Zemba v. Comcast Corporation et al

Filing 34

ORDER Granting 12 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim; granting 14 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 6/3/2015. (jw)

MIIIIIIIIIIII'''I'R''''''KKKKKK*''''''''''''''''''''
IIIIIIIIIIIIII''''''''''KKKKKKK'''''''''''''''''''''
IIIIIIIIIIIIII'IRR'''''IKKKRKKR*'''''''''''''''''''
'

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI 0F FLORI
CT
DA
M I IDI SI
AM
VI ON
CASE NO.1 CV4- 23928-1W 6
1
LI ZEM BA,
SA
Pli if
antf,

COM CAST CORPOM TI
ON,
aPe yl n aCop or ton;and
nns va i
ai
W TEG R ATED TECH G ROU P,LLC ,
a For gn Li ie Libiiy Compa
ei
m t d a lt
qy,
De e nt.
f nda s
/
O RDER GRANTI DEFENDANTS'M OTI
NG
ONS TO DI I
SM SS

THI M ATTER c me b f r teCo r u o De e d n Co a tCo p. (co a f'
S
o s e ae h u t p n fn a t mc s r ' l mc s )
st
M o int DimisPlitf' Co an ( #1 ) a dDe e d n l tg ae Te h Gr u LLC'
to o s s anifs mplit DE 2 , n fn a t n e rtd c o p
S
($ 'M oi nt Dimisa d S p rigM e rn u o ' w ( #1 ) Thi ma tri f ly
;TG' to o s s n u po t
I )
n mo a d m fLa DE 4 . s te s ul
bre ed, a as c e by t Pli tf ,De e nt M oto s d be g a ed a Pl ntf
if l nd
onc ded
he a n if f nda s
i ns houl
r nt nd ai if
s d begi n la t ame he Co pli t
houl
ve e ve o
nd r m a n .
1
.

Bac
kgro
und

I h rCo lit Pli t falg st a wh n Or se Alg e Ci e r ' ,a n w-o me
n e mpan , ani l e h t e e ts e r A1ge' o fr r
f e
)
e o eo De e d n 1 ( l g dt b p r ofaj itv nu ewi De e d n Co at, s
mplye f f n a t TG al e o e at
e
on e tr t fn a t mc s) wa
h
dipa c d t he home i or rt r para c bl t l vii box l td i he be oom ,Al r
s t he o r
n de o e i a e e e son
ocae n r dr
eg e
l s l i ione Pli if a pe f m e i
kley mprs d antf nd ror d nappr it a uns lcied s xua a t i he
opra e nd
oi t e l cs n r
pr s nc Pli ifalege t ts c l 305 COM CAST i or rt s hed e t r pai,t t
e e e. antf l s ha he aled
n de o c ul he e r ha
Al r a rve i ave cl be rng t Co c tl
eg e ri d n
hi e a i he m as ogo,t the wa wea i a Com c ts r,t t
ha
s
rng
as hit ha

1
Pli iffldhe Re pons i Oppostont I SM otont Dimis( #1 ,a he
antf ie r s e n
ii o TG' i o s s DE 9) nd r
Repons i Oppostont Comc tsM otont Dimis( #25) Comc s' Repl i Suppor
s en
ii o
as'
i o s s DE
.
ats y n
t
ofisM oi t Dimisa r at( #28) a I fld isRe yi Suppor a ( #30)
t ton o s s ppeas DE
, nd TG ie t pl n
t t DE
.

heutlze aCom c tis d i ntfca i ca d t gan a e st he hom e,a t ti wa onl
ii d
as-s ue de ii ton r o i cc s o r
nd ha t s y
are t e e s t t Pli tf l r e Al r wa not a e oye of Comca t but of
t r hes vent ha a n if en n d eg e s
n mpl e
s,
De e ntI
f nda TG.
Pli ifsCompl i a lge t e coun s Count1 f neglgen hii i lvel o y a
antf
ant le s hr e
t:
, or
i t rng, s e ed nl t
De e
f ndan I
t TG;Cou s 1 a 11 f neglg nthii a neg i nts r i i r s c i y,
nt 1 nd 1, or
ie
rng nd lge upe v son, e pe tvel
a elvel onl a De e ntCom c s .
r e ed y t f nda
at

Pl i if s neglg t hii cli agans l i f
antf
i en rng am
i t TG s ounde on t a lga i t t t
d
he le ton ha he
ba kg ound c k l ha peror e on Al r prort hi hii wasi de ebe a e i di
c r
hec TG d f m d
eg e i o s rng
na quat c us t d
noti l an c k wha s ve ofhi ba ound pro t hi a rvi i t Unie Stt s
nc ude y hec
toe r
s ckgr
i r o s r i ng n he
td ae
fom Cuba The ne i nt hii c am a i t Comca t i f
r
.
glge
rng l i ga ns
s s ounde on t alegai t t
d
he l ton ha

Co a t()a ovedI Sis ncet Al r oft i iiai ba ebeai t Comc t
mc s 1 ppr
TG' sua o eg e he dentfc ton dg rng he
as

lg ta e a e Alg e t g i a c s t Pli tf ho ,( )h d a a re n wi 1
o o h t n bld e r o an c e s o anips me 2 a n g e me t t TG
h
r ga di qua ii tons a ba o md c c f a i nt t whom l woul is
e r ng
lfcai
nd ckgr t
he ks or pplca s o
TG
d s ue

Comcata ove i ntfcai car ,a ( t tComc tt rf eha adut t e ur t t
s-ppr d de ii ton ds nd 3) ha
as heeor d
y o ns e ha
I ' ba kgr
TG S c ound c k wa s tc e t bo h e ur s f t ofc t
hec
s ufi i nt o t ns e a ey
usomer and t c
s
o ompl wih
y t
t e a e m e on ba kg o
h gr e nt
c r und c c al ge t exit bewee t Defnda s Pl n ips
he ks le d o s t n he
e nt . aitf
ne i e s r son cli a ns Comca ti f mded o t al ga i t t Com c tdi not
glg nt upe vii
am gai t
s s ot
n he le ton ha
as d
pr ry s pe vieI ' ba kg ound c c pr edur t e ur t s f t ofisc t r .
ope l u r s TG S c r
he k oc es o ns e he a ey t usome s
I
I.

Le St
gal andar
d

A co pl n mus c an s t a pl n sa e nt of t gr
m ait
t ont i hor nd ai t t me s
he ounds f r t c ts
o he our'

j rs ito ,o t e c u e o a to a d oft e r l fs ug t Fe .R.Ci P.8a .Un e te
u idcin f h a s f cin, n
h ei o h . d
e
v. () d r h
heg tne pe dngsa d r sstf rhb t eS p e Co r i As rh v I al 5 6U. 6 2
ihe d la i tn a d e b t y h u rme u t n hc o . qb , 5 S. 6
( 01 )a d Bel l Cop.v T mbe 55 U. 5 4 ( 0 7 ,t r mu tb S n u h f cst
2 0 n l At. r . wo ly 0 S. 4 2 0 ) hee s e ç o g a t o
e
saea cam t r l fta i pa sb eo (h )fc 'o t e c mplit T mbe 55 U. a
tt li o ei h t s lu il n t e a e' f h o an . wo ly 0 S. t
e
57 A pl ntf mus pl d s fc e f c st s
0.
ai if t ea ufi i nt a t o how e ilm e t r i a mus pl a t or
ntte nt o elef nd
t ed ç e
m
2

t lbe sand co l i ... f mul c r cia i oft e e t o a ca e ofaci n wil
han a l
ncusons. A br ai e tton he l men s f
us
to
l
a i e l i or ei f ur ve
ton o
no do. 1 d y a c
t ' d. ç
'
onl
ompli t t sa e a plusbl c am f r le s vi s a m o i t
ant ha t t s
t lm
A
a i l a i lt
n he antf e
dim is' I , 55 U . a 678. 1 cai has f c a plusbiiy whe t pli if plads
s s .' qbal 6 S. t
fzt alc e t tal t c tt d aw t r as nabl i e e t tt def nda i la e
ic u ontnt ha lows he our o r he e o e nf r nce ha he e nt s i bl
f t m ico
br he s nduc a l d.' d.
t lege '1

l de i ng a m o i t dimis t Cour mus a e a co pl i ' wel- e
n c di
ton o s s , he
t
t cc pt
m ants
lpl d

alg to s a tu .Erc s n v Pa d s 5 U. 8 ,9 ( 0 7 ,Su h alg to mu t b
l ain s r e ik o . r u , 51 S. 9 4 2 0 ) c l ains s e
e
e
consr ed i t lg mos f vor bl t t Pl n if Am.D e alAs ' v Ci Cor ,6 F.
tu n he i ht t a a e o he aitf
nt
s n . gna p. 05 3d

1 3 1 8 ( 1h Ci. 01 ) çn a ay i te s fiin yoftec mp ant gh Co rqlmill
28 , 2 8 1 t r 2 0 .t n lzng h u fce c h o li , t e u t i ts
l
gt)c n ieaint te welpla e fcu lalg to s d c me t c n rlt o r frnc d i
i o sd rto o h l- e d d a ta le ain , o u ns e ta o r e ee e n
s

N
e
y c '
t ec mpan , n matr j dcal n t e 'f Gr sav Fis Un o S c, n .3 8F.d 8 0
' o lit a d t s u iil oi d. a a t . r t i n e .I c, 5 3 4 ,
.
8 5 ( 1h Ci. 0 4 . e Co r ma as c n ul d c me t t a aeatc e t te Co lit
4 1 t r 2 0 ) Th u t y lo o s t o u n s h t r ta h d o h mpan
orm o i t dim isunde t tnc por ton by r f r nc ' docrne.The El ve h Cic thas
ton o s s
r he ç or a i
i
e e e e' ti
e nt r ui
defne t i om or ton by r e e docrnet m e n:
i d he nc
ai
ef r nce ti o a

( d c me tatc e t a moi n t ds s ma b c nsd rd b t e c u t
A) o u n ta h d o
to o imis y e o i ee y h o r
wih u c n e t gtemo init o frs mmayj dg n o l i t eatc e
t o t o v ri h to no ne o u r u me t ny f h ta h d
n
d cl n i: ( ) c nr l t te plitf cam; a d ( ) u ds ue . . . .
o l t s 1 e ta o h an ifs li n 2 n ip td
me
ç
i s e 'i t s c t xtmea t tt a he iiy of t doc e i no
undiput d' n hi on e
ns ha he ut ntct
he um nt s t
c le
ha lnged.

Ho se v Fed ,3 4 F.d 1 2 1 3 ( 1h Ci. 0 2 (nena ctto o te ) s e
rly . lt 0 3 1 5, 1 4 1 t r 2 0 ) i tr l i ins mi d ; e
a
t
as Da v T ylr 4 F.d 1 7 1 7 ( 1h Ci. 0 5 .
lo y . a o , 00 3 2 2, 2 6 1 t r 2 0 )
11
1.

D i c s on
s us i

Defnda sha m ove t dim is Pl i ips Compli on s ve algr
e nt ve
d o s s antf
ant
e r ounds a1 t i
, l unnng
on t a qua oft Compli tsf t la lga i .
he de cy he
a n ' acua le tons
I Sc e a gume i isM oton t Dim isi t tPli itsCompl n f l t sa ea
TG' hif r
nt n t
i o s s s ha antf'
ait ais o t t
cam f r neg i nthii unde Fl i La f sa e a c am f r ne i nthii pli if
li o
lge
rng
r orda w. $ tt
To
l i o glge
rng, antf
3

mus a l e f c ss wi t tt enpl rwa puton notc oft ha mf pr nstesoft
t leg a t ho ng ha he l oye s
ie he r ul ope ii
he

e ly e'Ur v Oc a i Cr ie ,I c,2 4 W L 5 2 2 * ( D.Fl Oc .31 2 4
mpo e ' e . e na us s n . 01
5 31 2 3 S. a. t , 01 )
r c i r i gr e on ot r grln#l,Ur v Oc a Cr s s I 201 W L 661158
e onsde aton ant d
he tx ' e . eani uie , nc, 4
6

( D.Fl Nov20, 4) Furhert Fl i Supr Cour ha hedt t
S. a.
201 . t ,he orda eme
t s l ha
To brng a prm af ci c e f ne i nthii a pl i ifmus de onsr t t t
i
i a e as br glge rng, antf
t m ta e ha :

( ) t e l y r wa r ql e t ma e a a rp it iv siain o te
1 he mp o e s e ti d o k n pp o rae n e tg to f h
r
e l y e a d fie t d s ; ( ) a a p o rae ivetg to wo l h ve
mp o e n ald o o o 2 n p r p it n siai n ud a
r ve l d t uns tbiiy oft e pl e f t pa tc a d y t bepe f med
e a e he uia lt
he m oye or he riul r ut o
ror

orf e oy nti ge r l a ( iwa un e o bl frt e o rt hie
or mpl me n ne a; nd 3) t s z as na e o he mplye o r
t e o i lghtoft i or ai n hekne ors ul ha known.
he mpl yee n i
he nf m to
w
ho d ve

li ikiv Doe,81 So.2 347,362 ( a.2002) l poi s t t compl e a e e fom
alc .
4
d
Fl
. TG nt o he
et bs nc r
Pl i ifs Compli of a a lga i r lt d t t s c elm e oft neglgen hii
antf
ant
ny le tons ea e o he e ond e nt he
i t rng
c us ofa ton.Pli ifdoesnota l e a f c st s
a t
ci
antf
leg ny a t o how t tany i tga i i t Al r s
ha
nvesi ton n o eg e'
ba r
ckg ound i Cubawoul ha r veaed Al r suns t biiy f e pl a doesno alege
n
d ve e l
eg e'
uia lt or m oy, nd
t l
t ta hi i Al r sba o wo d ha i f c r r hi uns t bl f empl I
ha nyt ng n eg e' ckgr und ul ve n a t ende ed m
uia e or
oy. n
s q Pli tf aleg no f c s s
hor a n if l es
a t howi t tt e pl r wa puton no i of a ham f l
ng ha he m oye
s
tce
ny r u
pr nstesoft e oye ort tt y w o d ha be had t co
ope ii
he mpl e, ha he
ul ve en
hey nduced a mor t oug
t
e hor h
c k.
hec

Pli ifdo notr s
antf es
e pond t' TG' a gume on t spoi a al.l t d,Pli ifa gues
cI S r
nt hi nt t l nsea
antf r
t ts ha pld e
ha he s e noug f ct t sa e s e uns ii d cli f rne i nc t era vi rous
h a s o t t om
pecfe am o glge e md
ca i
la lt ora ncyt r a t tt r f ehe Compl i s oul notbedim is d.Atl a t not
ibiiy ge
heo y, nd ha he e or r
ant h d
s se
e s,
wihoutla t a nd a r que td by I
t
e ve o me s e se
TG.
The Cour a e wih I bot t t Pl ntf f itr t plad f c s t s
t gr es t TG
h ha ai ifs alle o e a t o uppor he
t r
neg i nthii cli i f t t t tcli ,a t tPli tf s a ndo e of t tcai i
lge
rng am s a al o ha am nd ha a n if ba nm nt ha l m n
' al
fii t rs d t I Sa g ntwarnt dimis loft tcai Se We tCoas LteI .
ng o e pon o TG' r ume
ra s s s a ha l m. e s
t / ns
'

Co v ff Br k r g Pa te sLLC, 0 9 W L 2 7 49 ( D.Fl. 0 9 ( k mp, . (iig
. . e o ea e rn r
20
95 7 S. a 2 0 ) Rys n J) ctn

4

S. Fl L. 7 1 a d sai t litf fie t r s o d t ( fn a ts moin t ds s
D. a. R. . n ttng i an if ald o e p n o Dee d n ') to o imis
p
Co n 1 , ihao ec n t ue g o n sf r h Co r t d s s t i c u t y d fut'
u t 1 wh c l n o si ts r u d o t e u to imis hs o n b ea l.)
t
'
Pli tf s Com pli t s f r fom sm ia de i i nc e i Count 1 a II a ns
a n if
a n ufe s r
i lr fc e i s n
s 1 nd I gai t
Com c s .Fis,a Pl i ips cai f neglge hii as a i tCo ca ti bas d entr l on
a t rt s antf l m or
i nt rng
gans m s s e
iey
t s m e f c s i s t f hi n,a t f c s unde l ng Pl n ifs c am a i t I
he a
a t , n ho gun as o s he a t
ryi
aitf l i ga ns TG,t
he
Compl ntf ist sa e a cai a ns Comca t f r neglge hii f r t s m e r as t t
ai al o tt
l m gai t
s o
i nt rng o he a
e on ha
cli f l a i t I
am ais gans TG.Furhe ,bec us t Pl i ifs neg i nt s r ii ca m a i t
t r
a e he antf
lge upe v son li ga ns
a t na
tl upe v s d TG' c o md hec
Com c s r t on t t or t t Com c s i dequae y s r i e I S ba kgr t c k
a t ess
he he y ha
pr ce e ,and Pl ntf c nno sae a c am f neglge t hii bas d on t e pr e e ,
o dur s
ai if n t t t
l i or
i n rng e
hos oc dur s
Pli ifsne i en s r ii cam mus f i.
antf
glg t upe v son li
t al

M o eo r Pli tf hasc ede t the c
r ve , a n if
onc d ha r ompl i f ist sa e et roft s c us sof
ant àl o t t ihe
he e a e
aci n a i tCo c s .l he Re pons t Comca ts M o i t Dim is,Pl ntf c am st t
to gans m a t n r s
eo
s'
ton o s s ai if l i ha

he t or ofla lt ha c nge fom t f
r he y
ibiiy s ha d r hat ound i t Com pl n ,a t tt or f s not
n he
ait nd ha he y ç
i
ne i n hii r t nton,or s r ii def nda s a e rgh a
glge t rng, e e i
upe v son-- e nt r i t bout t t' DE #25 a 1
ha .'
t 3.
l tad,a i a tmptt s ve t f c soft Co pl nta ale d,Pli tf c am s t tt
nse
nd n te
o a he a t
he m ai s l ge
a n if l i ha he
Cour s ul l t t f c saleg a notdim isasl a t e f c sç l s
t ho d ook o he a t l ed nd
s s
ong s hos a t ç l uppor s
wi
t ome

vibl l lt or ' f Re ogni i t tt e a lga i do notsa e a cai f t c us of
a e ega he y. #. c zng ha hos le tons
'
t t l m or he a es

a to a tal alg d i t Co lit Plitf t e cts t te Re ttme t( c n ) o
cin cu ly l e n he mpan , anif h n ie o h sae n Se o d f
e
Age y f s m eunde i d c eofa ton s woul a lge a i tComca t
nc or o
fne aus
c i he
d le ga ns
s.

Th Co r rj csPli t f:atmptt n n t Co an t r u h h rRe p n e t
e u t ee t ani 1 te o me d he mplit h o g e s o s s o
f
t Def nda s M otonst Dimis Aspl a a asPli ifc
he e nt ' i
o s s.
e d, nd
antf once ,Pl ntf Compl i
des ai ips
ant
f ist sae a c am f ne i nthii agans et de e
al o t t l i or glge
rng i t iher f ndant and f is t sa e a c am f
,
a l o tt
l i or

ne i nts r ii a ns Comc t Ac or ngl Pli ifs Compl ntm us be dimis d,
glge upe vson gai t
as. c di y, antf
ai
t
s se
a Pl i if s d be g ve l a t fl m4 Am e d Compl nt t c e t s pl a ng
nd antf houl
i n e ve o ie
nde
ai o ur he e e di
dei incesi s i abl
fce i f he s e.
5

I
V.

Concl i
uson

The ef e i i ORDERED, ADJUDGED and DECREED t D e e nt Com c s
r or , t s
hat f nda
at

Cop.s Moton t Dimis Pli ifs Co ai ( #1 ,and Dee t l e r td Tec
r'
i o s s antf
mpl nt DE 2)
fndan ntg ae
h
Gr up LLC' Moton t DimismA Suppori M e a
o
S i o s s d
tng mor ndum ofLa ( #14)be and t
w DE
,
he

smeh rb ae GRANTED.Plitf Co an ( #1 i h rby DI I ED wih u
a ee y r,
an ifs mplit DE ) s ee
SM SS
to t
p eu iet Plitf fl a Ame d dCo an wi n 1 d y o ted t o ti Or e .
rj d c o anif ii n
ng
n e mplit t 0 a s f h ae f h s d r
hi
DONE AND ORDERED i Cha
n
mber a t J m e La e Ki Fe r J tc
s t he a s wr nce ng de al usie
Buidi a Unie Stt sCourhous ,M im i Fl i , hi 3r dayofJ
l ng nd t d a e
t e a , orda t s d
une,201
5.

<

J

ES LAW REN CE KI G
N
I
TED STATES DI
STRI J D E
CT
OUTHERN DI
STRI OF F
CT
DA

CC:

M agit at JudgeEdwi G.Tor e
sr e
n
rs
AI Couns lofRt ord
l
e
c

6