Pinero v. EDAL PLAZA, INC.

Filing 15

ORDER denying 12 Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 3/19/2015. (whl)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT FO R THE
CT
SO U TH ER N DI
STR I O F FLO RI A
CT
D
N o.1 CI 23507- O REN O
4- VM
EM I O PI
LI NERO ,

Pl it
an ?
VS.

EDA L PLA ZA ,I C .
N ,

Dee d n .
fn a t
O R DER D ENY IN G DE FEND A N TS'M O TIO N S TO D ISM ISS

Thi i an a in f vi ai oft Amei ns wih Dia lte Ac,42 U. C.j
ss
cto or oltons he
rca
t sbiiis t
S.
1 1 1 ets q. Pli tf Em ii Pi r al ge t tDe enda Eda Plza,I ' f ciiy con ans
28, e
a n if
lo ne o le s ha f nt l a nc.s a lt
ti
ar hie t alba r e st a es by i vi s r qui i t us ofa w hee c r Eda Pl za now
c t c ur
r i r o cc s ndi dual e r ng he e
l hai.
l a
m ove t di m i s t s ac i bec us , a cor ng t Eda Pl a, M r Pi o di not pl d
s o s s hi ton
a e c di o
l az
. ner d
ea
i or a i abouthi a t m ptt a c s t f c lt hi i er s i r t ni t t f c lt ort
nf m ton
s te
o c es he a iiy, s nt e t n e ur ng o he a iiy, he
f s biiy ofr m ovi ar hie t a bani r t ac s w ih s fc e pa tc art
ea i lt
e
ng c t c ur l
e s o ce s t ufi i nt ri ul iy.
l r vi w i EdalPl z s m oton t di m i s t Cour lbe aly cons r es t a l ga i
n e e ng
a a'
i o s s , he
ti r l
t u he le tons
co a ned i M r Pi r s c pl i ,a dr w s a lr a onabl i e enc f om t e a l ga i .
nt i
n . ne o' om a nt nd a
l es
e nf r es r hos le tons

Bel AtantcCor v Twombl 550 U. 544,555 (
l l i p. .
y,
S.
2007) Tur ngt M r Pi r sc ant
. ni o . neo' ompli ,
t Cour frt hol t t M r Eda ' alegai gi hi sa ng t brng s t M r Pi r
he
t is
ds ha
. ls l tons ve m t ndi o i ui: . ne o
vi ie Eda Pl a' f c lt i t pas ,a M r Pi r i ends t r t n t r i t f ur Se
std
l az s a iiy n he t nd . ne o nt
o e ur he e n he ut e. e

Pei k v N & D Hol ng,I .No.1 22 C1 201 W L 6511 a *2 ( D.Fl De
tnsy .
di nc,
3- 438- V, 3
738, t S. a. c.
1 201 . The Cour nextfndst t a c ptnghi algatonsastue Mr Pi r sc ant
2, 3)
t
i ha, c e i s le i
r , . neo' ompli
s i te e ch e em e r qui e ofa cl i unde t A m erca wih D i abiii sA c . D e e nt
atsi s a l nt e r d
am
r he
i ns t s lte t
f nda s

do no c nt t t t M r Pi r i a qua ii d i vi l w ih a di a lt M r Pi r w as
t o es ha
. ne o s
lf e ndi dua t
s biiy.
. ne o

e ude fo EdalPlza sf clt whe he at mpt d t a ce st f ciiy i hi whee c r
xcl d r m
a ' a iiy
n
te e o c s he a lt n s
l hai,
a M r Pi r wa e uded bec us oft a chie tla ba re s t e r e t tvi ae t
nd . ne o s xcl
a e
he r t ctr l ri r o ntanc ha ol t he
dit t oft Ame i a wih Dia ltes Ac .
c aes he
rc ns t s biii
t

Fi ly,t Cour dr w s t r as bl
na l he
t a
he e ona e

i ee
nf r nce t t f c lt s ba re s t e r a e r a l r m ovabl as l velng s de al a
ha a iiy' r i r o nt y r e diy e
e,
e i
i w ks nd
r a r ngi pi c t e a e pr bl w ihi t r l ofpr c i lpos i lt Fi ng t tM r
e r a ng cni abl s r oba y t n he ea m
a tca
s biiy. ndi ha
.
Pi r s a ed a c a m f vi a i oft A m e i ns wih D i a ltesA c ,i i
ne o t t
l i or ol ton he
rca
t s biii
t ts
A D J D G ED t tEda Pl z sm oto t di m i si D EN I . l i f t r
U
ha
l a a'
in o s s s
ED t s urhe
ORD ERED t t EdalPl z s l fl an ans e t M r Pi o' co pl i by M a c 31
ha
a a ha l ie
w r o . ner s m a nt
rh ,
201
5.

Q J
DON E AN D OR DERED i Cha be s a M i m i Fl i t s
n
m r t a , orda, hi

zday ofM a c 201
'
r h, 5.

FE Rl A.M OM NO
çO
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STR I J D G E
CT U

Co espr de t
pi ovi d o:
Cou elofRe or
ns
c d

-

2-