International Aerospace Group, Corp. v. Evans Meridians Ltd.

Filing 45

ORDER Granting 33 Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 1/26/2018. (jw)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRICT CO U RT
SO U TH ERN D I
STR I O F FLO R I A
CT
D
M I IDI I O N
AM
V SI
CASE N O .1 cv6- 24997- N G
Kl
I
NTERNA TI AL AERO SPA CE
ON
GROU P,CORP,
Pl i if
a ntf ,

EVAN S M ERI A N S,LTD ,
DI

Def
endant
.
/

O RDER G RAN TI G DEFEN DAN T' M O TI FO R SU M M A RY JUD G M EN T
N
S
ON
TH I CAU SE com esbef e t Cour upon D e e ntEvans M erdi ,LTD '
S
or he
t
f nda
i ans
S

(d ns' M otonf Sum ma yJudgment( #33) fld on Dece
$Eva '
) i or
r
DE
, ie
mber4,201 The ei
7. r n,

Eva s e s
ns e ks umma yj gme ton a1o Pli ifscamsf rr le ,a o Cou sIa d
r ud n
1 f antf ' l i o ei f nd n nt n
1 of Eva ' c
1
ns s ount r l m .Thi m a t r i f l bref 1 and as di cus e bel , t
e c ai
s te s uly i ed,
s sd
ow he

Co r fn t t Ev ns Mo i n s ul be g a t d, a s mma y j g n e e e
u t i ds ha a ' to ho d
r n e nd u r ud me t ntr d
agai tPl i ifon Count 1 I,a lIofisCom pl nt2and i f vorofEva on count
ns antf
s , l nd 1
n a
ns
s
t
ai ,

Ia 1 ofis Count cl i .
nd 1 t
er a m
1.

Backgr
ound

Thsc s aie o o t sl byPli ifofs v nj te i st Dee n,te
i a e rss ut f he ae
antf e e e ngne o fnda t h
c pl ton of w hi s l was i e r ed by t Unied St t G ove nm e a
om e i
ch a e
nt r upt
he
t
a es
r nt nd
al i ofs l orta f r ofengi t l an.
legatons
a es r ns e s
nes o r

1Pli ifha tld isRe pons i Opposton ( #40) a Defndanthasfld isRe yi Su tofSumm ar
antf s ie t s e n
ii DE
e
ie t pl n ppor
y
, nd
J
udgment( .42)
DE # .
2 On t s
he ame day i fl d is M oton f Sum m a y Ju
t ie t
i or
r dgment D ef nt tl a M oton f Ju
enda ied
i or dgment on t
he
,

Pla i sdrce a te es metrec ns I l h o teCo r' ga tofs mmayj d me ta t t s tre
e dng ietd t h s a he ou t.n i t f h uts rn
g
u r u g n s o hee h e
c nt , he M oton f J
ou s t
i or udgm e on t Pl di gsi m o .
nt he ea n s ot
1

Brefy s a ed, i a s res of conta s Pl ntf agr d t s l a Def
i l tt
n
ei
r ct 3 ai if ee o el, nd
endant

a r e t pu c s ,a t t lo s v n ar lnej te gi sf t s of$1 5 0 0.l
g e d o r ha e o a f e e ip a e n ne or he um
0,50,0 n
t efrtc ta t d t d Oc o r28, 3 (h t r tAg e me f',Pl i ifa r e t s l
h is onr c, a e t be
201 t e Tis r e n ) antf g e d o el
f re i e (e ilnu r d 69 4 6 02 ,6 21 a d 53 258 .On De e r23,
ou ng n s s ra mbe e 52 4, 9 51 95 9, n 0 )
c mbe
201 t pa i e e ed i o a Addendum t t Fis A gr em entwhi s tt e one
3 he rtes nt r nt n
o he r t
e
ch ubsiut d

o t o ii lf u e gi s( 02 ,prc d a $2, 0,00)f ra d fe e te gi e (e il
f he rg na o r n ne 69 51 i e t 90 0
o if r n n n s ra
n
umbe e 69 52 a prc d a $250 0 .On No mbe 2 2 3 t pa t se t r d
r d 03 , nd ie t , 0,0)
ve r 5, 01 , he ri n e e
e
i o a s cond contact(he tse
nt
e
r t s cond Agr
eemenf' or t pur s of t e addii l
)f he cha e
hr e
tona

e g n s( e iln
n i e s ra umbe e 51 38 5 04 a 53 67 f rat tlo $ 40 0
r d 75 , 3 50. nd 01 ) o o a f 2, 0,00.
Bet e O c ober25,2013 and D ec ber27,2013,D e e ntm a paym ent t
w en t
em
f nda
de
so

Pli ift tln $1102309 9 (n l i e of c t c n e l td u e t c nta t)
antf o ai g
, , 0.0 i c usv
oss o t mp ae nd r he o r c s .
Accor ngl D ef nt pai Pl ntf a 1 m oneys owed unde t contact Pl i if
di y,
enda
d ai if 1
r he
r s. a ntf
s ppe a1 s ve e nes t D e e
hi d l e n ngi
o
f ndant but onl f
,
y our of t e s
hos even engi w e e
nes r
rt
d lv r d ( n ne 6 24 69 9, a 5 25 fo t e Fi s Agreem ent and
ei e e e gi s 95 4, 521 nd 30 8 r m h

Ad nd t r t a d e i 530 0 fo t e Se o d Ag e me t.One e i fo
de um he eo; n ngne 45 r m h c n
r e n)
ng ne r m
t Fis Ag e me a Add n m t r t ( 90 2)a t e ne fo t e Se on
he r t r e nt nd
e du he eo 6 35 nd wo ngi s r m h c d
Ag e me t( 7 8 a 53 67 we eno d lve e be a eofa d r ci is e by t
r e n 51 53 nd 01 ) r t e i r d c us
ie tve s u d he
Unied St t G over ent as D ef nda was under s pi on of a t ptng t s p
t
a es
nm ,
e nt
us ci
tem i o hi
e nest I an.
ngi
or

Pu s a t t ef c ma e r ca e i t Agr e e t,a d be a s t e i e
r u nt o h or e j u e l us s n he e m n s n c u e he ng n s
c d notbe delve ed, D e e
oul
i r
f ndant ca l t contact . Pl i if di not r f
nceled he
r s a ntf d
e und t
o

Def ndant any of t m one Def ndant pa d f t t ee engi i w as not a e t
e
he
ys
e
i or he hr
nes t
bl o
3W hih ha ng a nded t c r cst isCompli a havi bas d iscli st oug
c
vi ppe
he onta t o t
ant nd
ng e t am hr houtt ca e upon, a
he s
nd
ha ng a it d i dicove y t t e a e nt gove n t pa tes di put , Pl i if ca
vi dm te n s r hat h gr eme s
r he r i ' s e a ntf nnot now genui y
nel
dipue asi at st doi isopposton- whi agr m e sgoven.
s tt tempt o n t
ii
ch ee nt
r
2

delver I t Pl i ifkeptt e engi ,and Def ndant sf
i . nsead, a ntf
hos
nes
e
' unds a hass nc r s d
, nd
i e e- ol

t oft engi f at alof$940, and hassrpped down and s d of f pars
wo he
nes or ot
000,
ti
ol f or t

t t r (o a un s l e s .
he hid f r n dicos d um)
Pli iffl d s i a a n tDe e nt al g n t r ec un s ()Br a h ofCon r c ,
antf ie u t g i s f nda , le i g h e o t : l e c
ta t

(1 Ac ou tSttd, nd(1)Unus Enihme . antf' Co antalg s a rlts
1) c n ae a 11 j t rc ntPli ifs mpli le e , s eae
t t Ad nd t t e Fis Ag e me t t a t e i e s tt e f r( 90 ,prc d
o he de um o h rt r e n , h t he ng n ubsiutd o 6 251 ie
a $2, 000,r ace by engi 690352) r ne prced at $2, 000.Pl ntf
t 900,
epl d
ne
emai d i
900,
ai if
a l ges t D ef
le
hat
enda f ied t pay t s am ount and a
nt a l o
hi
,
ccor ngl owes a dif r nce of
di y
fee

$400,
000.Howeve t Addendum,whih Pli if atche and i or aed i o is
r, he
c antf ta d
nc por t nt t

c l i , a esc e rt tt pu c s p ie f rt sne e i i n $2,00,0 b
omp ant m k la ha he r ha e rc o hi w ng ne s ot 9 0 0, ut
$2, 000- adif e of$400,
500,
fer nce
000.
D ef nda fl a Count r ai a i tPl ntf,alegi t ee count ofis own:
e nt ied
e cl m ga ns ai if l ng hr
s t

()Br a h of Con r c ba e o Pli ifs f iur t d lv r e i e 690 2 un r t
1 ec
ta t s d n antf' al e o ei e ng n
35 de he

Fis Ag e me a Adde um t e e o o r t r t p c s p ie pa d t r f r ,(1
rt r e nt nd
nd h r t r e u n he ur ha e rc i he e o e 1)
Br ac of Contac bas on Pl ntf ' f iur t de i e nes 51
e h
r t ed
ai if s a l e o lver ngi
7538 a 5301
nd
67

u e t Se on Ag e me torr t r t e pu c s prc pad t r f e, nd (1)u j s
nd r he c d r e n eu n h r ha e ie i he e or a 11 n u t

e ihme ba e u n Pli ifsrtii t s b e te gi sa t pu c s mon y,
nrc nt sd po antf' eanng he u j c n ne nd he rha e e
a s lng of t e engi and r a ni t pr edsoft e s es aswel.
nd eli
f hos
nes
et i ng he oce
hos al
l
I
l.

Sum m ary Judgm entSt
andard

éf e Co r s l gr n s m ma y j dg nti t mov n s ws t a t r i n
s'
rh u t hal a t u r u me f he
a t ho h t he e s o

ge i d s ut a t a y ma e ilf c a t mov n i e ild t j gme a ama tr
nu ne ip e s o n tra a t nd he a t s ntte o ud nt s
te
o lw . Fe R.Ci P.5 a .A pa t a s ri g t ta f c c nn be ori ge i l
f a ' d.
'
v. 6()
ry s e tn ha a t a ot
s nu ney
diput d m us s
s e
t uppor t as eri by S tng t pari a pars of m a e i l i t
t he s ton
d i o
ci
tcul r
t
t r a s n he

r cor i l ng depos tons docum e s el r caly s or i or aton,af i t or
e d, nc udi
ii ,
nt , ectoni l t ed nf m i
fdavis

deca atons si ai (ncl ng t e ma f pur es of t moton onl
lr i , tpultons i udi hos
de or pos
he
i
y),
a ssons i e r or ans er or ot m at i l 'or s
dmi i , nt r ogat y
w s
her
era s
, howi t m at ral cied do
ng hat
ei s t
notesabls t a enc orpr ence ofa genui di put ort ta adver e pa t cannot
t ih he bs e
es
ne s e, ha n
s ry

p o uc a s i e e de c t s p r t f c . I a 56 c ( ) ' nde e mi i g whehe
r d e dmisbl vi n e o u po t he a t' d. t ( ) l .' t r n n
'
l
tr

s mmayj dgme i a o it,t fcsa d ifrnc sfo t f csaeviwe i
u r u
nt s pprprae he a t n n ee e r m he a t r e d n
t lghtm os f abl t t non- ovi pa t a t bur i pl ced on t m ovi
he i
t avor e o he
m ng ry, nd he den s a
he
ng

pary t es a ih bot t a ence of a genui m at i l f t and t t i i entted t
t o t bls
h he bs
ne
era ac
ha t s il o

j d n a a mat ro lw. M as s t Elc I du .Co.v Ze t Ra o Cor ,4
u gme t s
te f a ' tu hia e . n s
'
. nih di
p. 75
U . 5 4, 8 -87 ( 986 .
S. 7 5 6
1 )

l o posng amo i f rs mma yj me t t non movi pa t ma no r l
n p i
ton o u r udg n , he - ng ry y t ey
s el on t pl di
ol y
he ea ngs, but m us s
t how by af i vis de ii , answ ers t
fda t , postons
o
i e r ores a adm i sonst ts fc f t exi tdem onsr tng a ge ne i s f
nt r ogat i , nd
si
ha pecii ac s s
tai
nui s ue or

til S eFe R. v.P.5 c ,( ) s e as Ceotx Cor v Catet 477 U. 31 ,32 ra. e d. Ci
6( ) e ; e lo l e
p. . r t,
S. 7 3
2 ( 98 .Fu t r t e itnc of a i cntla'o e d nc i s po t o t n 4 1 6) rhe , he x se e
i i il ' f vi e e n up r f he on
s

mo nts poston i i u fce t t e e mus b e de e o whih t e j r c l
va ' ii s ns fii n ' h r
,
t e vi nc n
c h u y ou d
r ona y fnd f t non- ova .Ander en v.Li t Lobb I ,477 U . 242, 252
eas bl i or he
m nt
s
bery
y, nc.
S.

(98 ) Li wie ac ur ne dno pemi ac s t g t aj r whe t i ee c st t
1 6 . ke s , o t e t r t a e o o o u y n he nfrn e ha
ar dr w n f om t evi
e a
r
he dence,a upon whi t non- ovantr les ar d m pl i e.
nd
ch he
m
e i , e t ausbl '
i
'

Mas s t 475 U. a 59 -9 Mie v Jye s f y Bd.OfEdu . 93 F.d 73 743
tu hia,
S. t 2 4; z . e ron 7r
c,
3 9,
( t Ci.1996)
11h r
.

Attes mma yj dg ntsa e,hej esf ncini no t û iht e i nc
h u r u me tg t udg ' u to s t o s g he vde e
we
a de e m i t tut of t m ater butt de e l ne w he her t e i a genui i s
nd t r ne he r h
he
t ,
o t rni
t her s
ne s ue

f ti l'Ander
or ra .
'
son,477 U . at249.I m aki t s det m i ton,t C our m us dec de
S.
n
ng hi er na i he
t t i
w h c i s a e m a e i l A m at ralf i onet tm i afectt out e oft cas
i h s ues r
tra.
e i act s
ha ght f he com
he e.

f a 248.tonl di put overf ct t tm i afectt out e of t s tunde t
#. t
t y s es
a s ha ght f he com
he ui
r he

g veni g l w wilp o ry p e l d t e e r ofs mma y j dg nt Fa t ldiputs
o r n a l r pe l r c u e h nty u r u me . c ua s e
t ta e ir eva orunne s y wilnotbe count 'f The Cour m us a s det r ne
ha r r el nt
ces ar l
ed.' #.
t
t l o erni

whet r t di put abouta m a era f cti i
he he s e
t i l a s ndeed ge ne,t i ,t f t evi nce i
nui hat s d he de
i
s

s c t tar a o b ej r c ul r t n ave d c f rt no vi pa t ' I ; e ,eg.
u h ha e s na l u y o d eur
r it o he nmo ng ry. d. s e . ,
'
M arn Co igso a.I c v Unie St e , 2F.d 1 70,1 75( 1h Ci.1 91 .
ie atn fAl , n . . td ats 93 2 3
3 1t r 9 )
1 1 D icus i
1.
s s on

De e n ha de nsr td t t i i e ild t s mma y j dgme o al o
f nda t s mo tae ha t s ntte o u r u
nt n l f
Pl i i f scl i sf r i ,a on Count 1and 1 ofisCount cl m .As a pr lm i r
antf ' a m or elef nd
s
1 t
er ai
e i na y

m atr i o sng De e ntsm o i Pli ifa g st ts ay j gme twou d
te , n ppo i
fnda ' ton antf r ue ha umm r ud n
l
be i
nappr i t becaus Pl ntf i i need of f t dicover f om D ef
opra e
e ai if s n
urher s
y r
endant
.

H owever as de a l i t Cour ' Or D enyi Pl ntf ' M oton t Compela f
,
t ied n he
ts der
ng ai i fs
i o
nd or
Ext i ofTi e t Com pl e D icover Pl ntf ' ow n del y- neary 1 m ont afe
ens on
m o
et s
y, ai if s
a
l 0
hs t r
enty of t Sc
r
he hedulng O r r i s ki any di over f om Def
i
de - n ee ng
sc
y r
enda i t c e
nt s he hi f
r on f isl k ofevi
eas or t ac
dence neces a y t pr is c a m s.
s r o ove t l i

As t Pl i if s c ai s f br ac of contac a ac
o a ntf ' l m or e h
r t nd count sa ed,D ef
tt
endanthas
dem onsr t t ti di pay Pl i ifa ls s due undert Agr em e sf t pur has
ta ed ha t d
antf l um
he
e nt or he c e

of t agr ed upon e ne and t t t $400, under
he
e
ngi s,
ha he
000
payment al
leged i t
n he
Compl i i a f i of a e r i dr tng t Com pl ntnoti a
a nt s uncton
n r or n afi he
ai
n ccor
dance wih t
t he

tr o t a r e n s W ih r s c t Pli tf' c am f u j t e rc me t
e ms f he g e me t . t e pe t o an ifs li or n us n i h n ,
Def
endanthasdem onsr ed t on t sr d Pl ntf c
tat hat hi ecor ai if annotpr t Def
ove hat endantw as

u j sl e ihe i a wa ,a i f c t ti i anifwho rti d n o y te
n u ty nrc d n ny y nd n a t ha t sPlitf
eane ot nl h
s j c e gi s bu as alpu c s mon yspad t e e o ,a we la a d tona mo y
ub e t n ne , t lo l r ha e e i h r f r s l s d ii l ne s
f t r s e of t of t engi , a s rppi and r s l of t t r f pa t .
or he e- al
wo
he
nes nd ti ng
e- a e
he hid or r s

Ac odigy,Dee nti ntte t s
cr nl
fnda se ild o ummay j dg n a i tPli ifon alt e
r u me t gans antf
l hre
count a l ged i t Com pl i .
s le
n he
a nt

As f Def
or
endant s count cl i s f br ch of contact a i t Pl ntf ,i i
'
er a m or ea
r
ga ns ai if t s

u ip e a d Pli if a t ha i r ti d t e t r e s b e t e g ne a ha no
nd s utd n a ntf dmist t t e ane h h e u j c n i s nd s t
rf
e unde Def
d
endantany oft pur has m oneys pa d t r or Accor ngl Def
he c e
i he ef e.
di y, endant

i e tte t s mma yj gme a ans Pl itf o Co t Ia 1 o isCou e cam.
s nild o u r ud nt g i t an if n un s nd 1 f t
ntr l i
The ef e, i i O RD ER ED , A DJU D GED, and D ECREED t D ef
r or t s
hat
endants
'

M oton f Summar J
i or
y udgme ( #33) be,and t sa her i, GRANTED.
nt DE
he me eby s
Def
endantsM oton f J
'
i or udgm e on t Pl ngsi DENI as m oot.
nt he eadi
s
ED
DO NE and O R DERED i Cham ber a t Ja esLa ence K i Feder lJ tce
n
s t he m
wr
ng
a usi

Buidi and Unied St t Courhous M i m i Fl i t s26t da ofJ
l ng
t
a es
t e, a , orda hi
h y
anuar 201
y, 8.

V
p

'

&

' AM ES LA W REN CE K I G
N
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI

Cc:A 1 Couns ofRe d
1
el
cor

,
UD GE