R&Q Insurance (Malta) Limited et al v. Piper Aircraft Corporation et al

Filing 156

ORDER Granting 80 Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 8/3/2017. (jw)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI C OURT
CT
SO UTH ERN DI
STR I O F FLO RI
CT
DA

CA SE NO . 1 2479 C1 Kl TORRES
52- V- NG/
W TACT I
NSURAN CE COM PAN Y?f mery
or l
A XA PA CI C I SURAN CE COM PAN Y
FI N

a d R&Q I
n
NSURANCE ( ALTA)LTD.a
M
,s
Subr e ofKEYSTONE A 1 SERVI LTD .
oge
R
CE
a KEVI HEPP,
nd
N
Pl ntfs
ai if ,
VS.

THE PI
PER AI
RCRAFT CORPO RATI
ON
I
RREVOCABLE TRUST,
Def nda .
e nt
/
ORDER GR ANTI DEFENDANT' M OTI FO R JUD G M ENT ON TH E
NG
S
ON
PLEADI S
NG

TH I CAUSE c esbef et Cour upon M agita e J
S
om
or he
t
sr t udgeEdw i G.Tores
n
r '

J n 2 201 Re r a dRe o n to (i ' ( 1 ) whihr c mme ds
u e 9, 7, po t n c mme dain (
R&R' DE 51, c e o n
)
g a tn Dee d ntsM o in f rJ g n o t Pla i s( 8 ) TheCo r ha
r n ig f n a ' to o ud me t n he e dng DE 0 .
ut s

a dton l c nsd r d Plitf Ob e to s( 1 4 , n De e a ' Re yt r t (
d ii al o i e e an ips j c in DE 5 ) a d fnd nts pl heeo DEC
y
:

15.
5)
A sba ound, hi i aconti i diput a ii fom pa e st tt Pl ntf
ckgr
t ss
rbuton s e rsng r
ym nt ha he ai if
i ur r m a t s tl s ver pr vi l w s t . si t tc rbuton s w a tl d
ns e s de o ete e al e ous a uis Thi nsan ont i i uh s l e
'

;

pur uantt t Pi rAic af Cor aton l r voca eTr tA gr e ent whih r quie t t
s
o he pe r r t por i r e
bl us
e m , c e r s ha
a c am as ered agai tPi rA ic a tbeas ered a i tt Tr ti t Unied St t s
ny l i s t
ns pe r r f
s t gans he us n he t
ae

DititCou tf t Sout n Di ti tofFl i l
src
r or he
her src
orda.
)

The i i ntgi ng r s t t unde l ng s t occ r d on N ovembe 6,2000,whep
nc de vi ie o he
ryi uis ur e
r
i
!
aPi Aic af pl c a hed i M a t ,Ca
per r r t ane r s
n nioba nada.Pur ua t a i ur
s nt o n ns ancepolcy,t
i he

Plitf i u e sp i d ma st s tl t pa s n r 'camsf rij r a d t r i u s
an if ns r r a d a ge o ete he s e ges li o n u y n o emb re
t owne oft plne f l soft aicr t On Dec m be 31 2015,Pl i if br
he
r he a or os
he r af.
e r ,
a ntf s oughtt ;
he
i t nts ts ki cont i i f om t Def nda Tr t a l gi t Pi rA icr ts
nsa ui ee ng
rbuton r he
e nt us, le ng hat pe r af'
f t desgn oft pl wasuli at y wha 1 t t c a h.
auly i
he ane
tm el
t ed o he r s
On M ar h 1 2017,Def nda m oved f J
c 5,
e nt
or udgmenton t Pl di ,a gui t t
he ea ngs r ng ha

t sa ueo r p eo ti d i t Ge e a Avito Re i lz to Ac (û
he tt t f e os u lne n he n r l ain vt iain t i
a
GARA'
'
)
p e ld dPli if fom b i i t eisa ts tDE 8 Pli tf fl disRe p ns (
r cu e antfs r rngng h n tn ui. 0. an if ie t s o e DE
95 o M a c 28 2 1 , n De e a tsRe y ( 9 f lo do Ap i 3, 01 .
) n rh , 0 7 a d fnd n ' pl DE 5) o lwe n rl 2 7 The
;
m a t wasr e r t J
ter
ef red o udge Tor esf a R& R pur uantt t Cour ' Or ofRef r a f
r or n
s
o he
ts der
e r l or

a1 era Pr c e i s( 1 ) Afe d ec nsdea in, ud eTo r suli t l
1 Prtil o e dng DE 01. tr u o i rto J g re tmaey
r comm e t tt under i d gr ntD e enda ' M oton.
e
nds ha he
sgne a
f
nts
i

GARA p o i e t tac vla to f rpe s na ij r de t o pr pe t d ma
r v d s ha i i cin o ro l n u y, ah, r o ry a ge
a i i f om a a i nti vi agener a a i a r r f ca
rsng r
n cc de nvol ng
al vi ton ic a t nnotbe br
oughti t
f he

a cd n o c re a treg te y a sfo : 1 t ed t o dr c dei r o t ear r f
c ie t c u rd fe i h e n e r r m ( ) h a e f ie t lvey f h ic a t
fo t ema ufcu e t isfrtp r h s r o ( )daeoffrtdeie y o t earr f t a
r m h n a t r r o t is u c a e ; r 2 t is lv r f h ic a t o
pe s e ged i t busne soft s li o lasng ofaic afs
r on nga
n he i s
he e lng r e i
r r t.
H e e t pl ne wasm a a ur d i 1
r , he a
nuf ct e n 978,a t c as di notocc untlt nt (
nd he r h d
ur i we y- i

IT'ePi Aicaf Comor tonlr voc eTr twasc e t d f l ngt ba r pty ofPi Aic a i 1 .
h per r r t
ai r e abl us
r a e olowi he nk u c
per rr h n 991

2

t yea slt ron Nove ber6,2000. a y,Pl ntf sdo notdiput t ef c s. nsea ,
wo r a e
m
Not bl ai if
s e hes a t I t d,
Pl ntfsi itt tGARA s d nota y he ebe us t s twoul have be fl d i '
ai if nss ha
houl
ppl r ca e he ui
d
en ie n
Ca
nada we ei no f t f um s ec i clusei t Tr tAgr em e . n t R&R,J
r t t or he or
el ton a
n he us
e nt I he
udgt

To r srj csti a g me t r a o ig t tPli if ha ef ie t ma easr ng s wi
re ee t h s r u n , e s nn ha antfs v ald o k to ho ng
1

ta e f r e n o t f r m s lcin ca ei u r a o a e u j t o wa pr c r db
h t n o c me t f he o u ee to lus s n e s n bl, n us, r s o u e y
wa offa J
y r ud. udge Tor esf t rc i e t tPl ntfsha of e ed no f c uals
r urhe onsder d ha ai if ve f r
a t uppor
t

f t c e i t tt f um s ec i clus s d nota y,buti t ad m e el r l op
or he ont nton ha he or el ton a e houl
ppl
ns e
r y ey 7
t c l ol s a e e t tt y ar be ng te e inequia y.z
he oncus ' t t m nt ha he e i r at d s
y
i
t bl '
'
J
udgeTor e addii ly r as t t e n i Ca di l w w e e t gove n t s
rs
tona l e ons ha , ve f na an a
r o
r hi
ma t ,GAlA ' sa ut ofr pos woul sila y undert Supr ac Cl us J
ter
t S tt e e e
d tl ppl
he
em y a e. udge

Tor e r c st sc l i n ahera t ough a yss ofGAI Ssat or l nguage,as
r s ea he hi onc us o
hor
nal i
tA' t ut y a

wela cons de a i ofs a c esfom ot rcourst tha a i d GARA t l ws t ,
l s
i r ton ever l as r
he
t ha ve pple
o a uis
a i i fom ac de swhi oc ured on f ei s l Fi l J
rsng r
ci nt
ch c r
or gn oi. naly, udge Toresnot t
r
es hat
Pl ntf sown pl adi i c t t tShe a lged neglgentconductas ere by Pl ntf
ai if
e ngs ndi a e ha d le
t
i
s td
ai if
t desgn,m anuf t e and diti i oft ar af- i am a t gover d by t 1w ofj
he i
ac ur ,
srbuton he icr t s
ter
ne
he a
t Unie St t , gar e s ofwhe et ac uala i ntt pl ce. DE 151a 14.
he t d a es re dls
r he t
ccde ook a '
'
t
Acc di y,J
or ngl udge Toresr om m e t tt Cour a y GARA' sa ut ofr pos a
r ec
nds ha he
t ppl
S t t e e e nd
gr ntDe e
a
f ndantsM oton f J
'
i or udgme on t Pl di .
nt he ea ngs

l t ero j cinsb f r t Co r, antfsr a g et a t 1w o M a t ba
n h i b e to e o e he u tPli if e r u h t he a f nio ,
Cana s d a y.Pl ntfsf t a gue t tJ
da houl ppl ai if urher r
ha udge Tor esered by r i on t M otop
r
r
ulng
he
i
2J geToresalo a l poi soutt we ei notfrt Tr t Pl ntfsc d nothavebr tt i tnts ti
ud
r s pty nt
hat r t
o he us ai if oul
ough he nsa ui n
t frtplc
he is a e.

:

f J
or udgm e on t Pl di prort r i on Pl ntf s M oton t Appl M a t
nt he ea ngs i o ulng
ai if '
i o
y nioban l w p
a
Pl i if addii l t ke is w ih J
antfs
tonaly a s ue t udge Tor e anal i oft Supr m ac Cl us ,
r s' ys s he
e y a e
a gui t tt Supr m ac Cl e doesnota y bec e Canada i nota sa e.
r ng ha he
e y aus
ppl
aus
s
tt
'

Th Co r ha p ror d a#en v r viw o t eR&R a d Plitfs o j ci n ,i
e u t s e f me
o o e e fh
n an if ' b e to s n
è

a ton t isr ew oft underyi M oton,a t Res
ddii o t evi
he
l ng
i nd he pons a Re y t et A fer y
e nd pl her o. t
'

ca ef consde aton, heCour fndst tJ
r ul
i r i t
t i ha udge Tor e R&R ac at y sat st 1w oft
r s'
cur el t e he a
he
ca e The R& R cl ry pr de a pl a l i t s
s.
ea l ovi s m e nayss o uppor t applca i ofGARA i t s C
t he
i ton
n hi
ï

i t nc i udi a l ls ofs mia ca esw he eGARA wasa i t l ws t arsng
nsa e, ncl ng ong it i lr s
r
ppled o a uis ii
fom ac dent t toc r d i f ei c res TheR&R f t s tf t s
r
ci s ha cur e n or gn ounti .
urher e orh ound,
a tr tver as f r ac ng t sco uson.l
le na i e ons or e hi hi ncl i ndeed,Pl i if havef l t r s a
antfs
aied o aie ny
c e nst tha nota r dy bee exhaus i y a es e by t R& R. c di y, he
onc r ha ve
lea
n
tvel ddr s d
he
A cor ngl t
Cour fndst tDef nda ' M oton f rJ
t i ha
e nt s
i o udgmenton t Pl adi s
he e ngs houl be gr nt
d
a ed.
l i t r or O RDERED,ADJUDG ED ,a DECREED t t
t s he ef e
nd
ha :

, , nd he
1 J dg To r s J e 2 ,201 Re o ta d Re o nd to ( 151) be a t
. u e re ' un 9
7 p r n c mme ai n DE
s
ame i , r by AFFI ED a AD OPTED asa Or oft sCour .
s he e
RM
nd
n der hi
t

2 De e d ntsM o in f rJ d n o t e Pla n ( 8 )be a t s mei,
. f n a ' to o u gme t n h e digs DE 0 , nd he a s
he eby G M NTED.
r

3. By s pa a e or r t Cour s l e er Fi lJ
e r t de , he
t ha l nt na udgm e on beha fofD e e
nt
l
f nde t
and agai tPl ntfs
ns ai if ,

4

DONE and O RDERED i Cha be s a t J m es La e e K i Fe alJ tde
n
m r t he a
wr nc
ng der us i
k

Buidi a Unied St e Courhous M i m i Fl i t s3r day ofAugus,201
l ng nd
t
at s
t e, a , orda, hi d
t
7.

l
1
;

ù

Ps u,x
u

<

J M ES LA W REN CE K I G
N
I
TED STATES DI
STY CT
GE
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF F ORI
CT
DA

cc:

M agit at Judge Edw i G .Torr s
sr e
n
e
AI Couns lofRecord
l
e