Hannat v. USAA General Indemnity Company

Filing 19

ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR REMAND. It is hereby ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that Plaintiff Bahreddine Hannat's Motion for Remand (D.E. 11) is GRANTED. This matter is REMANDED to the Circuit Court in and for Miami-Dade County, Florida. All pending motions are DENIED as moot and THE CLERK SHALL CLOSE THE CASE. Copies Furnished to: (i) Counsel of Record; and (ii) Clerk of the Court for the 11th Judicial Circuit in and for Miami-Dade County, Florida. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 10/18/2017. (da00)

UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI COU RT FO R TH E
CT
SO UTH ERN D I
STRI OF FLOR I
CT
DA
M i iDi s on
am
vi i
C as Num be 1 21
e
r: 7- 754- V- O R EN O
CI M
BA HREDD I H AN N AT,
NE
Pl ntf
ai if,
VS.

U SA A GEN EM L I D EM N I COM PAN Y ,
N
TY
Def nda .
e nt

O R DER G R ANTI G PLA I TI S M O TI N FO R REM AN D
N
N FF'
O
Ba e ne H a ts d U SA A Ge r ll m niy Com pa i C ic tCour f M i m i
hr ddi
nna ue
ne a nde t
ny n r ui
t or a D a Count Fl i ,a l gi br ac ofc r c . e Bahr ne Hannatv US Ge r
de
y, or da le ng e h
ont a t Se
eddi
. AA ne al
I m ni Compan Ca e N o.201 005627 CC- H a ts ks da a r uli fom
nde t
y
y, s
705. nna ee
m ges es tng r

USAA' alge fiur t pr l a j tHanna' i urnc cli USAA r
S le d al e o opery d us
ts ns a e am.
emove t cae,
d he s

c n e dn ta tefd r l o r h ds be tmatr u id ci nb s do d v ri o ctz n hi,
o tn ig h t h e e a c u t a u j c- te j rs ito a e n i est f iie s p
y
a m o d t di m i st Com pl i .Han ts e nty t l d a M oton f Rem a ar ng
nd ve o s s he
a nt
na ubs que l i e
i or
nd, gui

t tUSAA ca esa ih di riyj iditonbec us t a nti c r ves doe no
ha
nnot tbls vest urs ci
a e he mou n onto ry s t
e e $75,
xce d
000.
Bec e U SAA f l t es a ih t tHa ts c a m s t si d t a o -n- r r y
aus
ais o t bls ha nna ' l i a i t e he m unt i contove s

rquie ntatt tmeofr
e rme
he i
emova,Ha tsM oi f Rema ( E.11 i GRANTED. 1
l nna' ton or
nd D. ) s
A1
ot pendi m otons ar D EN I asm oot
her
ng
i
e
ED
.
1
.

LEG A L STAN D AR D

W heet fde a dititc t ha orgi l urs ci ove acvi a tonfldi sat
r he e r l src ours ve i na j iditon r i l ci ie n t e
c tadefnda ma r
our, e nt y emovet c et f rldititc t28U. C.j 1 .Fedea
he as o edea src our.
S.
441
rl

d src c u t h v oi ia j rs ci nb s do dvest o ctz n hi wheet p risa e
itit o rs a e rgn lu idito a e n i ri f iie s p r he a t r
y
e
ctz nsofdifrntsae a t a unti co r rye eds$75, 28U. C.j 1 2.
iie
fee tts nd he mo -n- ntoves xce
000.
S.
33
The El ven h Ci c tha he d t td n t r m o lcon e whe e da age a e
e t r ui s l ha t he e va
i
t xt
r m s r

u s e iid,h r mo i gp rybe r teb d no e tbihngt ej idcina a u t y a
n p cfe te e v n a t as h ur e f sa ls i h urs it l mo n b
o
prponde a eoft e de 'ftwcy v Al amaPowe Co.483F. 118 1 ( 1hCi.
e
r nc he vi nce. l r . ab
'
r ,
3d 4, 208 1 t r

2007)(iai o te .Cg dititc tma pr ryc i pos-e
cttons mitd) SAI src our y ope l onsder trmova e de ei
l vi nc n

d tn nigwheh r h j rs ito a a u twa stsida t etmeo rmo a. Wil msv
ee ui n
te t e u idcin l mo n s aife t h i f e v l' li .
' a
Be Bu Co.269F. 1 1 1 1 ( 1h Ci. ) s ealoSir ns v Tr s hFi Cor ,
st y ,
3d 3 6, 3 9 1 t r 2001 . e s e mi ki . an out n. p.
,
21 F.d 9 9 ( 1hCi.
6 3 45, 49 1 t r 2000)( ai ngt tiheei nogoodras t ke p aditit
expl ni ha ' r s
t
e on o e
src

c tfo eiii orr e ngevi nceouti t r
our r m lctng eviwi
de
sde he emovalpeii ,'andhol ngt t
ttongl'
di ha

d src c u t ma S o sd rp trmo a e ie c i a s si gr mo l u idcin'.
itit o rs y k n ie os-e v l vd n e n s e sn e va j rs ito ' To
c
)
a d i rngi on sa e s r gnt c t mus src l c tu r
voi nfi ng
tt ove ei y, ours
t ti ty onsr e emovalr uie e sa k l
eq r m nt nd s l
a

d u t a o t u idcins o l b r s le i fv ro rma dt saec u t' i.o . a. .
o b s b u j rs ito h ud e e ov d n a o f e n o tt o r. Unv fs Al v
'

1.
I
A.

AN A LYSIS

M oton f R em and
i or
Argum ent
s

S b e tmatr u idcinb sdu o d v ri o ctz n hi e it o yi () h p ris
u j c- te j rs ito a e p n i est f iie s p x ss nl f it e a t
y
e
aecii nsofdifr sae ,a (i t a
r tze
feent tts nd i) he mounti c r rye e $75, 28U. C.j
-n-ontoves xce ds 000.
S.
1332.A lhough Hannatand U SA A agr t t ar cii
t
ee hat hey e tzens ofdif
f erents at t di put
t es, hey s e
whet H annat scl m satsies t am ounti cont
her
' ai
i t he
-n- rover requiem ent
sy
r
.
H annatass t t hi dam ages f om U SAA ' aleged br
ers hat s
r
S l
each ofcont actdo notexceed
r

$10, muc l s$75, Buthealo s e pr vaii pa t ato ne sf esunde Fl rda
000, h es
000.
s e ks e lng- ry t r y' e
r oi

Stt esj627. Ac or ngt USAA,Hama' atnz sf sa c t f t sc ewil
aut
428. c di o
r ts to ey' ee nd oss or hi as l

t t la pr xi t l $84, USAA c e ,t r f e t tt a ounti c r ve s i
o a p o ma ey
000.
ont nds he e or , ha he m
n onto r y s
s ts i d b i l ng t e tm a ed a t ne s f esH a m a w ili urt ltgat t ca e.
a i f e y nc udi he s i t tor y' e
l t l nc o ii e he s l
Ha tc l U SA A ' f e c l ul ton i nta e 'a c e t tS he a ounti
nna als
S e a c a i û l t d' nd ont nds ha ' m
i
t
n

c r ryf t smatrg llnote e $60, ' veni l ngal a t landetmae
ontove s or hi te wil
xc ed 000'e ncudi l cua
si td
at ne sf s ( .Br a 2. Howe r heas diputsUSAA' mehod ofc c ai t
tor y' ee . P1 . t )
ve , lo s e
S t
alultng he
a t ne sf est i l i t a ounti c r r y. he e U SAA cont
tor y' e o nc ude n he m
n ontove s W r as
endst tt Cour
ha he
t

s dcou alofHama' at ne sf s(ncl ngf si ure pr r
houl nt l
l ts tor y' ee i udi ee nc r d e-emova aswela
l
l s
esi tdfest ltgaet c efo rmova tloughtil,Hama a g st tt Cour
tmae e o ii t he as rm e
l lr
ra) l t r ue ha he
t
s d i l onl f eshe ha i ur e a t tm e ofr m oval
houl nc ude y e
d nc r d t he i
e
.
LegalA nal i
ys s

Asi Wale rv Norhwe tr M ut LfeI ur eCompan Ha tsM otonf
n tmye . t se n ual
ns anc
y, nna'
i or
Rem and dependson twhet t am ountofator f i cal at t
û her he
t ney ees s cul ed hrough t end oft
he
he

c s o tr n tlla a e rird t f r u idcin l u p s s'2 0 W L 41 6 3, t* ( .
ae r emiaes t n ale ae o j rs ito a p r o e . 0 7
'
9 6 a 2 M D.
Fl 2007) TheEl nt Cic thashedt tt amounti c r rymus e ee $75, a
a.
.
eve h rui
l ha he
n ontoves
t xc d 000 t

tet o rmo a .S ePo r v Ame ia - c b eLf I s Co o e a , 8F.d 1 8 ,
h i f e v l e o e . rc nAmia l e n . . fT x s 21 3 2 7
me
1 -91( 1hCi.2000) o ruldonot rgr
290
1t r
, ver e
he oundsbyAlar zv Unio TieCo.2007W L
v e . r yal r
,

41 8( 1hCi.
4671 1 t r 2007)s aloSir n ki21 F. 945,949( 1h Ci.2000) kfhegenea
; ee s emis , 6 3d
1t r
. s'
rl
r e i t tt a o i con r r y i de e m i d a t tm e ofr m ova ,a s e nt
ul s ha he m unt n t ove s s t r ne t he i
e
l nd ubs que

matr ta af c tea u twil o dvettec u t f u idcin. Watmye , 0 7W L
tes h t fe th mo n l n t i s h o r o j rs ito ' le r 2 0
'
41
9663,a * D i ti tCour sa yi t tprnc pl i sm ia c eshave hel t tonl
t 2. s r c
t ppl ng ha i i e n i l r as
d ha y

l tf e gene a r e i t ta t ney' f esdo notcoun t r t a ounti con r r y unl s t ar
i'
-h
r l ul s ha tor s e
t owa ds he m
n t ove s
e s hey e

al dfrb saueo c nr c. Fe eae Mu. n.Co v Mc n o Moos LLC, 2 F.d8 5 8 8n. ( lh
l
owe o y ttt r o ta t' d r td tIs . . Kin n tr,
'
3 9 3 0 , 0 4 1t
Ci. 0 3 . r, ton y' fe c n twadtea u ti c nr es bea s Ha na camsh i t nildt
r2 0 ) Hee atre s e s ou to r h mo n n o tov ry c u e n t li e s t tt o
e e
pe aln p ryatr e ' fe . . ru n t Fo iaSaue j6 7.2 . ( mp. 1 )
rv i g at to n ys e s . pus a to lrd ttts 2 4 89 Co l! 9.
i
'

a t ne sf e i ur e pr o t r m ovalco t a d t a oun i c r r y. e i .;see
tor y' e s nc r d i r o e
unt ow r he m
t n ontove s Se d

JS Ro a isy v Mer . eI s Co, 0 9W L 3 6 0 3 a * ( D. a 2 0 )2
l0 g tn k . to Lf n . .2 0
6 7 7 , t 2 S. Fl. 0 9 .
U SAA fl d isN otc ofRe ovalon M a 11 201 a i l d a D ec a a i
ie t
ie
m
y , 7 nd nc ude
l r ton

e t t t a Ha na h dic re j s $12 0i atr e ' f e a tetmeo rmo a. De 1
si i h t n t a n u r d u t ,0 n ton y s e s t h i f e v l ( c.
ma ng
ofArur M a tne a 2.Ha tsownDe aai saest theha i ured(otlat ney'
t o ri z t ) nna '
clrton tt ha
d nc r t a tor s
t
fesofa prxi t y$3, ' tt tmeofrmo l( clofBa eddi Ha ta 2. Fi ly,
e
p o mael 375'a he i
e va.De .
hr ne nna t ) nal

Hama ' Co li t l g sls t a $1 0 0i d ma e . S e( mp . 1 ; P1Re p Br a
l ts mpan al e e s h n 0,0 n a g s ( e Co l! ) ( . s . . t
e
2 .Th s j ta i Watmye ,i ea u to at r e f e ic re p irt teNo ieo
)) u ,us s n le r lh mo n f to n y e s n u r d ro o h tc f
t
Re ova , he cou e w ih da a s a cr d asoft flng oft c pl nt w oul no be
m
l w n pl d t m ge c ue
he ii
he om ai ,
d t

s fcintt stsyt j iditona a
ufi e o aif he urs ci l mount' 2007W L 41 63,a #
.
'
96 t 2.
Eve i t Co tc c a ed t a ounti c r r y t i ude t t als of
n f he ur al ul t he m
n ont ove s o ncl
he ot um

ras bl at
e ona e tonwy' fest ltg t t sc et oughti ,t cile incea c
s e o iiae hi as hr
ral judi a xpere nd ommon
s ns 's s t ti silwo dnotexc ed$75, Tr uykv W - Lf?As ur eCo.201
e e' ugget ha t tl ul
e
000. atr . S. / s anc
, 6

W L 7 75 6, t* ( . Fl. e . 4 2 6 ( oi t a t eCo r ma S mpo isj d ca
2 4 a 2 M D. a F b 2 , 01 ) n tng h t h u t y s ly t u iil
e
e r e e and c m on s ns i es i a i t val ofa t ney' f s lke y r ove abl i a
xpe i nc
om
e e n tm tng he ue tor s ee i l ec r e n

gi nc e' (ii Roev M ihei N Am.I . 6l F.d 1
ve as ' ctng
)
. c ln
, nc, 3 3 058,1 4 ( 1h Ci.201 ) The
06 1 t r 0).

Co ti Tr ur v l:S.LfeAs ur eCo.r e l a esedasmia diput i vi a
ur n at yk . ls anc
ec nty ddr s
i lr s e nvol ng
$60, i ur nc cli ie,sx tme t a
000 ns a e a m . . i i s he mountHa ts eks 201 W L 7
nna e . 6
27546,a *2.The
t
Cour e tm a ed t ta r as bl co i
t s i t ha e ona e ntngenc f w oul r nge f o 33% t 40% ofa
y ee
d a
rm
o
ny
r ove y,a a r as bl hour y ba ed f e woul e il Pl i if sc
ec r nd e ona e
l s e
d ntte a ntf ouns t a oxi a e y
el o ppr m t l
2Tobes e s
ur ome c t hol t ttat neyf e tr
ours d ha ttor
e s h ought concl i oft ltgai a ei l d whe
he
uson he ii ton r ncude
n

t ea t n i fld iiil i fd r l o r. Wa tmye , 0 W L 41 6 3 a * ( ingM o rs n v Al t t l d mn
h c i s ie n tal n e e a c u t' le r 2 07
o
y
'
9 6 , t 2 ct
i
r io . l a e n e .
s
Co, 28F.d1 5 ,1 6 ( 1hCi. 0 0 ) Ho v rlk oh rdsrc c ut i teElv nhCic i teCo r
.2 3 2 5 2 5 1 t r2 0 ). we e,le te itit o rs n h e e t rut h u t
,
fndsS r a ont devit fom t gene a r et ti ar ove c et amou i contove s i dee mi d as
i û es o
no
a e r he
r l ul ha n em d as he
nt n
r r y s tr ne

o t tmeo rmo a a dtec u t a n t eyo p trmo a e e t i e a nn iss be t te j rsito .
fhe i f e v l n h o rc n o r l n os-e v l v ns n x miig t u j c matr u idcin'
'
l (iigPo r, 1 F.da 1 9 - 1.
d.ct
n oe2 8 3 t 2 0 9 )

-

4-

$20, 1 Appl ng t e f eesi t i t sc e,Hamatsc am silf l t s ts yt
000. d.
yi hos e tma es n hi as
l ' l i tl ais o a if he
amounti co r r y r quie tby mor t n $ 000.
-n- ntove s e r men
e ha 30,
B.

Pl nt f ' Requestf A t ornev' Fees and C os
ai i f s
or t
s
ts

Hal tas t Cour f a awadofat y' fesa c t. co e t tSlj r
ma ks he
t or n r tome s e nd oss He ntnds ha ithee
i no l ca r s n why U SAA w oul r ove t s c s ' e ptt t de Pl i if ... ih
s ogi l ea o
d em
hi a e ' xce o s
bur n a ntf
wt

ul c s r e ns sa j ca hur esi a efor t t 't pr es ofhi Complit'
me esay xpe e nd udiil dl n n f to hwal he ogr s s
t
an.'
( .Br a 7. l r pons USAA s ssitwa i umbe upon USAA G1 t rmovet
Pl . t ) n es e,
ugge t d s nc
i
nt
C oe
he
c e. ( .Opp. t8.
as ' Def
'
a )

TheSuprmeCour hashel t tt t ma a r at ne sf sunde j 1 c)o y
e
t
d ha û s y wad tor y' ee
cour
r 447( nl

wh r ter mo i pat lc e a o j ci eyr a o a l b ssf rs e n rmo a. M a t v
e e h e vng ry a k d n be tv l e s n be a i o e kig e v l' ri .
'
n
Fr lnCa t Cor ,5 U. 1 1 (
anki pial p. 46 S. 32, 41 2005) Alhough iwa bynome nsii umbe t
. t
t s
a inc nt,
upon USAA t r
o emove a$1 000 c r c dipu et f de a co t i doe nota a t tU SAA
0,
onta t s t o e r l ur, t s
ppe r ha

lc e a o j cieyr a o a l b ssf rd i s S eRo a isy, 0 W L 3 67 7 , t*
a k d n b e tv l e s n b e a i o ong o. e g tn k 20 9
6 03a 3
( nyi Pli ifsr uetf at ne sfesi smia rmova diput be a el fnda '
de ng antf eq s or tor y' e n i lr e
l s e c us i e nts
De
l gala gum en s w e e col a e a r s bl e pe a l gi n t pauc t ofc el w r r ng
e
r
t r
or bl nd ea ona e, s ci ly ve he
iy
as a ega di

how at e sf ss dbec c atd i rmo lca e ' . s h,heCour de e Ha ts
tonzy' ee houl alul e n e va s s' As uc t
)
t nis nna'
r que tf a t y' f esand c t a s i t d w ih t tlng oft s m oton.
e s or tonw s e
os s s oc a e t he i i
hi
i
11
1.

C O N CLU SIO N

Ha ng c i r d t m o i t r s
vi ons de e he ton, he e pons , a pe tne pori of t r c d,a
e nd r i nt tons
he e or nd
be ng ot r s f l ad s d i t pr m i e ,i i he e
i
he wi e - y vi e n he e s s t s r by
ul
O RD ER ED A N D A DJU D G ED t Pl ntf Bahr ne H annat' M oton f Rem and
hat ai if
eddi
s
i or

( E.11 i GRANTED.Thi matri REM ANDED t t Cic tCour i a f M i D. ) s
s te s
o he rui
t n nd or ami
Da Count Fl i A l pe ng m otons ar D ENI a m oota t c e k s l cl e t s
de
y, or da. 1 ndi
i
e
ED s
nd he l r ha l os hi
Case.

K
DONE AND ORDERED i Cha be sa M i mi Fl rda, hi
n
m r t a , oi t s

ofOc obe 201
t r 7.

'
)
pX
'
.'
,

FED ERI

.
.

A.

UN I
TE STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
Copi sf ni hed t
e ur s
o:
Couns lofRec d
e
or