Maurices Jewelers II, Inc. v. Pandora Jewelry, LLC et al

Filing 31

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 18 Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 8/29/2017. (mmd)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i miDi son
a
vii
Cas Num be 1 25079- V- ORENO
e
r: 6CI M
M AURI S J ELERS 1, I C.
CE' EW
1 N ,
Pli if
a ntf,
VS.

PANDOM J ELRY,LLC a PANDOM
EW
nd
FRAN CHI NG,LLC,
SI
D ef nt
enda .

O RDER GRANTI I PART AND DENYI I PART M OTI TO DI I
NG N
NG N
ON
SM SS

Thi c e a i e fom a fanc s r l i ns p. Pli tf i brngi c am s unde t
s as rs s r
r hie eato hi
a n if s i ng l i
r he
Fl rda De e i a Unf i Tr de Pr tc s Ac , t Fl i Fr nchi e A c , a com m o l w
oi
c ptve nd
ar a
aci e
t he or da a s
t nd
n a
cli sofpr s or eso la br c ofc r c . Def nda shavem ove t dimi sa1 t
am
omis y t ppe nd ea h
onta t
e nt
d o s s l he
cai . The Cou tgr nt t moton t dimi sas t t Fl i De ptve a Unf i Tr de
l ms
r a s he
i o s s
o he orda ce i nd
ar a
Pr c i s Ac , but gr nt Pl i if l a t ame is co pl i t ale a ua dnmage
a tce
t
a s antf e ve o
nd t m ant o l ge ct l
s
c itnt wih is r pons t t m o i t dim is The Cour tnds t Pli if has
onsse
t t es e o he ton o s s .
ti
he a ntf

s sce l pld t pr m is y e t ppe and br a h of co r t c am s a de es t
uf inty e he o s or so l
ec
ntac l i
nd ni he
De e ntsm o i t dimi st e t co s Fi ly,t Cour fndst pa tes fa s
f nda ' ton o s s hos wo unt . nal he
t i he ri ' r nchie
a e m e c t i ng a M a yl c ce ofl w pr son pr c ude t Pl ntf' cai under
gr e nt on a ni
r and hoi
a
ovii
e l s he ai ifs l m
t Fl i Fr nc s Ac , a c am t tsems fom t pa tes fa hi e r a i hi whi h i
he orda a hie t l i ha t
r he ri ' r nc s eltons p,
c s
gover by t ragr ent
ned
hei eem .

THI CAUSE ca beor t Cour u Dee ntsM oton t Dimis( .E.18 ,
S
me f e he
t pon fnda '
i o s s D
)
f l on Februarv 3.2017.
ied

TH E COU RT ha cons de ed t m oton, t r s
s
i r he
i
he e pons t peri nt por i of t
e, he
tne
tons
he
r c d,a bei ot w i e f ly a s d i t pr m ies i i
e or nd ng her s ' l dvi e n he e s , t s
u
A D JUD G ED t t m oton i G M N TED i par and D EN I i par . The Court
hat he
i s
n
t
ED n
t

g a s Pl i if l ave t fl a Am e
r nt a ntf e
o ie n
nded Com pl i c i t w ih t s O r r by no l t r t n
a nt ons s ent t hi de
a e ha
Sept m be 1 2017.
e
r 3.
1.

Backeround

Pl ntf,M a i s J weer I,I . brngs a f - ount c
ai if urce' e l s l nc, i
ourc
ompli a i tDef nt
ant ga ns
enda s
Pa aJ wely,LLC a Pa a Fr nc sng,LLC. l Febnz r 2011 t pa te e e e i o
ndor e r
nd ndor a hii
n
ay
, he ris nt r d nt

a Ma trP r h s Auho iain Ag e me tt alw Pli tf t r ti Pa d r j wer a a
se u c a e t rz to r e n o lo anif o eal n o a e ly t
D ol n M a l l a i i M i m i Fl i
phi
l oc ton n
a , orda. Pl ntf s prnci l A ndr w K oppel had pror
ai i f
i pa ,
e
,
i

a e m e swih Def nda sa arg offr tr f a t ope ne Pandor fa hie sor s
gr e nt t
e nt nd i ht is e us l o n w
a r nc s t e .
The Fi s A m e d Com pl i ale t r a e di f r ntt
rt
nde
a nt l ges he e r f e e ypes off a hi e
r nc s s:
Co e St r A f lbl n Pa
nc pt o e:
ul- ow
ndor s o e, w hi h ca e a 1 Pa
a tr
c
ni s l
ndor
a
pr uc s a br
od t , nd ande s or r .
d t efont
Shop-n- hop: A s i s
i s
hop-n- hop i a c e r y defne s e w ihi a s or
s
lal
i d pac
t n
t e
de c e t Pandor pr uc s
di at d o
a od t .

Gol De l r Gol dea e s a e m ulib a r t ie s wih a sr
d ae : d
lr r
t- r nd e al r t
tong Pa a
ndor
pr ie.
ofl
Sive a W hie D e e s:Sive de l s have Pa
l r nd
t
al r l r a er
ndor br nde ft i i t
a a d itngs n he
sor bu t a ls e e e t n gol de l s W hie deaer ar mulibr nd
t e, t o e s r xt nt ha
d aer .
t
l s e
t- a
r t ie s c r yi a lm ied a s t e .
e a l r a r ng i t s orm nt
The M aser Pur ha e A ut r z ton des g t s t D ol n M al l ton a a Sive
t
c s
ho i a i
i na e he
phi
l oca i s
l r
deal The M as er Pur e A ut zaton does not s f w hat pr
er.
t
chas
hori i
peci y
oducts a Siver D eal can
l
er

r t i,buti s ys i m us ca y a l as f lne . The M a t r Pur has A ut i a i alo s a e
eal
ta t
t n. t e t our i s
se
c e
hor z ton s t t s
t ta a horze r t ie m a e e tt be a G ol Sive ,or W hie r t ie a is di c e i a
ha n ut i d e a l r y l c o
d, l r
t e a l r t t s r ton nd
m ay el t change s r aiers at atany tm e.
ect o
uch et l t us
i

l Nove be 201 Pli ifa lgest tDe e nt e oye J Vir s ntPl i if
n
m r 3, antf le
ha f nda s' mpl e udy e a e
antf

a lte . Vi a a s t talhough t Dol n M all a i woul be desgna e a a Sive
e tr er dvied ha t
he phi
l oc ton
d
i td s
l r

d ae,Pli t fwo l b p r te t c ry alP n o aj wer l e a d p o u t wi t e
e lr ani u d e emi d o ar l a d r e ly i s n r d cs t h
f
t
n
h
e e i ofwache a t Dol n M al l a i .
xc pton
t s t he phi
l oc ton
l r la
n e i nce on V i r s e es a s a e, Pl i if alege i pr ee
e a' xpr s s ur nc
antf l s t oc ded t deveop t
o
l he
D ol n M a l l a i , by negotai a l s f r t i s e, undera ng i ove nt
phi
l oc ton
i tng ea e or e a l pac
tki mpr me s

,

and

p r h sn ix u e f rj wer ds a I i u rd ac ie t rl c t of $1 ,500 and t
u c a ig t rs o e ly iply. t nc re rh tcu a oss
4
he
c tu ton budge wa bewe n $ 000onsr c i
t s t e 400, $500,
000 Pandora Jewely r ewed t lyoutf
r evi
he a
or
.

t l a i a i di f Pl n ifs ot r l a i , whih i a Sc
he oc ton, s t d or aitf
he oc ton
c s tonce sor .' Pl i if a s
pt t e ' antf lo
e e e a la ef sx yea ssa tng on J 24, 201
nt r d e s or i
r t ri
une
4.
Pl i if ope d t sor i Nove r 201 . Def nda s di notpe m i Pl ntf t
antf
ne he t e n
mbe
4
e nt d
r t ai if o
ptr has t f llne ofPa a ofe i . Spe fc l De e nt di nota l Pli tf t
zc e he ul i
ndor f rngs
ciialy, f nda s d
low a n if o
pu c s t Diney, Es e e or Ros c lctons On Aprl 20, 201 Pli if a s d
r ha e he s
s nc ,
e ole i .
i
5, a ntf dvie

De e nt t t fnanc a gr t was sym id by is i biiy t r t i t e c l tons at
f nda s ha
i l ow h
t e
t na lt o e al hes oleci
Dol n M al
phi
l.
Ra he t n a l Pl ntf t s lt e c l tons De enda ss nta t r i ton notc
t r ha low ai if o el hes oleci , f nt e
e m na i
ie
t Pl ntf wihouta a nce notc . Pl i if alege t f itr t pr de notc was a
o ai if t
ny dva
ie
antf l s he a lze o ovi
ie
br c oft pa te a e nt The tnni ton wasefe tve i e a ey. Pl i if a l ges
ea h he ri s' gr eme .
e na i
f c i mm di t l
a ntf le
t tasar ul oft wr ult r i ton, i i i uri da age i t f r oflas pa e s
ha
es t he ongf e m na i t s nc rng m s n he o m
e e ym nt
f t ne f rye r .
or he xt ou a s
Pl n ifs c pl nt a lges a vi a i of t Fl i Dec ptve a Unf i Tr
aitf ' om ai le
olton
he orda
e i nd
ar ade
Pr tc s A c a t Fl i Fr hi e Ad a com m on l w cl i s ofpr i s y e t
ac i e
t nd he orda anc s
nd
a am
om s or s oppela
nd

br ac ofc r t Def nt ar movi t dim isa1t cl m s
e h ontac . enda s e
ng o s s 1 he ai

.

I.
l

Le St
aal andard

S s vve a m oton t dimis pli if mus do m o e t n m e el sa e l al
C ur i
TO
i o s s , antfs
t
r ha
r y t t eg
c l i ns'i t a pl ntfsmus ( l e s
onc uso ,' nse d ai if
t i eg ome s ii f c ua bassf t e c usonso
al
pec fc a t l i or hos oncl i
r
fcedim is oft i cai s'
a
s s al her l m . 'Jack v Be l h Tee
son . lsout lcomm., 372F. 1
3d 250,1 (11hCi.
263 t r

2004) W he r lng on amoto t dimis aco tmus viw t c ai i t lg mos
.
n ui
in o s s, ur
t e he ompl nt n he iht t
f vor bl t t pl ntf a a e t pl i ifswel- e ded f t a t e. Se St Jos ph'
a a e o he ai if nd cc pt he antf
lpl a
ac s s nz
e . e s
H os ,l .v H os . Cop.fzm. 7 F.d 9 , 5 ( lhCi.l 6 .Th stn t h we e,d e
p. nc . p
r o q , 95 2 48 9 3 1 t r 98 ) i e e, o v r o s
nota y t l galc us ons Se As r .f v l ,1 S. .1
ppl o e
oncl i . e hc o t . qbal 29 Ct 937,1 (
949 2009) M or r
. eove,

(wl i lg l o lso c np o iet efa wo k o ac mplit t mus be suppored by
i hl e a c ncu ins a r vd h r me r f o an , hey t
l e
t
f t la l gatons' I a 1 0. T s ç ta t a alg to smus b e u ht r iearg tt
ac ua le i . d t 95
'
ho e sl cu l l ai n
g
e
t e no g o as ih o

r if a
ele bove t s cultve l lon t as umpton t tal of t c
he pe a i eve
he s
i ha 1 he ompl i ' ale tons a e
ants l ga i
r
tue. Bel At.Cor v Twombl 550 U .S.5 5 ( ) l s t t c
r '
' l l p. .
y,
44, 45 2007 . n hor, he ompli mus not
ant t

m e ey alegea mic
rl l
s onduc , mus de
t but t monsr e t tt pl de i e ild t r i . Se I ,
tat ha he ea r s ntte o elef e qbal
1 S.Ct a 1
29
. t 950.
111
.

L eaalA nal s
vsi

Flrd De e iea d UnarT a ePr cie Ac
o ia cptv n f i r d a tc s t
TheFl i Dec ptvea Unf rTrdePrci sAc (
orda e i nd ai a
a tce t FDUTPA)i Ci ende t pr e t
s snt d o otc
acons e fom unf i orde ptve a t orpr ctc s whih di i s t vaue orworh oft
um r r
ar
ce i c s
a ie ,
c m nih he l
t
he
goodsors r i pur ha e by t c um e ,' Uri v.Hel sExt na o s I ,468 So.2d
e vces c s d
he ons r ' lng
m
enni t r s nc.

451 45 ( a.1 tDCA 1 ) The Ac pr desa c e ofa ton f tl nfi mehodsof
, 4 Fl s
985 .
t ovi
aus
ci or tul ar t
c pe ii n,unco ci bl a t or pr tc s a unf i o dec ptve a t or pr tc i t
om tto
ns ona e c s
ac i e , nd
ar r e i c s
aci es n he
conduct of any t ade or com m er .
r
ce

' j 501. 44) Fl Stt The elme sofaFDUTPA
'
20 1, a. a.
e nt

. ..

cam ae:;()ade eptveac orunf rpr ci ,( c ai a ( a t lda ges' Coach.
li r t1
c i t
ai a tce' 2) aus ton; nd 3) cua ma '
.

4

l .v.Swap Shop.I ., 916 F.Su 2d 1 , 1 ( 1h Ci. 2) Al
nc
nc
pp.
271 283 1 t r 201 . t h Dee nt do
houg fnda s

notc edet tPli ifha pr ry pl d t tr tt elm e s t m o i t dimi sf us
onc
ha antf s ope l e he is wo e nt , he ton o s s oc es
on Pl i ifs a l ga i ofa t lda age . 1
a ntf le tons c ua m
s

The Elvent Cic tha e a ne t t a t lda age ar t he dif r nc be ween
e h r ui s xpli d ha c ua m s e t
t
fe e e t

a

pr tsvaue unde t c r c a t m a ketva ue oft pr tde i r d.' D e oc a i
oduc ' l
r he onta t nd he r
l
he oduc lve e ' m r tc
Re oft Congo v. rCa tlGr m . LLC, 4F.
p. he
Ai pia ou
61 App' 460( ( 1h Ci.201 ( i
x
471 1 t r 5) quotng
Roli .I v.Hele ,454 So. 2d 580,585 ( a.3d DCA 201 ) t not eexc pton t t
lns nc.
lr
Fl
0). ( abl e i o he
A
nze ma e s whe t pr uc i r r vauels as a r ul of t de e t -- t n t
l
y xit
n he od t s ende ed l e s
es t
he f c
he he
pur as prc i t a oprae m e s e of a t l da
ch e i e s he ppr i t
a ur
c ua mage .' . çn s t pl ntfs mus
s'
k t hor, ai if
l
t
marhale de e t pr t ga i vauebe we n whatwaspr s d and wha wa delve e
s vi nc o ove he p n l
t e
omi e
t s i rd
,

unl s t de e ntpa me of a pr
e s he f nda
l d f
oduc t t wa tul worhl s . I t lte st ton,
t ha
s ry
t e s n he a tr iuai
pl ntf m a r cou t f lprc he pad f t vaue e sgood ors r i e.';.
ai if y e p he ul ie
i or he l l s
e vc '
l
De e nt m o t dim is a gui t Pli ifha f ie t a l e a ua da a s
f nda s ve o s s r ng he a ntf s a ld o leg ct l m ge .
Pl ntf s Fis Ame d Com pl ntaleg t t Pl ntf c i
ai if r t
nde
ai l es ha ai if ontnues t s f r acua dnmage
o ufe t l
s
ti l n butnotlm ie t t e ns s i ur e t ne i t and e e i o a l a e i udi
'nc udi g
i t d o he xpe e nc r d o gota e
nt r nt e s , ncl ng,

a
mong o he t ngs t c i
t r hi , he ontnued l a e oblgai t oug t e r ton oft l s t nn a
es
i tons hr h he xpia i
he ea e e nd
t e ns ofdesg a i pr menta t Dol n M al.''
he xpe e
i n nd m ove
t he phi
l
I rs
n e pondi t t M oton t Dim is Pl i ifa g t ti ha s fcinty pl d a ua
ng o he
i o s s , antf r ues ha t s ufi e l e ct l
da gesby alegi t tDe e nt s d t m t opporuniy t oper t asa t mal Conc pt
ma
l ng ha f nda s ol he he
t t o
ae
d l
s
e
St e'r t r t n a d l rDeaer' Pl i if a gues is da
or ' a he ha
k ve
si
l . ' antf r
t mage a e t dif e i val
s r he fer nce n ue

bewe n t f e St e' (..wha wa pr s d)a a ç l rDe e ' ( e.w hat w as
t e he s
conc pt or ' ie
t s omie nd d ve alr' i
si
.

lTheCou tdia ee wih Def nt t tt frtt el e sa ei ufi e l pl Pl ntf s fcinty
r s gr s t
enda s ha he is wo em nt r ns fcinty ed. ai if ufi e l
alege t tDefndant f l t c y wiht Fe alTr deComm isonFr nc s Rul w hih i ale i a
l s ha
e
s aied o ompl t he der a
si
a hie e
c t lges s
,

voaino tej5 . 4, l. tts ihsae ta û u c n i rt na dge tweg ts al gv nt te
ilt fh 0120 Fa Sa.whc tts h tt e o sdeai n ra ih h lbe ie o h
o
d
o

it ettonsoft Fe alTr deCo s i 'i c tui wha a eunlwf éunf rmet ofco pe ii
nemr ai
he der a
mmison' n onsr ng t r a ul ' ai hods
m tton,
u ons i bl acsorpr cies a unf rordec ptvea sorpr c i s.' Plitf as algest svi ai
nc cona e t
a tc , nd ai
e i ct
a tce ' an if lo le hi olton
c us i t i urdam a s.
a ed t o nc
ge

dei r d) n t atnmtve,i aQsive De lr'desgnato i dee vauees ( e.Pl ntf
lve e .I he le i f t l r ae' i in s med l l s i ai if
.

c n ma nomone ba e on rsrce pr tofei ) t Pl i ifi entted t r coveris
a ke
y s d e titd oduc frngs, he antf s il o e
t
e iepurhas prc (. t ali sment.Co 1oft Fis Ame
ntr c e ie ie.ot nvet ) unt
he rt ndedCompl ntalege t
ai l s he
lte st ton,no t f m e . l ot rwo ds i al ge t e e i t t r l t tPl i ifi
at r iuai
t he or r n he r , t le s he xc pton o he u e ha antf s
e il t r c risi sm e bec us t c r c was vauel s The Cour wilalow t
ntted o e ove t nve t nt a e he onta t
l es .
t l l he
Pli if t a e Coun 1 c it ntwih is a g e on t m o i n t dim is t t i i
antf o m nd
t onsse
t t r um nt
he to o s s ha t s

s e ng t r c rt dif r nc be we n wha De e nt pr s a whatwa de i r .
e ki o e ove he fe e e t e
t f nda s omied nd
s lve ed
#. Pr i s y Es o
om s or tppelCl m J
ai

Pl i ifspr is y eso lc am se sfom t pu pored pr ie t e n t
antf
om s or t ppe l i tm r he r t om s hat ve hough
i w a de i t d a a û l r D e l r'a D ol n M a l i wo l b a l t s l al e lyln s
t s s gna e s û ve
si
a e ' t phi
l, t ud e b e o el lj wer ie ,

wih t exc pton ofwathes a n t at nc ptSt e.' Def nda s m ove t dim i s a s r i
t he e i
c , ki o û
co e
or '
e nt
o s s s e tng
t c am i not vibl bec us t pa te ha a wrten ag e m e , t co pl nt lc
he l i s
a e
a e he ri s ve
it
r e nt he m ai a ks
a l ga i of a detnie pr i e, a pl i ifhasno a l ed t pur id pr ie wa mor
le tons
i t om s nd antf
t leg he pore om s s e

t n at t ulsa e e ofpr e i e i a t a f ur ac .
ha nzhf tt m nt
es nt nt ntons s o ut e t

Spjo so y et p li n ta alb e a a rme y whe t e p ris h v a wrte
' r mis r so pe s o v ia l s e d
g
n h at a e
e
in
t
c r c add e sng t r l va is ; t co r c ' slnc a ut pa tculr de a l i no
onta t r s i he e e nt s ues he nta ts ie e bo
ri a t is s t
c r lng a l
ontoli s ong as t c r c pur t t a es t br dl di put d i s s ' W hie
he ont a t pors o ddr s he oa y s e s ue . '
t
H ol ng Co. . LLC v. M a tn M a i ta M a e i s l . 423 F.App' 943,94849 ( 1h Ci.
di
ri
ret
t ral . nc,
x.
- 1t r

2011 (ii Adva edM kt Svs Cor v. Yac Sal ,830So 2d924,928( a.4t DCA
) ctng
nc
c. . p. ZK ht es
Fl h
.

200 JE.Dunn Cons.Co.v.S. P.De Lt P'hi 115F.Supp.3d 593, 609-0 ( M d.
2:; .
t
R. v. d. s p,
1 D.

2 5 (p yn M aya d lw a e trn s mmay j d me to p o so y et p e cam
01 ) a plig r ln a nd nei g u r u g n n r mis r so p l li
wheet r wasa e ore ec r c bewee t pa tes.I t sc e, t Pl i ifhaspl
r he e
n nf c abl onta t t n he ri ) n hi as he antf
ed
2Thepa tesa ee nts ecsM aylnd l a t gover ng l . Thepa tescieboh Fl i a M aylndlw
ri gr me el t l a aw s he
ni aw
ri t t orda nd r a a
i t motont dimiswih r ar t t pr s o yesoppe cam .
n he i o s s t eg ds o he omis r t l li

pr i s y esoppe a br c ofe r d cl i s A ti s i whet r t pr i s y e t
om s or t
l nd ea h
ont a
am .
s ue s
he he om s or s oppel

cai ca s v vet moton t dimisi vi oft br ac ofconta tcai .
l m n ur i he i o s s n ew
he e h
rc l m

Fe r Rul o Ci l Pr d e 8( al pladi i t atr tve e n i t
deal e f vi oce ur d) lows e ng n he lenai , ve f he
t is a e i
heore r ncons s e . l r Che nc A c ount Over a tLii a i , 69 F.Supp.2d 1
it nt n e: cki
c
dr f t c ton 4
302,

1 21( . Fl. 0 . Dee d n sh v n tc n e e t a Plitf i e tte t rc veyu d r
3 SD. a 201 ) f n a t a e o o c d d h t an if s n ild o e o r n e
t c r c ,a i i pos i e t ti t c r dualcl m f is Pl i ifm a silbe e tted t
he onta t nd t s sbl ha f he onta
ai a l, antf y tl
n il o

r ovey u rpr sor esoppe.é.(ii Tr coneW iee s I v.Acc sTee omsl ,
ec r nde omis y t lJ ctng a f
rls s nc.
es lc nc.
642 F.Supp.2d 1
354,1 ( D.Fl 2009). Cg l l t lw doe notpe mi a pa t t
366 S. a.
) tW hie he a
s
r t ry o
smula ousy prvai on a ( omis y e t )t r a a c rcualt or i doesnot
i tne l e l
pr sor soppel heoy nd onta t he y, t
r quiet dimis l(tt moin t dimis sa )ofa g omis y esoppe)cli meey
e r he s sa a he to o s s tge
pr sor t l am rl
because an expr s cont
es
ract exi s t a
st hat rguabl gover t conduct com pl ned of That
y
ns he
ai
.

a g e m a be pr ry r ie a a lt rsage i t s ltga i , s c a s mma yj d me t'
r um nt y
ope l as d t a e t n hi ii ton u h s u
r u g n.
'

L Att ssag t Cour wilalow t Plitf t pla br a h ofco rc a pr mis y
4. hi t e, he
t l l he anif o e d e c
nta t nd o sor
eso li t a tm ai
t ppe n he le tve.
Now, t Cour mus dec de whehe t al gai
he
t
t i
t r he le tons s fc e l sa e a cai of
ufi i nty t t
lm
pr s or esoppel Fl i a M a yl nd lw pr vi t t cai s of pr is r eso l
omi s y t
. orda nd r a a
o de ha l m
om s o y t ppe

esa iht f lwi t e ee nt ( )pl ntf deti ntlyr id on deenda ' pr s ;
tbls he olo ng hre lme s: 1 ai if rme al ele
f nts omie
()defnda ras na y s d ha e ce t pr s t i e r inc i t f m of
2 e nt e o bl houl ve xpe td he omie o nduc ela e n he or

a to o f r e r n e b te panif a d ( )ij tc c n o l bea od d b e o c me to
ci n r o b a a c y h litf; n 3 nusie a ny v ie y nfr e n f
t pr i e. W . Tow ns nd Cont a tncsl . v.J ns n Ci lConsr.I ,728 So.2d 297,
he om s
R.
e
r c i nc
e e vi
t. nc.
302

( a.1tDCA 1 ;ha powe LLC v.Ge Elc.Co. 256 F.Supp.2d 402,41 ( Md.
Fl s
999) ve
r
n. e
,
0 D.
2003) M or s ci ty,t pr pr s o y et
.
e uc ncl o ove omis r soppel apli ifmus s
, antf
t how:( )pr s t t
1 omies ha

ar detnie a s tntali nat e;( s j tfabl r i e on pr s sma and (
e i t nd ubsa i n ur 2) how usii e elanc
omie de;
3)

s
how de rm e alr la e on s h pr m i e . PD F Foods LLC .v.N a d J c Co. of G l ndor
t i nt e i nc
uc o s s
,
ke ui e
e
a.

I ,No.07- 21 C1 M I
nc.
81 7- V- DDLEBROOKS, 2 08W L 1 3 99 , 6( D. a Ap i29 2 0 )
0
1 31 0 * S. Fl. rl , 0 8 .

De e nt a g t t t pr s t Pl i if woul be alowe t o r t a a
f nda s r ue ha he omie hat antf
d
l d o pe a e s
t
i
conce St e'i t i i t t sa e a cai . A pr ie mus be ç tnie a t tr a
pt or ' s oo ndefnie o t t l m
om s
t s i t s o e ms nd
de

tme' u d rFlrd lw)o i la a d d fni '( n e Ma ya lw) W . Gr ce & Co.v.
i '( n e o i a a r t e r n ei t ' u d r r lnd a
c
e
R. a
.

Ge t Se v . l ,547 So. 2d 91 92 ( a.1 ) Pa Ene s l v.A. J ms Co
oda a r ss nc.
9, 4 Fl 989 ; vel tr . nc.
S. ol on

.,

3 2M d. 43 1 7( 9 6 .Th Co r fn t P an ifsalg to ss fiinl saeap o s
4
1 , 6 1 9 ) e u t ids he litf' l ain u fce t tt r mie
e
y
under Fl rda or M a yl nd lw . Pl ntf al ge t De e nt ag e t t at
oi
r a a
ai if le s hat f nda s r ed ha lhough t
he
Dol n M a ll a i woul be desgnatd asa Sive de e , t Dol n M all a i woul
phi
l oc ton
d
i e
l r alr he phi
l oc ton
d

b p r te t c ry alPa o ajwer ln s a d p o ucs wih te e c p in o wac s
e emi d o ar 1 nd r e ly ie n r d t, t h x e to f the
t

.

Pl ntfsa lge t de pie beng l beed a Sive deaer D ef nda s m a i c e r t Pl ntf s
ai if le hat s t i a l
l r l ,
e nt
de t l a o ai i f
t t ispr
ha t oduc ofe i woul be i lne wih a d
t f rngs
d
n i
t
d
conce St e,' whih i a lges i a t ul
pt or ' c t le
s s l
f
bl
own Pa a sor ,whi h ca es a c
ndor t e
c ni
omplt as orm e of Pandor pr t .
e e s t nt
a oduc s

' Pl ntf
' ai if

. ..

alo a lgest pari ag e d t tt t nu oft i a ee twoul be c er i
s le
he tes r e ha he e
her gr men
d
ot m nouswih t i
t her
las a t Dol n M al. The pa tes f t r ag e t t pa e t r s woul be lke
e e t he
phi
l
ri urhe r ed ha ym nt e m
d
i
Pl i ifs ot c e sor l t i t Fa l M al. The Cour fnds t e al ga i
antf ' her onc pt t e ocaed n he ls
l
t i
hes le tons

s fiin t e tbihap o s t ei iea t tr a dtme'u de Flrd lw)o é la a d
u tce t o sa ls r mie i fnt s o ems n i '( n r o ia a r s e r n
d
c
dei t '(
fnie' underMa ylndlw)
ra a .
De e nt 'fna a gumenti t tPl ntf f ist a lge t tt pr s wa m or t n
f nda s
lr
s ha ai if a l o le ha he omi e s
e ha
a t uhf saeme as t t pr e i e i of t pa t wih r ga d t is f ur a t
r t ul t t nt
o he es nt ntnton
he ry t e r o t ut e c .

tg r naiy,atuhf sae nta t t pr e i e i ofapa t wih r r t hi f ur
doldi rl rt ul ttme s o he esnt ntnton
ry t egad o s ut e
a ti no t f
c s t he ounda i upon w hi h e t
ton
c s oppelm a be buit' W . .Grace & Co. 547 So. 2d at
y
l. ' R
,

924 ( a.1 . The algai s
Fl 989)
le tons how mor t n a sae ntoff ur i e D ef ndants
e ha
ttme
ut e ntnt
e
.

r vi we t toor plns a t y woul f a Cco e St e ' a e d t a tm e f a e w ih
e e d he l
a s he
d or t nc pt or , ' gr e o i
rm
t
Pl ntf f t ope ng oft sor , a a e t payme tr s Ther f e, t sCour wilnot
ai if or he ni
he t e nd gr ed o
nt e m .
e or hi
t l

dimist pr is yesoppe c am on t s gr
s s he om s or t l l i
he e ounds
.
Fl i Fr hieAct
orda anc s

De e
f ndan s a gue t tPli ifsc am f vi a i oft Fl i Fr nc s Ac s d
t r
ha a ntf' l i or olton he orda a hie t houl
be dim is d bec us M a yl nd lw a i s as s tf t i t pa tes a ee e . l i w e l
s se
a e r a a pple
e orh n he ri ' gr m nt t s ls tl t ta df de alditi tc tsti i di r iy m us a y t c ce oflw nzesoft
eted ha çe r src our itng n ve st
t ppl he hoi
a
l
he
f u s a e. Cl nt v. nt .Ne Glb.LLC, F. 1 9,1 ( 1h Ci.
or m t t ' a on l er t o .
'
435 3d 31 323 1 t r 2006 .Genealy,
)
rl

Fl i e or eschoi - -a pr sonsunl s t lw oft c e f um c r ve sr
orda nf c
ce oflw ovii
e s he a
he hos n or
onta nes tong
publc polcy. M a zoniFa ms I . v.E..DupontDe Nemour .& Co. 761 So.2d 306,311
i
i
z
r p nc
I
s
,

( a.2000) A c c oflw pr son i pr umptvey vald a i i t bur n oft pary
Fl
. hoie- -a ovii s es i l i nd t s he de
he t
opposng t c ce ofl w pr son t de onsr t why i s d notbe e or e . J Pl ntf
i he hoi - -a ovii o m ta e
t houl
nf c d - ai if
(.
doe not a gue t t t c c - - a pr s on s d not be e or ed or t t i co r ve s
s
r
ha he hoi e ofl w ovi i houl
nf c
ha t nt a ne
s r publc polc
tong
i
i y.

The a e nts c c of1w pr so sat a f l
greme ' hoie a oviin t es s olows: çl s ( aser Purha e
s- M t
-hi
c s

Au h rz to js albeg v r e b ,a d c nsr d i a c r a ewih te lwsoft Stt o
t o iain h l
o en d y n o tue n c o d nc t , h a
he ae f
M a ylnd...' Pl i ifsposton i t t sna r c c ofl caus onl a i t cai s
r a
. antf
'
ii s hat hi row hoie- -aw l e y pples o l m
a ii outoft ag e m e is l a nott pa tes r a i hi .
rsng
he r e nt te f nd
he ri ' eltons p
To s
uppor isposton t M a yl 1w a is a t Fl i saut y c am s d
tt
ii hat r and a pple nd he orda t t or l i houl
be dim is d,De e
s se
f ndan sr l on Ha de Food Svse s I v.Bennet N 0. 8069,1 W L
t ey
r e
tm s nc.
t, 89994

1
372628,a * ( D.Fl M ac 24,1 . I Hadee t dititc tf
t 4 S. a. rh
994) n r , he src our ound t ag e me '
he r e nts
c c of l w pr son pr c ude t Fl i Fr nc s A c c ai a gr ed s m a y
hoi e- -a
ovi i
e l d he orda a hi e t l m nd ant um r

j me . The Hadee c tnoe t tt s Stt e c n onl be a i bl bec us oft
udg nt
r
our td ha hi t aut a
s
y
pplca e a e he
fa hie r ltons p.' The fa hie r ltons p wa c m e e i a ag e m e c ani a
r nc s ea i hi '
r nc s ea i hi
s e nt d n n r e nt ont i ng

c c oflw pr son.L ,Se Zou He i Fr hii LLC.v.M os r No.1 0061
hoie- -a ovii (. e nds arng anc snc.
.
e,
6- 9-

PHXDGC, 6 W L 6 7 2 ,a * ( Arz No 2 201 )( rn ig moi n t ds s a d
201
4 6 91 t 5 D. i. v. , 6 g a tn
to o imis n
fndi t pari 'c ceofAlba 1w prcudesaFl i Fr chieAc cam)
i ng he tes hoi
a ma a e l
orda an s t li .
l t s c e,t Fl i Fr nc s Ac onl a i by vit oft pari 'fa hie
n hi as he orda a hie t y pples
rue
he tes r nc s
r a i hi whi h i gove e by t pa te 'M ase Pur ha e Aut iaton. Tha a e m e
eltons p, c s
m d
he ri s
tr c s
horz i
t gr e nt
c ansa c ce ofl w pr sc eeci M a yl nd l a t Cour m us gi t pari s
onti
hoi - -a
oviim l tng r a aw nd he
t
t ve he te '
i e e f ct Acc di y,t Cour dim is t Fl i a Fr nc s Ac c am .
ntnt fe .
or ngl he
t s s es he ord a hie t l i

D.Br a ho nta t
e c fco r c
De enda sm o t dimist br a ofc r c c am be us t y cl m t lnguage
f nt ve o s s he e ch onta t l i ca e he ai he a
i t a e m e c r di t t Pli ifscl m . See Cr ns w v.Lit r 556 F. 1
n he gr e nt onta cs he antf ' ai
e ha
se ,
3d 283,1
292

( 1h Ci.2009 (k he t e bis c r c t ge r a co l oy ale tons o t
1t r
) tW n he xhi t ontadit he neal nd ncus r lgai f he
he
e
c
e
l he
pla ng,t e bis goven.) Alhough t M astr Pur hase Agr ement does alow t
e di he xhi t
r '. t
'
De e nt t t r nae t ag ee torpe ng or r ,i doe r quie i e a enotc t t
f nda s o e mi t he r men
ndi
de s t s e r mm dit
ie o he
Pli tf .Pl ntf cl m si di notr c venotcet tisor r wer bei t r na e a t ti
a n if ai if ai t d
e ei
i ha t de s e ng e mi t d nd ha t
woul not be pe m it d t s l c r a n lnes The Cour, t r f e fnds Pl i i f s f c e l
d
r te o e l e t i i .
t he e or , i
a ntf uf i i nty
s a e a c a m f rbr a h ofc r t
tt s l i o e c
ontac .
'

D N A DODRDiCabraMi ili,i l oAgs21.
O E N R EE n hme t n ,od ts
s m Frah
fuut07
a.
,

,' .
.

'
'

.

FEDERI

.M ORE

..
..

'

,.r
-r ë
-' :J
.
.

eze'
xw
e

UNI S
TE TATES bI TRI J
S CT UDGE
Copi sf ni he t
e ur s d o:
Co e ofRe or
uns l
c d