Martel v. United States Of America

Filing 23

ORDER OVERRULING OBJECTIONS re 22 Objections to Report and Recommendations filed by Manuel Manny Martel Signed by Senior Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 9/5/2017. (ail)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STR I T C O U R T
C
SO U TH ERN DI
STRI T O F FLO R I
C
DA
CA SE NO.1 20l CI SEI W Hl
6- 30- V- TZ/
TE

M ANUEL M ANNY M ARTEL,
M ovant
,

UNI
TED STATES OF AM ERI
CA,
De e nt
f nda ,
/
O RD ER O V ERR U LI G O BJEC TI N S
N
O

THI CAUSE i b f r teCo r o M o a tsObe t nst t eRe o t t eM a itae
S
s e o e h u t n v n ' jci o h p r of h g srt
o
J d eg 2 ) Byo d rd tdAp i4, 01 ,hsCo r a fr da da o e t eRe o t f
u g DE-2 .
r e ae rl 2 7 t i u t fime n d ptd h p r o
M a srt J
gitae udgeg 1 ,i whi MagitaeJ W hierc
DE- 6) n ch
srt udge t e omme dt tM ova '
nde ha
nts
M oton t Va at be de e ac tfc t ofa al lt no bei s d, a t sc s be cos d.
i o c e
ni d, erii a e ppe abiiy t s ue nd hi a e
l e
Att tmet Cour e er d isOr rAdoptng Re t M o a th dn tflda yo j ci st
he i he
t nt e t de
i
por, v n a o ie n be t
on o
t Re r .Ther a t r on M a 1 , 201 t Co tr cevedM ova ' M o i n f Ext nson of
he po t
e fe ,
y 2
7, he ur e i
nts to or e i

Ti g 1 1 i whc M o a t o g ta d to a tmet fl o j ci n t t eRe o t A
me DE- 8 ,n ih v n s u h d ii n l i o ie b e to s o h p r.
r vi w oft m oto i ca e t ti w astm el m aie butt m ont f t Cour t r c ve
e e
he
i n ndi t d ha t
i y
ld
ook
hs or he
t o e ei

be us i wasm al d t t wr a r s TheCo tg a edt M oton f Ext ns o a
ca e t
ie o he ong dd es .
ur r nt he
i or e i n nd

g v M o a t n i J ne3 , 01 t fl h so j cin .Th o d rf rhe sae t tt Co r
a e v n u tl u 0 2 7 o ie i b e to s e r e u t r ttd ha he u t
wo l r e n ie t Re o t p nrc ito M o a tso j cin .M o n s ug tas c n
ud e o sd r he p r u o e ep f v n ' be to s va t o h e o d
e e i whih t Cour gr nt gi ngM ova untlJ y 1 , 201 t tl hi obe to
xt nson, c he
t a ed, vi
nt i ul 5
7 o se s jeins.

M o a th sn w fld hso j ci n .
v n a o i i be to s
e
Mo a trie tr eo j cin .Fis, v n ag e t a hewa e tte t a
v n ass h e b e to s rt Mo a t r u s h t
s ni d o n
l
evi nta y he rngt de e mi whehe heknowi y a vol a iy wave hi diec a
de ir a i o t r ne
t r
ngl nd unt rl i d s r t ppea
l

rghs Ane de ir heai howe r i notr rd i t j2255moi t fls a t
i t.
vi ntay rng,
ve ,s equie f he
ton,he ie , nd he
r c dsd oncusveys t tt prs ri e ildt nor lef' 28U. C.j22551 I
e or ç l i l how ha he ione s ntte o ei .'
c
S.
(9. n
o he w o ds a e de i y hea i i notr quie w he t m o nt sSa l ga i a e
t r r , n vi ntar
rng s
e rd
n he va ' ç le tons r
afi m a i y conta c ed by t r cor ori s h cl i sar pa t nty f i o . Ros n v U S.
fr tvel
r di t
he e d f uc a m
e r e l rvol us'
'
i .
,

78 F. 873,877( lhCi.201)(ntr lquottonsomitd) Anevi ntayhe i
6 3d
1 t r 5 i e na
ai
te .
de ir arng,
howe r i wa r nt d i t m ova S le sf c st t i tue woul e il hi t r i .' 1
ve , s ra e f he
nt ' l ge a t ha , f r ,
a
d ntte m o elef' d.

(ntr lquoai mar omitd)
i ena tton ks te .
Ass touti t Repor,t pla a e m e M ova sgne c ai d a a la e
e
n he
t he e gr e nt
nt i d ont ne n ppe lt
w a ver The Repo tquot s ctons oft pl c l y i whi h t Cour di c s d w ih
i .
r
es e i
he ea oloqu n
c he
t s us e t
M ova t tt pl a ee e c a ned an a la e w a ver A fe t Cour expl i w ha
nt ha he ea gr m nt ont i
ppe l t i . t r he
t
a ned
t

t tme , ova saedt thema t wave ifeeya vol a iy. g i DE- a
ha antM nt tt ha
de he i r ûr l nd untrl ' crm. 56 t
'

3 2 3 21Afe d susigwi M o a ta1o tetlnso t pe a r e n ,n l dn te
4:3-5:. tr ic sn t v n 1 f h en f he la ge me t icu ig h
h
w a ve , m a ng s e t the unde sood w ha t t r sm e nt t Co tas M ova i he
i r and ki ur ha
rt
t he e m
a , he ur ked
nt f

mad t de iint pl dguit fe l a vol trl a hea weedye .Ld.a 35: 20.
e he cso o ea ly r ey nd una iy nd ns r s l t 6- 1
M o ntha pr s nt d no e de et c r di thi s r satm e satt c ngeofpl a
va
s ee e
vi nc o onta c s wo n t e nt he ha
e.
Thus t r or e de e cea l c r c sM ova ' cai a hehasnotpr f r d a y
, he ec d vi nc l ry ontadit
nts l m nd
ofe e n
e denc t twoul wa r n a e de ir he rng.Se Chandlrv M cDonou 471F.
vi e ha
d r a t n vi nta y a i
e
e .
gh,
3d

1 ( 1hCi.2006)( he rngwarntdi t a enc ofaf t lpr fr.Ac or ngl
360 1 t r
no ai
ra e n he bs e
acua ofe) c di y,

M o a tsfrto j cini o er ld
v n ' is be to s v rue .
Se
cond,M ova a gue t ta a l t cour,on di e ta a ,s d be a es i
nt r s ha n ppela e
t
r c ppe l houl
ddr s ng

whe he he i e ild t c edi f hi tm es ve i aSpa s prs
t r s ntte o r t or s i er d n
nih ion.Howe r a s touti t
ve , s e
n he

Re r a a
po t nd bove M ova w a ve hi a lat r ght i t pl a a ee e . Cons que l t s
,
nt i d s ppe l e i s n he e gr m nt
e nty, hi

o j cini o er ld.
b e to s v rue
Fial, o a t b e t t teRe o tsfn i g t t o a tu d rt dt etr o te
n l M v n o j cs o h p r' i d n s ha M v n n e soo h ems f h
y
plaag e nt hi a l t wai r a t thewoul notge c e tf t tme hes r d i
e r eme , s ppelae ve , nd ha
d
t r di or he i
e ve n
Spa n. How e r t ta crpto t c
i
ve , he r ns i f he hang ofpl be i s t e a gum ent . The Cour
e
ea le hes r
s
t

r pe t y a ked M ova i heunde sood t tr oft plaag e m e and t he was
e a edl s
nt f
r t he e ms he e r e nt
hat
wavi hi a la erght .I alo s ii a l a es e t f c t tM ova c d no r c ve
i ng s ppe lt i s t s pec fc ly ddr s d he a t ha
nt oul t e ei
c e tf t tm ehe s r d i Span. The ei no hi i t r or t i ca et thedi no
r di or he i
e ve n i
r s t ng n he ec d o ndi t ha
d t
unde s a w ha wasgoi o a w ha t t m s oft pl a ag e m e w e e Furhe m or ,
r t nd
t
ng n nd
t he er
he e r e nt r . t r e
t r i s sr pr um p i n t ts or s a e e s m a du i a pl a c l
he e s tong es t o ha w n t t m nt de r ng
e oloquy a e tue U S.v.
r r .

Me oc ,1 F, 1 1 ( 1hCi.1 4) Be a eoft sprs i ac ltrlatc
dl k 2 3d 85, 87 1 t r 99 . c us hi e umpton, olaea ta k
ba e on t S ubs ntpr entton ofco us r alegai uns
s d he l eque es a i
s
ncl o y l tons uppore by s cii i
td
pe fcs s

s b e tt s mmm' dimis l a aec n e to st a i tefc o t er c r aewh l
u jc o u
y s sa, s r o tni n h t n h a e f h e o d r ol
y
i r bl ' Bl ke v. lson, U. 63,74( 977 .Theeor t sob e toni
ncedi e. ac ldge Ali 431 S.
'
1 )
rf e,hi j ci s
over ul
r ed.

Th Co r Wi No Is eW Ce t aeo pe a ii
e ut l tsu
l
rsc t fAp alblt
y
The Cour w ildeny i s nce ofa ce tfc t ofappe l biiy f M ova ' m oton
t l
s ua
ri i a e
a a lt or
nt s
i

purua t Rul 1loft Rul Gove ni Se ton 2255 Ca e .TheCour,ha ng e t ihe
s nt o e
he es
r ng c i
ss
t vi sabls d
g oundsf e e i a i i or rad r et t a i a ' on hi m oto ' us i s orde a
r
or nt rng ' nal de ve s o he pplc nt'
f
s i n, t t s ue
m
ny

c riia eofa a a lt ' l or rt obti ac tfc t ofa
e tfc t
ppe l biiy. n de o a n erii a e ppea a lt M ova mus m a
'
l biiy,
nt t ke

i s t i s ngoft de alofaco tttonalrght' 28U. C.j2253()2) Thi
i ubsantal howi
a
he ni
nsiui
i .
'
S.
c( . s

sa d r i s tsidl yd mo srtn ta j rsso r a o c uddia rewi t ed src
tn ad s aife s e n tai g h t u it f e s n o l s g e t h itit
b
h

c u tsr s lto o h sc n ttto l li o ta j rssc u dc n l d t eis e p e e td
p r' e ou in f i o si ina cams r h t u it o l o cu e h su s rs ne
u
a e a qua et des r e ou a m e tt pr e f t r' Jone v Sec ear 607 F. 1
r de t o e ve nc r ge n o oce d urhe .
'
s . r t y,
3d 346,

1 ( 1hCi.201 (uottonomitd) Her,M ova ha no madet ss ng.
349 1 t r 0) q ai
te . e
nt s t
hi howi
Thus ha ng c r f l r vi w ed, ntv ? M a s r t J
, vi a e uly e e
de l t, gi t a e udge W hie' Re t t r c d,
t s por, he e or

a dM o a tso j ci n ,t s
n v n ' b e to s ii
OR DER ED t t
ha :

()Th Re o t fM a itaeJ d e( 1 j i AFF RM ED a dADOPTED, a d
1 e p r o gsrt u g DE- 5 s I
n
'n
i or a e by r f r e it t sCour' Or r
nc por t d
e e enc n o hi
ts de ;

( Mova ' MotonUnde 28U. C.j2255t Va at,Se Asi ,orCore aSe e e
2)
nts i
r
S.
o c e t de
rct ntnc

( I i DENI
DE- J s
ED.
()Mo a tsOb e to ( 2 jaeOVERRULED.
3 v n ' j cins DE- 2 r
( A1pe ngmoto notot r s r e uponi t sOr rar DENI ASM OOT;
4) 1 ndi
ins
hewie uld
n hi de e
ED
()TheCour wilno is aCe tfc t ofAppeaa lt a
5
t l t sue riiae
lbiiy; nd
()Thi c ei CLOSED.
6 s as s
.

DONE a ORDERED i M imi Fl rda t s K
nd
n a , o i , hi

&
da ofSe e r 201
y
pt mbe , 7.

%
-

*
p

&

PATRI A A .S 1
CI
TZ
UN I
TED STATES D I I JUD G E
STR CT

c
c:

M agita eJ
sr t udgeW hie
t
Al Couns lofRe or
l
e
c d

l he Cour a fr s a ado st Re tw ih t f l i c r c i on page 4,t
'
r
t f i m nd pt he por t he olow ng or e ton:
he
s ond t l s s nt nce i t onl f lpa ag aph s d r ad,t m s ldi c s d e h oft
ec
o at e e
n he y ul r r
houl e i
cot e s us e ac
he
plaagr e e tsf ten pa a aphswih M ova s heco d unde sand wha i m e nta t
e
e m n ' oure
r gr
t
nt o
ul
rt
t t a nd he
i pacton hi .'
m
m'
4