Gelber v. Akal Security, Inc.

Filing 109

ORDER denying 102 Motion to Certify Class. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 3/1/2017. (kcg)

UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i Di so
mni vii n
C as N um ber:16e
23170- l - O R EN O
C V M

ELLI GELBER,a a1 o he ssm ia l
OT
nd l t r i lry
s t t d,
iua e
Pl i if ,
a nt f s
VS.

AK A L SECUR I , N C .
TY l ,
D ef
endant
.

ORDER DENYI PLAI FFS'M OTI TO RENG
NTI
ON
CERTI AS A NATI
FY
ONW I
DE
C O LLEC TI A C TI N
VE
O
THI CAUSE c
S
ame be or t Co t upon Pl i if ' M o i t Re- riy a
f e he ur
antfs
ton o
ce tf s

Nai deColeci Aci ( E.102) fldonFe uar 6.2017.
tonwi
l tve ton D.
, ie
br v
THE COU RT has c i e t m o i D e e nt s r s
ons der d he ton, f nda ' e pons i oppos ton, Pl i if
en
ii
a ntf s'
r pl pe tne po to oft r or , a be ng ot m i e f ly a s d i t pr m i es i i
e y, ri nt r i ns he ec d nd i
he s u l dvi e n he e s , t s

ADJUDGED t tt moton i DENI a t ne f c ss tf t i Pl i if 'm o i
ha he
i s
ED s he w a t e orh n antfs ton

ae i u ûce tt j tf nainwie c riiai n. Thed caain o a sn l e lye fo
r ns f in o usiy to d e t c to
f
e lrto f ig e mp o e r m

M ea Arz n s e uai t a ohe ars c rt o fc r b s d o ti o M imima j i te
s , io a p c ltng h t t r i e u iy fies a e usde f n
y on h
s ii n t n u h t j siyn to wi ec riiain.S eRo gesv CV Ph r , nc, . :5
ut s o e o g o u tf ain d e t c to e d r . S a m.l .No 80 f
CV - T- M SS, 2006 U . D i t LEXI 23272,a *1 ( . Fl M a .22,2006 .Loui770- 27
S. s .
S
t 5 M D. a. r
)
, s
Char e v.Su sentne Co. N o.07ls
n- i l ,
80621 Cl , 2008 U. Di LEXI 20030,a *5( D. a.
- V
S. M.
S
t S. Fl

M a .1 , 0 ) F rh r teo ti p ro co e o J n ay 3 , 7 Se g 7 , 6 . Th
r 4 2 08 . u te ,h p -n ei d ls d n a u r 0 201 . e DE 2 ! 1 e
a tona de a a i ofer d by Pl i if wa e cutd on Fe ua y 2, 201 a w a fl d on
ddii l clr ton f e
antfs s xe e
br r
7 nd s ie
Fe ua y 6,201 a t rt opt i pe i ha cl ed.
br r
7, f e he - n rod d os

D ON E A N D O RDERED i Cha be sa M i m i Fl i ,t s
n
m r t a , or da hi
..

-

.' .

:l

/ @WE
'
o
f
'

. '
'

.

v. '
.*
.
.

FEDE

.

'
-'

O A. ORENO
V

> 1 D STATES D I
STRI J
CT UDGE
Co e f nihed t
pis ur s
o:
Couns lofRec d
e
or

2

21 .
07
.