Richardson v. United States of America

Filing 8

ORDER Adopting 6 Report and Recommendation, Denying Petition, and Denying Certificate of Appealability. Closing Case. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 11/4/2014. (ar2) NOTICE: If there are sealed documents in this case, they may be unsealed after 1 year or as directed by Court Order, unless they have been designated to be permanently sealed. See Local Rule 5.4 and Administrative Order 2014-69. Modified document type on 11/4/2014 (ar2).

U NITED STATES D I
STRI C OURT
CT
SO UTH ERN D ISTRI O F FLO RI A
CT
D
Cas N o.1 22680- V- TZ
e
4CI SEI
DARRYL RI A RDSO N ,
CH
Pett oner
ii
,

U NI
TED STATES O F AM ERI ,
CA
Re ponde .
s
nt

O RDER A FFI I AND A DOPTI M AGI
RM NG
NG
STRATE/ R EPORT,
S
D ENYI PETI ON,AND D ENYI CERTI CATEOFA PPEALABI TY
NG
TI
NG
FI
LI
Thi m ate i bef e t Cour on PettonerDar ylRi har
s
t r s or he
t
ii
r
c dson' t r habeas
s hi d

c lenge t hi c
ha l
o s onvi ton and 360- ont s e e f c pi i t dit i ec ai .
ci
m h ent nc or ons rng o s rbut oc ne
Se Unie St e z.Riha ds n, 5 2F.d 1 7 ( 1h Ci. 0 8 ( fimi hi c nviton
e
td ats J c r o 3 3 2 9 1 t r 2 0 ) a fr ng s o ci

a s nt nc ) c r. e e ,5 5U. 1 2 ( 0 9;Rih r s n p Un td Stts 556 Fed.
nd e e e , e td nid 5 S, 1 0 2 0 ) c a d o . ie ae,
Appx. 5 ( 1 h Ci. 1 (fimi t de a o hi fr tpe ii ; c a d o r FCI
8 1 1 t r 20 4) afr ng he nil f s is tton) Rih r s n
.

M imiNo. 4 2 0 3 C1 2 1 W L 41 1 1 ( D. a Aug. 4 2 4)( s isng hi
a , 1 - 0 6 - V, 0 4
0 2 6 S. Fl .
1 , 01 dim s i s
s c pe ii n a s c s i ) Dititc t c nnothe rs c s i ha a pe ii
e ond tto s uc e sve . src ours a
a uc e sve be s ttons
unl st pettonerfr tobt nsl ave f om t Cour ofAppeal . 2 U. C.
es he ii
is
ai e
r
he
t
s 8 S. j

2 4 ()A) Heha no o ane la ,a s ,a M a sr t J
2 4@)3 ( .
s t bt i d e ve nd o s gita e udgeW hiec l d
t oncude
( 6, hi Cour mus dim ishi pe ii n f rl c o j iditon
DE- )t s
t t s s s tto o a k f urs c i

.

Riha ds n ha obe td t t sc ncuson a g ng t thi pe ii i no
c r o s jc e o hi o l i , r ui ha s tton s t
s c s i be a ei i ba e o pr vi l una ia ei o m ai n: J y 3 , 2013
uc e sve c us t s s d n e ousy valbl nf r to a ul 0
l t fom t Unied St esPr ton O fie adm itng t hi Pr e e e
eter r he
t
at
oba i
fc
ti hat s es nt nc

l si to Re t(' 1' m ic r ce i d hi prorc nviton i Ge gi saec ur
nve tga in por ' ' s ha a trze s i o ci n or a tt o t
PS )
i 1 9 . DE- a 1 - 5.l t PS1ha be n c r c, c r on' s nt ncng g de i s
n 9 6 ( I t 3 1 1 f he
d e ore t Riha ds s e e i ui lne
r
ange w oul have bee 324 t 405 m ont i t of36O m ont t lf .
d
n
o
hs ns ead
hs o ie

Ac or ng t Riha ds n, hePr ba i n Ofie' lte i ane 'a tls
c di o c r o t o to fc s e t r s w ' c l uppori
f
tng

t ca m 'unde s ci n 2 5 f( , whih,
he li '
r e to 2 5()4)1 c unde J h s n7 Unied St e ,544 U . 295
r o n o J t ats
S.
.

( 0 5,ti r afe h o - a ha e slm ia i nspe i Riha ds f t rpont t
2 0 ) rgge s r s neye r b a i t to
rod. c r on urhe i s o
St war v.Unie St e ,6 F.3d 8 6 8 8( 1 h Ci. 0 1,whih hed t tas c nd
e t
td ats 46
5 , 5 1 t r 2 1 ) c l ha e o

ha e spe ii n r ii aJhn o cam wa nots c s i ( 7jS Riha ds n a gue
b a tto a sng o s n l i
s
uc e sve DE- . o c r o r s
.

hei e il t be r ent nc on t bassofa c r t PSI
s ntted o
es e ed
he i
or ec ed

.

H avi car uly r ew ed t r d deno , t Cour agr eswihJ
ng ef l evi
he ecor
vo he
t e
t udge
W hie' r om m e
t s ec
ndaton and w ildi m ist petton ass es i . Ri har on'
i
l s s he ii
ucc sve c ds s

o j cin i o r ul dbe a et 'a tl uppori t cam'i Riha ds n' 1 9
b e to s ve r e c us he ' c l s
f
tng he li ' s c r o s 9 6
Geor a c
gi onvi ton ise f w hih hasnotcha
c i t l, c
nged snc hi s encng. The Pr
i e s ent i
obaton
i
O fi e' l tersm pl r l ct a r ew ofdoc ent i f om t c
fc s e t i y efe s evi
um aton r
hat onvi i
cton

-

doc e aton t Ri har on c d havepr ded, att l es ,i hi fr ha
um nt i hat c ds oul
ovi
he at t n s ist beas

pr e di zT si e iey unlkeJ h s n a Stwa ti w hih ( )t ' a tl
oc e ng. hi s ntr l i o n o nd e r,n c 1 he ' c l
f
s
uppo tng t cam 'i e c c s w a t vac t o apr dia ec c i a ( )t
ri he l i ' n a h a e s he a' f e c t onviton nd 2 he
ur
pettoner c d nothavebr
ii s oul
oughtt rcl m suntlafert e pr orc
hei ai
i t hos i onvi i had
ctons
been vac ed.Atm os t Pr ton O fie' l t i new l dicover evi
at
t he oba i
fc s eter s
y s
ed denc , and as
e

M a ita eJ eW hieno e t ne y- s ov r d- vi nc e e i n do sno a y
g sr t udg
t t d, he wl dic e e e de e xc pto e t ppl
t s nt ncngca ms Se I r De n 3 1F. 1 4 ( 1 h Ci. 0 3 . Riha ds s
o e e i l i . e n e a , 4 3d 2 7 1 t r 2 0 ) So c r on'

pe ii n i s c s i ,a t sCo t a ksj iditon t he ri.
tto s uc e sve nd hi ur l c urs c i o a t

Se to 2 5 peii a es jc t aoneye rsa u eo lmiai whih be ns
c in 2 5 ttons r ub e t o
- a t t t f i t tons c gi
t r on t l toff ale nat dat , one ofw hih i 't dat on w hi h t f t
o un
he as
our t r e es
c s 'he e
c he ac s

s
uppor i t c ai ...c d havebeen di c
tng he l m
oul
s over t ough t e rcs ofdue
ed hr
he xe ie

dii e e'2 U. C. 2 5 ()4 .
lg nc . 8 S. 5 2 5 f( )
'
2
I f ,i afim i t deni ofhi fr thabeaspetton, t El
n act n fr ng he
al
s is
ii he event Cic t
h r ui
det m i t t ew asno i f tveasss ancei hi c
er ned hat her
nefec i
it
n s ouns ' f l e t pr de
els aiur o ovi
c tdocum ent f om hi 1 Ge gi c
our
sr
s 996 or a onvi ton. Rihar o t.Unied St e ,556 Fe
ci
c ds n ?
t
ats
d.

Appx.851 853( h Ci 201 .
,
11t r. 4)
-

2-

N o c tfc e ofappe abiiy i w ar a
er ii at
al lt s
r
nt bec e Ri har
ed aus c dson hasnotm ade 'a
'
s t ntalA
ubs a i how i oft de alofa c
ng he ni
ons iutonalrght'2 U. C. 2 5 ()2 .'
tt i
i ' 8 S. j 2 3 c ( ) '
A
pettoners i fest ss andard by dem o
ii
ats i hi t
.

nsr tng t t urssof e s c ul dia r e
ta i ha j it r a on o d s g e

w ih t di ti tc tsr s uton ofhi
t he s rc our ' e ol i
s

c tt i l l i ort turssc ul
onsiutona ca ms ha j it o d

c l t is pr nt her ar a
onc ude he s ues ese ed e e d
e t t des ve enc age entt pr eed
qua e o er
our m
o oc

f t r'J ne ,. e ', De tjcor,6 7F.d 1 4 ,1 4 (1hCi
urhe . o sf S cy p'o r. 0 3 3 6 3 9 1 t r
'
7
.

2 1 ) Riha ds ha
0 0 . c r on s

m adeno s h s i bec e hi pett
uc how ng aus s ii
on i pl nl s ce si . I he i ends t
s ai y uc s ve f nt
o
pr e wih t scas , he s
oc ed t hi e
houl appl f a horzaton t t
d
y or ut i i o h
e Cour ofAppe sf
t
al or
t El
he event Cicui usng t f m pr
h r t i he or
o

vi d. 5: DE- - .
de ( : 6 1J

Ac or ngl i i her by
c di y, t s e
ORDERED t
hat

1
)

TheRe r ofM a sr t J
po t
gita e udger 61i AFFI ED a ADOPTED and
DE s
RM
nd
-

i or at by r er e i o t sO r
nc por ed
ef enc nt hi der
,

e e t eac r f enc i t t t /14xc pt hat h e er e n he ext o /

CV- 2 8 M ORENO'(n Pa t , att t ofpage 3,
2 6 0' i r 1 he op
s
houl ber ac w ih '1 CVd
epl ed t '4
20063- O REN O
M
-

a i t m i eofpa 4)
nd n he ddl
ge

''
.

Riha ds n' o j ci ( 7 i OVERRULED The petton f aw rtof
c r o s b e ton DE- J s
ii or
i
ha a c r ( I i DI I SED W I PREJ CE
be s o pus DE- I s SM S
TH
UDI
.

.

A c riiaeofa a a lt i DE I W I PRE UDI
e tfc t
ppe lbiiy s N ED TH
J CE
.

s
s
4) Thi casei CLOSED
DON EAND ORDERED

.

up

i M i m i Fl i , t s T
n a , orda hi

d y ofNovember 201
, 4.
,

t
v

*

,
7

PA T I A A . SEI
CI
TZ
CC*

M a sr t J
gitae udgeW hie
t

UNI STATESDI CT J
TED
STRI UDGE

-

3-