Prince et al v. Cash Money Records, Inc.

Filing 24

ORDER Granting 7 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 5/8/2015. (jw)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M I M ID I I ON
A
V SI
CASE N O.1 CV4- 23057- NG/
Kl TORRES
J ES t AS' PRI CE,a
AM
Q ' N
J
nd
YOUNG EM PI M U SI GROUP,LLC,
RE
C
Pl i if ,
antfs
CA SH M ON EY RECORD S,I C .
N ,

De e
f ndan .
t
/

ORDER G RANTI DEFENDANT' M OTI TO DI I
NG
S
ON
SM SS
-

THI M ATTER c
S
omesbe n e t Co tupon Def nda ' M o i t Dimisor i t
f r he ur
e nts ton o s s , n he

Al r aie t S a ,a l o p r tdM e rnd m o La ( # ) Theen, nda n o h r
t n tv ,o ty nd nc r o ae mo a u f w DE 7 . ri a mo g t e
e
ag me t, f n a tCa h M o e Re o d (t s Mo y' s e ste d s s a o Plitfs
ru n s De e d n s
n y c r s d h ne ' e k h imis l f an if '
ca
)

Co li t nt b sso d fcsi Plitfs j rs ito lalg to s a dPlitfs fiu et
mpan o he a i f e e t n an if' u id cina l ai n , n an if ' alr o
e
j i a id s e a l pat t t i a to Thsmatri f l b ifd 1 n a s tfrhb lw te
on n n ip nsb e ry o hs cin. i te s ul re e , a d s e o t eo h
y
Co tfnds t t De e an ' M o i s d be gr nt d, a Pli tfs Compl i s d be
ur i
ha
f nd ts ton houl
a e nd a n if '
ant houl
dim is wih la t tl a n e
s s ed t e ve o se n m ndedco pl nt
m ai .
1.

Bac ound
kgr

Thi a ton a iesfom a diput overm one al dl owe by Cas M one a r cor
s c i rs r
s e
ys lege y
d
h
y, e d

l l t Pli if se mi fom Pli tfs'dic r oft populr r or ng a ts Aubr y
abe , o antfs tm ng r
a n if s ove y
he
a ec di rit
e
Gr ha a. a.t a ' a Pli if ' s e nt as it c i s czi Dr ke' r c di
a m, k. t ke,' nd antfs ubs que
Dr
s smA e n e trng a s e or ng
c r c wih Cas M one Ac r ng t Pl i if 'Compl i ,Pl i if dicove ed Dr ke i
onta t t
h
y. co di o antfs
ant antfs s r
a n
2007,l bef e he be me t popul r r or ng a ts he i t y, a as it d Dr ke i
ong or
cn
he
a ec di rit
s oda nd sse
a n

sg ngan e l i rco di a ts agee n wih non- ry As r MuscGr p Cd pie'
ini
xcusve e r ng rit r me t t
pat pie i ou As r'
)
1
Pli if fld t i Res e i Opposton ( #1 , and Defendantfl d isRepl i
antfs ie her pons n
ii DE 5)
ie t
y n
Suppo t( #20 .
r DE )

i De e ro 2 0 As ie sr l, c o dngt Plitfs wa t t u ns l Drk ' sr ie t
n c mbe f 0 8. pr ' o e a c r i o anif, s o ' r ih ) a es e vc s o
f
ot r f t pup os ofc eai m usc r co di . l J of2009,As r e e e i o a
he s or he
e
r tng
ial e r ngs' n une
'
pie ntr d nt n
a e men wih Cas M one pur ua t whih As r f r s t e usver c di s r ce
gr e t t
h
y s nt o c pie u nihed he xcl i e or ng e vi s
ofDr ket Cas M one
a o h
y.
Acc r ng t t Com pli ,i J y o 2009 a numbe ofsgna ore i l ng As r
o di o he
ant n ul f
r
i t is, ncudi
pie,
e e e it a és tl nt ag ee
nt r d n o te teme
r ment a g r l r l a e'whe e al a e t t Pli tfs
nd ene a e e s '
r by l gr ed ha a n if

wo d be pa d a s e
ul
i um qualt 22% ofAs r ' 331 % s e ofne pr hsde i d fom Dr ke'
o
pie s / har
3
t of
rve r
a s
r c di co r c wih Ca h M one The i J y of201 t s ag e m e wa t a ii d' t
e or ng nta t t s
y. n, n ul
0, hi r e nt s ç rfe ' o
cl

core tt di son ofpr is asf l :331 % ofne pr is de i d fom Dr ke' r c di
r c he vii
oft
olows /
3
t oft rve r
a s e or ng
co r c wih Cas M one was pa bl t As r ,a Pl i if we e t r ei 22% whie
nta t t
h
y
ya e o pie nd antfs r o ec ve
l

As r r ti d 11/% . The Co ait d s not i c t who t ot r sgna ores t t e
pie eane
13
mpl n oe
ndi a e
he he i t i o hes
ag ee nt we e.Howe r Pl ntfs ale t tt J y 201 a e nt ç pe fcal not d
r me s r
ve , ai if lge ha he ul
0 gr eme f cii ly e
s
Ca h M one s i ve nt wih m a ng pa
s
y' nvol me
t
ki
yment r l t d t Dr ke,sa i t t t a nc
s eae o a
t tng ha he dva e

pa a l t As iewo db p i b Ca hMo e . Co lit DE #1!1 .
y be o pr ul e ad y s n y' mp an ,
'
7
Pl i if a lge t tpurua t t s a e m e and t i pur td unde sandi t t
antf s le ha
s nt o hi gr e nt
her pore
r t ng ha

Ca hM one woul pa Pli if's r die tyt Pli if,s ppi As r ( c s e t
s
y
d y antfs hae r cl o antfk ki ng pie whih e ms o
be con r dit d by t a lgaton t t fhe a nc pa e t As r woul be pad by Ca h
ta c e
he le i ha ç dva e yabl o pie
t
d
i
s

51 n y' Cah M o e h sp i t Plitfsc ran s msa d a k o e g d iso lg to t
o e ', s
)
n y a ad o anif e ti u n c n wld e t biain o
r nde a a countng t r f e.Ca h M one hasnotpr vi d t a c i Pl n if a lge i
e r n c
i he e or
s
y
o de he c ountng aitf s le s

r quied,a woul be ne es a y t ens e c
e r
nd
d
c s r o ur ompla e w ih t oblgai n t pa 22% ofne
i nc t he i to o y
t
pr ss and t s m spa d t f ha be n a bir rl de de wihoutr f r e t a t ls es
olt,
he u
i hus ar ve e r ta iy ci d t
e e enc o c ua al
orpr i fg es
oft i ur .
Ac r i y,Pl i if sl d t i t t c pli al gi s ve c s agans Ca h
co d ngl
antfs e he nsan om a nt le ng e n ount
i t s

Mo e () Un u tEmi h n ;(1 Ac o tn (1)Co v rin;(V) Br a h o F d ca y
n y: 1 j s
c me t 1) c unig; 11 n eso I
e c f i u ir
Du y ( Co sr cieTr s; Vl To t u l tre e c wihCo ta t a a dAc n wlg (i)
t ; V) n tu tv u t ( ) ri s n efrn e t n rcu l n k o e e sc
o
2

Bu ie sReain hi;a d ( I Bra h o Co ta t Dee da th smo e t ds s ,ag ig
sn s lto s p n Vl) e c f nr c. fn n a v d o imis r un

t a Plitf j s ito a alg to s d n t s fiin l alg ter o ctz n hp fr
h t anifs mid cin l l ai n o o u fce ty le e h i wn iie s i o
e
p r o e o t i Co r' dv r i j rs ito , n frh rta As r i a ids e s b ep ryt
u p s s f hs u ts ie st u idcin a d ' te h t pie s n n ip n a l a t o
y
u
t saci n.
hi to
II
.

Le St
gal andard

A c
ompli t m us c an s tand pli saeme s of t g o mds f t c ts
an
t ont i hor
a n tt nt
he r t
or he our'

j rs ito o t e c us ofa to ,a d o te rle s u h .Fe R.Ci P.8 a .Un e t e
u idcin, f h a e cin n f h eif o g t d.
v. () d r h
h ihe e pla igsa d r ss tf rhb t eS prmeCo r i As c o v I b l 5 6U. 6 2
eg tn d e dn tn a d e o t y h u e
u tn h r? . q a , 5 S. 6
( 01 )a d #e/At Cop.v T nbe 55 U..5 4 ( 0 7 ,te emu tb t n u h fcst
2 0 n / l r . wo l ly, 0 S 4 2 0 ) h r s e i o g a t o
.
e

saeacam t rle t a i plu il o (h )f c 'o t e c mp an .T mbe 55 U. a
tt li o eif h t s a sb e n t e a e' f h o lit wo ly, 0 S. t
570.A pli ifmus pla s fce f t t s
antf
t e d ufi int acs o how e il me t r le a mus pl d S or
ntte nt o ei f nd
t ea t e
m
t n lbel a c usons ...A f mul c r cia i oft eeme sofa c eofaci n wil
ha a s nd oncl i .
or ai e t ton he l nt
aus
to l
no d ' 1 t y a compl i t sa es a pl usbl cli f r i s vve a moton t
t o. d. t
'
onl
ant hat tt
a i e am or elef ur i s
i o
dimis' I ,556 U. a 678. C cli ha f cil plusbiiy when t pl ntf pl ds
s s . qbal
'
S. t
6 am s a a a i lt
A
he ai if ea
f cualcontntt al w st c tt dr w t r s na e i er nc t tt def nda i la e
at
e hat lo he our o a he ea o bl nf e e ha he e nt s i bl
f rt mico
a he s nduc a l ed.' d.
t leg '1
I de i ng a m o i t dim is t Cour mus a ce a c
n c di
ton o s s , he
t
t c pt
ompl nts wel- ed
ai '
lpl

alg to s a t e Erc s n v 't l l 5 1 U. 8 ,9 ( 0 ) S h alg to mus b
le ai n s nl. ik o . z u , 5 S. 9 4 20 7 . uc le ains t e
r
consr d i t lghtm os f vor bl t t Pl i if Am.De al s' v Ci a Cor ,605 F.
tue n he i
t a a e o he antf .
nt As n . gn
p.
3d

1 8 ,1 8 ( 1h Ci.2 0 .d a ay i te s fiin yoft c mp an,(h Co r)lmil)
2 3 2 8 1 t r 01 ) tn n lzng h u fce c
l
he o lit t e u t i ts

gt)c n ieaint tewelp e d dfcu lalg to s d c me t c n rlt o r fr n e i
is o sd rto o h l la e a ta le ain , o u ns e ta o r e ee c d n
t ec mpan, n matr j diil n tc d. faGr sav Fis Uno Se . I .3 8F.d 8 0
h o lit a d tes u cal oie '
y
'
a t . r t in c,nc, 5 3 4 ,
8 ( 1h Ci.2004 .TheCour ma alo c ul d
45 1 t r
)
t y s ons t ocume st taeata hedt t Compli
nt ha r tc o he
ant
orm o i t dim isunde t ti or a i by r f r e' docrne.The Elvent Cic tha
ton o s s
r he t por ton
nc
e e enc ' ti
e h r ui s
defne t i or a i by r er nce doc r ne t m e n:
i d he nc por ton
ef e
ti o a

( d c me tatc e t a moin t d s s ma b c n ie e b te c u t
Aq o u n ta h d o
to o imis y e o sd rd y h o r
wi o tc n e t gt emoin it o ef rs mmayj d me t nl i t atc e
t u o v ri h to no n o u r u g n o y f he ta h d
h
n
doc
ument i: ( ) ce r l t t pl ntf s cai and ( undiputd. .
s 1 nta o he ai if l m;
2)
s e
t
d s t d' i t s c e m e ns t tt a he i t oft doc
undipu e ' n hi ontxt a ha he ut ntciy
he
umen i not
ts
c l nged.
hale

Hose v Fed ,3 4 F.d 1 2 ,1 3 ( 1h Ci.2 0 )(nena ctto o te ) s e
rly . l t 0 3 1 5 1 4 1 t r 0 2 i tr l i ins mitd ; e
a
as Da v T y o , 00F.d 1 7 ,1 7 ( 1hCi. 0 5 .
lo y . a lr 4 3 2 2 2 6 1 t r 2 0 )

Fial ,n c nsd rn aMo in t Dimisf rfi r t j i a i ds e a l p ry t e
n ly i o ie ig
to o s s o al e o o n n n ip nsbe a t, h
u
Colr mus l t Fed.R.Ci P.1 Se Chalen Home ,I .v Gr atr Na e Car Ct.
zt t ook o
v. 9. e
l ge
s nc . e e pl s e r,

l c,6 F.d 6 7 6 9 ( 1h Ci.1 8 ) Rul 1 () whc g v r s p ro rq rd t b
n . 69 2 6 , 6 1 t r 9 2 . e 9a , ih o e n e s ns e uie o e

j ie i fa i e p o i e '
on d f e sbl, r v d s
.
(qp ro wh i s be t os r ieo p o e sa d wh ej id rwil o d p ie
a es n o s u j c t e vc f r c s n os on e l n t e rv
t e c u to s b e tmatrj rs ito mus b i n d a a o rv i:( i t a
h o r f u j c- te i id ci n t e oie s a t f A) n h t
u
pe s sa e e t c tc nnotac or co plt r le a ong e si pa tes
r on' bs nc , he our a
c d m e e e if m
xitng ri ;

o ( ta p r o camsa itrs rltn t tes be to t ea to a d i s
r B) h t e s n li n n eet eaig o h u j c f h cin n s o
st tdt tdiposng oft a ton i t pe s sa enc may:()asaprci l
iuae ha s i
he ci n he ron' bs e
i
a tca
matri rori
te mpai mpedet pes sa lt t pr e tt i ees;or(i l vea
he ron' biiy o otc he ntr t i) ea n
e itn p ry s be t t a s b tn il rs o i u rn d u l,mutpe o
x sig a t u j c o u sa ta ik f nc rig o b e lil, r
ot r s i onsse oblg i be us oft i er s.
he wie nc it nt i atons ca e he nt e t

(mp a i s p id .ç o e v r i i teb r e o temo a tt s o tep ro t b j n d i
e h ss u ple ) t ro e ,t s h u d n f h v n o h w h es n o e oie s
M
re sa y ori s ns bl 'Pano osv,fe n on I s Ca,2013 W L 2708688 ( . Fl
tce sr
ndipe a e.
' poul
xigt n .
M D. a.

J n 1 2 3 (iig BF1 Wa t S 'o Am. I c v o r Cn ,2 9 F. D.5 9 51
u e 2, 01 ) ctn
se y5 fN
.
, n . .Br wa d @. 0 R. 0 , 4
( I F1 200 ;Shi Con t.*7Fundig Se v .(
S.7. a. 2) p sr
n r s USA),I .v St Cr s sPLC,1 F. zd
nc . ar uie
74 supp.

1 2 ,1 2 ( D. a20 1)
3 0 3 5 S. Fl. 0 ).
11
1.

D i c s on
s us i

A . Pl nt f s'Juri ctonalA legatonsare Insuf ci
ai i f
sdi i
l i
fi ent

Plitfs h ve atmp e t iv k t i Co r' dv ri j rs ito p ru n t 2
an if a te td o n o e hs u ts iest u idcin u s a t o 8
y
I . C.j 1 cai ngt tt ee ssc eedi riy(fciie hi a t tt n
JS.
332, l mi ha her xit omplt ve st ) tz ns p nd ha he mounti
n

c n rv ry e c e s $ 50 0 The s m t tlo Plitfs j rs ito a alg to s ae a
o to e s x e d 7 ,0 .
u oa f anif' u id ci n l l ai n r s
e
4

f lo ;( antf J mes % as'Prnce i a r sde of Houson,Texa a i t prncpa of
al ws Tli if n
$ ' i
J
s e i nt
t
s nd s he i i l

( litfjYo n EmpieM u i Gr u ,
Pan if u g
r sc o p LLC' a d t an ifYo n Empr M u i Gr u LLC
' n ç itf u g
;
pl
ie sc o p,
i a lm ie labiiy wih is prncpa pl c ofbusne s i Houson,Te ';a fna l t t
s i t d i lt t t i i l a e
i s n
t
xas' nd i ly ha

i f nda Cas M one i a Louii na c por ton ...wih b i s a e s of 1 NE 1 h
t e nt h
De
ys
sa or a i
t usne s ddr s
755
49t

Ste t M imi F o ia'Co litDE /1!3 .
re, n , lrd . mpan , / -5
'
De e nt a g t tt e a lga i do nots fc e ty al di r iy.Spe ii aly,
f nda s r ue ha hes le tons
ufi i n l lege ve st
c fc l

Ilitfsh v fie t pla t i ct e s i f rp r o e ofdiest j rs ito Plitf
' n if a e ald o e d her ii n hp o u p s s
a
z
v ri u id cin. an if
y
Prnc smpl al s t the i a ûrsde ' ofHo t Te .Ho ve ,tlqtz hi not
i e i y lege ha
s çe i nt'
uson, xas we r tciiens p,
r sde ,i t ke f tt tmus bealeg i t c
e i nce s he y ac ha
t
l ed n he ompli t e tbls di r iy f a naur l
ant o sa ih ve st or t a

pes n. T ylrv A plt n 3 F.t 1 6 ,1 6 ( 1h Ci. 9 4 (fimi ds sa f rlc o
ro ' a o . p eo , 0 3l 3 5 3 7 1 t r 1 9 ) afr ng imis l o a k f
'

s be tmatr u idcinf rf i r t pla ctz n hp o c mo aed fn a t. f rPli if
u j c te j rs ito o al e o e d iie s i f o rt e e d n) As o antf
u
Young Empie M usc Gr p,LLC,a1Pl ntfs a lge i is prncpalpl e of busne s i i
r
i ou
1 ai if le s t i i
ac
i s sn
l ouson,Te s a t tPli tf Prnce i t ' prnci oft lm ied la lt co pa For
l t
xa , nd ha a n if i
s d ' i pal he i t ibiiy m ny.
a

p r o e o e tb ihig dv riy ç to s fiin l alg tectz ns i s. . ap rymu tls
u p s s f sa ls n iest ,$ J u fce ty le e h iie h p .
'
(
a t s it
t ecii e hi ofalt m e
h tz ns ps l he mber oft lmie la lt c
s he i t d i biiy ompany. Roli Gr en M HP,L.
' lng e s
'
P.

v Co a tSCH Hodig L. . , 7 F.d 1 2 ,1 2 ( 1h Ci. 0 4 . to ydd Plitfs
. mc s
l n s L C 3 4 3 0 0 0 2 1 t r 2 0 ) No nl i an if
f lt ls t ctz ns p of t one prnci l of t LLC i i ntfed,Pl ntf Prnc but
ài o it he iie hi
he
i pa
he
t de ii
ai if i e,

Pl i if f rhe f ie t ale whehe Pli if Prnce i t s e m e
antfs u t r al d o lge
t r antf i
s he ol
mber of t LLC,or
he
whehert r a eot me be sa t i r pe tvectze hi .
t he e r her m r nd her es c i ii ns ps

Fo te er a o s Plit f j rs ito a alg ton fi t iv k ti Co r' dv ri
r h s e s n , ani s u idcin l l ai s al o n o e h s u ts ie st
f
e
y
Ju iditon.
- rs c i
B. A s re i an Indi
pi s
spensabl Part
e
y

De e
f ndan s a gue t tPli tf s c pli s f r fom a s c
t r
ha a n if ' om a nt ufe s r
e ond ove a c ng de e i
r r hi
f ct n

t a n n-a t As ie wa n tj ie a a d fn a ti t i a t n,a d t e Co r a r e .
h t o p ry pr s o on d s ee d n n hs ci n h u t ge s
o
Acc di t Pl i if 'c pl nt i i As r ,no Pli if ,who e e e i t a a e m e
or ng o antfs om ai , t s pie t antfs
nt r d n o n gr e nt
5

wih Def nda Ca h M one t f r s Dr ke' e l i musc r or ng s r c .M uli e
t
e nt s
y o u: h a s xcusve
ni
i ec di e vies
tpl

pm is i udi Pl ntfsa As r ( a rntynoti udi Ca hM one aealge t
e ,ncl ng ai if nd pie but ppae l
ncl ng s
y) r le d o
ha sgne a s tlm e a ee nta r eng t toft 1 3 ofDr ke' pr ispa bl t As r
ve i d ete nt gr me g e i ha
he /
a s oft ya e o pie
by Ca h M oney unde t r or ng a e m e be wee As r a Cas M o y,Pl ntfs
s
r he ec di gr e nt t n pie nd
h
ne
ai if
d
ntt e o
e ng / br pie
3
woul be e il d t 22. ,l avi 111 % f A s r . And whie t compli a lgest tt
l he
ant le
ha he

J y 201 a ee nt ç pe iialy notd Cas M one s i ve e
ul
0 gr me t c fc l
s
e
h
y' nvol m ntwih m a ng pa m e s
t
ki
y nt

r lt t Dr ke,sa i t t adva e pa bl t As r woul be pa d by Cas M oney,
eaed o a
ttng hat he
nc ya e o pie
d
i
h
'
'

Compli ,DE #1! 1 t sve yalgai s sst tmone aefrtpa bl t As r And
ant
7,hi r le ton ugge t ha
is r is ya e o pie.
whie t Compl ntale t Ca h M one ha pai c ran s
l he
ai lges hat s
y s d e ti ums die l t Pl ntfs t
r cty o ai if , he

agr e
e ment upon whi t e pa
s
ch hos yment- a t s Compli - a e bas d ne es a iy i ve
s nd hi
ant r
e
c s rl nvol
adva esç ya e t As r .'
nc t bl o pie'
pa

TheCour c ude t tt r le Pl ntf ss ek i t sc e c otbe afor d wihout
t oncl s ha he ei f ai if e n hi as ann
f de t
i
mpaci As r srght , nd t tt r or As r i a i s a epa t t t saci
tng pie' i s a ha he ef e pie s n ndipens bl ry o hi ton.
I .
V

Conc us on
l i

The e or i i ORDERED,ADJUDGED and DECREED t tDe e
r f e, t s
ha f ndantCa h M one
s
y
le or ,l ' M o i t Dimisor i t Ale na i ,t St y,a l or r ed M e andlm
t c ds nc.s ton o s s , n he t r tve o a nd nc po at
mor l

o L w ( #7 b ,a t s me h rb i,GRANTED.Plitfs Co an ( #1 i
f a DE ) e nd he n ee y s
an if' mpli t DE ) s
h rbyDI M I ED wih u p eudc a d wi la et fl a Ame d dCompan wi i 1
ee
S SS
to t rj ie n t e v o ie n
h
ne
lit t n 0
h
da oft da eoft sOr r
ys he t
hi de .
DONE AND ORDERED i Cha r a t J m e La e e Ki Fe a J tc
n
mbe s t he a s wr nc
ng der l usie

Buidi a Unie St t Cou t e M i mi Fl i ,t s8 h da ofM a 201
l ng nd t d aes rhous , a , orda hi t y
y, 5.

J

ES LA W REN CE KI G
N
I
TED STA TES D I
STR I J D
CT U
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI O F FLO D A
CT
c
c:

A l Couns lofR e ord
I
e
c
6