Westchester Fire Insurance Company v. Rolls-Royce Corporation et al

Filing 47

ORDER granting 35 Motion to Dismiss. Closing Case. Motions Terminated: 35 MOTION to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction 30 Amended Complaint, MOTION TO DISMISS 30 Amended Complaint, FOR FAILURE TO STATE A CLAIM fil ed by Vector Aerospace Helicopter Services, Inc.. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 9/26/2017. (mmd) NOTICE: If there are sealed documents in this case, they may be unsealed after 1 year or as directed by Court Order, unless they have been designated to be permanently sealed. See Local Rule 5.4 and Administrative Order 2014-69.

UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SO UTHERN D I
STRI OF FLO RI
CT
DA
M i iDi s on
am
vi i
C as N um be 1 2318 Cl - O R EN O
e
r: 69- V M
W ESTCH ESTER FI I SUM N CE
RE N
CO M PAN Y ,

Pli if
antf ,
VS.

VECTOR AEROSPACE,
D e e nt
f nda s.
O RD ER G R AN TI G M O TI N T O D I I
N
O
SM SS
Pl ntf W es c s e Fi e l ur nc Com pa fl d a br c of a t r pa t be f c a y
ai if
t he t r r ns a e
ny i e
ea h
hi d- r y ne i i r
e r d c a m a i tD e e n V edor Aer pa e. D e e ntV e orA e os ce i a Ca a
ont a l i ga ns f nda t
os c
f nda
d
r pa s
nadi n

coporton a i movi t dimisagui t Cour lckspe s j iditon. Pli ifha
r ai nd s
ng o s s r ng he
ta
ronal urs ci
antf s
notme isbur n t etbls pe s jlidito a Defnda ' contct wihFl i aenot
t t de o sa ih ronal trs cin s e nts a s t orda r
c i
ontnuous a s t a i e
nd ys em tc nough t m a Fl i hom e. The Cour al o fnds t Pl ntf has
o ke or da
t s i
he ai i f

n ts fiinl e pan d wh j rs ito ld s o ey wo l r me y t ej rs ito a is e
o u fce ty x lie y u id cina ic v r ud e d h u idcin l su .
Acc di y, he Cour gr nt t D ef nt sm o i t di m i st ndi t Cour l c pe s
or ngl t
t a s he enda ' ton o s s i ng he
t a ks r onal
J i di ton.
' s ci
ur
THI CA U SE c m e be or t Cour upon D e e
S
a
f e he
t
f ndant Vec or A e os ces M oton t
t
r pa '
i o

Dimis( E.35 ,fld o Fe uar 21.
s s D. ) ie n br y 2017.
TH E COU RT has consder t m oton,t r ponse peri
i ed he
i he es
tnentpori of t r
tons he ecord,

and be ng ot r i e f l advi e i t pr m i e ,i i
i
he w s uly
s d n he e s s t s
A DJU D G ED t t m oton i GR AN TED .
hat he
i s

Bac ound
kar

Pl i if W esche trFieI lr eCo pa i t s oge ofcli sbeong ngt is
antf, t se r nszanc m ny, s he ubr e
am
l i ot
i ur d,hePue t Ri El ti Powe Aut iy.l t Amende Com pl i , hePl i if
ns e t
ro co ecrc
r hort n he
d
ant t
antf
aleg t D e e ntV e t A e os e, Ca di n c pa per or ed i pe ton and
l es he f nda
c or r pac a na a om ny, f m
ns c i

m ant na e wor on t e nea f l t de e ta r i de e t i t e ne.Pl i if
i e nc
k
he ngi nd aied o t c nd epar f c s n he ngi
antf
al gest helco e owne by t Pue t Rio Elc rc Powe Aut iy s fr d a e ne
le he i pt r
d
he ro c e ti
r hort ufe e n ngi
f iur a c as d on J y 24, 5, es tng i at a l soft helco e .Pl i ifas e t
a l e nd r he
ul
201 r uli n ot l os
he i ptr antf s rs
onecli a i tDef nda Ve t rAe os ef br c oft t r pa t bene i ir c tac .
am ga ns
e nt c o r pac or ea h he hid- ry
fca y on r t
D e e ntV e t A e os c i m ovi t di m i st A m e d Com pl i as e tng
f nda
c or r pa e s
ng o s s he
nde
a nt s ri

t eei n p ro a j rs ito ,h cam i tmebard, n t ePlitf f ist saeacam
h r s o e s n lu id ci n te li s i - re a d h an if al o tt li
f br a h oft t r pa t bene i ir conta .
or e c
he hid- ry
fca y
r ct
l .Le St ndar
1 zal a
d
$To s vi am otont dimi s pl i if mus do m or t n me ey sa e lgal
1 ur ve
i o s s , antfs t
e ha
r l tt e
c l i ns'i t a pl i if mus dal s
oncuso , nse d antfs
'
t klege ome s ii f t ba i f t ec usonsor
pecfc acual s s or hos oncl i

fcedimis loft i cli . Jac s v Bel h Tee omm. 372F.d 1
a s sa her ams' k on . lsout lc
'
,
3 250,1 ( 1hCi.
263 1 t r

2 0 ) W h nr ln o amoint d s s , c u t t e tec mpliti t el h mo t
0 4 . e u ig n
to o imis a o r mus viw h o an n h i t s
g
f vorbl t t pl i ifand a ce t pli ifswel- e ded f c sa tue.Se St Jos ph'
a a e o he antf
c pt he a ntf
lpl a
at s r
e . e s

Hop.I c v Hop. r o , 9 F. 9 , 5 ( 1hCi.1 8 ) Thi tn t h we e , e
s , n . . s Cop.fAm.7 5 2d 48 9 3 1 t r 9 6 . s e e , o v r do s
n ta p yt lg l o cuso .S eAs c ot . q a ,l 9 S. .1 3 ,1 4 ( 0 9 .M o e v r
o p l o e a c n l ins e h rj v I b l 2 Ct 9 7 9 9 2 0 ) ro e ,
iwl ielg l o cu in c np o d tefa wo ko ac mpan ,h ymu t es p o tdb
s h l e a c n lso s a r vie h rme r f o litt e s b u p re y
g
f cua algai ' l a 1
a t l le tons. d t 950. Thos 'facualal ainsmus beenoug t riearg t
'
e ' j t leg to
g
t
h o as iht o
r le a
e i f bove t s c a i l ve on t a s pton t ta 1oft c pl ntsalega i ar
he pe ul tve e l he s um i ha 1
he om ai ' l tons e

tue. BelAt.Cor v.Twombl 550U. 544,5 ( ) l s tt c antmus not
r ' l l p.
'
y,
S.
45 2007 . n hor,he ompli
t

2

mer l aleg am iconduc ,butmus de
ey l e
s
t
t monsr t t tt pl deri e il d t r i f Se I al
ta e ha he ea s ntte o ele . e qb ,
1 S.Ct a 1
29
. t 950.
11 LeaalAnal i
1.
vs s
A . PersonalJuri ct on
sdi i

Fe r c t or naiyf l sae1 i deemi ngt ij idito overpes ns
deal ours di rl olow tt aw n tr ni her urs cins
ro ,

s ln a tee ecs o j rs ito i c n itn wi f d rld ep o e srq ie n s Se
o o g s h x r ie f u idcin s o sse t t e ea u r c s e ur me t . e
h
F d. Ci . 4()1( ' i e AG v Ba ma ,1 4 S Ct 7 , 5 - 4( 01 ) Th Co r
e R. v P. k ( )A) Damlr . u n 3 . . 46 7 3 5 2 4 . e u t
,
teeo e lo t teFlrd lnga m sauet d tr n wh t e t r ij rs ito o e
h rf r ,o ks o h o ia o -r ttt o eemi e eh r hee s u id ci n v r
Vecori t sc s .Scult r l .v Cent yArs Lt ,9 F. 6 626- ( 1h Ci.1 .
t n hi a e
p chai, nc . ur t, d 4 3d 23, 27 1 t r 996)

Plitf ag e isc s a an t fn a t co flsu e ter b i o g n r l u idcin
an if r u s t ae g is Dee d n Ve t r al nd r h u rc f e e a j rs ito
t e F o iaSauej48 1 3 2 , ihp r t g n rl u idci no e af rindee d n
md r lrd tt t
.9 4 )wh c emis e e a j rs ito v r o eg fn a t
t tCse ged i s t nta and notiol t a tviy'i Fl i and û t rornott y
ha d nga
i
n ubsa il
s aed c i t 'n orda
ç he
whe
he
i v t def nda ' ac i te i Fl i ' Car che v Tam bor ee M gm t,789 F. 1 ,
nvol e he e nt s tvii s n orda.'
mou
.
l
3d 201

1 0 ( 1hCi. 5 .tf er a ho t sp o iine tnd t telmi o p ro a j rs ito
2 4 1 t r 201 ) k h e c f hi r vso xe s o h i t n e s n l uidcin
s
i pos d by t D ue Pr es Cl us oft Fouree h A m endm en . Se Fr s r v. ih,594
m
e
he
oc s a e he
t nt
t' e a e Sm t
'

F.d8 , 46( 1h Ci. 01 ) W i r s e tt g n r lu id cinu d rFlrd ' l n -r
3 42 8 1 t r 2 0 . t e p c o e ea j rs ito n e o ia s o g am
h
saue,heeor,t Cour mus deemi whehert execs ofpe s j iditonove
ttt t rf e he
t t tr ne t he rie
ronalurs ci
r
Ve t re e co tt i bounds n s doi t Cou tnot st ti i apl ntf bu de
c o xc eds nsiutonal
.l o ng, he
r e ha t s ai ifs r n

t etbihp ro a j rs ito . d l v Pu bodeBa aLo a, . , 5 F.d 1 1 ,1 1
o sa ls e s n lu id ci n Olhed . e l
hi r SA.5 8 3 2 0 2 7
( 1hCi.2009)
1t r
.
Ge r j iditonal fde a c t t hea c esagans f eg c porto whe
nealurs ci lows e r l ours o r as
i t orin or ains n
t i i fii tons wih t St t a e s l ontnuous a s t m a i ast r nde t m e s i ly
he r l tla i
a
t he a e r o c i
nd ys e tc' o e r he s enta l

a homei t f um Stt 'Dai e ,1 S.Ctat754( i Good arDu o Tie
t
n he or
ae.' mlr 34
.
quotng
ye
nlp r s
Ope atons S. v Br
r i , A. . own,56 U. 91 91 ( 1) Good arclrfe t td y almie
4 S. 5, 9 201 ).
ye aiid ha t
onl i td

s tofafii tonswih af um wilr nde adef nta
e
flai
t or
l e r
enda mena et albl o l

p r s j rs cin
u po e u idito

t r .' mlr 1 S.Ct a 760. Ce t i y,a c por ton' pl c ofi m or ton a
he e'Dai e , 34
.t
r a nl
or a i s a e nco a i nd

p icp l lc o b sn s aet a e f rg n r l u idcin. Dai e , 134 S.Ct at760. l
rn ia pa e f u ie s r s s s o e e a j rs ito ' mlr
b
'
.
n
t sc s ,i i undipu e t tDe e ntVe t i noti or a ed i Fl i , nordoesi ha
hi a e t s
s t d ha f nda
c or s
nc por t n orda
t ve
isprnci lplc ofbusne she e. Tha bei t c e,Good ari tucst Cour t
t i pa a e
i s r
t ng he as
ye nsr t he
to
e m i w he he t tcor a i s ( fi i tonsw ih t St t a e s û i
xa ne
t r ha
por ton' l tla i
a
t he a e r o contnuousand s t m a i
ys e tc'

a t rnd r(t e sn il a h mei tetr m Sae'l ( oi Go d a , 6 U. a 91 )
s o e e i) se tal t o n h b u tt . d qu tng o ye r 5 4 S. t 9
y
'
.

Puta he w a t spl i if lke t D ai e pl i if i r quesi t Cour l
not r y, hi a ntf , i he
ml r a ntf , s e
tng he
t ook

be
yondt ee
hos xemplr , hepl c ofi or a i a t prncpa pl ceofbusnes , a
as t
a e nc por ton nd he i i l a
i s nd

a p o tee ecs o g n r lu idci nb s d o t ed tr n to t t co ' c na t i
p rve h x rie f e ea j rs ito a e n h eemiain ha Ve trs o tcs n
Fl i a e s C ntnuous a s t m a i ' ast r nde i es e i ly athom e he e. 1 ('otng
or da r o û i
co
nd ys e tc ' o e r t s nta l
r d. q i
u

Good ar 56 U. a 91 .TheDai erCour a dt ti ata nai c e ,a i t
ye , 4 S. t 9)
ml
t dde ha n rns tonal ontxt s s he
c s he e,f de alc t m us a s he prncpl ofi e na i lcomiy a s d no e pl
a e r e r ours t lo ed i i es nt r tona
t nd houl t m oy

a e p n iev e o g n r lu id ci n 1 a 7 3( li t eewa n g n r lu id dini
n x a sv iw f e ea j rs ito . d. t 6 hodng h r s o e e a j rs i o n
Caior aove cl msaii i Ar ntnaa ns aGe ma c porton)
lf ni r ai rsng n ge i gai t r n or ai .
M i uloft sgui nc t Cour l
ndf
hi da e, he
t ookst t c a t Vecorha w ih Fl i t
o he ont c s t
s t orda o
dee m i whehe isc a t wih Fl i a e s Sc i
tr ne
t r t ont c s t orda r o contnuousand s t m ai 'ast r nde i a
yse tc' o e r t t
hom ehe e. V e t ge r t d 1 9% ofis 201 a 2.9% of is 201 r ve f om Fl i l
r
c or ne a e .
t
4 nd
t
5 e nue r
orda.

Pl ntf a s alege t tVecorpari pa e i ta s
ai if l o l s ha
t
tci t d n r de howsi W e tPam Be h, St.A ugus i
n s l
ac
tne,
a Ora
nd lndo,Fl i Pl i ifa s as e t t ti or ton on Ve t ' we iei ntlesSc t
orda. antf lo s rs ha nf ma i
c ors bst de i
ot
M cEwen a t Regi lSa esM a gera M i Br n ast Sa e a Ser ce M a erf r
s he
ona l
na
nd ke ow
he l nd vi
nag o
Fl i
orda. The Pl i i fdoesnota s r t tt e e pl e ha a ofi e i Fl i ora e
a ntf
s e t ha hos m oye s ve n f c n or da r
lW ihou a e de ir s
t t ny vi ntay uppor, Pli ifconcl t tat
t antf
udes ha lhought er venuepe c t
hes e
r enagesa el ,t y m a
r ow he y
a ual c r s
ct ly ore pondt lr dola a ount gene ae i Fl i . Cai z v Am .Ro ArsCoy ,73 So.3 245
o age lr m
s
r td n orda
az o .
yal t r
d

2 9( l. t DCA 2 1.
5 Fa 4h
01 )

,

l ca ed i Fl r da. Beyond t e f t , he Pl i ifdoesnota l e a ot rcon a t w ih
o t n oi
hes ac s t
a ntf
leg ny he
tcs t

Flrda Plitf, o v r r q sst eCo r alw j rs ito l ic v r s ta i c nr b t
o i . an if h we e ,e uet h u t lo u idcina d s o ey o h t t a e u
t as e to madeby Pa Coc l i hi de lr ton i s
he s ri ns
ul ke l n s ca ai n uppor oft m oto t dim is l
t he i n o s s . n
t tde a a i M r Coc l a s r st tV e t doe notl a e orow n pr ry i Fl i doe
ha cl r ton, . ke l s e t ha c or s
es
ope t n orda, s

notha a te t a Fl i fna i i tt i , sne re ged i m a ke i
ve ny i s o ny orda i ncal nsiutons ha ve nga
n r tng
e l i l i Fl i and ha ne r de i d a pr
xc us ve y n orda,
s ve s gne
oduc o s r c f s l i Fl r da. The Cour
t r e vi e or a e n o i
t

a e swih t Def nda t tt ef csa e i ufi e t fnd t tVecori a d
gr e t he e nt ha hes a t r ns tcint o i ha
t s tt
home'i
'n

F oi a Th q sini wh t rteCo r wi alw Plitf j rs ito a ds o r t
lrd . e ueto s ehe h u t l lo an if u idcin l ic vey o
l
butr s isposton.
tes t
ii

1. J i ditona Dicove v
urs c i l s r

Sg e r lc t ha t powe t or r a t i dicei t dico r offct
iFlde a ours ve he
r o de , t her s rton,he s vey a s
ne e s yt a c ti t i c
c s ar o s eran he r ompe e t e e ti t mert . Eat v Dor se De ,I .
t ncy o nt ran he is' on . che tr v. nc,
'

692F. 727, ( 1h Ci.1 .J iditona dic r i or rdwher t ei adiput
2d
729 1 t r 982) urs ci l s ovey s dee
e her s s e

c n enigj rs ito l a t.Be n r eev Bo o io 6 8F. u p. d 1 3 1 21( D. l.
o c r n u idcina f cs r a d l . n rn , 0 S p 2 31 , 3 S. F a
2009) A pli ift tr ssj idito ldicoveymus tstf t s ii i omai ...
. antf ha equet urs cina s r
tte orh pecfc nfr ton

t a wil sa ls p ro a j rs ito 'Za r Ra i, LC.. a tm LT , 092 4 h t l e tb ih es n l u idcin. mo a do L v f sf D.No. -09 0
'
CI 2 1W L 2 8 401 a *1 ( D. a J e28 2 1 .Th r mu tb ac n e to b t e
V, 01
5 0 , t 1 S. Fl.un , 01 ) ee s e o n ci n ewe n
t d s o eys ug ta dj rs ito Ute v Ne En M u. 4?I s Co, s No. 7 01 9
he ic v r o h n u idcin. sy . w g. tL/ n . .Ca e 0 - 9 W S- ,2007W L 1
M
07670 a * ( D. a. i 9,2007 (s- r i noabs ut rg t
3, t 2 S. Al Aprl
) d-hee s
l
ol e iht o

c n c j rs cina d s o r id e , o t h v r uieyd nid s c r q e t i t e
o du t uidito l ic vey;n e d c urs a e o tn l e e u h e u ss n h
a e eofa s ii s ngbyt mo ntesa ihi t ne d frs ';nsaboo
bs nc ny pecfc howi
he va tbls ng he e o ame.) I t k
'
Cor v. n t publs ncom, F.
p. l sant ihe
469 Supp.2d 11 11 ( . Fl 2006)( ngrques f
20, 27 M D. a.
denyi e t or

j rs cina d so ey, n g a tn d f n a tsmoint d s s f rlc o j rs ito
u idito l ic v r a d rn ig ee d n ' to o imis o a k f u idcin,
whe pli ifdi no s how s hdic r woul boltrisposton)
n antf d t how
uc s ovey
d se t ii .
5

l t s c e,t Pl i ifdi no pr de isow' a f da ta want di cove y t û e tt
n hi as he a ntf d t ovi t n f i vi nd
s s
r o d s he
t
ve a t oft s at m e s m a by' PaulCoc l i s
r ciy he t e nt de '
ke l n uppor of t m oton t di m i s Br
t he
i o s s . own v
.

Car v Cor ,20 F.Supp.3d 1 1 ( D.Fl.201 . I Br
nial p. 2
332, 346 S. a 6) n own,J
udgeUngao di not
r d

alw j rs ito a dic v r h li t e panifsf i r t iv siaej rs ito a is e
lo u idcin l s o ey odng h litf al e o n e tg t u idcin l su s
u

p irt fln s i d e n tgv rs t ag n iej rs ito a ds ue S eas T o o v
ro o iig ut o s o ie ie o e un u id ci n l ip t. e lo h mps n .
Car v Cor ,No.1 CV- 1 201 W L 1
nial p.
5- 241 5, 6
24228 a * ( D.Fl M a .30,201 ( oor
0, t 7 S. a. r
6) M e,

J)(x rii gd s rto a dn tal wi gj rs ito a d s o ey .
. e ecsn ic ei n n o lo n u idci n l ic v r )
Thi Cou tdoes not f nd i a oprat t pr de Pl i if a oppo t t t e
s
r
i t ppr i e o ovi
a ntf n
r uniy o ngag i
e n

j rs it n lds o e y b c u e Sh r i n g n ie ds ue o amae il u idcina f c t
uid ci a ic v r e a s s e e s o e un ip t n
o
t
tra j rs ito l a t o
warntdico r ' Pe u r v Aibu ,S. S.83F.Supp.3d 1 1 ( D.Fl 201 .
ra s vey.' r ye o . r s A. ,
283, 290 S. a. 4)
D ON E A N D ORD ERED i Cham ber at M i i Fl i t s
n
s
am , orda, hi

201
7.

( oSpme
0 fet br
e

.''e

.*
'..
..J
., '
..
...

e,
...

.

:' Z .

.-

..

f.(.
,'
..

FEDERI
CO .M OP,
E
UNI
TED STATES DI
' STRI J
CT UDGE
.'

'
..

Co e f nihedt
pis ur s
o:
Cou e ofRe or
ns l
c d

6