Luperon v. Rosinella Market, Inc.

Filing 19

ORDER Granting 17 Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 6/12/2015. (jw)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
SO UTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M I IDI SI
AM
VI ON
CASE NO.1 c 20567- G
5- vKm
RI
CARD O LUPERON,a a1 o he ssmia l
nd 1 t r i l ry

stae u d r2 U. C. 21 ()
i td n e 9 S. j 6b ,
u
Pl ntf,
ai if
ROSI
NELLA M ARKET,I C.
N ,
De e nt
f nda .

ORDER G RANTI DEFENDANT' M OTI FOR SUM M ARY JUDGM ENT
NG
S
ON
THI CAUSE come bef e t Cour upon De e n Rosnela M ake , l .s M oton
S
s or he
t
f nda t i l
r t nc '
i

t Su r J d me t( /1 ) fld o M a 2 ,201 .Th r i De e d n se ss mma y
br mmay u g n DE /7 , ie n y 0
5 e en, fn a t e k u r

jlg me to a1o Plitf camsb o g tu d rt FarLa o S a d r sAc (TLS ' a d
td e n n 1 f anifs li r u h n e he i b r tn ad t ( A', n
)
t dimis loft sc e.Be us Pli ifha notr ponde et rt D e e
he s s a hi as
ca e a ntf s
es
d ihe o f ndantsSt t mentof
' ae

M aeilF ds( #1 ) o De e d n ' Mo inf rSu r J d me t a dbe a s t eCo r
tra a DE 6 , r fn a ts to o mmay u g n , n c u e h u t
fnds Def nda ' ar
i
e nts gume s t be a qua el s
nt o
de t y uppore by t r c d, t Cour fnds t t
td
he e or he
ti
ha

De e ntsM oto s ul begr nt d.
f nda '
i n ho d
a e
On Fe uar 1 201 Pl i iftld a one- ountc
br y 2, 5, antf se
c
ompli t a i tdef nda alegi
a n gans
e nt l ng
vi a i oft m i m um wagepr so oft FLSA . De e nta we e t Com pl nton
oltons he ni
ovii ns he
f nda ns r d he
ai
M a c 6,201 de ng t t Pl i if was e e oye by De e nt a t t ext
rh
5, nyi ha antf
ver mpl d
f nda , nd o he ent

Pl ntf wa e pl d by a a flaed e tt , butno De e nt Pli ifwasa co m isone
ai if s m oye
n fii t n iy
t f nda , antf
m si d
e n o who waspa d a we love one a a- l tmest sa e a f de almi m um wage
r plyee
i t l
r - nd- ha f i
he t t nd e r
ni
f e r hou t tPli ifwo ked.Pl i ifsc
or ve y r ha antf r
antf ouns lmoved t wihdr w a c
e
o t a s ouns ofr cor
el e d
or M a c 1 201 whih M oton wasg a e on M a c 1 , 201
t r h 6, 5, c
i
r nt d
rh 8
5.

On Aprl29,201 Deenda fl a M oton f Rul 11 Sa tons agans Pli it
i
5 f nt ied
i or e
nci
i t antfl
whih m oton was r f n'd t Unie St es M ag sr t J
c
i
ee e o
t d at
itae udge Ed n G . Tor e a r mai
wi
r s nd e ns
pe ng.
ndi
L e St
zal andard

Rul 56 oft Fe r RulsofCi lPr dur pr d , i pertnentpart
e
he de al e
vi oce e ovi es n
i
:

( )M o in f rSumma y J me to Pa ta Su
a to o
r udg n r ril mmar Judg nt A pa t
y
me . ry
ma mo e frs mmayj d me t i e tf n e c cam o d fns- orpato
y v o u r u g n , d niyig a h li r e e e - r f
e c cam o d fn e o wh c s mma yj d me ti s u h .Th Co r s al
a h li r ee s - n ih u r u g n s o g t e u t h l
g a ts mmayj d me ti t emo a ts wsta te ei n g n ied s u ea
rn u r u g n f h v n ho h t h r s o e un ip t s
t a ymaeilfc a dt emo a t se tte t j d me ta amatroflw.
o n tra a t n h v n i nild o u g n s te a The
Cour s d sa eon t r cor t r s f gr ntng orde ng t M oton.
t houl tt
he e d he ea ons or a i
nyi he
i
# *#

()Pr e e .
c oc dur s

()
1

S po tngFa t lPo ii n . pa t a srig ta af c c tbeo
up r i
cua sto s A ry se t h t a t mmo
n
r

i ge ney diput d mus s
s nui l s e
t uppor t a s ri n b
t he s e to y:

(
A) Ciigt p riu a p rso maeil i terc r , n ldig d p sto s
tn o a t lr a t f tras n h e o d i cu n e o iin ,
c
doc
umen s elc r c ly sor
t , e toni a l t ed i or a i , a fdavis or de ar tons
nf m ton f
t
cl ai ,

si ains(ncudng t e ma f pur e oft moin onl a si ,
tpulto i l i hos de or poss he to y, dmisons
i e r or a we s oro he m ae il ;
ntrogat y ns r , t r tra s or

(
B)

S o n ta te maeil ctd t d n t e tbih t e a e c o
h wig h t h
tras ie o o o sa l h bsn e r
s

pr s nc ofa ge ne diput ort a a re pary cn
ee e
nui s e, hat n dve s
t nnotpr e a isbl
oduc dm s i e
e de et s
vi nc o uppor t f c
t he a t
## *

()Faii t Pro l Suppor orAddre sa Fac.l apary f l t prpery
e lng o pery
t
s
t f
t ais o o l
s
uppor an a s ri off c orf ist pr ry a e sa he pary' a s ri of
t s e ton a t al o ope l ddr s not r t s s e ton

f c a r q rdb Ru e5 () tec u t y:
a t s e uie y l 6 c,h o r ma
(1 Gi a o t t t pr rys
) ve n pporuniy o ope l uppor ora es t fc;
t ddr s he a t
( Consde t fc undiput f t pupos soft moton;
2)
i r he a t s ed or he r e he i
( )Grn s mmayj g n i t e moi n a d s p o t maeil- i ldng
3 a t u r ud me t f h to n u p ri
ng tras ncu i
t f t c i r undiputd- s t tt m ova i entted t i;o
he acs onsde ed
s e
how ha he
nt s il o t r

( Is a ot ra opraeor r
4) sue ny he ppr it de.
Fe R. v.P.56.
d. Ci

Rul 5 1 ofLoca Rulsf t Sout r DititofFl i s e
e 6.
l e or he
he n src
orda upplment Fe . R.Ci P.
s d
v.
56 a f l s
s olow '
.

()St e nt ofM at i Facs A M oton f Summay J
a atme
eral t.
i or
r udgme a t
nt nd he
o
pposto t r t s l be a ompa e by a sa e tofm ae ilf t ast
ii n he eo hal cc
ni d
t t men
tra acs o
whi h i i con e d t tt r doe note s a ge ne i s t be ti d or
c t s t nde ha he e s
xit
nui s ue o
re
t r doe e s a ge neis t betid, es tvey. Thesa e e s l
he e s xit nui s ue o re r peci l
tt m nt hal:

( )No e e dtn( 0 pa e i ln t ;
1 t xc e e 1 ) g s n e gh
( )Be s p o td b s e ii r frnc st p e dng , e o iin ,a s r t
2
u p re y p cfc eee e o la i s d p sto s n wes o
ie
nt noga o i s a s i ,a a fda t on tl wih t Cour;a
t re , dmi sons nd fi vis ie t he
t nd

()Co itofspaael numberdpaag a .
3 nss e rt y
e r r phs
St tm e s of m aera f c s s itd i o
ae nt
t il a t ubm te n pposton t a m oton f s
ii o
i or umm a y
r

j d me t s alc re p n wih t e o d r a d wi t e p r g a h n mb rn
u g n h l o r s o d t h r e n t h aa rp u ei g
h
s he e us d by t m ova , but ne not r pa t t xt of t movants
c m
e
he
nt
ed
e t he e
he
'

p r g a s Ad iin l fcs whc t e p ry o po i s mmay j d me t
aa rph . dto a a t ih h a t p sng u r u g n
c e a e m ae i ls l be numbe e and plc a t e oft opposng
ontnds r
t ra hal
rd
a ed t he nd
he
i
pa t ssa e
ry' tt mentofma e i lf t;t m o nts lus t tnum be i s me i
t ra acs he va hal e ha
rng che f
t ea tonalf c sar a e s d i t r pl
hos ddii
a t e ddr s e n he e y.

( )Efe t o Fa l e t Co to e t St tme t o Unds e Fa t. A1
b fc f iur o n r v r a e n f
iputd c s 1
ma e i l f c s s t f t i t movan ' sa e nt tld and s ppore a
t ra a t e orh n he
ts t t me ie
u
td s
r quie a
e r d bove wilbe dee
l
med ad it d unl s co r red by t o
m te
e s ntove t
he pposng
i
pa t ssaeme ,pr de t tt Cour fndst tt m ova ' sa e
ry' t t nt ovi d ha he
t i ha he
nts tt menti
s
s
uppo td by e de i t r c d.
re
vi nce n he e or
S. Fl L. 56. .
D. a. R. 1
Addii l S. Fl L. 7. pr des i pe tne pa t
tonaly, D. a. R. 1 ovi , n ri nt r:

()M e r ndum o La Ea hp ryo p i amo ins als r ea o po i g
c mo a
f w. c a t p osng
to h l e v n p sn
me rn u o lw n ltrt a fu te ( 4 d y atr sr ie o t
mo a d m f a o ae h n o re n 1 ) a s fe e vc f he
moton.Faiur t do s m a be de e s fce c e f gr i t
i
l e o
o y
em d ufi int aus or antng he
m oton by def ul ....A l m a e i l i s
i
a t
1 t ra s n uppor of a m o i , r pons or
t ny t on es
e,
r pl i l ng a fda t a de a ai ,s l bes r e wih t flng.
e y,ncudi fi vis nd clr tons ha l e v d t he ii

S, Fl L. 7. (mphassadde .
D. a. R. 1 e
i
d)

D i c s on
s us i

Gi n Pl ntf sf iur t r po et rt Def ndan ' St tm e ofM a e i lFac sor
ve ai if a l e o es nd ihe o
e
ts ae nt
t ra
t

De e ntsM oto f rSumm a y J m e ,a hi f iur t compl wih Fe R.Ci P.56,
f nda '
in o
r udg nt nd s a l e o
y t d.
v.
S. Fl L. 56. a S. .Fl L. 7. a ahe a r viw ofDe e nts f c s whih t
D. a. R. 1 nd D a. R. 1, nd
r e e
f nda ' a t, c he
t r i d fnds t be s
mde sgne i
o
uppore by t e denc t under i d c i s Def nda '
td
he vi e, he
sgne onsder
e nts

r t ra f ct undiput d.M o eo ,t unde sgne fnds pe s i a adopt Def nda '
na e il a s
s e
r ver he
ri d i
r uasve nd
s
e nts
lga a gu e s i s
e l r m nt n uppor of is M o i f Sum mar J
t t
ton or
y udgment whi h sa unr bute by
, c t nd
e td
Pl i if
antf.
C onc us on
l i

The e or ,i i he eby ORDERED,ADJUDGED,and DECREED t tDe e ntsM oton f
rf e t s r
ha f nda '
i or

Su r J d me t( # 7 , ea dt s meh rbyi GRANTED. n ls
mma y u g n DE 1 ) b n he a ee s
Fia ummayj d me t
r ug n
s l be ENTERED a ns Pl ntf a i fvo ofDe e ntast t e iey ofPl n ifs
hal
gai t ai if nd n a r
f nda
o he ntr t
aitf
Compl nt
ai .
DONE AND ORDERED i Cha be s a t J mes La e e Ki Fede a J tc
n
m r t he a
m nc
ng
r l usi e
Buidi a Unie Stt sCourhous M im i Fl i , hi 1 h da ofJ ,2015.
l ng nd t d a e
t e, n , orda t s 2t y une

AM ES LA W R EN C E K I G
N
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STR I J
CT U E
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI O F FLO D A
CT
f>
c:

H on.Edw i G . or e
n T rs
A l C ounselof Record
l

Ri a do Lupe on
cr
r
2690 SW 24t Te r e
h rac
Apt 1
.
M imi FL 331
a ,
45