Diczok v. Celebrity Cruises, Inc.

Filing 85

ORDER ON OMNIBUS MOTIONS IN LIMINE granting in part and denying in part 73 Motion in Limine; granting in part and denying in part 77 Motion in Limine. Signed by Senior Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 7/26/2017. (kpe)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO U RT
CT
SOU THERN D I
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
CA SE N O .1 21 I CI - TZ/
6- 01 - V SEI TURN O FF
J N DI
OH
CZO K ,
Pl i if
a ntf ,

CELEBRI CRUI
TY
SES,I C ,
N
D e e nt
f nda .
/
O R DER O N O M NI S M O TI N S I LI I E
BU
O
N M N

THI M ATTER i be oet Cour onCee iy' Omni M otoni Li neg 73Ja
S
s f r he
t
lbrt s
bus i n mi DE
s
t tvee de ir is andDiz sOmni M oton ( 771ast f e de ir is .
o i vi ntay sues
c ok'
bus i DE
o our vi ntay sues

Twoo tep ris e ie tayis e o elpa da ea d e s dj ity Th r s aea d e s d
f h ate ' vd n ir su s v ra n r d r se onl . e e t r d rse
s pa a ey be ow.
e rtl l
A .CELEBR I ' M O TI N S I LI I
TY S
O
N M NE
1. l i ofA le d H e r a St t m ent ofA Ce ç iv Emml e
Exc us on
l ze
as y ae
s
l hrt
ove
-

Ceebrt movest e udehea s y saeme sal ge y m a by a uni ntfed d a ey
l iy
o xcl
r a t t nt le dl de
n de ii t f t
s
ofi r' ho ty a trDiz sf l Ac or ng t Di ok,t s f t ofi e s i ç ho' t a e
fce 's rl fe c ok' al. c di o cz he a ey fc r a d t
W
s he r a
ma
nage ,be a eyou know,t y'e g ng t ge r prm a d be a et char we e tputba
r c us
he r oi o t e i nde c us he is r n'
ck

i pa e'( 46( c o De o.7 9 1 . Diz ka g e ta te esae n saea misbea a
n lc . DE Diz k p ) 3:- 2) c o r u s h t h s ttme t r d s il s
'
non- as ya si ofaCee iye oye underRul 801d)2)D)
he ra dmison
lbrt mpl e
e ((( .

l l 8 ()2 ( rq ie t eprfe igpa t t lyaf u d to t s o ta a
' e 01d ( )D) e u rs h ofrn ry o a o n ain o h w h t n
Ru
o he wi e e udi e s a e e r l t t a m a t wihi t s ope oft a nt se pl e .'
t r s xcl bl t t m nt e a es o
ter t n he c
he ge ' m oym nt'

Wikns v Car valCr s Li s I ,920F.d l 1 ( 1hCi.1 )(mpha i i
li on . ni
uie ne , nc.
2 560, 567 1 t r 991 e
ss n
oi na) Thus amoto unde Rul 801d)2)D)r s saprlmi r is off tunde Rul
rgi l. ,
in
r e ( ( ( aie ei nay sue ac
r e
1 a wiht pr
04() t he opone oft sae ntha ngt bur nofpr .W hieana i notsrcl
nt he ttme vi he de
oof
l
me s tity

r quie aditi tcour s d bepr e e wih s fc e evi ncet c l t tt de l r nt
e r d, src
t houl
es ntd t ufi i nt de
o onc ude ha he c a a
wa i f c a a ntoft opposngpa t Funde bur v.
s n a t n ge
he
i
ry.
r k Fanni M ae 2015W L 11 6690,a *
e
,
21
t4

( D. . v mb r1 , 01 )af 65 Fe Ap x4 6 4 - ( 1hCi. 01 ) A s fiin
N. Ga No e e 6 2 5 ,f d, 4 d. p' 7 , 7778 1 t r 2 6 . u tce t
f
oundain t s ppor a age ' a sinsr rs( )t e se eofa a yrltons p;
to o u t n nts dmiso equie 1 he xitnc
n genc eai hi
( t tt sae
2) ha he ttmentwa ma durngt c s oft trltons p;and( t ti rlt t a
s de i he oure ha eai hi
3) ha t eaes o
m a t rw ihi t s ope oft a nc 1 A lhough t s a e en s t m s l m us be co i r d,
te t n he c
he ge y. d. t
he t t m t he e ves
t
ns de e
t y,by t m s l s do notesabls t a nt sau hort ort e s e ort s ope oft
he
he e ve ,
t i h he ge ' t iy he xi t nce he c
he

rltons pasrquie unde Rul 801d)2)C)a ( ,rs ci y.
eai hi e rd
r e ( ( ( nd D) e pe tvel
H e e,Di ok m a nt i t tt de l r nta oa he hi wea i a unionn wih e e s
r
cz
i a ns ha he c a a ppr c d m
rng
f
t paul t

a i ntfedhi el a as f t ofi r c sc
nd de ii ms f s a ey fce .Dizok' ompa on,J a Campbel, e tte a he
ni e n
l t sii d t r

de iint tt ss ofie die t ot remplye t rplc t char ( 47( mpbel
posto ha hi ame fc r rced he
o es o e a e he is DE Ca
l
De )1 1 1 a ltrme wihCa
po. 05:0- 51 nd ae t t mpbel i t M edialDe rme t floutaf 1 a
l n he
c pa t nt o il
onn.d. t
1 1 22. Howe r Cee iy' c por t r pr s nt tve Am a Ca
03: 9ve , lbrt s or ae e e e ai ,
nda mpos t sii d a he
, e tfe t r
de ii t tt r wa onl ones f t ofi e onboar t Cee iy Summ i on t da oft
poston ha he e s y
a ey fc r
d he lbrt
t he y he

i i t Andr Bafr ,( 52- ( mposDe )45: 1 1 201 a hewasno prs nti
ncdenew eos DE 4 Ca
po. 5- 0, 6- , nd
t ee n
t Re
he ndev Lou w hen t i i toc r d. #.a 9 20- M r Ba er onl vi ie t
ous nge
he nc den cur e f t 4: 23. . f os y s t d he
Re v Loun a t m ee i w ih D i z i t M edi alD e r m e . d. t94: 25;95: nde ous
ge fer
tng t c ok n he
c
pa t nt 1 a
231 4.

Be us t r i af c ua diput ast whe he t pe s who madet a lge sae e s
ca e he e s a t l s e o
t r he r on
he le d t tm nt
w a t Cel brt t af t of i r' a w he he t pe s m aki t s a e en s di s w ihi t
s he e iy l e y fce ,' nd
s
t r he r on
ng he t t m t d o t n he

s opeofhi e pl
c
s m oyme ,t m oton i tke unde a s nt Att Pr -ra Conf e e,
nt he i s a n
r dvieme . he e ti l
er nc
D i zok s d be pr pa ed t pr de e de e t m e hi bur
c
houl
e r o ovi vi nc o et s den.

2. l i ofRef r nc t Ca rorRe at Phia hr c W or
Excuson
e e es o nee
l td lnt opi
k
Celbrt m ove t e l a ir l va a 1e denc ofDi z sorM s Ca
e iy
s o xcude s re e nt 1 vi e
c ok'
. mpbel'
ls
hit y ofc nce .On t s m egr
sor
a r
he a
ounds Ceebrt alo m ove t exc udee de ofM s
, l iy s
so l
vi nce
.

Ca elsr ltdp i nh o i wok.Diz kr ie n o j ci nwi r g r st tee ie c o
mpb l' eae hl tr p c r c o as s o be to t e ad o h v d n e f
a
h
c e . o e r he cl i st tM s Ca pbe lsphia hr c w o k i r l va t he c edi lt
anc r H w ve ,
a m ha
. m
l'
l nt opi r s e e nt o r r biiy.
D i z hasnotpr de an l ga a hort t s
c ok
ovi d y e l ut iy o uppor t r l va y ofM s Ca pbe ls
t he e e nc
. m
l'

phia hr c e f t t esa ih herc e biiy i t sc s The e or t m oton i GRANTED.
l nt opi fors o t bls
r di lt n hi a e. r f e, he i s
3. l i n ofEvi eon Ec
Excuso
denc
onomi Stndi
c a ng
Cee iy movest excudee de e oft pa tes e
lbrt
o l
vi nc
he ri ' conomi sandi Dizok doe not
c t ng. c
s
o
ppos t m oton. c or ngl t m oton i GR AN TED .
e he
i A c di y, he
i s
B.DI ZO K ' M O TI N S I LI I E
C
S
O
N M N

1 Excuson ofZde k He zarsExpe tRe t
. l i
ne i l '
r por

Diz kmo e t e cu eCee rt ' rb ta e p r Zd n kHeza , r un t a t e
c o v s o x ld lb iy s e u tl x e t e e j lr ag ig h t h
e p r' rb ta tsi n i n t ee a ti lg t ft Co r' Or e Srkn Diz k' Ex e t
x e ts e utl e tmo y s o r lv n n ih o he u ts d r tiig c o s p r g
DE 691Rul 26pemisrbutale r t tmo wheeiçi i ende s el t co rditor
. e
r t e t xpe tesi ny r t's nt d ol y o nta c

rb te i e c o t es mes b e tmatrie tfe b a t e pat. Diz kp o i e no
e u v d n e n h a u j c te d n iid y noh r ry' c o r v d s
'
a hort t s
ut iy o uppor hi c enton t ta r buta e r ma onl be us t c r di tadve s
t s ont i ha e t l xpe t y y
ed o onta c
re

e p r tsi n Ho v r Cee rt as fist a t ult h w Mr Heza' tsi n wi
x et etmo y. we e, lb iy lo al o ri ae o
c
. j lrs e tmo y l
l
a ss t etiro fc. eUntdSa e v Fr ze , 7F.d 1 4 ,1 6 ( 1hCi. 00 )
sit h re f a tSe ie tts . a ir 38 3 2 4 2 2 1 t r 2 4 .
The e or ,t Cour wilt Dizok' m o i n unde a s nt
r f e he
t l ake c s to
r dvieme .Att Pr -ra Conf e e,
he e ti l
er nc
D i zok s d be pr pa ed t pr de a hort t s
c
houl
e r o ovi ut iy o uppor hi pos ton.l a ton, e iy
t s ii n ddii Cel brt

s o l b p e a e t d s u swhc is e M r Heza wil d rs a dh w Mr Heza'
h ud e rp r d o ic s ih su s . j lr la d e s n o
. j lrs
t s i ony w ila s s t t i roff t
e tm
l s i t he re
ac .

2. uson ofCop or t Re e e t tve' Tesi o Outi He Pe s lKnowl
Excl i
a e or s n a i s tm nv sde r r ona
edge

Diz kmo e t e ld C n h a sysae nso fr db g lb iy . . ndma eb
c o v s o xcu t t y e ra ttme t fte y cee rt) . a
a
d y
t co por t r pr en a i i de ii notba ed on he pe s lknowl
he r ae e es t tve n poston
s
r r ona
edge. Howe r Di ok
'
'
ve , cz

fist at ult wh c sae n sh o j dst .Th Co r wil o e cud p ri n o tsi n
al o ri ae ih ttme t e b e o e u t l n t x l e o t s f e t y
c
o
mo
wihou fr tha ng t opporuniyt a y ea h s ae e . r or Dizok' moto i
t t is vi he
t t o nalze c tt m nt The ef e, c s i n s

DENI wih u p eu ie ByTu s a Aug s 1 2 7 Diz kmu ttl als o t es e i
ED t o t rj dc .
e d y u t , 01 , c o s ie it f h p dtc
sa e e t he s e t e l
tt m n s
e ks o xc ude.Att Pr - ralc e ene t Cour w ilcons de a y s a e e s
he e t i onf r e, he
t l
i r n t t m nt

t tDizokpr de
ha c
ovi s.
C . H E PA R TI S'O V ER LAPPI G M O TI N S
T
E
N
O
1 Evi nc o Pr o Re t I de s
. de e n i r pored nci nt

Ce e iy move t e udeevi nceofprorac de son boa d aCelbrt ve s
l brt
s o xcl
de
i ci nt
r
e iy s el
i vi fxnvol ng i mount d t bl wiht char r m ove Spe ic l Celbrt a ii t ,a
e a es t he is e
d. ci aly, e iy ntc paes nd
Di z confr ,t tDizok wilofe e denc ofan i de whe ea i vi lf loverafxc ok
ims ha c
l f r vi e
nci nt r n ndi dua el
i
mount dt bl i t Re v sLoun ofa he s p. sCour hasar dy f undt tt s
e a e n he nde ou
ge not r hi Thi
t
lea o
ha hi
s pa a e i i nti nots tc e l s m iart D i zok' f l t putCe ebrt on notce a da r
e r t nc de s
ufi i nty i l o c
s al o
l iy
i
nge ous

c n iince tdb atb eb s lr e ta istbet p ( 7 a 4n. )Theeo e t emoin
o dto rae y a l- a e ag r h n t a l-o . DE 0 t 2. rf r ,h to
i GM N TED .
s

S p rtl, c o mo e t p e ld Cee rt fo o f rn e i e c o tea s n eo
e a aey Diz k v s o rcu e lb i r m fe ig v d n e n h b e c f
y
sm iari i nt prort Di z sf l.
i l nc de s i o c ok' a l Unde t Fede a Rul , le de ei ad isbl i i i
r he
r l es al vi nc s m s i e f t s
r e nt Fed.R. d.
elva .
Evi 402.
None hees ,adi titc tma e uder eva evi nc i t
t l s
src our y xcl el nt de e f he

p o aiev lei s b tn il o t ih db t ed n e o u fi p eu c . e . Evd. 0
r b tv au s u sa tal uweg e y h a g r f n ar rj die F d R. i 4 3.
y
Evi nc o t l k ofsm iari i nt i a isbl i t ofe i pa t lyst pr pe
de e n he ac
i l nc de s s dm s i e f he f rng ry a he o r

f
oundai For e v Beoi Cor ,424F. 3 355- ( dCi.
ton. rst . l t p.
3d 44, 56 3r r 2005) Coursi t sditit
.
t n hi src

4

a ele r ha hel t ts h e de i a isbl çbu t pa t s ki t r l on i m us
nd s whe t ve d ha uc vi nce s dm s i e,i t he ry ee ng o ey t t
s w t tc tonsdurngt pe i i quesi we e s t ntal sm ia t t epr va lng a
ho ha ondii
i he rod n
ton r ubsa i ly i lr o hos e ii t

t tmeo t a ci nt'Hol rb v Car valCopor i 201 W L 1
he i f he c de .' de aum . ni
r aton, 5
2085846,a *3( D.
t S.

F a M ac 4 2 5 a dMu ln yv Hi o Hotl Co p.6 4F. u p. d 1 3 1 5 ( Ha i
l. rh , 01 ) n la e . l n es r , 3 S p 2 1 0, 1 1 D. wai
t
2 0 )(o hctn Pima v fite l 43 F.d65 6 2( s Ci.1 71)
0 9 b t iig t n . t fed, 8 2 9, 6 1 t r 9 ).
t
l
He e, e iy mai ai t tt Re vou Lounge a ist bl sha bee i t s me
r Celbrt
nt ns ha he nde s
nd t a e ve n n he a
c to snc 2001. sf c aone doe notesabls a s fcen f
ondii n i e
Thi a t l
s
t ih ufi i t ounda i t a l e de e
ton o low vi nc
o t a e e ofs m ia i i nt . r or t Cou tw ilt ke D i zok' m oton unde
n he bs nc
i l r nc de s The ef e, he
r l a
c
s
i
r
a s e . A tt Pr -r a Conf r nce Ce e iy s d be pr pa ed t l y t pr rf
dvi em nt
he e t i l
e e , l brt houl
e r o a he ope ounda i
ton
f t evi nce a di cus how ispr tve va ue i nots t ntaly out ei d by a
or he de
nd s s
t oba i
l s
ubs a i l
w ghe
ny

P eu ie
rj dc .
2.Excl i ofCola er lSour e Be f t a M e ca B il tW rten Of 'b H e t Ca e
us on
lt a
c
ne is nd di l ls i it
f y ah r
Pr de s
ovi r

Diz m ove t e l e denc ofcolatr s c bene isher ceved wih r a dst
c ok
s o xcude vi e
l e al our e
ft
e i
t eg r o
hi media bil. c lt r s c r l pr bisade enda fom ofe i e denc t ta
s
c l ls The ola e al our e ue ohi t
f nt r
f rng vi e ha
pl ntf wasc
ai if
ompe aed byt r pa t s c s h asheat i tr nc Bour e v Di
ns t
hid- ry our es uc
lh nsla e.
qu . amon
dM

Drlig Co,6 F. 351,35 ( hCi.1 0) Celbrt doe notdipuet tii baredfom
iln . 23 2d
4 5t r 98 . e iy s
s t ha t s r r
of e i s h e de e.The ef e t t e e Cel br t s e t ofere de e ofc l t r l
f rng uc vi nc
r or , o he xt nt e iy e ks o f vi nc
ola e a
s ce be ft ,D i z sm o i i G RAN TED .
our
ne s c ok' ton s

I opposng m o i ,t pa te diput ove wheherDi z m a c am da a sf t
n
i
tons he ris s e r t
c ok y l i m ge or he
f lunr duce a oun ofmedialbil i r e a trhi f l. l brt a gue t Di ok ma not
ul e
d m t
c ls ncu r d fe s a l Ce e iy r s hat cz
y
r ove a m edi ale
ec r ny
c xpens t tw e e nota ualy a a or ngl m ovest pr c ude D i zok
es ha r
ct l nd, cc di y,
o el
c
f o oferng e de e ofa m e c le ns s ç rte of by hi he t ca e pr de s I
r m f i vi nc
ny di a xpe e t it n f'
w
s alh r ovi r . n
r s ns ,D i zok a gue t ts h a r t i ton w oul vi a e t c l t r ls c r l . How e r
e po e c
r s ha uc es rc i
d ol t he ola e a our e u e
ve ,

t cola e als c doc rnedoesnotgove' t a oun ofm e ca expe e apl i ifma
he lt r our e ti
l he m t
n
di l
ns s antf y
c am i da
l i n mage . a
s An bundanc ofca el i t sDiti thol t t unde ge r lm a ii e
e
s aw n hi src ds ha ,
r ne a rtm
lw,r c a em e ca e ns a e lm ied t ea ualy pa d b t pli if Se eg.
a e over bl di l xpe es r i t hos ct l i y he antf . e, . ,

S c r ov Celbrt Cr s s I .Cas No.1:5z zu k . e i uie , nc, e
y
1 20592- V- ( 41 ;
CI UU DE q Samps v Ca ni
on . r val
Cor aton,Ca eNo.11 24339- V-LK ( 471 Theeor Cee iy' moi i
por i
s
:5Cl J DE . rf e, lbrt s ton s
GRANTED.To t e entDi ok c e i hi own moton t thei e ild t r c
he xt
cz ont nds n s
i ha
s ntte o e overt f l
he ul
a
mountofbil d mediale
le
c xpens , sm oton i DENI .
es hi
i s
ED
Ba ed on t di c s on a
s
he s us i bove,i i
ts
ORD ERED THA T

( )Cee rt sOmniu M o ini Li n g 7 )a d Diz k' Omniu Mo in (
1 lb iy'
b s to n mi e DE 3 n c o s
b s to DE
7 JaeGRANTED-N7 r
I PART a dDENI I PART a sae a o e
n
ED-Ns ttd b v .
( Dizok' motonsi lmi rgadi Ceebrt srbuta e r a Cel rt s
2) c s i n i ne e z ng l iy' e tl xpe t nd ebiy'
e denc on t lc ofsmia i de swilbe a es e a t Pr TralConf r nc
vi e he a k i lr nci nt l
ddr s d t he e- i
e e e.

&

DoxEAxo ORDERE i MimiFoiati 26 dyo ll, 0 7
D n a , lrd,hs
a r uy 2 1.
e

%

PATRI I A .S I
A
T
UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI J G E
CT UD
c
c:

Alc
1 ouns lofr c d
e
e or

6