Westchester Fire Insurance Company v. Rolls-Royce Corporation et al
Filing
47
ORDER granting 35 Motion to Dismiss. Closing Case. Motions Terminated: 35 MOTION to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction 30 Amended Complaint, MOTION TO DISMISS 30 Amended Complaint, FOR FAILURE TO STATE A CLAIM fil ed by Vector Aerospace Helicopter Services, Inc.. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 9/26/2017. (mmd) NOTICE: If there are sealed documents in this case, they may be unsealed after 1 year or as directed by Court Order, unless they have been designated to be permanently sealed. See Local Rule 5.4 and Administrative Order 2014-69.
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SO UTHERN D I
STRI OF FLO RI
CT
DA
M i iDi s on
am
vi i
C as N um be 1 2318 Cl - O R EN O
e
r: 69- V M
W ESTCH ESTER FI I SUM N CE
RE N
CO M PAN Y ,
Pli if
antf ,
VS.
VECTOR AEROSPACE,
D e e nt
f nda s.
O RD ER G R AN TI G M O TI N T O D I I
N
O
SM SS
Pl ntf W es c s e Fi e l ur nc Com pa fl d a br c of a t r pa t be f c a y
ai if
t he t r r ns a e
ny i e
ea h
hi d- r y ne i i r
e r d c a m a i tD e e n V edor Aer pa e. D e e ntV e orA e os ce i a Ca a
ont a l i ga ns f nda t
os c
f nda
d
r pa s
nadi n
coporton a i movi t dimisagui t Cour lckspe s j iditon. Pli ifha
r ai nd s
ng o s s r ng he
ta
ronal urs ci
antf s
notme isbur n t etbls pe s jlidito a Defnda ' contct wihFl i aenot
t t de o sa ih ronal trs cin s e nts a s t orda r
c i
ontnuous a s t a i e
nd ys em tc nough t m a Fl i hom e. The Cour al o fnds t Pl ntf has
o ke or da
t s i
he ai i f
n ts fiinl e pan d wh j rs ito ld s o ey wo l r me y t ej rs ito a is e
o u fce ty x lie y u id cina ic v r ud e d h u idcin l su .
Acc di y, he Cour gr nt t D ef nt sm o i t di m i st ndi t Cour l c pe s
or ngl t
t a s he enda ' ton o s s i ng he
t a ks r onal
J i di ton.
' s ci
ur
THI CA U SE c m e be or t Cour upon D e e
S
a
f e he
t
f ndant Vec or A e os ces M oton t
t
r pa '
i o
Dimis( E.35 ,fld o Fe uar 21.
s s D. ) ie n br y 2017.
TH E COU RT has consder t m oton,t r ponse peri
i ed he
i he es
tnentpori of t r
tons he ecord,
and be ng ot r i e f l advi e i t pr m i e ,i i
i
he w s uly
s d n he e s s t s
A DJU D G ED t t m oton i GR AN TED .
hat he
i s
Bac ound
kar
Pl i if W esche trFieI lr eCo pa i t s oge ofcli sbeong ngt is
antf, t se r nszanc m ny, s he ubr e
am
l i ot
i ur d,hePue t Ri El ti Powe Aut iy.l t Amende Com pl i , hePl i if
ns e t
ro co ecrc
r hort n he
d
ant t
antf
aleg t D e e ntV e t A e os e, Ca di n c pa per or ed i pe ton and
l es he f nda
c or r pac a na a om ny, f m
ns c i
m ant na e wor on t e nea f l t de e ta r i de e t i t e ne.Pl i if
i e nc
k
he ngi nd aied o t c nd epar f c s n he ngi
antf
al gest helco e owne by t Pue t Rio Elc rc Powe Aut iy s fr d a e ne
le he i pt r
d
he ro c e ti
r hort ufe e n ngi
f iur a c as d on J y 24, 5, es tng i at a l soft helco e .Pl i ifas e t
a l e nd r he
ul
201 r uli n ot l os
he i ptr antf s rs
onecli a i tDef nda Ve t rAe os ef br c oft t r pa t bene i ir c tac .
am ga ns
e nt c o r pac or ea h he hid- ry
fca y on r t
D e e ntV e t A e os c i m ovi t di m i st A m e d Com pl i as e tng
f nda
c or r pa e s
ng o s s he
nde
a nt s ri
t eei n p ro a j rs ito ,h cam i tmebard, n t ePlitf f ist saeacam
h r s o e s n lu id ci n te li s i - re a d h an if al o tt li
f br a h oft t r pa t bene i ir conta .
or e c
he hid- ry
fca y
r ct
l .Le St ndar
1 zal a
d
$To s vi am otont dimi s pl i if mus do m or t n me ey sa e lgal
1 ur ve
i o s s , antfs t
e ha
r l tt e
c l i ns'i t a pl i if mus dal s
oncuso , nse d antfs
'
t klege ome s ii f t ba i f t ec usonsor
pecfc acual s s or hos oncl i
fcedimis loft i cli . Jac s v Bel h Tee omm. 372F.d 1
a s sa her ams' k on . lsout lc
'
,
3 250,1 ( 1hCi.
263 1 t r
2 0 ) W h nr ln o amoint d s s , c u t t e tec mpliti t el h mo t
0 4 . e u ig n
to o imis a o r mus viw h o an n h i t s
g
f vorbl t t pl i ifand a ce t pli ifswel- e ded f c sa tue.Se St Jos ph'
a a e o he antf
c pt he a ntf
lpl a
at s r
e . e s
Hop.I c v Hop. r o , 9 F. 9 , 5 ( 1hCi.1 8 ) Thi tn t h we e , e
s , n . . s Cop.fAm.7 5 2d 48 9 3 1 t r 9 6 . s e e , o v r do s
n ta p yt lg l o cuso .S eAs c ot . q a ,l 9 S. .1 3 ,1 4 ( 0 9 .M o e v r
o p l o e a c n l ins e h rj v I b l 2 Ct 9 7 9 9 2 0 ) ro e ,
iwl ielg l o cu in c np o d tefa wo ko ac mpan ,h ymu t es p o tdb
s h l e a c n lso s a r vie h rme r f o litt e s b u p re y
g
f cua algai ' l a 1
a t l le tons. d t 950. Thos 'facualal ainsmus beenoug t riearg t
'
e ' j t leg to
g
t
h o as iht o
r le a
e i f bove t s c a i l ve on t a s pton t ta 1oft c pl ntsalega i ar
he pe ul tve e l he s um i ha 1
he om ai ' l tons e
tue. BelAt.Cor v.Twombl 550U. 544,5 ( ) l s tt c antmus not
r ' l l p.
'
y,
S.
45 2007 . n hor,he ompli
t
2
mer l aleg am iconduc ,butmus de
ey l e
s
t
t monsr t t tt pl deri e il d t r i f Se I al
ta e ha he ea s ntte o ele . e qb ,
1 S.Ct a 1
29
. t 950.
11 LeaalAnal i
1.
vs s
A . PersonalJuri ct on
sdi i
Fe r c t or naiyf l sae1 i deemi ngt ij idito overpes ns
deal ours di rl olow tt aw n tr ni her urs cins
ro ,
s ln a tee ecs o j rs ito i c n itn wi f d rld ep o e srq ie n s Se
o o g s h x r ie f u idcin s o sse t t e ea u r c s e ur me t . e
h
F d. Ci . 4()1( ' i e AG v Ba ma ,1 4 S Ct 7 , 5 - 4( 01 ) Th Co r
e R. v P. k ( )A) Damlr . u n 3 . . 46 7 3 5 2 4 . e u t
,
teeo e lo t teFlrd lnga m sauet d tr n wh t e t r ij rs ito o e
h rf r ,o ks o h o ia o -r ttt o eemi e eh r hee s u id ci n v r
Vecori t sc s .Scult r l .v Cent yArs Lt ,9 F. 6 626- ( 1h Ci.1 .
t n hi a e
p chai, nc . ur t, d 4 3d 23, 27 1 t r 996)
Plitf ag e isc s a an t fn a t co flsu e ter b i o g n r l u idcin
an if r u s t ae g is Dee d n Ve t r al nd r h u rc f e e a j rs ito
t e F o iaSauej48 1 3 2 , ihp r t g n rl u idci no e af rindee d n
md r lrd tt t
.9 4 )wh c emis e e a j rs ito v r o eg fn a t
t tCse ged i s t nta and notiol t a tviy'i Fl i and û t rornott y
ha d nga
i
n ubsa il
s aed c i t 'n orda
ç he
whe
he
i v t def nda ' ac i te i Fl i ' Car che v Tam bor ee M gm t,789 F. 1 ,
nvol e he e nt s tvii s n orda.'
mou
.
l
3d 201
1 0 ( 1hCi. 5 .tf er a ho t sp o iine tnd t telmi o p ro a j rs ito
2 4 1 t r 201 ) k h e c f hi r vso xe s o h i t n e s n l uidcin
s
i pos d by t D ue Pr es Cl us oft Fouree h A m endm en . Se Fr s r v. ih,594
m
e
he
oc s a e he
t nt
t' e a e Sm t
'
F.d8 , 46( 1h Ci. 01 ) W i r s e tt g n r lu id cinu d rFlrd ' l n -r
3 42 8 1 t r 2 0 . t e p c o e ea j rs ito n e o ia s o g am
h
saue,heeor,t Cour mus deemi whehert execs ofpe s j iditonove
ttt t rf e he
t t tr ne t he rie
ronalurs ci
r
Ve t re e co tt i bounds n s doi t Cou tnot st ti i apl ntf bu de
c o xc eds nsiutonal
.l o ng, he
r e ha t s ai ifs r n
t etbihp ro a j rs ito . d l v Pu bodeBa aLo a, . , 5 F.d 1 1 ,1 1
o sa ls e s n lu id ci n Olhed . e l
hi r SA.5 8 3 2 0 2 7
( 1hCi.2009)
1t r
.
Ge r j iditonal fde a c t t hea c esagans f eg c porto whe
nealurs ci lows e r l ours o r as
i t orin or ains n
t i i fii tons wih t St t a e s l ontnuous a s t m a i ast r nde t m e s i ly
he r l tla i
a
t he a e r o c i
nd ys e tc' o e r he s enta l
a homei t f um Stt 'Dai e ,1 S.Ctat754( i Good arDu o Tie
t
n he or
ae.' mlr 34
.
quotng
ye
nlp r s
Ope atons S. v Br
r i , A. . own,56 U. 91 91 ( 1) Good arclrfe t td y almie
4 S. 5, 9 201 ).
ye aiid ha t
onl i td
s tofafii tonswih af um wilr nde adef nta
e
flai
t or
l e r
enda mena et albl o l
p r s j rs cin
u po e u idito
t r .' mlr 1 S.Ct a 760. Ce t i y,a c por ton' pl c ofi m or ton a
he e'Dai e , 34
.t
r a nl
or a i s a e nco a i nd
p icp l lc o b sn s aet a e f rg n r l u idcin. Dai e , 134 S.Ct at760. l
rn ia pa e f u ie s r s s s o e e a j rs ito ' mlr
b
'
.
n
t sc s ,i i undipu e t tDe e ntVe t i noti or a ed i Fl i , nordoesi ha
hi a e t s
s t d ha f nda
c or s
nc por t n orda
t ve
isprnci lplc ofbusne she e. Tha bei t c e,Good ari tucst Cour t
t i pa a e
i s r
t ng he as
ye nsr t he
to
e m i w he he t tcor a i s ( fi i tonsw ih t St t a e s û i
xa ne
t r ha
por ton' l tla i
a
t he a e r o contnuousand s t m a i
ys e tc'
a t rnd r(t e sn il a h mei tetr m Sae'l ( oi Go d a , 6 U. a 91 )
s o e e i) se tal t o n h b u tt . d qu tng o ye r 5 4 S. t 9
y
'
.
Puta he w a t spl i if lke t D ai e pl i if i r quesi t Cour l
not r y, hi a ntf , i he
ml r a ntf , s e
tng he
t ook
be
yondt ee
hos xemplr , hepl c ofi or a i a t prncpa pl ceofbusnes , a
as t
a e nc por ton nd he i i l a
i s nd
a p o tee ecs o g n r lu idci nb s d o t ed tr n to t t co ' c na t i
p rve h x rie f e ea j rs ito a e n h eemiain ha Ve trs o tcs n
Fl i a e s C ntnuous a s t m a i ' ast r nde i es e i ly athom e he e. 1 ('otng
or da r o û i
co
nd ys e tc ' o e r t s nta l
r d. q i
u
Good ar 56 U. a 91 .TheDai erCour a dt ti ata nai c e ,a i t
ye , 4 S. t 9)
ml
t dde ha n rns tonal ontxt s s he
c s he e,f de alc t m us a s he prncpl ofi e na i lcomiy a s d no e pl
a e r e r ours t lo ed i i es nt r tona
t nd houl t m oy
a e p n iev e o g n r lu id ci n 1 a 7 3( li t eewa n g n r lu id dini
n x a sv iw f e ea j rs ito . d. t 6 hodng h r s o e e a j rs i o n
Caior aove cl msaii i Ar ntnaa ns aGe ma c porton)
lf ni r ai rsng n ge i gai t r n or ai .
M i uloft sgui nc t Cour l
ndf
hi da e, he
t ookst t c a t Vecorha w ih Fl i t
o he ont c s t
s t orda o
dee m i whehe isc a t wih Fl i a e s Sc i
tr ne
t r t ont c s t orda r o contnuousand s t m ai 'ast r nde i a
yse tc' o e r t t
hom ehe e. V e t ge r t d 1 9% ofis 201 a 2.9% of is 201 r ve f om Fl i l
r
c or ne a e .
t
4 nd
t
5 e nue r
orda.
Pl ntf a s alege t tVecorpari pa e i ta s
ai if l o l s ha
t
tci t d n r de howsi W e tPam Be h, St.A ugus i
n s l
ac
tne,
a Ora
nd lndo,Fl i Pl i ifa s as e t t ti or ton on Ve t ' we iei ntlesSc t
orda. antf lo s rs ha nf ma i
c ors bst de i
ot
M cEwen a t Regi lSa esM a gera M i Br n ast Sa e a Ser ce M a erf r
s he
ona l
na
nd ke ow
he l nd vi
nag o
Fl i
orda. The Pl i i fdoesnota s r t tt e e pl e ha a ofi e i Fl i ora e
a ntf
s e t ha hos m oye s ve n f c n or da r
lW ihou a e de ir s
t t ny vi ntay uppor, Pli ifconcl t tat
t antf
udes ha lhought er venuepe c t
hes e
r enagesa el ,t y m a
r ow he y
a ual c r s
ct ly ore pondt lr dola a ount gene ae i Fl i . Cai z v Am .Ro ArsCoy ,73 So.3 245
o age lr m
s
r td n orda
az o .
yal t r
d
2 9( l. t DCA 2 1.
5 Fa 4h
01 )
,
l ca ed i Fl r da. Beyond t e f t , he Pl i ifdoesnota l e a ot rcon a t w ih
o t n oi
hes ac s t
a ntf
leg ny he
tcs t
Flrda Plitf, o v r r q sst eCo r alw j rs ito l ic v r s ta i c nr b t
o i . an if h we e ,e uet h u t lo u idcina d s o ey o h t t a e u
t as e to madeby Pa Coc l i hi de lr ton i s
he s ri ns
ul ke l n s ca ai n uppor oft m oto t dim is l
t he i n o s s . n
t tde a a i M r Coc l a s r st tV e t doe notl a e orow n pr ry i Fl i doe
ha cl r ton, . ke l s e t ha c or s
es
ope t n orda, s
notha a te t a Fl i fna i i tt i , sne re ged i m a ke i
ve ny i s o ny orda i ncal nsiutons ha ve nga
n r tng
e l i l i Fl i and ha ne r de i d a pr
xc us ve y n orda,
s ve s gne
oduc o s r c f s l i Fl r da. The Cour
t r e vi e or a e n o i
t
a e swih t Def nda t tt ef csa e i ufi e t fnd t tVecori a d
gr e t he e nt ha hes a t r ns tcint o i ha
t s tt
home'i
'n
F oi a Th q sini wh t rteCo r wi alw Plitf j rs ito a ds o r t
lrd . e ueto s ehe h u t l lo an if u idcin l ic vey o
l
butr s isposton.
tes t
ii
1. J i ditona Dicove v
urs c i l s r
Sg e r lc t ha t powe t or r a t i dicei t dico r offct
iFlde a ours ve he
r o de , t her s rton,he s vey a s
ne e s yt a c ti t i c
c s ar o s eran he r ompe e t e e ti t mert . Eat v Dor se De ,I .
t ncy o nt ran he is' on . che tr v. nc,
'
692F. 727, ( 1h Ci.1 .J iditona dic r i or rdwher t ei adiput
2d
729 1 t r 982) urs ci l s ovey s dee
e her s s e
c n enigj rs ito l a t.Be n r eev Bo o io 6 8F. u p. d 1 3 1 21( D. l.
o c r n u idcina f cs r a d l . n rn , 0 S p 2 31 , 3 S. F a
2009) A pli ift tr ssj idito ldicoveymus tstf t s ii i omai ...
. antf ha equet urs cina s r
tte orh pecfc nfr ton
t a wil sa ls p ro a j rs ito 'Za r Ra i, LC.. a tm LT , 092 4 h t l e tb ih es n l u idcin. mo a do L v f sf D.No. -09 0
'
CI 2 1W L 2 8 401 a *1 ( D. a J e28 2 1 .Th r mu tb ac n e to b t e
V, 01
5 0 , t 1 S. Fl.un , 01 ) ee s e o n ci n ewe n
t d s o eys ug ta dj rs ito Ute v Ne En M u. 4?I s Co, s No. 7 01 9
he ic v r o h n u idcin. sy . w g. tL/ n . .Ca e 0 - 9 W S- ,2007W L 1
M
07670 a * ( D. a. i 9,2007 (s- r i noabs ut rg t
3, t 2 S. Al Aprl
) d-hee s
l
ol e iht o
c n c j rs cina d s o r id e , o t h v r uieyd nid s c r q e t i t e
o du t uidito l ic vey;n e d c urs a e o tn l e e u h e u ss n h
a e eofa s ii s ngbyt mo ntesa ihi t ne d frs ';nsaboo
bs nc ny pecfc howi
he va tbls ng he e o ame.) I t k
'
Cor v. n t publs ncom, F.
p. l sant ihe
469 Supp.2d 11 11 ( . Fl 2006)( ngrques f
20, 27 M D. a.
denyi e t or
j rs cina d so ey, n g a tn d f n a tsmoint d s s f rlc o j rs ito
u idito l ic v r a d rn ig ee d n ' to o imis o a k f u idcin,
whe pli ifdi no s how s hdic r woul boltrisposton)
n antf d t how
uc s ovey
d se t ii .
5
l t s c e,t Pl i ifdi no pr de isow' a f da ta want di cove y t û e tt
n hi as he a ntf d t ovi t n f i vi nd
s s
r o d s he
t
ve a t oft s at m e s m a by' PaulCoc l i s
r ciy he t e nt de '
ke l n uppor of t m oton t di m i s Br
t he
i o s s . own v
.
Car v Cor ,20 F.Supp.3d 1 1 ( D.Fl.201 . I Br
nial p. 2
332, 346 S. a 6) n own,J
udgeUngao di not
r d
alw j rs ito a dic v r h li t e panifsf i r t iv siaej rs ito a is e
lo u idcin l s o ey odng h litf al e o n e tg t u idcin l su s
u
p irt fln s i d e n tgv rs t ag n iej rs ito a ds ue S eas T o o v
ro o iig ut o s o ie ie o e un u id ci n l ip t. e lo h mps n .
Car v Cor ,No.1 CV- 1 201 W L 1
nial p.
5- 241 5, 6
24228 a * ( D.Fl M a .30,201 ( oor
0, t 7 S. a. r
6) M e,
J)(x rii gd s rto a dn tal wi gj rs ito a d s o ey .
. e ecsn ic ei n n o lo n u idci n l ic v r )
Thi Cou tdoes not f nd i a oprat t pr de Pl i if a oppo t t t e
s
r
i t ppr i e o ovi
a ntf n
r uniy o ngag i
e n
j rs it n lds o e y b c u e Sh r i n g n ie ds ue o amae il u idcina f c t
uid ci a ic v r e a s s e e s o e un ip t n
o
t
tra j rs ito l a t o
warntdico r ' Pe u r v Aibu ,S. S.83F.Supp.3d 1 1 ( D.Fl 201 .
ra s vey.' r ye o . r s A. ,
283, 290 S. a. 4)
D ON E A N D ORD ERED i Cham ber at M i i Fl i t s
n
s
am , orda, hi
201
7.
( oSpme
0 fet br
e
.''e
.*
'..
..J
., '
..
...
e,
...
.
:' Z .
.-
..
f.(.
,'
..
FEDERI
CO .M OP,
E
UNI
TED STATES DI
' STRI J
CT UDGE
.'
'
..
Co e f nihedt
pis ur s
o:
Cou e ofRe or
ns l
c d
6
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?