AIG Property Casualty Company v. Charlevoix Equity Partners International, Inc.

Filing 14

ORDER granting 8 Motion to Dismiss. Closing Case. Motions Terminated: 13 Plaintiff's MOTION to Compel Appraisal Plaintiff's MOTION to Stay Proceedings Pending Appraisal filed by AIG Property Casualty Company, 7 Plaintiff's MOTION to Consolidate Cases with Supporting Memorandum of Law filed by AIG Property Casualty Company, 8 Defendant's MOTION to Dismiss 1 Complaint, filed by Charlevoix Equity Partners I nternational, Inc.. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 1/18/2017. (mmd) NOTICE: If there are sealed documents in this case, they may be unsealed after 1 year or as directed by Court Order, unless they have been designated to be permanently sealed. See Local Rule 5.4 and Administrative Order 2014-69.

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SO U THERN DI
STR I O F FLORI A
CT
D
Cas Numbe 16e
r: 24272- V- ORENO
CI M
A 1 PROPERTY CA SUA LTY COM PA N Y ,
G

Pli if
a ntf,
V S.

CHARLEVOI EQUI PARINERS
X
TY
I
NTERNATI
ONAL m C.
,
Dee
f ndan .
t
O R D ER G M N TI G M O TI N T O D I I
N
O
SM SS

THI CAUSE ca beor t Co tupon Dee n' M otont Dimis( E.8) fld
S
me f e he ur
fnda ts i o s s D. ,ie
on N o
vem ber 21.2016.

THE COURT ha c i e t m o i t pe tne pori oft r cor a beng
s onsder d he ton, he ri nt tons he e d, nd i
ot r s f l a s d i t pr mies i i
he wie uly dvie n he e s ,t s
ADJUDGED t tt moton i GRANTED ba e on t fr tt fl r l Prort t s
ha he
i s
sd
he is-o-ie u e. i o hi
s tbe ng f l d,D e e ntCha l voi Equiy Pa t r I e a i l I .f l d a c e i s a e
ui i ie
f nda
re x
t rne s nt m tona , nc ie
as n t t
cou t A l Pr pe t C a ua t Co pa r m ove t fr tfl d c e Cas N o.1 24764- V r . G o ry s ly m ny e
d he i s ie as , e
6C1

SCOLA and Cha lvoi doesnotc es t r m ovali pr r Bot t r m oved c s and t s
re x
ont t he e
s ope . h he e
ae
hi
ca e a e bas o A I ' pa e ofonl a pori oft da age i ur e by Cha l voi i
s r
ed n G s ym nt
y
ton he m s nc r d
re x n
r pa rng a ve s .The pa te dipu e pr s ons oft i ur ncepolc w ih r s c t cove age
e ii
s el
ri s s t ovii
he ns a
i y t e pe t o
r
a t va ue ofda age .
nd he l
m s
E her t o a tons i vi ove l ppi i s s a pa tes ar pe ng i t o f de al
i
W
e w ci
nvol ng
r a ng s ue nd r i
e ndi n w e r

c t,t r i a sr pr s pton ac os t f der lcr uist tf vor t f u oft frt
ours he e s tong e um i
r s he e a ic t ha a s he or m
he is-

fld s tunde t frtfl r e.'
ie ui
r he is-ied ul 'Manue v Conv r ysCor ,430F. 11 11 ( t Ci.
l.
eg
p.
3d 32, 35 11h r

2 0 ) ç e fis t fl' r l i g o n e i p icpls o c miy a d s u d j dca
0 5. '
Th frt o ie ue s r u d d n rn i e f o t n o n u iil

ad i sr ton... d 'e c
m nitai
. 'h once n m a f sl i t a d t wase ofduplcai t a d r i
T
r
nie ty s o voi he t
i ton, o voi ulngs
w hi h m a t e h u
c
y r nc pon t au hort ofs serc t ,a t a d pi e e r ol t on ofi s
he t iy
i t our s nd o voi ec m al es u i
s ues

ta c l frau io m rs l. 'S v Po rLt v S tkFi.Cop. 1 1F.d 9 7,9 0 (t
h t al o n fr e ut' ' a e we d . yne n r , 2 3 4 5 5h

Ci.1 9 )( u tn We tGuj rtmeAs ' v I A Dep S a Lo a 24 7 F.d 7 1 7 9 (t
r 9 7 q o ig s lMa ii sn . L e e c l 51 2 2 , 2 5h
Ci.985).
r1 )
W he t fr tt fl r e i applca e,a ditit c tm a el tt sa ta f r or
n he is-o-ie ul s
i bl
src our y ec o t y, r ns e ,

ds s ad piai eltrfld a to a d i a p yn t efrtt fl nze j d e aea fr e
imis u lc tv ae-ie cin, n n p l ig h is-o-ie l, u g s r fo d d
tsnampl de e ofdicei '' e i Lt v Cll Lt 681F.d 1 1 ( d.Ci. 2)
'a
e gre s rton.'M ral d. . p a d,
3 283, 299 Fe r201

(u tn Ke oe tMf Co v C-O-F ?FieEq i Co,3 2 U. 1 0 1 3 4 7 S.Ct 21 ,
q o ig r ts g. . .
wt r up. . 4 S. 8 , 8 -8 , 2
. 9
96L. 200(1 2).l or rt ovec t pr umpton fvorngt f m oft frtfl
Ed.
95 ) n de o rome he es i a i he onl
he is-ied

s tt eo j ci gp ry mu t:a' t eb r e o p o i gço el cr u tn e 'owarn
ui,h be tn a t s ç ly h u d n f r v n c mp li ic msa c st ra t
cr
ng
a exc pton t t frtfld r e. Manue,430 F. a 11 ( i M e rl Lynch Pir e
n e i o he is-ie ul '
'
l
3d t 35 quotng r il
, ec,
Fenne drSmih I v Ha 675F. 11 11 ( 1h Ci.98 ) Stot rv Hyl Yac s
r
t, nc. . ydu,
2d 69, 74 1 t r1 2); r he . as ht,
I .No.1 80 CV,201 W L 4531 a #1( D.Fl.Oc.1 201 .
nc,
2- 2832
357, t S. a t , 2)
The Pl ntf a guest frtt tl nle doesnota y he e bec us t fr tfl d ca e
ai if r
he is-o-ie l
ppl r
a e he is-ie s

o iiae i sae c u t Th tc s h sn w b e r mo e a d i i i t ei tr sso j d ca
rgn td n tt o r. a a e a o e n e v d n t s n h ne et f u iil

e o o n t oh v t d src j d e a j diaigt eis e . ea j dc to o c s n 1 c n my o t a e wo itit u g s d u c tn h su s Th d u iain f a e o. 6
24764- V C1 SCO LA i lke y t r s ve al t i s s be w ee t s pa tes A c r ngl t
s i l o e ol
l he s ue t n he e r i . co di y, he

mo int d s s i GRANTED a dtec s i DI M I ED wih u p eu c .
to o imis s
n h a e s S SS
t o t rj die
D ON E AN D O RD ERED i Cha be satM i m i Fl i ,t s
n
m r
a , or da hi

of J
anua y 201
r
7.

A'

w'
..*'

'
'
-

>

FED
CO A .M OR EN O
UNI
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U
Copi s f r s d t
e u nihe o:
Couns lofRec d
e
or

V
2