sa ihn hssa dn t s eDee da t o ij n tv rle .
litf e r h u d n e tbl ig i tn ig o u fn n f r nu cie eif
s
Bo h s v Fl o n el lt4 5F.d9 4, 7 ( 1hCi. 0 5 .It Plitf f i t me thi
c e e . t fpo c ne, 0 3 6 9 6 1 t r 2 0 ) fhe an if al o e t s
wn
s
b r e t eCo r lc s u id cin. ic s k eT ieo n a so o iav Flrd Sat Atlt
u d n,h u ta k j rs ito M c o u e rb fl din fFl rd . o ia t e hei
c
Com ' 226F. 1 1 ( 1hCi. ) Ari e1Issa ngr rme sa ye l t
n,
3d 226, 230 1 t r 2000 . tcl 1' tndi equie nt ppl qualy o
ADA c s s No ku v Se s NB,LLC,444Fed.
a e . r nas . ahore
Appx.41 41 ( 1h Ci. 1.
2, 5 1 t r 201 )
Chaln e t Aril ll tn i gma atc u idcin fcal o fcu l M o rs nv
le g s o t e I sa d n y ta kj rs ito a il r a tal
c
y
y. rio .
Wvwl Cop.3 3F.d9 , 2 n. ( 1h Ci. 0 3 .W h r t ej rs ito l ta ki b s do
l y r , 2 3 20 9 4 5 1 t r 2 0 ) e e h u idcina atc s a e n
t f c oft pl a ngs t Cour l
he a e he e di , he
t ookst t f c ner oft c
o he our or s he ompli , nd t al gai
a nt a he le tons
i t pli ipscompl i a e t ken astu f pur e oft moton t dim is Lawr nc v.
n he antf
ant r a
r e or pos s he
i o s s.
e e
Dunb ,91 F. 1 15 ( 1hCi.1 .
ar 9 2d 525, 29 1 t r 990)
1 1 Anal i
1.
ys s
The Cour fndsPl ntf l c Aril lIsa ng. Pli ifhasf ie t s tsy t fr t
ti
ai if a ks tc e l t ndi
a ntf
a ld o a if he is
ee e ofsa ngwhe e s hasi ufi i n l aleg at ea a i e ae ...hr a off t e
lm nt t ndi
r he
ns fc e ty l ed ' l nd mm di t
r
t e t uur
ij r , Wo d n 2 7F.da 1 4, n ha fie t me t e b r e o d mo tai terq iie
n uy' o e , 4 3 t 28 a d s ald o e h r u d n f e nsrtng h e u st
'
i o ceea draitcp a 't rt r t tes b e t r p risE..Hou tn, 3 F.da 1 4 To
t n rt n e l i ln'o eu n o h u j c p o e t . g, so 7 3 3 t 3 0.
c
s
e
a s st t e toff t eADA vi atonsi t contxtofsa ng,he Elve h Cic templ ys
s es he hr a
u ur
ol i n he
e
t ndi t
e nt r ui
o
atot iyofcic tnc 't ta ha l dt t f l ngfcor ( pr miyoft publc
k alt
t
rumsa es'es, nd s ooke o he olowi a t s:a) oxi t he i
a c mmo aint p an ifsh me ( )plitf sp s p to a eo d f n a tsa c mmo ain;
c o d to o litf o ; b an if a t ar n g f ee d n ' c o d to
()t dei tnes ofpli ifsplnt rt nt dee ntsa commo ton; d( t fe nc
c he fnie s antf a o eur o fnda ' c
dai an d)he r que y
ofpl ntf ' ta lne de e
ai ifs r ve ar f ndan ' a commodai I a 1
ts c
ton. d t 337.
W ihr s t ot pr m iyf cor t Cour doe not i t tadit nc of25t 30mies
t e pec t he oxi t a t ,he
t s fnd ha
sa e
o
l ,
byis f de
tel, monsr t sPl i ifsi biiyt alegeaf ur vi a i Howe r whe c i r d
ta e antf na lt o l
ut e olton.
ve , n onsde e
i c nu cinwiht rmanigfco s Plitf h sfie t p o i ea y s p r frteb r
n o j n to t he e i n a t r, anif a ald o r v d n u po t o h ae
a srint t h wo l rt r t tes be t r p ris Fis, t rs e t ot ed a t ar n g '
se t ha s e ud eu n o h u j c p o e t . rtwih e p c t h i s p to a e'
o
e
p
a dSrq e c o ta e'fco s t s l isa c P an ifh svii dt es b e t r p risi t e
n l e u n y f rv l a t r,he oe n tn e litf a st h u j c p o e t s h
f
'
e
e
unde l ngFe a y28, 4vii.Pl i ifdoesnota lget havevi iedt pr risbe or t
ryi
bnzr
201 st antf
le o
st he ope te f e he
unde l ngvii, t e t tme oft vii a whe s fld t compl i ,orsnc s fl
ryi
st be we n he i
he st nd
n he ie he
ant
i e he ied
t ec mp an .Smpyp tt eei nop ro a hit r o u eo t s b e t a iiisoh rta t e
h o lit i l u ,h r s e s n l so y f s f he u j c f cl e t e h n h
t
l ne unde l ng vii.SeeAc e sNow,l .v Sout Fl i St u Cor ,1 F. p. 1
o ,
ryi st
cs
nc . h orda adi m
p. 61 Sup 2d 357,
1 65 ( D.Fl 2001 (i ng pe s hit y ofus offciiy a r sde i t ae
364- S. a. ) fndi ronal sor
e a lt nd e i nce n he ra
-
4-
s pore Aril Ilsa ng) NordoesPl nifalegea c
up td tce I tndi .
aitf l ny onneci t t pr ri , uc a
ton o he ope tes s h s
fi ndsorf m iy l td nea by.
re
a l ocae
r
Pli ipsf ct alegai de
a ntf a ual l tons monsr eiol e a t r or i r que c a twih t
tat s atd nd he ef e nfe nt ont c t he
s be t r p ris a dac mplt lc o c n cint t es b e t o ris Fo t e era o s
u j c p o e t , n o ee a k f o ne to o h u j c prpe t . r h s e s n
e
e
aone,
l Coursha dim is d ca esf lck ofsa ng. e eg. Lamb v.CharoteCt/n/ 429
t ve s s e s or a
t ndi Se , . ,
l t ? y,
z
F. p 2 1 0 1 0 - 1( . Fl. 0 6 (i digife ue t o tc wi r pe fiigt ii
Su p.d 3 2, 3 9 1 M D. a 2 0 ) tn n n r q n c na t t o hy,al ov st
hp
n
pr rysnc flngcompli , ndnoc meci t t pr rywar tdfndi ofnosandi ;
opet i e ii
anta
or ton o he ope t rane i ng
t ng)
Gome v. ade C/ln/ Fe alCr tUni 201 W L 1 7965, t* ( D. a. a . 201
z D
f . der
p
edi on, 4
21
a 4 S. Fl M r 24, 4)
( ai iflc sa ng whee,i e ala,t ewa no fcuals
pl ntf a ked tndi
r ntr i her s a t uppor f co e i t tt
t or ntnton ha he
s be ta ii sc n e e ti ue /wnzvM a kpo ls 2 4F. u p. d 1 5 , 2 3 5 ( .
u jc fclywa o v nin l#t ae / . r o uo , 5 S p 2 2 0 1 5 - 4 M D.
t
Fl.2003)( aniflc sa ngwhee,i pa t pli ifsta lt t aeawa freg a,
a
plitf a ked tndi
r n r, antf rve o he r
s s r ulr
i
oc sona,a i rque )
cai l nd nfe nf'.
La t ,Plitf h sn l o cee a r aitc'pln t r tr t t e s be tp o e t s
sl an if a o t n r t nd e lsi' a o eu n o h u j c r p ri .
y
c
e
Pl ntf ha i ta m a t concus y alegai t ts t ie t a woul r - st't
ai if s nse d de he
l or l ton ha he ç r s o, nd
des
d e vii' he
s be t r pe t sSoa alh refo teg o s s ni e , a i t s p iie e , d a tg sa d o
u jc p o ri t v i es l f h o d , e c s fcl i , rv lg s a v n a e n / r
e t
ie
a c mmo ai n 'a dt a s r d o la c wi teADAg)' e Co l a ! 1 ,1 Id e ,
c o d to s' n o s u e f mp in e t h
c
h
.'S e mp . t ! 1 3. n e d
Pl i ifc
antf once i he r s
des n r e pons t t M oton t Dim ist tt s pa a a demonsr t a
e o he
i o s s ha he e r gr phs
ta e
' l rde iet r t n. Pl. s a 5- The Cou t
f ea s r o e ur ' f Re p. t 6.
c
'
r doesnota e Pl i i f of s e anons c f c
gr e. a ntf pr e s s
pe ii
a de tr l u u p re d sr t rtr l ndh rtuu eta l ln aej s So d y itnins
n n iey ns p o td e ie o eu n,a e s tr rve p a s r u t s me a 'n e to
f
a l k a de c i i n ofc r t pl ns o a hi m or defnie ' ha t s ( s r t a
nd ac ny s rpto
onc e e a r nyt ng
e
t ' t n hat he C ies o, nd
de
' antf e nf l t al s woul vii t s j c pr ryi t ne rf e
Pli if ve ais o lege he
d st he ub e t ope t n he a mur,
t
houg s h a a l ga i woul s e dubi f t r s pr vi i t s Or r
h uc n le ton
d em
ous or he ea ons o ded n hi de .
wo l 'rtr t t es b e t a iie . Ro e k a t, 4F. u p. da 1 5 ; e as Ho wic e
u d'eu n o h u j c fclt s' s n r nz 25 S p 2 t 2 3 s e lo e s h r
i '
v. 'Prpe te ,LLC,201 W L 1 1 a * ( . Fl J n.18, 2)(s hies cii dae
Joes o ris
2
393 9, t 4 M D. a. a
201 l l pe fc ts
W
ofr um m a notber r d,Someda i ento -wihouta de c i i n ofco r t pl ns or
et
y
equie s
y' nt i ns t
ny s rpto
nc e e a ,
i edeve a s cii ton ofwhe t s
nde
n ny pe fca i
n he omeda wilbe-donots
y l
uppor afndi oflct lor
t i ng a ua
i ne t ij r ta o r a e r q r .)( i n Luan 5 4U. a 5 4 . Plitf,h r f r, a
mmi n 'n uy h t u c s s e uie' ct g j , 0 S. t 6 )2 an if tee o e h s
' i
fie t alg ar a a di daetr a o ft r ij r rq ie t e tbih sa dn i ADA
ald o le e e l n mme it h e t f u u e nu y e u rd o sa l tn ig n
s
c s sse n ij nci erle .
a e e kig n u tv eif
I .Conc us on
V
l i
Acc di y,De e
or ngl
f ndan ' M o i t Dim isi g a ed duet lck ofAri e llsa ng.
ts ton o s s s r nt
oa
tcl l t ndi
Plitf Co an i d s se wi u p eu c ,wi la e t fl a a n e c mpan
an ips mplit s imis d t t rj die t e v o ie n me d d o lit
ho
h
c nsse twi ti Or e b n ltrta
o itn t hs d r y o ae h n
h
X' .2 4.l Plitf fist fl a
- 01 f anif al o ie n
D
ame d compl ntby t de dlne, heCour m a c os t c s
nde
ai
he a i t
t y l e he a e.
DONE AND ORDERED i Cha be sa M i mi Fl rda, hi
n
m r t a , oi t s
FED
> 1
da ofOc o r 201
y
t be , 4.
. OM N O
STA TES D I
STRI J DG E
CT U
Copi pr ded t
es ovi o:
Couns lofRec d
e
or
2 eas Na in l la c f rAc esblt, nc v Pa ReBcC LLC, 01 W L
Se lo to a Alin e o c si ii I . . r
y
f
2 3
1 27 a *3- ( . Fl M a .1 201 (i ngno sa ngduet t guea s ultve'
296 2, t 4 M D. a. r 2, 3) fndi
tndi
ok
va nd pec ai '
algainst tPl ntf i endst rt nt Defnda ' prpet ;famb,429F. pp.2da
le to ha ai if nt
o eur o e nts o ry)
Su
t
1 11( sa ngwheed l ai ofi e t rt nt t pr ry...l kt s iiiy
3 no tndi
r t eg tons ntnt o eur o he ope t
al
ac he pecfct
r q ie t man an as i f rij n tv r l f'.
e urd o iti u t o n u cie ei .)
e'
-
6-
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?