Melton et al v. Century Arms Inc. et al

Filing 68

ORDER denying 58 Motion to Compel; Overruling 66 Defendants' Objection of Magistrate Judge Order to District Court regarding [35 and 42] Motions to Compel; Overruling 65 Plaintiffs' Objection of Magistrate Judge Order to District Court regarding [35 and 42] Motions to Compel. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 1/8/2018. (lfs)

Download PDF
UN I TED STA TES DI STR I CO URT FOR TH E CT SO U TH ERN D I STRI O F FLO RI CT DA M i iD i s on am vi i C as N um ber:1 21 e 6- 008- I M O R ENO C VJ EFFREY M ELTON ,EZEK I M ORRI EL S, TO M M Y J HN SON , U AN VA LD ES, nd O J a M ANVI LLE SM I TH, Pl i tf s a n if , CEN TURY ARM S,m C . CEN TU RY ; I TIRN A ''O N A I ARM S CO RP. N I II , ; CENTU RY A RM S O F V ERM O NT,l C. a N ; nd CIN ''JRY I TERN ATI NA L A RM S OF ï It N O V ERM ON T,I . NC , Dcf endant s. O RD ER O N M O T I N S TO CO M PE L O Tll CAUSE ca be or t Cour upon t f l ng m otons 1S me f e he t he olowi i : * Pli if ' M oton antfs i f om r Compel Un- da t d Docume Re c e nt Compa onl ti snc.( E. ,ie o De ember1 201 ni ndusres l D. 58) fld n c 2. 7. Pli tfs Obe to st Ma itaeJ d eTu n f sOr e o Mo in t Co e anif' j ci n o gsrt u g r o f d r n to s o mp l 1 ( E.35and D. 42) tld o Januaa 2, DE. ,ie n 2018. I ! i : @ De e d n s Ob e to s t Ma itae J d e Tun fs Or e o M oi n t fn a t' j cin o g srt u g rof' d r n I to s o i C fld onJanuar 2.201 ie v 8. ompel( E. and D. 42) D. 35 E. , i j i THE COURT ha consde e t motons a be ng ot r s f l a s d i t s i r d he i , nd i he wie uly dvie n he pr i i i em ses, t s A DJUD G E D t hat: @ Pl ntf ' M o i ai i f s ton Com pe Unl Reda t d D oc e Pr ce um nt oduc i f o ton r m ! I Compani l ti ,l ( E.58)i DENI asi i Compani l ti , on ndusres nc. D. s ED t s on ndusres l ' de s on, not D ef ndant , how i choos t c pl w ih Pl ntf s nc.s ci i e s' t es o om y t ai i f ' dicove y r ques s s r e t. ! @ Panif'Obe t n t Ma itaeJ d eTu n fsOr e o Moi n t Co e litfs jci o gsrt u g r of o d r n to s h mp l I I ( E.35a 4 )i OVERRULED.A Ma itaeJ d esod rlh s ge st D. nd 2 s gsrt u g ' re i al b ) e s ! ! asde i (f i ij f nd t be clary e r eous or c r y t l ' i t s ou o e l ron ontar o aw. ' * S. Fa L. 4 a( ) Un e Flrd lw,$a cam f ru j s e rci n h s D. l. R. ()1 . d r o ia a û 1 li o nu t n ih t a g me 1 tre ee n s ( )te panifh sc n er d ab n fto te d fn h ;( )t e h e lme t: l h li tf a o fre e e i n h ee da t 2 h 1 dee fndant volntrl a ce ed a rti u aiy c pt nd eaned t t be i; a 1( t ha neft ndj 3) he I cr u tn e aes c ta i wo l b ie utbef rted fn a t t rti i ic msa c s r u h h t t ud e n q i l o h e e d ns l ean t a I o wihoutpa ng t vaue t r of' Vr l v R a d Gr ,I c,6 0 F 3d 1 t yi he l he e .' igii . yln p. n . 8 i 329, j . I 1 ( 1h Ci. 2) Ont tba i,Pli if's tt tDefndans ie ue , 337 1 t r 201 . ha ss antfs ubmi ha e t'rven s ë pr i,a c t of goods s d f t cl s w e pons ar nec s r t pr t oft nd os s ol or he a s a e es a y o ove he I ! unus be i c e rd on Dee nt by Pli if.The Cour diagye The j t nett onfre fnda s antfs t s e s. : cux ofanunus e i ntcli i t difr nc bewee whatPliIfs pad r j t nrchme am s he fe e e t n anj f' i i i a d wh tt e e p ce t rc i f rt erp y n - n tDe e d n t p o is n a h y x e td o e eve o h i a me t o fn a t' r ft. ! A c di y, M a s r t J cor ngl gi ta e udge Tur f s or r i not cl a l e r l ous or nof de s e r y r qne con r r t l w . ta y o a * i i ! 1 l Defnda s' Obeci t Magitae J e nt j ton o srt udge Tu n t Or r on Votons t r of's de !i o I Compe ( E.35 and 42)i OVERRULED.Defnda s s k t i ke tnonl D. s e nt ee o ns c i Cent y A K fr a m s ow ne by Pl ntf s t s e how t y a e c i ed,a i ur ie r d ai if o e he r ontgur nd f t confgur i pr ded know l he i aton ovi edge t t Pl ntf s' r evant t t s l s t o he ai if el o hi aw ui. : ! i I Def nt s enda s ubmi t M a sr t J e Tur f sde aloft sr s i cla l t hat gitae udg nof ni hi eque t s e ry i I e r ou a c r y t l w be us M a s r t J r one s nd ontar o a ca e git a e udge Tur f pe m it d nof r te di c er oft Pl ntf s nons ov y he ai if ' cent y A K fr r m a al ,butnott fr r s ur iea m nu s he iea m t s l .The Cour di a e be us t c nt ali s be or t s Cour i t hem e ves t s gr es ca e he e r s ue f e hi t s he ale def c s i t Cent y fr ar owne by Pl ntfs notPli if nonlged e t n he ur ie ms d ai if , a nsfs' i Ce tr frams Th Co r noe ta Ma itaeJ d eTu n f' g r rst i nuy ier . e u t ts h t gsrt u g r ofs ej o iy n e I : p r tigds o eyo rten n ce tr ma u l d e n t u tf t sf q e t emi n ic v r ve h o - nu y n as o s o j siy hi e u s. t z- DONEAND ORDERED i Ch mb r a MimiFlrd ,hs n a es t a , oia ti ofJn qy2 8 a u r 01 . r* .. ! e - ! FED ERI CO .M O REN UN I TED STATES DI STRI J CT UDGE * r : . , . Copi s f ni he t e ur s d o: Couns ofRe or el c d

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?