TELESTRATA, LLC. v. NetTalk.com, Inc. et al

Filing 35

ORDER Denying (13) Motion to Dismiss Pursuant to FED. R. CIV. P. 23.1 in case 1:14-cv-24137-JLK. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 7/9/2015. Associated Cases: 1:14-cv-24137-JLK, 1:15-cv-20435-JLK (jw)

UN I D STA TE S D I
TE
STR I C O U R T
CT
FOR THE SOUTH ERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA

Ca eNo.1: 4- 241 J
s
1 CV- 37-LK
TELESTRATA,LLC,aC o or lm ied Iabiiy c pany, i vi l and de vatvey
l ado i t i lt om
ndi dualy
ri i l
on behal oft s ehol sofNe TALK .com ,I . a Fl i c poraton,
f he har der
t
nc , or da or
i

Pl ntf
ai it

N ETTALK . M ,I C . a Fl i c pora i ,
CO
N , or da or
t on
ANASTASI '
OS i
TAK I :KYRI DES.
S'
AKI
STEVEN H EA LY,
ANASTASI S ' CK 'K YRI I
O S
NI '
AK DES l ,
I
K ENN ETH H O SFELD ,
GARRY PAXI
NOS,
KYRI DES I
AKI
NVESTM ENTS.LTD. aFl i Im ie par ner hi
, or da i t d t s p
SHADRON STASTNEY,and
,
A N GE LA I SI
LI E,

Def nda s
e nt .
ORDER DENYI DEFENDANTS'M OTI TO DI I
NG
ON
SM SS
PURSUANT TO FED.R.CI P.23.
V.
1

THE COURT,ha ng r c ve a r vi d t M oto t Dim isPur ua t Fe . R .
vi e ei d nd e ewe he
in o s s
s nt o d

Ci P.23. s te by Defnda s( 1 (i oton',Pli ifs Repons ( 1 ) a
v.
1 ubmitd
e nt DE 3) ç i ' antf' s e DE 5 nd
M
)
Dee nt'Re y( 1 t rt a ha ng c
fnda s pl DE 9) heeo, nd vi onduce or arume ont M otononAprl
td al g nt he i
i
27, l t Cour he e DENI De e
20 5, he
t r by
ES f ndan s M oton f t r a onss tf rh be ow .
t ' i or he e s
e ot l
A m o i t di m i s pur ua t Rul 23. 1 s
ton o s s
s nt o
e
ounds a a m oto t dimis f f lng t
s
i n o s s or aii o

saeacam upon whih rle c n begrntd go r d by Rul 1 b)6 .Se e. Chr t lv
tt li
c eif a
a e vene
e 2( () e g. ysal
.

Se de Te hnol e ,913 F.Supp. 2d 1 ,1 ( D.Fl. 2) To s vi aRul 1 b)6)
r n c ogi s
341 351 S. a 201 .
ur ve
e 2( (

l in,t c
noto he ompli mus i udete
ant t ncl tnough f c st sae a cai t r i ft ti plusbl on is
a t o t t l m o ele ha s a i e t

1

f c ' BelAtantc Cor . v Twombl 550 U . 5 570, 1 S. . 1
a e, l l i
'
p .
y,
S. 44,
27 Ct 955, 1 L. 2d 929
67 Ed,

(
2007) Th eo tg neal i lmie i is rviw t t tf eones oft c ai ,''
. e ur e rly s i td n t e e o he dour r r
he ompl nt

S a e v U S De to He lh t Hu S r s,6 3 F 3d 1 ,1 ( 1h Ci.201 ,a
pe k r . . p' f at f man e v . 2
r
371 379 1 t r 0) nd
.

m us a c ptal welpld f t ale tons astue. Erck on v Par ,55l U.S.89,94, 127
t ce
l l- e acual lga i
r
i s . dus
S. .21 1 L. .2d 1 (
Ct 97, 67 Ed
081 2007) I t compl i ' alegatons ar plusbl under t
. f he
ants l i
e a i e
he

al ge f c s t n t coul mus viw t m i t lgh m os f a e t t pl ntf. Am .
le d a t, he he
'
t t e he n he i t
t avor bl o he ai if
De alAs n v Ci a Cor ., 605 F. 1
nt
s' . gn
p
3d 283,1 (11h Ci.201 . TheCour doesnotma
289 t r 0)
t
ke
bi ng f t deer i i i e l tng am oton t dim is butr t re ua e whet t
ndi acual t m natons n vaua i
i o s s,
a he val t s
her he
al gai and c am si t c pl ntm i s fc gi n t f c st ta e pl . H awt ne v
le tons
l i n he om ai
ght ufi e ve he a t ha r ed
hor .

Nà Ak'sme tl c,1 F.d 1 67 1 7 ( 1h Ci.1 9 )
l c u t n, n . 40 3 3 , 3 0 1 t r 9 8 .
The Cour not st tt M oto onl s kst dim ist tr tt r cai sofPl ntf s
t e ha he
i n y ee o s s he l s h ee l m
ai if

ni cli Compli ( c a edei tvecli f r ifpurua t Fe R.Ci P.23.)
ne- am
ant whih r rvai ams or ele s nt o d.
v
1,
.

a do nota es t r m ani sx c am sf r i .
nd es
ddr s he e i ng i l i or elef

Dee nt'frtchalnge ba e u Fl i Re s St ut j 607. 401 s e ng
fnda s is le
s d pon orda vied at e
07 , e ki
dim is oft de i tve c am sduet Pl i ifnotha ng fr ts
s s al he rva i l i
o antf
vi is ubmit a wrte d nd t
ted
it n ema o
Net
TALK' Boar ofDie t sa waii sxt da bef e c
S
d
r cor nd tng i y ys or omm e ng t , i denid.
nci hem s
e

Hit i a l u rFl i lw ,ade a on diecor ors r hol r nee no bem a i
sorc ly nde orda a
m nd
r t s ha e de s d t
de f
i woul be i aci al unr s na e orus e s Orando Or
t
d
mpr tc , ea o bl
els . l
ange Gr e Co. v.Hal 1 Fl .
ov s
e, 07 a

3 4 1 4 S 6 4 6 7 ( 9 2 . kDlma i n tn c say i t dr co s ..wh te b
0 , 4 o. 7 , 7 1 3 ) i e nd s o e e s r f he ie tr
g
eh r y
r as ofhosiei e es orguit pari pa i i t wr
e on
tl nt r t
ly tci ton n he ongsc
ompli of c nno be e ct
aned , a t xpe ed
t i tt e s t or i t y do,i i a r nt t y wilnotbe t pr r pa tes t co
o ns iut ui, , f he
t s ppa e he
l
he ope r i o nduc t
t he
ltga i '' Be ch v.Schilng,309 So. 2d 32,35( a. s. .
ii ton.' l er
li
Fl Dit Ct App.1 ( ?tfng Orando
975)t,7J
?/ '
l

Or geGr sCo. 1 So.a 678) ac or Fis W?lBank(7Tr stb Le t v Fr b7 F
an
ove , 44
t ; c d r t '.
r
t u y vit . ogel 26

.

Supp.1 1 ( D.Fl.1 (a ) d rFlrdalw, t s eexcepton t t sdemand
292, 298 S. a 989)s me. i
unde o i a he ol
i o hi
r quie nti whe e s h a de
e r me s
r uc
mand ' d be i pr c ial unr s na e orus l s ..' l r
woul
m a tc , ea o bl
e e s .'' n e
.
M e c de Ho s I c, 31B. 8 9 8 7 ( n r SD.Fa z ogl ot g Bec e v
r e s me , n . 4
R. 6 , 7 Ba k . . l. o lqu i
n lh r .

Sc li
hilng,

309So. 32,35( a.3dDit CtApp.1 5) SDemand on t diect st brng t acton, a
2d
Fl
s. .
97 ) t
he r or o i he i
.

c dii pr ce ntt s t i e us bl whe edema obvi l woul be u va lng.' Conl e
on ton e de o ui, s xc a e
r
nd
ousy
d
na ii '
e
Cta ' Co.v Ca Con t Co. 221 So. 2d 792,796( a. s. . p.1 (iig 1 Fl che
) J.
/
.
y
s. ,
F1 Dit Ct Ap 969)ctn 3 et r

Cyc. mortonsj6008( 961rv. d.)
Co ai
1 e e ).
The Cou tfndst tPli ifha s fc e l pl t ta dema made t t Boar of
r i ha a ntf s ufi i nty ed ha ny
nd
o he
d

Die t s( t i vi l pumori t ac a t Boad ofDiecor)woul ha be f ie
rcor or he ndi duas
tng o t s he r
r ts
d ve en utl
u e t cr umsa sa lge i t Ve i d Com pli .
nd r he ic tnce le d n he rfe
a nt

Se o dy,te Co r rj cs De e d n s ag me tta te d rv tv cams s o l b
c n l h u t ee t f n a t' r u n h t h e iaie li h ud e
de ed, al i t tTeesr t ca t f il a a quae y r pr e t i t r t of o he
ni
leg ng ha l ta a nno ary nd de t l e es nt he n e ess
t r
smia l st t d s r hol r Und t t t lf c s a cr um sa esaleg i t Ve ii d
i lry iua e ha e de s.
er he o a a t nd ic tnc
l ed n he rfe
Com pl nt s e Rot nbe g v. c M gm t Co., 667 F. 958, ( 1hCi.3 (ii Davi v
ai , e
he r Se .
.
2d
961 1 t r 9824ctng
s.

Come ,l ,61 F. 588,5 94 ( h Ci.1 ) Pli ifha s fcenty alege f t t
d nc. 9 2d
93- 6t r 980), antf s uf i l l d acs o
s tsy t Rot nbe g f c or t ti i apr
a if he he r a t s ha t s operpl ntf f t de i tvecli s
ai if or he rvai a m .
Thidl ba ed upon t wel- e f cs i t Ve is d Co pl i , tke as tue a
r y, s
he
lpl d a t n he rte
m ant a n
r nd
viwed unde Fl i lw ,Pl i if s f inty aleg i ha tquia e sa ng t a s tt
e
r orda a
antf ufk e l l ts t s
tbl t ndi o s er he

ThidDei ai Cli frReiff rd caao yj d me t
r rv t am o le o e lrt r u g n .
ve
The Cour fndst tt al tonswih r pe tt t fr tde i tvecl m f r le f
t
ha he lega i
t es c o he is rvai ai or e if or

ij tver i ,stf ' a paa ap 90 t 1 o t Veis d Compli ,aewel pld,t
nunci elef e olh t rgr hs o 02 f he rte
t
ant r l e he
el m e s a e s tf t a r quie a a w e . The Cour f t rtnds t tt de i tve cli
e nt r e orh, nd e r n ns r
t urhe s
ha he rva i a m

f bra of fducar dut a d i tve cli f de a aor j me , s f t i
br e ch
i i y y, nd ervai am or clr t y udg nt et orh n

pa a a
r gr phs 1 t oug 11 of t Ve ii d Com pl i ,a e bot a s w el pl d a r uie a
03 hr h 6
he r fe
a nt r
h lo
l e nd eq r n
ans er.
W

Fort r s s tf t above Defnda s Moton( 13)i DENI
he ea ons e orh
, e nt' i DE
s
ED.
Da ed t s
t hi

day ofJ y,201
ul
5.

on. a e La r nce K i
Jm s w e
ng
nie St esD it i J
t d at
s rct udge

4

,
.?
.