Domond et al v. People Network APS et al

Filing 68

ORDER denying 55 Motion for Recusal. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 10/27/2017. (mmd)

UNI S
TEb TATESDI CT COURT FOR THE
STRI
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M im iDi son
a
vii
1 24026- V- ORENO
6CI M
J
OSHUA DOM OND and HAROLD HUNTER,
JR.
,
Pli if ,
antfs
VS.

P E O P L E N E T W O R K A P S , d/b /a
BEAUTI
FULPEOPLE.
COM , BEAU TI
FUL
PEOPLE LLC, GREG H OD GE , and
GENEVI
EVE HODGE,
Def nda s
e nt .
/

O RDER DENYI M OTI FO R RECUSAL
NG
ON
Al tt mont afert Cour dim is d t i ca e Pl i if fld t s m o i f
mos wo
hs t he
t s s e her s , antfs ie hi ton or
r c a .Therm otonse sfom af
e us l
i
i tm r
onne l w c e k' r pr s nt ton ofDe e
r a l r sl e e e ai
f ndant i t sm ate
s n hi
tr
,

whih Pli if fl mor t n sxy r a trhi clr hi t r e d. Afe ca e u l c i rng
c antfs ied e ha i ea s fe s e ks p e m nde
tr r f ly onsde i
t saut y sa r a t c s l , t Cour c l
he t t or t nda ds nd he a e aw he
t oncudest tt moton f r c als d be
ha he i or e us houl
de e
ni d.

THI CAUSEca bef et Couruponpl ntfs M otonf c alD. .No. ) fld
S
me or he
t
ai if' i orRe us ( E
57 , e
on Auzus 2. 7.
t 201
THE COURT hasc i r d t m oto , t r s
onsde e he
i n he e pons ,a t pe tne pori oft
e nd he ri nt tons he
r co d, be ng ot wi e f l a s i t pr m i e , i i
e r and i
her s uly dvi ed n he e s s t s
AD JUD G ED t tt m oton i DEN I f t r a ons s a e i t sor r
ha he
i s
ED or he e s
t t d n hi de .

l unde sgned' f m e lw c e k, Rya Zaga e i no l nge wor ng a t 1w tr
'
rhe
ri
s or r a l r
n
r , s o r ki t hi a im
t tr pr s nt De enda si t snow cos d c e.
ha e e e ed f nt n hi
l e as

Le lSt
ga andar and Anal i
d
ys s

Two f r lsaut s 2 U. C.j 45 a d 1 4, o en r c s la d c u t mu tc n tu
ede a t t e , 8 S. j 5 n 4 g v r e u a n o rs s o sr e
t m i par matra. Ra v Eq f xIf r t nSe v .LLC, 2 F. p' 81
he n i e i
y . u a no mai rs,
o
3 7 Ap x 9 8 4(11hCi.
, 2
t r

2 0 ) Un e t s sau e ,u g saep e u dt b i a t la dtemo a tb a steb r e
0 9 . d r hee tttsj d e r rs me o e mp ri n h v n e r h u d n
a

o d mo taiga o j cieyr a o a l b ssf rq eto n tej d esi a t lt HPC US
f e nsrtn n b e tv l e s n be a i o u sinig h u g ' mp ri i
ay
.

Fund 1 L. v Woo , 1 F.Supp. 1 4, 1 7( D. l . 01 )
, P. . d 82
3d 28 28 S. F a 2 6 .

Se to 4 5 a rq ie adsrc j g t rc s çna yp o e dn i whihh s mp rilt
cin 5 4) e ur s ititud e o e u e i n r c e ig n c i i a t iy
i
a
m i r s bl beque toned.'28U. C. 4 5 a ;Th ma v T n e oPa k gig Co
ght ea ona y
si
' S. j 5 () o s . e n c c a n

.,

293F.
3d

1 0 ,1 2 ( 1h Ci. 0 2 . S cin 4 5 b ()r q ie j d e t ds u lf t ms l e ' e e
3 6 3 9 1 t r 2 0 ) e to 5 ( )1 e ur s u g s o iq aiy he ev s ' r
wh
(h y h v apes na b a o p eudc c n enig ap ry orpers lknowldge ofdiputd
t e ) a e ro l is r rj ie o c r n a t,
ona
e
s e
e d ta y f c sc e ni t pr e ng.' I Thoma ,t Elve h Cic tsaed:
vi en ir a t onc r ng he oce di ' n
s he e nt r ui t t

Un e j4 5 t esa d r i wh te a o j ci , ul i f r dly
d r 5 ,h tn ad s eh r n be t f l n o me a
ve y
o s r e wo l e tran sg i a t d u t a o t t j d es
b ev r ud ne ti infc n o b b u he u g '
i ri iy.Furhe m o e t ge r lr e i t tbi s fcintt
mpa talt
t r r , he ne a ul s ha as ufi e o

ds u lf aj d emu t tm fo e tau iils u c s
iq aiy u g s se r m xrj dca o r e .
I (nen l u tto o t d ( u tn Ch it v Pa g t, 2 F.d 1 2 ,1 3 ( 1hCi. 0 0
d itr a q o ains mit ) q o ig rso
e
d et2 3 3 3 4 3 3 1 t r2 0 )
.

a dHa v Bd o ge t 7 8F.d6 7 6 ( 1hCi 1 3:; ieyv.Unie ats, 0U.
n mm . fRe nh 0 2 4 , 51 1 t r 98 f tk
tdst e 51 S.
.

5 0 5 55 (9 4.
4 , 5 -6 1 9 )
A M o i t Re us fld unde 28 U .SC. 1 4i ame a r c i aj d efra ta
ton o c e ie
r
. j 4 s i d t e usng u g o cu l
bi s a we la t a a a ofi o it . Thes c i r r apa t stm ey afi vi
a , s l s he ppe r nce mpr pre y
e ton equies ry' i l fda t
,
whih mus be s itd a on wih c
c
t ubm te l g t ouns lsaddii lc rii ton ofgood f ih. Se ton 1
e'
tona e tfcai
at
c i 44
r dsasf l :
ea
olows

-

2-

W he
neve apa t t a pr e ngi adititc t kesa fls
r ry o ny oc edi n src our ma
nd ie

atmeya ds fce t f a it a t e u g beo ewh m t ma tr
i l n ufiin afd vth th j d e f r o he tç
i pe d n ha ap ro a ba o p eu ieet ra ans hm o i
s n i g s es n l is r rj dc i g i t i r n
he
f vor of a a r e pa t , s c j d e s alp o e d n f rh r
a
ny dve s ry u h u g h l r c e o u te
teen b t n t r u g s lb a sg e t h a s c pr c e ig
h r i, u a ohe j d e hal e sin d o e r u h o e dn
.

Theafi vi s l sat t f c sa t r s f t bei ft t
fda t ha l t e he a t nd he ea ons or he le ha

ba o prj d c e ss a s alb tld n tls t a tn d y
is r eu ie xit, nd h l e ie o e s h n e a s
be or t be nni oft t m atwhi h t pr e ng i t be
f e he gi ng he er
c he oc edi s o
he r orgood c us s lbe s wn f f iur t 5l i wihi s h
a d,
a e hal
ho or a l e o e t t n uc
tme.A pa t m a fl onl ones haf vi i a c e. I s l be
i
ry y ie y
uc ûda t n ny as t ha l
a ompa e by a c tfc t ofc
cc
nid
erii a e
ouns lofr c d sa i t ti i
e
e or t tng ha t s
madei good f ih.
n
at

2 U.. j 1 4. l d tr n n wh t rr c s li a p o rae t r or ,t Courtm us frt
8 SC. 4 n eemii g ehe e u a s p r p it , he ef e he
t is

d tr n wh t rtef l wigt e ee n sh v b e me : 1 wheh rap ryh sma ea d
eemie ehe h ol n hre lme t a e e n t ( ) te a t a d n
o
tmey fld a a fd vt ()wh t e te afd vti a c mp nid b a g o fih c riiaeo
i l ie n fia i; 2 eh r h fia i s c o a e y o d at e tfc t f
c u s l a d ( )whehe t ea fd vti lg l s fce t I Alh u h te Pli tfsfld a
o n e; n 3
t r h fi a i s e al ufiin . d t o g h anif ie n
y
afi vi i s
fda t n uppor oft i r c a moton, t r i ltl doubtt ti f l t c
t he r e us l i he e s ite
ha t ais o ompl wih t
y t he

saut stmelne sr r m e s.Them oto t r us a t a fda twe efl afe t Co t
t t e' i i s equie nt
i n o ec e nd he fi vi r ied tr he ur
e e ed a fna or r i t s c s .
nt r
i l de n hi a e

l addii t bei untm ey,t Pl ntfs m o i t r us a s f iso t me isunde
n
ton o ng i l he ai if ' ton o ec e lo a l n he rt
r
bot sa ut y pr sons. The c nt m ice ofPli if a lgatonsco e i t Cour ' and
h tt or ovii
e e e
antfs' le i
nc m ng he
ts
J
udge O' lva s al ge t c ua bi s'i a f me 1 w clr s s r c t t unde sgne fom
Suli n' le d s t l a ' s or r a e k' e vie o he
a
ri d r

2009 t 201 Pl ntfsa g t tt 1 ce k' wo kon t sc e sx yea sa trhi t r ende
o 0. ai if r ue ha he aw lr s r
hi as i
r fe s e m
d
wa r t t Cour' r cus l Fl i St e Ba Rul 4- .1 pr des t tç l wye s l not
ran s he
ts e a . orda at r e 1 2 ovi ha ç a r hal
a
r pr e a
e es nt nyone i conne ton wih a ma tr i whih t lwye pM ii t d pe s ly a
n
ci
t
te n
c he a r
cpa e r onal nd
s t n i ly asa . .a c er .. ' a St B arRul 4-1. ç- sdoesnotam ountt a pr i i
ubs a t a l
. l w l k. . Fl . .
'
e
12. trhi
o oscrpton

onf me lw cekspr tcng i fontoft ij s'Br wnv Brock,169 F.App' 579,583
or r a lr acii n r
her udge .' o
x
.

( 1h Ci. ) TheElve h Cic ta d t tt n ehialdange e ssonl i t lw clr
1 t r 2006 .
e nt rui dde ha s t c
a
r xit y f he a ek
-

3-

k o t ej g st u h sa o t s e ii matra dt elw ceks b e u n l rp e e t o e
n ws h ud e' ho g t b u a p cfc te n h a lr u s q e ty e r sn s n

o tepat s otematr e o ete u g . 1 .Be a s M rZagar di nott rtci eper onaly
fh ri t h te b fr h j d e' d c u e
e
'
e d
ç i pat s l
pa
.

a s tntaly' a a 1 w clr i t sc s t tpos- t hi t r by sx ye r r c a i no
nd ubsa i l ' s a e k n hi a e ha
tdaed s e m
i a s e us l s t
,

w a r nt d.
ra e
>

DONE AND ORDERED i Cha be satM i , Fl i ,t s
n
m r
ami orda hi

Copi spr de t
e ovi d o:
Couns ofRe or
el
c d

FEDE
UNI
T

-

4-

S

da ofOc obe , 201
y
t r
7.

.M
ES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE