Alfonso v. CARE FIRST MEDICAL CENTER INC. et al
Filing
47
ORDER granting 25 Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 3/4/2015. (mmd) NOTICE: If there are sealed documents in this case, they may be unsealed after 1 year or as directed by Court Order, unless they have been designated to be permanently sealed. See Local Rule 5.4 and Administrative Order 2014-69.
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI COU RT FO R TH E
CT
SO U THERN DI
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
M i m iD i son
a
vi i
C as Num be 1 2271 C I M O R EN O
e
r: 47- VAN I A LFON SO,
A
Pl i if
antf,
VS.
CARE FI ST M ED I
R
CAL CEN TER I C . fal,
N c .
D e e nt .
f nda s
O R D ER G M N TI G M O TI N FO R SU M M A R Y JUD G M EN T
N
O
Pl i if Ani A lons ha t r m a ni cl i si t sca e, i f unpai w a sunde
a ntf , a f o, s wo e i ng a m n hi s one s or
d ge
r
Flrdaco monlw andt o he f r t la i unde heFarLa Stnda dsAc .De e n has
oi m
a
he t r or e a iton
rt
i bor a r
t f nda t
mo e f rs mmayj dg n ag i t a Plitfwa a i d p n n c nr co a di tee o e
v d o u r u me t r ung h t anif s n n e e de t o ta tr n s h r f r,
note tte t unpai wa a c nnotmake acli unde FLSA. The Cour ag ee a tnds
n ild o
d ges nd a
am
r
t r s nd i
Pl i ifw o ked a a i pe ntc r t .Bec us t r i no c ai be or t Cour f ea h
a ntf r
s n nde nde ontac or
a e he e s l m f e he
t orbr c
o t ep ris id p nd n c n rco a re n ,h Co r g a t s mmayj dg n .
f h a t ' n e e e t o ta t r g e me tt e u t rn s u r u me t
e
THI CAUSEc mebeor t Courupont M otonfrSummayl
S
a
f e he t
he i o
r udgmentD. No. ,
( E. 25)
fl d on D e em ber2.
ie
c
2014.
THE COURT ha c i e t m oton, es e a t pe tne pori oft r cor
s onsder d he i r pons , nd he ri nt tons he e d,
and bei ot w i f l advi ed i t pr i es,i i
ng her se uly
s n he em s t s
A DJU DG ED t t m oton i G M N TED .
hat he
i s
1. Backeround
The e a et o r m a ni cl i si t sca e Count 1ofPl i if scom pl i i a cl i f
r r w e i ng a m n hi s .
V
a ntf
a nt s a m or
S
t i wa unde Fl i c mon lw a s c i 448.08 Fl i St t e .'CountV 1 i a
unpa d ges
r orda om
a nd e ton
, orda a ut s '
Is
cli f rr t lai n unde t Fai La St ndar Ac . Pl ntf,Ani Alons ale s i he
a m o e ai to
r he r bor a ds t ai if
a f o, l ge n r
c
ompli t t s was empl
ant ha he
oyed by Ca e Fis M e ca Ce e , l ,t r c ui pa i nt f om
r rt di l nt r nc. o e r t te s r
a oxi a el Se e be 2,201 t M a c 1 , 201 f a s lr of$600 perwee t ts was
ppr m t y pt m r
3 o rh 5
4 or aa y
k ha he
ne rpai De e ntCa eFis i am e ca c i cl aedi Hi ea , Fl i t tm a ges2,
ve d. f nda
r rts
di l lni oc t n al h or da ha na
000
t t pai n s Def nt vi Se r noi t Pr sde a Diecor a M a lSe r i t Vie
o al te t . enda Da d ra s he e i nt nd r t l nd be rano s he c
Pr s de ofCa e Fi s M edi lCe e .
e i nt
r rt
ca nt r
On Se e be 2, 3, a ntf a i f aposton a Ca eFis M e c lCentra s
pt m r 201 Pli if ppled or
ii t r r t dia
e nd he
i e vi wed wih Da d Se r no. Alo o De . a 27. Pli tf fled out a e pl
ntr e
t
vi ra
f ns
po t
a n if il
n m oyme
nt
a i ton a ot rpr - rng doc
pplcai nd he e hii
ument on Se e r2, 201 I ,Exh.1a 4. Pl i ifhad
s
pt mbe
3. d.
t
antf
wor a anur ef oneyea i Cuba. I a 49. M r Ser a of e e Pl ntf ça c r c t do
ked s
s or
rn
d t
. r no f r d ai if t ont a t o
tl ma kei t thewa e ndngt of ; ha hewa goi t ha phonest m a c l t
e e r tng;ha
s xpa i he fce t t
s ng o ve
o ke als o
pe e' hom e a t s e how t s l t Si pl l ur e.' 1 a 51. Si pl H e lhca e i a
opl s
s nd o e
o e l he m y ns anc ' d. t
m y at r s n
H M O t tCa e Fi s M e c Ce e ,I .a ce s I at39.
ha r r t di al nt r nc c pt . d.
On Se e be 1 2013,Pli ifc e t d a c
ptm r 8,
antf r a e
ompa c led Alons Se vies LLC a t
ny a l
f o r c ,
t he
die on ofDa d Se r no,who wa g ngt pa Pl n ifasa i pe ntc r c o . I a 43,
r di
vi r a
s oi o y aitf
n nde nde onta t r d. t
4 .Plitf t si e t a i tal h r o wo de t i lo i f rpain si t esre, e a s
5 anif e tf d h t ni l e j b ul nal o kng o te t n h te t b c u e
i
iy
Da i S ra o d d n th vet e c n to (..p n s a d tbls s tu i te o t t d
v d e rn i o a h o di ns i ho e n a e ) e p n h f o o
i
e
ke
t lm a ke i I a 52.Pli ifa ist ts sg d a i pe ntc r t rag e m e . 1
ee r tng. d t
antf dm t ha he i ne n nde nde ontac o r e nt d
a 55. Tha a r e enti i Engls a Pl ntf doe nots k or r ad Engls , but she does
t
t gem
sn
i h nd ai i f s
pea
e
ih
undesa s . f oDe . !3. s i t tM r Sera expl ne t he t ts woul be
rtnd ome Alons clat She ad ha . r no ai d o r ha he
d
l a d Se r no as um e t spos ton on M a c 1 , 201 Pr ort t tda e,M r Se r no
D vi r a
s d hi
ii
rh 4
4. i o ha t
. ra
w a nota e pl e, f c r ordi e t roft c i c
s
n m oye of i e ,
rco
he lni .
pai c
d omm iso f wha s s dofSi yHe lhc eonceCa eFis M e c Cent rs tup t
s i ns or t he ol
mpl a t ar
r r t di al
e e
he
c to f rhe t dot t l ma kei A lonso D epo. 56. l t mea i Pl ntf s yst t
ondiins o r o he e e r tng f
at
n he
ntme, ai if a ha
.
M r Se r nove bal a e d t pa he $600pe wee I a 58, Pl ntf ad itd t tt $ 0
. ra
r ly gr e o y r
r k d t 59. ai if m te ha he 60
.
pa e pe wee w asnoti t c r c , buti wrte o apic ofpa r 1 a 59- Pl i if
ym nt r k
n he ont a t
s it n n e e
pe . d. t 60. antf
a d t tt pic ofpa ra s i ude t na ofpai nt , how muc s woul ge pa dpe
dde ha he e e
pe lo ncl d he mes
te s
h he
d t i r
pai t a t t i a
ten nd ha t dded up t $600 I at 62. She lt r t tfed t t she t
o
d
a e esii ha
hought he wa
s
.
gua a e i he $600pe wee a t tt s pa at pic ofpa rdi r fec t t butSnot- not
r nt eng r
r k nd ha he e r e e e
pe d e l t ha ,
ç
s e tybutye .'d. Shec dnotr membe who wr et i or to downon t pa . I a
o xacl
s'1
oul
e
r
ot he nf ma i n
he d d t
Pl i ift tfe t ts wor d f De e nt fom Se e be 201 a c i nguntl
antf esii d ha he ke or f nda s r
ptm r 3 nd ontnui
i
M a c 1 201 Alons Dec . a !6 S ewo eame ia sr u io m dzigtetmes esy
r h 5, 4. f o
l t . h
r
d c l cub nf r t n h i h a s
r
s wo ked a Ca e Fis .1 a ! 1 . rn t ttme s etsiid t ts ev std p os e tv
he r
t r r t d t 3 Du ig ha i , h e tfe ha h iie r p cie
.
pa int i t rhom e t r c u tt m a pa int f Ca eFis M e c lCe e . A lonso D epo.at
te s n hei
s o e r i he s te s or r r t di a ntr f
68.Shes i s br
ad he oughtnumer uspa i t t Ca eFis, buti t e r r t da oxi ael 1
o
ten s o r r t
n he nd ec uie ppr m t y 5-
20pai s I a 7 73,Exh.1a P000055- ( fndanssat t tt numbe ofpaint i 1 ,
tent.d t 2t
65 Dee t t e ha he
r te s s 5
butt e bisrve asi l gr trnumbe) Pl ntf s ds s nta1 oftmetki t s
he xhi t e al lghty eae
r. ai if ai he pe ot i a ng he e
pai nt t do era ,t t pha m a y, a t feam a ke s She m a a nt
te s o
r nds o he r c nd he l
r t.
de ppoi ment f t m
s or he
,
dr t t s ilss a ge r ly dr t a ound i herown c r I at7 79. Pli if
ove hem o peca it, nd ne a l ove hem r
n
a. d
4,
antf
t tfe t ts unde soodt tDa d Se r no di no hiehe t do t s a tvii , butr t t
esiid ha he
r t ha vi ra
d t r r o he e c i tes
aher o
r nltpa i nt tlough m a ke i . I a 75.Pl i ifdoe , w e , i l t a ountoftm ei
ec i te s lr
r tng d t
a ntf
s ho ver nc ude he m
i t
t k he t drvet wor t d i patent hom e a t dr vet pi up he s l t f om a s r i
oo r o i o k, o rve i s
i o ck
r on a e r
po tng
, nd o
a tviy,i t am ountofhour wor . She as s yst ts wor drvi pa int a ound on
c i t n he
s ked
lo a ha he ked i ng te s r
w e ke f om 9 am t 1 pm a s i l s t ti he w or hour . I a 81 82.W he s
e nds r
o
nd he nc ude ha n r
k
s d t n he
do
r pped of te sa t c i c,Pl i ifcai s us t s he et i o he a
fpa i nt t he lni antf l ms he ed o c dul he r t r ppoi m e swhie
nt nt
l
s waied.I a 77.Pl ntf alot tfe t ts woul go pi u he c l e e r da a
he t d t
ai if s esiid ha he
d
ck p r hidr n ve y y nd
a tme he c l e wat d f he i s wasdrvi pa i t . 1 a 8
t i s r hidr n ie or r f he
i ng ten s d. t 4.A lhough s di pi k up
t
he d c
he c l e s s ds wor d o as hedul fom 8a t 6: a woul no m a i homet i
r hidr n, he ai he ke n c
er
m o 30 nd
d t ke t
mtl
8pm .I a 76- 79.Pl i ifdi nothavea ce st t c
d t 77,
antf d
c s o he omputrs t m sa Ca eFis. I a 79.
e yse t r r t d t
Pl i ifpr de he 201 a 201 t x r t ns The 201 r t n s st ts wass la ntf ovi d r 2 nd
3 a e ur .
2 e ur how ha he
ef
e o d a aphysc lt r pita ha ag os i omeof$1 425.Sheha f r d ac por ton
mpl ye s
i a he a s nd d r s nc
7,
d o me or a i
c le Alons sTher py Cor a i a Edua do Care apai herc pa t cl n t ofi e,
al d f o'
a
por ton nd
r
rr d
om ny o ea he fc
ge l h f t e oye s a pik up pai nt. I a 22. M r Ca r r w e outofbus nes i
t unc or he mpl e , nd c
te s d t
. r e a nt
i sn
J nua y201 a Alons sThe a Cor a i we outofbusne si M a c 201 . I a 21 23.
a r
3 nd f o'
r py por ton nt
i s n rh 3 d t ,
He 201 r t n s
r 3 eur howst ts wa s fe oye a aphysc t a s a ha agr si m e
ha he s el- mpl d s
ial her pit nd d os nco
of$3 11 a i ure $9, i c ra tu k e ns fom he busnes .Pl ntf a s t t t
2, 0 nd nc r d 523 n a nd r c xpe es r
r i s ai if s ers ha
f o Se e be t s e i e i 201 s w o ke e us ve y f D e enda Ca e Fi s M edi a
r m pt m r o om tm n
4 he x d xcl i l or f
nt r r t
cl
Ce e f r50ho spe w e k wihoutgetng pa d.Pli tf t sii dt td i 201 , s al o di
nt r o
ur r e t
ti
i
a n if e tfe ha urng 3 he s d
o dj bs o p o ea drnern f roh rp o l.1 . t3 l J n ay2 3 s ha woke f r
d o f r e pl n a ra ds o t e e p e d a 9. n a u r 01 ,he d r d o
M r Ca r r be or he we outofbusnes 1 a 24.Pl i ifsa e t tM r Ca r r pai he
. re a, f t
nt
i s. d. t
antf t t s ha
.
re a d r
$63 we whies wor d f hi .1 a 25.Pl i ifcli st $32, pr de o he 201
0/ ek, l he ke or m d. t
antf am he 000 ovi d n r 3
t xr t na s c m efom M r Ca r a.f a 30. l t c r
a e ur lo a r
. rer #. t She aer orededhe s fa s i t ts di not
r el nd ad ha he d
r m e rwhehert $3 000 s m a i 201 c m efom Edua do Ca r r 1 a 55.Pli if
e mbe
t he 2, he de n 3 a r
r
re a. d. t
antf
a s s i s doesnotr e be wha w or s di dur ng pori nsof201 . 1 a 38.
l o a d he
em m r
t k he d i
to
3 d. t
I i undiput d t tDe e nt ne r pa d Pli if a De e nt cl m t y di no
ts
s e ha f nda s ve i antf nd f nda s ai he d t
e pl Pl ntf .A ts e poi i 201 Pl i ifa ke M r Se r no a
m oy ai i f
om
nt n 4, a ntf s d . ra bouthe s l y.M r Se r no
r aar
. ra
t d he he had t s l t c i c, S t wor y, ha t pe s he w ass li t w a goi t
ol r
o e l he lni but t o
not
r t t he r on
e lng o s ng o
ke p k anit;ha myc nr c wa g igt k e g i . 1 .a 7 .Plitf sy s eto h r
e plitfl t t o ta t s on o e p ong' d t 0 an if a s h o k e
'
c r c wih he t tda 1 Thepari a r t tDe e nt ne rt r na edt Pl ntf.
onta t t r ha y. d.
tes g ee ha f nda s ve e mi t he ai if
ll.LegalSt
andard
S mmayj d me ti a t o ie wh r te ei n g n i is eo mae il a t Fe R.
u r u g n s u h rz d e e h r s o e une su f tra fc . d.
Ci P. 6c .Th pat s e i s mmayj dg n be r teiiil u de o d mo srtn te
v. 5 () e ry e kng u r u me t as h n ta b r n f e n taig h
a enc ofag neis ofmaeilfd.Adi e v. H. e st7 , U. 1 15 ( 970)
bs e
enui sue
tra a
ck s S. Krs lCo.398 S. 44, 7 1 .
Thep ryo p sn temo inf rs mmayj dg n ma n tsmpl r s u o meealg to s
a t p o ig h to o u r u me t y o i y e t p n r le ain
orde a soft pl di ;t non- ovi pa t m us esabls t es en i le e e s ofisc e
ni l
he ea ngs he
m ng r y
t t i h he s t a l m nt
t as
onwhi i wilbea t bur ofpr atti .CeotxCor v.Catet, U. 31 ( 986)
ch t l r he den
oof ral l e p.
r t477 S. 7 1 ;
Matus t Elc I s.Co.v Ze t Radi Cor ,475 U. 574 ( 98 . Thenonmova mus
s hia e . ndu
. nih
o p.
S.
1 6)
nt t
p e e t r ta as itlao e d n ei s p o t f h n n v n 'p sto .Aj r mu t ea l
r sn mo e h n cn il f vie c n u p ro t e o mo a t o iin u y s b be
s
r s bl t fndf t nonmova . r onv fi ry Lobb I ,477U. 242, 4 ( 986 .
eaona y o i or he
ntAnde s . be t
y, nc.
S. 25 1 )
111.A nal s
ysi
A.
CountV I Fl i C om m o Law C l m f
: or da
n
ai orunpai W age and Sec i 448. o t
d
s
ton
08 f he
Fl da Stat es
ori
ut
Unde Fl i c
r orda omm on lw, pl ntf c r cove t i wage unde abr ac ofc r t
a a ai if an e
r mpad
s
r e h ontac
te r Se Co/ev DitBd o r se s Mi - d Co Colg , ? S 2 1 , 4 ( a
h oy. e fz . s. .fT u te , amiDa e mm. le e 7 9 o. d 48 1 9 Fl
3.
d DCA 1 9 )Asf r h sauo ycam,tse to 4 .8do sn t r aeo oh r s p o d
9 9 . o t e tt tr li d lcin 480 e o ce t r te wie r vie
g
f a c us ofa ton f ba k w a s' tr a e i t ad t pa en ofa t y' f est a pr ii
or a e c i or c
ge , el t s ns e o ym t tonw s e o eva lng
i
pa t i a a ton f ba k w ag . Shor v Br
ry n n c i or c
es'
'
t . ynAl St di ,I . N o. 08- Tan u os nc , 8: CV- 30TG W ,
2008
W L 2222319,a *3( . Fl Ma 28,2008)(ii Fl Stt j448. whihsae i-heco t
t M D. a. y
ctng a. a.
08 c tts:l- ur
l
m a awa dt t pr ii pary i a a ton f runpai w ag c t oft ac i a a r as bl
y
r o he eva lng t n n c i o
d
es os s he ton nd e ona e
at ne sf .'. I t sc e,Pl nifscam f unpai wa i CountVIi baed on he
tor y' ee' n hi as aitf li or
)
d ges n
s s
r
a s rin t ts wa a e oye a Ca eFis M e c Ce e a t ts wa notpai $600pe
s e to ha he s n mpl e t r rt dial ntr nd ha he s
d
r
we k aspr s t he by Davi Se r no.
e
omied o r
d ra
Atis i t Pl ntf ' e oyme saus- wa s a e oye a $600perwe korwas
s ue s he ai ifs mpl
nt t t
s he n mpl e t
e
s a i pende c r c oro c
he n nde
nt onta t n omm ison f t pa i t s r nzt d. ih v Ne drSun
s i or he ten s he ec ie Ket . ws
Se i lCo.667So. 1 ( 995)i i tuci a hol t tc t is di tal l t t
ntne ,
2d 67 1
s nsr tve nd ds ha ours lhoul niily ook o he
a e m e be we n t pa tes .. a û r o he pr vii ofan ag ee t ort a t
gr e nt t e he ri . ' nd s e t r o sons
'
whe
r men , he cual
pr c ieoft pa te , let c e ton oft sa usa e t byt pa tes t a t l a tc a
a tc
he ri s be i he r a i
he tt gr ed o he ri , he cua pr c ie nd
r l tons p oft pa te s d c r . z1 ., 667 So. a 1 1; ee al o Ca r lv f twcçH om e
e a i hi
he r i s houl ontol' d
'
2d t 7 s
s
r ol . p ,
Ce e s I . No.1 23996- V,201 W L 1
ntr, nc,
2C1
4
928669,a *6- ( D.Fl M a 6,201 . in
t 7 S. a. y
4) i
l
de e m i ngw he hera e pl m e o i pe
t r ni
t n m oy nt r nde nden c r c orr l i hi e s s t f c spec i r
t ont a t e atons p xi t , he a t
ula
t e hca egove' t decson. Har re r .Daly v Tol ,884 So.2d 11 11 ( a.2d
o ac s
l he ii ' pe x el e . er
n
'
24, 33 Fl
DCA 200 . tl r e 'a t pe i t e c ca e'aet fcsco eni t c r cual
4) û- elvant fcs cular o a h s r he a t nc r ng he onta t
-he
a e m e bewee t pa te , welast c s oft pari 'co
gr e nt t n he ri s as l he our e he tes nduc unde t a ee nt''
t
r he gr me .'
I
d
Thepa tesi t sc s e er d i o a l pe
r i n hi a e nt e nt n nde ndentCont a t A gr e e t r quied t
r c or e m nt hat e r he
Pli if opr dem a ke i s r i e oCa eFis f
antf t ovi
r tng e v c st r r t oraso% c mi so yabl e r he
om s i npa e ve yot rwee
k.
Exhi tA t Pl ntf ' Res
bi o ai i f s pons Pl i ift tfed t ti addii t t I pe
e. a ntf es ii ha n
ton o he nde ndentConta t
r c or
Age me , vi Se rnoofeedhe $600pe we kuntl c ds upt co tons(. atbl
re ntDa d ra fr r
r e ihe oul et he ndii ie. a e
a te
nd elphone f rt pef r t e r tngfo t ci c Tha pr s ofawee ys l ywa
) orhe o rom elmakei rm he lni. t omie
kl aar s
z a n if s r l on t s a r s tf t i Fr und v H i Tec Sat lie I . 185 Fe
pl i tf e y
he t nda d e orh n e
. - h e lt , nc ,
d.
App' 782( 1hCi.2006) whihe tbls ss vealfcor f fde a courst consde i
x. 1 t r
, c sa ihe e r a t s or e r l t o i r n
Fai La St nda dsA c c s st de e m i whe hera i vi
r bor a r
t a e o t r ne
t
n ndi duali an e pl e oran
s
m oye
i pe ntc r c or A s t CountVlw hi h i a s a e c m on l w c ai , he C o tr leson
nde nde ont a t .
o
c s t t om
a lm t
ur e i
t sa r i Keih t ts t f t Fl rdal w on t sis TheFr nd t ti ve y smia t
he t nda d n t ha e s orh o i a
hi s ue.
eu es s r i lr o
Keih a a s pl c t e pl er scontolove t e pl e a t tr tf t t c i r
t nd l o a es he m oy '
r
r he m oye s he i s ac or o ons de .
not r duc d t wrtng i t l
e e o ii n he ndepe
ndent Conta or Ag ee
r ct
r ment l i undiput d t t t
.
ts
s e ha he
l pe nt Conta t Agr e e c aned a i eg a i c a e sa i t tt S gr m e
nde nde
r c or e m nt ont i
n nt r ton l us t tng ha he ç ee nt
a
c tt est fna unde sa ng a a e m e bewee t pa tes
onsiut he i l
r t ndi nd gr e nt t n he ri
wihr s c t tes be t
t epe t o h u j c
m at rher ofa s pe s sa 1prorneg itons unde sa ngs a a ee
te
e nd u rede 1 i
ota i ,
rt ndi , nd gr ment be we n t
s t e he
pa tes' Theag ee ntis l esa ihest tPli ifwa a i pe ntc
ri .
'
r me te f t bls ha a ntf s n nde nde
ontac orw or ng f
r t
ki or
c
omm ison.
si
Keih a ispr ny,
t nd t oge howe r i t c t Cour t a s e ua et c s oft pa te '
ve , nsnlt he
t o lo val t he our e he ri s
c
onduc unde t a e m e . W he el he a t lpr c ie oft pa tes bei t c eai n oft
t
r he gr e nt
r û cua a tc
t
he ri , le he r to
he
sausa ee t by t pa tes t a t lpr c ie a r a i hi oft pa tess d cont ol'
t t gr d o he ri , he c ua a tc nd eltons p he ri houl
r .
'
Keih,6 So. at1 1 The c tmus r or t af cts cii a yssunde t Resat nt
t 67 2d
7.
our
t es t o a -pe fc nal i
r he t eme
( e o of e c ) a e o tea t a p a tc o tep ris I l t scas t cours ofconduct
S c nd Ag n y b s d n h cu l rcie fh a t d n hi e,he
e
e
.
s
upporst l
t he ndepe ntConta orAg e m e .
nde
r ct
r e nt
TheRettme ( ondof nc lsstnfcor frt Court c i i dee mi ng
sae nt Sec
Age y)it e a t s o he
to onsdern tr ni
whe he a w o ke i a e pl ee or a i pe nt c r c or3 Ket 667 So.2d at1
t r
r r s n m oy
n nde nde ont a t .
ih,
70, n.
1;
Car ol,201 W L 1 669a * 7. Fl i c t ha he dt tt prm a y f c orço bedecde
r l 4
928
t 6orda ours ve l ha he i r a t s
t
i d
wih r ga dt whehe a e iyi ani pe ntco r c ori t deg eeofc r e ci ed over
t e r o
t r n ntt s nde nde
nta t s he r
ontol xer s
t deaisoft wor 'PaulN Howar Co. v A f ode, n .7 S 2 4 2 4 4 ( a 5h
he t l he k.
'
d
. fh l r I c, 01 o. d 0 - 0 Fl. t
3'etnfcor no i ude:()t xtntofco r whih, by t agr em ent t
'h e a t s w ncl
I
a hee e
ntol c
he e
, he
m a trmaye r ieOvert det l o t ewo k ( )wh t ro n t h o ee o e i e a e
se
xe c s
he ais f h
r ; b ehe r o t e n mply d s ng g d
i aditnc oc upai orbusnes;()t ki ofoc upai , w ih r f ence t w het r i t
n si t c ton
i s c he nd
c ton t e er
o
he , n he
l
oc iy,hew o k i us ly doneunde t dieci oft e o orb as cils w ihout
alt t
r s ua l
r he r ton he mpl yer y pe a it t
s r so ( t s lrquie i t pa tc a occ ton;( whehe t emplyeeort
upeviin; d) he kil e rd n he riulr upai e) t r he
o
he
wor n s plest i tum e altes t s a t plceofwor f t pe s doi t
kma up i he nsr nt ii , ool, nd he a
k or he r on ng he
wok; 9 t elngho t f rwhc t ep ro i e ly d; g temeh do p y n ,
r ( h e t f i o ih h e s n s mpo e ( ) h t o f a me t
me
wh t e b t etmeo b t j b;h wh t e o n t h wo ki apat ft rg lrb sn s o
eh r y h i r y he o () eh r r o t e r s r o he e u a u ie s f
t ee o e ; i wh te o n thepa t sb le et e aec e tn t rlto o ma tra d
h mply r () eh r r o t ri eiv h y r r aig he eai n f se n
e
sr a t a d()wh t e tep icp l so i n ti b sn s. i , 67S 2d at170,n.
evn; n
eh r h rn ia i r s o n u ie s Ket 6 o
h
1.
.
DCA 1 9 )(ingMa s nv Miyet, 41S 2 1 1 ( l . s DCA 1 8 ) whihwa a p o e
9 7 ct
i
dio . d te 5 o. d 3 5 F a 1 t
9 9, c s p rv d
byt Fl i SuprmeCour,559So. 11 ( a.1 ) TheEl nt Cic thassae t t
he orda e
t
2d 26 F1 990).
eve h rui
ttd ha
dll e s eoft c
dthe senc he ommon lw' ts frwhehe anag i a e oye ora i pe ent
a s et o
t r
ent s n mpl e n nde nd
c r cori t c r oft de a l't ti,whehe t prncpa hast rg t c r t
onta t s he ontol he t is ha s
,
t r he i i l
he i ht o ontol he
ma ra me bywhiht ag ta c ihest wor 'fan îtv Fe MarneTe mi s
nne nd ans
c he en c ompls he k.' gjt . d
i r nal,
I . 647 F. 111 11 1 ( 1h Ci.2011. tll mode ofdoi t wok i t prncpal
nc,
3d 6, 2 1 t r
) i- he
f
ng he r s he i i
c i rton,'be a ewheetaperon i s j c t t c r ordie i ofa he ast hi
onsdeai ' c us
r d s s ub e t o he ontol rcton not r o s
rs lso l ,h i a i e e d n c nr co ,i h i s be tt c nr la t t eme n u e t
e ut n y e s n nd p n e t o ta tr f e s u jc o o to s o h a s s d o
a hivet r uls hei a e oy 'KaneFar Cop.v M ianda,506So. 1 1 ( a
c e he es t, s n mpl ee.
'
m r . r
2d 061, 064 F1.
2dDCA 1 .
987)
I t sc e, he r cor e de e doe nots
n hi as t e d vi nc
s
uppor atndi t tDef nda sc r ld t
t i ng ha
e nt ontole he
de ais of Pl i if s wor t s h a e e t t t Cour s
tl
a ntf
k o uc n xt nt ha he
t houl di r ga d t I pe
d s e r he nde ndent
Conta t r A g e e . The onl f t t s
rco
r em nt
y ac s hat uppor Pl i if a e t t s w or a m e ca s r
t a ntf r ha he
e
di l c ub
u f m whie wor ng a s t s ii d s wor d f om 8 a t 6: pm .She di notpr de
nior
l
ki nd he e tf e he
ke r
m o 30
d
ovi
t tm ony t ts w asr quie t w e rt unior and s al o s a e t ts i l d a i e
es i
ha he
e r d o a he f m
he s t t d ha he nc ude nytm
s wasdrvi t wor drvi pa int hom e drvi t he chidr n' s hooli he caculton
he
i ng o k, i ng te s
, i ng o r l e s c
n r l ai
ofhe w or hour . ti undi put d t tPl ntf a a 1tm e d ovepa i nt i he ow n ca .The e i
r k
sI s
s e ha ai i f t 1 i s r
te s n r
r
r s
nor c devi nc t tPli ifr pore t as pe viora t m e c clni orc c i u n he
e or de e ha antf e td o u r s t he dial i c he ked n po r
a vala outupon he de ru e.Pl i ifdi no us t c
ni nd
r pa tr
antf d t e he omput rs t m a t c i c a at
e yse t he lni , nd
mos s us d t pho t m a a nt e son occ son whies wat d f he pai nt .
t he e he ne o ke ppoi m nt
ai
l he ie or r te s
Pl ntf t s ii d i he de ii t ts us t r r tpa i nt f D e e nt a t
ai i f e tfe n r poston ha he ed o ec ui te s or f nda s nd he
l pe ntContac ora e e r uie he t do m a ke i She t tf e t ts w oul g t
nde nde
r t gr em nt eq r d r o
r tng.
es ii d ha he
d oo
pot nta pa i nt hom es a w oul e a n t Si pl H e lhca e pl She woul d i t e
e i l te s
nd
d xpl i he m y a t r an.
d r ve hos
po e i lpai nt t r e r nds fom g ng t t fe m a ke t t ph
t nta te s o un r a
r
oi o he la r t o he
a c e no t
nna y, ve n he
wee nds whih s a it da he de ii wasnots ehi t tM r Se r no r qui e ofhe
ke , c he dm te t r poston
om t ng ha . r a e r d
r
.
Ye,s c i r t tme s ntdrvi a ound t pa int aspa tofhe wo k.
t he onsde ed he i pe i ng r
he te s
r
r r
l i undiputd t tPli if di no r c i fom Ca e Fis a Empl e O re a i n
ts
s e ha antf d t e e ve r
r rt n
oye
i nt to
Ha
ndboo or ot f m s gi n t ne hi e , s h as a Empl e Sa e y Che it
k,
her or
ve o w r s uc
n
oye f t
ckls
.
Ra he ,
t r
Pl i ifpr ed i t s ltga i a cop of he applc ton a t I pende Cont act
antf oduc n hi ii ton
y
r
i a i nd he nde
nt
r or
A g ee e . M o e r Ca e Fis i rquie by t Fl i Admi sr i Code j 59
r m nt
r ove , r rt s e rd
he orda
nitatve
A-
3 . 2()h t k e p ro n lflso a1 mpo e sa n n wa k p f rPli tf
301 5( ) o e p es n e ie n 1e ly e nd o e s e t o anif
.
Ba e on pa te ag e m e a t c s ofco
sd
ri s' r e nt nd he our e
nduc i t sca e t Cour fndst t
t n hi s , he
ti
ha
P an ifc n o r c v ro asaelw cam f ru padwa e a g a t s mmayj d me ta t
litf n n t e o e n tt a li o n i g s nd r ns u r u g n s o
ComtVl Pli ifdi nots f br a h ofc r c ba e on Def ndants f iu et pa hera
t
. antf d
ue or e c
onta t s d
e
' al r o y
c
omm ison unde t l pe nt Contacor Ag e m e . Li wie Pli if c nnotr ove
si
r he nde nde
r t
r e nt ke s , a ntf a
ec r
at ne s f esunderFl i St t e s c i 448.08 be aus s i a i pende c r t .
tor y' e
orda aut e ton
c e he s n nde
nt ontac or
M ur a v Plymak Se s LLC, Fe Ap x 873, ( 1h Ci.
ry . a
er rv .,
325 d. p'
875 1 t r 2009 .
)
B . R e alaton C l m unde FLSA
t i i
ai
r
CountVI i a c am f r t lai undert Fai La Stnda ds Ac . 29 U. C.j
l s l i or e ai ton
he r bor a r
t
S.
2l ()3 (etn f rhtea t-eaito pr v so o t FarLa o Sa d r Ac a saigi
5 a( ) s tig o t h n irt l in o iin f he i b r tn ads t nd tt t
a
n
a i t e o es.TheElve hCic thass tf t t Fr undf cor i t FLSA co e
pples o mplye )
e nt rui
e orh he e a t s n he
ntxt
t de e ne whehe a wo ke i a e oye o a i pe nt c r c or The a l i i
o t nni
t r
r r s n mpl e r n nde nde onta t .
na ys s s
s t nta l sm ia t t Fl i c m o 1 w t te pl d a
ubs a i ly i l r o he orda om n a es m oye bove.
TheFr ndfcor aet ( )naur a de eeoft algedemplye sco r ast t
eu a t s r he 1 t e nd gr
he le
o r' ntol o he
mame i whiht wor i pefr d;( t algede oye sopporuniyf pr i orl s
l r n c he k s ro me 2) he le
mpl e'
t t or oft os
de ndi upo hi mana ra s l;()t ale d e oyee' i t nti e pme o
pe ng n s
geil kil 3 he lge mpl s nvesme n qui nt r
maeil;4 wh t e t esr ierq ie s ca s il;5 t d g e o p r ne c a d rto
tras ( ) eh r h e vc e ur s pe il k ls ( )he e re f e ma n y nd u ain
oft wor ngr ai hi a ( t e e t whiht s r ierndeedi ani e a pa t t
he ki eltons p; nd 6) he xtnto c he e vc e r s ntgrl r ofhe
busne s Fr und,1 Fed. App' a 783. Li t Re t t me ' f c or , t e f c or wei i
i s. e
85
x t
ke he sa e nts a t s hes a t s gh n
f voroffndi Pl ntf wasa i pe ntc r c or
a
i ng ai if
n nde nde onta t .
As a l ed e ri ,t De enda s e r ie ltl contoli s r sng t m n ri
nayz a ler he f nt xe c s d ite
r n upe vi i he nne n
whih t Pl ntf wor d. She eve t sii d t tmuch ofwha s di , drvi pa int on
c he ai if ke
n e tfe ha
t he d i ng te s
e r nds wa outi ofwha Da d Se r no a ked ofhe . Sec
ra , s sde
t vi ra s
r
ond,t Pli tf so
he a n if pporuniy f
t t or
pr i t ne on c
oft ur d
omm ison a i wasup t he t ç
s i nd t
o ro ç
pound t pa
he veme 't r r i pa int t e r
nt'o ec ut te s o a n
t tco m i son. Se al o M ur a , 51 F.Supp. a 1
ha m s i
e s
ry 2
24 t 278 ( di t tt pli ifwa a
hol ng ha he antf s n
i pe ntcontacorwhe s wa hie on acommison- y bass. Thet r a f t
nde nde
r t
n he s rd
si onl i)
hid nd ourh
Fr ndf c oï alodonot i t ba a eawa fom fndi Pli if a i pe ntc r t .
eu a t s s
tp he l nc
y r i ng a ntf was n nde nde ontacor
Pli ifsi sm e sconsse off r ngacor ai t a e pa e a he ca , whi s
antf nve t nt
it d o mi
por ton o cc pt ym nt nd r r ch he
dai d asabusne se ns of$9500 on he 201 t x r t . a ntf a s t si dt ts ha
me
i s xpe e
r 3 a e um Pli if lo e tle ha he d
no pe f me m a ke i orr r tng ofpa int be or t stme a t ewe e no s i s ls
t ror d r tng ec uii
te s f e hi i nd her r
pecal kil
s ne ded. The ffh a sxt f t s we gh i f vorof fndi Pl i ifwasa i pe n
he e
it nd i h acor i n a
i ng antf
n nde nde t
c r c or The ewa no pe ma
onta t . r s
r nenc t t r lto hi a t a e
e o he e ai ns p s he gr emen ga Pli ift rg
t ve a ntf he i ht
t tr na e wih one m ont s no i a Pli if di l ve a tr a
o e mi t t
h' tce nd antf d ea fe bout sx m ont . Fi ly,
i
hs na l
Pl n if swo kwa no i eg alot busnes .Shet tfe t ts di notha co put a ce s
aitf
r s t nt r t he i s
esii d ha he d
ve m er c s
a t clni I a ton, hepr de e denc a herde ii t ts br
t he i c.n ddii s
ovi d vi e t
poston ha he oughti a
n bout1 t 20
5o
pa int a ne r r isf t c i c, c c e f 2, pa i t . A c r ngl t Cour fnds
te s s w ec ut or he lni whih ar d or 000 ten s co di y, he
ti
t tPli ifwas a i pe ntc r ct a a s h i una e t r ove unde FLSA f
ha antf
n nde nde onta or nd s uc s bl o ec r
r
or
r t la i
e a i ton.
I a y e e t t saeacam o rtlai nu e FLS Plitf mus s w t t()s e
n n v n , o tt li f eaito nd r A, an if t ho ha 1 h
e ag i a tviypr ece unde (he ac;( s s e nty s frd a rea ton b t
ng ed n ci t ot td
r t ) t 2) he ubsque l ufee dve s ci y he
e oye;a ()ac us c
mpl r nd 3 a al onnecin e sed bewe n t e oye sa tviy and t a re
to xit t e he mpl e' ci t
he dve s
a ton. Wol'.Coc col Co.200F. 1 13 43( 1h Ci.2000) l i undiput t t
ci ' fv a- a ,
'
3d 337, 42- 1 t r
. t s s ed ha
Plitf so p dwo kngv ln ai I rs o s t tes mmayj d me t s ecamsta s e
anif tp e r i ou trl n e p n e o h u r u g n , h li h t h
y.
wasc t c i l dic r d be aus De e nt f iedt payhe ,
onsnz tvey s ha ge c e f nda s a l o
r howeve , antf' co ai
r Pl i ifs mpl nt
d e n tp e d acam f rc nsr cieds h r e Th rf r ,h Co r fn ss mmayj g n
o s o la li o o tu t ic a g . eeo e te u t id u r ud me t
v
a opr a e ast t FLSA r t i ton c a m .
ppr i t
o he
e ala i l i
?
.
DO A OR E E iC a est a ,lratif dyoMac,05
NE ND D R D n hmbraMimiFoi ,hs a f rh21.
d
re
'
.
.
z
..
.
,e e
y '.
C-
x x- ...
''
W
.
-
'
*
.
.
FE
CO A .M O
O
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U
Copi pr de t
es ovi d o:
Couns lofRec d
e
or
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?