Richardson v. United States of America

Filing 36

ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO VACATE declines to adopt 14 Report and Recommendations. Signed by Senior Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 5/10/2017. (lan)

U N I D STA TES DI RI T C O U RT
TE
ST C
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA

CASE NO.1 23827- V- TZ/ k
5CI SE1 TUlNOFF
DARRYL RI
CHARDSON ,
Pe ii r
ttone ,
V.

UN I
TED STA TES OF A M ERI ,
CA
Re ponde .
s
nt
/
O R D ER G M N TI G M O TI N TO VA C A TE
N
O

THI M ATTER i beor t Cour onaRe r a Re omme ton( 1 (t
S
s f e he
t
po t nd c
ndai DE 41 t
Repor' ,
t'
)

a d e sn Dar lRih r o sM oint Va aeS n e c pu s n t 2 U. C. 2 5 ( 1.
d r sig ry c ads n' to o c t e tn e rua t o 8 S. j 2 5 DE 1
Ri r on r que t t thi c i i hi t y be r c c a e i lghtofa pr ors a e s nt nc t
cha ds e s s ha s rm nal sor
e al ul t d n i
i t t e e e hat

h ssn eb e v c td Th Re o t i st a t eCo r lc s u idcin t c nsd rteMo in.
a ic e n a ae . e p r fnd h t h u ta k j rs ito o o i e h to
The Re ta s r om m e t tt M oton be di m i s d as s ce s ve a a tm e ba r d.
por l o ec
nds ha he
i
s se
uc s i nd s i - r e

Ha igrv e dd n v teRe o tRih r o sObe to ( 1 jt eGo en n '
vn e iwe e o o h p r, c ads n' j cins DE 5 ,h v r me ts
Re p n e( 1 1t era dto a b ifn s( 2 & 3 1 o a ag me t a dterc r t
s o s DE 8 ,h i d iin l rei g DES 8 3 , rl r u n , n h e od,he
Cou tde i t adoptt Re ta c udest tRiha ds i e il t a r s ntncng.
r clnes o
he por nd oncl
ha c r on s ntted o e e e i
Ac di y, he s i n i g a ed.
cor ngl t doto s r nt

On J nua y 30,2006,Riha ds wa c ced ofc pii t diti efveormor
a r
c r on s onvi t
ons rng o srbut i
e

kiogrmsofc i .g eNo.04- 20705- TZ.ThePrs ntnc l si tonRe t
l a
ocane cas
CRSE1 1
e e e e nve tgai
por
(% ' a sgne hi aTot Ofens Leve of40andaCrmi lHit yCae yIIba e on
tPSl' s i d m
)
al f e
l
i na sor tgor I s d

f u ci n l itr p ns - ep i t o a1 93j d me tn ta is e o ep n fra 1 9
o r rmia hso y oit- on o n f r 9 u g n o t su ; n oit o 9 5
Fulon Count St t Cour c
t
y ae
t onvi ton a s nt nce f t t and t o poi s f c m itng t
c i nd e e
or hef ;
w
nt or om ti he

fde a ofe ewhieonpr ton fom t 1 c cto ( 8a 2.
e r l fns l
obai r he 995 onvi in. DE t 1

Rih r s n o jde t tePS , li ngt r wa i u tee te i e c t ie tf hm a t e
e ad o be d o h I cami hee s ns fi in v d n e o d n iy i s h
d fn a ti t o ep irc s s g 8 3. Hewi r w hi o j cinho v ra trPr b to
ee d n n h s ro a e .DE - )
t e s b e to we e fe o ain
hd
p o ie fn ep itv rfc to . DE 8a 2. OnAp i 21 2 0 ,heCo r sn e c dRihad o
r vd d i g r rn eiiai n g
t 1
rl , 0 6 t
u t e tn e c r s n
s onvi ton w a a f r e i J y 2008. Unie St e v
ci
s f im d n ul
t 3 m o hs i pr s e . fd a 3. H i c
o 60 nt m ionm nt1 t. t
t d at s .

Rihar on,532F. 1 ( 1hCi.2008) On a alRihads di notr s a is swih
c ds
3d 279 1 t r
.
ppe , c r on d aie ny sue t
hi prorofe e .2
s i f ns s
l J y 2007,Rihar on fl apr s sae ha spe ii i t Fulo Co y Su ror
n ul
c ds ied
o e t t bea tton n he t n unt pe i
Cour, rquesi t hi 1 c ci bevac tdongr
t e tng hat s 995 onviton
ae
oundst tiwasunco eld. ( a e
ha t
uns e 3 c s

No.
HC0061 1 Hi peii wasrt ne unpr s e i De mbe 2007.( 16;DE 17. l
4. s tton
eur d oce s d n ce r
DE -1n
J nuay2008,Rihads wr et t Supei Cour as ngwhyhi peii wa rt ned.(
a r
c r on ot o he
ror
t ki
s tton s eur
DE

181 Hecamsh n ve rc ie a a we . c ads nt nfldas c n h be sp tto i
-.
li e e r e ev d n ns r Rih r o he se e o d a a eiin n
teS p ro Co r i Au u t2 0 g s No.1 0 9 )
h u eir u tn g s 0 8.ca e 1C0 6 2.
W hiehi saepeii waspendi Rihads fldaj2255peii i Augus 2009,
l s tt tton
ng, c r on ie
tton n
t
cai ngt thi 1 convi i n wasunco el and s ul notha bee i l
l mi ha s 995
cto
uns ed
ho d
ve n ncuded i hi
n s

ci na hit y.( s No.09- 22349- TZ. MagitaeJ
rmi l sor Ca e
CVSEl j
srt udgeGoodma is daRe t
n sue
por
a Re om me ton,
nd c
nda i conc udi t tRiha ds wa pr e alyba r d fo a tc ng hi
l ng ha c r on s oc dur l re r m ta ki
s

saec n ito f rfiu et riet eis ea s n e cn o o a p a.DE 8a 5 7) ThsCo r
tt o vcin o alr o as h su t e tn i g r n p e l g
t -. i ut
a t d t Re ta de e t peii i Se embe 201 TheEl nt Cic tafi d i
dop e he por nd nid he tton n pt
r 2.
eve h r ui fnne n

Ap i 2 4.g 8a 7 81
rl 01 DE t - .
lI Nove be 201 , Rihar on' Tot Ofens Le wasr duce t 38a hi s nt ewasr duc t 292
n
m r 5 c ds s al f e vel
e do
nd s e enc
e ed o

mo tsp ru n t Ame me t7 2t teUntdSae S ne cn Gud l s ( s No 0 - 2 7 , 2 .
nh us a t o nd n 8 o h ie tts e tn ig iei . Ca e . 4 CR-0 05 DE 61)
ne
2I J y 201 , Ri r on c ace t U. Pr ton Ofi cli i t thi PSli cc ael sat t thewas
n ul
3 chads ont td he S. oba i
fce, am ng ha s
na ur t y t ed ha
convit oft a s ntnc t 1 m ont 'pr ton.I r lt Rihads wasco ce ofsm pl batr a
ced heû nd e e ed o 2
hs oba i n eaiy, c r on
nvitd i e tey nd
gi n a l mon hs pe
ve z- t us ndeds t ewih adie tvet sayawayfom t vitm.ThePr ton Ofi a te
enenc t
rci o t
r he ci
oba i
fce dmitd
t re r a a e d t tRihar on s d onl haver ei onepoi f t batr convitona s nt e,
hei ror nd gr e ha c ds houl y
ec ved
nt or he te y
ci nd e enc
bu nott t a tona poi sfrc m itngt ofe ewhieonpr ton. owe ,t Pr ton Ofi
t he wo ddii l nt o om ti he fns
l
oba i H
ver he oba i
fce

rfs dt atrhi PS wi o tac u t re .DE 12)
eue o l s I t u o r od r ( -.
e
h
3 srq etopo e dif r pa pei wa d ne i J l 2 07 ( 15. Rih rs nte p i tefl gfei
Hi e u s t rc e n o ma u rs s e id n uy 0 .DE - ) c ad o h n ad h ii e n
n
S pe e 2 07 ( la 5J
e tmb r 0 .DE t .

l J nua y a J y 201 Pe ii rt l d t o addii lf de alha a pe ii whi h w e e
n a r nd ul
4, ttone i e w
tona e r
be s ttons c
r

ds se a s c e sv . ca eNo .1 CV- 0 63M ORENO;l - 2 6 0 S TZ.
imis d s u c s ie g s s 4- 2 0 4 CV- 2 8 - EI 1
Rih r s n' 20 8saep tto wa d ne i M ac 2 4f rlc o s r ie ( 3 - ) I
c ad o s 0 tt ei n s e id n rh 01 o a k f evc .DE 3 3. n
i
Oco e 2 4 Rihad onfldat r saeh b a p tto wi t ea ssa c o c t e.DE 1
t b r 01 , c r s ie hid tt a e s ei n t h sitn e f oms l (
i
h
a 6 71 On Ap i 1 2 5 teS aeCo r o Fut nCo nyv c tdt 1 9 sn e c a d
t -.
rl , 01 ,h tt u t f lo u t a ae he 9 5 e tn e n
a tnn dt ec n ito . ( j9j Rih r s nte tldt eisa tMo in o Oco e 1
f e h o v ci n4 os . . c ad o h n ie h n tn to n t b r 4,
s
201 r quesi t thi f r ls t ncebevac t d i lg ofhi va t sa es nt e.
5, e tng ha s ede a en e
a e n i ht
s caed t t e enc
M a sr t J
gi ta e udge Tu nof i s d hi Re ta Rec m e ton on J
r f s ue s por nd
om nda i
une 1 201
3, 6.

Rih r s n fld Ob e to so J n 2 , 01 a dt eGo e n n fldisRe po eo J l 25
c ad o i
e j cin n u e 7 2 6 n h v r me t ie t s ns n u y ,
2 6 Th Co r h l ah a igo No e e 8 2 6t ds u st eo j cins TheCo r
01 . e u t ed e rn n v mb r , 01 o ic s h b e to .
ut
c i d t he rng untlM a c 7, 7.l t i e i bot pa tesfl d a tona bre i
ontnue he a i
i r h 201 n he ntrm, h ri ie ddii l i fng.
A NA LY SI
S

TheRe tr commendst M oton bedim is f s ve alr as . r t t Re t
por e
he
i
s s ed or e r e ons Fis, he por

c n ld sta tealg ds n e cn er rwo l n trs l i at o eemic rig o j tc '
o cu e h t h le e e tn i g ro ud o e ut n t mplt s ara e f usie'
c
a t ,i notcogniabl unde 28U. C.j2255.Ne ,t Re tfndst t Motoni
nd,hus s
z e
r
S.
xt he por i hathe i s
s c s ve. s l t Re r fnds t tRi r on di nots e t va at hi s a e s nt nce w ih
uc es i La ty, he po t i ha cha ds
d
e k o c e s tt e e
t

s fiin d l e c t r sa th o e y a saueo lmiai n u d rj2 59( ) Rih r o
ufce t ii n e o e tr t e n - e r tt t f i tto s n e 25 ( 4 . c ads n
g

o jcst e c o te ec n lso s
be t o a h f h s o cu i n .
Asat es d ma tr t Gove n e a gue t Ri ha ds i pr dur ly ba r fom
hr hol te , he
r m nt r s hat c r on s oce a l red r
brngi hi cli f f iur t r ie i a t tm eofs nt ncng.The Re tdoe no a es t s
i ng s am or a l e o a s t t he i
e e i
por
s t ddr s hi
i s a t Cour r vi si i t sr ti t nce I ge r l a de e nti ba r d fom r i i
s ue nd he
t e ew t n he s ns a . n ne a , f nda s r e r
a sng

a is ei aj2255peii t twa notr s da s e i oronappea.Unie St e v
n su n
tton ha s aie t entncng
l td ats .
4TheAprl1 201 Or rdi notv at t par ofRihar on' saes ntnc pr hi tnghi fom contc i t
i , 5 de d
a tng he
ac e he t
c ds s tt e e e o bii m r

vci Th t rciewa v c tdi a a n e od rd tdDe e e 1 , 01 .( 282.
itm. a di tv s a ae n n me d d re ae cmb r 4 2 6 DE - )
e
3

Fr d 4 6U. 1 2 1 7( 98 ) f nv UntdSa e , 6 F.d 1 2 ,1 3 - 3( 1h Ci. 0 4 .
a y, 5 S. 5 , 6 1 2 ; yn . i tts 3 5 3 2 5 2 2 3 1 t r 2 0 )
e
TheGo nme c r cty a s t t tRi r on c d ha r ie hi unc
ver nt ore l s ers ha cha ds oul ve as d s ouns l sa e
eed t t
s nt nc durnghi f de als nt nc ngpr e ng. Cusi v.Unie St e ,511U . 485,495e e e i
se r e e i
oc edi See ts
td at s
S.

96( 994)( nnitngadefnda t colaealyatc aproruncouns e saec ci
1
pe ti
e nt o ltr l ta k i
eld tt onviton
durnghi fderlsntncngpr ee ngs.Thus a J eGood nnotd i hi 201 Re t
i s e a e e i oc di )
, s udg
ma e n s 2 por,

Rih r s n i p o e u al b re fo atc i ghssaes ne c o aj2 5peiin.Cae
c ad o s r c d r l a rd r m ta k n i tt e tn e n
y
25 t o ( s
t
No 0 - 2 3 9 DE 6 a 1 (ii gDa il v UntdS ae , 3 U.. 7 , 2( 0 ))
. 9 CV- 2 4 , 2 t 0 ctn n es . ie t ts 5 2 S 3 4 38 2 01 .
Howe Rihar o i no a tcki hi sa es nt nc a
ver c ds n s t ta ng s tt e e e nymor He s ce suly vac t d t t
e. uc s f l
a e ha
s ntncei sa ecour bas o isc tt i lde e t Ri r on i now as ngt Cour t
e e
n tt
t ed n t ons iutona f c . cha ds s
ki he
to
r ope a r duc hi f de als nt e i lg oft va t sae s nt e. The Supr m eCour
e n nd e e s e r e enc n i ht he caed t t e enc
e
t
a t El nt Cic tha r pe t dl r c z t a lt t r ope a f de a s nt nc a t
nd he eve h r ui ve e a e y e ogni ed he biiy o e n e r l e e e fer
ha ng an enha ng s a e s nt e vac t d i s a e c t Cu ts 511 U . a 1 . ani l 5
vi
nci t t e enc
a e n t t our . s i ,
S. t 97,
D e s, 32

U. a 382;Unie St esv.Waler 1 F. 811 81 1 ( 1hCi.1 .Therf e,
S. t
td at
k , 98 3d , 3- 4 1 t r 999)
eor
Ri ha ds s c ai i no ba r
c r on' l m s t r ed.

A. Ri ha ds sne c am i c za e unde 28U . C.k2255.
c r on' w l i s ogni bl
r
S.

Reifu d rj2 5 i r sr e f rs ne e i o e ( )i vilto o t eCo si to , 2
l n e 2 5 s e e v d o e tnc s mp s d 1 n oain f h n tt in ( )
e
u
wih u ac u ts u idcin, 3 i e e so t ema i m a t o ie b lw, r( )l t r s
t o t o r' j rs it ( ) n xc s f h xmu u h rz d y a o 4 % hewie
o
o

s be t oc laea atc '28U.. j2 5 () No c nsi to a a no -u id cina
u j c t o ltr l ta k.
'
SC. 2 5 a . n-o tt in l nd nj rs ito l
u
c a m s m us a l ge 1a f
li
t le ç unda e a def c whi h i r nty r uls i a c pl t m i ca rage of
m nt l e t c nhe e l es t n om e e s r i

j sie'Uni dSttsv Ad o ii 4 2 U. 1 , 8 ( 9 9 .l g n r ler r i g d ln s
u tc . t ae . d nzo, 4 S. 78 1 5 1 7 ) n e ea, ro s n uieie
' e
s nt esi
e enc mpos beow t sa u or maxi
ed l he t t t y
mum a e no c i e tc
r t onsder d tomplt m ic ri ge of
e e s a ra s

j sie'S e eg , s v Un tdS ae , 61Fe Ap x98 , 9 ( 1hCi. 0 ( e yn j
u tc . e , ..Ayu o . ie t ts 3
'
d. p' 8 9 1 1 t r 201 ) d n ig
2 r i ff non- ns iutonalcl i t ta pe ii r s c i i lhi t y poi s wer
255 ele or
co tt i
a m ha
ttone ' r m na s or
nt
e

mic lu ae ) Ra n v Un tdSats 2 2W L 5 6 1 a * - ( D. a Od. , 01 )
s ac ltd ; ie . ie t e , 01
8 91 7 t 2 3 S. Al . 25 2 2
(eusngt a nda advior gui i sntnc afe aprorco ci wasva td)
rf i o me n s y delne e e e tr i nviton
cae .

TheRe o t o sno a d e sal o rc mpo e t ofj22 5 $. n ta , ingS n e v
p rd e t d rs 1fu o n ns
5 ( l se d ct pe c r .
i
Unie St e , 7 ?F.d 1 3 1 40( 1hCi. 01 )5t eRe tsmpl f us son t f t
t d ats 7 3 1 2, 1 1 t r 2 4 , h por i y oc e
he ourh
compone a s ma iy c l st tRihar on' advior gui i s nt nc i no
nt nd um rl oncude ha c ds s
s y- delne e e e s t

d t ewies be tt c l tr l ta k' e a s i wa i s db lw t esauo yma i m.
% h r s u j c o ol ea atc 'b c u e t s mpo e eo h tt tr xmu
o
a
g 1 a 1 - 3) Ho ve, pe c ri ardh ni g.Uni eS nc ra dt eo h rc s st e
DE 4 t 2 1 . we rS n e s e e n
lk pe e n h t e a e h
G o r ntc t s Ri ha ds scl i i co tt i
ve mne ie , c r on' a m s ns iutonali na ur a t tdi tncton m a t r .Se
n t e; nd ha s i i
te s e

Addonii 442U. a 1 (k'ec tt i lrg t t asitnc ofc e i isl vi ae
zo,
S. t 87 tf onsiutona iht o he ssa e ouns l s tef oltd
-h

whe u c u s ldc n ito ss r ea teba i fre h n e p n s me t' ( ingBu getv
n n o n ee o v ci n e v s h ss o n a c d u ih n -) ct
' i
r t.
Te ,389U. 1 11 ( 967:.Be us Rihads cli hi s ntnc wasi e i
xas
S. 09, 5 1
ca e c r on ams s e e e
mpos d n

vi atonoft Consiuton, scai i cog za eunde j2255.SeeMatov Unie St e ,
ol i
he
tt i hi l m s ni bl
r
e . td ats
398F. 1 1 ( tCi.2005)(e ni af r s ntnc t twasenha dbya
3d 26, 36 1s r
rope ng edeal e e e ha
nce
n
unc tt i saeguit pl ) Unie St e v favale,1 F. 11 11 ( h Ci.1
onsiutonal tt ly ea ; td ats .
l 75 3d 06, 08 9t r 999)
(a ) Unie St e v Nihol,30F. 35,36( h Ci.1 (a )
sme ; td ats . c s
3d
5t r 994) s me .
B. Pe ii rsM o i i NotSucc s i
ttone ' ton s
e sve.

A defnda i onl pe te t fl asngl j2255peii a s ce svepeii ae
e nt s y nuitd o ie i e
tton nd uc si ttons r

g n rlyds se S e2 U. C. 2 5 4 Va au o ap irc n cinh we e i an w
e eal imis d. e 8 S. j 2 5 1
$. c t r f ro o vito o v r s e
ta t ta ma fr teb ssf ras c ndj2 5 p tto u d rs b e to ( 4 . o n o v
s c' h t y o m h a i o e o
f '
2 5 ei n n e u s cin 94 ) J h s n .
i
Unie St e 5 U. 295,303(
td ats, 44 S.
2005) ft prorconviton i va ae ahe t peii rsj
.I he i
ci s c td r he ttone '
5I S encer, t pettonerwassent ed asacar of enderbas i par on a prorconvi i off ony
n p
he ii
enc
eer f
ed n t
i
cton el

c l a s .Folo ngt Su r meCo tsde ii i Be y v Unie ae , 3U. l ( 008 ,
hid bu e lwi he p e
ur' cson n ga . tdstts 55 S. 37 2 )
whi diqualfed f ony chid abus asa çcrm eofvi ence,'Spencers
ch s ii el
l
e
li
ol
'
oughtt vacat hi enhanced
o
e s
s ence asacar ofende Hedi notcl m a vi aton ofhi consiutonalrght l t t
ent
eer f r.
d
ai
ol i
s
tt i
i s. nsead, he

p tto ra g d ta hi cam wa c g z bl u e j2 5be a e iwa ç h r s s j c t
eiine r ue h t s li s o nia e nd r 25 c us t s û e wie ube t o
ot

c lt alatack. TheEl nt Cic tdiagr hol ng t tan eroneouss enceasa ca eerofender
ola er t '
'
eve h r ui s eed, di ha
r
ent
r
f

i n taf da n a de e tt tr s t i ac eemic rig o j sie S nc r 7 F.da 11 .
s o un me t l fc ha e uls n omplt s a ra e f u tc . pe e , 73 3 t 40
5

2255 peii i decded,as c pe ii bas on t va a e convi i wilnotbedim is
tton s i
e ond tton ed he c t d
cton l
s s ed

a s esi Stwar v Unie St e ,646F. 856,8 ( 1hCi. 1;Bo v Unie St e
s ucc sve. e t . td ats
3d
63 1 t r 20l ) yd . td ats,

75 F. 1 1 - ( 1h Ci. 4) Cii t l
4 3d 298, 30102 1 t r 201 . tng he angua i Johns Stwar andBo t
ge n
on, e t
yd, he
Re tfndst tRi ha ds spe ii n i s e svebe a e i i ba e on hi vac t d s nt e
por i ha c r on' tto s ucc s i
c us t s s d
s a e e enc

rt e t nav c tdc n ito Rihad o ag e o o j dint t h r i norlv n
ah r ha a ae o v ci n. e r s n r u s n b e o ha t ee s ee a t
ditnci bewe ava tdc cin a ava ae s ntnc f pur e ofj22551 Basd
si ton t en cae onvito nd c td e e e or pos s
($. e
on t uni f t i t sc e,t Co ta e wih Ri ha ds
he que ac s n hi as he ur gr es t c r on.
W hiet Cour i Johns St
l he
tn
on, ewar a Bo mader f r ncet ea h de e ntsc ci
t nd yd
e ee
o c f nda ' onvi ton,
isf
t ocusi e ch c ewasnoton t convitonre s buton t ne û ac , na ey, va a e
n a as
he
ci
r e
he w ' t' m l a c t d
f '

pr ee ng,whi pr dedt bassf t s co j2255peii Fo i tnce Boydr eve
oc di
ch ovi he i or he e nd
tton. r nsa ,
ec i d
ae
n nhanc d sntnc unde 21U. C.j85l Se enc enha me sunde j851aebas on
e e e e
r
S.
. nt e nce nt
r
r ed
prorl vitons'21U. C.j851d)1 ($1ft c tdeenni s...t t pes i
i ' ci .
con
'
S.
( ( ) û(1 he our t ne
hathe ron s

s be tt i ra e p nih n byra o o pro c n ito s tec u t hal r c e t i s
u j c o nce s d u s me t e s n f ir o vcin ,h o r s lp o e d o mpo e
s ntnceuponhi a pr dedbyt par.)(
ee
m s ovi
he t' emphassadde .
'
i
d) Boyd' vac tdc ci t
s ae onviton hus
f dt ba i f hi s condj2255.Li wie Stwa twassntnce asac r rofe r
onne he ss or s e
ke s , e r
e e d
aee fnde
unde t U . Se enc ng G ui i s The ca e of e r e nce e i ba e on pror
r he S. nt i
delne .
r er f nde nha m nt s s d
i

k onvito . U. S. j4B11a (% deenda i ac e rofe ri ...( t dee nthas
f cins' S. G.
c
'
.() $ f nt s are fnde f 3) he fnda
A
a la tt pro f l convcto ofeihe ac i ofvi e eora c r l d s t nc
t e s wo i r eony
i i ns
t r rme
olnc
ontole ubsa e

ofe e' (mpha i a
fns .' e
)
ss dded) Stwatsva tdc ci f
. e r' cae onviton onnedt ba i f hi s c j2255.
he ss or s e ond
Bec us t s ba e di note s prort ea hdefnda ' frtj2255,heElve hCic thel
a e he e s s d
xit i o c e nts is
t e nt r ui d
t tt s c pe ii we e nots e s ve.
ha he e ond ttons r
ucc s i

6

I t sc e Ri ha ds r e ve a to lc i na hit y poi sunde U .S. G. 4 ..
n hi as , c r on ec i d ddii na rmi l sor
nt
r
S. j AII
e ' or de i
c ai 6
Th ts ci nc n ie s1p i rsent nces'f Gui lnecalultons. See U S. G. 4 .()()
a e to o sd r $ro
S. j A11a-c
.

(f 3poi sf ea hpro s ntnc ofi io nte ee ngoneyea a onemont ...
i
Add
nt or c ir e e e mprs nme xc di
r nd
h.
Add 1poi f e hprtrs nt enotcount i ()o ( ,u t at alof4poi sf t s
nt or ac / e enc
p
ed n a r b) p o ot
nt or hi
s e ton.)(mphassadde .Rihads sva ae s ntncet f mst bai f rhi mos
ubsci ' e
'
i
d) c r on' c td e e hus or he ss o s t
rc ntMoton.Be us t tbassdi notaieuntlafe Ri r on' frtj2255,hi c rnt
ee
i
ca e ha i d
rs i tr chads s is
s ure
M o i i nots e s ve.
ton s
ucc s i

C. Ri ha ds sPetton i Ti ey Be us HeDii nty Va t Hi St t Se enc
c r on' ii s m l ca e
lge l caed s ae nt e.

Rih r s no j cst t eRe o tsfn i r g r i hi dlg n e Un e J h s n a
c ad o be t o h p r' i dng e adng s iie c . d r o n o ,
p t in rp o e d n un e j2 5 ( 4 mu th v s u h v c t ra t saelv l t
ei o e r c e i g d r 2 5 9( ) s a e o g t a au the tt-e e wih
t
dii nce 544 U. a 31 Dii ncei a que ton off c t tc i r t i vi l
lge .
S. t 0. lge
s
si
a t ha onsde s he ndi dua

crumsa esofc i me .Ar v Unie St e 291F. 708,71 ( 1hCi.2002) s e
ic tnc
onfne nt on . td ats,
3d
2 1t r
;e

aloRie sv Unie St e ,41 F. 1 9,1 23( 1hCi.2005)( di t taf yea
s v r . td ats 6 3d 31 322- 1 t r
hol ng ha our r

d lyi fl gasaeh b a peiinwi o ta y atmpt oepl i t er a o s o tedea i
ea n ii tt a e s t o t u n te t x an h e s n f r h ly s
n
t
h
n duedii nc (mpha i a d) W hiepr s r pr e ai a pr e a ino a edo
ot
lge e) e
ss dde . l o e e esntton nd oc dur l g r nc
note us a lc ofdii nc t lge c bes
xc e a k
lge e,l i nce an
di
hown bypr
ompta ton on t pa toft
ci
he r he
pe ii rass a he i i a pos ton t r lze t the ha a i e es i c le ng t pr o
ttone
oon s s n
ii o ea i ha
s n nt r t n ha l ngi he i r

c ci 'Johns 544 U. at308. or ove ,o ea pe ii rdii nty i ta e
onvi ton.
'
on,
S.
M e r nc
ttone lge l niit s
pr e ngsi sa ec t a dely i t epr e ngsnotati a et hi wilnott
oc edi n tt our, ny a n hos oce di
trbut bl o m l
hwar
t
hi a lt t ob a n r le . d. t31 n.
s biiy o t i e if 1 a 0 8.
6TheGovenm e ague , b s do UntdSae v Ac naRe a 6 7F.d1 2 1 4-5( 1hCi. 01 )ta
r nt r s ae n ie tts . u - yn , 7 3 28 28 8 1 t r2 2,h t
Rihar on' s r vi c c i woul silc
c ds s u vi ng onviton
d tl ountt r hi crmi lhit y c c ai Acu ya- yna sa
owa ds s i na sor alulton. n Re
tnds

fr utteo p ie I Ac n - yn ,h p tto e rc i dci n l soyp it b sdo ap irmide a o
o j s h p ost. n u aRe a te eiin r e eve rmia hitr ons ae n ro s me n r

c ci andam onea y fne.Thepeii cai e ondie ta alt thi prorc c i wasunc el
onviton
tr i
ttoner l m d
r c ppe ha s i onviton
ouns ed.
Ac di t t El ent Cicui howe ,eve i t c cton wasuncouns l t monetr tnewoudr mai
cor ng o he ev h r t
ver n f he onvi i
eed,he
ay i
l e n
i plc a t c i i hit y c c a i woul r m ai unc nge 1 a 1
n a e nd he rm nal sor alulton
d e n ha d. d. t 283.The de ii t r f e
cson he e or
e pha iest i poranc ofprors ntnce whencac a i c i i hit ypoi s
m sz he m t e
i e e s
lultng rm nal sor
nt.

Ba e on Riha ds se f t,whih ar des rbe i mor deai i Se on Ia
sd
c r on' fors
c e ci d n
e t l n di
bove,t
he
Coul fndst tRi r on a t d dii nty.Ri ha ds wa s nt ed i f r lc ton Aprl
' i ha cha ds c e lge l
t
c r on s e enc n ede a our
i
2l 2006.Tha s m eda heas d hi br he ,Da on Ri r on t hel l a er co dsfom hi
,
ta
y,
ke s ot r m
cha ds o p oc t e r r
s

saec s . mo p o d dRih r o t e erc r si F b u r 2 07 ( 1 - . I J l 2 0 ,
tt a e Da n r vie c ads n h s e o d n e r ay 0 . DE 5 1) n uy 0 7
whiehi diec a a w a pendi Riha ds fld hi frtsa eha spe ii r quesi hi
l s r t ppe l s
ng, c r on ie s is t t bea tton, e tng s
1 saeco c i beva a e Afe t Supe i Cour r t nedhi pe ii unpr es e
995 tt nviton
c t d. tr he
ror
t eur
s tton
oc s d,
Ri ha ds fl a s c
c r on ied e ond s a e ha aspe ii i Augus 2008.I M a 2011, s a notc ofa
t t be
tton n
t
n y
he ent
ie

c ngeofa es t t Clr oft Supei Cour.( 1 3. Thec er mai dopenuntl
ha
ddr s o he ek he
ror
t DE 5- 1
as e ne
i
M a c 201 whe i wa de e f l k ofs r i e.l Oc obe 201 Ri har on fl at r
rh 4
n t s ni d or ac
e v c n t r 4, c ds ied hid
sa eha speii wih t a ssa eofc ms l The Supe i Cour g ant t petton a
tt bea tton t he s it nc
ot e .
ror
t r ed he ii nd
vac t Riha ds ssa es nt nc i Aprl2015.
aed c r on' t t e e e n
i
Eve t
n hought sae c ts ton t s cond pe ii f ove fveyea s Riha ds a al
he t t our a
he e
tton or r i
r , c r on t 1

tme b le e t a t ec s wa u d ra tvec n ieai n ( 1a 61 Rih r s nwa n t
i s eiv d h t h a e s n e ci o sd r to . DE t . c ad o s o
a r oft s r i ofpr s eroruntlt c tdim is d t c e i 201
wa e he e vce
oce s r
i he our s s e he as n 4.
M or ove ,Ri ha ds di no s ti e i t e f ve ye s W hie hi sa e habe w a pe ng,
e r c r on d t i dl n hos i
ar .
l s tt
as s ndi
Ri ha ds t l d t e f r lha spettons i A ugus 2009, a r 201 a J y 201 I
c r on i e hr e ede a bea
ii n
t
J nua y
4 nd ul
4. n
t 2009 pe ii Ri r on a t m pt d t a t c hi unc
he
tton, cha ds te e o ta k s ouns l d s a e s nt nc How e ,a t
e e t t e e e.
ver fer
t ee ye r ofltga i t s Cour f
hr
a s ii ton, hi
t ound t tRi ha ds w asba r d f om r i i t
ha c r on
re r
a s ng he
unc
ouns e s nt nc W hie t 2009 pe ii w a on a al Ri ha ds t l t J nuar 201
el d e e e.
l he
tton s
ppe , c r on i ed he a
y 4

peii whih wasdim is a s es i Ri ha ds alo wr et t U . Pr ton Ofi e,
tton, c
s s ed s ucc sve. c r on s ot o he S. oba i
fc
c a m i t thi PSIw as i cc a e Pr ba i a it d t t e r r butr f ed t a e t
l i ng ha s
na ur t . o ton dm te o he r o ,
e us o m nd he

PSIwihoutacour or r Thi pr e Rihads i J y201 t fl at r j2255,i whih
t
t de . s omptd c r on n ul 4 o ie hid
n c

8

hecl me t thi PSlwasi cc a ea a t he Pr ton' l te .Howe r t pe ii wa
ai d ha s
na ur t nd tac d oba i s et r
ve , he tton s
as dimis d a s c sve.
lo s s e s uc es i
Gi n Riha ds sc i
ve c r on' ontnuouse f t a hi r a ona eexplnato f t deaysi t
fors nd s e s bl
a i n or he l n he
pr es ,t Co tfndst tRi ha ds a t dii nty. e Gol
oc s he ur i ha c r on c ed lge l Se
dman v.Wi 565 F.
nn,
supp.
zd

20 220- ( M as.2008 (% dma spr
0, 21 D. s
) fGol n' ompta co i ngef t,a hi ex a tonf
nd ntnui fors nd s plnai or
s oft pa s oftme,ma hi deay i obt ni va a urofhi s ae c c i n m or
ome he s age i
kes s l n ai ng c t
s t t onvito
e

te s n bl'ha ted lyc n ie e i J h s n.) c J h s n 5 4U.. t31 Cvoms nh s
ra o a e t n h ea o sd r d n o n o t;f o n o , 4 S a 1 l o a
'
o fr dn e pa to fr( i tr ey a ) ly, y n o s r i gt a h wa a tn /s a d
fee o x lnai n o hs h e - e r dea be o d b e vn h t e s ci grr e n
l ke t s siato t unde sandt pr dur .) Ac or ngl i i
ac d he ophitc in o
rt he oce es'. c di y,t s
'
O RD ERED THA T

1 Th Co r DECLI TO ADOPT teRe o t n Re o n ain ( 1 .
) e ut
NES
h p r a d c mme d to DE 41
2 Peiin rsObe to st teRe o t( 1 1aeSUS NED.
) t o e ' j cin o h p r DE 5 r
t
TAI
3) Peii ' M otont Va ae,Se Asde orCore Se e purua t Til 28U. C.
ttoners i o c t t i ,
rct ntnce s nt o te
S.

j2255 ( 1 i GRANTED.
DE 1 s
4) TheU. Pr to Ofi s l a ndt Pr e enc l tgaton Re ti lgh of
S. obain fce hal me he es nt e nvesi i
por n i t
Peii r sva t 1 sa es nt e.
ttone ' caed 995 t t e enc
A r e e ng i SCH EDULED f Tues
es nt nci s
or
day,June6,2017,at1 00 a. .i Courr
0: m n
toom

DONEadORDE D i MimiFoiati/& dyo Ma , 0 7
n
RE n a , lrd ,hs
a f y 2 1.
*
1

<

PATRI A A .S Z
CI
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D G E
CT U

c
c:

A1 c
1 ouns lofr c d
e
e or
Hon. ila C.Tur f
W li m
nof