Promenade Plaza Partnership v. Centimark Corporation

Filing 61

ORDER Denying Without Prejudice 37 Motion to StrikeThe Opinions of Plaintiff's Roofing Expert. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 3/31/2015. (jw)

UNI
TED STATES D I
STRI C OU RT
CT
SO UTH ERN D I
STRI OF FLO RI
CT
DA
CA SE NO .14- 22784- 1
cvK NG
THE PROM ENADE PLAZA PARTNERSHI
P,
a Fl i parne s p,
orda t r hi
Pl i if
antf,

CENTI ARK COR. . a f ei cor aton,
M
P , or gn por i

D e e nt
f nda .
/
OR DER D ENYI W I
NG
THO UT PREJUDI DEFENDANT' M O TI N TO STR I E
CE
S
O
K
TH E OPI O NS OF PLAI FF' RO O FI EXPERT
NI
NTI S
NG

THI CAU SE comes bef e t Cour upon Def nda Ce i ar sDauber M oto
S
or he
t
e nt ntm k'
t
in

t S rke t Opni s o Pli ifs Rooi g Ex e t J hn L.Br wn ( 3 ) Th sa to
o ti he i on f antf'
tn p r, o
o DE 7 . i cin
c er a r s t m t tCentm a k i t l ove Pr enade' s
onc ns oof ys e ha
i r nsaled
r om
s hoppi ce e i 2005
ng nt r n
a 2006.Pr e
nd
om nade br
oughtt s ac i f r da ages ale ng va i def c s i t r
hi ton o m
l gi
rous e t n he oof
s tm t t we e S oxi ael ca ed by t i ope consr i and/ f l e of t
yse ha
r i
pr m t y us
he mpr r
tucton
or aiur
he

RoofSysem ,'a wel ast us ofi ope m at ra s Pr e
t ' s l he e mpr r e i l . om nade a s cont ndst tce t n
lo
e
ha rai
r par Ce i a k pe f m ed i 201 have c ed orc rbut d t c t n r def c s
e is ntm r r or
n
2
aus
ont i e o erai oof e t .

Pr me de hie a r fn e pe t J n Br wn who o n s t a t the r f i
o na
r d ooi g x r, oh o ,
pie h t f l oo s
g
e re i pr
xpe inc ng oductf l e'ca e by Ce i ar s i ope i t l i us ofm a e i s
aiur ' us d
ntm k' mpr r nsalaton, e
t ral,
a r pais DE 42,a 1
nd e r .
t 4-24.Si fc nty,he opi t a oxi a ey 93% oft r
gnii a l
nes hat ppr m t l
he oof

s se i we,a d t tSdj et t ef ie me r n a d i o ry rpar d c r s mp e ,
y tm s t n ha û u o h al d mb a e n mpr pe l e ie o e a ls
l
open lp,t o bule hol a one punc u e peror ed by Ce i ar whi h e se on t
a w
l t es nd
tr
f m
ntm k
c xit d
he
Ce i a k RoofSys e f om 2012 t 201 i i ouro ni t tt Centm a k RoofSysem
ntm r
tm r
o
4, t s
pi on ha he
i r
t

f l s ei e be wee 201 a 201 and i i nee of r a m ent' DE 42, a 20.
aied om tm
t n
2 nd
4
sn
d
epl ce
.'
t

Acc di t Br
or ng o own' e e i CV,he i ça lce ed r i c r c or wih 44 yea s
s xt nsve
s i i ns oofng onta t
t
r
expe i
rence i a lphas s ofc m e cal i t i a r i ntalr i a watr oofng
n l
e
om r i , ndusral nd esde i oofng nd e pr i
s t s' He hasbe a m e be of a ha s ved on t boa d of diec or of num er
ysem .
'
en
m r , nd s er
he
r
r t s ,
ous
buidi a r i pr e s o as oci i .He ha s ve asan e r wine s i doze
l ng nd oofng of s i nal s atons
s er d
xpe t t s n
ns
of c es.Centm a k doe not diput Br
as
i r
s
s e own' qua i atons Ra her Ce i a k m oves t
s
lsc i . t , ntm r
o
e l hi opi onson t gr
xcude s ni
he oundst tt y a e concl ol a wihouta expl ton of
ha he r
us ' nd t
y,
ny
ana i
t m e hodol us t r h t .
he t
ogy ed o eac hem
l Br
n own' exper r po t he a a as oc a e sa e t t t y Si peced t r
s
t e r,
nd n s i t t t ha he ûns t he oof

as embl a cons t w ih Cl ar I pec i Se vi I ,aM er D a Count a ove
s
y nd
uled t e y ns ton r ce, nc.
to de
y ppr d
t tng l at y,t peror a c r ntm oit e s r ' DE 42,a 1 They r ewed m a
esi abor or o f m
ur e
sur u vey.'
t 6.
evi
ny
doc e s i l ng m oit e s ve conduc e i 2006 a 201 1 at 17.The alo
um nt , ncudi
sur ur ys
td n
nd
2. d.
y s
i pec e t Centm a k RoofSys e on J
ns t d he
i r
tm
anuar 8,201 M a 7,201 Sept m be 5,201
y
4; y
4;
e r
4;
a Se e ber 8, 201 The w e e pr ent durng t m oit e s ve and c e c s
nd pt m
4.
y
r es
i he
sur ur y
or ut
pe f m e by Cl r f a 1 Br
r or d
ea y. #. t 8. own r i on hi pe s
eled
s r onali pe i ,t doc
ns ctons he ument t t
s ha
her viwed,a t Cl r I pec i Re tt f m hi concl i .
e e
nd he ea y ns ton por o or s
usons
Sfhe i l e s oned by Rul 702 ...i a fe bl one ...The f ,ofcour e
t' nquiy nvii
e
s l xi e
.
ocus
s,

mus be s el on prncpl s a m ehodol
t
ol y
i i e nd t
ogy,noton t concl i t t t gene a e.
he
usons ha hey
rt '
'

Dau e tv M e r l Dt Pha ma e tc l,I c,5 U. 5 9,5 4 95 ( 9 ) TheCo r h s
b r . r el p
w r c uias n . 09 S. 7 9 - 1 93 .
ut a
ca ef l r viwed Br
r uly e e
own' e
s xper r por a r t lr por.Br
t e t nd ebuta e t own' opi ons a t t
s ni
s o he

curent c ton oft r a e r i y ba ed on hi per ona ,viuali pe tons a on
r
ondii
he oof r elabl s
s s l s
ns c i
nd
sur ur y. f
nt
e i l s e he ela lt
hes
Clar s m oit e s ve De enda does not s rousy diput t r ibiiy of t e
e y'
m e hods a i ed f uls Br
t
, nd nde a t own c el f notafor ng due wei t ot r sudi and
hi ty or
f di
ght o he t es

m oit e s ve t whi Centm a k woul have hi a c i gr atr c e nc See Kumho
sur ur ys o
ch
i r
d
m s rbe e e r de e.

Tie Co.v Ca mih l 5 U. 1 7 1 6 ( 9 )( it )(io on d n e t a a e pe t
r
. r c ae, 26 S. 3 , 5 1 99 dca û
n e e is h t n x r
mi dr w a concl i fom a s t of obs r i bas d on e ensve and s alzed
ght a
uson r
e
e vatons
e
xt i
peci i

e peinc .)
x re e' .
'
The Cour ac
t know l
edges t ce t n of Br
hat rai
own' ca a i opi ons a e s ewha
s us ton
ni
r om
t

vaguel sa e a t t quesi ofhow he r ac t e c usonsc d be e ai
y t t d, nd hat he
ton
e hed hes oncl i
oul
xpl ned

mo e rg r usy.S e DE 4 t2 (r u t t e fie me r n a d i r pe l r p ie
r ioo l e
2,a 0 i e o h ald mb a e n mp o ry e ar d
cor s mpl ...t Ce i a k Roof Sys e f ld s e i e be we
e a es
he
ntm r
t m aie om tm
t en 201 and
2

201 ....'.Ye Ce i r hasnots
4 ' t ntma k
)
hown t tBr sopi onsar s unr ibl t t y
ha own' ni
e o ela e hat he
s d be sr c n i t i entr y.A c di y,t Cour de es Centm a k' m oton t
houl
ti ke n her iet
cor ngl he
t ni
i r s
i o

srkewi u p eu iet riea p o raeo j cinsa til Ce tma k i o c refe t
ti t t rj d c o as p r p it b e to t ra . n i r s f ou s r e o
ho
e oi a pe ce ved i
xpl t ny r i
ncons se esori dequacis i Br
it nci
na
e n own' t tm ony atti by c os s es i
ral
r s
e m i ton.
xa na i

Ce i ar a s m ovest e l ose i y new opi onst Br
ntm k l o
o xcude t nsbl
ni
hat own ofe e f t
f r d or he

frttmei hi r b ta rpo t c ntay t Fe r lRu eofCii Pr c du e 2 ( )2 ( (i.
is i n s e u tl e r, o r r o dea l
v l o e r 6 a ( )D)i)
The fr tofBr
is
own' os e i y ne r t opi ons i t ti he i opersope c ed t
s t ns bl w ebutal ni
s ha ' mpr
t
l
aus he

f i r o t r of'DE 3 ,a 1 I Br wn' i ta e p r d s l s r ,he sae t tû the
al e f he o '
u
7 t 7. n o s niil x e t ic o u e
tt s ha l j
l
r ha poor sope at s r l tons' conta y t t Fl i Buidi Code,w hi h
oof s
l
eve al oca i ,
'
r r o he orda
l ng
c
û e r pos tve s ope t dr n orm a e i s a ove f poor dr na even on r r s'
i quies ii l
r
o ai
t ral ppr d or
ai ge
e-oof .'
DE 42,a 1 The Cour c l s t t t s s a e e ,t he wih Ce i a k' e r '
t 8.
t onc ude ha hi t t m nt oget r t
ntm r s xpe ts

d s u so ofso e( 4 a 4 - ) r n r Br wn' c u ai nr ma ksi r b t l o r
ic s in lp DE 2, t 3 44 , e des o s a s to e r n e uta pr pe
unde Rul 26.The s ond of Br
r
e
ec
own' ose i y new r t opi ons i hi ca aly
s t nsbl
ebutal ni
s s us l
r l i Ce i a k' ale d i pr rpathi and t f ii mem br t t f l eoft
eatng ntm r s l ge m ope
c ng
he a lng
ane o he aiur
he

r o s se DE 3 ,a 1 Ce tmak' o j ci n o t e e po n si wi u me i.Br wn
o f y tm.
7 t 7. n i r s b e to n h s i t s t t rt o
ho
ce ry d e ofe t s o nins i h s iii lr po t DE 42 a 2 (Du t t e f ie
lal o s fr he e pi o n i nta e r.
, t 0 t e o h ald
f
me br ne a
m a
nd i pr ry r par d c e s m pl ...he Ce i a k Roof Sysem
m ope l e ie
or a es t
ntm r
t

f i d.. .)
al .' .
e
'
The e or i i O RD ERED , A DJUDGED, and DECREED t Ce i ar s
r f e, t s
hat ntm k'

Dauber M otont Sti t Opi onsofPli ifsRoofng Expe t J L.Br ( 37)
t i o rke he ni
antf
b
r, ohn
own DE

b ,a t e s me i,hee y DENI wiho pr j c t r ie a p o rae o j cinsa
e nd h a s r b
ED t ut e udie o as p r p it b e to t
ti l
ra .

D ONE and O RDERED i Cha ber a t J m e La e e Ki Feder J tc
n
m s t he a s wr nc ng
al us ie
Buidi a Unie St t sCourhous M i m i Fl i t s31 tda ofM a c 201
l ng nd t d a e
t e, a , orda, hi s y
r h, 5.

e - x

V

M ES LA W REN CE KI
NG
I
TED STA TES DI
STRI J GE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF F RI A
CT
D

cc:

A1 Couns ofRec d
1
el
or