YOUNG v. Carnival Corporation

Filing 13

ORDER denying 4 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 10/29/2014. (whl)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
Ca eNu be : 1 22924- V- OREN O
s m r 4C1 M
ERI YOUN G,
KA
Pl i if
antf,

CARNI
VAL CORPOM TI ,
ON
Def nda .
e nt

ORDER DENYI M OTI TO DI I
NG
ON
SM SS
Thi c us c m e be or t Cour upon De e nt Car val Cor a i s moton t
s a e a
f e he
t
f nda
ni
por ton'
i o
dimisPl n ifErkaYot sc
s s aitf i
mg' ompli f rf iur t sa ea cli i ac or e wih FED. R.
ant o a l e o t t
am n c danc t

CI P. 1 ( ) M s Yo n cams t a s e wa ij r d whe s e si p d a fl a o r
V. 2 b . . u g li h t h
s nu e
n h lp e nd el b ad

Ca v lscu s l ,a d s e s e srle f rh rij re b s d o svea r ltd n gie c
mia' r ie i n h e k eif o e nu is a e n e rl eae e l n e
ne
g
t is Ca ni lmoved t dimis M s Young' c
heore . r va
o s s
.
s ompli f rf l e t plad t br a a
ant o aiur o e he e ch nd
c us ton ee e sofhe cai .
a ai lm nt
r lm
The Cour ha consde e t moton a t pe tne pori oft r or , a bei
t s
i r d he
i nd he ri nt tons he ec d nd ng
ot m ie f ly a s d i t pr m i e , i i a j d e t a Canva' mo in i d n e b c u e
he s u l dvi e n he e s s t s d u g d h t r i ls to s e id e a s
M s. Young' com pl nt s a e a pl us bl c ai f ne i nce See Be lAtantc Cor v
s
ai t t s
a i e l m or glge .
l l i
p. .

Twombl 55 U. 55 570 (
y, 0 S. 4,
2007) The Cour l t f r martme lw t d emi
.
t ooks o edeal ii a o etr ne
whehe M s Young' alega i a e s fce t s
t r .
s l tons r ufi int o uppor he cli . S eNof l S pb i n d
t r a m e ro k hi ul g r
di
Dr
ydoc Cor v G ar i 532 U . . 81 ,820 (
k
p. . r s,
S
1
2001. M s Young mus alget t 1 Cani l
) .
t le ha: ) r va

h d ad t t prtc h rfo apa t ua ij r 2 Canv lb e c e t td t ;3 teb e c
a u y o oe t e r m
ri lr nu y; ) r ia ra h d ha u y ) h r a h
c
a tal a pr xmaey c u e M s Yo n sij r ;a d 4 M s Yo n s f rd a ta h r
cu l nd o i tl a s d . u g' n u y n ) . u g ufee cu l am
y

.

Se Cha r v Ca ni al Cor ., 693 F. 1 33, 1
e
par o . r v
p
3d 3
336 ( 1h Ci.201 . Ac ptng he
1t r
2)
ce i
r

al gai nsa tu M s Yo pl dss fc e f c st sa e aprma f ci cai f ne i enc .
le to s r e, . ung ea ufii nt a t o t t
i a e l m or glg e

SeeAs o v I al556U, 662, (
hcr)t . qb ,
S. 678 2009)
.
M s Young al gest t s si d a f l on a l t a si r f e g s t nc '
.
le
ha he lppe nd e l
'
we nd lppe y or i n ubsa e'
whie tavei o Cani ' c ie lne, a t a s s fe e an mb ro ij re a ars l.
l r lng n r vals nzs i nd h t he u frd u e f nu is s e ut

D. 1a ! 8 1 . Canv l eiv sta t s alg to saei u fce tt s p o t cam f r
E. t ! , 6 r ia b l e h t he e l ain r ns fiin o u p r a li o
e
e
neg i nc be us s f l t i ntf t si r s t nc on t foo ofCa i ls s p
lge e ca e he aied o de iy he lppe y ubsa e
he l r
m va ' hi
a il ta e pr c s y ho t si r s t e c us d he t f l. D . 4 a 3. W hie t
nd lusr t e iel w he lppe y ubsanc a e r o a l E. t
l he
Cou te ds t t M s.Young wilil tae t i i nt i g a c de al a ti l s i not
r xpe ha
l lusr t he ncde n r phi t i t ra , he s
r quie t pr de a c pr he i pl y- pl ofhersi a f l wihi he ts 'a pli
e r d o ovi
om e nsve a by- ay
lp nd a l t n r khol nd an
t

sae toft cl m. Se FE R.CI P.8()2) Pr o o v RoyalCarbbe Cr s s
ttmen he ai ' e D.
'
V. a( ; ok penk .
i an uie
Lt ,No.1 d
0 20068- V ,201 W L 1
CI
0
524546, a *2( D. a. . 201 .
t S. Fl Apr 15, 0)

W ih r ga d t t d ea h' ee e ofhe cli , t Cour r c niest tCa ni li
t e r o he t c ' lm nt
br
r a m he
t e og z ha r va s

n tla l t M s Yo n s ll b c u es ewa ij r do iscu s s p.E.. u yv Ca nv l
o ibe o . u g o ey e a s h s nu e n t r ie hi g L b . r ia
Cr s Li s I ,633 F.Supp.40,41 ( D.Fl.1 . Thi prnci e,howe r doesnot
uie ne , nc.
S. a 986)
s i pl
ve,
a og t Ca ni ls d y t m ant i r as bl s f pr m ie f is pas e r a t wa n
br a e r va ' ut o i an e ona y a e e s s or t
s nge s nd o r
t m ofknown hi n dange s Se Ke mar v Compa e Ge r e Tr atantque,358
he
dde
r . e r ec .
gni ne al ans l i

U. 6 5 63 ( 9 9 (1T) eo e o as p i n v g bewaeso st a1wh aeo bo r
S. 2 , 2 1 5 ) $ h wn r f hi n a i a l tr we o l o r n ad
(
f rpur esnoti mi a t hi l gii t i er sst dut ofe r sng r s bl ca e unde
o
pos
ni c l o s e tma e nt e t he y
xe cii ea ona e r
r

t crumsa sofe hca e' ;Kor er v.Car v Cr s Li s l .741F. 133 1
he ic tnce ac s .' nb g
)
nial uie ne, nc,
2d 2, 224,
1 ( 1h Ci.1 .Acc di t M s Young' eompli ,Ca ni lbr c isdut ofcae
336 1 t r 984)
or ng o .
s
ant r va ea hed t y
r
t wa dsispa s r by f ii t pr ry mai ai isfoorand f ii t wa n M s Young of
o r t s enge s
alng o ope l
nt n t l
a lng o r
.

a si r s tnc on is foor ( whi Cani ha adua orconsnltve knowldge .
lppey ubsa e
t l of ch r val d
l
t ci
e )
Ca ni l s br a h c us d M s Young t s i on t t s t e, a s now s ksr i f t
r va ' e c a e
.
o lp
ha ubsanc nd he
ee elef or he

-

2-

rs ln ij re .Th s alg to sc n ttt ap i fcen gie c cam i a c r a c wih
e ut g nu is e e l ai n o si e rma a i e l n e li n c o d n e t
i
e
u
g
Cha r 693 F. a 1
par o,
3d t 336.

D N A DO DRDiCabraMi ili,i Pdyfcbr2014.
O E N R EE n hme t a ,od tJ /aoOte
s m Frah
o
,

FEDER

A . ORENO
V

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
Co e pr de t
pi s ovi d o:
Couns lofR e or
e
c d