SETAI HOTEL ACQUISITION LLC v. LUXURY RENTALS MIAMI BEACH, INC. et al
Filing
17
ORDER granting in part and denying in part 10 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 12/9/2016. (mmd)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M im iDi son
a
vi i
Cas Num be 1 21 CI M ORENO
e
r: 6- 289- V-
SETAIHOTEL ACQUI TI
SI ONS,
LLC,
Pl ntf,
ai if
VS.
LUXURY RENTALS M I IBEACH,I C.
AM
N
a KRI NE HALL,
nd
STI
De e nt .
f nda s
/
O R DER G M N TI G I PAR T AN D D ENY I G I PAR T M O TI N TO D I I
N N
N N
O
SM SS
Pli if SeaiHot Ac stons LLC,i brngi tade a k a t tous i e f r e
antf, t
el quiii ,
s i ng r m r nd ori nt re enc
c ams agans De e
li
i t f ndan s Luxur Ren a s M i Bea h,I and Krsi Hal, r al e t t
t
y
tl
ami
c nc.
itne
l e sa e
br ker t tr nt d outprvae c
o s ha e e
i t ondomi um sa t Sea Hot l a ntf cli t De e n s
ni
t he ti e .Pli if a ms he f nda t
a e ope a i a s
r
r tng hadow ho e wihi t hotl a i s doi a e c e f ii diutng,a
t l t n he e , nd n o ng r ount re tng, l i nd
i rngi on Pl ntf s ta a ks a
nf i ng
ai if r dem r
nd t tous y i t r e i w ih Pl i if s busnes
or i l n e f rng t
a nt f
i s
r a i hi wih t c
eltons p t he ondom i um uni o r . De e
ni
t wne s
f ndan shave moved t dim is The Co t
t
o s s.
ur
fnds t a l ga i a e i uf i e t s a e a c a m f t a m a k vi a i , butt t r i
i
he le tons r ns fci nt o t t
l i or r de r ol tons
he o tous
i e f r nce c ai i s fci nty pl d. Pli ifm a fl a ame d c pl ntconsse wih
nt r e e
l m s uf i e l e
a ntf y ie n
nde om ai
it nt t
t sO r r
hi de .
THI CAUSE c beor t Cour uponM otont Dimis( E.10)
S
ame f e he
t
i o s s D.
.
THE COU RT has cons de e t m o i t r pons pe tne pori oft r or
i r d he ton, he es
e, ri nt tons he ec d,
a be ng ot wi e f l a s d i t pr m i e ,i i
nd i
her s uly dvi e n he e s s t s
A DJU D G ED t t t m o i i GR AN TED a t t tade a k cl i s w iho
ha he
ton s
s o he r m r a m , t ut
p eu iea dwi la et r tl.I i as
rj dc n t e v o eie t s lo
h
AD JU D G ED t tt m oto i D EN I a t t t tous i e f e c a m . Pl ntf
ha he
in s
ED s o he ori
nt r er nce l i
ai i f
ma fl a a e
y ie n m nded c
ompli c itntwih t sor rby De mbe 20, 2016.
ant onsse
t hi de
ce r
Ba kg ound
c r
Pli if Se a Hot lAcq sto LLC, i t owne a ope aorofû-he Se a Ho e 'i
antf, t i e
uiii n,
s he
r nd r t
ç'
f
t i t l'n
M imiBe c Fl i Def nda Luxur Rent s M im iBea h, l i a r le t t br r ge
a
a h, orda. e nt
y
al a
c nc. s ea sa e oke a
fr t tm a gesprva ey owne pr tes i l y hot l i Sout Fl i , i l ng The
im ha na
i tl
d operi n uxur
es n
h orda ncudi
Se a Re or a Re i nc i M im iBea h. De e ntKrsi Hal mana Luxur Re al
t i s t nd sde es n a
c
f nda
itne l
ges
y nt s
M imi Be h, l
a
ac nc. Pl i ifs c
antf
ompl nt a lges t De e nt o r t a f l - i e a e
ai le
he f nda s pe a e uly nt gr t d
f ha
i dow ho e ' wihi t Se a Ho eli l ng pr di c e ge s r c , hous kee ng
s
t l' t n he t i t ncudi
ovi ng oncir e vies
e pi
s r c s a gues as it e s r i s Pl ntf c endst s a tvii scountr et diut a
e vi e , nd
t s sanc e vce . ai if ont
he e c i te
e f i, l e nd
i rnge on Pl ntf ta ma ks Pl ntf s c
nfi
ai ifs r de r . ai if ompl nt as r ies t tous i e f e e a
ai lo as ori
nt rer nc nd
unf i c
ar ompeii cli
tton a ms.
De e
f ndan s have be n ofe i unis f r a t Se a Ho elf r s ve ye r a
t
e f rng t or ent t he t i t o e n a s nd
Pl i ifpur has d t Se aiHot i De e be 201 . De enda smovet dimis ctng ll
antf c e he t
el n c m r 4
f nt
o s s ii s-he
De lr ton of Seai Res rs a Resdenc , a is a e e s D e e nt a g t
c a ai
t
o t nd
i es' nd t m ndm nt .
'
f nda s r ue he
De lr to e i ty aut i s t t i owne st ofe t i unis f r ntt ough t r pa t
ca ai n xplcil
horze he m t
r o f r her t or e hr
hid- ry
r a ag i . D e enda s a gue t D e l r ton die s uni ow ne s t r e t t Se a H ot
ent l enc es
f
nt r
he c a a i
r ct t
r o ef r o he t i el
usng is pr r na - t ta
i t ope me he r dema k a is
r t s ue. Def nda s c e t us t nn oft
e nt ont nd hey e he me
he
hot t ac ur t l de c i t geog a c l a i oft unis be ng ofe ed f r nt whih
el o c a ey s rbe he
r phi oc ton
he t i
f r or e ,
c
c tt e af i us oft m a k.
onsiut s ar e he r
l L e St
I. zal anda
rd
$ s vve a m oton t dim is pli if mus do mor t n m e el sae lgal
$ ur i
To
i o s s , antfs
t
e ha
r y tt e
c usons'i t a pl ntfsmus ç l s
oncl i , nse d ai if
'
t s ege ome s ii f cua bassf t e c usonsor
al
pecfc a t l i or hos oncl i
f ce di m i s loft rc a m s ' Jac s v Belo t T lc mm. 3 2F.d 1 5 ,1 6 ( 1hCi.
a
s sa
hei l i .
' k on . ls u h ee o , 7 3 2 0 2 3 1 t r
2004) W he r i on a moton t dimis a c tmus vi t co ai i t lghtmos
.
n ulng
i o s s , our
t ew he mpl nt n he i
t
2
f vor bl t t pl ntf and a e t pl ntf s we lpl de f ct as tue. Se St Jos ph'
a a e o he ai if
cc pt he ai if
l- ea d a s r
e . e s
H os ,I .v H os Cor . o
p. nc . p. p fAm. 7 5F.d9 , 5 ( 1hCi.1 8 ) Thstne, o v r d e
, 9 2 48 9 3 1 t r 9 6 . i e t h we e, o s
n ta py t lg lc n lso s S eAs c o v I a ,1 9 S. .1 37 1 4 ( 0 9 . M o e v r
o p l o e a o cu in . e h rp . qb l 2 Ct 9 , 9 9 2 0 ) ro e ,
dg hiel lconcuso c npr vi t fn wor ofac ai ,he mus bes
twl l ega
l ins a o de he r me k
ompl ntt y t uppore by
td
fcu l l g to . I a 1 5 . Th s 'ta t lalg to smu tb e u h t riearg t o
a ta al ains' d t 9 0 o e 'l cua le ain s e no g o as ih t
e
'
g
r lefa ve t s ultve l velo t as umpton t t a1of t compli ' al ga i a e
ei bo he pec a i e
n he s
i ha l
he
a nt le tons r
s
tue. BelAt.Co p.v.Twombl 550 U. 544, 5 5 ( 0 7 . I s r, h c mpan mu tn t
r ' l l r
'
y,
S.
4 2 0 ) n ho t t e o li t s o
me ey alegeam ic
rl l
s onduc ,butmus de onsr t t tt pl ade i e il d t r le . Se I al
t
t m ta e ha he e r s ntte o ei f e qb ,
1 S. .a 1 0.
29 Ct t 95
1 1 A nal i
1.
vs s
A. Do steDe lr to b rPli t ' cai a dauh rz Dee d ns' ciiis
e h ca a in a a nt s l ms n t o ie f n a t a tvte ?
The prma y is r i e i t m oton t dimis i whe he ç-'e De l r ton ofSe a
i r s ue a s d n he
i o s s s
t r lh
f
caai
ti
Res t a Resde e ' co r di t t al ga i i t c pl nt r quii dimi s l of
ors nd
i nc s' nta cs he le tons n he om ai e rng s s a
Pli ifs ta m a k a t t c am s Alhough t De l r ton wa not at c
antf r de r nd or l i .
t
he c a a i
s
ta hed t t
o he
Pl i if s c pl i , t s Cour m a cons de i w ihout conve tng t m oton i t one f
a ntf
om a nt hi
t y
i r t t
ri he
i no
or
s mmayj d me t Br o v BleCr s & Bl eShed o o ia I c,11 F.d 1 6 ,1 6
u r u g n . o kç . u o s
u il fFl rd , n . 6 3 3 4 3 9
( 1h Ci.1 .
1 t r 997)
Bo h sdesa e t De l r ton a l f t r nt lofprva er sde i unisatt
t i gr e he c a ai lows or he e a
i t e i ntal t he
Se a Hot l TheUni Owner a t Hot lOwne ag e d t tUni Owne sc d prva e yr nt
ti e.
t
s nd he e
r r e ha
t
r oul i t l e
t ic
he r ondo i um s die l t t na s ort ough t r pa t br r . The D e a a i r ds i
m ni
r cty o e nt
hr
hid- r y oke s
cl r ton ea n
r evantpar :
el
t
Iii e
t s ntnded t tt Unis ma be us f r ta intand/ hot lr nt l . A s
ha he
t y
ed o r nse
or e e a s
s h,lasng ofUnis( he t n Cl Unis orpori t rofs lno be
uc e i
t ot r ha ub t)
tons hee hal t
s b e tt tea p o lo t eAso ito a d o a y oh rl tto s o h rt a
u j c o h p r va f h s cain n / r n t e i ain , t e h n
mi
e es l pr vi d he ei ...t f egoi a ho i ton f t us ofUnis f r
xpr sy o de r n
he or ng ut rzai or he e
t o
r nt l pur e s l r f r s el t r nt l t t publc f ta i nt or hot l
e a
pos s hal e e ol y o e a s o he
i or r ns e
e
occ nc c
upa y onduce by t Uni Owne die ty ort ough r nt lage es or
td
he t
r r cl
hr
e a
nci
r lesaebr r .
ea tt oke s
Exh.A a 1 7,1 Thi pr s on a s r r s t na s t com pl w ih t oc dlr s ado e by
t 6. 7. s ovi i l o equie e nt o
y t t e ze
pr
pt d
t Hot Uni Owne r r ng m a t y c k-n f Owne s a r i nt, coor na i of
he el t
r ega di
nda or hec i or
r nd esde s
di ton
c r ng prvieg a o he ma tr r as bl ne s ar t a l Owne sa hot lguesst
ha gi
i l es nd t r te s e ona y ce s y o low
r nd e
t o
be wel i e r t i o a unii d sr t e a ope a i .'1 To t te t Dec a ai as
l nt g aed nt
te tucur nd r ton ' d.
ha nd, he
lr ton lo
dr csUntOwn r t tith n me b whc t i c n o nu i t b ie tfe i S
ie t i
es ha l l e a y ih h s o d miim s o e d n iid s ETAI
l
RESORT & RESI
DENCES,A CONDOM I UM . Exh.A a ! 1.
NI '
'
t 3.
TheDe a a i as dic s ss r cng oft condomi um uniswhiear ntri o
clr ton lo s us e e vii
he
ni
t
l e e sn
pr m ie .I saesasf l :
e s s t tt
olows
( 1 sr ieis e e o ne e (y rn a tn n)whl i -e ie ei teUnt
A)l e vc su s nc u trd b e tl e a t ie nr sd nc n h i
Om wrs Uni s l be a es e by t Uni Owne or is t r pa t age ..
'
t ha l
ddr s d
he
t
r t hid ry
nt
gn th d srb to a d e c n e o Uni k y mu tb ma a e b a t id
a d l e itiu in n x ha g f t e s s e n g d y hr
.
pa t a nt d a t s ec tand e ns oft Uni Owner
ry ppoi e t he ol os
xpe e he t
.
Exh.A !1 1c, 1 1d) I addii t t spr son whih a is t s r c is s i
7.() 7.( . n
ton o hi ovii
c pple o evie s ue nr i nc t De a a i sa e t t t Hot l Uni Owne , ie. t Pl ntf Se a Hot
esde e, he clr ton tt s ha he
e
t
r . he ai if t i
el
Ac stonsI ,ma çr tmet tme...ha t e l i rght( nott oblgai t
quiii nc. y d om i o i
f
ve he xcusve i but he i ton) o
pr de hot l a o t a i nt r nt s vi es i udi but not lm ie t s i t ton a or
ovi
e nd/ r r ns e e al er c , ncl ng,
i t d o, olcia i nd/
pr son oft ho e e ng,pes na s r ies(.. masage pe s tai ng,dy ce ni
ovii
he uske pi
ro l e vc ie, s , ronal r ni r la ng,
ec. a orf a be r s r ce t t Condomi t a t Uni Ownes'Exh.A a !
t ) nd/ ood nd veage evi , o he
niun nd he t
r.'
t(
1 3. l i t Pli ifs e usve rghtt pr de t s a
6. t s he antf xcl i i o ovi he e meniis t t i cli s Def nda s
te ha t am
e nt
s d notbe pr vi ngt isr nt lg t .
houl
o di o t e a uess
Bas d on t l
e
he angua ofpa a a 16. g a i t Pl i i ft te l i r g ' t
ge
r gr ph 3 r ntng he a nt f he i xc us ve i ht' o
pr d t s t a to lho e a enii st guess, he Cour c nnotfnd t tt D e a a i n
ovi e he e r dii na t l m te o
t t
tn
i ha he cl r t o
p e ld sP an ifscamsa ti j n tr .
rcu e litf li t h s u ct e
l
#. Do st eu eo h S ti r c n ttt n mia ie aru e
e h s fte ea ma k o si e o n tv f i s ?
u
Def nda sm' t tisus o t Se a M a k on iswe ie t de c i t l to of
e nt gue ha t e f he t i r
t bst o s rbe he ocai n
u t a ia e f r nti a pe m isbl f i us tlhe f i us def ns , i es e e f bi a
nis val bl or e s
r s i e a r e. t- ar e e e n s nc , or ds
ta ma k r sr ntt a oprae a des rptvet r f ise l i us a s pr ve o he s
r de r egita o ppr i t
c i i e m or t xcusve e nd o e nt t r
fo a c rtl d s rbn a c r ce itc o t erg o s(rsr c s. 1 t1Stmp Ar,l c v
r m c u aey e c iig haa trsi f h i o d o evie l' n ' a
'
t n. .
US Po tlSe v,45 F.d 1 7 1 4 ( 1h Ci.2 0 )( i to o te ) A d fnd n c n
. sa r . 6 3 2 0, 27 1 t r 0 6 ct ins mitd . ee a t a
a
e t bls a f rus de e e i a def nda de
sa ih ai e f ns f
e nt monsr t t tisus i ot rt a am a k, i a
ta es ha t e s he han s
r n
de c i i s ns , a i g d f ih. 1 t ne c n us a t r s m a k t t uly t i ntf
s rptve e e nd n oo a t d. t
o
a
e no he '
r m hf l o de iy
a t rs g
no he ' oods or s r c i or r t de c i o c pa e is pr
e vies n de o s rbe r om r t odud t t m a k de '
o he r hol r s
p o u ' Bd. fs pe vs r o teLo san Sae Unv v S c Ap r l .43 F. u p. d
r d d.
' o u r io s f h uii a tt i. . ma k pa e Co , 8 S p 2
6 3 6 2 ( D.La 2 0 ) s eas Ne Kiso teBlc v Ne Ame ia Pu . n . 971F.d
5 , 6 E. . 0 6 ; e lo w d n h o k . w
rc b I c,
2
3 2 ( t Ci.1 9 )( p o dn an ws a e ' n mig o ab n Sl Ne Ki so t eBlc '
0 9h r 9 2 u h l ig e p p rs a n f a d %-he w d n h o k'
bec us t ewer nowor a lbl t de et bandot rt nbyisname)
a e her e
ds vaia e o not he
he ha
t
.
Re e ng t a lga i of t s Compl i , t Pli if has not s
vi wi he le tons
hi
ant he antf
hown how t
he
De e ntha us d The Se a ma k be
f nda
s e
t i r yond a f i us Pl i ifsbar al ga i onl sae t t
a r e. antf ' e le tons y t t ha
De e ntha çc e e a i e son of a fla i a horz ton,s
f nda
s tr atd n mpr s i
f iton, ut i a i pons s p,o c
orhi r ooper ton
ai
wi ( an it wh n i f c,no s c r lto hp e it. W ih u a y fcua e a ls te
t Plitf e , n a t
h
l
u h eains i x ss' t o t n a t l x mpe , h
'
Com pl i as e t Def nda s us of t Se ai m a k on is w e ie and e s w he e e e
a nt s rs
e nt ' e
he t
r
t
bst
l e r xt nds
be
yond whati t ea ona y ne es a y t i t f 't Set ir sD e enda sr nt The e a e no
s ç s bl c s r o den iy' he a oom
r
f
nt e .
r r
f c ualalega i i t Com pl n des i ng how Def ndan us t m ar be nd a i t
at
l tons n he
ai t crbi
e
t es he
k yo
s s he
Dee da tsc ne to t d s rb t eg o rphc llc to o t eu t. S h f rCo v I n o
fn n ' o tn in o e cie h e g a ia o ai n f h ni c a e . . n c
s
Mgmt Cor ,797 F.Su 477,481 ( D. C.1
. p.
pp.
E. N. 992)(i ng fi us docrne a iswhe
fndi ar e ti pple
n
maki us dt de ci ag a cl ton) W heet pladi f lt alegeus ofamak
r s e o s rbe eogrphi ocai .
r he e ngs ai o l
e
r
be
yond t f i us a i t ca ehe e,t pl i iff ist sa e a c am f whi r i c be
he a r e, s s he s r he antf a l o tt l i or ch elef an
ga td a ds sa wih u prj d c i a p o rae He se v Mf I c v Prprd ,I c,
rn e nd imis l t o t eu ie s p r p it. n ly . g. n . . o ie n .
57 F. 603,61 (t Ci.2009) Stv De gn I .v SBR Mkt ,L/ ,91 F.Supp.2d 111
9 3d
3 6h r
; e o si , nc .
g. t 9
f
2,
1 2 ( Ne 2 3 . Ac o dn l teCo r d s se wih u p eu ieteta e r cams
1 4 D. v. 01 ) c r igy,h u t imis s t o t rj dc h r d mak li
w ih l ve t r - ea i a A m e d Com pl i .
t ea o e pl d n n
nde
a nt
C.
Do sPl n t sa eacamf rtriu itre e c ?
e ait tt l i o o to s nef r n e
Unde Fl i lw,apli ifcami t to i eree mus ale ( )t e se
r orda a
antf li ng orius nt frnce t lge: 1 he xitnce
o a b sn s r lto s i () d fn a ts k wld e o t a b i s r lto hp; ( )
f u ie s eain hp; 2 ee d n ' no e g f h t usne s eains i 3
d fn n ' itni n la d u j tta l itre e c wih t a b i s rlto s p;a d ( )
ee da ts n e to a n nusiib e ne frn e t h t usne s eai n hi n 4
da
mage t pl ntf a a r ul. Romia- A,I v HSBC Bank USA,N. ,51 F.Supp.2d
s o ai if s es t
k us nc. .
A. 4
l
he se
nes ea i hi
1 3 , 1 3 ( . Fl.2 7 . Pli if has aleged t exit nce of a busi s r ltons p
3 4 3 9 SD. a 00 ) antf
bewe n t Uni Owne sa is f whih r ltons p i go r by t Dec a a i Pli if
t e he t
r nd tel, c e ai hi s ve ned
he
l r ton. antf
al ge t tt De l r ton i udesapr vii gr ntng Pl i ift e l i rghtt pr de
le s ha he c a a i ncl
o son a i
antf he xc usve i o ovi
hot la ta intr t l s r i e t t Se aiand Uni Owne s kncl ng c c i s r i es
e nd r nse en a e v c s o he t
t
r , t udi he k-n e v c ,
i
dal s r ce ,c ir a ma ketng s r i es' Pl ntf ale s t t De e nt kne t
iy e vi s once ge nd r i e v c . ai if l ge ha
'
f nda s w he
c t nt oft Deca ai and ne rhe e s t a ton t i e abr ac by t Uni Owne s
on e s he
lr ton
ve t l s , ook c i o nduc
e h
he t
r,
by e our i U ni O wne s t us D ef nda s ç or t a i r nt s vi s s h a c c i
nc ag ng
t
r o e
e nt d r ns ent e al er ce uc s he k-n
f
sr ie ,d iy s r ie ,c n ir e a d mak tng s r ie i ta o Plitf ' Plitf as
e vc s al e vc s o ceg n r ei evc s nse d f an io. anif lo
'
a lgest Uni Owne sus De e nt t Pli ifsdeti e t pr de t e s r i s The
le
he t
r ed f nda s o antf
rm nt o ovi hos e vce .
Cour fndst e al ga i s fc e t sae ac am f t tousi e f r nc
t i hes le tons ufi i nt o t t l i or ori nt re e e.
(
DON E AN D ORD ERED i Cha be s a M i m i Fl i , t s
n
m r t a , orda hi
of D e em be
c
r
201
6.
ep'
.
,
FED
l A ..
CO
,
NO
UNI SYXTES DI TRI J
TED
S CT UDGE
Co e f ni hed t
pi s ur s
o:
Cou e o Rec d
ns l f or
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?