Malik v. Wexford Health Services, Inc. et al

Filing 18

ORDER OF PARTIAL DISMISSAL. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 4/17/2015. (jw)

UN I
TED STA TES DISTR I CO U RT
CT
SO U TH ER N D I
STRICT O F FLO R I
DA
CA SE N O .14- vc 23204- l G
K N

N AJ B M ALI ,
I
K

Pl ntf,
ai if

W EXFORD HEALTH SERV I
CES,I C,
N
e al
t .
I ef nda s
l e nt .
/
O R DER OF PART I L DISM I
A
SSA L

TH I CAU SE com esbef e t Coul upon t Suppl e alScr ni Re tof
S
or he
'
t
he
em nt
ee ng por

M a itaeJ eParc A.Whie(1
gsrt udg tik
t û
R&R' ( 1 ) I t sj 1 83c s , aitf Nai
' DE 6 .n hi 9 a e Pl nif jb
)
M alk s fve gove nm e a em pl
i ues
r nt l
oyees a ofi s f vi atng hi cons iutonal
nd fcer or ol i
s
tt i
rght by i i or f lng t a
i s
gnorng
aii o dequa el tea hi m edi al condii . J
ty r t s
c
tons udge W hie
t
r om m e t dim i alof s e of M alk' cl m s w hie alowi ot s t pr
ec
nds he s ss
om
i s ai
l l ng her o oceed.

M ai fld obe to t t R&R ( 1 ) Fo t ra o t tf lw,a e e a
l ie j cins o he
k
DE 7 . r he e s ns ha olo nd xc pt s
m odii he ei t Cour a ovesand adopt t R& R as a O r roft s Cour .
fed r n, he
t ppr
s he
n de
hi
t

L

M a i sCl msAza ns De e
lk' ai
i t f ndantDanilL.Conn
e
The R&R s a es t t S ai if s t D ef ndant D a el L. Conn, CEO of
t t ha t ntf ues he
pl
e
, ni

W e or i hi s pe vior / sc a c pa iy . .. DE 1 a 8.M ai o j cs sa i
xf d, n s u r s y of il a ct . '
'
6, t
lk b e t, t tng
t he s eks t s Conn i bot hi of i ala i vi lc ciy.DE 1 at 1 I
hat e
o ue
n h s fci nd ndi dua apa t
7, . ndee
d,
M alk' Second Am e
i s
nded Compl nt s a es t t l ani L.Conn i s d i hi of al
ai t t ha r el
s ue n s sci

and i vi
ndi dualca t 'D E 15,a 3.Thi Cour hasr vi ed M alk' Second Am ended
paciy.
'
t
s
t
e ew
i s
Compl nt #c nov The f t alega i t r n a e c eary lm ie t Conn' r e i
ai
o.
ac ual l tons he ei r l l i t d o
s ol n
hi s
s uper s y ca t Ther ar no f ct alega i s fci nt t s a e a cl m
vior paciy.
e e
a ual l tons ufi e o t t
ai
agai tConn i hi i vi
ns
n s ndi dualca t
paciy.

I
L

M a i sOfii Capact Cl i Aa ns Do a Ga ol Os a Or e ,
lk' fcal
iv a ms ai t r xi a. c r t za
M ari Louisant and Ri k Row e
a
s
.
c

Judge W hie c uded t M alk' cl i s agai t t e D ef nt i t i
t oncl
hat
i s am
ns hes
enda s n he r

o tca c pa iis s oul b ds se M ai obe t,b o y r ctslga sa r s
fi il a cte h d e imisd. lk j cs ut nl e ie e l tndad
r di delbe a e i f er nce.H e doesnots t ntvel r butJ
egar ng i r t ndif e
ubs a i y e
udge W hie' sndi
t s
ngs
off torc us onsofl .
ac
oncl i
aw

1 1 M alk' C l m f I unctve Rele
1.
i s ai or ni i
if
J
udge W hie de er i t tM alk has notalege s fci f t t s
t t m ned ha
i
l d ufi ent ac s o uppor hi
t s

cam frij nci r le .Mai fc e hi o j ci st t spo to oft R&R o
li o nu tve eif lk o uss s be ton o hi rin he
n
J
udge W hie' sat entt çpl ntf hassnce been t a e r f om Eve gl
t s t em
hat i ai if
i
r nsf r ed r
r adesCI A s
.

a rs t t cam f rij tve r le a pe r t ha be ome mo t' DE 1 a 1
eul, he li o nunci eif p as o ve c
o.
'
6, t 7.
Co tay t Mai s o j ci s J dg W ht di no c ncu t tM ai s cam h d
nrr o lk' be ton , u e ie d t o lde ha lk' li a
becom e m oot J
. udge W hie concl d onl t i a
t
ude
y hat t ppear s i addii t expr sy
ed o, n
ton o
es l

c n l i t tMai di no alg s fiin fcs s po t irpaa l ij r a
o cudng ha lk d t l e u fce t a t up ri re r be n u y,
e
ng
lkelhood of s es on t m ert t t ale
i i
ucc s
he
is, hat he l ged t eat out ei t ha m t t
hr s w gh he r o he
adm i sr ton oft prs s t ,or t t gr ntng t m oton w oul notbe adve s t
nita i
he ion ys em
ha a i he
i
d
re o

t e p i i t r s.As t t s ee n s o ij tv r le ,M a i o j c s t t Sh
h ublc n e e t
o he e lme t f nunci e ei f lk b e t ha ç e
t
ir pa abl ha m i ati m edi el rs ofpl ntf s l tf be amput e oft ongoi
re r e r s m
at y ik
ai if ef oot
at
he
ng

l k of team e m alci l a s s i l vi a i caus ha m ,of ga e has se ac
r t nt i ousy nd adi tcaly ol ton
e r
ngr ne
t
i and l tf s
n,
ef oot econd t s r cutt ti be i a w ound ca i unbear e pai
oe eve e
ha s com ng
us ng
abl n,

a d s li oft e whol 1g a t o sz . .'DE 1 a 3 (i ) The esae n sa e
n welng h
e e s o ne ie . .
'
7, t sc . s tt me t r
toublng,butno s
r i
uch f t alegatons a
ac ual l i
ppea i M a i s Sec
r n lk'
ond Am e d Com pl nt
nde
ai

( l ug i do sme i ç i r ltd t t e d f r te o hi f es gij' I lgh o
at h t e nton t n ea e o h e o miis f s e t sc . n i t f
ho
pa
'
M alk' s a em e s r ga di gangr ne and a put i m ade f t fr t tm e i hi
i s t t nt e r ng
e
m aton,
or he is i n s

obe to t te R&R,t Co td nis M ai s cam f ij tve r le wiho t
j cins o h
he ur e e lk' li or nunci eif t u
Prj c .
eudie
l .
V

C oncl i
us on

Upo aden orviw oft s po to o t R&R t whihM ai o j ce t
n
ov e e
ho e rins f he
o c lk b e td,he
Cour concl
t
udes t t M a sr t J
ha
git a e udge Pa rck A .W hie cor e l a i t l a
ti
t
r cty ppled he aw nd
pr de w el-eas
ovi d
lr oned r
ecomm e tonsf dim i i s e ofPl ntf s cl i sw hie
nda i
or s ssng om
ai if a m
l
alow i ot st pr
l ng her o oceed.
The ef e,i i O R DERED,A DJUD G ED,and DECR EED ;
r or t s

1 M a sr t J g Parc A.W hie' Su e ntlS r e ng Re r ( 1 )
. gita e ud e tik
t s pplme a c e ni
po t DE 6
be,a t s e i her A FFI ED a A DO PTED as a O RD ER of
nd he am s, eby
RM
nd
n
t sCour ,exc asm odii he e n.
hi
t ept
fed r i

2. Plitf Obe to teeo( 1 )aeOVERULLED.
anifs j cins h rt DE 7 r
3. Pl ntf cl m s agai t Def nda Conn i hi i vi
ai i fs ai
ns
e nt
n s ndi dual capaciy a e
t r
DISM I
SSED W I
TH PREJUD I E. Pl ntf cl i s a ns Conn i hi
C
ai ifs a m gai t
n s

s
uper s y ca t a e notdi m i s
vior paciy r
s s ed.

4. Pl ntf Ei h Am e
ai ips ght
ndm ent cl m s of delber e i fer nce t a s r ous
ai
i at ndif e
o
ei

m edi need aga ns Def ndant G a ol Orega, Loui a nt and Row e i
cal
i t
e
s xi a, t
ss i ,
n
t r ofi al capa tes be a t s m e a e, he eby D I I
hei fci
cii
, nd he a
r
r
SM SSED W ITH
PR EJUD I E.Pl ntf cl m s a ns t m i t ri vi
C
ai ifs ai gai t he n hei ndi dualca cii a e
pa tes r

notdim i e
s ss d,
5. Pl ntf ' punii da agescl m agai ta1 Def
ai if s
tve m
ai
ns l endant i notdim is
ss
s s ed.
6. Pl ntf cons r y a decl at y r i cl m s, be, and t s e a e,
ai ips
piac nd
ar or elef ai
he am r

her D I I
eby SM SSED W ITH PR EJUD I ast a1 def
CE
o 1 endant
s.

7 Pli ifscam frij ci r le be a tes mei,hee yDI M I
. antf li o nun tve eif , nd h a s r b S SSED
W I O UT PR EJUD I
TH
CE.

8. Pli tf i h r by g a e l a t r ne hi cam f ij tv r leli he
a n if s e e r ntd e ve o e w s l i or n unci e e il f
s c
o hoos ,w ihi 30 da oft dat oft sOr r
es t n
ys he e hi de .
DO N E and OR DERED i Cham be s a t Ja esLa r nce K i Feder lJ tce
n
r t he m
w e
ng
a us i

Buidi and Unied St es Courhous M i i Fl i t s6t da ofA pr l 201
l ng
t
at
t e, am , orda, hi h y
i, 5.

W

c

AM ES LA W REN CE K I G
N

I STATESDI UCT J '
TED
STI
UV
cc:

S U H R DIT ITO F C A
O T E N SRC F LV

Al Couns ofRecor
l
el
d
M agitat Judge Pa rck A .W hie
sr e
ti
t

Nai M ai, o s
jb lk pr e
X 41
699
Sa aRos Cor e tona l tt i Anne
nt
a r c i l ns iuton
x
5850 Ea tM it Roa
s lon
d
M it FL 32583
lon,
4