Quintero v. JPMorgan Chase Bank

Filing 30

ORDER granting 26 Defendant JPMorgan Chase Bank's Motion to Dismiss. Closing Case. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 7/14/2017. (kcg) NOTICE: If there are sealed documents in this case, they may be unsealed after 1 year or as directed by Court Order, unless they have been designated to be permanently sealed. See Local Rule 5.4 and Administrative Order 2014-69.

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M im iDi son
a
vi i
Ca eNum be 1 20443- V- ORENO
s
r: 7CI M

ROBERT F. NTERO,
QUI
Pli if
antf,
VS.

J ORGAN CHASE BANK,
PM
Def nda .
e nt
/

ORDER GM NTI DEFENDANT JP M O RGAN ' M OTI TO DI I
NG
S
ON
SM SS

Thi ca eaie fom asae-our f ecos es e.l 2005,Robe tQuitr e c e a
s s rs s r
tt c t or l ur al n
r neo xe utd
not a morga i f vorofW as ngt M ut lBa FA.whi h J or n Cha eBa lt r
e nd
t ge n a
hi on
ua nk, , c pM ga
s nk ae

a uie l 2009, s br
cq rd. n
Chae oughtaf e os ea ton a i tQui e oi Fl i saec t l
orcl ur ci gans ntr n orda tt our. n

De e e 2 4,h saec u t n ee ac nsn fn lu g n o f rco u e Ont ed t t s
c mb r 01 t e tt o r e trd o e t i a j d me t f o e l s r. h ae hi
f r co m ej dg n wa e tr d Cha ewa n t h o e o sr ie o t enoe ho ve,
o e ls u me t s ne e , s s o t e wn r r e vc r f h t ; we r
Chas contnued t pr ec e t f ec os e ac i I a s r e ofs a e ti la a l t c t
e
i
o os ut he or l ur ton. n e i s t t r a nd ppela e our

p o e dng , itr u s c e sul c aln e t f r co u ej d me ta d fr cos r s l,
r c e i s Qun eo n u c sf ly h l g d he o e ls r u g n n o e l u e ae
e
a g ng,i e ala,t tCha e w a nota pr pe pl ntf i t f e os e ac i On Fe a y
r ui nt r i ha
s
s
o r ai if n he or cl ur ton.
bnl r

2,
2017, ntr tldt sl c compli a ns fvedee
Qui eo ie hi 6-ount
ant gai t i fndant algi ( )vi ai
s le ng: 1 oltons
oft FarDe Coleci PrciesAc;( vi ai oft FlrdaCo lme Cole ton
he i bt l ton a tc
t 2) oltons he o i nsl r lci
PrciesAc;( vi ai oft FlrdaDe ptvea Unf rTr dePr tc sAc ;( fa
a tc
t 3) oltons he o i ce i nd ai a acie t 4) r ud;

a d()e tte n t ij ci er l f1F u of h tved f n a t' t nst ds s wee
n 5 nilme t o nun tv ei . o r t e i ee d n s moi o imis r
e
o
1 WOWe k atrQuneofldti c s , etldf rb n rptyi t UntdSae Ba k u tyCo r
T
e s fe itr i hs ae h ie o a k u c n he ie tts n rpc ut
e
f t Sout r DititofFl i . Butonemont l e ,heba u c cour dim is d t cas
or he
he n src
orda
h atr t
nkr pty
t s s e he e.

ga tdb d futu d rSD. l . R. .()f rQuitr ' fi r t tmeyo p e Al ug
r ne y e a l n e . F a L. 7 1c o ne o s al e o i l p os . t h
u
ho

tecamsa an ttos fu d fn a t weed s s e wi u p eudc , ne oha n tfld
h li g i s h e o r ee d ns r imis d t t rj ie Quitr s o i
ho
e
ane adi n,i t d c
w
o nsea hoosng onl t pr ee agans t s e r m ani de e n ,
i
y o oc d i t he ol e i ng f nda t Chas
e.

Ch s mo st d s s tecamso t ef lo n g o n :( )teRo k rFed n
a e ve o imis h li n h o lwig r u ds 1 h o e - lma
d crn b r t cams ( )rs u iaaa dc l tr l so e ba tecams ( )teFarDe t
o tie a s he li ; 2 e j dc t n ol e a e tpp l r h li ; 3 h i b
a
Colec i Pr tc sAc cai a Fl i Cons e Cole ton Pr c i sActcli sa etme
l ton ac ie t l ms nd orda
um r l c i
a tce
am r i -

b re ; 4 F oi a sl i ai np iie ep e l e t eFlrd Co u rCo lcinPr cie Ac
ar d ( ) lrd ' i g to rv lg r cud s h o ia ns me le to a tc s t
t
cams ( )t Fl i De e i a Unfi Tr dePr cie Ac doe no a yt Cha e a
li ; 5 he orda c ptve nd ar a a tc s t s t ppl o s ; nd

()t eAnilj n to Ac basij n tv r le .Qun eoa g st a h d e no s e rv e
6 h t-n u ci n t r nu cie eif itr r ue h t e o s t e k e iw
orr ve s lofa sa e c tpr ee ngs Rahe , a e Cha ei nott owne oruli ae
e ra
ny t t - our oc di . t r bec us
s s
he
r
tm t

be e ir o t ej dg n , neo c ne st a hes e srle a ans Ch s f rp o e u ig
n fcay f h u me t Quitr o tnd h t e k eif g i t a e o r s c tn

t ee e uin o t esae c u t o e l u ej d me t
h x c to f h tt -o r f r cos r u g n.
TheRooke - dman docrnepr bisapa t fom s ki r le i f de a c ta tr
r Fel
ti
ohi t
ry r ee ng ei f n e r l our fe
bei de edt s m er i fi saecour.SeeRooke v Fi lt Tr Co., 263U. 41 ( 923)
ng ni he a ele n tt
t
r . de i .
y
S. 3 1 ;

D. Co r o p asv Fed n, 0U. 4 2( 98 ) Th d crn i c nfn dt t a e
C. u t fA pe l . l ma 46 S. 6 1 3 . e o tie s o i e o t s s
c
b o g t y saec u t o e sc mp anngo ijzisc us db saec u tu g n srn e e
r u h b tt -o r l s r o lii f nt e a e y tt-o r j d me t e d r d
r
bef et f r ldititco tpr e ngsc menc a i tng diti tcour r vi w a
or he ede a src ur oce di
om
ed nd nvii
src
t e e nd

rj dino tos j d me t . Ex o Mo l r v S u Ba i I d s Cop. 5 4U. 2 0
et o f h e u g n s' x n biCop. . a di sc n u . r , 4 S. 8 ,
'
28 ( 0 ) Th Elve t Cic t e at -a ra ay i t d tr n wh t rteRo k r
3 2 05 . e e n h ruiuss wo f do n l ss o ee mi e ehe h o e Fed nd crneb r afd r l h l n et asaec u tu g n :( )wh t rtesaec u t
lma o ti a s e ea c al g o tt-o rj d me t 1 ehe h tt o r
e
rn e e j dg n b f r t ed src c u t r c e ig c mme c d; n ( )wheh r h
e d rd u me t e o e h itit o r p o e dn s o n e a d 2
te t e
p anifi asaec u to e wh i c mpann o ij re c u e b saec u tu g n s
litf s tt-o r ls r o s o liig f n u is a s d y tt-o rj d me t.
Cor e v Hor an,397F.App' 55 552- ( 1hCi.201 .I a yzngt ssc fcor
mir . k
x 0, 53 1 t r 0) n nal i hi e ond a t ,

2-

-

course l t whet rt pl i ifscai sa eEne rc bl i e t ne ' t t sae- ur
t vauae
he he antf l m r t xti a y nt rwi d'wih he tt co t
i

j d me t me nn t ywo l ç fe tv l n liyt sae c u tu g n o (u c e )o l t
u g n , a ig he ud % fciey ulf he tt-o rj d me t r s c e d ny o
e
t e en t tt sa ec t ongl de de t is .' I a 553.
he xt t ha he t t our wr y ci d he s ue ' d. t

Her bot ee nt aeme.Fis,Qui eofldt sfderlcompli mor t nt
e, h lme s r t rt ntr ie hi e a
ant e ha wo

y a sa trtesaec u t ne e t f rco u ej g n , n as a trd f a i sae
e r fe h tt o r e trd he o e ls r ud me t a d lo fe ee t n tt
a p laec u t S c n , lh u h Qun eos e mo e d ma e t e teg ieo sauo y
p elt o r. e o d ato g itr e ks n y a g s md r h us f tt tr
a c
nd ommon1w vi ai ,Qui eoc nnots c dwiho adeer nai t tdie ty
a oltons ntr a
uc ee t ut t mi ton ha rcl

c nrdcstesae c u t cin t t a ei n te tte t p o e dwi t j d ca s l.
o ta it h tt-o r a to - ha Ch s s o n i d o r c e t he u iil ae
l
h
Th , l o hn n o te1 c u t s e i al s e rv e o tesaec u tu g n ,h
us at ug o e f h 6 o n s p ct l e k e iw f h tt-o r j d me t te
h
k y
cli aefne rc bl i e t ne ' Qui eoese ilyas t sCour t a a as ond
ams r t xtia y ntrwi d. ntr s ntal ks hi
i
'
to d s ec
a lae c ta t fnd t tCha ei a i ope pl n ifi t f e oslea i n. H a ng
ppel t our nd o i ha
s s n mpr r aitf n he or cl tr cto
vi

ar a l to t sis i saec tQui eocn c t t sCour t sekt r i he
le dy os n hi s ue n tt our, ntr nnot ome o hi
t o e he elef
wa una et ge i t tve
s bl o t n ha nue.The em' pr iel t t
s e ec s y he ypesofcl m st tt Rooke - l
ai ha he
rFe dman
docrnes e t pr ve . The ef e, ti
ti e ks o e nt
r or i s
ORDERED AND ADJUDG ED t t Chas s M oton t Dimis i G RANTED as
ha
e'
i o s s s

Qui e o' cli aebare byt Rooke - l
ntr s ams r rd he
rFedmandocrne.
ti z
DONE AND ORDERED i Cha r a M im i Fl i ,t s
n
mbe s t a , orda hi

ofJ y 201
ul
7.

FEDE
O A.M
O
UNI
TED STAT S DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
Co esf i he t
pi um s d o:
Couns ofRecor
el
d

2Alh u hCh s ' oh rag me t frdimis l fs meo al Quitr scamsma h v mei te
t o g aes te ru ns o s sa o o r lof neo' li
y a e rt h
Co r n e n t e c t e eag me t b c u et eRo k rFed n d c n b r al fQuitr ' cams
u t e d o r a h h s r u n s e a s h o e - l ma o tie a s l o n e o s li .