Mighty v. Miami-Dade County et al

Filing 55

ORDER Adopting 42 Report and Recommendation. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 8/25/2015. (whl)

Download PDF
U NI TED STAT ES D I STR I T C O U RT FO R TH E C SO U TH ER N D I STR I O F FL O RI A CT D Cas N um be : 1 23285- V - OREN O e r 4Cl M TRUD Y M I HTY , G Pl ntf, ai if M I M I D A DE CO UN TY a A nd M I UEL CARBA LLO SA , G D e e nt . f nda s O R DER AD O PTI G M A G I N STM T E' REPO R T AN D R EC O M M EN D A TI N S O A ND DEN Y I G D EFEN D AN T M I U EL C A RBA LLO SA ' M O T I T O DI I N G S ON SM SS d e s o ec r or lege i l i t Thi i an acton by t esa e of Davi N . A l xi t r ove f a l d c vi r gh s s s i he t t vi a i t t w e e c m it d when O fi er M i ol tons ha r om te tc guel Car los s a kil d M r Al xi . ba l a hot nd le . e s Pl i if Tnz M i y, a r pr e a i of M r A l xi e t t , a s f l d s t ag ns M r a ntf dy ght s e es nt tve . e s' s a e l o ie ui ai t . Ca ba l a' em pl ,M i m iD a e Count The Cour r f r d t s c e t t H onor bl J r los s oyer a - t y. t e er e hi as o he a e ohn J.O' lva Unie Stt s M agita e J Suli n, t d a e sr t udge who tl a Re ta Rec me ton on t , ied por nd om nda i he D e e n s m oto t di m i s t Pl i if s cl m s A fe a c e ul r vi of t f c s f nda t ' i ns o s s he a ntf ai . lr ar f e ew he a t pr e e i t Co pl nt M ag s r t O ' lva r om m e es nt d n he m ai , i t a e Suli n ec nded t t Cour di m i s t c s hat he t s s he a e a i tM i m iD a count bas on s r gn i m uniy,butr om m e ga ns a - de y ed ove ei m t ec nded a l ng t ca e lowi he s t pr e d agans M r Ca balos The Cour now r viws t is spr e e i t Pa te ' o oc e i t . r l a. t e e he s ue es nt d n he ri s moto bresa ob e tonst t Re ta Re ins if nd j ci o he por nd comme tonJcnov Bengf l advied ndai o. i uly s i t prmie of t Deenda s motons t dimis i i a j d t t M a srt n he e s s he f nt' i o s s , t s dudge ha gitae O ' lva sR e ta R e om m e ton i a tr ed a a Suli n' por nd c nda i s fi m nd dopt d. e Th Co l n ts ta te Plitf d d n t o j c t M a itae O' l v n' e u' oe h t h anif i o b e t o g sr t Sul a s t i rc e omm e ton t tt c e a i tM i miDa be dimis d ba e on s r gn i uniy. nda i ha he as gans a - de s se s d ove ei mm t l a e nt t Pl i ifdi no pla f c st tc d esa ih t e se e ofa c y- de n ny ve , he antf d t e d a t ha oul t bls he xit nc ount wi lpolcy or c t ' e i i usom ' ncour gi or a l i polc of i r t s a ng low ng i e fce s o hoot i nnoc nt a una m e e nd r d c vii ns. A ss h, i i Da sm o i t di m i si gr nt d. i la uc M am - de' ton o s s s a e M r Ca ba l a pr en sa mor difc tis i hi qualfe i uniy defns Afe a , r los es t e fi ul s ue n s ii d mm t e e. tr deaie r e oft 1w gove ni qua ii i uniy i t sCic t M a sr t O' lva t ld eviw he a r ng lfed mm t n hi r ui, gitae Suli n ca e uly a i d t f ct a lge i t Co pl ntt fnd t tM r Ca ba l a wa note ild t r f l pple he a s le d n he m ai o i ha . r los s ntte o q lfe i m uniy f om s t M r Ca balos now as t Cour t s e entt Pl i if ' ua ii d m t r ui. . r l a ks he t o uppl m he a ntf s nanutve wih t i de r por f om M r A l xi s i whi h pa nt a g a l d f e e i t he nci nt e t r . e s' hootng, c i s r ve y i f r nt pi t r oft eve s l di up t M r A l xi de h. c u e he nt ea ng o . e s' at The Cour c udes t t M r Ca ba l a i not e il d t i m uniy bas on t f c s t oncl ha . r los s ntte o m t ed he a t a l ge i t Com pl nt I r a ng t s c us on,t Cour de i t co i rt i de le d n he ai . n e chi hi oncl i he t clnes o ns de he nci nt rpor f t s merasm Mr Car los a kst Cou't c i ri;us asa pli ifc d e t 0r he a e c . bal a s he l o onsde tj t ny antf oul t a tuly dr f a Compli t def a quaiid i u t and de i a ofi eroft docrne' rf l a t ant o e t lfe mm niy prve n tc he ti s i ende pr t c i a of ie co d c eai l dr f a i de r por t de i t ci la nt d o e ton, ny fc r ul r tvey a t n nci nt e t o prve he vii ns i v oft Cour ' pr e ton. The i i ntr por i uli a e y t of i e ' na r i oft nvol ed he ts ot c i nc de e t s tm t l he f c r s r atve he e nt l di up t M r A l xi de t and att s s a of ltga i t Cour m us a ce t ve s ea ng o . e s' a h, hi t ge ii ton, he t t c pt he Pl ntf s'na r i of t e eve s as tue. 1 , a a l ge M r Ca ba l a s a kil d M r ai if r atve hos nt r f s le d, . r los hot nd le . Alxi wihoutprvoc ton o j tfc ton,he hevi ae Mr Alxi'ce rye tbls d rght e s t o ai r usiiai t n oltd . e s lal sa ihe i t be fee f om unr s bl s i e. The Cour w il r ons de M r Ca ba l a' qua ii d o r r ea ona e e zur t l ec i r . r los s lte - 2- i nt d fn ewih p riulratnin te icd n rpo ta te s mmu i ee s t a t a t to h n ie t e r t h umma yj g n sa e y c e r ud me t tg , butM r Car los sm o i t di m i si de e . ba l a' ton o s s s ni d. DO ANDO E DiC a est a ,lrati2 dyoA gs21. NE RD RE n hmbraMimiFoi ,hs a f uut 05 d , FEDER CO A NO UN I TE A TES D I STRI J D GE CT U .X Copi pr de t es ovi d o: Unie Stt sM agita eJ td a e sr t udgeJ O ' lva ohn Suli n Couns lofRe d e cor - 3-

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?