Adria MM Productions, Ltd. v. Worldwide Entertainment Group, Inc.

Filing 93

ORDER Reaffirming Prohibition on Deposing Sandra York. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 11/30/2017. (kcg)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SO UTHERN D I
STRI OF FLO RI
CT
DA
M i iDi s on
am
vi i
Cas Num be 1 21 CI M ORENO
e
r: 7- 603- VA DRI M M PRO DU CTI S,LTD .
A
ON
,
Pl n if
ai t f ,
VS.

W ORLDW I ENTERTAI ENT GROUP,
DE
NM
m C.
,
De e
f ndant
.
/
O R DE R R EA FFI M I G PR O H I TI N O N D EPO SI G SAN D M Y O R K
R N
BI O
N

W ord deEnt rai e Gr
l wi
e t nm nt oup,l i apr
nc. s omot ra o ga ze ofmusc le nt ,
e nd r ni r
i a ve s
i udi t Ulr M uscFesi l I e e e i o alce i ag e m e r ga di t ta'
ncl ng he ta
i
tva . t nt r d nt i nsng r e nt e r ng d r '
ul
pr it r mar wih AdraM M Pr tons Lt ,apr m otona c
opre a y
ks t
i
oduci , d. o i l ompany i Cr tawih
n oa i t
e us ve lc ns and r ght t Cr ta ve s Thi c e a i esf om t tlc ns ng ag ee e t
xcl i i e es
i s o oa i n nue . s as r s r ha i e i
r m n.

Adrafld a l countc pl nta i tW ordwi s
i ie
oom ai gans
l de oundi i br c ofc r c , r ud,a
ng n ea h
onta t fa
nd
e t bl r le . W ordwi ans r d wih a g- ountc er l m s mdi i br c of
quia e ei f
l de we e t
c
ount cai ot ng n ea h
c r c , r des r tand tade r vi a i ns a c ran sa or vi ai .
onta t ta ec e
r ma k olto , nd e ti t mt y oltons
l Aug t201 Adrais d a s
n
us
7, i s ue ubpoenaduce tcum t Sa aYor W o l de'
se
o ndr
k, rdwi s
ge a co e a ltga i s r ior c
ner l uns l nd ii ton upe v s y ouns i t sc s W ordwi movedt qua h t
el n hi a e.
l de
o s he

s
ubpoe TheCour gant t motont quas l t la f ( ilt r pond ltra t
na.
t r ed he i o h t h e ve or Adra o es
wi
ae s o
w hy i s d be pe te t de e o
t houl
nni t d o pos ppone ' ge r lc
nt s ne a ouns l' A dra fl a r pons t t
e.
'
i ied es e o he
or ra W ordw i fl a r pl The i s i now rpe f r e .
de nd
l de ied e y.
s ue s
i or evi w
A d i a g st tY o k ha pe s l f r t ha exc us ve know l
r a r ue ha r s r ona , i s - nd, l i
edge ofa l as s ve
te t e n
non- i l ged, e-ii ton f c ua m a t r ,a t tques i ng on t e m a t r w oul not
prvie
pr ltga i a t l te s nd ha
toni
hos
te s
d

expos ltga i sr t gy. How e ,A d i f l t m e tt sr nge s a r r quied t de e
e ii ton ta e
ver r a ais o e he t i nt t nda d e r o pos
an opposi part s atonw y.
ng
y' t

W hie not ng i t Fe a Rul s ofCi lPr edur pr bis t de ii ofa
l
hi n he der l e
vi oc
e ohi t he pos ton

pa t sator
ry' t ney,f de alcou t ge r l dif
e r
rs ne aly savors h de ii a pe mi t m i o y
uc postons nd r t he n nl
lmie cr umsanc s.Se l( Peni ul Til Co.v Pal Be Count 1 F. D.
i t d ic t e
e I
ns ar te
. m ach
y, 32 R. 301,
302

( D. l.1 9 )( n ae , . (ç d r l o rs . v h l t t e sto o atr y
S. F a 9 0 Go z lz J) s e a c u t.. e ed ha d po i ns f tone s
Fe
ha
i
i r nty c tt e a i t ton t ha a st a t ey a pa tes andt dir pta de a t
nhe e l onsiut n nvia i o r s he tom
nd ri ,
o s u nd l y he
ca e ' .The c r tcours a e s i on w he he t a y t Shelon t s lort l l xi e
s.'
icui
t r plt
t r o ppl he
t e t he 4 e bl
f
)

t r o low he poston
ry' tor y
a oa h't s 2i dee ni whe he t a l t de ii ofapa t sat ne . The
ppr c ' e t n tnni ng
Elve h Cic thasnote es l r l ont i s But c t i t Sou he n Dititof
e nt r ui
xpr sy ued he s ue. , ours n he t r src
Fl i ha g ne aly hel t t a l w t de ii ofa pa t s a t ne t m ova m us
or da ve e r l
d hat o lo he poston
ry' tor y, he
nt t

s o t a:( ) h d p sto i teo l p a tc l a o o tii gt eif r to ( ) h
h w h t 1 t e e o iin s h ny rcia me ns f b an n h n o main; 2 t e
i o ton s ug w ilno i
nf nna i o ht l t nvade t r al oft a t ne sw or pr
he e m
he tor y'
k oduc ori e f r wih t
t nt r e e t he

at ne cle prviege ( t i or tons
tor y- int i l ; 3) he nf mai oughti r e nta cr ilt t pr paai of
s elva nd uca o he e rton
t c e;a ( t movan ' ne dsout ght da r ofde i apary' at ne Se
he as nd 4) he
ts e
wei he nge s posng
t s tor y. e
Co ngt v.Wal e nCo, 112290 201 W L 21
vi on
gr e .No. - 0, 2
20776,a * ( D.Fl Jme 1 201
t 3 S. a. t 1, 2)
(
Goodma M . )(ii Klyr v Fr dom ' Wath,I , 07n, J. ctng a nan . ee s c nc.No. 22433,2007W L 441
4803,
a * 4( D. a.Dec.1 2007)( mont M ..'Br c nrdgePhar ,I .v M eabolt
t 3- S. Fl
4,
Si on, J) e ke i
,
m. nc . t ie
Labs,I .No.04. nc,
80090,2007W L 433084,a *3- ( D. a.Fe 2,2007)( m,J) IC
t 4 S. Fl b.
Col .;?
F
'l Shet v. Ame ia MoosCop.teEihhCic tsae t th mo i p rymu tso th t()
n lon
rc n tr r ,h g t rui ttd ha te vng a t s h w ç a 1
t

nooh rme nse itoo ti teifr t nta t d poeo po igc u s l()teif r to s u h i
te a xs t ban h nomai h n o e s p sn o n e, 2 h n omain o g ts
o
r lv nt n n np i lg d a ()teifr t ni cu ilotepe aainofh c s . 8 F.d 12 12
ee a a d o -rvi e , nd 3 h nomai s r ca t h rp rto te a e' 05 3 3 3, 3 7
e
o
'
(t Ci.1 8 )
8h r 9 6.
2Undert çte bl ts 'heopertvei r i whehert çpr ed de ii woul e ai a
he tl xi e e t't
a i nquiy s t he ç opos
poston
d nt l n
i ppr i ebur n o har hi 'ont r s
na oprat de r ds p' he e pondi pa t I reSub naIsue t D e sFre a 35 F.
ng ry. n
poe s d o nni idm n, 0 3d

6 , -2(dCi. 0 3 ( tma r J)
5 717 2 r 2 0 ) Soo yo, .
.

-

2-

Peni ul Til Co,1 F. D.a 302) Thepa t seki t de et opposngpa t s
ns ar te
32 R. t .
ry e ng o pos he
i ry'
c ms lbea st btr n t de onsr t t ef c or .Sun Ca t Par ne s I v Twi Cf
ot e
r he lde o m ta e hes a t s
pial t r , nc. . n l
y

FieI s Co, 0F. D. 2 , 2 ( D. a 2 5 ( at wma M ..
r n . .31 R. 5 3 5 8 S. Fl. 01 ) M the n, J)
.
Her ,Ad i ha f ie t demonsr t t tYor sde ii i t onl pr tc lme ns
e ra s al d o
ta e ha
k' poston s he y ac ia a
ofobt ni t i or a i s ht ort tt i or ai s ug i r l va a cr i t t
ai ng he nf m ton oug , ha he nf m ton o ht s e e nt nd ucal o he
pr par ton oft ca e Furhe ,at ug Adraag ee t lmi quesi ngt non- i lge
e ai
he s . t r lho h
i r so i t
toni o
prvie d
m a t s t r i no ot ri c ton t tAdra snee out i h t da r ofde i Yor
ter ,he e s
he ndia i ha
i'
ds we g he nge s
posng k.
Be us Ad i f l t m e tmuli er quie e st de ea opposngpa t sa t ne Adra
ca e ra ais o e
tpl e r m nt o pos n
i
ry' tor y, i
i pr bied fom de i Yor
s ohi t r
posng
k.

D N A DO D R DiCabraMi ,liati )D oNoebr07
O E N R E E n hm est n Fod, s f vm e21.
mi r h
.

FED E

UNI
T
Co esf m i he t
pi u s d o:

Couns ofRe r
el
co d

7'
'
'
'

. O REN O

S
TATESDI TRI J
S CT UDGE