Mighty v. Miami-Dade County et al

Filing 55

ORDER Adopting 42 Report and Recommendation. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 8/25/2015. (whl)

U NI
TED STAT ES D I
STR I T C O U RT FO R TH E
C
SO U TH ER N D I
STR I O F FL O RI A
CT
D
Cas N um be : 1 23285- V - OREN O
e
r 4Cl M
TRUD Y M I HTY ,
G

Pl ntf,
ai if

M I M I D A DE CO UN TY a
A nd
M I UEL CARBA LLO SA ,
G
D e e nt .
f nda s

O R DER AD O PTI G M A G I
N
STM T E' REPO R T AN D R EC O M M EN D A TI N
S
O
A ND DEN Y I G D EFEN D AN T M I U EL C A RBA LLO SA ' M O T I T O DI I
N
G
S
ON
SM SS
d
e s o ec r or lege i l i t
Thi i an acton by t esa e of Davi N . A l xi t r ove f a l d c vi r gh s
s s
i
he t t
vi a i t t w e e c m it d when O fi er M i
ol tons ha
r om te
tc
guel Car los s a kil d M r Al xi .
ba l a hot nd le
. e s
Pl i if Tnz M i y, a r pr e a i of M r A l xi e t t , a s f l d s t ag ns M r
a ntf
dy ght s e es nt tve
. e s' s a e l o ie ui ai t .
Ca ba l a' em pl ,M i m iD a e Count The Cour r f r d t s c e t t H onor bl J
r los s
oyer a - t
y.
t e er e hi as o he
a e ohn

J.O' lva Unie Stt s M agita e J
Suli n, t d a e
sr t udge who tl a Re ta Rec me ton on t
,
ied
por nd
om nda i
he
D e e n s m oto t di m i s t Pl i if s cl m s A fe a c e ul r vi of t f c s
f nda t '
i ns o s s he a ntf
ai .
lr
ar f e ew
he a t
pr e e i t Co pl nt M ag s r t O ' lva r om m e
es nt d n he m ai ,
i t a e Suli n ec
nded t t Cour di m i s t c s
hat he
t s s he a e
a i tM i m iD a count bas on s r gn i m uniy,butr om m e
ga ns a - de
y ed
ove ei m
t
ec
nded a l ng t ca e
lowi he s

t pr e d agans M r Ca balos The Cour now r viws t is spr e e i t Pa te '
o oc e
i t . r l a.
t
e e he s ue es nt d n he ri s

moto bresa ob e tonst t Re ta Re
ins if nd j ci o he por nd comme tonJcnov Bengf l advied
ndai
o. i uly s
i t prmie of t Deenda s motons t dimis i i a j d t t M a srt
n he e s s
he f nt' i
o s s , t s dudge ha
gitae
O ' lva sR e ta R e om m e ton i a tr ed a a
Suli n' por nd c
nda i s fi m
nd dopt d.
e

Th Co l n ts ta te Plitf d d n t o j c t M a itae O' l v n'
e u' oe h t h anif i o b e t o g sr t Sul a s
t
i
rc
e omm e ton t tt c e a i tM i miDa be dimis d ba e on s r gn i uniy.
nda i ha he as gans a - de
s se s d
ove ei mm t
l a e nt t Pl i ifdi no pla f c st tc d esa ih t e se e ofa c y- de
n ny ve , he antf d t e d a t ha oul t bls he xit nc
ount wi
lpolcy or c t ' e
i i
usom ' ncour gi or a l i polc of i r t s
a ng
low ng
i e fce s o hoot i
nnoc nt a una m e
e nd
r d
c vii ns. A ss h, i i Da sm o i t di m i si gr nt d.
i la
uc M am - de' ton o s s s a e

M r Ca ba l a pr en sa mor difc tis i hi qualfe i uniy defns Afe a
, r los es t
e fi ul s ue n s
ii d mm t
e e. tr
deaie r e oft 1w gove ni qua ii i uniy i t sCic t M a sr t O' lva
t ld eviw
he a
r ng lfed mm t n hi r ui, gitae Suli n
ca e uly a i d t f ct a lge i t Co pl ntt fnd t tM r Ca ba l a wa note ild t
r f l pple he a s le d n he m ai o i ha . r los s
ntte o
q lfe i m uniy f om s t M r Ca balos now as t Cour t s e entt Pl i if '
ua ii d m
t r
ui. . r l a
ks he
t o uppl m
he a ntf s
nanutve wih t i de r por f om M r A l xi s i whi h pa nt a g a l d f e e
i
t he nci nt e t r
. e s' hootng, c
i s r ve y i f r nt
pi t r oft eve s l di up t M r A l xi de h.
c u e he nt ea ng
o . e s' at
The Cour c udes t t M r Ca ba l a i not e il d t i m uniy bas on t f c s
t oncl
ha
. r los s
ntte o m
t
ed
he a t
a l ge i t Com pl nt I r a ng t s c us on,t Cour de i t co i rt i de
le d n he
ai . n e chi hi oncl i he
t clnes o ns de he nci nt

rpor f t s merasm Mr Car los a kst Cou't c i ri;us asa pli ifc d
e t 0r he a e c . bal a s he l o onsde tj t ny antf oul
t
a tuly dr f a Compli t def a quaiid i u t and de i a ofi eroft docrne'
rf l a t
ant o e t lfe mm niy
prve n tc
he ti s
i ende pr t c i a of ie co d c eai l dr f a i de r por t de i t ci la
nt d o e ton, ny fc r ul r tvey a t n nci nt e t o prve he vii ns
i v oft Cour ' pr e ton. The i i ntr por i uli a e y t of i e ' na r i oft
nvol ed he
ts ot c i
nc de e t s tm t l he f c r s r atve he
e nt l di up t M r A l xi de t and att s s a of ltga i t Cour m us a ce t
ve s ea ng
o . e s' a h,
hi t ge
ii ton, he
t
t c pt he
Pl ntf s'na r i of t e eve s as tue. 1 , a a l ge M r Ca ba l a s a kil d M r
ai if
r atve
hos
nt
r
f s le d, . r los hot nd le
.

Alxi wihoutprvoc ton o j tfc ton,he hevi ae Mr Alxi'ce rye tbls d rght
e s t
o ai r usiiai t n
oltd . e s lal sa ihe i
t be fee f om unr s bl s i e. The Cour w il r ons de M r Ca ba l a' qua ii d
o
r r
ea ona e e zur
t l ec i r . r los s
lte

-

2-

i nt d fn ewih p riulratnin te icd n rpo ta te s
mmu i ee s t a t a t to h n ie t e r t h umma yj g n sa e
y
c
e
r ud me t tg ,
butM r Car los sm o i t di m i si de e
. ba l a' ton o s s s ni d.

DO ANDO E DiC a est a ,lrati2 dyoA gs21.
NE
RD RE n hmbraMimiFoi ,hs a f uut 05
d
,
FEDER CO A
NO
UN I
TE
A TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U
.X

Copi pr de t
es ovi d o:

Unie Stt sM agita eJ
td a e
sr t udgeJ O ' lva
ohn Suli n
Couns lofRe d
e
cor

-

3-