Promenade Plaza Partnership v. Centimark Corporation

Filing 59

ORDER Denying Cross Motions for Summary Judgment. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 3/25/2015. (jw)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRICT CO URT
SO UTH ERN DI
STRICT O F FLO RI
DA
CASE NO .1 c 22784-11
4- v1 NG

THE PROM ENADE PLAZA PARTNERSHI
P,
a Fl i pa t r hi
orda rne s p,
Pl ntf,
ai if

CENTI ARK CORP. a f egn cor aton,
NI
, or i
por i
Def nda .
e nt
/

QRDER DENYI CRO SSS OTI NS FO R SVM M ARY JVD G M ENT
NG
M
O

THI CAUSE c me beo e t Co r up n c o sm oins f rs
S
o s f r he u t o r s- to o umma y j g n :
r ud me t
De e da tCe tmak' M o in f rS
fn n n i r s to o umm ay J g n ( 3 )a Plitf Pr me a e s
r ud me t DE 8 nd an if o n d '
M o in f rPa ta S
to o ril umma y J g n ( 4 ) The moi nsa' f l b if d Thi a to
r ud me t DE 0 .
to l ul ree . s cin
e y
co e ns a r s t t tCe i a k i t led ove Pr e de' s ppi ce e i 2005
nc r
oof ysem ha ntm r ns a l
r om na s ho ng nt r n
a 2006. The pa i ' a ee ent t i t l t r
nd
rtes gr m
o nsa l he oof s t i ude a contac da e
ysem ncl s
r t td
De m be 1 2005,a aw a r nt da e Aprl6,
ce r 5,
nd
ra y t d
i 2006.

Pr
omenade br
ought t s ac i f dam a
hi ton or
ges a lgi va i
le ng rous def t i t r
ec s n he oof
s t m t t wer i oxi a el ca e by t i ope c tuc i and/ f l e of t
yse ha
e l
pr m t y us d
he mpr r onsr ton
or aiur
he
RoofSyse s'ort us ofi pr rm a e i l durng i t l to Pr e
t m ' he e m ope
t ra s i nsala i n. om nade a s c e
l o ont nds
t tc t i r par Ce i k pe f m e i 201 ha ca ed or c rbut t ce ti r
ha eran e is ntmar r or d n
2 ve us
onti ed o ra n oof

dee t .Th p ris c o smoi ns fr s mma y j gme a d e s t e nar w is s
fc s e a te ' r s - to o u r ud nt d r s hr e ro sue :
( )whih saelw a le ,a d e s q n l whih l tto p ro g ve sPr me d '
1 c tt a pp is n on e ue ty c i ai ns e i d o m o na es
mi
cams ( )wh t r Pr me d s cams ae tme bar d u e t g v r n l iain
li ; 2 ehe o na e' li r i - re nd r he o e nig i t to s
m

p ro a d ( )wh t r Pr me a e s po e ta d ma e a e lmie b t Ap i 20 6
e id; n 3 ehe o n d ' tn il a g s r i t d y he rl 0
W a r y.Upon c i r i of t pa tes' c os - otons a w ih t be ft of or
rant
onsde aton
he ri
r sm i , nd t he ne
al
t
udest tt c os - i s d be de ed.
ha he r s motons houl
ni
a gum e , t e cour concl
r
nt 1 h

L

St nda d o M o i n f S mar Judz nt
a r n to or um
v
me

S mmay j g n i a pr p it whe e t e pla n a s pp rig mae il
u r ud me t s p o rae
r h e digs nd u o tn
tras
e t ih t tt r i no ge ne i s a t any mat ralf tand t tt m ovi pa t i
sabls ha he e s
nui s ue s o
e i ac
ha he
ng ry s

e tte t j d n a amatroflw. eFe R. v. 5 ;Ceotx Cor v Catet 47
n ild o u gme t s
te a Se d. Ci P. 6 l e
p. . r t, 7
U. 31 ,3 2 ( 9 6 .A f c i i tra' i i i ma d t r ne t e o t o u de te
S. 7 2 1 8 ) a t s v e il f t s y ee mi h u c me n r h
ma
'
a pl a e s sa tvelw. de s n v Li e t Lob y I c,47 U. 2 2,2 ( 98 ) The
p i bl ub tn i a An r o . b ry b , n . 7 S. 4 48 1 6 .
c
nonm ovi pa t m us s
ng ry
t how s fc f ct t s
pecii a s o uppor t tt e i a ge ne di put 1 a
t ha her s
nui
s e. d. t

2 6. amo in f rs mmayj g n ,t c u tmus viw t e d n e a d r s l a 1
5 On
to o u r ud me t he o r t e he vie c n e ove 1
i er nc i t lghtm os f a e t t nonmovi pa t f a 255.I r e ng t
nf e es n he i
t avor bl o he
ng ry. #, t
n evi wi he

r c r e d nc ,heCo tma no u e tk t j r sf ncin of ihi t e d n eo
e o d vie e t ur y t nd ra e he u y' u to weg ng he vie c r
unde t ng cr biiy det m i i .Latme v.Roarng To ,I ,601 F. 1
raki
edi lt
er natons
i r
i
yz nc.
3d 224,1
237

( 1h Ci. 01 )
1 t r2 0 .
Ez

W hih La Go e ns Fl rdaorPe v v ni ?
c w v r - oi
nns l a a

The pa tesdia e ove whi h l w gove nsPr
ri s gr e
r c a
r
omenade' cl m s Pr e de a gues
s ai . om na r
t t Fl i l w gove ns be us Doc e A205,whi h i pa tof t Contac ,s ys i
ha orda a
r , ca e
um nt
c s r
he
r t a t

do s ûf e Co ta ts l bego e n d by t 1w oft plc whe et p o e ti l c td
e : l' n r c hal
-h
v re
he a
he a e r he r j c s o ae
g..Fl rd l'DE 4 1 a 4. n i r a g e t a Pe s l a i lw g vens be a et
i , oia.
e
'
4- , t Ce tma k r u s h t nn y v na a o r , c us he
Aprl 2006 W a r nt s ys i doe S-hi W a r nt i i s
i
ra y a t
s: i s
r
r a y s s ued a t Com or e ofi s of
t he
at fce
1TheCour he r a oxi a el one hourofor ar e on M ar l 5 201 5 a t Ja es
t a d ppr m t y
al gum nt
ch 7
5 t he m
La e Ki Feder J tceBuidi a Unie St t Courhous M i m i Fl i
wr nce ng
al us i
l ng nd
t d a es
t e, a , orda.

Ce i a k Cor a i i Ca
ntm r
por ton n
nons g, Pe yl ni , a a or ngl i gover
bur
nns va a nd cc di y s
ned by
Penns va a lw . DE 38-1 A s mpl copy oft Aprl2006 W a r y i i or a e i o
yl ni a '
'
. a e
he
i
r ant s nc por t d nt
t Conta ,a t pa tescont
he
r ct nd he ri
emplt isf ur is nc
a ed t ut e s ua e.
Fl rda' c ce of lw r esde er i whe herFl i orPenns va a l w a i .
o i s hoi - -a ul
t m ne
t
orda
yl ni a pples

Am.
Fami fteAs u an e Co o u u ,Ga v U.. r Co,8 5F.d 8 6,8 0 ( 1h
l ' ' s r c . fcolmb s . . S Fie . 8 2 2 3 1 t
y /
Ci.1 8 ) Aso Co ti t e So t e n Ditito Flrd r c n l r c gnz d,i a c s
r 9 9 . ne ur n h u h r src f o ia e e ty e o ie n a e
i vi Ce i k a sm ia contac ua pr s ons t e i a ditnc i be w e n cl m s
nvol ng ntmar nd i l r
r t l ovii , her s s i ton t e ai

b o h u e t Conr c a t os br u t s ll u de t W a rnt Dr t od
r ug t nd r he
ta t nd h e o gh o ey n r he ra y. f wo
Hos t i M gmt,LLC v. Ce i ar Cor ,N o. 1 c 61
pialt
y
.
ntm k
p.
4- v- 802,201 W L 4825274,a *2
4
t
s a ng hi he ur c ncu e ha he wo
( D. a Se t 2 2 4 ( o m , .. Under t ndi t s, t Co t o l d st tt t
S. Fl . p . 5, 01 ) Blo J)2
c c of lw pr sons do not c lc .By t i e e s t r s t Fl i c c of l
hoie- -a
ovi i
onfi t
her xpr s e m , he orda hoie- -aw

p o ii n i t e Co ta t g v r tth Co r c, a d t e Pems va a c ie o -a
r v so n h
nr c o e ns s l e nta t' n h r yl ni ho c - flw
g
'
pr v so i t Aprl 0 W a rnt g ven ith sW ar ny.
o ii n n he i 20 6 ra y o r s û j i ra t '
g
'
The Cour' concl i a
ts
uson bout whih 1w gover Pr enade' c ai s de e m i
c a
ns om
s lm
t r nes
whi h lm ia i ofac i pr son gove ns Pr enade' cl m s The contacualone ye r
c i t ton- - ton ovi i
r
om
s ai '
.
r t
- a
lm ia i ofac i pr s on i t Aprl2006 W a r nt gove nsc ai st ta i e undert
i t ton- - ton ovii n he
i
ra y
r l m ha rs
he
Wa
nunt r ng i r t da e t ta def c i m a eral orwor a hi or ot rbr ac
y, unni i om he t ha
f
et n t i s
km ns p,
he e h
or a o her cli i dicover or r ona y s d ha bee dicover ' D E 38-1
ny t
am s s
ed
eas bl houl ve
n s
ed.'
.
Fl i s f - rs a ut oflm iai govel el m st ta ie unde t Contad,r ng
orda' ouryea t t e i t ton
' ai ha r s
ns
r he
r
unni

2 The Dr woo o i i n a d e s d c c - fv n p o so r t e t n c oieoflw
ft d p n o d r s e hoie o - e ue r viins ah r ha h c - -a
pr s ons
ovii .

fo bh tme t e gae t d f c i d s ov r d o s u d ha e be n d s o e e wih t
r m l e i h ltn l e e t s ic ee r ho l v e ic v r d t he
t
e e cs ofd d lg n e'Fl. a . 5. 13 ()3
x r ie ue ii e c . a Stt 9 1 ( )c .
'
1 TheLi t to o - me e Pr v so i t Aprl2 06W a r v
mia in- fRe dis o iin n he i 0
r ant
As m or f l e ai d i Pa t 11 be ow, t Cour cam ot concude t t
e uly xpl ne n r 1 , l
he
t l
l
ha
Pr
omena scl i sne s arl a ie unde et t Contac ort Aprl2006 W arant as
de' am
ce s iy r s
r iher he
r t he
i
r y

a ma t r of f t Centm a k neve t l s a gues t t Pr
te
ac .
i r
rhees r
ha omenade' cl m s nec s rl a ie
s ai
es a iy rs
unde t Aprl2006 W a r y asam at rofl
r he
i
rant
te
aw.
The Aprl2006 W a r nt by is e es t r s c r onl tlaks r uli f om
i
r a y,
t xpr s e m , ove s y ûe
es tng r

d fcs i t mae il o wo k ns p i t e r of s r c s ( evie ) pe f r d b
e e t n he tras r r ma hi n h o evie s r c s ro me y
CentM a k.'DE 38-1 Thi Sl ks'W a r nt m us be r d as a lm iaton on t Conta t s
i r '
. s iea ' r a y
t ea
i ti
he
rc'
gene alwa r nt ofm a e i sa wor a hi
r
ra y
t ral nd
km ns p:

The Co ta t r wa rn s t t Owne a d Ar hie tt t ( ) ma e il a
nr co ra t o he
r n c tc ha : 1 tras nd
eq pm entf nihed unde t Conta tw ilbe new a ofgood qualt unl s
ui
ur s
r he
rc l
nd
iy e s

ohewierqur d o p nni e b t eCo ta tDo ume t;( t e W o k wil
t r s e ie r e t d y h nr c c n s 2) h
t
r l
be fee fom def t no i r i t qualt r r or pe m it a
r r
ec s t nhe ent n he
iy equied
r ted; nd

( )t eW o kwil o f r t t r q r me t ofteCo ta tDo u nt.
3 h
r l c n o m o he e uie n s h n rc c me s
DE 44-1 a 2.Tha i,t t e e Pr e
,t
t s o he xt nt om nade s ks t r cover f kl ks r uli fom
ee o e
or lea es tng r

d fcs i t e mae i l o wo k n hi i t r o sr i e (e v c s p ro me b
ee t n h
tras r r ma s p n he o f e v c s s r ie ) e f r d y
Ce i ak'Pr nade' r ovey i lmie by t t msoft tl ks'W a rnt
ntM r ' ome
s ec r s i td he er
he lea ' ra y.
3Alhough t one- rlm ia i ofa ton pr s on i t Apr l2006 W arant a i st
t
he
yea i t ton- - c i
ovii n he
i
r y pple o
ta c am s' t lm iaton i voi underFl i l w,Fl St .95. a t r f e ca
dny l i ,' he i t i s d
orda a
a. at 03, nd he e or nnot
gove' Pr e de' cl m s a ii unde t Contac . The one ye lm ia i i
l
n om na s ai
r sng
r he
r t
- ar i t ton s

pemisbl u de Pe ns va alw, Pa Co . t t j5 01a , n e o c a ei Fl rda
r s i e n r n yl ni a 42 . ns S a . 5 () a d nf r e bl n o i
cou t ast Pr e
rs o om nade' cl m sa ii unde t Aprl2006 W a r nt M az oniFar ,I
s ai r sng
r he
i
r a y. z
ms nc.

v E1 Du tDeNe r & Co. 761So. d 3 6 ( a 2 0 ;Bu r u s Co p.v Su tgs
. . pon
mou s
,
2 0 Fl . 0 0) r o gh r . n o
o amiI c, 7 So 2d 1 6 ( a 1 85 .
fMi , n v4 2 . 1 6 F1, 9 )

Centm a k neverhel s a gues t tPr m enade' onl a iabl c es ofac i a e
i r
t es r
ha o
s y va l e aus
ton r
t e cove e by t fl ks' W a r nt due t t ll ks' W a r nt s i
hos
rd
he iea '
r a y,
o he iea '
r a y' ' usviy of
Excl i t
W a r nt and Li t i ofRe edi 'pr son:
ra y
miaton
m es' ovi i
CEN TI A RK EX PRESSLY DI
M
SCLA I S A LL EX PRESS OR I PLI
M
M
ED
W ARRAN TI I CLU DI G THE W ARRAN TI O F M ERCHAN TA BI TY
ES N
N
ES
LI
AN D FI ESS FOR A PA RTI
TN
CULAR PURPO SE OR AN Y OTHER I PLI
M
ED
W ARRAN TY .THI EX PRESS LI I
S
M TED W ARRANTY CON TA I THE SO LE
NS
AN D EXCLUSI W A RRAN TY AN D REM ED Y OF PURCHA SER AGA I ST
VE
N
CEN TI ARK . THERE I N O EX PRESS W ARRAN TY OTH ER THAN THAT
M
S
STATED I TH I W AR RAN TY.
N
S

DE 3 - . eCo tc n l e t a t sp o iin mus b r a a r ltn o y t t s j c
8 1 Th ur o cud s h t hi r v so
t e e d s e aig nl o he ub e t
m at r of t i e ' W a r nt Fis, t t e ent t s pr son ca be r d t lmi
te
he i aks' r a y. rt o he xt
l
hi ovi i
n
ea o i t
Pr e de' ava l e l r lefagai tCentm a k t ac i f il ,'r r e sofa
om na s iabl egal e i
ns
i r o tons or seaks' ega dl s
ny

c n eva l b e c o o h rwr n o n r ltn t t epa te 'Co ta t( ih i go e n d
o c i b e r a h r t e o gd i g eai g o h ri s nr c wh c s v r e

b Flrd lw) t e Co r fnd t e lmiai t b un e s n bl S e Oc a Du e o
y o ia a , h u t i s h i tton o e r a o a e. e e n n s f
Huc is I ln De .Cor v Co a geo 46 S 2 43 ,4 ( a 4h DCA 1 5
th n on sa d v
p. . l n l , 3 o. d 7 39 F1. t
98 )
( s c c n r cu l p o ii n .. mu t b r a o a e t be e o c d' . Se o d, t e
i u h o ta t a r vso s . s e e s n bl o
i
nf r e .) c n h
'
pr son mus be r ad t he wih a lt pr son i t il ks' W a r y: i-hi
ovi i
t
e oget r t
a er ovii n he vea '
rant d- s
l
W a r nt Agr m e i unde sood t be t compl e a e usve war a y a ee ent
ra y
ee nt s
rt
o
he
et nd xcl i
r nt gr m

bew e n t Pur e a Ce i a k, s s ng al pror a ee ent ,whet r or or
t e he
chas r nd ntM r uper edi
l i gr m s
he al

wrte a d a1ohe c mmu c to sbewe n t pa t sr l tng t t s j c ma t ro
itn, n l t r o niai n t e he ri e a i o he ub e t te f
e
t sW a r nt ' DE 38 1 ( mph ss a e .Th Co r h dst a Pr me d sa albl
hi r a y.
'
- e a i dd d) e u t ol h t o na e' v ia e
l galr i a i t Centm a k i lm ie t a i unde t ç e ks ' W a r y onl t t
e
elef ga ns
i r s i t d o ctons
r he i a '
l
r ant
y o he

e e t t s h lga r i r l t s t iea r uli fom def t i t m a e i s o
xt nt ha uc e l elef e a e o l ks es tng r
l
ec s n he t ral r

wo k ns p i t er fs r ie ( evie )p ro me byCe tM ak.
r ma hi n h oo e v c s s r c s e f r d
ni r '
'

11
1.

H ast St ut ofL i iat ons E xpi e on Pl nt f C l m s
he at e
m t i
rd
ai i rs ai ?

The Co t ha c ude t t Fl i s f - a sat e of lm iatons gove ns
ur s oncl d ha orda' ourye r t ut
i ti
r
Pr e de' c a ms arsng unde t Conta ,a t tt contac ualone ye r lm ia i
om na s l i
ii
r he
r ct nd ha he
r t
- a i ttonofac i pr son gove ns Pr e de' c am s a ii unde t il ks'W ar a y.Thr e
- ton ovii
r
om na s l i
rsng
r he kea '
r nt
e

q e ton t e f lw:( )wh c o P o n d ' cam sa ie u de t e Co ta t ( )whih
u si s h n ol
o 1 ih f r me a e s li rs n r h n r c ; 2
c

o t m a ieu de t eie k 'W ar ny;a d ( )aet ytm eba -d?
f he rs n r h i a s' ra t n 3 r he i - ne
l
l te i tn c o smo insf rs mma yj g n ,a d a o a ag n ,t pa t s
n h nsa t r s - to o u r ud me t n t r l r ume t he ri
e
f e e usve y on t i s ofm oit e i t r s t .The m o i do notaddr s
ocus d xcl i l
he s ue
sur n he oof ysem
tons
es

ot ralega i i Pl i if sCom pl ntt tar notpa e l r a ed t m oit e i t r
he l tons n antf
ai ha e
t nty elt o
sur n he oof
s t m , i udi t f l ng: k oduc f l e a l sope a e wih expos d
yse
ncl ng he olowi
i
pr
t aiur t ow l d r as t
e

fbegls/ o y se r i o c me ' ithe r o d e no h v T-on c v r wh c a e
i r a sp l e tr enf r e nt; s l o f o s t a e j it o e s ih r
' g
n e e a mulil ly ritr e to st p e e r fla ' S imp o e so i o te r of
e d d t tp e a e n e s ci n o r v nt oo e ks' l l r p r l png f h o
;g
s t '; a S r r t t Roof Sysem Conta t' Ce i k i t led a i e i ,
ysem ' nd k
conta y o he
t
r c ,' ntmar ns a l n nf ror
de e i a i pr
t ror tng oductc l d Ver i o r t rt n a contaced- orpr
ale
s c a he ha
r t f
oduc cale Ca lse.Se
t l d ril
e
DE 1,at8
-9. As t t s ale i ,Centm a k has not s
o he e l gatons
i r
hown t tt a ie unde t
ha hey rs
r he

ll ks'W a
iea '
nunt Thes alega i a e smpl unaddr s d i t i t cr s m otons
y.
e l tons r i y
es e n he nsant os - i

( b i d sus e b t epa t s c mp tnge e t, os r po t a ei t r c r )
alet ic s d y h ri ' o ei xp rs wh e e rs r n he e o d .
e
As f t alega i r l i t m oit e i t r s t m ,Ce i k does not
or he l tons eatng o
sur n he oof ys e
ntmar

ge nel diput t tû i i t la i Ce i a k r ur a wat pi t ttoode t
nui y s e ha i ng nsa lton, ntM r upt ed
dur
er pe ha l
d he

Ba c k f r t r so e'DE 4 ,a 7! 8. e DE 5 ,a 2 ! 8. rh r r ,aJ nu r 20 6
d oc u niu e t r .
'
9 t
Se
5 t
Fu te mo e a ay 0
r fm osu es r y o d r d b Ce tma k s owst e e wa a a e o û mj it r ta pe
oo it r u ve r e e y n i r h
h r s n r a f k o su e r p d
l
be we r s t m s'e bef e Ce i k i t l d t r s t m a is i t s c e.
t en oof yse ' ven or ntmar nsale he oof ys e t s ue n hi as

DE 5 - ,a 4.l i as u ip e t a ith p e e e ofmo su e i a r ofs se i
5 1 t t s lo nd s utd h t l j e r s nc
g
it r n o y tm s

comm on a eve y r has a l s s e am ount of m oit e i i.' DE 41 a 4 ! 1
nd
r oof
t ea t om
sur n t '
,t
6.
Fi ly,i a i ce f r wor c pl t d o M a 7, 201 Ce i a k i or e Pr e de
nal n n nvoi o
k om e e n y
4, ntm r nf m d om na

t t a uni ntsed num be of ipundur i t m e br ne.... e e due t i r c
ha n
de i
r
i
es n he m a
w r
o ncor e t

mae il us dt p t ht c r gils mplst a we et k n b Ce tmak. DE 4 1 a 3 .
tras e o a c he o e sc a e h t r a e y n i r '
'
9- , t 0
Pr m e de a s rs t t t s i ce i a adm is on by Centm a k t t i i or e l
o na
s e t ha hi nvoi s n
si
i r ha t nc r cty

pe f m ed pat hwor i 201 whih ca ed orconti e t m oit e i t r s t .
ror
c
k n
2, c us
rbut d o
sur n he oof ysem
DE 49, a 1 Centm a k co e s t t is use of t tr ii r t m aera s' was a
t 0.
i r
unt r ha t
he e m incor ec
t il'
n

i
nnoce wa of e ani t t i f m e l us d m a era s f t m por y r r a was
nt y
xpl i ng ha t or ry e
t i l or e
ar epais nd
m e el r pl i t m w ih m a e i l f per a ntr par .DE 55,a 5.I ot w or ,t
r y e acng he
t
t r a s or m ne e is
t n her ds he
pa te genui l diput t m e ng oft i ce.
ri s
ne y s e he ani
he nvoi
One concl i i i s a bl :t pa te genui y diput t ca e naur a
us on s ne c pa e he ri s
nel s e he us , t e, nd
e e oft m oit e i t r s t .On t s r r t Cour c nno co ude as a
xt nt he
sur n he oof ysem
hi eco d, he
t a t ncl ,

m at r oflw ,t tt m oit e pr bl snec s rl consiut ,i whol ori pa t S e .
te
a ha he
sur o em
es a iy
tt e n
e n r, ' aks'
l
'
The e or t al ge def t i t r s t r atng t m oit e a e no nec s iy
r f e, he le d
ec s n he oof ysem el i o
sur r t es arl
gove ne by t i ea ' W a r nt s one- r lm iaton- - ton pr son.I i a ca di l
r d
he i ks' r a y'
l
yea i t i ofac i
ovii t s
r na
prnci e of i er e a i t t a conta ' t r s unl s ot r ie i c ed, a e t be
i pl
nt pr t ton ha
r cts e m , es he w s ndi at
r o

co tue ac di t t r pl i a or nar mea ng, as unde sood by t ave a
nsr d cor ng o hei a n nd di y
ni
rt
he
r ge

p ro A gr u o a r g p r o s a tn a t f cfnd ri t f r o aj r ae i t e
e s n. o p f ve a e e s n , ci g s he a ti e n he o m f u y, r n h
be tposton t a y t t r il ak't Pr e de' cl m s i lghtofal oft evi ncet
s
ii o ppl he e m se ' o om na s ai , n i
l he de
o

1e a d e a til Net rp ry i e tte t j g n a a matr o 1w a t whehe
n d uc d t ra. ihe a t s n ild o ud me t s
te f a s o t r
Pr e de' cl m s a e ba r d by t one ye r lm ia i n- - c i pr s on i t Sl a '
om na s ai r r e
he - a i t to of a ton ovii n he 'e ks'
' a r nt
W r a y.

7

The Cour woul be a e t fnd t tPr e
t
d
bl o i ha om nade' c ai sar tme- r e asa m at r
s l m
e i ba r d
te
ofl onl i i f
aw
y f t ound t t c rai 2009 e- l s
ha e t n
mais how t tPr e
ha om nade was on notce ofis
i
t

cl m sbr
ai
oughti t i tnta ton.I t e m aiss d ha c us Pr enade t di c r
n he nsa c i f he - l houl ve a ed om
o s ove
any a l
leged r def ct t ih t e r ie of due dii nc ' hen Pr
oof e s i t he xe c s
w
lge er
't
omenade' cl m s
s ai

r ltn t t s d fcswo l b tmebar d.Fl. a.95 1 ( )c . n o o t e e mal,
eaig o ho e e e t u d e i - re a Stt . 1 3 ( ) I ne f h - i
s

Pr me d ' r ofn i pe t r( uro Roo i Co p. t dPlitf a f lo :
o na e s o i g ns c o M tn fng r ) ol an if s o lws
t t i ul ton i we on a oxi el 40% -50% oft e ie r a ea.
hat he ns a i s t
ppr mat y
he ntr oof r

g e tmaor c tt r ofi o ea e a ba e o t fe o t er o whe e
our si t ) u he o n n r a nd s d n he e l f h o f r
hew ake he i as um i t tt ot ra ea a e a s w e ....Thi t l ust t
l d
s s ng ha he he r s r lo t
s els ha
eihert i ul ton gotwe durng t i t l i orwe sm pl have notye
t he ns a i
t i he nsalaton
i y
t
dicover wher t wa e i ent rng t s t m .
s
ed
e he t r s e i he ys e
DE 39- I t ot r e m ai,Pr m e
9. n he he - l o nade t d Centm a k t tPr e de Sdi c e drli
ol
i r ha om na ' d or ilngs
t tr ve e aw e r aferyou advied t r wasdr ' DE 39-1 The quesi ofwhen
ha e ald
t oof t
s he oof
y.
'
0.
ton

a pa t s d ha dicover a l t ntde e tw ih t e r i e ofdue dii nce i or narl
ry houl ve s
ed a e
f c t he xe c s
lge
s di iy

a q sin o fc f r t j y. The 1w i ta r s c i t s m e i Flrd a
ue to f a t o he ur
a n h t e pe t s he a n o i a nd
Pe ns v na. e Ca trv Br wn & Wil o T ba c Cop. 77 So 2 93 ,9 ( a
n yla i S e re . o
li n o c o r , 8 . d 2 37 F1.
ams
2 0 ) Amod ov Rya Ho s I . 5 A.d 1 2 1 6 ( .S r 1 ) l lg tofte
0 0;
e . n me , nc, 95 2 23 , 23 Pa upe . 991 . n i h h
pa tes'genui diput a t t ca e,nat e a e entoft m oit e i t r s t ,
ri
ne s e s o he us
ur , nd xt
he
sur n he oof ysem

t Cour c udes t tr as bl pe s c d dia ee a t w he her t 2009 e- a l
he
t oncl
ha e ona e r ons oul s gr s o
t
he
m is
s d ha ca e Pr
houl ve us d omenade t dicovera a l d r def t w ih t e r ie ofdue
o s
ny lege oof ec s t he xe c s

dlg n e Net e p ry i e tte t j d n a amatroflw a t wh t e Pr n d '
iie c . ih r a t s n ild o u gme t s te a s o e h r ome a e s
cl m sa eba r by Fl i sf - a sat e oflm ia i .
ai r red
orda' our ye r t ut
i t tons

I .
V

A re Pl nt f D am aee Li i e bv t dt eaks 'W arrant
ai i ps
s m td
he i u
'
v?

Ce i a k a guest tPr e de' pot nta da a s a e lm ied by t t l s oft
ntm r r
ha om na s e i l m ge r i t
he e'
m
he
kl ks'W ara y.I lghtoft Cour' de e m i i a t t lm ia i ofac i is
iea '
r nt n i
he
ts t r naton s o he i t ton- - tons s ue,
a
bove,t Cour ca
he
t nnotconcude,asa m ate ofl w,whi h i a ofPr ena spot i
l
tr a
c f ny
om de'
ental

da ages ar lm ie by t t r s of t i e ' a r y.N et r pa t i entted t
m
e i td
he e m
he t aks'W rant
l
ihe ry s il o

j g n a amatroflw o t i is e
ud me t s te a n h s su .
=
V

C onc us on
l i

Ther or i i ORDERED,ADJU DGED,and D ECREED:
ef e, t s

1 De e a Ce tma k' M o in f r S
. fnd nt n i r s to o umma y J d n ( 3 )be a d t
r u gme t DE 8 , n he
s
ame i ,he e DEN I ;a
s r by
ED nd

Plitf Pr me a e sM o in f rPa ta S mma y J d n ( 4 b ,a d
an if o n d ' to o ri l u r u gme t DE 0) e n
t s e i,her by DEN I
he am s e
ED.
DO NE and O RDERED i Chambe s a t J m es Lawr nce Ki Fe r J tce
n
r t he a
e
ng de al usi
Buidi a Unied St t Courhous ,M im i Fl i ,t s25t day ofM ar h,201
l ng nd t
a es
t e a , orda hi h
c
5.

<
AM ES LA W REN CE KI
NG
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FL
CT
cc:

AI Couns lofR e
I
e
cord
N i asD .Si ri
chol
egf ed
Segfi d,Ri r Hyman,Le ne ,De w -- e,M a s e al
i re
ve a,
r r lalon'
r, t .
20l A l m br Cicl
ha a r e
El vent Fl
e h oor
Cor Gabl ,FL 331
al
es
34

Emal n ig re @shllw.o
i: se fid r -a c m
9

A

M at he R .Tuchm an
t w
Si gf i Ri a, ym a Le neret a .
e red, ver H
n, r
.1
201Al mbr Cic e,Elve h Fl
ha a r l e nt oor
Cor Ga e FL 331 5108
al bls,
34-

Emalmtc ma shllw.o
i: u h n@ r -a c m
Kat ri A bi lRober s
he ne
gai
t
Rum be ge , ik & Cal
r rK r
dwel
l
Brc lBa e Ce r Suie 3000
i kel yvi w nte, t
80 SW 8 h Stee
t r t
M i m i FL 331
a ,
30

Emal a o e t@r mbeg rc m
i: r b rs u r e .o
M i hae Kevi G ut an
c l
n
m
Rum ber r Kik ,Cal
ge , r
dwel,P.
l A.
80 S. .8t Ste t
W h re
Suie3000
t
M i m i FL 331
a ,
30

Emalmg t n@r r rc m
i: uma umbege.o
Gr
egor M ark Pal er
y
m
Rum ber rKik & Cal l
ge r
dwe l
Brc lBa e Ce r
ikel yviw nt e
80 SW 8t St e t
h re
Suie3000
t
M im i FL 331
a ,
30

Emalg l r rmb re .o
i: pame@ u eg rc m

1
0